Chapter Text
‘You should go with them.’
‘Oh, not you as well!’ Bilbo exclaimed, only narrowly resisting the urge to roll his eyes. He had been quite enjoying his quiet time in one of the smaller libraries, just himself and a book and a world of adventures he could enjoy without people pestering him! That plan, it would appear, had just met an untimely demise.
‘Me as well as who?’ Elrohir asked with great curiosity, and now it was a groan that Bilbo was suppressing.
Curse his unwary tongue! Did he not know better than to give the twins an opening by now?
‘No one,’ he lied as smoothly as he could. ‘It was an expression, that is all.’
‘It is a very specific expression, Bilbo,’ Elrohir said sternly, though his eyes were gleaming merrily and Bilbo knew that the solemnity was a façade being put on for effect. ‘One that implies something has happened before. Come now, you know I will not give up. I never do. You may as well simply tell me.’
‘It will be less painful for all involved?’ was Bilbo’s sarcastic reply. Elrohir laughed.
‘Let us say, “less painful for you”,’ the elf chuckled. ‘That is surely the most important thing.’
‘One would think so, yes,’ Bilbo muttered, ‘and yet somehow simply leaving the topic be, which would be least pain… irritating for me, never seems to be an option.’
‘Bilbo, stop avoiding the question,’ Elrohir said, and now the sternness was not a façade. Bilbo sighed.
‘Bofur – the one with the hat -’ he explained, when Elrohir did not appear much enlightened, ‘has expressed the opinion that I should accompany them further once or twice.’
‘Or ten times?’ Elrohir queried, seeing right through Bilbo as always.
‘I think it was eight at last count, but I will admit I may have lost track,’ Bilbo acknowledged.
‘You do not agree with him, or with me?’ Elrohir asked. Bilbo shook his head.
‘I came this far because there was a need, Elrohir,’ he insisted. ‘The Shire required more protection than I could give and this was what I could do. There is no reason for me to be away for months more when I am able to be there.’
‘Bilbo, I know that this runs counter to everything you believe,’ Elrohir said, crouching before Bilbo’s chair and making very sure that their eyes were meeting before he continued, ‘but the security of the Shire is not your responsibility. You are not chained to it for life simply because you are the only martial hobbit of your generation.’
‘Who is going to look to their defence if not me?’ Bilbo demanded. ‘You know none of the others would ever think to do anything but pray the Rangers arrive in time, Elrohir. You have seen the results of it!’
‘I think a good deal of this problem arises from one hobbit who did not simply pray, but we will leave that aside for a moment,’ Elrohir murmured so quietly Bilbo almost didn’t catch it, before raising his voice to a normal level. ‘Bilbo, did it ever occur to you that what you came here to do has now freed you up to do whatever you wish? Elladan and I will be there, and with two full patrols. You are not their sole defender anymore.’
Bilbo just… sat there for a moment.
That seemed to be happening to him quite a bit since he’d arrived in Rivendell.
First Elrond, then Bofur, now Elrohir.
Was everyone determined to turn his world on its ear all of a sudden?
‘I have a life there,’ he said weakly, suddenly realising he must have been silent too long. ‘I have responsibilities.’
‘Which you no doubt set in order before you left,’ Elrohir reminded him patiently. ‘Anything else that may be needed, you can tell me about now and I will see to it.’
‘Why are you pushing for this?’ Bilbo asked, hands clenching on the edge of the chair as he resisted the urge to jump to his feet and begin pacing. ‘Why does it matter?’
‘You have been smiling,’ Elrohir said simply. ‘You even laugh. Do you know, Bilbo, Elladan and I barely knew what your laugh sounded like? We were with you for months and hardly ever heard it, only a choked-off version when we did something particularly ridiculous.’
‘It was not the easiest of times,’ Bilbo objected, insulted and angry with it. ‘Were you expecting me to burst into paroxysms of laughter every five seconds?’
‘Of course not,’ Elrohir countered gently, and that was the second time in two days someone had made Bilbo feel like a complete arse for snapping at them, ‘but a little bit would not have been unusual, when with family or friends. You were so sad, and nothing seemed to help. Even when we met you later, you were still so solemn. Can you blame us for wishing you to be happy?’
‘You are being melodramatic, my friend,’ Bilbo scolded. ‘I am perfectly well as I am.’
‘As you are now,’ Elrohir insisted. ‘Bilbo, travel has been good for you. Leaving the Shire has been good for you. Why not see how you like going further? What can it hurt?’
‘I could be gone a year with the dwarves’ plan,’ Bilbo reminded him in exasperation.
‘What is a year?’ Elrohir asked airily, though Bilbo thought his eyes had lost most of the merriment they had held earlier.
‘Very little, when you are immortal,’ Bilbo said tartly. ‘Quite a lot when you are a hobbit!’
‘Bilbo, you told me once you owed my brother and I a debt,’ Elrohir told him, gentleness returned. Bilbo nodded. He knew the debt, and acknowledged it. On his darker nights, its existence was yet another thing that prodded him with sharp, icy fingers. He hated not being able to pay them back for all they had done.
‘Then go,’ Elrohir stated simply. ‘A year of your time in return for six months each from Elladan and I, if you choose to see it that way. Go, have your adventure, leave your Shire in our hands, and we will call the debt paid.’
‘You care about this so much?’ Bilbo queried, finding that hard to believe. He did not understand why Bofur and Elrohir both seemed so set on Bilbo travelling to the Iron Hills but, to himself at least, he could not deny that the idea had its appeal.
He liked the dwarves. He enjoyed their company, and their stories, and their songs. He had become ridiculously fond of a pair of young Princes and their scribe, and it was hard to resist the idea of continuing to know them, of watching them as they came to know more of the world and their place in it.
He could even admit, as long as it was only between him and himself, that he would not mind knowing a little more of the world and his own place in it.
The Shire felt so far away now, and Bilbo was realising slowly that he liked that. He had good friends there, though he sometimes forgot it, but so many of the memories associated with the Shire were unhappy.
Perhaps Elrohir was on to something.
Perhaps it was time to get away from the bad memories for a while.
Perhaps it was time to make some new ones; ones which included loud laughter instead of quiet tears and stony silences.
Bilbo thought for some time, mulling things over and unconsciously alternating between tracing patterns on the chair arm and tapping it in a rhythm of his own devising. Elrohir said nothing, sitting quietly and presumably thinking deep thoughts of his own.
Or possibly contemplating where his next bout of havoc should be aimed.
With the twins it was often a toss-up which was occupying their minds.
Bilbo’s own mind had slipped sideways now, and was contemplating another facet of extending his trip. The dwarves’ King was… well, he was a mystery, and one that Bilbo would not object to having time to study further.
Thorin appeared to Bilbo to be made up of endless contradictions. Grumpy and gentle by turns, clearly fond of his nephews and cousins, but unable to keep his companions’ names straight. Almost unbearably rude and then, turning about completely, suddenly as courteous – perhaps more so – than any well-brought-up hobbit.
No, Bilbo would not object at all to learning more about Thorin Oakenshield and trying to get to the bottom of those contradictions.
It only made sense, after all. Ered Luin was a fairly close neighbour to the Shire, and it never hurt to know your neighbours.
It made them all the easier to avoid if the need arose.
In Bilbo’s experience, the need generally did.
‘Very well, then,’ Bilbo said at last. ‘I will go.’
Elrohir’s smile was bright and beaming.
‘Wonderful,’ he exclaimed happily. ‘I will tell Erestor’s staff to increase the provisions for your Company,’ when Bilbo began to object, having suddenly realised the extra cost involved, Elrohir waved him away. ‘You fed us all the time we were in the Shire, Bilbo,’ he reminded firmly. ‘A little food from our stores will simply balance that debt. We are very well-balanced people today, had you noticed? I must tell Erestor, he will be impressed with my good sense. A novel feeling for him! I will see you at dinner.’
Elrohir turned to leave, then paused. Looking over his shoulder, he called, ‘Bilbo?’
Bilbo simply rolled his eyes in response. How likely was it that Elrohir had lost his attention in the two seconds before he’d changed his mind about going?
‘You should tell them about the Winter.’
With that, Bilbo’s elven friend sailed out of the door before Bilbo could utter a word, leaving the hobbit gaping.
Elves!
***
‘You convinced him?’
‘Of course.’
‘And you didn’t have to….’
‘Have to say, “We think you should go because falling in love with these dwarves is good for you and we have a strong suspicion that, given the opportunity, they will keep you”? No, brother, I did not. Have a little faith.’
‘We share a soul. I have exactly as much faith in you as you deserve.’
‘I hinted. That’s all. I do not think he caught on. He was a little busy attempting to fight his own inclination to follow them.’
‘Very well, you are forgiven.’
‘Gracious as ever. Now as long as the dwarf is not as thick-skulled as he appears at first, all should be well.’
….
‘Yes, alright, perhaps a few prayers might not go amiss.’
***
‘Thorin, you are being unreasonable!’
‘Unreasonable?’ Thorin did not shove the wizard across the room, but it was a near run thing. The conversation had worsened swiftly after Thorin informed the wizard he was wasting his time, and it had yet to recover. In fact, Thorin was as near to being toe-to-toe with Gandalf as he could be without finding himself face-to-stomach with him instead.
‘You would suggest that I take thirteen of my best dwarves to face a dragon that wiped out dozens of my people, that successfully drove us from our kingdom without appearing to expend any effort at all, and I am being unreasonable?’
Thorin was almost incandescent with anger. Maybe if Gandalf had simply accepted his first refusal it would not have come to this, but the wizard could not help but push. Always so convinced he had the answers.
Always so very convinced that he was the only one who did.
It felt like Thror all over again, and Thorin could not let that stand. Every time he did, disaster followed and his people suffered.
‘Thorin, I tell you, there is a way in,’ Gandalf insisted. He slapped an old piece of parchment onto the table, along with a large metal key which was clearly of dwarven make. ‘A way that Smaug knows nothing of. No one knows of it except your family, and Thráin entrusted me with the knowledge and with the means to open it. It can be done.’
Could it, Thorin wondered, gazing at the items before him, apparently heirlooms of his family. It was… Mahal, it was such a tempting thought. To be home, to be safe, not scraping by but living as his people should be, taking what was their right, driving that thing from their kingdom, from life itself…
Thorin laughed bitterly, barely realising that he was doing so aloud.
Where have you heard such words before, he asked himself. Did Thrór not say the same, all the years of their exile? First about Smaug, then turning his fury upon the orcs in Azanulbizar. What had all his dreaming come to, in the end?
Blood.
His, and that of far too many of their warriors. Too many innocent dwarves merely following their King.
Not this time.
Thorin would not be Thrór. He would have care for what was entrusted to him.
He would not destroy everything for pretty stories spun in nothing but air.
‘No,’ he told Gandalf adamantly. ‘We go to the Iron Hills, to Dàin. Erebor is lost to us. It is time my line admitted to it. We are Kings of the Lonely Mountain no more.’
‘You will choose the narrow view then,’ Gandalf said wearily, looking utterly disappointed. Thorin felt nothing but the faintest pang of sympathy. ‘Little risk for little gain.’
‘It may be little gain to you, Tharkûn,’ Thorin retorted, shoving his hands through his hair irritably, trying to dissipate the quivering tension in his limbs. He felt as he had when he shoved Wikan up against the wall mere weeks before, burning with impotent energy. Unable to undo the past, and knowing that was the only way to truly solve his problems. ‘It is not to us! We do not value our lives as little as you clearly value them.’
The small movements had not succeeded, Thorin was on the verge of shaking with pent up emotion. It was the same instinct that had driven him to accidentally kick Fíli, but he could hardly start abusing Elrond’s furniture. Besides, the elf actually appeared to be on Thorin’s side here. He had weighed in to support Thorin’s arguments at the beginning, until he realised that Gandalf had every intention of ignoring him.
‘You are deliberately misunderstanding me,’ Gandalf complained. He was indignant, almost as if he were the wounded party, and Thorin’s temper slipped its leash again.
‘And you are trying to treat my Company like pawns in the great chess game you are playing,’ he shouted. He forced himself to lower his tone before continuing. You’re on display, Thorin, he reminded himself. You said it yourself. You are not among friends here. ‘Can you not see how that leads me to think we are dispensable to you? This is not about my people, Gandalf, not truly. At least be honest about that!’
He met Gandalf’s eyes squarely and after a brief pause, Gandalf gave the slightest of nods.
‘It is as much about your people as any other,’ Gandalf spoke, and Thorin wondered if the wizard could avoid hedging if he tried. Maybe it was so ingrained that he really could not help himself. ‘It is about the evil in our world more than anything. Smaug is a powerful force for evil, Thorin.’
‘Trust me, I remember,’ Thorin sighed, turning his back on both Gandalf and Elrond. He clasped his hands behind him, hoping it would help him to stillness. ‘If you are concerned about the dragon, find yourself an army. Thirteen dwarves will not avail you. Not against Smaug. That is not the narrow view, Gandalf, it is reason. You do not stop an avalanche with a pebble.’
‘You do not stop an avalanche at all,’ Lord Elrond stated firmly, re-joining the conversation. ‘Gandalf, I will tell you now; even if you did convince Thorin to follow this plan, you would not convince me to let their party out of Imladris. We cannot risk turning the dragon’s ire upon the world. The days of my father are gone. We have not the strength to face every evil which walks Middle Earth.’
‘And when the evil chooses to face us instead?’ Gandalf demanded. ‘What then, Elrond?’
To that Lord Elrond had no reply, but Thorin was not much concerned. The blatant threat to imprison his Company here if they decided to go along with Gandalf’s plan had brought home forcibly what Thorin had told himself earlier. This was enemy territory, and the sooner they were gone the better.
That meant not wasting precious time arguing over decisions which had already been made.
This conversation was over.
He swiped the parchment and the key on the way out, hoping that the argument Elrond and Gandalf were having was sufficient distraction.
He might not use these pieces of his heritage to enter his lost kingdom, but damned if he was going to let Gandalf convince some other fool to do so instead.
***
‘Thorin?’ a wary voice asked carefully, as Thorin slipped quietly through an archway and crossed the balcony it led to. Thorin cursed under his breath. Then he turned and leaned back against the balustrade, to face the small figure perched on a bench hidden in the corner. It was set back from the rest of the balcony, which explained why Thorin had not realised he was out here.
‘Bilbo,’ Thorin murmured as politely as he could. He reminded himself that he had made it all the way through the evening meal without letting slip how unsettled he was by the day’s events. Perhaps he had wished for a few moments alone in this (apparently not) empty spot, but he could wait a little longer.
Balin and Dwalin were on their guard, following a quick, pointed briefing from Thorin, and would make sure the Company were safe. It would not matter if Thorin was gone a little longer than planned.
‘What brings you outside?’ Bilbo queried.
‘I thought to get a little air,’ Thorin told him, wondering if Bilbo would catch the allusion to the night they had discussed Fíli and Kíli. Bilbo’s wry smile confirmed that he had.
‘This is a good place for it,’ the hobbit said blandly, but there was a little crease on his forehead which made Thorin think the hobbit had something else to say.
Resigning himself to conversation, even though that had been exactly the thing he had not wished for when he escaped the rest of the Company, Thorin looked around for somewhere to sit. Preferably somewhere that was not directly next to Bilbo. There were a shortage of options – typical. After a moment’s thought, Thorin moved across to the side of the balcony, a few feet distant from its only bench, and sank to the floor so he was sat at right angles to the hobbit.
‘It is a very peaceful place,’ Bilbo said after a moment, looking at Thorin more closely than usual. Thorin felt himself tense at the scrutiny, and forced himself to relax again. He did have some friends in Rivendell, he told himself firmly, and Bilbo had already proven himself one of them.
‘It is,’ Thorin acknowledged. ‘Perhaps the most peaceful I have ever been, even including your Shire.’
‘Yet, you are not tempted to stay,’ Bilbo stated, without even a hint that this was a question. ‘In fact, everything here seems to put you on edge.’ He smiled slightly at Thorin.
‘No, I would not stay,’ Thorin confirmed. ‘As we discussed before, my responsibilities lie many miles away from here; in opposite directions, at the moment, but thankfully Dís can be relied upon to take care of Ered Luin in my absence. I cannot afford to tarry here. Besides, the inactivity such peace invites is not in my nature.’
‘No’ Bilbo echoed, eyes distant for a moment. Then he looked sharply at Thorin once again. ‘Nor mine. I would not stay here either.’
Now that did surprise Thorin. Bilbo had appeared very comfortable here, particularly in his friendship with Elrond’s twin sons. Thorin had quite expected to hear that Bilbo would be spending some time here before returning to the Shire.
‘It does not appeal?’ Thorin asked curiously. ‘Your friends were certainly glad to see you. I am sure they would welcome you here, and clearly you are fond of them.’
‘I would not be so sure of that,’ Bilbo muttered in response, and Thorin raised an eyebrow in response. Bilbo must have realised how that sounded, for he shook his head and hastened to clarify. ‘Oh, I am certainly fond of them, maddening though they can be. It is only that they have their own views about what I should do next, and remaining in Rivendell does not form part of their plan.’
‘Indeed?’ Thorin queried, astonished to hear it. Were he Elladan and Elrohir, he would not be so swift to send a good friend out into the world again without him. Perhaps elves, with all their immortality, were not properly aware of how fragile life could be. How soon it could be lost.
‘Yes,’ Bilbo said bluntly. Then he paused again, and the look on his face suggested that he was somehow gathering his courage before he continued. Thorin was tempted to press, but instead he waited as patiently as he could. There was a feeling washing over him, a sense of something important coming, and he had a sudden suspicion that if Bilbo did not say his piece – whatever it may be – now, he might never do so.
‘They would have me travel further with your Company,’ Bilbo blurted out, at length. ‘In fact, they would have me travel all the way to the Iron Hills with you. They have requested it as payment of a debt I owe them.’
Thorin was silent a moment, though not as long as Bilbo had been, while he pondered this. He wondered if he looked as confused as he felt.
‘That is… a strange way to pay a debt,’ was what eventually came out of his mouth and, even to his own ears, he sounded bemused. ‘Is there aught they would have you do in the East? Is there some task you are to complete?’
‘No,’ Bilbo replied, and he sounded almost as confused as Thorin. ‘They have asked nothing else. Simply that I travel with you. They are elves,’ he added, as if hoping that would be an explanation in and of itself.
In fairness, to a dwarf it was. Elves were flighty, contrary creatures, everyone knew that. Who knew what strange fancy had come into their heads to have them request this.
The question was, would Thorin accept their request?
Only a moment’s thought was enough to tell Thorin the answer to that.
It would very much depend what Bilbo wished to do.
For while Bilbo owed the elves a debt, Thorin’s own debt to Bilbo was still very much owing. The hobbit was a competent fighter, a quiet, steady travelling companion (most of the time), and well-favoured by Thorin’s nephews. He had no reason to refuse to take Bilbo further.
Unless Bilbo did not wish to come along.
If that was the case, Thorin would make sure the elves knew quite clearly whose fault it was that their plans had failed. He would not have the hobbit pushed into something he did not wish for.
‘Would you like to accompany us?’ Thorin asked Bilbo sincerely, looking closely to judge his reaction. ‘Has Bofur convinced you of the wisdom of his plan?’
Bilbo visibly started, and a smile crept unbidden onto Thorin’s face.
‘A word to the wise, if you are to come with us, Bilbo,’ he teased kindly. ‘Balin knows almost everything, and the majority of what he knows is passed to me. What Balin does not report, Dwalin generally does. And the very little that escapes them, the boys can be relied upon to pick up. I am, in the main, exceptionally well-informed.’ He finished this litany with a proud expression cribbed from some of Erebor’s most arrogant nobles.
Bilbo began to laugh, head falling back as his mirth broke the still atmosphere briefly.
‘Goodness,’ he said through his chuckles, ‘I am in the company of accomplished spies. Maybe I should rethink my original answer to your question.’
‘I promise they only use their powers for good,’ Thorin assured him, his smile now widening to a grin. ‘My good, at least, which is all that counts.’ Bilbo grinned back, and Thorin’s heart stuttered in a way he determinedly ignored. He shoved the sensation into the back of his mind, along with a variety of impulses which had cropped up of late, and which he had occasionally let slip.
He had no time for such things, not now.
Then the moment passed, for Bilbo sobered again and Thorin remembered what he had wished to ascertain in the first place.
‘Bilbo, if you do not wish to join us, I will tell one or both of Elrond’s sons that their assistance with populating my Company is neither needed nor wanted,’ Thorin promised the hobbit. Bilbo’s eyes widened, then he shook his head again.
‘No, I would… I think I would like to come with you,’ he said, voice strengthening as he finished his sentence. ‘Yes, I would like that,’ Bilbo nodded sharply. ‘I have always wished to see a little more of the world, and the twins assure me that they will defend the Shire thoroughly even in my absence.’
‘Then you are welcome in my Company, Bilbo Baggins,’ Thorin assured him. A wry smile quirked the corner of his lips, and Bilbo tilted his head in question. ‘And we can make Bofur happy into the bargain. A good day’s work.’
They sat a moment in silence, and Thorin suddenly realised that the worst of his tension had indeed faded, even if he had not found the solitude he’d sought. He was just musing on this, eyes closing briefly, when Bilbo spoke again.
‘How much did Balin tell you of our conversation before we left the Shire?’
******
