Chapter Text
‘You took the map and the key.’
By a strong effort of will, Thorin prevented himself from spinning around and drawing his sword on the person who had somehow crept up on him. Instead, unarmed, he pivoted smoothly towards Lord Elrond, who had positioned himself in the doorway to Thorin’s room, and cursed elven light-footedness in his head.
The elves were worse than Nori and Bilbo combined when it came to scaring a dwarf out of his wits.
‘They are heirlooms of my people,’ Thorin said carefully, purposefully keeping his face blank. The elven Lord had not come here idly, not when Thorin’s Company were on the verge of departing from Rivendell. Not when he had begun with something that could be interpreted as an accusation.
‘They are,’ Elrond acknowledged. ‘Yet somehow I do not think you took them for the sake of sentimentality.’
‘I took them by right,’ Thorin pointed out harshly. ‘They may have been given into Gandalf’s keeping, but that does not change the fact that they were given to him by my father, for me, and belong to my Line. My people do not have many pieces of our history left to us. The dragon sits upon most of them now. Or has treated them all to a fiery death, for all I know. I am not willing to give up any of what is left.’
‘I have no argument with that, Thorin,’ the elf told him, and Thorin barely resisted the urge to scoff. This from the person who had threatened to lock his party up if they looked likely to use the map and key as intended. Did he think to convince Thorin he bore them no ill will, after that?
‘I can see by your face that you do not believe me,’ Elrond said quietly, ‘but it is true. I regret how I phrased my disagreement before. It is not the first time that Gandalf has provoked me into saying what I did not mean to, but I hope it will be the last. I would like to believe that after thousands of years I would grow out of such things.’
‘So you would not imprison us?’ Thorin asked sharply. Elrond sighed.
‘I hope it would not come to that. I hope that we would be able discuss the matter sensibly and reach an agreement,’ he replied. To Thorin it sounded like an evasion, and his expression must have told Elrond so.
‘Tell me, Thorin, were it someone other than yourself bound for Erebor, intent on trying to kill the dragon, and you had every reason to expect what we both fear could happen, what would you do?’
It took Thorin a moment to parse the question, and the first thing he felt obliged to point out was, ‘I am not bound for Erebor.’
‘Yes, my pardon, I mean hypothetically,’ Elrond replied immediately.
Thorin paused to think. What would he do? If it were a party of elves bound for his homeland to try and reclaim it?
‘No other has a claim to Erebor,’ he informed Elrond, meeting the elf’s eyes squarely to force his point home. ‘Any other who travelled there would be an intruder and I would deal with them as such.’ Elrond looked thoroughly frustrated for a moment, and Thorin felt a little pity for him. He knew he was being awkward so, having made his point, he let it go and took the question in the spirit it was meant. ‘However, if one of my own people now announced that they were travelling to Erebor to face the dragon, I would prevent them, both for their own safety and that of others. The dragon is simply too dangerous.’
‘Yes,’ Elrond agreed. ‘I hope, then, that you can at least understand my motives, even if we will not agree on my authority to intervene.’
Thorin gave a reluctant nod in response. They would not agree over Elrond’s authority in this matter because Thorin would still, and always, maintain that he had none and that what Thorin chose to do with his former kingdom was his own business. However, he could acknowledge that they were of the same mind on the topic of whether Smaug should be disturbed.
He would never truly trust this elf, but nor did he feel the need to begin another feud the likes of which his Line had fallen into with the Woodland King. Such feuds were simply a waste of energy that could be better used for other things.
‘I would offer an… apology of sorts, if I may,’ Elrond added. Thorin looked over questioningly, curious as to what an apology “of sorts” might look like.
‘You say much of your history is gone,’ Elrond continued, ‘and I can easily see how it might be so. However, there is a little more included in that map, I suspect, than there might first appear. Gandalf did not choose to meet you here with it, rather than giving it to you at the beginning of your journey, without a reason. Besides which, it would be very unlike your people to leave access to a secret passage, meant only for the direst of emergencies, lying out in plain sight as it appears to be.’
‘That it would. Very unlike them, indeed, especially if my father and grandfather had some part in its creation.’ Thorin repeated quietly, thinking aloud. His interest caught, Thorin reached into his coat and extracted the map from the inside pocket, where he had placed both map and key for safe-keeping. Opening it and laying it on the table, he took a proper look at this part of his heritage. It took him only moments to come to a realisation. ‘Moon-letters. If there was something to hide, that is how my forebears would have hidden it. Dwarven secrets kept safe with a dwarven invention.’
‘So I, too, believe,’ Elrond confirmed. ‘The only question, then, would be how safe they chose to keep it. If it can be read at any time, we will be able to look now. If not, then you will need to keep looking as the weeks pass.’
Thorin eyed him suspiciously again, wondering if this really was the apology that Elrond was making it out to be, or whether it was simply an attempt to gain more information about Erebor’s secret entrance. Elrond, ever sharp, held his hands up as if to show he was unarmed.
‘You are under no obligation to share with me what, if anything, you find, Thorin,’ he insisted. ‘By all means, look in private or not at all. There is a good viewing point on the south terrace, not far from my study. Whether you choose to use it or not is entirely up to you.’
With a nod, the elf exited, leaving Thorin with a quandary.
Could he resist knowing what might be there? Could he resist looking now?
It might be nothing. There might be nothing. It was naught but pure speculation on Elrond’s part, and on Thorin’s as well.
Yet, there might be something. One final message from his family, left for him to find.
How could he give up the chance to learn of something like that?
Patience had never been the strongest of his virtues, after all.
***
There was nothing.
Thorin was bitterly disappointed in himself for being so disappointed.
What did it matter what was or was not there? He had no intention of ever returning to Erebor. He was only heading that way at all because Dain lived on the other side and Thorin would have to pass by in order to reach him.
Fool.
Sentimental fool.
What had he hoped to gain? Neither Thrór nor Thráin had left him anything but trouble, unless one counted Dís.
Perhaps even if one did count Dís. She was hardly a paragon of serenity, even on her best days.
Either way, it was ridiculous to be disappointed that he had not found something which might not even be there.
Thorin sighed, ready to scrunch the cursed thing up in his hand and stuff it away again, even if Balin would murder him for treating old documents with such disdain.
Then he saw it.
Just the barest flicker of silver on the bottom of the parchment.
Tiny.
Barely there.
But something.
The phase of the moon was not right yet, but it seemed it would be soon. The moon-letters were just beginning to reflect the light.
It seemed Thorin was destined to learn this secret after all.
***
Bilbo was quiet as they left Rivendell, but then Thorin had expected him to be. The hobbit had spoken a great deal of something he rarely held up to the light, and it would take time to tuck those memories away again. It was the same reason that Thorin almost never spoke of Azanulbizar. The remembering was difficult, but trying to forget again was almost worse.
The Company had been, for the most part, plainly delighted by Bilbo’s decision to continue on to the Iron Hills with them. Thorin had even received a wholly unexpected hug from his youngest nephew, accompanied by a beaming smile from the eldest, which appeared to relate to his agreement that Bilbo should come.
It worried Thorin a little that the boys seemed to be using the same tactics he and Dís had used on them when they were small, trying to reward what they viewed as good behaviour, but he chose to ignore it for now.
The celebrations over Bilbo’s decision had been muted, however, by normal dwarven standards. The Company had picked up on the steady wariness Balin and Dwalin had been exuding prior to their departure from Rivendell, and also on Bilbo’s pensive mood. None of the Company knew what Thorin and Bilbo had spoken of - Thorin was no rattle-mouth, to spill someone’s secrets to the world – but they respected Bilbo’s evident desire for quiet time to think. They were good dwarves, those he had brought with him, even the ones who were… of occasionally dubious morality.
Now, as they broke camp on the second day since their departure, Thorin moved between them, checking that all was well. The Misty Mountains always made him nervous. They were not mountains like those in Ered Luin, or the solitary peak of Erebor, used to being mined and lived in by generations of dwarves. These mountains were inhabited only by orcs and goblins and other fell things Thorin preferred not to encounter. They did not feel friendly to his kind, and it set Thorin on edge.
‘Adjust that strap, Bombur,’ he murmured quietly, tapping the reserved dwarf on the shoulder and gesturing to the pack he wore. ‘Tighten it just a little. They are uneven at the moment, and one is wearing more than the other.’ Bombur smiled, without speaking, and moved to do as Thorin suggested.
Thorin carried on, but paused almost immediately and tried to hide a smile.
‘Dori,’ he said patiently, only to snort when he realised he’d done it again. Sometimes dwarven naming conventions were a curse. ‘Ori,’ he corrected himself, and the young dwarf looked up at him expectantly. ‘Aren’t you forgetting something?’
Ori looked thoroughly puzzled, until Thorin gestured to the rock on which the scribe had left both his spare shirts after washing them last night. Apparently, covering everything you owned with ink on a regular basis was one of the perils of being an apprentice scribe, at least according to Dori’s cries of tolerant exasperation when he’d discovered the damage.
Ori immediately abandoned the sketchbook he had been packing so carefully and shot across the campsite to collect his belongings, presumably before Dori worked out he’d nearly left them behind. Thorin stopped trying to hide the smile.
Which wasn’t a problem, because it was short-lived anyway.
‘What, exactly, do you think you are doing up there?’ he rapped out, striding forward and catching a handful of Kíli’s hair. His troublesome nephew was hanging upside down from a tree, of all things! Thorin could not wait to hear the explanation for this one.
‘I was… er, that is… I was…,’ Kíli stuttered.
‘Doing your best to break your idiot neck and get me in trouble with your mother for the rest of my life?’ Thorin suggested helpfully, loosing Kíli’s hair long enough for him to get down.
‘No,’ Kíli replied brightly, looking relieved to be able to answer this question. ‘No, I am absolutely certain I wasn’t doing that. No matter what else I was… might have been… doing on a dare. Such as seeing how long I could last upside down without going purple.’
This last section came out all in a rush, and Thorin lost the power of speech for several seconds, then viewed Kíli with utter disbelief for several more.
‘Oh, just… go and do something useful!’ he commanded eventually, unsure if anything else he said would even make a difference. The trouble with his nephews was that they always applied the commands he gave them (in these sorts of situations, anyway) in the most frustratingly specific fashion.
Well, yes, Uncle. We KNOW you said not to try hunting for honey from bee-hives anymore, but that was in the summer. It’s nearly mid-winter now, we thought they’d be asleep!
Sometimes it just wasn’t worth wasting his breath.
Thorin pinched the bridge of his nose and took several deep breaths, then turned back to checking on his Company. When he did, he caught sight of Bilbo looking at him curiously. Thorin raised an eyebrow in question, wondering about the wry quirk at the corner of Bilbo’s mouth. Bilbo said nothing, however, just gave him the most beautiful smile and then turned back to the pack at his feet.
That was… odd.
Very odd.
Not unpleasant, though.
***
It had taken Bilbo some time to settle himself after his conversation with Thorin, which he supposed was only to be expected. He had wondered if he would have nightmares again, after dragging it all back up. Reminders of those days normally left a week’s worth of bad dreams behind. However, while the first night had been restless, it had been nowhere near as bad as he’d feared and once they were back on the road he had been fine. Perhaps it was being surrounded by so many others whose presence was so obvious in the night. At home, Bilbo had always felt very much alone at night-time, even when Bungo was still alive and sharing the smial.
His days had been filled with quite a lot of thinking, but that was also not as painful as it could have been. Bilbo had found himself turning his memories over, viewing them first from one angle and then from another, and discovering that somehow, some of the worst of the pain had drained away. It still hurt, and he had wiped away more than one tear at the thought of his feisty, determined mother discovering that the world was harder than she had ever thought, and that sometimes not even immense courage could save you.
Yet, impossible though it was for Bilbo to explain, the harshest pangs had eased now he had shared the worst of his life with someone and had received understanding and sympathy in turn. He knew the sympathy in the Shire had been genuine, but his fellow hobbits generally preferred to forget such evils as soon as possible. Bilbo had been unable to forget, and they had not understood. Even Violet had urged him to move forward.
Thorin, it seemed, did understand, and was equally unable to forget his own griefs. Just knowing it made Bilbo feel less alone.
Besides, it was hard to feel alone when there were dwarves everywhere, and half of them were fussing over you in the gentlest way imaginable. The boys had, for the most part, been stuck to him like glue, and he was half-convinced that Kíli’s antics in the tree had been designed solely to make him laugh. Ori had given him a truly beautiful drawing of the twins as a gift only last night, ducking his head when Bilbo praised his talent profusely. Nori had magically produced mushrooms out of nowhere (as far as Bilbo could tell) and Bofur and Bombur had happily included them in dinner that night and ensured Bilbo had the largest portion.
They were sweet and, though Bilbo wasn’t quite sure what to do with such sweetness, he could not help enjoying it. It reminded him of all the best parts of life with his family, years and years ago.
Thorin, Bilbo was increasingly realising, was also surprisingly sweet when you watched a bit more carefully. Bilbo had been keeping an eye on the dwarven King as he made his way around the camp, and had noticed the easy way that he checked up on his people and the small steps he took to solve their problems.
He had also concluded, after further observation, that Thorin could actually tell the Company apart, he was just abysmal at picking the correct name when speaking to them. Bilbo could accept that. Apparently giving your children confusingly similar names was something of a dwarven tradition, and in all honesty it was a wonder any of them were ever called by the correct name.
Or perhaps they were not and just, like the larger hobbit families, got used to answering to a variety of names. Fortinbras’ father, Isumbras, had always claimed that as long as his mother didn’t reach the cats’ names before she got to his own, he counted himself perfectly content.
Either way, Bilbo could not help but smile when Thorin’s gentle patience with Ori gave way to a kind of exasperated tolerance as he dealt with Kíli’s mischief. It was easier, now, to see the fondness underneath it all.
And that made Bilbo fonder of Thorin, even if Bofur had told him that Thorin was treating him like a dwarven princess.
Some changes happened whether you wanted them to or not.
***
The Misty Mountains were, Bofur soon decided, a climate unto themselves. The weather hadn’t been all that bad when they left Rivendell, but the winds up here could freeze Mahal’s balls off.
Ah well, as long as they didn’t freeze Bofur’s off, that was the main thing.
Still, he was keeping a close eye on their hobbit, walking along in front of him. Bilbo was such a little thing, for all his ferocity, and those clothes were not made for this sort of weather. He needed something fur-lined, really, but they hadn’t been able to find anything to fit him in Rivendell. Instead they’d made do with adding a layer or two underneath his cloak and then putting him in between Bofur and Bombur so that the two of them could try and block the wind out.
Not that they’d told Bilbo this. There was no need to set the lad off when he’d only just stopped bristling at the slightest hint that they didn’t think he was a warrior.
Other than the cold – or possibly including the cold – the Misty Mountains were very boring, in a life-threatening, death-possible-at-any-moment, sort of way. There was nothing to do except stare at the head of the person in front of you, or the stone next to you, which was hardly thrilling.
Bofur liked stone, as a general rule. Most people said you couldn’t talk to the stuff, but Bofur had yet to find anything he couldn’t talk to. Things didn’t always answer back, but if he was going to let something like that stop him then he’d rarely talk to anything. Anyway, the stone did answer back, after a fashion, with images and feelings if not with words and Bofur had spent many a happy hour entertaining himself that way.
The problem was, this stone was wrong.
Bofur had tried to talking to it when they first began walking, though admittedly it was more difficult when he had to keep moving all the time and couldn’t keep steady contact with the surface. It didn’t respond like he’d expected though, and Bofur wasn’t sure why. He’d had his brother and cousin try as well, and they’d both reported the same thing, but neither had been able to explain any better than he had.
It was as if the stone was separated out into much smaller sections than normal, which Bofur had never come across before. Those sections were none too friendly, either. Bofur had been receiving definite ‘get lost and leave me alone’ impressions from it, which was one of the main reasons he’d given up. He’d never yet been rejected by the stone like that and he didn’t much like his chances if it decided to take serious exception to his presence.
If the whole thing made him think of old legends – ones so old that their origins were lost in time – about stone giants that lived in the mountains and came out in thunderstorms to battle one another. Well, he kept those thoughts to himself. Some of their Company were more nervy in this setting than others, and there was no need to set Dor… well, set any of them off over an old story.
Not that he’d have worried about all that, of course, if he’d known what was going to happen next.
***
It was Dwalin who realised first, which didn’t surprise Ori in the slightest. Dwalin always seemed to spot these things before anyone else did, which was one of the reasons he managed to keep Nori almost in line when no other guard had ever done so. Dwalin was bringing up the rear of the line, with Ori just in front of him, and Thorin was leading the way at the other end. They all startled when Dwalin suddenly bellowed at the top of his voice, but particularly Ori, who wondered if he’d just lost his hearing on that side permanently.
‘Thorin, look down,’ Dwalin roared at full volume, pulling both axes into his hands, and inevitably they all did exactly that. Below them, a group of goblins were scaling the rock face with a speed that Ori, at least, found frightening. He fumbled for his sling, wondering if he could hit them at that angle when they were moving so fast. Then, unexpectedly, he felt Dwalin shove a dagger into his hand. He looked down and discovered that he was holding one of Nori’s blades, which confused him utterly, but moments later he no longer had time to think about it.
The goblins were on them, and it was immediately clear that it was going to be a hard-fought battle. Thanks to Dwalin’s warning all of the Company were armed, but they were also hemmed in on a narrow path, with a horrific drop only inches away if they faltered. Almost as one, they pressed their backs to the rock behind them and held their weapons before them. Ori lost sight of what the others were doing only seconds later, caught up in fending off the first of his attackers.
He managed that first one fairly well, catching it in the throat as it scrambled up over the ledge and killing it quickly. It fell back off the edge, unable to find purchase because its hands had instinctively come up to staunch the wound at its throat.
Unfortunately for Ori, the next two goblins decided to work in tandem. As one of them came up onto the path to face Ori directly, the other remained below and grabbed at his ankle, tugging forward as it tried to unbalance him into falling.
Ori kicked out with his other foot once, then had to pause as the goblin on the path lunged for him with a dirty, serrated knife. Ori knew he needed to buy himself time to deal with the goblin below, so he knocked the knife out of its hand and used his own free hand to grab the goblin by its skinny throat and thrust it away from him, holding it at arm’s length. With its much shorter reach it was now unable to get to him. The goblin made as much fuss as it could, scrabbling at his hand and trying to yank it away, but the move at least bought Ori the time he needed.
He kicked at the goblin below a second time, then a third, and finally on the fourth go he caught it on the head and stunned it. It, too, fell to its death. When it tried for a handhold, realising too late what was happening, it only succeeded in pulling a goblin that was attacking Bofur down with it.
‘Thanks, lad,’ Bofur shouted gaily, breaking another’s goblin’s hand with the end of his mattock as it tried to pull itself up over the ledge.
At this point, the goblin Ori was holding succeeded in pulling Ori’s thumb back enough to make him howl unintentionally. It shrieked gleefully as Ori released it, leaping forward at him only to find itself impaled on the dagger he’d thrust forward. Ori yanked the dagger back out and shoved the goblin backwards off the path.
Then there was another attacker to deal with, and another after that, until suddenly Ori found himself with no goblin in front of him. He looked around, startled, to find that many of the others had also run out of enemies; Óin was reaching forward to untangle a goblin that had all-but plastered itself to Glóin and, once done, hurled it casually into the abyss before them.
Fíli and Kíli, at the far end, were exchanging places so that Kíli could fire on a particularly large goblin that Thorin was facing, while Fíli took his daggers to the three goblins all attacking Balin at once. Balin was wearing, from what little Ori could see, the same expression he wore when having his beard tugged by young dwarflings at the market, so Ori wasn’t too worried about him.
Having checked that the others were alright, Ori was about to turn to see if Dwalin needed help – it didn’t sound as if he was struggling but it was only polite to check – when he discovered that the goblins had one last surprise for him.
A final wave had somehow, perhaps by pressing close to the rock face and creeping up ever so slowly, escaped their notice. Suddenly, the goblins launched themselves upwards all at once and the Company were each under attack once more. Ori heard a yelp and some scrambling from his left, but he did not have time to worry about it. He had been stupid, and lax, and had not been prepared for this final assault.
Before he even had time to protect himself, a goblin had shoved in close and was making a concerted effort to rip his throat out with its teeth. Ori dropped his weapon in surprise.
The goblin didn’t even seem to have a weapon, or not that Ori could tell in his admittedly distracted state. It wasn’t trying to stab him, or club him, just to gets its sharp, pointy teeth into his jugular.
Now, abruptly, Ori found that he was the one scrabbling around his neck, getting one hand onto the goblin’s forehead and another on its chin and shoving back with all his might. That worked to keep him alive, but he could not seem to free himself from the goblin completely. It had one hand clawed in the back of his coat, the other yanking down on his hood to bare his throat, and both legs wrapped around his waist as it clung on determinedly.
Ori knew that he needed to loosen its grip. He wanted to try and slam back against the rock behind him, thinking he might be able to break its knee or one of its hands, to buy himself some room, but he didn’t dare take an ounce of his attention off keeping its head pushed back. If he lost that fight, he was done for.
All he could do now was hope that Dwalin or Bofur came to his aid.
In the end, however, it was neither Dwalin nor Bofur who saved him.
Instead, one large, hairy foot shot past his head and impacted on the face of the goblin holding him. Ori had been holding it with its head almost horizontal, facing the sky, and so the foot broke the goblin’s nose… and possibly one of Ori’s fingers in the process, but Ori was hardly going to complain at the result. The goblin squealed madly and lost its grip on Ori’s hood and coat in surprise. Ori, not in as much pain and so reacting quicker, leaned forward and then jerked backwards, inflicting as much damage on its legs as possible. He heard another satisfying crack, and one of the goblin’s legs slipped loose.
That was all Ori needed.
He let go of the goblin’s face, caught it by the scruff of the neck and yanked backwards. Still squealing with pain, the goblin detached from him and Ori let it go, dropping it off the edge.
All should have been over and done, but the goblin flailed upwards for a hold, grabbed Bilbo’s foot and yanked at the thick hair that covered the top. Bilbo, balanced rather precariously on the side of the mountain, slipped, toppling past Ori and into nothingness, and Ori heard himself yell with fright.
At the same time, he heard two separate shouts as Bofur and Dwalin threw themselves forward to grab for Bilbo. Dwalin got a handful of jacket at almost the same time that Bofur – thank Mahal and all the Valar – clasped Bilbo’s hand and upper arm, and between the two of them they hauled Bilbo back onto the path.
Bilbo looked as shaky as Ori felt, and for long moments they all stood there, pressed together and breathing hard with leftover shock. There were, to everyone’s relief, no more goblins.
From down the line came various cries of, ‘Bilbo! Is Bilbo alright?’ and ‘Ori? Ori!’, and after a pause to steady himself Dwalin shouted back, ‘They’re fine. Everyone’s fine, calm down!’ but he didn’t move.
‘That was exciting,’ Bofur finally spoke, sounding distinctly shaky. ‘Let’s not do it again, lads. Ever, please.’
‘Agreed,’ Dwalin grumbled instantly. ‘The two of you took nearly a hundred years off my life.’
‘We’d better hope I didn’t lose a hundred as well,’ Bilbo said smartly, though his voice quavered as he did so. ‘Hobbits don’t even live that long. I’d drop dead in a few minutes, and wouldn’t that surprise you all?’
‘I think I’d like to get off this mountain now,’ was Ori’s contribution, and the thought of doing so straightened them all up.
‘Also agreed,’ Dwalin replied. ‘Thorin!’ he yelled again, ‘get moving, will you? The sooner we’re off this blasted death-trap, the better.’
Thorin didn’t hesitate and, though they were still careful, they travelled very swiftly after that.
***
