Chapter Text
‘How much did Balin tell you of our conversation before we left the Shire?’ Bilbo forced himself to say, though it was perilously close to the top of his ‘things I never, ever wish to do’ list. There were one or two things which beat it to the top of that list – invite Lobelia Sackville-Baggins to live at Bag End, face a dragon from the old tales single-handed, take advice from Gandalf etc, etc – but discussing his history with another was still fairly high up.
It was only fair, however. They were to be his travelling companions for months on end. It was right that they should know the truth behind his waking nightmares. Goodness knows, the journey to the Iron Hills was not likely to be safe. They might yet be faced with orcs, and Bilbo might slip again.
Besides, much as he hated to admit it (and he truly did) the twins had rarely steered Bilbo wrong with their advice.
Certainly they had been the only ones to take him seriously all those years ago, which suggested they viewed the world with clearer eyes than many Bilbo had met.
‘Very little, except that he saw no cause for concern,’ Thorin replied, surprising Bilbo greatly. His surprise must have shown, for Thorin immediately added, ‘I was truthful when I said that Balin reports most of what he knows to me, Bilbo, but he makes an exception for information which is truly private. In those cases I must trust to his judgement, but I always do. Balin would not be my Steward if I could not place my confidence in him.’
‘No,’ Bilbo murmured, thinking fast, ‘I suppose not.’
Now, it seemed to Bilbo, there was another choice before him. Did he tell his story to Thorin, who would lead the Company, or did he take the easy way out and tell only Balin, who already knew a small part and would apparently keep his secrets for him?
He pondered for a moment, thankfully not long enough for Thorin to become restless with their stuttering conversation, then upbraided himself firmly.
Thorin was trusting him to join an important undertaking simply because Bilbo was curious about the world and had a debt to pay. He had, of late, been nothing but kind. Had offered, in fact, to do battle with the sons of Elrond on Bilbo’s behalf, in defence of his right to do as he pleased.
What reason had he given Bilbo not to trust him, really? Grumpiness did not equate to being untrustworthy. Nor did an occasionally short temper.
Otherwise, Bilbo admitted in a burst of frankness, no one would ever trust him with anything!
And it might feel… good, he suddenly thought, to tell someone who didn’t already know what had happened. Someone who hadn’t had a role, however small, in this story. Bilbo could say what he liked to Thorin, didn’t have to worry about hurt feelings or well-meaning corrections of his memory. He could just… Get it out in the open. Just once.
Coming out of his musings, Bilbo removed his gaze from his knees (which he had apparently been contemplating with great fervour for the last minute or two) and met Thorin’s eyes.
‘Very well,’ Bilbo said, taking a deep breath. He noticed that Thorin immediately straightened, as if sensing that the conversation was to turn serious again. Bilbo quirked his lips wryly, and settled more comfortably on his bench.
‘It began with the Fell Winter,’ he told the King. ‘2911, by your reckoning.’
‘I remember it,’ Thorin informed him gently. ‘It was not a year I will soon forget. I do not think any who lived through it will.’
‘You might be surprised,’ Bilbo replied darkly, then shook it off and continued. ‘I was 21 that year, still 12 years from my majority but beginning to feel, as all young people seem to at that age, that I could do anything and knew everything. I must have driven my parents mad.’
Thorin chuckled, his face showing sympathy. Bilbo suspected he had been on both sides of that particular problem, with Fíli and Kíli so recently grown to manhood.
Almost-manhood. There were still a few creases to iron out in that pair.
‘At first I didn’t truly concern myself with the changes to our normal winter weather,’ Bilbo continued. ‘It was colder than usual, yes, but what is a little cold when you are in your tweens? It was an adventure. More snow than I had ever before had to experiment with, which was simply a good reason to find entirely childish things to do with it, whilst still assuring myself that I was far beyond such juvenile pastimes.’
‘The blissful ignorance of youth,’ Thorin murmured, his expression kinder than Bilbo would have expected when dealing with such folly. Thorin shook his head. ‘At 22, I took it into my head that I was quite ready to leave the custody of my parents and live on my own. I was certain that I was far too old to spend so much of my time with my considerably-younger siblings… in truth, there were five years between my brother and myself, but I would not be told. My mother, being a wise woman, swiftly found a way to disabuse me of this notion, but I am not unfamiliar with the feelings you describe. As you said, almost all young people seem to suffer from the affliction.’
‘Do they all miss the disaster right before their eyes, I wonder,’ Bilbo said. His tone was bitter, for this was a crime he had charged himself with many a time. Perhaps if he had noticed what was happening, he might have done… more.
Done something.
‘My grandfather was losing his grip on sanity,’ Thorin told Bilbo bluntly. ‘At that age, the change in him barely registered. He was an adult, and therefore of little importance in a world where I was, ironically, convinced that I was an adult also.’
Having finished, Thorin wore the same expression he had after they spoke of Fíli and Kíli, as if he could not quite believe what had fallen out of his mouth. He did not take it back, however, or try to gloss over it. He simply left it there, sitting between them as a balm to Bilbo’s regret.
Strangely, despite the failure of every other reassurance Bilbo had received over the years, this one made him feel better.
Maybe it was because Thorin’s situation had been equally grave, and yet Bilbo could not imagine criticising the 22-year-old Thorin for not having been more aware of the problem. In fact, he realised, Fíli and Kíli were years older than either Bilbo or Thorin had been, and yet Bilbo still would not blame them for being unaware of the brewing disaster in Ered Luin…
It was certainly something to consider further.
***
Thorin’s last words had, it seemed, given Bilbo cause to think. He was happy for it. Thorin was not unfamiliar with that sort of guilt, the type that insisted you ought to have acted, because hindsight gave you such a wonderful view of all the roads that could have been taken.
Bilbo, unfortunately, did not seem to have had a Balin or a Dwalin to take him to task over it.
More than that, he had not had a Dís to lose patience with him entirely and all-but bash him over the head with reality.
Which was not to say that Thorin did not hold himself accountable for what had happened with Thror in later years, but he had, at the least, admitted some years ago that he did not hold the main responsibility for Erebor’s downfall.
He tried not to think too often about who did hold responsibility for that. It was too painful a subject.
Self-reflection aside, Thorin was aware that they were drifting off Bilbo’s original topic, and that the hobbit had by no means reached the end of his tale.
‘So, the winter came in hard…’ Thorin stated, allowing his voice to trail off in an invitation for Bilbo to continue.
‘Yes,’ Bilbo said abruptly, also realising that they had wandered and taking up his thread again. ‘The first time I really noticed what was happening, it was because we had smaller portions at meal-times. It was not something I had ever encountered before, the sort of rationing I now know my mother was practising. After a few days, I asked why she was trying to starve us, thinking it was all a joke. That was the first time she suggested the food might be running out.
‘I hardly believed her at first, though she was not in the habit of lying to me, but the next time I was at the market I realised it was true. There was far less to buy than there usually would be. Worse, the poorer hobbits were taking scraps that were usually left for the pigs. When I went home, I looked more closely and realised that the Gamgees’ eldest children were already beginning to look gaunt. I mentioned it to Mother that evening, and the next day there was even less on our table, but more on theirs. In the end, even that was not enough.’
‘Famine,’ Thorin said, voice laden with sadness, thinking of the curse he was trying so desperately to avoid in Ered Luin. Thinking of the times, both during the Fell Winter and during their exile, when that curse had overtaken his people despite his best efforts.
‘Yes,’ Bilbo confirmed gravely. ‘I did not know what to call it then, but I soon learned. The stores ran dry. We began to starve… and then the Brandywine River froze.’
This last he uttered as if it were a death knell, then gave Thorin a shy look which took him entirely off guard.
‘You probably didn’t need to know the rest of that,’ Bilbo told him, though he did not seem particularly dissatisfied with where he had begun his tale. ‘It was just…’
‘Important for you to tell, perhaps?’ Thorin concluded, when Bilbo trailed off. The hobbit nodded sharply.
‘Yes, I think it was,’ he agreed. Conclusion reached, he shook his head slightly and carried on with his recounting.
‘With the river frozen, the wolves began to cross into the Shire. White wolves from the frozen lands in the North, near twice the size of the type we were used to. The Horn-call of Buckland sounded when they first appeared, a warning to all, and everyone who could retreated into their homes and barred the doors. Some were not so lucky, and the wolves soon realised that crossing the frozen river would earn them a meal. Particularly with the famine gripping us. People were desperate, they went foraging even knowing that it was dangerous outside. What else could they do? Their children cried for food, some wasted away from the lack of it, as did the elderly. They weighed up the risk of the wolves against the certainty of starvation and took their chances. Some won, some lost.’
Thorin nodded sombrely, all too familiar with weighing up such risks. This was exactly the sort of conundrum that had sent Thorin out on his journey. Was it better to act, and hope that nothing worse caught you unawares, or to hide away and hope that the original problem did not kill you off?
He scolded himself firmly for his arrogant assumption that the hobbits, particularly Bilbo but also all of the others he had met, could not have known suffering like his own people. Clearly they had known more than anyone should.
‘We had been amongst those locked in our homes,’ Bilbo said, lost to the present now and gazing distantly into the past. ‘We had had some small stores left when the horn sounded, and Mother had invited some of our neighbours to join us with their own stores as well. Bag End was sturdy and well-built, more capable of withstanding a possible attack. The Rangers had been sent to, they were always our first line of defence in times of trouble, and the adults reassured themselves it would not be long… but a day turned into a week, and still no help came. Only the wolves.’
Thorin’s brow creased in surprise, for he knew of the Rangers and had never heard them to be lax in their duties.
‘I learned, months later, that our defenders had been hard pressed in their own lands, trying to deal with roving bands of orcs driven out of the mountains by the snow and ice. They had received our calls for help and had, in turn, sent their fastest riders to Rivendell to ask for aid. As many of them as could gather together were pushing forward to the Shire, defending their backs all the time from the orcs and other creatures in search of easier food. They were only a few days away when Mother lost patience with waiting.’
Internally, Thorin winced. That did not bode well, not when he felt instinctively that they were now coming to the crux of the matter.
‘Mother had always counted Gandalf as a good friend,’ Bilbo explained sadly. ‘I vaguely remember meeting him as a small child, when he came to the Old Took’s Midsummer’s-Eve party to provide the fireworks.’ His voice turned nearly wistful for a moment, and in other circumstances his next words would have made Thorin smile, ‘I believe I beat him with a wooden sword. It is a thought that has often comforted me over the years.
‘When Mother grew impatient with the waiting, concerned that the Rangers had not received our messages and would not come, she decided to set out to find them and, more importantly, find Gandalf. He had promised to visit her near Yuletide with a curiosity they had discussed during his last visit, and she was certain that he could not be far away. My parents argued about it, that much I remember clearly, though they kept the arguments in their own room. They did not like to be seen disagreeing in public.’
By now, silent tears had begun to run down Bilbo’s face from his closed eyes, and he had a death-grip on the edge of the bench he sat on, though his voice remained remarkably steady. Thorin felt frozen in the face of his grief, not sure Bilbo remembered who he was telling his tale to.
Or if he even remembered there was anyone there at all.
‘The arguments lasted three days. On the fourth day, she set out before dawn, while everyone else was still sleeping. We slept as often as not, by then, when sleep would come. It helped stave off the hunger. Only I was awake. I’d heard her moving through the smial. I sat up as she began to open the door, and she looked over, held her finger to her lips, and winked. Even then, she still tried to pretend as if everything was alright for me. I knew what she meant to do, I did, but I was so used to Mother having all the answers, being able to solve every problem, that it didn’t occur to me to try and stop her. I do not think Bungo ever forgave me for it.
‘She left, closing the door behind her, and never returned. I do not know how long she was gone before she ran into trouble, but it cannot have been long. It was no more than a week before the orcs arrived in the Shire, holding her head aloft as a trophy.’
Thorin could not help a groan of horror, and Bilbo’s eyes opened briefly, focusing on Thorin for only a second before pain forced him to close them again.
‘I did not see it,’ the hobbit whispered, perhaps as a reassurance. ‘Of course, the orcs did not know where their trophy would have most effect, and they reached Brandybuck lands first. They arrived at about the same time that Gandalf, the elves and the Rangers did; they never made it as far as Hobbiton. There were reports, however, from the Brandybucks who had tried to guard their borders. It was definitely Mother.’
‘Bilbo, I am sorry,’ Thorin murmured, though he knew it could make no difference to so deep a grief.
‘It was a long time ago,’ Bilbo replied, then shook his head disbelievingly. ‘We learn to do that, have you realised?’ he asked Thorin starkly. ‘To say things like “it was a long time ago”, to let people feel as if we are somehow better now. As if the pain has somehow lessened.’
‘Yes,’ Thorin agreed, equally blunt. ‘I know.’ When Bilbo looked at him questioningly, drawn out of his own mind by the sincerity of Thorin’s response, Thorin added, ‘I have lost all of my family except Dís and the boys, Bilbo. Some griefs do not heal. Not truly. I think perhaps some of us do not know how to let them.’
‘No,’ Bilbo concurred. ‘I do not, though Gandalf preaches that I must every time we see one another, the interfering old busybody. As if my grief is somehow his business simply because he knew my mother, even though he would do nothing to help me when it mattered.’
‘When it mattered?’ Thorin questioned, sensing that there was another poisonous wound sitting beneath that statement. Perhaps one that also needed leaching. Bilbo had told his tale so far as if he could not stop. As if, having started to let someone see all that he usually hid, he had to get everything out at once. Thorin could only hope there was some sort of healing in it.
Whether there was or not, Bilbo chose to answer.
‘Danger came to the Shire and none of us could do a thing about it,’ he explained. ‘Looking back, I can see it was madness for Mother to even try and reach Gandalf. She knew nothing of swordplay, or of travelling in that sort of weather. She was, quite literally, a lamb among a wolf pack. Or an orc pack. Even then, however, I knew that we could not rely on others to save us. We had to be ready to save ourselves. Elladan and Elrohir were amongst those who came to our aid. When I asked to be taught to fight, they agreed to try and teach me. Gandalf objected, strenuously. He said I had no need of the lessons, that it could do no good. They discussed in private, in the main, but that much I heard. He did not wish me to be able to defend myself. Maybe it offended his view of the Shire as a well-protected idyll, I do not know. Regardless, as you can see, the twins ignored his objections and I learned. When they returned to Rivendell in the late summer, I… convinced the Rangers to continue my training, and then to take me out on patrol with them sometimes.’
‘They trained you well,’ Thorin offered, suspecting that Bilbo’s fighting prowess was as much a point of pride for the hobbit as it would be for a dwarf. He was glad now that Dwalin had offered praise even when Thorin had not thought to do so himself. Thorin could understand, only too well, the driving need to be able to protect what you loved when you had suffered such a loss.
‘Thank you,’ Bilbo replied, though Thorin was sure the response was as much training as, “It was a long time ago,” had been. The hobbit remained thoughtful, focused inward, for several moments longer before he added one final verse to his tale.
‘This is why I want to come with you,’ he told Thorin fiercely, when he spoke again. ‘To see a different world. It was like… like when you see a pattern or an image in a mark upon the floor. It is clear as day one moment, but if you look away and then back it is gone and you can never see it again. The Shire will never be the same for me now, and I think Elrohir is right. It is time I saw more of the world. Maybe then, when I return, the Shire will have changed again.’
‘Then we will take you with us,’ Thorin promised him once more. He rose to his feet, stiff and achy after so much time spent in one position, and crossed to clasp Bilbo on the shoulder. ‘We will take you with us, and see if we can find you a different way of looking.’
******
