Chapter Text
By the following evening, it was quite clear that Fíli was very ill indeed.
Deathly ill, Óin was sure, though the thought was so fiercely painful that he shied from it instinctively.
This was his little cousin, Fíli. The child of Durin’s blood his people had longed for when all seemed to be falling to pieces despite Thorin’s best efforts.
Óin had delivered him, and wept alongside Dís when they managed it safely. They’d waited for him to start screaming, as all the new-born babes Óin had delivered had done. When nothing had happened, Óin had feared he’d done something wrong after all, that the birth had been deceptively easy and something serious was wrong with the lad.
He’d lifted Fíli oh-so-carefully towards him, to get a better look… and the babe had calmly reached up with one hand and patted him on the cheek, as if reassuring him that everything was alright.
Not so much as a whimper.
He was whimpering now.
He was trying so hard not to, trying not to distress Kíli and Thorin any more than they already were, but he could not keep the sounds back. Fíli was in agony, they all knew it, but he was determined for their sake to pretend he was not.
Still reassuring them all, even now.
Mahal, would this curse Thror had laid over their family ever leave them?
At first, Dori had carried Fíli carefully as they walked, draping the lad over his back so that Fíli could rest his head against Dori’s shoulder and try to sleep. The strength in that family was one of those well-known pieces of gossip that Óin had never really believed until he’d seen it first-hand. Dori seemed to have no trouble at all carrying Fíli, and Nori had shouldered two extra packs without appearing to notice the additional weight. Óin, who would be the first to admit that he judged quickly and rarely changed his opinion, found increasing respect for both of them.
For all this Company, in fact. They had pushed on without rest since the battle and there hadn’t been a single complaint. He could feel them willing Fíli on, hear murmured prayers at intervals as they all tried to intervene with their creator for Fíli’s life.
Let it work. Please let it work.
Their only hope now was a miracle. Óin had done all he could.
No one had mentioned, when he’d gone into the healing profession, how many people he would singularly fail to save.
If they had, he’d probably have changed his mind. No doubt that was why they hadn’t mentioned it.
A few hours before, Fíli had finally whispered to Dori that he couldn’t hold on any longer. His arm was going numb and he couldn’t grip. At that point Bifur had found them two sizeable branches and they’d lashed a blanket between the two. Now Dori, Dwalin, Bombur and Thorin carried their sick Prince, taking as much care as they could in the forest.
Bofur led the way, his face a mask of concentration that Óin had never seen on him before. He had an idea, from the conversation between the miner and his cousin, that Bofur was not only guiding them but also seeking constantly for some sign of how far they had to go.
Something for Fíli, Kíli and Thorin to hold onto.
‘Did they execute the dwarf who caused that mine collapse?’ Bilbo asked him suddenly. Óin was so startled by the choice of topic that he tripped and had to catch hold of Bilbo to keep upright. He hadn’t realised the hobbit had joined him. Whether that was due to Bilbo’s quiet way of moving or Oín’s own deafness was hard to say.
‘Aye, they did,’ Óin confirmed. ‘Only punishment for treason.’
‘Pity,’ Bilbo said mildly, but Óin looked over and saw that his eyes were anything but mild. Inside, they held a banked fury that rivalled dragon-fire for heat. ‘I would have liked to have met him.’ Óin nearly gaped, but then Bilbo continued and he understood that this was the hobbit version of rage, tucked nice and polite-like behind their social masks. ‘I would have brought him to this forest and lashed him to one of these trees and then found somewhere to wait. I’m sure the spiders would appear soon enough if I laid their food out for them.’
‘We would thank you to keep your criminals to yourself,’ said a light, clear voice that nevertheless managed to sound hard as iron. Oín’s head whipped round and he saw that, for the second time in as many days, they were surrounded.
Elves, a whole patrol of them, all armed and all pointing their weapons directly at the dwarves. The one who had spoken was blond, though most of the others had hair the colour of deep mahogany, and he held his bow like an extension of himself. It was pointed at Bofur, who was still in the lead, and his hands didn’t waver for a second.
Bofur groaned, looking straight at Thorin and ignoring the arrow less than ten feet from his face.
‘I’m sorry, I didn’t even feel them coming…’
‘I should think not,’ one of the other elves said. ‘Dwarves are as sensitive as the stone they were made from. You must consider yourselves lucky if you manage to avoid the trees more times than you walk into them.’
Bofur glowered at the elf but, seeing a quick sign from Thorin, said nothing.
‘You are trespassing,’ the blond elf – stern and imperious – informed them. ‘These are elven lands. You will come with us and explain yourselves to our King. Tie them up,’ he ordered his companions. The dwarves bristled, but did not resist as the elves moved to search and bind them. They were entirely outnumbered and they knew it.
Of course, that level of compliance only lasted until the elves went for Oín’s brother. Of course. All guts and no brain, or so Óin tended to tell people.
‘Oh, and you’re going to carry the lad, I presume,’ Glóin snapped, stepping towards the elf who had tried to move Dwalin away from the litter and gesturing to Fíli, who had gone utterly silent by virtue of biting his lip so hard it bled. Ignoring the elves for a moment, Óin crossed to him and pulled said lip from between his teeth.
‘No use causing any more pain than you have to,’ he told Fíli very quietly.
‘I won’t be weak in front of them,’ Fíli replied in Khuzdul, doing his best to sound defiant despite the weakness in his voice. ‘I won’t.’
‘Enough,’ the leader of the elves cracked out. ‘Move away from him. Lay the litter down. Now,’ he added, when the dwarves hesitated. Reluctantly, Dori, Dwalin, Bombur and Thorin followed his orders, eyes on the weapons around them, but when they placed Fíli on the floor it must have jolted his wound. He keened loudly and Thorin moved to stroke his forehead, murmuring apologies in their own language.
The elven leader moved forward, bow suddenly gone from his hands and sword appearing just as swiftly. Thorin felt him coming, looked up and growled, baring his teeth in a snarl.
‘You will not hurt him,’ he ordered, with the weight of decades of command behind him. ‘He is hurt badly enough as it is.’
‘Then perhaps he ought not have been where he did not have permission to be,’ the elf responded cuttingly, but he signalled to four of his fellows and they approached. ‘Carry him carefully,’ he commanded, examining Fíli closely. ‘He’s no threat as he is. The spiders have had him.’
Óin, because he was watching them all carefully, saw one of the new litter-bearers flinch at the words. His heart sank even further. The elves knew what this was.
There really was no hope.
Whether the regret which briefly crossed the elven leader’s face was comfort in the face of this fact, or simply a further dose of salt in the wound, Óin couldn’t decide.
***
With the elves leading them onwards, they moved swiftly away from the Mountains and further into the forest. Bofur heard the elves mutter that the Company should not have been able to travel so far into their realm without using the Road, and felt a certain satisfaction at that.
Only a stone-blind elf could so easily underestimate dwarven senses.
Arseholes.
Unfortunately, the satisfaction was nowhere near strong enough to dull the fluttering panic as they were led away from their one point of reference in this place. Even if they were able to escape, how long would it take Bofur to get them back where they needed to be?
He wasn’t thinking about whether they would be a full Company in such a future. There was naught to be gained by dwelling.
Nor by daydreaming. They were outnumbered, Bofur had known that even as he was staring down an elven archer, and now they had been stripped of both weapons and supplies. Escaping into the forest with nothing but the clothes on their backs would be pointless. If they truly wanted to die, King Thranduil would no doubt oblige them.
Bofur might not be a dwarf of Erebor, but he knew the stories. Thror had loathed the elves, and the feeling had been more than mutual.
Though Bofur had reason to believe that not all Mirkwood elves felt the same about all dwarves. He’d held a quick conversation in Iglishmek with Bifur the first morning after they’d been captured, when the elves were getting them all lined up. One of the elves was treating Fíli’s wound with… something. Something for the pain, Bifur thought, because Fíli was easier afterwards.
The blond elf, the one who seemed to be in charge, must have known but he said nothing either to encourage or forbid it.
Bofur had tried to get the message to Thorin, thinking it might help at least a little, but their King was kept at the head of the line and Bofur couldn’t catch his attention. Instead, Thorin’s anger simmered along, obvious in the ramrod straightness of his spine and the tension in his shoulders. Bofur had seen it before, most memorably on the morning Thorin had stood before him while Bofur explained they would never be able to mine the central tunnels again.
Bofur had never feared his King – Thorin had been nothing but good to him, despite their occasional disagreements – but in that moment he had come close.
Just hold it together, Thorin, he begged in his mind. Hold it together until we find a way to escape.
There must be a way.
There must.
***
Arriving at Thranduil’s Halls, most of the Company were taken straight to the dungeons. Most, but not all.
At some point during the journey, Prince Legolas had finally recognised Thorin. Thorin had known him early on, not by sight but because one of his party had called him by name. They had never formally met, but Thorin had been a Prince in Erebor and had been taught the lineages of the neighbouring kingdoms as a matter of course.
Prince Legolas had not had the advantage of hearing Thorin’s name, because he refused to allow the Company to speak to one another, but he had the virtue of an elven memory and the same training Thorin had been given. He’d worked it out in the end.
Thus, rather than being relegated to the cells with the rest of the Company, Thorin was instead dragged to an audience with King Thranduil of Mirkwood.
Not immediately, of course. Apparently it was vitally important that the Prince speak with Thranduil first, leaving the King of Ered Luin standing in an ante-chamber like a petitioner who must wait until the more important personages had been seen to before being granted a turn.
Thorin felt the rage that had hounded him since he realised that Fíli was hurt, the rage he had tried to expel by slaying spiders as violently as possible, bubbling up again. He began to pace, squeezing his hands into fists as he often did when he was fuming over something. He was King in his own right, yet he had been taken prisoner without hesitation and for no reason. He did not have time for petty elven games. He didn’t have time for their arrogance and insistence on doing everything their own way.
When Thorin was finally led before Thranduil, he had built himself into such a fury that he barely resisted the urge to spit in Thranduil’s face. Or at least on the floor, as his face was sadly out of reach.
‘Thorin, son of Thráin,’ the Elven King stated calmly, icy and collected on his throne. ‘Why have you been found trespassing in my realm?’
‘Your son happened to be in the right place at the right time,’ Thorin snapped. His patience was all but non-existent at this point. Even in the ante-room, as he had tried to focus on other things, more than half of his mind had been down in the cells with Fíli, hearing his nephew whimper with pain as the poison burned through his veins. Now it was even worse.
At first, the fact that the poison was slow-working had given Thorin hope. He had thought Fíli was fighting it off, holding his own against the death the spider had tried to inflict upon him.
Then he had realised that the spiders were simply vicious enough that they wanted their prey to suffer. The poison was slow-acting, eating away at Fíli a little more each day, leaving him in agony.
It was agony for Thorin as well, though he could not let it show before his nephews. Poor Kíli did not have the experience to hide his emotions. His distress was palpable even as he pretended to be fine for Fíli’s sake.
Thorin was their Uncle and King, he had to set a good example.
He was drawn back to the present when Thranduil barked out an order in his own language and everyone, including his son, left the room abruptly. The door closed behind Prince Legolas with a snap.
Thranduil rose from his throne slowly, the movement graceful despite the coldness of his expression, which made him look brittle and sharp. He took the steps down equally slowly, then stopped without approaching Thorin.
‘Why are you here, Thorin Oakenshield?’ he asked. Strange, Thorin thought, that the news of his battle-name had travelled even here. Somehow he had not expected the elf to know it.
‘I am travelling, Thranduil,’ he returned, glaring up at the elf with disdain, hands clenched at his side. ‘People do. The better question is why your elves have begun arresting travellers.’
‘You have not come into this forest without purpose,’ Thranduil insisted. ‘Few travel through my realm except my own people.’
‘Well that is hardly surprising,’ Thorin said caustically, remembering his thoughts from earlier in their travels. Perhaps it was time someone gave this elf a few truths, knocked some of that conceited composure out of him. ‘I do not know what you think kingship entails, Thranduil, but I was taught we had a duty of stewardship to our realm. Your forest is a haven of evil, surely you’ve noticed! The trees fall to sickness, the water is undrinkable, you have a truly impressive collection of Ungoliant’s spawn breeding… what have you been doing? Have you done nothing to stop this decline?’
If it was possible, Thranduil’s face grew even icier. He took several steps forward, hand rising, and for one moment Thorin was certain he was about to be struck. He raised his head to meet the blow – what could one scrawny elf do to a dwarf, after all? – but Thranduil stopped abruptly. He stared unblinkingly at Thorin for a long moment, then a disturbing, nasty smile spread across his face.
‘I have not been attracting a dragon to my kingdom with my greed and then whining to other realms when I lose it forever,’ he commented, sneering. ‘That is what I have not been doing.’ He paused, allowing Thorin to fully absorb the insult, then spoke again. ‘Will you tell me why you have come?’ he enunciated clearly.
‘It is no business of yours,’ Thorin informed him, feeling utter satisfaction in being able to deny Thranduil as he had once denied the dwarves when they came for help. Especially after that last slight. ‘I do not answer to you, King of Mirkwood.’
‘Of course not,’ Thranduil replied, the cruel smirk fading only a little. ‘No matter, you will have plenty of time to change your mind. I am told my dungeons are relatively comfortable, though I cannot say I have ever tested the accommodation.’
The Elven King returned to his throne, seating himself with apparent unconcern and reaching for a staff which sat beside it. He rapped it sharply on the floor twice, and the doors opened.
‘Take King Thorin to the rest of his party,’ Thranduil commanded Prince Legolas. Thorin wondered if it was normal in Mirkwood for the heir to the throne to act as a common guard. Perhaps the younger elf was bored.
‘The young dwarf…’ Prince Legolas began to question. Thranduil waved a hand like a knife and Legolas trailed off.
‘King Thorin tells me his business is none of ours,’ the King told Legolas firmly, ‘and I have no desire to waste resources on an ailing dwarf. Take him away.’
The Prince hesitated only a moment, then drew Thorin out of the room. They followed the stone corridors down to the cells in silence.
It was beginning to dawn on Thorin that his temper, which Dís had always sworn was his greatest fault, even before his pride, had just led him terribly astray.
***
When they reached the dungeons, Legolas led Thorin not to one of the unoccupied cells but to that which housed Fíli. The elf still did not look at him, his face was almost impassive, but his mouth twisted as he locked them in.
As he walked away, Thorin looked desperately around, trying to locate the rest of the Company. Kíli and Bilbo were across from him, imprisoned together, and Balin was a little further up. They were the only ones Thorin could see.
‘The rest?’ he called to Balin.
‘All here,’ Balin replied. ‘What did he say?’
‘Nothing of use,’ Thorin hedged, not wanting to tell Balin he had insulted their host so thoroughly. Not in front of Kíli, whose brother lay dying before his eyes. Rather than say any more, Thorin turned and sat, checking Fíli’s forehead. At first he had been deathly cold, now he burned and shivered with fever.
Thorin gathered Fíli up off the ground and laid his head in Thorin’s lap. Stroking Fíli’s hair back from his forehead, he murmured softly.
‘How are you, sweet lad?’
‘Cold,’ Fíli whispered, though he felt like a furnace to Thorin. ‘Not so bad.’
‘Fíli, don’t lie to me,’ Thorin requested. When Fíli forced his eyes open and looked up, Thorin made sure to hide all of the worry and guilt and show only the steadiness he had tried to offer the boys all their lives. ‘It is not your job to protect me.’
Of course it was not. It was Thorin’s job to protect Fíli, and what a truly wonderful job he had done of that so far today! Or a few days ago, when Fíli had been fighting alone because Thorin had not stayed close enough to him.
‘Pain’s getting worse,’ Fíli admitted, the walls he had built as an adult crumbling and the child showing through. ‘The elves were treating it but that’s fading now. Feels like the thing’s still biting at me. Was just the shoulder at first, but now it feels like I’m being eaten alive. I’m scared, Uncle.’
‘I know,’ Thorin replied, feeling sick with shame and grief. Fíli had always been his shadow, a little more serious than his brother, aware of the responsibilities that would fall to him on Thorin’s death and feeling an obligation to begin shouldering those burdens as soon as he was able.
Always so ready to help.
Why could Thorin not have helped him today? Why had he not even tried to hold his tongue?
‘I will be here,’ he promised Fíli quietly, knowing it was all he could give now. ‘I will be with you.’
‘Alright,’ Fíli murmured, eyelids already falling shut again as he tried to fight the growing pain. One hand came up to grip at Thorin’s coat, as if to make sure he stayed right where he was.
‘Try to sleep,’ Thorin whispered, and Fíli hummed a response.
Thorin looked up, across the landing, and saw Kíli pressed up against the door of his cell, staring desperately at his brother.
There were tears rolling down his face.
***
Things worsened.
Fíli’s muscles began to cramp unexpectedly, his body going into spasm and lifting off the floor with the violence of the cramps. It seemed to wake him any time he actually managed to sleep, and that wasn’t often. He told Thorin he had a terrible headache, that his vision swam, that he felt constantly sick. He could keep no food down, though he was still taking water.
After that first night, the elves appeared with a small pot of salve every time they brought food, and Thorin applied it every time. It helped a little; Fíli was more likely to sleep after it was placed on the wound. The effects didn’t last, however, and as the days passed they weakened.
The elves were also kind enough – or perhaps just fastidious enough – to bring a larger bowl for Fíli to throw up in. Mostly it was bile now, he had nothing left in his stomach, and the waves of nausea that wracked him were painful to watch.
Thorin soothed, and wiped him clean, and sang old lullabies he had not used in years, but he could not help.
He had tried to request another audience with King Thranduil and the elf had denied him. Thranduil had years, after all. There was no urgency on his part.
Kíli, of course, became increasingly frantic. At first he pretended calm so that Fíli would not worry, but as Fíli began to lapse into unconsciousness at intervals, he took to pounding on the bars, shouting pleas and invective by turns. A few days into their confinement Prince Legolas appeared, and Kíli nearly broke something trying to get out of his cell, even as Bilbo desperately tried to calm him.
‘Why won’t you help him?’ Kíli cried, looking at Legolas with utter disbelief. ‘Elves are supposed to be good, aren’t they? How can you let him suffer like this?’
‘He was beyond the usual methods of healing before we ever reached these Halls,’ Legolas told Kíli, and now his mask fractured and his voice was endlessly sad. ‘Their poison is virulent, it must be treated quickly or else by one with great power.’ He turned away from Kíli and looked to Thorin. ‘Such power comes with age,’ he explained sombrely.
And Thorin understood.
Legolas had known what would be required before they left the forest. He had brought Thorin to his father immediately upon their arrival, had met with him privately to pave the way, and had sent Thorin in expecting him to plead Fíli’s case; but Thorin had thrown his chance away. Thranduil had been their hope, and Thorin had been too blinded by rage to see it.
He closed his eyes, and when he opened them Legolas was still there, looking at Fíli with an expression that was almost lost.
‘There is no hope?’ Thorin asked him.
‘No,’ Legolas replied. ‘None. I have asked the healers. Were it one of our own we would have…’
Would have treated it more quickly. Would have appealed to their King for his aid.
Thorin gazed down at his sister-son, who had been the apple of his eye all his short life, and felt himself begin to weep. Not loudly, but like Kíli, silent tears of despair.
He would have given his life for these boys willingly. Without a moment’s hesitation.
That was no good to Fíli now.
Looking up again, Thorin met Kíli’s eyes and knew his dark-haired lad had heard their exchange. They stared silently for a long breath, then Kíli nodded. They both knew what Thorin had to do.
The one thing he had never dreamed of. The exact opposite of every parental instinct he had.
He met Prince Legolas’ gaze.
‘Bring me a dagger?’ he requested, voice catching on the words. ‘Please.’
******
