Chapter Text
Legolas froze.
For a long moment he simply stood there as he tried to decide if King Thorin truly meant what Legolas thought he meant.
The sounds of grief from both before and behind him proved that he did.
Valar, how had it come to this?
Legolas was aware that the Woodland Realm was no Rivendell or Lothlórien. His kingdom did not provide a haven of peace and tranquillity. Theirs had been a hard life in recent years, the safe areas of their forest shrinking bit by bit as evil spread towards them. Latterly, his father had more often chosen to retreat rather than lose any more of their people, but they were not unfamiliar with the losses that came with battle and strife.
It was just that those losses did not normally come upon them like this.
He was acquainted with the idea of mercy killings after a battle for those who would not recover. Better for the end to be quick rather than let soldiers suffer further.
And he had just told the dwarven King that there was no hope his nephew would recover.
But still…
Still.
Not like this.
He could not bear for this to be how things ended.
‘No,’ he heard himself tell Thorin Oakenshield, though he had not consciously made the decision to speak. ‘No, I will not.’
Then he turned on his heel and hastily ascended the stairs once more.
***
That was it then, Thorin thought to himself.
The elf was a coward, and Fíli would continue to be tortured by this poison until he died. Perhaps the Prince of the Woodland Realm did not have the stomach for blood. Or perhaps an armed dwarf struck fear deep in his heart, even when that dwarf was locked in a cell Mahal-knew-how-many feet underground and had not the slightest hope of escape.
When all he wanted was to end his kin’s suffering.
Did they truly think he would stage some sort of escape attempt now? When Fíli was dying in agony here and all the rest of his Company were still locked in their separate cells?
Apparently the elves gave him far more credit for ingenuity than he actually deserved.
He heard the bitterness in his own thoughts but could do nothing to change it. He had, for some ridiculous reason, thought better of Prince Legolas. The young elf had seemed less unfeeling than his father, a better sort of person. A little more like Lord Elrond, perhaps, with some compassion for those outside of his own race.
The Prince had sent that salve, after all. At least Thorin had assumed it was him. He did not think the guards would have been brave enough to do it without their Prince’s support. That had suggested a level of empathy, or so Thorin had thought.
Apparently not.
‘Uncle?’ Kíli whispered across the hallway. Even locked in his thoughts, Thorin heard the plea in his nephew’s voice and it brought him back.
‘I’m here,’ he replied, making sure to catch Kíli’s eyes again.
‘What will we do?’ Kíli asked. He glanced down at Fíli and then away again, as if he could not bear to look. Probably he could not. Increasingly, when sleeping, Fíli’s face was a cruel facsimile of the death to come. Thorin looked down himself and flinched.
Fíli was so still now. So pale.
What would they do?
What could he do, if the elf would not help him?
‘Thorin,’ another voice called, and Thorin looked over to see Bilbo standing at the front of their cell. The entry was narrow, so Bilbo had moved in front of Kíli and all Thorin could glimpse of his nephew was his eyes.
Bilbo’s face was filled with compassion, and a grief that matched Thorin’s own, though it could not equal it.
Bilbo cared for the boys too. Despite a troubled start, he and Fíli had taken to each other almost as well as Bilbo and Kíli.
This loss would leave holes in so many lives.
‘There will be something,’ Bilbo reassured him. ‘We will find a way.’
It should have sounded like meaningless reassurance, yet there was something about Bilbo’s face that made Thorin think there was more to it than that. He waited for Bilbo to say something else, but nothing came for several seconds. He thought briefly that Bilbo seemed conflicted, as if he could not decide what to do, but in an instant the look was gone.
When Bilbo spoke again, it was only to repeat himself.
‘We will find a way.’
***
Can you do it? Bilbo asked himself, leaning against the bars of the cell and staring across at the hopeless scene before him. Can you kill that boy?
It would not be like that, he knew logically. For a start, Thorin would take responsibility for Fíli’s death, would deal the wound himself when the time came. He had already made that clear. It would not be by Bilbo’s hand, and it would not be Bilbo’s decision.
But it would not now happen unless Bilbo told Thorin what he knew.
For while Thorin had been in the audience with the Elven King, Bilbo had been here. Trying to comfort Kíli.
Watching.
He had watched the elves lay Fíli out in the cell, as gentle as they could be in the circumstances. He had watched them search Fíli’s body – search Fíli, he was not dead yet – and seize his weapons.
Had watched them miss a small dagger that Bilbo knew Fíli kept tucked into a hidden pocket inside his coat. Fíli had amused him one afternoon by disarming bit by bit and showing Bilbo just how many weapons he had managed to secret about his person. It had been a true lesson in dwarven ingenuity. And dwarven tailoring. Bilbo knew that one blade was still where it was always kept. The elves had not found it and had not known to take it away.
Kíli had not noticed. He had been too distraught, and had had to turn away from the scene so that the elves would not see his tears. Bilbo was sure none of them had thought less of Kíli for his distress, but Kíli had a young one’s pride in these things.
Bilbo could understand that. Though he was no longer young, he also had that same pride.
Either way, that now meant that the decision to mention the dagger, or not, was Bilbo’s alone.
Or was it?
Thorin and Kíli were Fíli’s nearest kin, and they had made a decision in that moment when Prince Legolas confirmed that Fíli would surely die. What right had Bilbo to assume he knew better?
Besides, it was not as if Thorin would take such a step without even consulting Fíli first. The poor boy was failing fast but he was only asleep, not unconscious. Thorin would ask him what he wished them to do when he woke.
If he had the power to act upon the answer. If Thorin did not have the means to give Fíli mercy, he would not dream of asking Fíli the question.
Did Bilbo speak, or stay silent?
He just didn’t know what to do.
Damn it all, no one should have to make such a decision! Bilbo pounded his fist on the wall in frustration, turning his back to be sure Kíli did not see him do so. This was madness. Cruel, vicious, soul-destroying madness.
Movement in the other cell caught Bilbo’s attention, and he turned back to see Thorin adjusting his position carefully as Fíli began to wake. The younger dwarf gasped as his retching began again, and Thorin reached swiftly for the basin he kept close at hand. By the time Fíli finished heaving into the bowl, tears running down his face both as a natural reaction to his body’s spasms and from the pain, Bilbo had made his decision.
Fíli ought to at least have the choice.
He opened his mouth to get Thorin’s attention, but at the same instant he heard a cell door open and close above, and the sound of steps on the stairs. It would be the elves bringing their midday meal.
Bilbo could not risk them finding out about the dagger and removing it.
For now, the chance to speak was lost.
***
‘Father, I must speak with you,’ Legolas informed Thranduil, slipping into the chamber where the King dealt with day-to-day business just as Thranduil’s Steward exited by another door. Thranduil looked up sharply, for Legolas’ intrusion on his day was extremely unusual.
In fact, Legolas’ continued presence in their Halls was extremely unusual. With the growing danger outside, he was gone for weeks at a time more often than not, trying to patrol the limits of their kingdom and contain the worst of the damage.
He could not remember the last time he had spoken to his father.
He spoke to his King fairly regularly, to make official reports and receive his orders, but very rarely to his father.
‘Do we have another incursion?’ Thranduil asked, with only the slightest hint of worry. ‘If so, you know that you are permitted to deal with them as you see fit. If it is outside the boundaries we have drawn then you know what my answer will be for that also.’
‘It is not about a threat to the kingdom,’ Legolas replied. ‘Not as such.’
His father’s face clouded with confusion.
‘Then to what do I owe the honour of your visit?’ he asked, and Legolas could hear the wariness in his tone.
When had it become so strange for them to speak to one another? Legolas was certain that, in another family, a father would not be surprised to speak to his child for something less than an emergency.
He did not imagine that Thorin Oakenshield was startled if one of his nephews came to speak to him.
Or perhaps he was, and what Legolas had seen and heard over the last few days was an exception. A reaction to the stress they were under.
How could you ever know what was normal in someone else’s family?
‘It is about the young Prince,’ Legolas began, and immediately Thranduil’s face went blank, even as his voice grew bleak.
‘I have said all I am willing to say on the matter,’ he declared with great finality. ‘Legolas, the boy is simply dying, as mortals do. The experience comes to them all in their time. I fail to see why you are attaching such importance to the event.’
Legolas sucked in a breath, though he thought he had been quiet enough that Father would not hear him. He knew that Thranduil had become colder as the years passed, but this? To attach so little importance to another’s life? To their suffering?
Had they truly fallen so far as this?
He paused, searching for the words that would convince Thranduil that it would not benefit the kingdom to allow a dwarven Prince to die just to punish the boy’s uncle for an insult. Searching for an argument that his father would, in his anger, be willing to accept.
What came out instead was, ‘If it were me, if I were dying like that, would you even care, Father? After all, this sort of death comes to elves as well. The spiders do not discriminate as we do!’
‘Legolas…’ was Thranduil’s toneless response. His mouth tightened as he said it, and the corners became pinched with displeasure. It was clearly a warning.
Legolas ignored it. He had started now, had broached the subject as he had never intended to. Had already damned himself, if Father chose to take exception to his feelings on the subject.
He might as well continue.
‘I have been to the cells. For three days, I have listened and I have looked,’ he continued obstinately, allowing all the passion he felt on this subject into his voice. ‘He sits there, the Dwarf King, holding his nephew as if he can keep him through sheer force of will. He sings to him. He reassures him. He sleeps rarely and briefly. He hardly eats. He devotes all his time and attention to the boy. And now, with no other way out, he asks to be allowed to give him mercy. He wants me to bring him a dagger, Father. So that he might protect Prince Fíli from pain if not from death. If it were me, would you even be there?’
‘Legolas!’
And this time Legolas did stop. Not because there was a warning, but because his father sounded truly… distraught.
‘Nothing means more than you,’ Father said after a moment, though it seemed to pain him to say it. The words were taut, harsh, as if strained by the effort it had taken to force them out. Father’s face remained almost blank, but the slight lines of tension had moved from around his mouth to his eyes. ‘Of course I would be there.’
‘Then help him!’ Legolas begged. He did not think he had ever begged before, but Thorin Oakenshield was not the only one who had barely slept in the last few days. He could not forget what was happening in those cells. The boy, Fíli, was dying so slowly. Just listening to him was agony. ‘Not for them, but for me. If you would want someone to help me, then help them.’
Father remained motionless for several seconds, utterly still in the way that Legolas had never seen anyone else manage.
Then, suddenly, he was in motion like a whirlwind.
Legolas flew after him as Thranduil strode through the corridors of the palace with his long silver robe flaring out behind him. The elves they came across plastered themselves to the walls in an effort to clear the way, certain that disaster must threaten to have their King in such a hurry. Legolas might have smiled had things been different. He was sure the Halls would be in uproar within half an hour as the rumours began to fly.
In the corner of his heart which had for so long felt unloved and somewhat unwanted, hurt by his father’s seeming disinterest in Legolas outside of his position as heir, a little healing took place.
His father was hurrying like this for Legolas.
He hoped.
He certainly wasn’t doing so for Thorin Oakenshield.
Thranduil reached the stairs to the dungeons, Legolas only a step behind, and stopped. Legolas could not understand why and worried that Father had changed his mind, or perhaps that Legolas had misunderstood his intentions, until he gestured for Legolas to lead the way.
Of course, Legolas realised, Father would not know which cell he needed. Legolas moved past him to take the lead, caught the eye of one of the guards who had just finished serving the prisoners’ meal and gave a quick signal of his own.
The elf’s reluctance to approach reminded Legolas just how daunting most of Thranduil’s people found their King. He felt his expression harden as the elf failed to obey his summons, and the guard took the last few steps in a hurry. Legolas wasn’t sure if he was pleased or saddened that he was apparently just as daunting.
‘The key to the lowest cell,’ Legolas ordered, and the guard quickly removed it from the ring and handed it over. Legolas nodded a dismissal, and the guard withdrew with unseemly haste.
Perhaps it was a good thing they did not often have prisoners, Legolas mused. The calibre, or at least the courage, of their guards did not appear to be high.
Legolas began their descent once again and he saw the dwarves come to their feet as he and Father passed, hands reaching for weapons they no longer had, as if somehow they could protect their Prince even from within their cells.
As if they would protect him against something, even if there was no protection against the poison in his blood.
Clearly the dwarves recognised Thranduil’s crown, if not his person, and were drawing dire conclusions. Legolas could not entirely blame them. They had had no reason to think well of the Woodland Realm, or its King.
Not until now.
Legolas slowed his descent as they reached the final few cells, and it took no introductions for Thranduil to know they had reached the end of their journey.
Prince Fíli was awake and moaning softly with pain. The smell from their cell made it clear that he had not long finished emptying his stomach, and his face was deathly pale and clammy with sweat.
Father paused, so briefly the dwarves in view likely never noticed, then held out his hand for the cell key. When Legolas handed it over, he opened the door behind which King Thorin and his nephew lay and swept through.
King Thorin immediately rose to his knees, arching over Prince Fíli’s whimpering form and murmuring apologies to the boy as he keened in agony.
‘I am sorry. Hush, Fíli, I am sorry. It is alright now.’
‘Let him go,’ Father commanded. King Thorin sneered.
‘If he is to be killed then it will not be by you, Thranduil of the Woodland Realm,’ he spat out.
‘Let. Him. Go,’ Father ordered, biting out the words. He took a long breath and Legolas sensed he was on the verge of walking out again and letting the poison take its course. Heart pounding, afraid that he had already used his greatest weapon and it would not prove keen enough, Legolas stepped up to his father’s side, just close enough to appear in the corner of Father’s vision.
Father’s head moved almost imperceptibly, then he exhaled and looked King Thorin directly in the eye.
‘I cannot heal him if you do not let him go,’ he told the dwarven King fiercely. Thorin stared, silent, disbelieving. The quiet dragged on.
‘I could leave,’ Father suggested, pleasant as he always sounded when his temper was trembling on a knife’s edge.
‘NO!’ Legolas heard the younger Prince shout from the opposite cell. It was enough to throw King Thorin out of his trance. He loosened his hold on Prince Fíli, easing him towards Father. Legolas watched as his father reached out, taking the boy more carefully than Legolas had thought possible after so many years of watching the ice creep over his heart.
There was utter silence as Thranduil gazed down at the young dwarf he now held, and Prince Fíli stared back hazily. The lad’s hand reached up, as if he was about to touch something, then the haze cleared a little and it dropped again. Thranduil rested a hand, just for a second, on the Prince’s forehead, as a parent might when checking for a fever.
Then the King of the Woodland Realm set to work.
******
