Chapter Text
When Thorin woke the next morning, it was to the sound of joyful whispering nearby.
Whispering in voices he knew well.
‘I didn’t dream it?’ Fíli was asking quietly. Though the question was not in itself funny, laughter bubbled in his voice as if his happiness at being healed had to find an outlet somewhere. ‘It really was him?’
‘Yes,’ Kíli said. ‘The Prince, Legolas, went flying off and half an hour later he was back with the King and then the King healed you. It took a long time and he looked awful when he was finished, but he said it will be fine now. You’ll live to be just as stupid as you were before.’
‘Say that again when I can lift my arms and I’ll give you the thrashing you deserve,’ Fíli muttered in response, this time chuckling for real despite his attempt to sound threatening.
‘The only one in this family distributing well-deserved thrashings will be me,’ Thorin took the opportunity to interject. ‘Can I surmise from the threats that you are feeling better, Fíli?’
He sat up and looked sternly down at his two nephews, both of whom looked suitably chastised at being caught needling each other.
‘Yes, Uncle,’ Fíli responded. ‘I’m still so tired I could sleep for a year, but nothing hurts and I don’t want to throw up anymore. I’m actually quite hungry. I don’t suppose we can expect breakfast any time soon?’
Thorin reached inside his coat and pulled out a hunk of bread that had been delivered the day before. He’d tucked it away when it arrived, intending to eat it later, but then Thranduil had arrived and he’d become rather distracted.
Fíli fell upon it like he hadn’t eaten in a week, which wasn’t far shy of the truth. It didn’t really count as eating if you couldn’t keep down anything that you ate. Not in Thorin’s book, anyway.
Once Fíli had finished devouring the bread, he settled so that his back was resting against Kíli’s chest (probably the only admission Kíli would ever get that he was the taller of the two) and looked solemnly at Thorin.
‘How are the others?’ he asked worriedly. ‘Is everyone else alright?’
‘The rest of the Company is fine,’ Thorin confirmed. ‘Balin has been keeping in contact with Bifur, who’s been watching over the others. They’re all much better now that we know you’re going to live, of course, but there were no injuries other than your own.’
‘Good,’ Fíli said firmly, then found himself interrupted by a yawn. ‘Oh, that’s ridiculous,’ another yawn. ‘I haven’t even been awake for half an hour.’
‘Your body knows what’s good for you,’ Thorin reminded him, reaching out to touch Fíli’s forehead, just to be sure the fever hadn’t returned. Thranduil had said it was a possibility, after all. Everything seemed fine, however, and Fíli was no warmer than Thorin would expect when he was leaning against a living furnace.
‘The Elven King did that too,’ Fíli murmured vaguely, eyelids already starting to slide shut. Kíli wiggled out from behind him slowly, lowering his brother to lie back against the cloaks laid out on the floor. Once he was lying down, Kíli tugged a blanket up over him. By now, Fíli’s eyes were firmly closed. ‘I don’t think he’s as bad,’ another yawn, ‘as we thought he was, Uncle.’
‘No,’ Thorin conceded. ‘Perhaps not.’
He had no idea if Fíli heard him or not. If his nephew was not already asleep, he headed that way shortly afterwards.
***
‘What does Balin say? Is Fíli getting better…? Bifur?’
‘Give me a chance. We’re still talking.’
‘Talk faster. You’ve been at it an age.’
‘Five minutes.’
‘Exactly. An age! I’m dying of boredom over here. Oomph.’
‘If you hadn’t been trying to climb over me, Bofur, that wouldn’t have happened!’
‘Well, if you hadn’t been taking up two thirds of the cell, brother dear, I wouldn’t have had to climb over you.’
‘Enough! Next time we get locked in a bloody dungeon, I want smaller and quieter cellmates!’
‘Now, don’t be like that, Bifur. Think how boring these days would have been without us.’
‘That’s what I am thinking of.’
‘I’m sorry, Bifur. I don’t know why they put us all in together. Anybody could have seen we wouldn’t fit easily. They should have given me a cell of my own.’
‘Because they’ve got a nasty sense of humour, that’s why. Bloody elves. Never mind, here…’
‘OI! Mind me hat!’
‘That’s better. More room now.’
***
‘We will have the truth from him this time, I hope,’ Father told Legolas, in a tone suggesting a level of certainty Legolas found quite surprising. Then again, Father had just saved the life of King Thorin’s kinsman. Perhaps expecting honesty in return was not too much of a stretch after that. ‘Go, bring him up.’
Legolas nodded, and set to his task.
His conversation with Father had been short and fairly simple this morning. Thranduil would see King Thorin now, having finished his morning audiences, and would put several questions to him regarding his purpose in coming to the Woodland Realm and where he intended to go from here. If Father was convinced that he was receiving an honest answer, and that there would be no harm to the Woodland Realm, then the dwarves would be allowed to leave.
Legolas wondered if the dwarves realised how lucky they had truly been.
They had come so very close to living out what was left of their lives in those dungeons.
Legolas himself had to admit curiosity about their Halfling companion. With all of the goings on in the last few days, the hobbit’s presence had barely registered before. In earlier years, before the darkness had fallen over their realm, Legolas had travelled to Bree and beyond and had seen some of the small folk there. Yet now Legolas realised that he had never seen one of that kind so far from their homeland.
It was a mystery, and one Legolas hoped to solve before the dwarves disappeared with their smaller companion. He did not imagine he would ever see them again once they left.
As Legolas began to descend past the line of cells that held the dwarves, he was distracted momentarily by a low-voiced, ‘Oi, Prince!’
Legolas would admit that, at first, he stopped mostly because he had never been greeted in such a way in his life.
‘I beg your pardon?’ he asked icily, turning to see one of the dwarves beckoning to him from a landing slightly further down. When the dwarves were captured, Legolas had remarked this one only because he had been carrying twice as much gear as any of the others, and wore one of the most ludicrous hairstyles.
‘C’mere,’ the dwarf ordered impatiently. Legolas was sorely tempted to move on regardless, to teach this dwarf a lesson in manners, but something in the furtive nature of the summons caught his curiosity, so he approached anyway.
The dwarf’s eyes were shifty, even for a dwarf, and he seemed to have developed a nervous twitch which led him to flick his eyes to the right every few seconds. When Legolas glanced casually in that direction, it appeared that the most dangerous-looking of the dwarves – big, bald and tattooed – was the object of all this nervous attention, though he was currently occupied in conversation with his cellmate and oblivious to other goings-on.
The presumptuous dwarf appeared, at first, to have no cellmate, but then Legolas caught sight of a mild-mannered, cardigan-wearing figure sitting in the back corner. Almost as if he was being hidden away. Dwarves were a truly strange people. It was no wonder the elves so often found themselves at odds with them.
‘Yes?’ Legolas demanded, though some instinct led him to keep his voice as low as the dwarf who had accosted him.
‘Here,’ the dwarf offered, sticking his hand through the bars and opening it once Legolas was close. On his palm lay two items; one was entirely familiar to Legolas, the other not at all.
‘What...?’ Legolas began, before changing his mind mid-thought. ‘Where did you get that?’
He snatched up the ring, a token of his mother’s which was usually kept on a chain around his neck, and stared at it suspiciously. Then he turned that suspicious gaze on the dwarf in front of him.
‘You dropped it in the forest, didn’t you?’ the dwarf replied. The performance was convincing, sounded utterly so, and still Legolas did not believe a word of it. He hadn’t dropped that ring once in the few hundred years he’d owned it. How likely was it that the first time had been in sight of this dwarf, who had then picked it up?
Then again, how likely was it that a dwarf had somehow managed to remove the ring from around Legolas’ neck without him noticing?
‘Anyway,’ the dwarf continued, unconcerned by Legolas’ obvious suspicion, ‘if you’d proved to be the arsehole you were looking to be, I’d probably have kept it, but one good turn deserves another.’
‘And if it had been valuable, Dwarf?’ Legolas asked sharply, in the tone that usually sent his soldiers scurrying to obey his commands.
‘Then it would be like Fíli’s life, wouldn’t it?’ the dwarf asked, voice easy and eyes hard. ‘And our freedom.’ He smiled, but the smile was mostly teeth.
Really, Legolas should report something like this to Father. The dwarf might not have admitted the blatant theft – from his captors, no less – of a valuable keepsake, but he had come damned close. Even if Father didn’t choose to hold Thorin Oakenshield responsible for his companion’s actions, he might well choose to punish the thief for his sheer cheek.
The part that made such an action stick in Legolas’ throat was this moment here.
The moment where the thief all-but-admitted his theft, and returned the stolen property.
One thing of value for another.
If Legolas had allowed Prince Fíli to die, could he really have blamed the dwarf for keeping a piece of jewellery as revenge, when he had no idea of its significance? Or even if he did?
Valar, all these moral questions were going to give him a headache.
‘Indeed,’ Legolas said slowly, hoping that was non-committal enough. ‘And the other?’ The second item in the dwarf’s hand was a brooch of some kind. Worked in gold, with a single emerald inlaid, it was not an elven style, and yet was still the sort of thing Legolas could see himself wearing if the occasion was right. It was finer and more delicate than he would expect of dwarven craft, engraved with runes that Legolas did not understand.
‘That’s one of ours,’ the dwarf replied, gesturing between himself and his cell companion. ‘Or was. Like I say, Fíli’s life is valuable, and one good turn deserves another.’ He lowered his tone a little further, and Legolas was very glad of elven hearing.
‘It was our brother guarding Fíli’s back when he was injured,’ the dwarf commented. ‘Now, if he’d died, there might have been some that suggested he ought to have been better protected. As he didn’t, in all likelihood it will never come up again, and Dori won’t need to think on it any more than he already has. That’s worth some thanks, in our minds. Take it or leave it. Up to you.’
Legolas paused a moment longer, looking between the two dwarves before him and trying to measure their sincerity. The younger, silent one met his gaze guilelessly, and Legolas could see that whatever innate dishonesty there was in the elder, it had no foothold there.
He looked down at his hand again, considering, and then mentally shrugged.
Why not? What harm could come from accepting honest thanks, as this appeared to be?
Besides, there were not many firsts left in life when you had lived so long, but he had never yet received a piece of dwarven jewellery gifted to him by a dwarven thief.
It would be a story to tell, one day.
He closed his hand around the two small items of jewellery, tucked them into a pocket in his tunic, and moved on without another word.
Time to do the job he had originally come here for.
***
Thorin’s second audience with the King of the Woodland Realm began a great deal more auspiciously than the first.
For a start, he had not been dragged in with the mud of Mirkwood still ground into his person. The elves were not entirely unpleasant captors. They had provided water for washing.
It was cold water, but any survivor of winter in Ered Luin was well-used to that.
Thorin was also, in contrast to last time, not kept waiting in an ante-room before being shown into Thranduil’s presence. He was taken straight to a small room which appeared to be Thranduil’s study, rather than to the throne room, and Prince Legolas used only a brief knock to announce their presence.
‘Enter,’ Thranduil called, and moments later Thorin stood before the Elven King. There was no throne here. Instead, Thranduil sat with a desk at his back, the chair he was using clearly the desk’s usual partner.
‘King Thorin,’ Thranduil said, with a very slight nod of acknowledgement. He did not ask Thorin to sit, but then Thorin had not expected him to. The dwarves were still prisoners, after all.
He had promised Bilbo good behaviour, Thorin reminded himself, and now would be a good time to begin.
‘Our thanks, once again, for your intervention with my nephew,’ Thorin said plainly, turning to include Prince Legolas in the statement. ‘I am relieved beyond measure to see how much better he is this morning.’
‘We are glad to hear it,’ Thranduil replied magnanimously. Whether this was a royal ‘we’, or if he was speaking on behalf of his son, Thorin was not sure. ‘The spiders are a curse, which is why visitors are now advised to keep solely to the path through the forest. Advice you presumably did not receive.’
‘No,’ Thorin agreed. ‘Gandalf did not mention it, but then we parted on ill terms.’
‘I often find that Gandalf fails to mention all manner of pertinent information, whether one is on ill terms with him or not,’ Thranduil said with great asperity. Out of Thorin’s vision, Prince Legolas gave a startled sounding cough. ‘Still, it is a brave person who quarrels with a wizard.’
‘It is a pity Master Baggins did not join us,’ Thorin found himself saying, completely unplanned. ‘As best I can tell, he has spent nearly thirty years doing nothing but quarrelling with Gandalf, without ever considering the possible consequences. A greater act of bravery I cannot conceive.’
‘I meant to ask about that,’ Prince Legolas said abruptly, then stopped short as he apparently realised that he was inserting himself into his father’s conversation. Thranduil’s brows drew together in a frown, but he waved a hand lazily for Legolas to continue anyway. ‘It just seemed odd, that a hobbit had travelled so far with you. How did that come to be?’
Here, Thorin realised, he had best choose his words a little carefully. He did not have Bilbo’s permission to discuss his life with all and sundry, and Bilbo clearly held his secrets close.
‘Bilbo is a friend of Lord Elrond’s sons,’ Thorin told the Prince. ‘He had assisted us in the Shire when my Company stopped there on our way east, and when we moved on he joined us to visit them and ask for their help. The twins suggested, at that point, that Bilbo might find it interesting to journey further with us. I do not imagine they were expecting our journey to be quite so eventful when they made the suggestion.’
‘With Elladan and Elrohir, anything is possible,’ Legolas commented, eyes glinting with humour. ‘I have not seen them for many years, but I remember how they loved mischief.’
‘Perhaps, but I believe they love Bilbo, too, and I do not imagine that an elven cell is the sort of mischief that they wish on their friends,’ Thorin pointed out. Legolas looked abashed.
‘No, of course not.’
‘To other matters,’ Thranduil interjected, and the subject was finished with. ‘I asked once before why you were travelling through my realm, and you chose not to answer. Now I ask the question again.’
There were moments in life, Thorin decided, which were designed to make you feel rather stupid. For him, this was clearly one of them.
It was hardly a difficult question, after all.
Nor particularly unreasonable.
Nor was his answer drastically confidential.
Yet, out of pique, he had refused to answer and had caused a great deal of fuss over nothing.
Sometimes he really was a monumental fool.
‘We travel east to visit my cousin, Dáin, Lord of the Iron Hills,’ he informed Thranduil calmly. ‘I wish to negotiate a deal between our kingdoms, preferably as soon as possible, and it is far quicker to reach the Iron Hills through Mirkwood than it is to travel around.’
‘That it is,’ Thranduil agreed. ‘Might I enquire about the subject of this negotiation?’
Thorin paused, wondering how much he wished to reveal. He was far more in charity with Thranduil than he had been previously, but this was state business, and sensitive state business at that.
And this, said a voice in Thorin’s head which sounded very much like Balin at his most painfully tolerant, is the elf who has the power to hold you here indefinitely and ensure that business is never completed.
Fair enough, Thorin thought in response. A little truth would not hurt.
Just a little.
‘Our food supplies begin to run lower than I am comfortable with each year,’ Thorin informed Thranduil, ‘and the local Men seem unwilling to help. Bilbo’s people have been accommodating over the winter, but I would rather deal with my own kin in the long-term. Dáin is, by blood, the nearest of those kin.’
Thranduil’s nod of acceptance somehow seemed to acknowledge the vagaries of dealing with Men, and the desirability of dealing with one’s own people instead, all without a word being spoken.
‘One could, perhaps, be forgiven for expecting that your journey, passing as close as it does, might involve a stop at your former kingdom, King Thorin,’ the elf said, after a second’s pause. ‘That is a prospect that would make me rather nervous, given our own proximity to the dragon. If you could put my mind at ease, it would go a long way towards resolving our… misunderstanding.’
What was Thranduil up to? Thorin wondered confusedly. What misunderstanding? Thorin had angered him and that, on top of a long-held grudge, had been sufficient cause for Thranduil to throw them in the dungeons. What was there to misunderstand in that?
And why would he assume Thorin was going to Erebor? Had Gandalf been spreading rumours of some sort that Thorin did not know about?
‘I have no intention of going to Erebor,’ Thorin stated baldly, partly from sheer surprise. ‘I am in a hurry, even more so now than before, and there is nothing near Erebor save ruin and desolation. Not ideal travelling conditions. We will travel directly east and turn north once we are below Dáin’s lands, where the ground is less treacherous and the route better guarded.’
‘Then I see no reason to detain you any longer,’ Thranduil granted easily, though his eyes had weighed Thorin thoroughly before he spoke. ‘Particularly in light of your desire for haste.’ Thorin felt very much as if his head was spinning. Had someone dealt the Elven King a blow to the head the previous night?
Had healing Fíli taken more out of him than they’d realised?
Surely there had to be some reason for such a sudden change of heart.
Even his son seemed surprised, if the short, sharply-contained jerk of movement in the corner of Thorin’s eye was any indication.
‘My people will return your belongings later today, and Legolas will see you to the edge of the forest. You will no doubt be able to find your way from there. I wish you luck on your journey, Thorin Oakenshield. I doubt we will see you when you return this way, all being well. Do try to keep to the path.’
With that, it seemed, his audience with the Elven King was over.
It was quite the strangest audience of Thorin’s life.
And this was from the dwarf whose Grandfather-King had been an acknowledged lunatic!
***
The next morning, just after a breakfast which was of considerably better quality than any they had been served so far, the elves returned their packs to them. Thorin rifled quickly through his own, checking that everything was still there that ought to be. He was surprised to discover that, not only was he still in possession of everything, there were a few additions as well.
‘Your supplies did not survive the week here,’ Prince Legolas told him, as if this should have been obvious. ‘Naturally, we replaced them.’
They had been replaced, it seemed, by an elven waybread. Not a great deal of it, considering how far they had to go, but Thorin was not going to complain. He was still too relieved by Thranduil’s easy decision to let them go.
Prince Legolas led them out of Thranduil’s Halls and into the forest, accompanied by the same patrol of elves who had taken them captive all those days ago. They were a quiet group, often uneasy in each other’s’ company after such a difficult start, but not entirely silent.
Prince Legolas, in particular, seemed continually fascinated with Bilbo’s presence despite Thorin’s explanation. The two chatted in fits and starts as they travelled, even as they both kept a wary eye on their surroundings. Thorin suspected that Legolas’ curiosity had been awakened further when it fully dawned that Bilbo did not just travel with them, he also bore weapons with the surety of a trained warrior. This had led them to a discussion of Elrond’s sons and Bilbo’s training – though Bilbo carefully avoided all mention of the reasons he had chosen to learn sword-craft – which lasted them a good long while.
Thorin had been most worried, before they left, that Fíli would struggle to keep up. His nephew had barely been able to stay awake after his healing, and that was not a state which leant itself to travel. The elves, however, were ahead of him. Before they left, Fíli was given a drink of a cordial that none of the others were offered, and it provided him with a renewed energy that lasted most of the day. By the time he began to flag, they were already considering stopping for the night.
The next morning, Fíli was given another sip of the cordial but, by then, it seemed that the effects of the healing were wearing off. That night he was weary but not debilitatingly so. The following morning, their last in the forest, he did not need the cordial at all.
In the eaves of the forest, they said their goodbyes to the elves with little ceremony. Even from here, Thorin could see the imposing peak of the Lonely Mountain in the distance and its appearance left him uneasy. He was eager to be off, even though the next stage of their journey would only bring them closer to his lost kingdom for a while. In the end, at least, it would lead them away.
‘On we go,’ he told the Company, as the elves melted back into the forest. ‘We’ve a long journey yet.’
‘You’re not kidding there,’ Dwalin grumbled, eyeing the horizon with disfavour. Balin had just opened his mouth, likely to tell Dwalin to stop moaning, when Dwalin’s general frown became a growl they usually only saw in battle.
Even as Thorin swung to look at what Dwalin had seen, he heard two separate voices groan aloud.
‘Oh, not again!’
******
