Chapter Text
Chapter Twenty-Four: Understanding
By the time Thranduil finished his task, he was almost as grey as Fíli had been. In stark contrast, Fíli was noticeably healthier, with colour back in his face and a peaceful expression he had not worn in days.
Thranduil remained kneeling on the floor, breathing harder than Thorin had ever seen in an elf, for several moments. Then he looked up from Fíli’s sleeping form and nodded to Thorin.
‘He will live,’ he said tiredly. ‘He may suffer the occasional fever in the coming months, if I did not burn all of the poison out, but he will live.’
It was a hope that Thorin had given up, even before Legolas had confirmed that Fíli could not survive without assistance he had never dreamed they would get.
Fíli would live.
There was no greater gift he could have been given in Middle Earth at that moment.
‘Thank you,’ he told the Elven King with all the sincerity he could muster.
Thranduil rose to his feet, nodding regally at the same time as he said, somewhat dismissively, ‘Thank my son. It was his doing, though the power may have been mine.’
He glanced away from Thorin, and something across the hallway caught his attention. Thorin looked that way himself and saw Kíli pressed, as it seemed he had been for hours, up against the door of his cell. The look of hope on his face was almost painful, and Thorin immediately called over to him.
‘He is alright, Kíli,’ he promised. ‘It will be well now.’
Kíli made a noise of relief that was almost a whimper and sagged against the bars.
Thorin, who had moved to sit close to Fíli again and had one hand pressed firmly above his blessedly-still-beating heart, could sympathise entirely. He saw Bilbo also deflate at the reprieve and take hold of Kíli’s arm to steady him.
‘Another of the royal line?’ Thranduil asked, and Thorin saw that he was speaking to Legolas and gesturing to Kíli. Though he continued to look rather pale and drained, he was perfectly steady on his feet and showed no other signs of distress. Thorin worried, in a way he would have thought impossible only an hour before, that Thranduil was simply putting on a show for them and that he would suffer for what he had done later.
‘Yes,’ Legolas answered. ‘The younger brother, I think.’
Thranduil nodded, and said nothing for a second or two.
Then, just as he began to walk away, he said, ‘Put them in together. It will do no harm. They are not going anywhere.’
As the Elven King ascended the stairs, the rest of the Company began to shout and call to one another in an attempt to work out what was happening. Thorin heard the noise only vaguely, he was still closely focused on Fíli’s continued breathing, but he clearly heard Thranduil’s announcement as he continued to climb. It was meant to carry.
‘Your Prince will live,’ the elf decreed in his most regal tones, sounding for all the world as if the whole business had not a thing to do with him. ‘You may now cease disturbing my Halls with your abominable racket. Instantly!’
Thorin could have sworn he saw Prince Legolas smile wryly, just before he turned with the keys in his hand and opened the door to Kíli’s cell. Seconds later, Thorin had his younger nephew practically in his lap as they both willed the elder to wake. He clasped Kíli close and sent a prayer to Mahal in gratitude, with a small plea for further deliverance.
It couldn’t hurt to ask.
Thranduil was right, they still weren’t going anywhere, but Thorin found it hard to care too much at that moment.
***
Once he was done with the dwarves, Legolas moved rapidly back up the stairs and along the route Father would have taken to reach his rooms. Legolas was well aware of the effort it must have taken to heal Prince Fíli; he had judged himself incapable of it only an hour or two after he had discovered the dwarves wandering the forest.
His father’s power was truly impressive – he was among the eldest of the Eldar still remaining in Middle Earth – but it was not limitless.
Legolas would never forgive himself if Father had come to harm in an attempt to win back his good opinion.
Thranduil had, in fact, made it all the way to his rooms, but it seemed he had used all his strength to do so. When Legolas entered, unbidden, he found Thranduil slumped in a chair not far from the door, elbow resting on the arm of the chair and his head in his hand.
‘Father?’ he asked, concern mounting, but Thranduil waved him off quickly enough.
‘I will be fine,’ he insisted. ‘It was tiring but not beyond me.’
‘You are sure?’ Legolas queried, too worried to consider that questioning his father’s word might not please him.
‘I am,’ Thranduil confirmed, straightening fully in the chair and signalling for Legolas to take a seat. ‘The display of concern is heart-warming, Legolas, but misplaced. I am in no imminent danger of death. Even so, if you could choose a slightly less dramatic labour the next time you wish me to prove myself, it would be appreciated.’
The latter was acerbic in the extreme, and Legolas flinched at hearing it.
Thranduil sighed.
‘I did not mean that,’ he assured Legolas. ‘As I said, I am tired, if unharmed.’
‘You would not accept the dwarf King’s thanks,’ Legolas stated carefully. ‘Will you accept mine? I would have deeply regretted the boy’s death on my conscience.’
‘It would not have been on your conscience,’ Thranduil said with complete certainty. ‘You had already made your entreaty and, while Oakenshield was far from conciliatory, still I ought not to have ignored the situation. Simple mercy should not require thanks.’
They sat in silence for some minutes, then Thranduil spoke again.
‘It is so easy to forget how young they are; particularly the ill child and his brother, but also the King himself. We live so long, and see so much, but they will never have the years we have. It is easy to become weary with it, to assume that their lives have less value because they are so short. Then you see how desperately they love in those short years, and wonder if they have not the right of it after all, protecting every minute because they will have so few.’
‘He loves his nephews a great deal,’ Legolas commented, because it was the only thing he could think to say. He had never heard Father speak so. When it came to battle, of course, he treated Legolas like an equal - he could not have made Legolas a captain and done any less - but Father did not bare his inner thoughts like this, not to anyone.
‘And now you wonder if my own love for my child pales in comparison,’ Father said, and it was not a question. Legolas flushed, embarrassed to be understood so thoroughly, though he had only himself to blame.
If it were me, would you even be there?
What conclusion had he expected Father to draw from such a question?
‘It does not,’ Father asserted, steady and sure in both speech and manner. ‘You have had cause to doubt it in years gone by. It is likely you will have cause to doubt it in years to come. I am not a demonstrative person, Legolas, and I do not imagine I ever will be now. Yet, I hope you will not allow that doubt to take root again. I would do more than was done today at your bidding. Know that, if nothing else.’
Legolas could not allow that to go unanswered, though he knew not what to say.
Instead, he moved to kneel in front of Father’s chair, took his hand and kissed it, as a loyal subject might when granted an audience. Then, in a move no mere loyal subject would ever be allowed, he rested his cheek against it for a moment afterwards. When he made to move back, Thranduil rested the same hand briefly atop his head and there was the barest stroke over his hair.
‘I hold audience tomorrow morning,’ Thranduil told Legolas when he rose, though there was nothing unusual in that. His father held audiences most mornings, unless he had pressing business elsewhere. ‘Wait upon me afterwards, in my study. I suspect we will have decisions to make.’
A cryptic utterance which might have been designed to send Legolas mad with curiosity, but he knew he’d pressed his luck far enough for one day.
He left the room almost silently, heart easier than it had been in years.
***
He had not lied to his son.
Thranduil rarely lied to anyone. What would be the point? Dishonesty suggested that you wished for something that could not be acquired by other means: an emotion, an outcome, a gift or something which would never be gifted to you. There was little Thranduil wished for which he could not acquire, and he did not trouble himself overly with what remained.
Except peace, of course, for his kingdom and his people, but no amount of lies could bring him that.
Mordor was not overthrown. The forces of darkness lived out their days, as he did, and no doubt they would meet again before the end. When they did, no amount of lying would convince Mordor he was not their enemy, for he could not have told such lies with any hint of conviction.
No, he could not buy peace through dishonesty, nor would if he could.
He owed Sauron and his vassals a number of deaths, and one day the debt would be repaid.
Here and now, as he told Legolas, there were decisions to be made and rather smaller concerns to deal with.
A dwarven King and his thirteen companions, cluttering up his cells and making the place untidy. And noisy.
Perhaps not now, Thranduil admitted, as he paused on one of the walkways above the cells. Now they were mostly silent, save the snoring. It was not pleasant, certainly, but it was quieter than their earlier caterwauling.
Some impulse had driven him here, as the rest of the Halls went to their beds, and he was not quite sure what it was. What did he hope to learn? Did he expect to know more of the dwarves simply by being in their presence?
Then he heard sound – sound that was not snoring – from below.
***
‘They’re sleeping now?’ Bilbo called across quietly. Thorin looked down at Fíli and Kíli, lying just behind where he was leaning against the metal bars, and chuckled slightly.
‘Yes,’ he replied, ‘like a pair of puppies. I would not have thought that position could possibly be comfortable, but they do not seem particularly concerned.’
‘They’re young,’ Bilbo told him wryly. ‘The aches and pains from sleeping in strange arrangements come with age.’
‘And just how many “strange arrangements” have you slept in in your time, Master Baggins?’ Thorin queried with great amusement.
Dwarven eyesight allowed him to see that Bilbo blushed a fairly impressive shade of red, and also stuck his tongue out.
‘I refuse to dignify such an impertinent question with a response,’ Bilbo rebuked. ‘Honestly, dwarves!’
‘You would be lost without us,’ Thorin retorted. ‘Just think of all the tales you would not have to tell your grandchildren if we had not taken you with us. Troll swings; fights with bears; goblin battles and daring acrobatics in the Misty Mountains; plus being chased by orcs and imprisonment in an elven king’s dungeons? We don’t offer this sort of excitement to everyone who travels with us, I hope you realise that.’
‘Do you know,’ Bilbo replied contemplatively, ‘when you arrived on my doorstep with that dreadful scowl, growling at me and stealing my sword…’
‘Disarming you,’ Thorin muttered, feeling that this was an important point. ‘If you want to keep the sword you shouldn’t point it at innocent dwarves.’
‘I would never have believed that you could be so utterly ridiculous,’ Bilbo finished, raising his voice to drown Thorin out. Then he hastily dropped it again to avoid waking their sleeping boys. ‘You are, you know. There’s a sense of humour hiding under all that glowering.’
‘Not much of one, if most of my people are to be believed,’ Thorin assured him. Bilbo snorted, and Thorin smiled across at him. ‘I’m sure it is possible to be dour and angry with the world every moment of the day, Bilbo, but it must make raising children very difficult. Without some sort of sense of humour, trying to drag these two up would have driven me out of my mind. And that was with help from their mother, and from Dwalin and Balin.’
‘They are a little unconventional,’ Bilbo said kindly. ‘I have wondered… what happened to their father? You mention their mother, but never their father.’
‘He died,’ Thorin confirmed, ‘not many years after Kíli was born. A wave of sickness came through Ered Luin, and it took Vili from us. We had been having a hard winter, and he had been eating less to ensure Dís and the boys had enough. We all tried to do so, but somehow we did not notice all the weight Vili had lost until it was too late. He had not the strength to fight the disease and such things always take the weak first.’
Bilbo hissed in sympathy. ‘I am sorry,’ he said, and it was heartfelt, not said by rote.
‘All I can do, all Dís has ever asked me to do, is try to make our people strong enough to endure when illness comes. I would have done it anyway, but it is still a debt I owe her. We must get to the Iron Hills,’ he murmured, and by this time he was talking mostly to himself, reminding himself of the duty he owed his people and that complacency must not be allowed. ‘Every day here is a day longer before Ered Luin has the supplies it needs.’
‘They will be fine over the winter,’ Bilbo hurried to reassure him. ‘My people will make sure of it. I may not always have described them in the best light, but they are far from unfeeling. They will not renege on the deal that was made.’
‘It did not seem to me that you had much time for them,’ Thorin pointed out, as gently as he could. Bilbo shook his head and then rested it back against the bars.
‘I did not,’ he answered, ‘for many years. It is too easy to see the bad in people, Thorin, and miss what is in front of you. I thought them all against me, and yet in a few short weeks several of them proved their friendship. Violet Chubb had always been good to me, but I had allowed myself to forget it. Farmer Maggot thanked me for my help. Rory proved himself more than willing to be a friend if only I would make the attempt. Fortinbras, for all our arguments, was quick enough to help me get that “discount” sorted once I made it clear I meant it.’
‘Ah yes,’ Thorin said, distracted from darker thoughts by deep curiosity. He straightened from his slouch and was sure that his face was alight with interest, ‘About the “discount”….’
‘Oh bother,’ Bilbo grumbled. ‘Bilbo, you Yavanna-damned idiot!’
‘Now, now, Bilbo, don’t be like that,’ Thorin hushed, trying not to grin. ‘You might as well just tell me what you did. I knew you had done something even before we left the Shire.’
‘Of course you did,’ Bilbo muttered. Then he huffed out a breath, but did not speak.
‘Come, Bilbo,’ Thorin encouraged. ‘Put me out of my misery. Dwalin is convinced I owe you half of my kingdom. If I do then I ought to know it.’
‘If I had wished to be owed anything then I would not have tried to keep the secret!’ Bilbo snapped. Then he took a deep breath and appeared to let his temper fade away. ‘It was not done to create a debt, Thorin. It was done to help friends. And, perhaps a little, in memory of those in the Shire who suffered as your people might if we do not resolve this problem. I could hardly allow your people to starve when I had the means to prevent it.’
‘You would be dismayed how many people would do exactly that,’ Thorin told him sadly. ‘What did you and Fortinbras agree, Bilbo?’ He had begun to have strong suspicions after what Bilbo had said, but he wished to have confirmation nonetheless.
‘The ten percent that we offered was a fiction,’ Bilbo said bluntly, at last. As if, having decided to tell it, he wished to get it out there and done with as soon as possible. ‘I paid it. A deposit to begin with, to encourage my fellow hobbits to agree without a fuss, with Fortinbras to take the rest at the same time your people paid the balance owing.’
It was no more than Thorin had thought Bilbo would admit, but all at once the enormity of it hit him.
Ten percent.
A king’s ransom.
Almost literally.
Valar above, Dwalin was right.
‘Bilbo, that is…’ he tried, then faltered when he realised he did not have the words for such a gift. For gift it had surely been, and one with no expectation of return.
‘It was what I could do,’ Bilbo said with finality. ‘It was not as if I was Thranduil, saving Fíli’s life in the face of near-certain death, so there is no need to sound so impressed; it is only money. I had plenty of it and I have not beggared myself in the giving.’
‘You can say that only because you do not know what Dís will do with the extra your generosity has given us,’ Thorin assured him. Bilbo looked over in query, and Thorin clarified.
‘She buys medicines, Bilbo,’ Thorin told him solemnly. ‘Every winter. As many as she can afford with what we have, and any dwarf who has need can come to her, or to Óin, to request them. You have saved lives, Bilbo. I promise you that.’
‘Oh,’ Bilbo said after a short space, apparently absorbing what Thorin had said. ‘Well, good. I am happy to hear it.’
Thorin almost laughed. It was such a prosaic, Bilbo-type response.
He must have chuckled at least a little, for Bilbo scowled over at him. ‘I don’t want half a kingdom, Thorin,’ he protested. ‘For goodness’ sake, don’t go spreading such a thing around. I have enough trouble with Bag End. You’ve all given me a place to feel like I belong for a while. That’s plenty for me.’
That was perhaps sadder and more telling than Bilbo realised, but Thorin could appreciate the sentiment behind it. It was no small thing, a place to belong. Thorin knew that, after the years his people had spent in exile, and he had always had Dís, and Balin and Dwalin too.
It had not sounded, from their previous conversations, as if Bilbo had had much of anyone to care for him in the small ways that counted.
‘Fair enough,’ he replied after a moment, keeping his voice mild. ‘After all, by your reckoning I would owe Thranduil half my kingdom too, and then I would have no kingdom left. I’ll admit it’s not much to look at, but it is mine nonetheless. I think I will keep hold of it a little longer.’
Bilbo hmphed a response, but Thorin saw the smile of gratitude and returned it. He still wasn’t sure if Bilbo could see them in the dark, but he felt better for doing it.
‘Of course, it will all be for naught if we cannot get out of here,’ Thorin sighed after some minutes of quiet. ‘We must make it to the Iron Hills soon. In the morning, I will ask again for an audience with Thranduil and this time, if I can get one, I will try to keep my temper for once.’
‘It would probably help,’ Bilbo agreed.
They lapsed into silence after that. These had been some of the longest days Thorin could remember, longer than any since his grandfather’s death and the loss of his father and brother, and he fell into an exhausted sleep not long after.
***
Above them, the Elven King stood still and silent for some time.
It had been a most enlightening conversation after all. On a number of levels.
He had assumed, without questioning the assumption, that the dwarves were headed for their lost kingdom.
That they planned to take the Lonely Mountain back.
A quest to reclaim a homeland, and slay a dragon.
Apparently not.
******
