Actions

Work Header

A Loophole in the Tapestry

Chapter 4: Clematis for Cunning

Chapter Text

            The Company goes down the familiar path that is slowly but surely leading them to the clutches of the trolls, and, a day later, high elves. Thorin thinks the whole ordeal with the elves is a bit more taxing than those three ugly fools, but none of those could be avoided.

            If they don’t get close to the trolls, there will be no Sting, no Glamdring and no Orcrist. King’s hands felt empty without the latter by his side ever since he returned to the land of the living. If they don’t go to Rivendell, Gandalf will suspect divine interference in Thorin’s sudden awareness of moon runes and what their content is. So the answer lies in playing the unknowing fool and bending like a reed in the sway of circumstances.

 

“I say we make camp here” Thorin said, glancing over, counting thirteen exhausted faces staring back at him “We can use the walls of this old farmhouse for additional protection”

“This house hadn’t been abandoned, Master Oakenshield” the wizard chimed in “Something more sinister has a hand in desolating it”

“Clearly the thing you talk about didn’t pay the remnants a visit” he gestured towards old bricks “The moss has begun to spread, and so did the weeds. Has your age tampered with your sight?”

“I still say we move forwards, towards the valley that will act as more suitable shelter”

“And I as a leader say we make camp here!” he put on an irritated act “The ponies are barely holding up”

“We can lead them, go on foot for a couple of miles” Gandalf frowned

“Or we could rest for a couple of additional hours” Thorin scoffed “Gloin, start the fire! Bombur, Bifur, get going on the gruel. Fili, Kili, you’re on pony duty tonight”

“Why us?” the boys groaned

“Unlike some of us, you have keen eyes” the dwarf approached the wizard

 

            Gandalf’s eyes narrowed, brows frowned and Thorin was afraid he will fall victim to some nasty curse or two. Bilbo’s eyes nervously jumped from one to another, not daring to interrupt. Thorin almost smiled as he saw the hobbit wring his delicate hands, his own ones traitorously twitching with the urge to hold them, to make them lay cradled, still, and pliant under the caress of his calloused thumbs. 

 

“Save me from the stubbornness of dwarves!” Gandalf cursed to who knows what “I am going to seek the company of the one person who manages not to set my nerves on fire!”

“…who’s that?” Bilbo smiled timidly

“Myself, Bilbo!” the wizard’s eyes threw sparks of ire “Myself!”

 

            As the wizard stomped off, there was a minute of awkward silence. Gloin hesitantly begun to gather firewood, the cooks following the dwarf’s lead. Soon, the Company was going through the now familiar routine of settling down. As Thorin observed, he felt the presence of his love more than he heard him approaching.

 

“You have outdone yourself, Master Oakenshield” Bilbo threw an unintelligible glance at him

“It’s a passion of mine” Thorin smiled, reveling at the sight of small blush coloring Bilbo’s cheeks

“Really? Because clearly you excel at it” the hobbit drew back and approached Myrtle, taking off his travel pack

“What can I say, I’m a natural”

 

            Bilbo gave an unceremonious snort to Myrtle’s mane. The pony then begun to nuzzle into hobbit’s side and face, making him laugh even harder at being tickled. Thorin’s heart soared. Then, he was smacked upside the head with Dwalin’s elbow as the dwarf exaggeratedly stretched out his limbs.

 

“Shut up” Thorin hissed

“I’m not saying anything” his cousin grinned

“You better not be” he sighed “This is not yet the time to make any advances regarding this…stuff”

“Stuff? You mean in pursuing the love of your life?” Dwalin’s brows shot up “How could you disregard the topic so?”

“I am not disregarding anything” Thorin laid down his cot, sat down

“Finding your One is no joke, lad” the dwarf persisted, crowding the view of the rest of the Company

“I know, Dwalin” their eyes met “Believe me, I know”

 

            Thorin knitted his brows almost involuntarily, silently pleading his cousin to leave the topic be. It was a quiet and personal kind of torture, to be unable to touch his hobbit, to not let his gaze linger a bit too long lest he notices. He knew his love was too big for Bilbo to bear, and he worried that if everything goes on smoother than it did last time, he will never find the courage to tell the truth to him. If the hobbit would want to know the truth, that was.

            The Bilbo he knew and loved would’ve pried the words out of him with any means necessary. Thorin paled at the traitorous thought.

 

“Alright” he nodded “Alright brother, do as you deem wise”

“Thank you” Thorin smiled bitterly

 

            Thorin dared to pick Bilbo apart as the hobbit sat across the fire from him later that night.

            Right now, he was telling a story of him and his cousins fighting over some inheritance business the dwarf couldn’t grasp, and frankly, didn’t care for. Bilbo was radiant, all dimpled smiles and open gestures, savoring the attention of the dwarrow he managed to easily befriend. Despite the events unfolding as they were supposed to, in the minor details everything was all so starkly different, that it made Thorin dizzy.

            Bilbo was gaining confidence, unravelling the iron beam of resilience that was always present, yet buried deep beneath years of self-doubt and soft life. Thorin was truly happy that the process had been gentler, supported by the warm words of dwarrow, yet at the sight of it, his stomach couldn’t help but churn with unease. And did Thorin berate himself for such thoughts.

            He now knew more about Master Baggins than ever, all with help of his nosy nephews. For the first time in his past and present life, Thorin was aware of Bilbo’s favorite hobbies, holidays, meals, colors, memories. He knew of his doubts and regrets, more easily shared as the halfling was now met with understanding and not scoffing. He knew Master Baggins almost entirely, but it felt like Bilbo was slipping further and further from his grasp.

            As the new memories filled the place where old ones used to be, the intertwining of both scared Thorin. To know Master Baggins, yet not share the perils that brought them together in the first place, to speak with him and see the soft gaze, too naïve and trusting to bring the familiar thrill of the ire running between them as Bilbo and Thorin clashed at the beginning of the first journey – it all was too much and all of it felt wrong.  

            Thorin knew that he would need to make countless sacrifices to see the journey through, yet he didn’t know that one of those would be seeing a stranger in the face of the person he loved most.

 

“Bilbo-lad!” Bombur called gently “Take the bowls to the boys, please”

“Sure” the hobbit stood up “Where are they gone off to?”

“A bit towards the mountainside, I think” the dwarf hummed “Just stick to the right-rand side and you’ll stumble onto them”

“Alright”

 

            As Bilbo passed him while balancing the plates, the hobbit smiled, yet Thorin couldn’t manage to bring himself to return the gesture. At the confused gaze, he lowered his head in shame. His gaze stayed that way even as the camp returned to its usual bustle, not wanting to receive questioning looks or unnecessary questions.

            When Kili came running, panic clear in his gaze, Thorin was more concerned with keeping Bilbo in one piece than to grasp the look the hobbit gave him as he was being help up and threatened to be torn to bits. He lowered his sword as the ambush failed, and let himself be put in the sack, laying there, watching the half of the company being tied to the poor resemblance of the roasting spit.

            As on que, Bilbo sprung up, waddling towards the trolls in a mix of fear and pure determination. Did they already say that the dawn should be near? Thorin hummed. Listened to the spiel about spices, flavors, waited. There, parasites.

 

“I’ve got parasites!” he shouted “As big as my arm!”

 

            A beat of silence. His nephews quickly followed, and so did the rest of the Company. Bombur had been dropped with a thud in disgust. Before the least dim out of three could catch on, Gandalf approached, breaking off the huge rock with a simple hit of his staff.

 

“Thank you for saving us” Thorin bowed to the wizard as the Company recovered “And thank you for your burglar. He had proven himself once again with his keen hearing and quick thinking”

“Why yes” he smiled “Bilbo has many hidden talents, most of which come off as a surprise even for him”

“The Company keeps on reminding him of his importance, for which I’m glad” Thorin looked at the dwarrow who assessed the sloppy footprints

“And do you remind him of that?” Gandalf nudged him “Even though I am not present on the journey at all times, I can tell that the shadow has fallen over you two”

“It is my fault only, not his” the dwarf sighed “I will deal with it, when I find the right words”

“Words…strange things, these words” Gandalf led them over towards the excited shouts “For it is by actions a man is judged”

“It’s a good thing that I am not a man, then” Thorin smirked, and descended into the putrid cave

 

            Being chased by the feral warg pack wasn’t as scary now with Orcrist strapped to his belt. Thorin kept the headcount, held his nephews close, and Bilbo even closer. The metal that gleamed as he cut and stabbed the monstrous claws of wargs threatening his dwarrow was unchanging, steady and reliable in the chaos that persisted Thorin both in life and in thoughts. The king was the last to slide down the cavernous passage, relying on Gandalf to lead them straight from one threat to another.

            He feared the elves more than the target Azog had placed on his head. Their folk had an uncanny ability to know the inner workings of the mind and soul, to assess where all the rotten parts lie. They knew what to heal, and what lo leave be. Sometimes, while reminiscing on the past journey, Thorin thought that they could predict the outcomes of the future too.

            Thorin was scared that Lord Elrond will know what a coward he truly is.

 

“Mithrandir!” a clear, powerful voice rang through the stampede of the horses

“Lord Elrond!” Gandalf’s smile widened “I hope we are not intruding”

“Never” the elf looked over them from the height of his steed and smiled

 

            Thorin met the ageless eyes of the Lord as he approached the Company. His face was mature, yet there was that juvenile gleam in his gaze and in the quirk of lips that was so typical for elven folk. And there was no malice, nor prejudice. Thorin straightened.

 

“Thorin Oakenshield” he bowed “It is nice to finally meet you”

“I could say the same thing myself, Lord Elrond” he found it surprisingly easy to let the words out “My Company and I had just been chased by the pack of wargs, and would be eternally grateful if you aided us by providing a short refuge while we recover”

“Hm” his eyes twinkled “You have your grandfather’s bearing, Master Oakenshield. I will provide you and your people with food and shelter under the condition you tell me more about the objective of your venture”

 

            There was a thrum of voices as the dwarrow scoffed and scowled at the Elvenlord’s words. Bilbo couldn’t stop looking around with pure wonder in his gaze, and Gandalf frowned as few of the rowdiest of the Company tried to speak to Thorin at once. The King stepped forward, ceasing the onslaught of opinions.

 

“Whatever you ask of me, I will answer” he nodded, noticing the concealed look of surprise on Elrond’s face

 

            The Company was escorted towards the ornately decorated terrace, and Thorin found himself throwing pointed glances at his dwarrow like an agitated school-dwarrowdam as he turned behind the Lord’s back at any instance of complaint. He will allow only one possibility of food tossing this evening, and perhaps two or three drinking songs. The Battle may have changed him, and the Halls of Mahal proved the meaninglessness of a hate-filled life, but it didn’t mean that the elves didn’t need some loosening up.

            Thorin couldn’t help but chuckle in his sleeve as the dishes were brought out. Almost all, surprisingly, were meaty and with plenty of bread. There were even few different kinds of sausages, just what a hungry dwarf needed. Politeness will get them far, it seemed.

            Elrond patiently explained the history of Thorin and Gandalf’s swords, and the dwarf noticed Bilbo bashfully sheathe his letter-opener at the lower table. He smiled at the memory of his boys teaching the hobbit how to do basic moves as he sat under the shade of Beorn’s trees recuperating, watching them. Kili was now chuckling with Fili, both eyeing the elves that played flutes and harps. Thorin rolled his eyes as Kili winked at one of them. Dis would give her pebbles a scolding of the lifetime if she caught the act.

            The rest of the Company feasted on cuts of meat, avoiding the vegetables with more politeness than Thorin expected. Soon, as the wine settled into their bellies, dwarrow pulled out a couple of their own instruments that weren’t taken away with the bolting of the ponies. Bofur climbed onto the table, and begun the Company’s favorite drinking song. Thorin grinned as the elves tried to play in tact with the ruckus. In the corner of his eye, he could see Elrond smiling.

 

“Master Oakenshield” Elrond found him an hour later at dusk “May I have a word with you before we make it to the waterfalls?”

“Of course” the king nodded

 

            Bilbo was just waving the elf Lord goodbye, and rushed to explore the wonders of Rivendell further. Elrond waited a beat, smiled at Thorin and gestured towards the edge of the balcony where they saw the hobbit cautiously looking around and trespassing on carefully cut grass.

 

“Outstanding creatures” elf sighed contently “As pure and happy as children, yet wise in the ways of life as ancient scholars”

“Yes, you speak the truth” Thorin hummed “He certainly taught me a few things on the course of our journey”

“And what would those things be?”

“That, if more people valued food and cheer over the gold and riches, this world would be a merrier place” the dwarf tried not to think of the taste of copper on his tongue as he uttered those words the first time “What is the purpose of the hoard if you don’t use it to better the life of the ones you love? It might just as well be a pile of dirt”

“I see” Elrond nodded to himself “You do have a chance in succeeding, Thorin”

“Hm?” he looked at the tall figure beside him

“I am aware you are headed over toward the Lonely Mountain, and I think you will reach the goal you had set out for yourself. There is a steadiness in you, a strong soul. Like an arrow pointing North, it will lead you in the right direction, despite everything”

“Despite everything?” Thorin whispered, looking into Elrond’s eyes

“Despite everything” the elf smiled

 

            The hidden runes have been read, and Thorin had found himself wandering through the terraces and paths of Rivendell, now shimmering softly in silver and as bright as a mountain spring in the light of the moon. There had been no talk about the golden sickness as the wizard and the elf walked towards the lonely gazebo, and he didn’t know what to do about it. It meant that Bilbo didn’t know. And it meant it was from Thorin’s lips he must be told about it.

            The smell of roses hit him, and Thorin paused to look at the white petals, opalescent at night. His fingers were too calloused to grasp the softness of the petals as he reached for them, so he let them be, strolling deeper into the garden. He remembered scoffing at Bilbo as the hobbit reverently looked at every carved bench, every tree, and touched the buds of flowers as if they were made of glass last time they been here. It hurt Thorin then, and it hurt him now, knowing that Erebor, his home, once so warm and safe, would never receive such adorning treatment from his hobbit.

            Even when he was at Mahal’s Halls, Thorin wondered if Bilbo ever visited Erebor again. Not the dim, cursed death trap of the mountain, but lit by the forges and covered by veins upon veins of gold and precious metals as if she chose the adornments herself. He remembered whispering about the beauty of it all night as they clung between dreams and consciousness on soft hay at Beorn’s, Bilbo’s eyes shining as if the two stars decided to hide beneath his creamy eyelids.

            Thorin remembered kissing at the ruined gates after Smaug fell, panicked and delirious from the events that transpired, from playing with death and miraculously winning. How he fervently whispered about the mountain being theirs, how she will be singing with the strikes of anvil and laughter of children. And he remembered what followed after that.

            The reason the hobbit left right after the last mourning songs were sang, probably repulsed by the memories the very sight of the mountain brought up.

            Thorin cursed under his breath.

 

“Master Dwarf!” Thorin startled

“Master Baggins” he watched the hobbit approach him “What are you doing up so late?”

“Could ask you the same thing, but with mutters of us leaving in the middle of the night, I suppose you chose to wake up everyone on time” he smiled “And it’s ‘Bilbo’, you know me long enough to call me that”

“Right, Bilbo” he nodded, slowly continuing his walk “I couldn’t sleep, and keeping the check on the time seemed to be the plausible answer to not even trying to lay down…I suppose you decided to take one last look at Rivendell before our departure?”

“Yes! Isn’t this place amazing?” Bilbo sighed dreamily “I find it hard even thinking of leaving in an hour or so”

“Don’t worry, Mas- Bilbo, when you see the halls of Erebor being lit, and how the gems glimmer with every movement of the candle, elven architecture will be dull in comparison”

 

            Bilbo scoffed at Thorin’s smug expression. As they went along, he went on the tangent why it was pointless to compare such vastly different things, each one beautiful in its own way. Thorin smiled and nodded along, but didn’t voice his own opinions, for there currently were none forming in his mind. Instead, he thought of Azog hunting them after their venture into Goblin Town, and the eagles carrying them closer towards the cursed Mirkwood. He thought of the Carrock. The apology, the first time he had the privilege of cradling Bilbo in his arms-

 

“I am getting irritated by you, if I’m being honest” Bilbo sighed “One day, you are this lovely dwarf, who jests and talks to me like any friend would, and then I say something, or, I don’t know, do something, and suddenly something shifts in you, and you avert your eyes, scowl, or worst of all – ignore me! What is it all about? I know you said you have a lot on your mind, and I too am still getting over the howls of wargs we witnessed, but this is getting ridiculous! I dare say, this is getting personal”

“Personal?”

“Yes! Because you act like this only when conversing with me!” the hobbit frowned “Everything was going so well up until it didn’t, for some unknown reason. It’s like the dwarf I met in Bag End is being overtaken by somebody entirely different!”

 

            Thorin’s mind turned to the biting cold of Erebor’s ramparts. The words were alike, yet different. The tone was all off, the ire was replaced by concern. This gentler Bilbo was looking at him so pleadingly, that Thorin was struck with a sudden wish to be scolded at, not reasoned with.

            It was easier to shout than to calmly explain the mad dissonance churning in his head.

 

“Look!” Bilbo shouted “There you went off again! Has me confronting you set off one of your fits? What is it?”

“It’s noth-“

“Don’t tell me it is nothing!” the hobbit grasped a handful of his tunic “I care about you, and want to help you! I tell you everything, why can’t it go both ways?!”

“Because you’re not him!”

 

            Thorin’s shout was thunderous in the silence of the night.

            Bilbo’s hands fell down. There was this blank expression again, of pursed lips and storm brewing only in the blues of those eyes. There was no shouting back, no huffs and angry mutterings. Just silence and the flutter of the petals in cold, crisp wind.

 

“I’m sorry I don’t exceed your expectations, Master Oakenshield”

 

The hobbit said gravely, and made his way towards the guest wing.