Actions

Work Header

A Loophole in the Tapestry

Chapter 5: Obsidian for Protection

Chapter Text

“Stay close to one another!” Balin shouted “This is no thunder storm, this is thunder battle!”

 

            The deafening sound of storm and rain rang all around the mountain pass, gusts of wind almost succeeding in throwing them off of the rocky cliffs. The stone giants were as terrifying as they were magnificent, not paying the minuscule dwarrow any attention as they fought. Thorin gasped as a boulder landed somewhere above the Company. Quick headcount, twelve dwarves and one distressed hobbit, who, despite the danger, continued to look at Thorin in utter disappointment.

            Thorin sighed, shouting to the dwarves ahead something about finding shelter. He hoped the fate would be kind to them this time around as it was the time previous. No Goblin Town, no magic ring. No magic ring, no chance of the hobbit surviving Mirkwood, Smaug, and the Battle while saving their backs in the process. Thorin marched on, repeating the words over and over again.

             He came to as there were shouts behind him. Before he could even feel his heart seize from the panic, Bilbo was being pulled up by Bofur and Kili from the edge of the cliff where he slipped and fell. Thorin met his panicked eyes, small hands clutching to the rocky surface.

 

“Thought we lost our burglar!” Dwalin laughed with an edge of panic in his voice

 

            Bilbo was still looking at him. Thorin needed to say something, but couldn’t find the words. This halfling wasn’t lost ever since he left home. He wasn’t ostracized nor prejudiced against. Master Baggins was the friend of the company now, and there will be no need for his heartfelt speech about helping them to reclaim their home after they escape the goblin tunnels. There won’t be many things this time around. Thorin turned away, and marched on.

            He knew Bilbo wouldn’t even consider returning to Rivendell this time. The city didn’t have reassuring back pats, jests and kind words of support. But it also didn’t have the brooding dwarf King who was set to make his journey harder. Maybe the hobbit will return after the Quest will be fulfilled. Thorin scoffed.

 

“How are you, Bilbo?” Bofur whispered as the Company settled

“I’m alright, but my knees are still shaking” the hobbit sighed “Such an embarrassment, I think I slipped on smoothest part of the road”

“It’s all because you don’t have boots on! Now see, these babies are made for mine work” dwarf grinned, swinging his foot around “Soles give feet a good grip, and toe box protects from anything that may fall on them”

“You still fell over the table at Rivendell” Thorin could hear him smirk

“Don’t compare mine shafts with smooth marble tabletops, alright?”

“I won’t” he laughed “I won’t wear shoes either”

 

            Thorin sighed, and turned to look at the rocky ceiling. Hobbit and dwarf fell silent as they realized they were being listened to, and the king suppressed the urge to pretend to sleep for their sake. There was no use, not when they thought him an insomniac from how many times he took the night watch. His thoughts were churning, as they did on all those sleepless nights, all because he couldn’t stop pulling the journey wrong, bending it too early or missing the cues completely, distancing from the dwarrow he swore to protect, and completely sabotaging his relationship with the one he was supposed to love.

            He simply couldn’t love Bilbo as he did back then. And he also couldn’t dismiss and snarl at him as he did the first time, since he was set on acting civil and adoring ever since he crossed the threshold of Bag End, erasing the possibility of them moving through all the steps that brought them together in the first place. The events that made Bilbo who he was.

            Thorin’s atoning manner of acting worked well the first weeks. It was elating, to see the hobbit happy and content. It was even promising, if Thorin rightly judged the soft looks Bilbo gave him. But then, one night, barely breathing and getting over the nightmare of the Raven Hill, Thorin realized that the love he was directing at Master Baggins was actually the love he wished to place on the lonely hunched figure of the halfling that watched him die. This hobbit didn’t know; he couldn’t grasp the guilt Thorin’s love was soaked with. And the more Thorin was glad the halfling didn’t suffer for him, he hated himself for wishing Bilbo eventually did.

            Because now he won’t hear those honeyed words about helping them find home. He won’t have a chance to embrace the halfling, to breathe in the warm scent of the flaxen curls, to clutch at the soft velvet of his red jacket. The tenderness that Master Baggins felt for him wasn’t aimed at Thorin, the sick, greedy and mad dwarf that fell on the icy surface of the waterfall. It was aimed at Master Oakenshield, a very polite and measured king, who upon first meeting spewed nonsense about destiny, prayers and the scent of honeysuckles.

            Thorin closed his eyes.

 

‘Green Lady’ he thought ‘I can’t help but fail. Every step I took was faulty, every word I directed at your sweet child misplaced. I was right, I am not worthy of the blessing you bestowed on me. If I die by Azog’s blade tomorrow, I won’t be angry. I won’t be glad either, because the first time I passed, I passed in peace and happiness, lost in the eyes of the burglar of my heart. This time I will perish ostracized and alone, as I was destined to before Bilbo showed up in my life and made me complete’

 

“Bilbo” Bofur broke the still silence “Why is your sword glowing?”

 

            Thorin shot up.

 

“Everyone, wake up!” he roared “Wake-“

 

            They were falling through the tunnels, trapped in nets and staring into the ugly faces of the goblins. Thorin tried not to listen to the distressed cries of his dwarrows.

            The hobbit managed to avoid getting caught, lingering on the sidelines of the commotion. Thorin felt proud at his stealth, but it evaporated as the imp once again managed to seize Bilbo while the Company was led towards the platform on which the Goblin King sat. No tunnels, no ring. Thorin watched the hobbit thrash around the vice grip. No ring, no escape from the woodland realm. Bilbo wriggled free, toppling the ugly thing over. No escaping the elves, no reaching Erebor in time. The orc managed to get a hold on his calf. No Erebor, ho home.

            Bilbo fell, and there was nothing Thorin could do about it.

                       

“Where’s Bilbo?!” Bofur shouted as they ran through the tunnels

“He will catch up!” Thorin shouted back

“He fell!” Nori cried “I watched him fall! There is a huge drop, we lost him!”

“No one is lost!” the king roared “He will turn up!”

“How are you so sure?!” there were tears in Bofur’s eyes now

 

            Thorin was interrupted by the light shining through the crack of the mountainside and the gasps of dwarrow at the sight of an exit. Gandalf rushed them forward, and Thorin swore he caught a glimpse of a deep red coat somewhere to the left.

            As they ran, he could distantly hear the howls of wargs approaching. The hands that were clutching the hilt of Orcrist felt clammy, eyes scanning the perimeter. Bofur was still sniffling, talking about going back to check for their friend. Thorin’s ears were sharp enough to hear the rustle of the pine needles behind them.

 

“Master Baggins!” Thorin smiled at the approaching hobbit

“Master Oakenshield” he looked beaten and tired, yet content “Good evening”

“How did you get out of the caverns?” dwarf asked

 

            A flash of gold slipping into the waistcoat pocket told him everything that he needed to know.

 

“I met the most peculiar creature down there that helped me out” Bilbo hummed as Bofur all but thrown himself into a hug “I think it was a hobbit once…not anymore, though”

“Why not?” Thorin breathed in, any time now

“It was all pale, and stretched out thin” hobbit shuddered “Ate raw fish and orcs, hated the sunlight and everything that made him less of a monster. But his eyes remained genuine, though sanity was lost in them…yes, he was genuine”

“We thought we lost you!” Bofur smiled tearfully

“It’ll take more than a tumble down the cliff to make me stray away from the Company!” Bilbo laughed “I would’ve gone with you all through the thunder battle and Goblin Town ten times over, don’t you worry”

“Why?” Thorin couldn’t help but ask “Why do you continue to go on with us?”

 

            Master Baggins was finally looking at him, and Thorin couldn’t help but compare. There were still brass buttons on his waistcoat. There was more roundness to his cheeks, there were no eye bags despite the perilous journey. There was freshness in him, remainder of childish naivety, that wasn’t yet broken. Bilbo looked worn, beaten, and frustrated, but impossibly kind and compassionate at the same time. Master Baggins looked timid and uncertain instead.

 

“Master Oakenshield, I know you doubt me more and more as the journey progresses” he sighed “You thought of me as a sign, but I continue to underperform. I am a simple hobbit, after all, not a token of good fortune! And yet, I value me being here in your Company. I cherish every day that passes, and the closer we get to the Lonely Mountain the more determined I feel to aid you to reclaim it”

 

            Thorin nodded, brows knit. It all was wrong. It all tasted like bile.

 

“I hear how the Company longs for it, and how excited the young dwarves are to see it” Bilbo smiled hesitantly “Please have mercy on me, and I’ll try to do my best in the meantime”

“I’m sorry, Mas- Bilbo” it hurt to use his name “I am truly sorry, that I let my concerns and fears poison the good parts of our journey”

“It’s alright” hobbit smiled more earnestly now “Just talk to your loved ones about what troubles you, and there’ll be less reasons to mend fences that often-”

 

            Thorin sighed in exasperation as the pack of wargs made themselves known. Gandalf took the lead, making them climb the pine trees. Fili and Kili were laughing somewhere above him, and Thorin couldn’t help but smile to himself at their antics. Over all, they were as much of a trouble and joy on this journey as one previous, so it was easier to accept the love and admiration in their eyes. They were alive and merry, they didn’t see him go mad, and their mother will receive them back into her arms, just as Thorin promised. 

            They were easier to think about than the hobbit. They were stable, almost unchanging in comparison to them prior. Even in the Halls of Mahal there were the same mannerisms and quirks. The Halfling, on the other hand…Thorin absentmindedly thrown the flaming pinecones at the heads of wargs. The hobbit was a wound that reopened again and again, and they were Thorin’s hands that poured the salt.

 

“Thorin” black speech of the pale orc managed to croak out his name “Son of Thrain, son of Thror”

“Azog” he said, resigned “We have met once again”

“I have unfinished business with you” he grinned, black gums showing “With all three of you”

 

            Thorin’s hands ached from his grip at the hilt of his sword. He cast a glance toward his boys. His pale, terrified, painfully young nephews. He looked downward again, smoke from the flaming trees making his eyes sting. The tree started to give out under him.

 

“You have no right!” Thorin hissed at the orc “You have no chance of hurting them, not while I’m breathing!”

“Too bad you won’t be breathing for long, Oakenshield” Azog stretched his smile impossibly wider “I’ll make sure of it”

 

            This is it, Thorin sighed, and scaled up the laying bark, listening to the cries in the distance. Soon, the eagles will be here soon, it all will be over. He smiled. The Company will be safe, as will his hobbit, his nephews. Azog’s grimace didn’t waiver. Identically white warg bared his teeth. Thorin managed to avoid the bite, bow quickly enough under the swing of the flail. He landed a hit on orc’s leg, and the sound of a pained wail was like a music to him.

            He whacked Orcrist against warg’s side, drawing it off. The Company yelled a battle cry, and lunged forward to aid him. Thorin laughed at the hesitance written all over Azog’s face. Dwalin fought beside him, an involuntary gesture. The moment his brother-in-arms was beside him, Thorin’s eyes pulled out form the battle and searched for a red coat. He prayed this Bilbo would be fearful enough to stay back, to hide behind the wizard’s cloak. As in most of his prayers, he received no answer to his pleas.

            Thorin stilled and watched the hobbit stand against an orc twice his size. Different times, different possibilities, and yet all Bilbo’s were aching for self-sacrifice. Orc was toying with the creature, watching him futilely swing the sword as cat watches a cornered mouse.

 

“Foolish hobbit!” he roared

 

            Hobbit turned from a standoff for just a second, just to see the flurry of blue and black rushing to him, and that was enough for an orc. Heavy mace connected right into the soft middle, sending Bilbo sprawling by the edge of the cliff.

            Kili’s arrow landed right between orc’s brows. Thorin’s knees gave out.

 

“Bilbo” Thorin whispered, crawling over to the limp body “Bilbo…Bilbo, please, wake up! My burglar, my treasure”

 

            Bilbo wasn’t responding, eyes shut. He looked serene, not bothered with the troubles of the world, nor the dreadful fate that awaited him. Thorin’s gaze broke off from the quickly bluing lips towards Azog, who was approaching leisurely, as if it was a usual ordeal to him, to wreck the foundations of other’s lives.

            Thorin turned to the hobbit, who was going cold. Bilbo wasn’t supposed to be cold. He was as warm as a sunshine, and just as pleasant. He wasn’t this lump, lying on the ground. The clammy skin that Thorin touched didn’t belong to Bilbo, but to someone else. Not to his hobbit, never to his hobbit. Bilbo never supposed to be the one lying down on his deathbed, Thorin was.

 

“This was not supposed to go like this!” he wept, clawing at hobbit’s limp hands “You were not supposed to get hurt, bunmel-“

          

            As Azog raised his massacred limb to land a fatal cut on Thorin’s neck, the claw of an eagle threw him over. Thorin watched the birds swarm, and barely noticed being picked up by one himself. Bilbo was taken too, and so were the rest of the dwarves. Someone was shouting, but Thorin’s mouth was sewn shut, eyes unmoving from the small figure clutched by the talons.

            Azog wasn’t dead, that Thorin knew. He will still have to watch out for the orc as he leads his nephews into battle. If there ever will be a battle. If the mountain will be reclaimed without the burglar. Thorin closed his eyes and lowered his head onto the smooth feathers, trying not to let the tears fall. Falling. It seemed all he did was falling, if not to madness, then to his own folly. If Bilbo manages to stay alive, Thorin would kiss the ground he walks on in a pitiful attempt of an apology.

            He couldn’t love the both of them right, both past and present hobbits, no matter how badly he wanted to. Thorin was unable to protect them, nor cherish them. He should have let Azog take his life once more. It would’ve been easier this way.

            The eagles gently laid the hobbit on the Carrock. As soon as dwarrow feet landed, they circled him, giving way only to the approaching wizard. Big, gentle hands were placed on the cold forehead, and Gandalf begun muttering incomprehensible words.

             Thorin watched from the distance. The hobbit should have been awake by now, just as he once was. But Bilbo laid still while the wind played with his curls, and the wizard’s hands begun to shake.

 

“Bilbo, dear” he chuckled “It’s dawn already, don’t you feel the sun? You’re not a faunt to sleep in, there are…there are adventures ahead, Bilbo”

 

            Everyone watched as Gandalf sat down, gazed to the distance, and lit up his pipe.

            His free hand rested atop of Bilbo’s heart. Hobbit’s breathing was so faint, it was almost unnoticeable. Then there was a gasp, a rustle of clothes, two panicked eyes opening.

 

“-Yavanna! Where am I?” Bilbo whispered, eyes wide “…Gandalf?!”

“Bilbo! You- you don’t believe how badly you scared us, dear” the wizard sprung up, embracing the hobbit “I wouldn’t be surprised if you forgotten your very name after the tousle you’ve been through! You’re on the Carrock, in the realm of the mighty eagles, who carried you all the way here after Azog attacked us”

“Eagles?” hobbit gasped

“Yes” the wizard gestured to the ever moving shapes in the morning sky “You have been unconscious to witness their flight, I’m afraid”

 

            Bilbo looked around, bewildered gaze sweeping over every face of the Company. They were all concerned, yet smiling, praising him of his courage. Hobbit turned his head abruptly, eyes latching to the lonely figure of a king.

 

“Thorin…” he whispered, and smiled “You’re alright”

 

            Thorin’s heart skipped a beat. How can Bilbo regard him with such tenderness? Even wincing as the wizard urged him to stand, the hobbit kept smiling. Thorin didn’t feel the urge to look at Erebor looming in the distance of a pink sunrise, not when Bilbo started to take shaky steps towards him.

 

“Master Boggins, be careful not to fall off!” Kili outstretched his arms as the hobbit stumbled

 

            Bilbo’s head whipped towards the source of the sound. Smile was wiped off of his mouth in an instant. Thorin and Fili shared a confused look, younger dwarf rushing to aid his brother as Bilbo’s knees gave out.

 

“Boys!” his eyes welled up with tears

“What is it? Where does it hurt?” Fili knitted his brows “Come on, we can’t help you if you don’t tell!”

“No- no” he shook his head frantically “Nothing hurts…everything hurts- no, boys, no! Wait- I can’t…I don’t know-”

“Master Boggins, calm down!” Kili pleaded “Come on, Master Bilbo, stand up! We’ll set camp and there’ll be a nice meal, will make you feel all better!”

“No!” hobbit clutched at his hair, white knuckles not letting go even as the brothers tried to unclasp them “No! We will not! I will not- I will not, no! Don’t touch- no!”

 

            Oin and Gandalf approached the three of them, and the Company felt dread at the incomprehensible look they shared. Thorin paled. He seen those eyes before, that distinct awareness mixed with crazed absentmindedness, heard the nonsense spewing out of the panicked mouths. Bilbo went mad, just like the tender-hearted dwarrow at Azanulbizar.

            He was silent as Dwalin vouched to carry the shaking hobbit down the Carrock. He was silent as his nephews looked at him with knitted brows, silently demanding an ounce of explanation from him. He didn’t want to believe it, so he stayed silent not to turn his words into something real.

            Up until their healer pronounces Bilbo mad, he would simply think of the Halfling sensitive, unused to the battle and scared by the threat of death. Bilbo’s soul was too strong to get knocked down so easily, he was too brave to be scared of a simple mace.  He conquered a dragon, for Mahal’s sake! He couldn’t be mad, he simply couldn’t.

 

“Be a good lad and drink this” Oin was unusually soft spoken

 

            Bilbo, puffy with the amount of tears he shed and distant-gazed, silently took the offered vial, not wincing at the bitter-tasting brew. Thorin stayed close, urge to care for the Halfling overcoming the guilt. The Company huddled close to the fire, leaving them with some sense of privacy.

 

“Master Baggins” he whispered “Please try to sleep, the herbs Oin brewed will aid you in it”

“I don’t want to” Bilbo whispered back “If I go to sleep now, there will be nightmares, and because I drank the medicine I will be unable to wake up to escape from them”

“Why did you drink it, then?” Thorin took off his cloak

“So the Company would be happier” Bilbo smiled bitterly “…And they wouldn’t think I’m crazy to the point of non-compliance”

“But you deem yourself crazy?” Thorin gently laid the cloak on top of the hobbit, who nuzzled his nose into the fur lining, eyes drifting shut

“I certainly feel crazy” a dazed murmur

 

            Thorin took smaller hand in his, thumb drawing lazy circles on the tender skin. Bilbo sniffled, and the first tear track made its way down the wind-bitten cheek. Dwarf’s heart wrung itself at the sight of it.

 

“Don’t worry, I will be there when the nightmares overcome you” Thorin ran his free hand through the tangled curls

“I know you will” one tired eye opened to look at him

“Do you now?” Thorin tried to muster up a smile

“…You don’t have to pretend to be happy” the eye closed “Not after I made a scene”

“You had all the right to make a scene”

“Is this right bestowed on me by the King? Balin should scribble out a contract for such an honor” there was a faint smile in the muffled voice

“You always disregarded my kingship” Thorin rolled his eyes

“Damn right I did” Bilbo yawned “Good night, Thorin”

“Good night, Master B-”

“Bilbo”

“Good night, Bilbo”

 

            Thorin sat there and waited before faint breaths turned into soft snores, and gathered the hobbit into his arms. As he approached the fire, the Company instantly parted to let some room for the outstretched bare feet as Thorin sat down, rest of Bilbo’s body sloped against him.

 

“Why Bilbo can’t stop crying?” Kili whispered, still looking shaken “He looks at us, and he breaks down. The more we try to comfort him, the more he weeps”

“He’s grown very attached to the two of you on the course of the journey” Gandalf threw a saddened look at the small sleeping figure “Perhaps, in seeing you being put at risk and himself suffering the brute force of it, he realized how close you were to never seeing each other again”

 

            Thorin chose to look at the sky instead of the sorrowful faces of his kin. The stars were out tonight, and the king smiled as he managed to make the constellation Bilbo taught him. The hobbits were in dispute till this day whether it was a wagon or a ladle. Thorin placed his bet on the ladle back then, once hearing the hobbit threaten to discipline his nephews with it, but Bilbo insisted that there was a pony hiding in the sky somewhere, so the wagon it was.

            Oin clearing his throat broke the king out of the haze of the fond memories.

 

“Poor laddie is in emotional distress, Kili…some form of hysteria” healer shook his head “I have seen it in warriors. They go mad with fear before the battle, or relive the brutality of the things they witnessed after it ends”

“But Bilbo is not a warrior” Kili murmured, hand reaching out to clutch Bilbo’s

“Exactly. Perhaps it is the reason he took it so badly” Dwalin hummed “The lad did tell us there isn’t anything sharper than a butcher’s knife in the entire Shire, and I told him that the wild is no place for a folk that cannot defend oneself. But he didn’t listen”

“The sight of an orc ready to kill you will shake the resolve of even the strongest of us, Dwalin” Fili shuddered “Just the thought of our Bilbo…never mind”

“Is there a cure?” Kili looked between his brother and Oin “Calming herbs? A balm to make the bruises fade quicker?”

“Bruises may fade, but memories will not” the elder stood up “Bilbo must cry it out, shout and complain and whatnot. Do not try to stop him, it’ll be like not letting the venom seep out of the bite. Let’s just hope our hobbit is stronger than we thought he was”