Actions

Work Header

A Loophole in the Tapestry

Chapter 6: Turquoise for Truth

Chapter Text

            Next morning, Bilbo was barely present in the hum of the conversation as the Company made it out of the Misty mountains. Thorin didn’t know whether it was the remnants of the brew coursing through him, or whether he was simply too tired to do anything but move his feet forward. The hobbit didn’t flinch nor avoid his hand as Thorin led him by the elbow, so it was a relief.

            Fili and Kili chose to linger somewhere further from the hobbit, not risking another crying fit, not with the threat of the huge bear lurking somewhere in the trees hearing them. As they ran for their life towards the lonely house, there was a semblance of consciousness in his eyes, and Thorin prayed to Mahal and his Wife to give the hobbit strength to climb out of the abyss his mind fell off to.

 

“Eat up, little bunny”

 

            Beorn adored Bilbo just the same this time around, saving the best slices of bread and the creamiest cups of milk to pamper the hobbit with. Bilbo begun to smile back at the skin-changer, and Thorin could’ve wept with the relief of seeing the soft dimples appear on his cheeks. Flower garden seemed to improve hobbit’s mood, and the soft bleats of sheep made a few chuckles escape his lips.

            Thorin followed him like a shadow, and tried not to pay attention to the sight of tears that appeared every time Bilbo dared to meet his eyes. He understood that bringing Bilbo’s distress out in the open was the last thing the hobbit wanted, so he resorted to holding his warming hand and telling silly stories of his youth. Bilbo thanked him every time he calmed down, and Thorin scolded him for it. There was no need to thank the person who caused the distress at the first place by mindlessly rushing into the battle with overpowered orcs. Thorin sighed.

 

“I’m fine, Oin” Bilbo’s assuring smile was a faint, barely there thing “I think I will sleep soundly tonight without your brew”

“Do as you seem fit, laddie” the healer’s eyes lingered on him, assessing “I see us being at skin-changer’s house put your mind more at ease, so there’ll truly be no reason to overwhelm your body with such potent concoctions”

“Thank you” hobbit sighed in relief “In the Shire we have this saying, that nature heals”

“Well, it certainly doesn’t do it for us dwarrow” Gloin chimed in “We feel better underground, or working on our craft”

“I assume you all must be in dulled spirits, then, all out in the open” Bilbo took a bite out of buttered bread

“No spirit is dull within this Company, not when we have such a mighty and honorable ordeal in front of us!” red-aired dwarf grinned

 

            Bilbo smiled, and his mouth opened to add something, but both he and Gloin were chided with the gruff words of the healer about sleep and recovery. Rushing the idle dwarrow to the beds of hay, the Company settled. Thorin saw Fili and Kili wishing to be beside him and Bilbo, but hesitating and resolutely settling beside Dwalin and Bofur. He promised to talk to Bilbo about it tomorrow. Slight confrontation was worth the beaming smiles they gave him upon hearing it, Thorin thought. It pained all three of them to see hobbit so distant.

 

“Thorin” Bilbo whispered in the dead of the night “I know you aren’t asleep”

“How?” Thorin smirked, eyes still closed “I could be sleep talking right now”

“You snore, not sleep talk” hobbit’s curls tickled his cheek “And your mouth hangs open”

“It does not” Thorin frowned

“How do you know? You’re asleep while it happens”

 

            Thorin opened his eyes, glaring at the hobbit. Bilbo was smirking back, perched up on the elbows. There was finally clarity in that storm blue gaze, and no hint of sluggishness in the tone of his voice. This Bilbo looked like he could be reasoned with.

 

“I need to talk with you” Thorin whispered “It is…it is about Fili and Kili”

 

            Bilbo’s face fell.

 

“They have been distressed at your state, and begged me to coax you into giving them a chance of mending whatever transpired”

“Nothing transpired, it’s all on me” hobbit lowered his eyes in shame “I am the one unable to handle it all”

 

            Thorin watched his face contort and become lost in deep thought. Bilbo wrung his hands, looked at the window, then, at the sleeping dwarrow. The dwarf noticed hobbit’s gaze linger at two figures of his nephews. Bilbo’s head snapped to look at him.

 

“I cannot talk here. The Company may be asleep, but their ears are not” he whispered fervently “There’s a hayloft outside, beside the barn”

“There is also a bear” Thorin deadpanned

“He will understand” Bilbo was looking desperate now “Please, Thorin”

 

            Thorin looked at the knit brows, a wrinkle forming between them. Bilbo’s eyelashes were still wet from recently shed tears, his mouth pulled into a tight line. The dwarf sighed, silently raising himself. He could never say no to his hobbit, no matter the request. And the worst part, Bilbo was aware of this particular weakness of his, and not afraid to use it.

 

“It’s a good thing you have a good heart” Thorin muttered as they sneaked out of the doors like a pair of lovesick teens “Because, if we get caught, you can make me fight the bear off with my bare hands just by looking at me so”

“Don’t jest, Thorin” a hitched whisper “Not tonight”

 

            Thorin turned to face Bilbo as he finished locking the door, and his breath caught.

            There was a pair of haunted eyes looking at him, unblinking. Bilbo’s face was a mask of unshed emotions, that were ready to burst out at any second. It was an expression Thorin saw a long time ago, painted on the last face he saw as he lost his life on the Raven Hill.

            Bilbo had the look of someone who saw the face of death.

 

 “I remember, Thorin”

“What?” Thorin’s heart skipped a beat “Remember what?”

“Everything” Bilbo continued to stare at him “You went about it all differently this time around, didn’t you?”

“Bilbo…” Thorin breathed it out like a prayer “It’s you”

“A sign from Yavanna, really?” the hobbit scoffed

 

            Thorin stared at the moonlit figure of the hobbit. His hobbit. Bilbo’s hair shone like a halo of finest mithril, true and radiant, priceless. His eyes were bottomless, and their despair terrified him.

            If Bilbo truly knew, he would remember what Thorin had done to him. He would hate him, if he doesn’t hate him already. Thorin lowered his gaze, ready to bear the judgement, the anger and the truth. He was stupid for once wishing that Bilbo would never know of his past mistakes. He was stupid, but so relieved he didn’t have to hide the ache of his guilt anymore, that a tear made its way down his cheek.

 

“I am sorry for everything I have done, Bilbo” he whispered “It may not count in this life, it all may never happen this time around, but the weight of my past deeds followed me to the Halls of my Maker. It did count for me, and it always will. Green Lady offered me a chance to fix what I had done, and I took it. Now that you know, I beg not of your forgiveness, but of willingness to see the journey through. Do not leave m- do not leave us just because of one stupid dwarf who had done you harm. You, Bilbo- I will listen, I will comply, I will wait for the wizard even if it means waiting for the next Durin’s Day! Just- please, please, Bilbo, please-”

 

            Thorin dropped to his knees, blades of hay digging into his calves and palms as he bowed like a man in front of the gallows, waiting for that sweet voice to respond to his pleas.

 

“I mourned you. I remember mourning” Bilbo hummed “And I remember…I felt guilty for thinking that, I still do, but I remember feeling sick kind of satisfaction that I was the last thing you saw as you died” the hobbit chuckled bitterly “I never confessed it to anyone, I took it to my grave, but I thought you should know”

“I hoped you would never marry” Thorin said after a moment of silence “I hoped my lips were the last lips you tasted, and the thought of you being with someone else made me sick to my stomach. I was selfish up till the end, and on after that. When ravens reached the Halls, I prayed that there was no news of the end of your bachelorhood. I would rather you be alone in mourning than happy with another…isn’t that immoral?”

“No” Bilbo shook his head “It was decided the moment I heard about dwarrow souls being split in two. I wanted to be your other half whether you acknowledged it or not, and I kept that promise to myself all my life”

 

            Thorin’s heart ached. Bilbo’s gaze was full of fury, of feelings finally allowed to burst out.

 

“You aren’t the only selfish one, Thorin Oakenshield” Bilbo said gravely “You put me on pedestal, think of me as a being of light, and not of soil. I too am sinful, prideful, arrogant and possessive. I am an earthly thing, and earthly pleasures and wishes still affect me. I wished to have you all to myself, and I still do. You hurt me, threatened me, banished me, but you know what? I still crawled back to you, because I knew I was no better”

“But-“

“I betrayed you, no matter what you continue to spew about it being for greater good, I still did it. I snarled at you, disobeyed you more times than I can count, roused the dragon, led to deaths of many innocents and destruction of Lake Town. The blood was still on my hands, and yet I played the hero at trading the thing that wasn’t mine to own. I was being named the Hero of Erebor while your body, your and your nephew’s bodies, rotted underground”

 

            Thorin shook his head. Bilbo stared on, unmoving.

 

“Do not try to tell me I had no part in the things that happened. Do not tell me that I am good, and that I did nothing wrong”

“But you are good, Bilbo” Thorin uttered “Despite everything-“

“Why can’t you tell the same things to yourself then, Thorin?” the hobbit approached him “Your only wish was to reclaim your home, to give your people the comforts they had been deprived of. You managed to start a new life in the Blue Mountains out of nothing but rags, scraps and hope. You were the hope, don’t you understand? You were the life force of sheer, bull-headed dwarrow stubbornness that drove your people forward instead towards the utter despair!”

 

            Thorin felt few more tears escape his eyelids. Bilbo’s face was soft, oh so soft. Not even the cold light of the moon could dim the warmth of the eyes that were aimed at him. The press of his lips against Thorin’s was even warmer, firmer, trying to convey the desperation and ache of ages spent waiting for this moment through the lifetimes, through the afterlife, through the time itself.

 

“Do not dare to say you aren’t worthy of love, Thorin Oakensield” Bilbo whispered, now on his knees beside Thorin “You are worthy of everything on this green earth, and everything underneath it. Every treasure, every gold vein, every flower. I still wonder how you managed to fall in love with a simple hobbit while you were…everything. Thorin, you are everything”

“You’re being a hypocrite” Thorin shook his head as Bilbo cradled him in his palms

“I am, but I am learning to accept the weight of your love. I still wonder, and I wondered for years what did do to catch your gaze before I proved myself by all those great tricks and battles…” Bilbo chuckled “We deserve each other, don’t we?”

“Mhm” Thorin nuzzled into the familiar softness of Bilbo’s shoulder “Mahal, I missed this. You don’t realize the amount of willpower it took not to ravish you there and then in the moment I saw you again at the door of your smial. I wanted to capture you in my arms and never let go”

“Would’ve scared me half to death, and I would never had joined you” Bilbo buried his nose into Thorin’s temple, breathing in the scent of vetiver and sweat “The Company will be shocked at the sight of us. There he was, Bilbo Baggins - a sweet and clueless hobbit, one hit upside the head, and he is suddenly a seasoned burglar madly in love with their king”

“Better not say anything, or younglings will try to achieve your wisdom and get concussions”

 

            Bilbo snorted, shivering as Thorin’s hands found their way underneath his shirt, tracing the shoulder blades, his spine, his sides. Dwarf’s fingers lingered on the spots where Bilbo’s birthmarks were, and his heart warmed with the sentimentality of his usually reserved beloved.

 

“You remembered them?” Bilbo smiled

“I remember everything about you, bunmel”

“Still refer to me as a beauty of all beauties?” he sighed, content “Should have seen me at hundred and thirty, then”

“I bet you were still very bonny, if you retained those chubby cheeks of yours” Thorin chuckled “Did you truly live up to that age?”

“Died at hundred and thirty-two”

“Oh” Thorin faltered “It’s truly-“

“An anomaly. Magic, to be frank” the hobbit drew back “Up till I was a hundred and eleven, I was quite good-looking for my age. A bit too good looking…as if I was preserved, you know, like the vegetables? Rumors spread, and I got tired of them. I got tired of life. I wished to go on a last adventure, to see the Lonely Mountain again, to see you. So I gave Frodo my Sting, and your mithril, barely parted with that cursed ring, picked my walking stick and went”

“I am not surprised” Thorin grinned “And did you reach me?”

“No…” Bilbo sighed, lowering his eyes in shame “The age caught up to me, and I settled in Rivendell, waddling around and going greyer and greyer by minutes, it felt. It was my Frodo who went on an adventure instead”

 

            Bilbo fiddled with Thorin’s braids, fingers tracing the patterns etched to the metal clasps.

 

“Did you know that your shirt of mithril saved the whole Middle Earth?” Bilbo smiled “It saved my nephew from being speared, saved the bearer of the…the ring”

“The ring?” Thorin muttered, the answer hiding somewhere in the crevices of his mind “What has your trinket to do with the saving of the world?”

“It was the One Ring to rule them all, it turned out” Bilbo said, spitting it out like a curse “Found it at the Goblin Caves, didn’t know what it was at first, what power it held. I thought it’s abilities were only of invisibility. Then, it started to consume me. I couldn’t stop…looking at it, admiring it, using it to hide from my troubles. Gandalf took it away from me. I was free from it, but the dark powers rose, and it needed to be destroyed. I volunteered, but was too old and corrupted by it, and my sweet boy-“

 

            There was a draw of breath, a whine, and a pair of hands clutching the front of Thorin’s tunic as Bilbo collapsed, moment of tenderness forgotten as it dawned on him.

 

“Frodo- oh, my Frodo!” Bilbo begun to weep, eyes wide, unseeing “I loved my boy to bits, how much he suffered because of me! It was I who picked the- the ring, and my sweet fauntling had to carry it all the way to Mordor! H-his parents were drowned in the Brandybuck, I knew it was Gollum’s doings be-because I was stupid enough to tell him that I am a Baggins- Thorin-“

“Bilbo, shh, shh, my sweet” Thorin cradled him close, nose burrowed in the honey curls as he tried not to weep at the sight of his love in distress

“It is all my fault!” hobbit was still unseeing, still panicked “He did it, he almost died and took Sam with him, but he did it! And Pippin and Merry- oh, the wars! Fauntlings fought in wars be-because of that stupid ring! And it was I who found it! It was me! I failed them…On every anniversary, Frodo would weep and cradle his injured shoulder, but there was no wound, no way to heal- no way I could offer comfort- and even in healing halls of Undying Lands- Frodo-“

 

            Bilbo shook his head as if it would dissipate the dark memories clouding his mind.

 

“He looks so much like you, Thorin” Bilbo’s tears left a soaked patch at the collar of Thorin’s tunic as he pulled off to look at the dwarf “He has ink black hair, a sharp nose and piercing blue eyes, just like you. His character, and his posture is so- was so- before it happened- he looked-“ he choked on saliva, heaving a labored breath “W-when I got older, my vision started to fault me, and I wept as I saw you in his blurry silhouette before my eyes focused, Thorin, my boy didn’t know what to do with me-“

“I was mad even before I went senile- after the adventure and- and you- my boy was only thing I had. And to see him grow…I deluded myself imagining he was our son growing up” Bilbo let out an ugly, deprecating laugh “How pitiful is that?! Me imagining you sitting beside me on the bench as I watched Frodo play with Sam, and thinking that if I wished hard enough, by some miracle a raven will come from Erebor and tell me you were just recuperating in sleep-“

“Bilbo…”

“Did you know I hallucinated you standing beside Frodo as I passed away in the Undying Lands?” Bilbo chuckled hysterically “I was fading in and out, no hobbit should been able to live as long as I did, and- and my boy was crying, he was so young, so sad. He was crying for me not to leave him, but I just laughed and told him that his ‘adad will be caring for him, I said, ‘boy, don’t you see him? he’s standing right beside you!’ and you were so beautiful, Thorin, I thought you finally became real, with white hair like fresh snow in the mountains…I thought at that moment ‘how this beautiful dwarf could still love such an old husk of a hobbit as me?’ but you smiled and Frodo started screaming, and the elves begun chanting the mourning songs, and I got lost again, in fever or the age-“

“And then, I was in Yavanna’s gardens, there was my ma and dad, and I was young again, but it wasn’t enough” Bilbo hiccupped “There was no Frodo, and there were no dwarrow to shake hobbits out of their stuck-up ways, and there was no you. I think I spent majority of my time drawing you, trying to have at least a piece of you with me. My parent’s tried to cheer me up, to have me talk and eat the feelings away, but nothing helped me in the long run. And my- hah! As the last resort my mother and I began to dig a hole underground to reach Mahal’s Halls”

 

            Thorin shook his head in disbelief, laughing through the tears.

 

“It was about four hobbits deep before Green Lady herself looked down on us, laughing her heart out. She wiped our dirty faces with her thumb, and told us of great news, something about tapestries and fate, I don’t remember, but I had a chance to see you again and my parents all but shoved me forwards toward her and she was laughing at us, she never stopped laughing, and her laugh was like bells-“

 

            Bilbo sniffled, burrowing in the crook of Thorin’s neck.

 

“And she whispered something about my thread being woven a bit later in the pattern, but woven nonetheless, and I awoke on the Carrock where you first embraced me, and I was speechless as my previous memories intertwined with current ones, but you looked at me then, and it all didn’t matter up until the gravity of the situation and the guilt of the past hit me…”

“And I realized what a failure I was” Bilbo whispered

 

            Thorin swallowed a lump in his throat.

 

“You and I both failed, then. And both of us are selfish, for I am glad that you returned to me, even though I will hurt you and put you through the same perils all over again. I felt so guilty keeping the unknowing Bilbo at distance, but I just couldn’t make a step forward. He wasn’t you. Not entirely. He didn’t witness me at my lowest, begging him for forgiveness at the grave I dug with my own hands, and still loved me regardless. For you I returned, Bilbo, it is for you I am ready to fight dragons and orcs and sickness. Only for you, always for you”

“Thorin” Bilbo whined, blinking through the new onslaught of tears “Oh, Thorin”

 

            Their kisses were full of bitter, salty tears. Thorin savored the taste of Bilbo on his tongue regardless, reveled in the wet warmth as their tongues met, interlocking in the strange dance only them knew the steps to. Bilbo’s soft hands latched onto whatever part of Thorin he could reach, pulling them impossibly closer, futilely trying to merge them into one being. Thorin chuckled. It was no use, for their souls have already been sewn back together a long time ago.

            Bilbo latched onto his jaw, his neck, whispering soft nothings into the darkness of the night in between the fervent kisses more to himself than to Thorin. The dwarf cradled him, gently rocking and humming an old lullaby. The hobbit pulled back, eyes hard like stone.

 

“After you live, after everyone lives, I will go to Mordor”