Chapter Text
The rest of the day was surprisingly enjoyable. Billy couldn’t believe half of the things Maxine told him, but given all the circumstances, he had no choice but to believe her… because it was all true.
She told him how Hargrove had actually left them alone after everything that happened at the Byers house, but how, eventually, getting closer to Steve led him to learn about the Upside Down and all the weird things that had happened in Hawkins.
“How did I get close to Harrington?” He needed to know how that relationship had started.
“Steve’s the best one to tell you that,” Max shrugged with a smile, making Billy roll his eyes yet again.
She went on to explain how it had taken him a long time to apologize for being an asshole, but once he stopped harassing her, he never did it again. How he protected her when things got bad at home with Neil and Susan. How it had been Billy’s idea that they coordinate whenever they wanted to go out so they could lie to their parents; but that they could never lie to each other.
Despite the conflicting emotions, Hargrove felt satisfied knowing he had grown closer to Max and become someone she genuinely trusted. He could see that Max had suffered just as much as he had with all those changes, before and after Hawkins. “Once your dad made up this fake-ass happy-family trip and we didn’t want to go. I’d already planned to hang out with El, and you were going to do whatever with Steve, Jonathan, Nancy, and Robin,” she said, laughing. “We agreed I’d pretend to be sick and you’d promise to take care of me. My mom, who trusted you by then, didn’t argue at all. Your dad complained like hell, but in the end, he bought it.” Her eyes were full of nostalgia. “It was one of the best weekends I can remember. By the end of the night, everyone watched Return of the Jedi at Steve’s place before heading home, and on the way back… it was the first time you told me you didn’t hate Hawkins anymore.”
Hargrove felt almost like a complete stranger listening to that story. It sounded possible, but he couldn’t feel himself inside it; as if something was missing. Hating that shitty town was one of the few certainties he’d ever had in life, just like the certainty that he’d go back to California the moment he got the chance, and the certainty that he’d die young.
The photographs on the walls, Maxine’s words, and the pained look in Steve Harrington’s eyes screamed in his face that none of those certainties meant a damn thing anymore.
Who was Billy Hargrove?
Who could he… be?
The hours passed. Hargrove had taken off his swim trunks and was now wearing the first pair of jeans he found and a basketball jersey. The conversation drifted to other topics.
Max didn’t live far from them, still in the same region of California. She worked as a design manager at a company that made skateboards and other extreme sports gear. She was still dating Lucas, even though they’d gone to college in different places and spent some time apart. At some point, they started drinking beers, even as Max insisted that Billy’s favorite drink now was cognac.
“Am I, by any chance, an old gay snob?”
“Yes, Billy, you literally are an old gay snob.”
“Go fuck yourself, Maxine!”
The siblings were laughing in the living room, their beers now warm in their hands, when the front door opened to reveal Steve Harrington, looking exhausted behind his glasses, carrying his teacher’s bag.
“Max!” He smiled before dropping his things on the nearest table and rushing over to hug her.
Billy didn’t know whether he felt happy or uncomfortable witnessing such an affectionate moment.
“How are you? Did you have trouble leaving work early to come here?”
“I’m fine, Mom,” she teased, making Steve laugh as he shook his head, his hands settling on his hips. “Relax, you know they need me. And I was already planning on taking a few days off anyway… Oh, I managed to talk to Will and Jonathan, like you asked!”
Steve’s face lit up.
“Can they come?”
“Yes, they’ll be here tomorrow!”
“Great! The more help, the better!” He clasped his hands in front of his chest, hopeful. Then his gaze fell on Hargrove, who met it with intense blue eyes. “Any… signs of improvement? Did he remember… anything?” He was still speaking to Max.
“Do you think ignoring me helps at all in this fucked-up situation, Harrington?” Hargrove snapped. He didn’t like the way Steve came in and didn’t address him with only that look of hurt and disappointment cut into him, making his chest ache.
“As you can see, no,” Max clicked her tongue, finishing her warm beer. “But I explained enough and brought up important memories from our relationship.”
“About me and h-”
“I didn’t say anything, like you asked.”
Steve nodded.
“Are you staying for dinner, Max? I’m making beef ribs with smashed potatoes, and there’s cheesecake in the fridge.”
“I’d love to, Stevie, but Lucas is waiting for me. We planned this dinner weeks ago.” She brushed Harrington’s arm, guilt flickering across her face. “But I’ll be back tomorrow when Jonathan and Will get here. And I’ll bring my photo albums!”
“Perfect. We’ll be waiting.” Steve’s reply was almost automatic, the same tone he used when he and Billy, together as a couple, were expecting friends.
They exchanged glances, and it was still strange. Billy noticed how shaken Steve remained.
“I-I’ll let you two say goodbye. Thanks for coming, Max.” He hugged her one last time before retreating toward the kitchen to start making dinner.
Billy felt awful; an intruder, an invader in his own life. He’d felt that way all day, but Steve’s presence, his looks and gestures, made it worse. He sighed.
Hargrove and Max walked to the front door when she touched his shoulder.
“Can I… give you some advice?” She had that sharp look from earlier. Billy almost rolled his eyes but held back. “You can follow it or not. It depends on what kind of outcome you want from all this.”
“Spit it out, Maxine.”
“Go easy on him.” Her expression softened, but her certainty remained. “Since you two got close, you became each other’s anchor. For Steve… it’s like he’s lost that now. He might act or say things that you find odd or don’t like, but if you want this to really work, if you want your memories back, you need to be willing to let it happen. Do you get what I’m saying?”
“Yeah…” He sighed. “I’ll try my best.” He smiled, running his tongue over his lips.
“I’m not so sure that’s a good thing…” Max frowned.
“Relax, Maxine. Literally, I don’t have any other options.” He shrugged and opened the door. “See your ugly face tomorrow, when the freaks get here.”
“You’re a freak too, you fucking asshole!”
“Sure. Whatever. Later, redhead.”
