Actions

Work Header

hargrove paradox

Chapter 5: a flavor of memory

Notes:

hellooooooo!!
this is one of my favorite chapters!
get ready for the angst!! (⁠ᗒ⁠ᗩ⁠ᗕ⁠)
hope you enjoy ♡ sorry for any mistake!! ♡⁠(⁠˃͈⁠ ⁠દ⁠ ⁠˂͈⁠ ⁠༶⁠ ⁠)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

When Billy stepped into the kitchen, the smell of roasted beef ribs already filled the air. Steve was wearing a white apron with little yellow flowers, his glasses off and had a dish towel draped over his shoulder, frying asparagus to serve as a side.

Hargrove replayed Maxine’s words in his head and knew he had to try. Still, he remained irritated by the fact that Steve couldn’t see his side of things. He was still Billy… maybe not the perfect version, not the one who was Steve’s boyfriend, his anchor; but he was still Billy Hargrove.

Harrington was mourning him, and he was right there. Very much alive.

“Do you… want me to set the table?” He tried to be proactive, maybe it was something the improved Billy always did.

Steve looked at him, a little surprised, then turned his attention back to the stove.

“Yes… uh… the plates are in that cabinet, the glasses are next to them.” He pointed as he spoke. “You can pick the wine from the cellar.”

Hargrove started setting the table. Everything was fine until that point; except he didn’t know a damn thing about wine. When he opened the cellar and saw more than twenty bottles, he felt lost and frustrated. He thought about it for a moment and grabbed the one that looked the oldest and most expensive.

When he came back, the food was already served. Roasted beef ribs with mashed potatoes and asparagus. The smell was simply divine. Billy’s stomach growled; he’d spent the entire day living on cereal and beer.

He placed the bottle on the table, and before he could sit down, he heard a soft laugh escape Steve’s lips.

“What’s so funny, Harrington?” He stared at him seriously, offended, but also worried he’d screwed something up.

“Sorry…” Steve picked up the bottle and chuckled quietly again. “That’s the most expensive wine we have. It’s the one we drank the night you told me about your promotion, to celebrate…” It was impossible to deny the affection spilling from Harrington’s gaze; his fingers traced the label as if the memory were taking shape right in front of him.

“Do you want me to swap it?”

“I-I’ll do it,” Steve said, his voice slightly thick, but he quickly cleared his throat, heading back to the cellar and returning a few minutes later. “You like this one too.” He poured Billy’s glass, then his own, and finally sat down to eat.

Dinner went by in silence at first; mostly because the food was excellent and Hargrove was starving. The wine wasn’t bad, but he definitely preferred beer. Steve’s gaze stayed lowered and distant, clearly chewing over his sense of loss.

Billy couldn’t take it anymore.

“So…” He tried to follow Max’s advice and not give in to his aggressive tendencies. “Before you left for work, you said you’d tell me how this happened.” He gestured vaguely between them, watching Harrington take a sip from his glass that seemed heavy in his throat.

“Yes… our story.” Steve gave a small smile and took another sip; longer this time. He closed his eyes, set the glass back down, and took a deep breath before continuing.

“You didn’t bother the kids anymore after that night at the Byers house. With me… it wasn’t exactly like that.”

He ran a hand through his now-short hair and rested his chin in his palm.

“You still provoked me at school, especially during basketball practice. I managed to ignore it. I was about to graduate and… eventually, your teasing worked. I wanted to prove you wrong, to prove I could be better than you at basketball. So I started staying after practice to train on my own. Until you found out about it.”

Billy’s ocean-blue eyes were locked on Steve, absorbing every word, careful not to miss a single detail.

“You messed with me… like always, but you said you wanted to win the championship that year and that you’d help me; really help me, get better. So even though you threw jabs every time you saw me in the hallways, you were there, training with me after everyone else had gone home.”

“I bet I was a damn good coach,” Billy said with a grin, running his tongue over his lower lip.

Steve rolled his eyes, shaking his head, but smiled genuinely.

“You were. We won the championship.”

He topped off his glass and took another sip.

“We’d already grown close during the training. I’d realized that even if you were an asshole, you weren’t the worst person in the world, and… I liked your company, even though it was still confusing to me back then…”

Harrington’s fingertips toyed with the rim of his glass; his voice grew shy.

“So… I invited you over to my place a few times. We’d listen to music, talk shit, drink beer. I don’t know if that was the moment when you stopped hating me…” Steve let out a humorless laugh, his shoulders shaking a little.

“Then one night at a party at Tina's house, we got really drunk. Like… really drunk. We probably smoked weed too. That night… I noticed the way you looked at me, and… I thought it might mean something.”

Steve lifted the glass and drained the last of the wine.

“When we were alone, in a corner of the garden, I kissed you… and you kissed me back… B-But when we heard someone coming, you shoved me, knocked me to the ground, and… left. And you… You didn’t talk to me for the rest of the year.”

Harrington’s doe eyes were glassy now, his breathing heavy, fingers restless as they fidgeted with the base of the empty glass. Billy didn’t know how to react; his pulse raced, his mouth went dry.

“I’m sorry, I-it’s just…” Steve took a deep breath and closed his eyes, letting a single tear fall. “I was so alone back then… Having your friendship and then losing you was… it was awful. I blamed myself for… falling in love with you.”

Harrington's gaze stayed low, unable to look Billy in the eye, as if he expected judgment or something worse.

“For a long time, I thought it would’ve been better if I’d done nothing, if I’d ignored those feelings completely.” He breathed in again, tears rolling freely now, still unable to face Hargrove's ocean eyes. “Then… one night you showed up at my house… y-you told me Neil had beaten you up…”

The words came out in a whisper, making Billy’s blood run cold, his hands curling into fists on the table.

“Y-Your white shirt was stained with blood, your face swollen and cut, and your ribs hurt. I wanted to take you to the hospital, to the police, to Hopper, but you didn’t want any of that… Y-You… you just wanted to stay with me.”

For a moment, Billy remembered.

The metallic taste of blood in his mouth. Steve’s doe eyes, frightened, worried. Harrington’s hands were gentle, even as they trembled while touching his injuries.

“I just want to stay with you, pretty boy. I never should’ve left you alone.”

The memory dissolved like smoke when Steve stood up from the dinner table and, his voice choked with tears, said:

“I-I’m sorry… I can’t do this anymore today.”

“Harrington.”

Steve went upstairs in a rush without looking back. Hargrove remained at the table, his wine glass half full, his gaze lost and his head beginning to ache.

Notes:

what did you think about the memory Steve shared? and the memory Billy remembered? (⁠ ⁠T⁠_⁠T⁠)⁠\⁠(⁠^⁠-⁠^⁠ ⁠)
i’d love to read your thoughts and reply with lots of love!!(⁠≧⁠▽⁠≦⁠)
see you in the next chapter!!(⁠ ⁠ꈍ⁠ᴗ⁠ꈍ⁠)