Actions

Work Header

the passing of mysteries

Chapter 27: on the precipice

Chapter Text

 

         Thorin looked up from the report spread out on the table to see Gandalf and Maedhros duck into the tent where Thorin had settled into. The loss of the Silmaril had hit the encampment hard, causing unrest throughout all who had gathered on Thorin's front lawn. The wizards had spent much of the rest of the day – and some of the night – going up and down the hallway of the Royal Wing, muttering and doing whatever business wizards did in the world. Thorin had requested that Gandalf do most of the warding about Thorin and Dwalin's rooms while the other wizards, save Radagast, did the rest. He knew Saruman had a bit of stink about it but Thorin didn't much care. He trusted exactly one of those wizards and Gandalf was it. Thankfully Gandalf had agreed and the protections about their rooms and door were laid double quick.

         “How goes the search of the camp?” Thorin said as he looked back down at the report. He had come out to the tents to be with the rest of the encampment, so that no one could accuse him of hiding inside his mountain or hording the Silmaril. There had already been mutterings of that going about the tents of the men, though not with the Rangers, Nori had whispered to him on his walk outside. Thorin had left Dwalin in their rooms once more, though he knew Dwalin hated the idea of it, unwilling to allow the Silmaril to be left alone for a minute. If Dwalin was not there then Thorin would be, until whatever strangeness that had settled on the world came to an end.

         “Slow,” Gandalf's tone was grim. He sat with a sigh in a chair opposite Thorin, looking a bit wan and pale. “Lord Ecthelion II is refusing to allow anyone but his own people to search their tents.”

         Thorin frowned at that, sitting back as he glanced between the wizard and the elf. “We have already said we do not believe a man could do such damage to the throne by themselves,” Thorin pointed out. “A search is to make sure no one – or no strange power – is attempting to set us upon one another.”

         “And that is the issue,” Gandalf shook his head, his mouth twisted down into a frown. “Lord Ecthelion II claims that by insisting to search their tents with your people – or even by my Order – is claiming that there is already division among our ranks.”

         Thorin had to pause there, because Lord Ecthelion II did have a point. “There is some legitimacy to that.”

         “Is there?” Maedhros raised an eyebrow at him. “Ecthelion of the Fountain and I have already allowed our tents to be searched, both by your own people and by Lord Ecthelion II's people. Thranduil is allowing his people's tents to be searched but only by Bard's small contingent with your King's Guard watching on.” He smiled a bit. “I am told that your nephew Kíli is helping them.”

         Thorin slid the palm of his hand down his face with a noisy sigh. “You mean he's too busy mooning at that elf of his to do more than glance at the tents they pass.”

         Maedhros' smile was small but true. “He does seem rather...enthusiastic when Tauriel is near.”

         Thorin closed his eyes against that. “You mean he's showing off and being an idiot.”

         “Perhaps,” laughter was thick in Maedhros' voice at the word. “Is it so wrong? He clearly...cares for her.”

         Thorin made a face at the thought of what nonsense was going to come out of Thranduil's mouth in the coming days. “I have no objection to my nephew's choice in partners. I worry,” he slanted a long look at the still-smiling elf. “That their ages might be a problem, and that Tauriel may be hesitant to accept Kíli's suit, considering...”

         “Yes,” Maedhros' smile faded at that. “There is that.”

         “But,” Gandalf said as he got his pipe out and began to light it. “You have not considered a very pertinent fact.”

         “And that is?” Thorin raised his eyebrows at the wizard.

         Gandalf leaned back as he puffed out a series of large smoke circles, each bigger than the last. The final circle was...strange, not perfectly round, but flat on the bottom, looking almost like a door. “If the Healing of Arda is truly upon us,” the wizard said as that final smoke circle began to wisp away. “Then we do not know what that shall do to all who live on these far shores.”

         Thorin glanced at Maedhros but the elf looked as confused as Thorin felt. “What do you mean?”

         Gandalf tapped the stem of his pipe against his lips, his eyes focused on some far distant point. “I do not have clear memories of the Timeless Halls,” he began. Thorin curled his fingers into a loose fist on the table. He had known, of course, that Gandalf was no mere mortal man, and Eönwë's presence in Arda had confirmed that. But to hear that Gandalf was...that he was...

         “The Song that Eru Ilúvatar showed all of the spirits in His Halls was a creation I cannot explain.” Gandalf puffed out a series of strange shapes that made Thorin's eyes cross when he tried to focus on them. “In the beginning...” A strange smile tugged at Gandalf's mouth as he shook his head. “In the beginning,” he continued, “we did not sing as a chorus as we later did. We sang one by one, or rarely two together, while all listened and hearkened to the Song that only Eru alone knew. But bit by bit, as we listened to the songs of our brethren, we began to...see a vision that was given to us by Eru Himself.”

         As the wizard spoke more and more figures began to slip into the tent. There was Lord Elrond, followed by the Lady Galadriel, along with Balin and Master Erestor right behind him. Following the slight elf came the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion, who took seats on either side of Erestor, placing themselves between Lord Elrond's councilor and Maedhros. Thorin had to bite down on his cheek to keep from smiling at the sight.

         “Eru Ilúvatar then declared to us a mighty Theme,” Gandalf said as silence settled over the table. Thorin saw Prince Thengel and Lord Ecthelion II slip in, alongside Bard and Thranduil, taking their own seats at the table. “He sang to us,” Gandalf's voice dipped into a murmur, his eyes glowing in the light of the crystals that Thorin had brought out for the tents. The iron fire pits held banked coals in the corners of the room, pushing away the growing cold of the winter days. It was two days to Yule and it was starting to feel like it at last. “The Song He sang unfolded before us as a great vision, one that grew and grew in our minds until we could comprehend it no more. It was after such a song that Eru Ilúvatar had us join in to that great Song, adorning His theme with our powers and delight.” His smile faded. “It was in that chorus of voices that Morgoth – then Melkor – began to sow discord and dissent among the Ainur, trying to take over the theme and ruin the Vision that had been laid out before us.”

         Gandalf seemed to give himself a shake and his gaze swept over those who had gathered in the tent. “I tell you this, because never before had such a Song been sung in the Timeless Halls and never since. But.” His gaze swept over them again and it made something shiver down Thorin's spine when that gaze settled onto him. “It has been said that a greater music shall be made by the choirs of the Ainur and the Children of Ilúvatar after the end of days.” He puffed on his pipe for a moment. Then, “Should that day come. And what happens after that day, to the length of the lives of those who live on Arda's shores as compared to the Eldar, we do not know. But first,” Gandalf blew out another smoke ring. “Morgoth must be defeated.”

         “I was of the impression that Morgoth's defeat had been foreseen by Eru Ilúvatar Himself,” Lady Galadriel said into the silence left by Gandalf's words.

         “Was it from Melian that you heard such words?” Saruman's said as he ducked into the tent. He stared down his nose at the full table, a twist of distaste to his mouth present until Balin had someone bring in another seat. The wizard settled himself near one of the banked fire pits, something Thorin had noted that the wizard often did.

         “The Lady did speak to me of such things, yes,” Lady Galadriel said.

         Saruman made a huffing sound as he drew out his own pipe and lit it with a taper thrust into the coals. It scraped back some of the ash, leaving the red-hot coals exposed like a gleaming red eye in the corner. “She would do such a thing,” the wizard grumbled as he began to puff out his own smoke rings.

         “She is not wrong,” Gandalf said.

         “She is also not right,” Saruman pointed his pipe at the other wizard. “Morgoth's defeat was prophesied, as Lord Eönwë has said. But,” he thrust the stem of his pipe at Gandalf. “That prophecy is now defunct.”

         “It is,” said the herald of Manwë himself. Eönwë held up a hand as many made to stand at his appearance. He took the seat that Erestor offered with a bow. The elf stepped back to stand against the edge of the tent, his papers clutched close to his chest. Thorin noted the way both lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion went tense as Erestor left them.

         Interesting.

         All eyes had turned to Eönwë. “As I said when we arrived,” he glanced at Ecthelion next to him and then to Maedhros, “the Song has changed. The protections about Aman are almost completely broken.” Murmurs rose up around him. “Late last night I received message from my Lord Manwë that very soon the realm of Valinor will return to the world that Is and what happens after that...” Eönwë shook his head, small lines appearing about his mouth and eyes. “We do not know. Already there are reports of great waves starting to wash upon the western shores of Arda.”

         “It is true,” Lord Ecthelion II sat forward then. There were dark smudges under his eyes. “We received word that Gondor's ports are being broken down by these waves and that the trade ships are having problems finding safe ports to dock in.” He shared a look with Prince Thengel that Thorin could not read. “The winter grains that Gondor imports have taken a large loss, both by the destruction of the Shire and now with issue of the ships being unable to unload.” His expression turned grim. “There is already talk of possible rations until the summer crops come in.”

         “My father is planning to send Riders to help with guiding and protecting the overland caravans from the southlands to Gondor,” Prince Thengel spoke up then. “But the way is long and there is much spoilage in the trip. More so should that grain make its way to Rohan. And that is saying nothing of possible attacks from bandits or hungry villagers that they pass.”

         Thorin curled his hand into a fist in his lap. He could almost see the divide starting to form around the table.

         “And the search for the Silmaril?” Saruman said from his spot near the brazier. Thorin saw how several of the lords went stiff at his words.

         “It is still missing,” Thorin said, forcing his hand to relax in his lap. He placed it on the table, palm flat, as he swept a look over the gathered lords and lady. “All of the encampment has been searched. I thank you for your patience and your cooperation,” he gave the lords Ecthelion II and Thengel a half-bow from his seat. He was pleased to see some of the tension leave them at that.

         “Someone in this encampment stole the Silmaril,” Saruman snapped, thrusting the stem of his pipe at Thorin. “The fact that you cannot find them concerns me. Especially since you still have possession of the second.”

         Thorin took in a slow breath, keeping a firm hold on his temper. “I am aware,” he said, tone as dry as dust. “Since you have pointed out that fact many times in as many hours.”

         Saruman let out a loud huff as he went back to puffing on his pipe. His dark brows were drawn down into a fearsome scowl.

         “And we will find the Arkenstone,” Thorin continued, keeping his gaze on Saruman. He saw the way the wizard's mouth drew down even further. It was a wonder he even managed to smoke his pipe with a scowl like that on his face. Then Thorin transferred his attention back to Eönwë. “You say that great waves are breaking against the shores of Arda,” he said. The herald of Manwë nodded. “What will happen when all of Valinor returns to this world?”

         “That,” Eönwë said with a grave expression. “Is something we do not know. Perhaps nothing. Perhaps more of the same. And perhaps...”

         “A great wave,” the young Aragorn said from his seat by the door. He had been one of the last men to arrive, slipping in without a word said to anyone. His eyes were shadowed as he glanced about the table.

         “Perhaps,” Eönwë sighed. “We can only hope that Lord Ulmo will help calm the seas should that happen.”

         Mention of that Vala made Thorin think back to his own time in the waters under the mountain. “Would the Lady Uinen help as well?”

         Eönwë looked at him. “All of those who serve Lord Ulmo would do as he asked.”

         Thorin frowned down at his hand, tapping his fingers against the table. “Would...would the Silmaril that was returned to us, the one from the waters,” he looked up at Eönwë. “Would it be best to take it to the shores and see if it would help against the waves that are breaking now and that which might come in the future?”

         That caused more than one murmur to ripple around the table. Even Eönwë looked shocked at his words. “I do not know,” Eönwë said and glanced at Maedhros.

         “The Silmarils are not mere toys to be played with,” Saruman spat as he sat up in his chair. The brazier next to him seemed to glow brighter with his anger. “They are not to be waved about at the seas like some kind of tool!”

         “Then why are they here?” Lord Ecthelion II frowned back at the wizard. “Surely they can help us!”

         “They are to be kept safe!” Saruman's grip about his pipe was so tight his knuckles had bleached white.

         “Safe for what?” Lord Ecthelion II shook his head. “Things are changing.” He nodded to Eönwë. “The very herald of Manwë has told us so. Two of the three Silmarils have returned to Arda. Surely this is a sign from the Valar that they are to be used?”

         “Then Lord Manwë would say as much!” Saruman shook his head. “They should have been given to me – to the wizards and to Lord Eönwë the second we realized what the stone in that throne was and when King Thorin returned with a second from the depths of his mountain.”

         “To what purpose?” Lord Ecthelion II pressed. “To be kept safe? Fine. But safe for what? To what purpose would you use them?”

         “For what might come!” Saruman surged to his feet. Thorin blinked at how the fire behind him flickered back into active flame. “I fear we are perilously close to the breaking of the world,” Saruman's dark gaze swept across the table. “The Silmarils have long been thought to be the tools with which the world is then healed after the great battle that was to take place. But that, too, is changing. The prophecy of Mandos is no more. But the Silmarils have still come, so therefore,” his gaze went back to Lord Ecthelion II. “They still have some role to play in what might come. And to whose use they should come under,” he shook his head. “That is yet to be seen.”

         “I agree with you, that the Silmarils have some part to play in what might come,” Eönwë said after a moment. All eyes swung to him. “But fearing that they might be used by Morgoth to achieve his own plans, and thus hidden away, would defeat the purpose of having them here.”

         Saruman scoffed at that, turning away. “You think he would plan for such a thing? That my – my own wisdom is not enough to account for such a thing and then dismiss it? No.” He shook his head. “I fear that Morgoth's hooks are not just in these holy gems but also in the people here on Arda.” His shoulders slumped and he sank back down into his seat. “The shadow of Morgoth's evil has ever been long. His mark has been left on this world whether we like it or not. It cannot be erased until that evil spirit is gone for good.”

         “Well,” said Gandalf as he lowered his own pipe. Thorin had noted the way Gandalf's gaze had not left Saruman for a minute. “I would argue that point, old friend.”

         Saruman's head came up. “What point?”

         Gandalf lowered his pipe. “Have you not felt it?”

         Thorin saw the way Saruman shifted back in his seat, frowning back at the other wizard. “Felt what?”

         Gandalf looked at the Lady Galadriel, who nodded, then at Eönwë, who frowned at him, tilting his head to one side. “Lady Galadriel said it best. That the air has become clearer, the waters sweeter, but only here, at Erebor.” Gandalf looked back at Saruman. “Morgoth's shadow has been seen, yes, but it is fighting something, I believe. Something that is pressing back against that darkness and corruption that Morgoth left on the world and...fixing it.”

         “Fixing it?” Saruman snorted, turning his face away. “What nonsense. There is no fixing it. Only Eru Ilúvatar can do such a thing. To imply otherwise is blasphemy.”

         “Blasphemy,” Gandalf murmured, pressing his lips together for a moment. “You know that He would not care for such words, old friend. Have a care for how you speak.”

         Saruman's shoulders came up about his ears. His arms were folded across his chest. “I am a creature of order,” he said, still not meeting the other wizard's gaze. “I understand patterns, how things work. None of this makes sense and you are ready to go haring off on strange half-baked ideas that sound more like something Radagast would think up in the depths of one of his mushroom-induced dream states!”

         Small lines seemed to ease about Gandalf's eyes and mouth at that. “I know how you desire for the world to make sense, to be orderly and methodical. But I am afraid that is not how the world works.”

         “It should work like that,” Saruman muttered, still curled in about himself.

         “Saruman,” Gandalf sighed, leaning forward to place a hand on Saruman's knee. The other wizard moved away from his touch. A look of sadness passed over Gandalf's face, there and gone, as he leaned back in his chair. “How can we make this easier for you, my friend? You placed your own protections about the hallways that lead to the Royal Wing. What else can be done to ease your worry? And perhaps,” Gandalf cast a glance about the table. “The worries of the others here?”

         Thorin followed that gaze, taking note of the signs of concern on many of the men's faces.

         Saruman's sigh drew Thorin's attention once more. “I would have King Thorin show me more of the mountain. If you can,” the wizard added on, his arms dropping from his middle. “You can explain your theory of some strange spirits fixing things to the others while I go do something productive,” he sniffed at that. Gandalf rolled his eyes at the other wizard, but the look he turned on Thorin was a touch pleading.

         “King Thorin, would you be willing to do that for Saruman?”

         Thorin did not want to leave the tent. Thorin wanted to hear about Gandalf's theory and how it possibly pertained to the spirits Thorin was increasingly convinced were inside Erebor. But he also knew that there was a delicate line he needed to walk here. The men were already staring at him with suspicious eyes. He could not risk more distrust being sown here.

         “I will take you were it is safe,” Thorin said with a nod. He caught Balin's eye and his old friend gave him a strained smile. He knew Balin would tell him all that Thorin would miss as he played a glorified guide to a wizard he would rather boot in the rear.

         “I wish to see all of the mountain,” Saruman said with a huff as he stood. Thorin stood as well, hating how the wizard towered over him.

         “All of the mountain you cannot see,” Thorin held onto his patience with both hands. “The mountain is not completely safe for even my people as I have said. Multiple times,” he pinned the wizard with a look. “But I can take you were it is safe, and there are more places than you have yet seen that can be examined. Would that work?”

         “If it must,” Saruman said as he all but flounced from the room.

         “Thank you, King Thorin,” Gandalf said as Thorin passed him.

         “You owe me,” Thorin muttered at the wizard, just low enough for the two of them alone. And perhaps the elves.

         “As you say,” Gandalf's smile was far more amused than it should be. “I will speak to you later of my theories, should you wish,” he added, his smile turning gentle.

         “That would be most welcome,” Thorin said.

         “King Thorin!” Saruman's called from outside the tent.

         “Yes, coming,” Thorin gave Gandalf one more look and then stepped through the tent door to find Saruman already stalking towards Erebor's gates. His shadow seemed to stretch back almost to Thorin's feet but the sun was setting and the mountain's own shadow was starting to loom large over the encampment as well.

         Thorin did not jog to catch up to the wizard. He was pleased to see how the guards at the gates kept Saruman in place until Thorin could reach his side, smiling up at the wizard as Saruman huffed and puffed and leaned on his staff as he glared at the guards. “This way,” he told Saruman as he gave the guards a nod and stepped ahead of the wizard and into the darkness of the mountain beyond.

         In Thorin's youth the entrance to Erebor was once full of light and busy with people at almost every moment of the day and night. There were visitors from Dale and beyond, along with traders coming in from most of the known world. At times there had even been envoys from the southlands, places like Harad and Rhûn, though they had been few and far between. The main gates opened up to a grand hall that had suffered much damage when the dragon came. The tall statues of their forefathers had been cracked in half at some point, with the one on the right missing its head completely. They still had not found it.

         The granite floors had once been polished so fine that they would reflect the light of the torches that illuminated the hall. The thick pillars that held up the ceiling far above their heads had also been damaged by Smaug's arrival, which had led to the iron bars being fastened to the most obviously broken areas. Both Bofur and Bifur had agreed that the central supports of those thick pillars had not been damaged and that most of what was seen was cosmetic, but they preferred to err on the side of caution. Thorin had gotten word that all of their artisan's clans would be arriving in the weeks following Yule, so perhaps more repairs to their mountain could be had sooner rather than later.

         But, as Thorin walked with the wizard through the quiet hall, Thorin had to admit that the pillars were looking far better than Thorin remembered. The thick cracks in the stone almost seemed to have...not vanished, exactly, but gotten smaller, thinner, as if they were disappearing.

         Or being fixed.

         Thorin let out a breath at that, pushing the thought away for now. As they walked deeper into the hall, the crystal lights began to spark to life, their glow catching on the gold inlays set into those towering pillars and bringing the details of those reliefs to life. Thorin avoided the deep gouges that Smaug's claws had carved into the granite floors as he led the wizard past the pillars and into the central chamber of Erebor.

         “Most of this floor is damaged to some degree, but many of the support pillars are still holding.” Thorin pointed to the arching pathways and the stairs that used to crisscross the deep cavern before them. “All of these are suspect and a few, as you can see, are destroyed. I cannot take you on them.”

         “I see,” Saruman's voice was deeper than Thorin had heard it before. He stepped up next to Thorin on the edge of the chasm, his staff planted before him as he glanced down. “And below us?”

         Thorin followed his gaze. “The mountain has many levels,” he said, able to pick out old hallways that lay in the shadows. “Many made their homes above and below this central chamber.”

         “And what was this chamber used for?”

         Thorin glanced up at the wizard, a little surprised at how interested Saruman sounded. “Food,” he said after a brief pause. He pointed to the ledges that lined the southern edge of the chamber and then over to the smaller areas on the east and western sides. “Great mirrors were set up when the mountain was first inhabited to allow more light into this area.”

         “So this was natural?” Saruman squinted at the areas Thorin had pointed out.

         “This chamber?” Thorin saw Saruman nod. “Yes.”

         “How interesting,” Saruman muttered, leaning forward on his staff. Thorin put a hand on the wizard's arm, which earned him a sharp look.

         “There are no handrails,” Thorin said. “And the fall is steep.”

         “A wizard has many abilities. Such a fall would hurt but I would survive such a thing.” But the wizard did lean back – and away – from the edge of the chasm. “Do you know how this mountain was formed?”

         “Originally? No,” Thorin gestured to the left, leading the wizard away from the main hall that came from the gates. “It was suspected that it was a volcano, once.”

         “A volcano,” Saruman echoed. “How interesting.” Thorin frowned at that but Saruman did not seem to notice. His gaze was for the central chasm and the bridges and stairs built over it. “Are you quite sure of this?”

         Thorin paused, not wanting to impart more lore of the mountain to the wizard but Saruman was a member of the same Order as Gandalf. Surely it could not hurt. “It was said that when our people first came here, there was still a glow at the very depths of the mountain.” He stopped at a ledge where they could step out onto a point, looking out over the chamber. The light of the sunset was barely making it into the mountain, the huge mirrors still too dusty and grimy from smoke and soot from the dragon to reflect much at the moment, if they were still intact. They were yet one more thing on the long list of things that Thorin needed to have his people check on, clean, or repair in the mountain. He swept a hand over the cavern below them. From their vantage point the pit seemed bottomless. “Here is where our first king of Erebor stood and looked below and beheld that glow,” he said.

         “Was it still warm? Was that recorded at all?”

         Thorin blinked at the question. “It was warm,” he said, glancing up at the wizard. “The chamber stayed warm for many centuries. It was said that warmth helped the gardens carved into this chamber grow and feed our people, until we could fashion another system that made up for the heart of the mountain going cool.”

         “How fascinating,” Saruman stroked his beard, his dark eyes shadowed in the dim light of the chamber. “And was this heat in the belly of your mountain...used for anything?”

         Thorin had to think about that. “As in a smithy?”

         “Yes.”

         “No,” Thorin shook his head. “It was considered sacred, a sign from our Maker. We would not use it in such a fashion.”

         “I see,” Saruman stroked his beard again, but there was a thoughtful tilt to his mouth that Thorin had never seen before. “And this Bilbo Baggins,” the wizard's words made Thorin want to shiver but he didn't know why. “You have seen him before in this very same chamber?”

         Thorin peered up at the wizard. “You heard about that?”

         “I did.”

         Thorin waited but the wizard would not meet his gaze, staring down into the darkness as if it alone held all the answers. “I did see Bilbo here,” Thorin said slowly, watching the wizard's face. “I was with my cousin Dáin and several others. They all saw him.” And someone tried to kill him, Thorin did not say.

         “Here, above the chasm? Hanging like a specter?”

         “No,” Thorin could not make out why the wizard was so intent on this. “He stood there,” Thorin pointed up at one of the walkways.

         Saruman drew himself up, his hand dropping to his side. “I want to go up there.”

         “You cannot,” Thorin was quick to say.

         “And why not?”

         “All the ramps leading to that area are damaged,” Thorin held onto his patience with all his might. He pointed to the right, where the ramp led down to an area that was almost completely destroyed, with only the bare metal rods that had once held up the sides of the ramp were exposed. “The stone will crumble under my feet, much less yours.”

         “Then we can get to it from above!”

         “Again,” Thorin drew in a slow breath. “The ramps above are just as damaged.” His finger moved to the gaping hole in the stairways and ramps that once crisscrossed the space like the most delicate of lace. “It looks as though the dragon tried to fly out of the central chamber at least once and could not. But his attempt left the walkways broken beyond our current ability to repair.”

         Saruman's staff thumped against the ground, sounding strangely hollow. “Nonsense. There must be a way to get there.”

         Thorin frowned up at the wizard. “Why are you so intent to see the area? The balcony above the gates is a place that Bilbo was seen as well.”

         That got the wizard's attention. “Was he, now?”

         “Yes,” Thorin tried to see just what Saruman's interest in Bilbo was but he could not make it out. “Would you like to see that instead?”

         “Yes. Show me.”

         Thorin raised his eyebrows at that.

         The wizard huffed, dark brows drawn together in a scowl. “Please.”

         Thorin left his eyebrows up as he turned and led Saruman away from the central cavern. He kept quiet the entire walk, not about to be pleasant to a wizard who refused to use basic courtesies when even the most wild of his Order did. At least Radagast said please and thank you. Most of the time.

         The wind was biting as Thorin led the wizard out into the twilight-lit balcony. The sun was setting fast this close to Yule, the dark stretch of the mountain's shadow reaching out over the land. Thorin tugged his jacket closed as the wind came screaming past him, blowing his hair in his face and making his raise his hands to shield his eyes. Saruman strode forward, his dark hair waving like a banner, his robes flapping about his body. The bulk of that heavy fabric made his silhouette strange for a moment, outlining not a man but some strange mass that looked like a man with perhaps too many limbs. Then Thorin blinked and he could see how the wizard was wearing possibly every single robe he had, plus perhaps thick woolen trousers underneath it all. Thorin could only guess that the wizard felt the cold more keenly than his brethren, which would explain why he was forever haunting the braziers in the tents and elsewhere.

         “The hobbit was here?” Saruman's words could barely be heard over the scream of the wind.

         “Yes,” Thorin had to stop and cough, his breath taken away by that frigid air. He had never felt it be so cold on the balcony before. He pushed against the battering wind until he was at the wizard's side. Thorin could not look down, for right where the wizard had stopped was where Thorin...where he had... “Bilbo appeared here when we...when we came to take back our – my – pronouncement of Exile. It was here we named him a dwarf-friend of Erebor, for now and forevermore.”

         “I am certain Gandalf had much to say about that,” Saruman sounded as sour as his expression.

         “Gandalf did have much to say about it, yes,” Thorin shivered as the wind gust eased, but the chill had cut him right to the bone.

         “Where exactly was the hobbit?”

         “Bilbo,” Thorin stressed the name. “Was here,” he pointed at the bit of the railing where Bilbo had last touched. “This is where he bled for the first time.”

         Saruman's dark gaze went to him and Thorin wanted to shiver again. “A specter bleeding. That is most unusual.”

         “Yes,” Thorin said. “It is.”

         “And this is the blood you...kept?”

         “No,” Thorin looked away, picking out the shadows of Ravenhill in the distance. “That was from a later meeting.”

         “So you have met this spirit multiple times?”

         “Three, well, no. Four,” Thorin had to stop and think about that for a moment. “At least four.”

         “Four times for four quarters,” Saruman murmured. The words made Thorin want to shiver yet again.

         “What was that?”

         The wizard gave himself a shake and did not answer. Instead he held out a hand over the balcony's railing, muttering strange words under his breath that Thorin could not make out. For a moment Saruman's hand turned into a claw, the veins and bones prominent against the thin, pale skin. Thorin thought his ears were ringing. Then Saruman pulled his hand back as if burned. There wasn't a single mark on the stone before him.

         “Strange,” Saruman said at least. Thorin shook off the strange feeling in his ears. The wind was howling over the ridgeline. That had to have been the sound he had heard.

         “What is strange?” Thorin felt a sudden stab of pain through his head, hissing as he closed his right eye against the ache.

         “King Thorin? Is something the matter?”

         “No...no, I am fine.”

         “You do not look fine. You look rather pale.”

         Thorin blinked away wetness from his eyes to see Saruman standing too close in front of him. Thorin wanted to step back but it felt like his feet were stuck to the floor. “I am...fine.”

         “Are you?” Dark eyes studied him and Thorin felt like a bug under that cool gaze. “Are you sure?”

         “My lord!” Nori's cry broke the strange moment. Thorin jerked back, feeling something crack in his neck as he did so. The wizard stepped away and Thorin shook his head, rubbing at his temple as the pain faded away as fast as it came.

         “Nori?” He stepped around Saruman to see...nothing. “Nori?” Thorin looked back and forth but the balcony was empty, as was the hall when Thorin stepped out of the wind.

         “King Thorin?” Saruman trailed after him and it made the back of Thorin's neck start to itch to not have the wizard in his sights. “What is the matter?”

         “You heard Nori's call,” Thorin glanced at the wizard. “So where is he?”

         “I heard no call,” Saruman said, raising one dark brow. “I thought you saw your kinsman. That is all.”

         “You didn't hear...” Thorin closed his teeth on the rest of the words he wanted to say. “It is getting dark,” he said instead. The urgent desire to get the wizard out of his home burned through him. “The mountain is not safe. If you wish to see more of it tomorrow I can arrange another tour.”

         “I think I have seen what I need to see,” Saruman said as he swept past Thorin. Thorin pushed down hard on the urge to trip the wizard down the stairs that led to the front gates. Saruman said not a single word more to him as Thorin led the way out of the mountain. The two blue wizards were waiting at the gates when Saruman emerged, the two of them converging on the other wizard like Thorin had tried to spirit Saruman away against his will.

         “Thorin,” a whisper said from behind him. All the hairs on the back of Thorin's neck stood up at once. He turned on his heel, heart beating hard in his throat to find...

         Nothing. He stood alone in front of the gates of Erebor, as the sun set and the stars began to come out one by one above them. That prickling sensation did not leave, not until a troop of Dwalin's guards came by, illuminating the area and banishing the shadows that Thorin wanted to pretend were something – someone – else. He stayed there until another dwarf came to him, this time definitely one of Nori's lads, and he went back to the council chambers inside the mountain to hear what he had missed in the tents outside from Balin. But that whisper stayed with him, as did the strange voice on the balcony, all the way until he returned to his chambers and Dwalin's arms. That prickling sensation only left when the door was locked tight behind him and he could stand in front of the altar and see what was left of their Bilbo, the only tangible things he could hold now of the one they loved.

         And when he dreamed that night, Thorin dreamed of shadows moving along the wall, wild and graceful at turns, with music he could not remember drumming in his bones when he woke the next day.