Actions

Work Header

the passing of mysteries

Summary:

In a world where Bilbo Baggins destroyed the One Ring in a wave of dragon fire, where he is forced to rely on ancient abilities of his folk long thought gone, Bilbo – with the help of his people – kills Smaug the Golden...

And gets declared Outcast from his gold-mad Company and King. But those old abilities of his people have far more consequences than even they know, and as they explore this strange new situation they have found themselves in, they find that the world as they know it has changed as well, and things far larger than themselves have been moved by the smallest folk on Arda's far shores. It will take faith, forgiveness, and love to find their way through it all, but Bilbo, so afraid of falling now, will have to fall again and again to save the ones he loves yet again.

Notes:

Here's the collected fic for the passing of mysteries! I hope you all enjoy!

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Chapter 1: snowdrops on the mountainside

Chapter Text

      Bilbo pressed his ear to the door but he could hear no sound of heavy boots on the ground nor the murmur of any voices. He was in between, which was always dangerous, all the more so because of his current designation with the inhabitants outside his hidden door.

     Bilbo rested his forehead against the soft wood and sighed. In between he didn't have to answer all of the numerous questions of his Shire kin about the lack of spouse – or spouses – he'd brought back. In between he could exist in a place where he was forgiven for all his trespasses, known and not. In between Bilbo could just...rest and not panic and worry and all the hundred other things that had taken up his mind since he'd accidentally dropped his pretty little ring into the golden river of mixed dragon fire and melted treasury items.

      That had been quite the mess.

      Bilbo was still unsure just what had happened. One moment he was running from that great wurm and the next the ring was slipping off his finger, exposing him to the beast and his dragon fire. Bilbo hadn't meant to call on the Old Gifts of his people. Most of his kin couldn't do it anymore, or if they did it was in small ways, not like this. Bilbo had reached, with everything he had, and felt...something stir in the back of his mind. For a moment it felt like he was back in the Shire. He could smell the sweet hay being pulled in from the fields, the last of the harvests just getting tucked away before the cold snap of the fall. For a moment it felt like his feet were back in his beloved Bag End – but also so much more.

      The Old Festivals were kept secret in the Shire for good reason. Their traveling days had been long, and even with the help they had been given here and there, most of their lore stayed within their people and not told to Outsiders. It was said that once upon a time, when they still traveled from camp to camp, that they had been blessed with a gift from a Stranger fallen from a star. It was said that even the Stranger didn't know what he had done to them, for he had left too soon to see what his blessing had done. The lore said that because of something that had happened between their people and the Stranger, the Stranger made it possible that they were able to leave no one behind. That they had a kind of...walking trick, was what the old timers called it. That they could find a crossroads and s t e p in between and they would find themselves miles and miles away, home again or safe if need be.

      Bilbo had never stepped in between before. He'd seen his mother do it in the Fell Winter, to try and save his father, but it hadn't worked. Her attempt was what caused her death years later, wasting away from something they called the Fading, having used up too much of her spirit to stay in the world of the living anymore.

      Putting on his little ring had felt a lot like what he imagined being in between felt like. Halfway. Indistinct. Stretched thin, like too little butter over too much bread. The world had looked strange too, not quite twisted, but more like a silver mirror that had been improperly made, turning the well known into something terrifying at first glance.

      Bilbo hadn't liked it, to be honest. Perhaps losing the ring was a blessing in disguise. But losing it at that moment, when he was running from a dragon in a foul temper...that had been rather inconvenient. An absolute disaster. Which was why, at that moment when all seemed lost, Bilbo had reached...

      And with a s t e p, went between.

      Bilbo had watched, frozen, as all the world about him went crimson and gold and then white as the fire licked over the space where he had been. He saw his little ring bounce up from the piled gold, spinning in the air, almost looking like a strange eye spinning about...and then it too melted, combusting into flames as it joined the rivulets of gold streaming about where Bilbo had once stood.

      But, when he checked, Bilbo found himself whole and well. His feet were on well known boards. He was standing in Bag End's front hall, looking out the front door and into a dwarven treasury turned into a nightmare with a rampaging dragon going this way and that. To be honest, he'd panicked. He'd run out of Bag End, shouting for help and somehow...somehow he felt his kin, all of the Shire, reach back. He wasn't...he wasn't really in the Shire. But he was. He wasn't really in Erebor. But he was. He was in between and for whatever reason, in that moment, so was the Shire.

      All of it.

      His Took family were the first that reached back. It felt like a great spiderweb in his mind, all of them leading to him right in the center. There was a little of that strange blue fire that had come from his little ring – maybe it had helped him somehow? – but most of it was emerald and gold and smelt of the fresh plowed earth in spring. It was the sense of home and all of it stretched out from him, connecting family after family, through the massive genealogies they all kept, connecting them all together, so that no one would ever be left behind.

      Bilbo still didn't know how his kin knew what he needed. One moment he was in between and the next it felt like he had a dozen minds all looking through his eyes, all of them looking at the dragon – and at the little empty spot on the dragon's chest. His hands had moved on their own. They'd pulled a bow from...somewhere and fitted an arrow to the string. Hobbits always had excellent aim. They were known for their keen eyes and ability to hit their targets – though most of their targets these days were at the summer fairs. Bilbo had drawn the bow back. He'd let the arrow fly.

      Bilbo Baggins had killed Smaug the Golden with that fateful blow.

      He had been released from that strange hold on his mind, feeling the way his kin were sprawled out where they had been standing or sitting, all of them feeling mentally sore and...tired. Then Bilbo had a great many other things to worry about, namely the river of molten gold that he was being pushed towards, so he had to figure out how to get out of that first before he poked at the strange connection that he could still feel in his head.

      Once he was clinging to a rock and marveling over the fact that he had survived, another problem came to him. Namely that he was supposed to have gotten his hands on the Arkenstone for Thorin...and now that Arkenstone was potentially somewhere in that mess of molten gold.

      Bother.

      Thorin had become...strange in the days leading up to this mess. All his dwarves had. Where Thorin and Dwalin would loom over him, tucking him between the two of them at Laketown, Bilbo had been left alone. Thorin and Dwalin were snapping at everyone, even each other, when before they had been so in sync that Bilbo thought nothing could disrupt that.

      As it turned out, that strangeness stayed, and after Bilbo returned without the Arkenstone – and without an angry dragon on his tail – that odd hostility did not disappear. It just grew worse. And worse. And when they had found the Arkenstone, with Bofur chipping it out of the solidified gold to place in Thorin's hand, that madness had seemed to spread from dwarf to dwarf, until all of Bilbo's Company were wild with it. So wild that they turned away the elves and men who had come to help them. So mad that they threatened war on Bard and Thranduil's people. So mad that when Bilbo spoke up about it, Thorin turned on him, held him by the throat and dangled him over the wall, naming Bilbo a Betrayer and Enemy of Erebor.

      Then Thorin had let go.

      As he fell Bilbo reached once more, that inner part of him still sore and painful, but what else was he to do? The rocks below were razor sharp. Bard and Thranduil had already ridden away, angry at Thorin's threats. Bilbo did not think anyone saw him fall. So all he could do was reach...

      And s t e p in between.

      He'd ended up flat on his back in Bag End's front hall...but it wasn't Bad End. Not exactly. It was...strange. Different. It held all the feeling of home without the touch. And when he'd opened his door, it opened not into the Shire but into a hall that he did not recognize. A hall that was quiet and cold. A hall...

      That was in Erebor, hidden deep, deep in the belly of the Mountain.

      The Old Gifts came easy to him then, as he sneaked about the Mountain, trying to figure out what was going on. That was how he realized that there were armies marching on Erebor. That was how he realized that his dwarves were mad, for Thorin was wild-eyed with it, strange and fey and not himself. None of them were. So what was a hobbit to do but to fix something that was so broken? He'd had to bring in his aunts, of course, and with them came most of the Brandybuck matrons – who were a force in and of themselves – and with their help they found the nasty web of something that was hanging over the mountain and snipped away at it with their golden scissors, strand by strand until that web fell away like frost on a spring morning.

      Then did Bilbo see his Company become his Company once more. He saw them...wake up perhaps was the best term. Bilbo wrote a little note and tucked it into what remained of his bedroll and pack, since none of the Company had touched it since his...well. Since the incident on the battlements. He hadn't stuck around to see if they'd found it, but he supposed they had, since when Bard and Thranduil came again, this time angry and defiant about the armies of orcs and wargs and bats and all number of evil things coming their way, Bilbo saw Thorin give out the part of Bilbo's share of the treasure for their help. Thranduil had been rather snooty about the whole thing, if you asked Bilbo, but Bard seemed to see something in Thorin's changed demeanor, and pledged that he and his people would help. That seemed to shame Thranduil into helping – also the long look the elven king had given Bard was interesting – and the elves had joined the fight as well. And with the coming of the dwarves from the Iron Hills, it looked almost like it would be a fair fight.

      But Azog and his ilk never liked to fight fair. So when Bilbo's Company was lured out of the gates and into the depths of the battle, Bilbo had reached once more...and his kin had come running to help.

      Bilbo wasn't sure how the elves, men, and dwarves saw it, but with the hobbits' old gifts coming into play, they were able to s t e p between the fighting and slip knives into ribs, ruin ankles, slash bellies and all manner of things that helped turn the tide of the battle in a snap. But it was Thorin, Dwalin, and the boys facing Azog and his fiercest lieutenants in the ruins that had almost ended Bilbo. He had done everything he could to stop the White Orc, collapsing the ice in one mad last chance effort that finally, finally saved Thorin's life. His Took cousins had made sure Fíli and Kíli survived. And for a moment, when Thorin was in Dwalin's arms and the din of battle was receding, Bilbo thought...well. He was a silly fellow but he thought that Thorin and Dwalin saw him, even though Bilbo was still in between, and had reached out towards him.

      But he was a coward and had fled from them, stepping to the side and ending back in the odd Bag End before he knew what he was doing. He'd huddled in a corner for an entire candlemark until his uncle Isengrim had come and fetched him, taking him back to the Great Smials and tucking him into bed there.

      And now here they were, in this strange in between. The Shire – their Shire – was gone. They'd tried to go back, tried to step back into the world that is and was, but the Shire they found was destroyed. Completely. Crops were gone. Fields devastated. It looked as though a great inferno had swept over the land, blackening it to ash and dust. Bag End itself was gone, as were most hobbit homes. A few ruins remained here and there. The only thing they had now was the in between...

      And the lands about Erebor, on the mountainside, were flowers were starting to peek through the ash.

      All their homes had one door that led to the in between and one door that led to the halls under Erebor, were the dark was so complete Bilbo couldn't even see his hand when he waved it in front of his face. They were being careful – so very careful – when they ventured out into Erebor's surrounds. Bilbo was still the Enemy of Erebor, the Betrayer, the Thief. According to Thorin's ranting during that moment any hobbit seen in Erebor would be killed. Their entire species were Outcast. But they had no where else to go so the bravest of his kin would go slipping through the halls, finding what tools they could find, so that they could go out into the fields about the mountain and start planting what they could. Hobbits had lived a long time wild planting. Hiding their crops in the open, where an unpracticed eye would overlook their plants and gardens, that had been their way for longer than they had lived in the peaceful, orderly Shire. They were out of practice with it, yes, but the knowledge remained. They'd done it once before and they could – and would – do it again.

      Which led to here, with Bilbo on the cusp of sneaking out of his strange Bag End. One of the cousins had said that they'd heard the wizard was coming to Erebor. Bilbo rather wanted to see Gandalf. He wondered if Gandalf would be able to see them. Perhaps the wizard would be able to let them pick a different place with their in between, somewhere far from Erebor, where they did not run the risk of being killed on sight. But Bilbo would not know until he spoke to Gandalf. So out he must go.

      Bilbo sucked in a breath, his heart hummingbird quick at his throat, and opened the door. Now or never. He hadn't meant to take his entire people there and not back again, but here he was. It was time for him to do what he could to fix the problem he'd caused.

      One step at a time.

Chapter 2: sun setting on a field of blood

Chapter Text

       Thorin stood on the battlements above the great gate of Erebor and stared out over the ruined fields. Where the great battle had taken place the earth was disrupted, torn and ragged, gray in some places, black in others. Mounds had been created where the bodies of the orcs and bats and wargs and all manner of enemies had been buried. There were small flowers appearing out of the devastation, white delicate things with drooping heads, turning those tiny mountains pale. Their sweet scent drifted up from the ruin, making Thorin's heart turn over in his chest.

       Bilbo would have loved to see them.

       Thorin closed his eyes against the thought, an ache spreading through him.

       “Thorin,” Dwalin's soft voice broke the silence. Thorin opened his eyes and put his hands on the wall, not wanting to move, not yet. “Come away.”

       “Did they find him yet?”

       Thorin heard Dwalin sigh as his partner joined him at the wall. They stood shoulder to shoulder as they looked out over the ruin that had been a battlefield not a month before. “Nothing,” Dwalin said.

       Thorin swallowed hard around a knot in his throat and nodded. “He...Bilbo has to be down there. Somewhere,” he blinked away the burn of tears. “We have to find him.”

       Dwalin's hand covered his own. “We will, Thorin. We'll find him and bring him back to the Shire so that his people can...” Dwalin's hand tightened on Thorin's but he did not pull away. “He deserves to go home.”

       “He deserved –,” Thorin bit back his words when he saw Dwalin tense. He sighed, curling his fingers through Dwalin's and holding on tight. “The ravens should return soon. Bilbo's kin will tell us what we need to do. To make it right. To honor him as he deserves.”

       “Aye.”

       Thorin glanced down beyond the wall and then had to look away when his stomach heaved. He remembered little of the gold-sick madness that had overtaken them all. But what he did remember...he had shamed himself in front of his Company, in front of his partner, in front of the One they both shared. If Bilbo stood before them now Thorin would take his crown at put it at Bilbo's feet, for it should be Bilbo's decision alone what should be done with him. The Company disagreed. Thorin's council disagreed. Thorin had not been able to tell Bard or Thranduil about it, not until Gandalf came and they had given Bilbo the hero's funeral he deserved.

       Bilbo Baggins the Dragon Slayer. Quite a fitting title for one so brave. For one so glorious. For the one Thorin should have cherished. Protected. Kept safe.

       Instead he had dangled his Bilbo above these very gates and let go, that strange darkness inside himself gleeful at Bilbo's tears, at Bilbo's terror, at the way Bilbo screamed as he fell.

       At the way that scream had cut off and only silence remained.

       All of them felt that burn of shame. Thorin and Dwalin most of all. Bilbo had killed the dragon for them. Had saved the Men and the elves from the same calamity that had destroyed Erebor. Had saved them. And instead of cherishing him for it, they had let his body rot on the rocks and be lost in the crevices below.

       There were teams of stone workers, excavators, all other manner of specialists down in the rocks, all of them looking for Bilbo's remains. Even their holy people were there, incense burning, murmuring prayers to Mahal to help guide Bilbo's soul to wherever it needed to go.

      It had been wrenching to wake from that gold-sickness. To be raving one moment and the next it felt like something had snapped in his head. Thorin had blinked and blinked and blinked again, but no, he was covered in what remained of the treasures that had been laying in the royal wing, a crown heavy on his head, all the while his Company was kneeling before him, eyes strange and misty before they too started to wake from that strange pall they had all been under. He'd watched as Dwalin crumpled to his hands and knees, hiding his face in his hands. He'd watched Balin cover his head and hide. One by one his Company woke and with them came what memories remained and...

       Well. Bilbo's death was painfully clear for them all.

      Worse had been when they had found Bilbo's things, tucked away in a dusty corner, as if kicked there and forgotten. There had been a note tucked inside the bedroll, a hasty thing in Bilbo's neat script. Thorin and Dwalin had kept it, tucked away in their mourning box that sat on their altar, as one of the few things they had left of their One. In that note Bilbo apologized , as if he ever needed to. Bilbo spoke of forgiveness. Bilbo spoke...as if he knew they had gone gold-mad and wanted nothing more than to cure of them of it, to keep them safe. That Bilbo had given up his entire share of the treasury to buy their protection, to appease the Men and elves that were banging at their door.

       Thorin had wanted to cast himself from the battlements in that moment but the shame of being a coward before the oncoming armies had stayed his hand. He would remain. He would lead the charge from the gates. He would stand before the armies as a dwarf with a sword and axe in hand. It had been humbling when Bard had accepted and had pledged to stand with them in the face of the oncoming hordes.

       Thorin tried his best to ignore all memories of the elf-king altogether.

      The battle had been so strange . All of them agreed on that, Man, dwarf, and elf alike. They should have been pressed back, even with Dáin's reinforcements coming to help. Bard had told Thorin of how many of his opponents seemed to...fall without a single arrow of Bard's to help them. Indeed, when they had gone out after the battle Thorin's people had found many of the orcs with their bellies slashed, ankles ruined, and what looked like kitchen knives stuck between ribs of many of the fallen bodies. No one could make any sense of it.

      And then there was Azog and the entire mess of the ruined tower. Thorin had told his boys to fall back. He had told Dwalin to fall back. None of them would let him meet the White Orc in battle, not alone. Thorin had thought he had lost both Fíli and Kíli to his pride, to his despair, but the boys...it was so strange . They both agreed that they had been saved...but by whom? Kíli's elf was on the battlefield and no where close. Fíli claimed that a small body, almost like a hobbit, had pulled him away before he could be caught and killed. That Fíli had been pulled somewhere strange, somewhere that made his stone-sense spin and shudder before Fíli had passed out. They'd found both boys at the base of the tower, laid out as if sleeping...or dead. Thorin had wept when he saw both their chests moving, but that was all he could do, due to his own wounds and with the way Óin was ordering the healers to take him away.

      Thorin still believed that Bilbo had saved him. Had saved them. For had not he and Dwalin seen their Bilbo? He had been like a specter, pale against the gray clouds, thin enough to see through. He had lost his blue jacket and had on just a worn white shirt with suspenders that held up nut-brown pants. His golden hair tumbled across his forehead as he stared at them. Those blue eyes had still been so scared. Thorin had reached, as had Dwalin, wanting nothing more than to hold Bilbo just once more but that vision was gone with the wind and the cries of his dwarrow coming to their aid.

       Thorin was not brave enough to return to the tower. He did not want to go searching for his lost One and not find him again. He did not think he heart could take it.

       “Thorin,” Balin's voice broke the somber moment. Thorin turned, hearing a note of panic in his old friend's tone. Balin's face was lined and he had a letter clutched in one hand as he emerged from the dark side hall. A letter...from the ravens? But it looked to be the same letter Thorin had sent, as if it had never even been opened.

       “What is wrong?” Thorin stepped forward. The wind chose that moment to whistle past the battlements, a high, thin sound that made a shudder work down Thorin's spine. It sounded like a scream. “What has happened?”

      “The Shire,” Balin was shaking. Thorin reached out and steadied his old friend. “It's gone.”

       “What?” The word was punched out of him. “What do you mean?”

       Balin held out the letter, the paper trembling like a leaf in his hand. “The ravens said...the ravens said the entire Shire was a blasted ruin. Nothing remains. Not a single hobbit or hobbit hole was left standing. Nothing remained of Bag End. It was a burnt out husk.”

      “What ,” Thorin felt the world sway around him. “How? This cannot be. Azog's army was here. Did he...did he lay waste to the Shire before he came? But that could not be possible.”

       Balin shook his head, face pale. “The ravens do not know. We must find Gandalf. The Rangers might know.”

      “Write everyone you can,” Thorin felt Dwalin take his elbow and was grateful for it. “We must find out what happened. All of the Shire is gone? All of it?”

       “Nothing remains,” Balin whispered. “Nothing.”

      Thorin closed his eyes. What had happened? How was this possible? Who could do this?

      But, as the days passed and ravens came and went from the Mountain in thick clouds, no one had an answer. Lord Elrond was as shocked as Thorin. The Rangers had seen no armies come close. And worse, it seemed as though the fields had been decimated by dragon fire...but what dragon? From where? The only dragon anyone knew about was Smaug and Bilbo had slain the dragon in Erebor's treasury, hundreds of leagues away from the Shire's quiet pastures.

       Lord Elrond was coming to Erebor. As was Tharkûn and Thranduil and Bard. The leader of the Rangers was on his way as well. For there were other things afoot, or so the letters with the wizard claimed. And all of it, Tharkûn said, pointed at Erebor for being the cause of it all.

       So Thorin waited, going to the battlements day after day, with more and more of his Company joining him as the days dragged on. They still had not found Bilbo's body. They had turned over every stone and pebble. Their people found not a single bone. It was as if Bilbo's very body had vanished into thin air. Their holy people had retreated into their temple as the great fires in the belly of the Mountain were lit, their incense burning thick as they prayed to Mahal for answers. There were also whispers of strange creatures moving through the lowest tunnels, shadow-folk, mist-like. Thorin's mining teams had been spooked by several of them. No one knew what they were. No one could catch them.

       So Thorin sat on a Mountain that was becoming stranger and stranger, all the while waiting for the lords of the land to come to his door. For even as his Mountain echoed with steps no one could see, the lands about the Mountain were waking up. Flowers bloomed in the ruins and when the sun set it looked like a field of blood lay over the mountainside, each petal glowing with crimson light.

       Thorin stood on the battlements, hand-in-hand with Dwalin, waiting. Then, on the horizon, he saw a white horse with a gray rider approaching.

       Tharkûn, Gandalf, had arrived at last.

Chapter 3: phantoms of hatred

Chapter Text

        The tunnel was pitch black, far taller than anything hobbit-made, and as cold as a winter morning. Bilbo shivered, pulling his old blue coat tighter about his middle, frowning when he realized that it closed without any strain. Food for hobbits was a necessary thing, made all the worse by this to-ing and fro-ing in between and out. All of them were starting to show wear from it, the faunts worst of all. Fall was already upon this part of the world, making it impossible to get anything planted though the farmers were trying. There were some root vegetables that might make it through the winter but no one was sure on that. Thankfully most of the harvest from the Shire had been brought in and the contents of all their smials had come with them in between, so they were not facing a complete famine.

        At least not yet.

        The Thain was already in talks with the Mayor about rationing and most all of them – saving the ones born after – well remembered the Fell Winter and the hardships they'd all gone through during that time. It would be grim but they had no other choice. They still did not dare show themselves to the dwarves who were exploring deeper and deeper into the tunnels – armed now – and their doors opened no where else. Yet.

        Which led Bilbo to here, stepping out of his front door and into the tunnels of Erebor, where he was Outcast. Each step felt like walking on shattered glass. Their kind held fast to oaths and being named Betrayer, Outcast, Thief...well. There were consequences to all things, he supposed. Bilbo chewed on his inner cheek as he made his stealthy way up through the halls, following the old signs their hunters and trackers had made in the walls, far lower than most dwarves would think to look but where hobbits could brush their fingers over and find their way.

        From what Bilbo understood during his talks with the Thain and the rest of his kin was that they were somewhere deep inside the mountain, far deeper than any hobbit ever dared to build a smial. No one knew quite why they ended up here, least of all Bilbo to whom many had looked for answers. Perhaps it was because the treasury was buried so deep inside the Mountain. Perhaps because when his dwarves were going mad with the gold-sickness Bilbo had fled to these dark tunnels, trying to find some semblance of home in this strange place when he had been denied the open air of the outside.

       Hobbit feet made little to no sound when they weren't paying attention. Now, even though each step was an agony, Bilbo made no sound at all, keeping close to the edges of the tunnel, ready to step in between at a moment's notice. The tunnel was rounded at the top, functional yet still carved as were many of the places in Erebor that Bilbo had dared to explore before his...well. Before.

        Some of the trackers thought the main tunnel many of their smials opened up to might have once been a mine shaft, but Bilbo didn't think so. There were no ruts in the center of the tunnel, no signs of wear from carts being pulled to and fro. From what little Bilbo had learned from Bofur during their quest was that dwarven mines – of whatever kind – were built for practicality and function. There would be rails for the carts to glide along, making it easier to transfer the contents of the mines to the surface or to the forges if need be.

        This tunnel had smooth floors, almost glassy, and there were more carvings starting about head-height on hobbits, or eye-level for dwarves. Bilbo stopped to rest his aching feet at one point, wishing for a strange moment to have Thorin or Dwalin's boots and then blushed at the boldness of his thoughts. Bilbo patted his cheeks, trying to calm himself and push down such a scandalous idea. While he was waiting for some of the pain in his feet to ebb away Bilbo let his fingers wander over the carvings just above his head, still sightless in the complete blackness.

       The lines were angular, cutting down at points but not in any pattern Bilbo could puzzle out. Were they words? Some sort of street signs that only dwarves could read? But at points there were other designs, like the ones Bilbo had seen on Thorin's armor, or Fíli and Kíli's. Were they clan signs? That would not do, if they were encroaching on such spaces. There were Rules about that. But such thoughts would have to wait. Bilbo knew when he was procrastinating. So with a breath to steel himself against the pain, Bilbo stepped away from the wall and continued his cautious way down the hall.

        Bilbo blinked watering eyes when the opening of the tunnel appeared as he came about a corner. There were a number of branching ways out of the main tunnel their smials opened onto and Bilbo had taken one of the higher ones, hoping that he would come out somewhere well above where most of the dwarves were inhabiting. During the start of the gold-sickness Bilbo had listened as Thorin and Bofur spoke about the structural stability of Erebor's upper halls. Bofur had used a lot of terms Bilbo didn't know and didn't remember but from what he could glean the upper halls of Erebor were sound, but the staircases to get to them were not. Something about the dragon forcing his way in through the main gates compromising some of the main arches. Or something like that. Bilbo wasn't sure. Either way it meant that there technically should be far fewer dwarves up where Bilbo planned to come out at.

        Bilbo shivered as he paused at the tunnel's end. There were two tall statues on either side of the tunnel, some strange device over their faces, with each of them holding their swords, point down, in between their feet. Almost like they were guarding the tunnel entrance. But beyond that...

        Bilbo had seen very little of Erebor besides the rooms around the treasury and what few tunnels he had managed to escape into. And the battlements, but he tried not to think about those. The vast chamber that opened up before him was larger than any hall or house or even cave Bilbo had ever been in. High above him thick shafts of sunlight streaked through the dark, hitting some sort of mirror or surface that illuminated the area. Thick pillars held up floating staircases and ramps that had not a single railing in sight. Those stairs went this way and that, soaring through that open air like magic. All was covered in a thick layer of gray dust but underneath that Bilbo thought he could make out brilliant crimsons and the glimmer of gold and the shine of silver. Once these halls were painted so brightly it must have dazzled the eyes.

        As Bilbo stared he started to pick out flaws in the vast beauty. One of the main stairways was cracked and crumbling, more than halfway destroyed. One of those thick pillars looked as if it was tilting to one side. Some of the archways above and below the level Bilbo was standing were cracked, some completely covered in rubble while others looked as though one sharp kick would cause it all to come tumbling down.

        The dragon had done far more damage than Bilbo had thought.

       Then Bilbo gave himself a shake. He couldn't linger in the hall like this, in the full light of day. All of his people were relying on him to find Gandalf and speak to him. They had to find a way to fix this strange stickiness of their in between. Even the matrons had tried to move it and nothing could be done. So to the wizard they must go. And that was why he was here.

       Eyeing the damage he could see, Bilbo decided it would be best to stick closer to the walls, just in case. He could always throw himself in between should he need to but that would lead to other problems and one dislocated shoulder was quite enough for him, thank you and good morning.

        It felt like it took an Age but was probably less than half a candlemark found Bilbo at a crossroads he did not expect. He had not thought he had come so low through the tunnels, for he knew this wide walkway. He knew the tall pillars with the severe angles and wide doors with the narrow tops. He knew that breeze that blew down through the hall, making a strange whistling noise that sounded more like a scream each time Bilbo heard it. Like his scream.

        The battlements were a handful of steps away. The floors were clean, with obvious signs of regular use. As he stood there he thought he could hear the thud of boots on the stone floors. Surely...surely there would have been more guards here, right? Had...had his Company declared this area unstable? Or...unclean? Bilbo shivered, clutching at his coat. His feet felt stuck to the floor. He wanted to go forward. He wanted to see the sky. But on the other hand he did not want to go back there. He did not want to see the place where Thorin had grabbed him and dangled him over the wall, letting him go with that mad smile that for one strange second looked so – so –

        Bilbo took one step forward. A second. A third. That strange moaning wind swept around him as he stepped out onto the battlements, eyes closing and hands releasing their death grip on his coat to turn palm-up to the sun. His breath caught in his throat, some strange emotion making it hard to swallow and a few hot tears streak down his face. It had been weeks since he had felt the sun on his face. Oh, how he wanted...

        “Bilbo?”

        The whisper felt like a punch to the chest. Bilbo's eyes flew open as he turned, hands coming up to – what? He didn't have Sting with him, not even a stone to throw. He was defenseless. He was such a fool. At the far side of the battlements was Balin, looking far older than Bilbo remembered him last looking. Balin had always been white-haired and his beard long, but he seemed...frailer to Bilbo. As if a strong wind could blow him away. But even so Balin still had his mace strapped to his side, with one hand on it.

        As if he was about to pull it forth.

       “Don't. Please,” Bilbo stuttered out, stumbling back from the dwarf. “I'm sorry. I'm sorry –”

        “Lad,” Balin breathed but all Bilbo could see was Balin's hand on his mace, which he still had yet to drop. Were they still so angry at him? Would nothing he do prove his –

       Bilbo turned his face away, feeling more heat on his face. Then he forced his eyes open, not daring to look away from Balin for a moment. He had to get out of there. He had to – he had to get back to the tunnels, but not the one where their smials opened to. He had to – he had to lead them away, he had to do something –

       “Bilbo,” Balin said, louder. Then, to Bilbo's horror, he saw other shadows on the far side of the battlement, heard other boots coming their way, slow at first but at Balin's almost-shout they began to run. Bilbo turned to flee in the other direction but pulled up short when he saw Bofur staring at him with wide eyes, a bare arms length away. Balin blocked one exit, Bofur the other, with what sounded like an entire party of dwarves headed their way at a sprint.

        Bilbo had no way out. No way out but one.

       It felt like time had turned to molasses. Bilbo felt each thud of his heart in his chest, each rasp of his breath as it tore through a too-tight throat. He felt hot and yet frozen, with a faint buzzing in his ears that almost sounded like someone crying out his name. But that could not be. It could not be. Thorin would never sound like that. Dwalin would never cry out like that. So Bilbo forced his feet to move, to take one step, another, darting out of reach of Bofur's sudden lunge, a foot on one block, then a higher one, then the next. His foot spiked with agony as he leaped, twisting him around so that he was forced to see his beloved Company so angry, faces red and shouting as Bilbo fell backwards off the battlements, just like he had...

       And, as his body plummeted towards the gates, going from warm sun into frigid shadow, Bilbo closed his eyes and reached...

       To step in between.

        And he was gone.

Chapter 4: a creature of grief and dust

Chapter Text

        Thorin walked hand-in-hand with Dwalin down the steps towards Erebor's great gate. His heart was being rabbit-fast in his chest, but from grief or fear, he was not sure. Bilbo had been dear to Gandalf, they all knew that. Gandalf had been wroth with them when they would not tell the wizard of Bilbo's whereabouts after the Battle of Five Armies, though Thorin had no part in that. He had been confined to the healer's tents then, too injured to see anyone. By the time Thorin was able to have visitors once again Gandalf had quit the area to places unknown.

        Then had come the news that the Shire had fallen and all the world was upturned. More news had come out of Gondor, stating that Mordor's gates had fallen and that some great explosion had taken place in that black land. Some claimed that Orodruin had destroyed that entire land, causing a giant sinkhole to swallow all of that land whole. So far none had dared to brave those fallen gates, though word was that Steward Turgon of Gondor was going to send parties there soon. But it was the news of the Shire's destruction that had caused the most concern. Many nations across Arda relied on the goods that came from that fertile land. The loss of such a breadbasket was sure to cause tensions across all the lands.

        The stairs that led up to the battlements were some of the few that were still sturdy enough to walk on in all of the upper levels. Thorin remembered that much from the gold-sickness, talking in depth with Bofur in the rooms about the treasury about the structural integrity of the Mountain and how much work would need to be done to make sure it did not come down about their ears with one misplaced hammer hit. It would be a decade before they would be able to access the upper halls as it was, for Bofur – after the gold-sickness and while Thorin had their people searching for Bilbo's body – had gone through what areas of the Mountain he could get into for a better, less impaired, look.

        The results of that study were rather grim.

        The dragon had done much damage to Erebor in its years there. At least two of the main support pillars were cracked all the way through. It was going to take years of work to repair that – if they even could. Bofur was hopeful that what remained of their artisan clans would come out of the hamlets in the Blue Mountains to lend their expertise in such work. As it was Bofur and the Ur clan were miners by trade – Bifur's toy making aside – and as such, construction of the interior of Erebor had never been theirs to study. Thorin's people had lost more than their home when the dragon came, clans being torn apart by the stress of their evacuation of the Mountain and their attempts at finding a new home, leaving huge gaps in their people's knowledge and apprenticeships.

        The stairs led to a wide hall beyond the gates, where once the King's Guard would have commanded. They were currently using those barracks to house Dáin and his people from the Iron Hills while their warriors healed from their wounds and returned home. Dáin himself had stayed while Thorin was recovering, not letting anyone question Thorin's claim on the crown. It was a kindness Thorin had not expected.

        Caravans of their people were starting to arrive as the fall days grew colder and colder. Thorin worried the most about how they were going to get through the winter with so many people under their roof. The dragon had destroyed the fields of the people of Lake-town and Thorin was not about to beg for help from Thranduil. Balin had broached the idea of sending some of their traders to Rohan or Gondor for foodstuffs. Thorin had agreed to it. Gold they had in plenty but gold would not feed their people.

        It was a pity he had not learned that lesson before...

       Thorin gave himself a shake and tried to focus on the here and now. He had cast off all the trappings of kingship that he had draped himself in during the madness of the gold-sickness, leaving just a small circlet to wear when he was out in public. Once he was in his rooms he refused to wear it at all. His people – and Dáin's – gave him short bows as they passed, all of them already full of tasks set out by either Balin or Bofur and hopefully Bombur soon, since Thorin had put that trusted dwarf in charge of the food and meals for all their people. Thorin and Dáin had had some short talks about perhaps relying on Dáin's own stores to get Thorin's people through the worst of winter but Thorin was reluctant to do so. Politics were a messy thing and Thorin had already heard from Nori and his growing herd of informants that there were grumblings about Thorin and his people putting strain on the Iron Hills folk as it was.

        The great gate of Erebor had changed much since Gandalf, Bard, and Thranduil had been there last. All of the rocks at the base of the gate had been cleared in the search for Bilbo's body, inadvertently speeding up the clean up from the dragon's damage in that area by weeks, if not months. The wide swaths of dying grass on either side of the road that led to their gates had been cleared of rubble. The damage done to the two Guardians of the Gate was being assessed. There were tents set up on those grassy areas, some for the workers that had already arrived, while their main kitchens were still set up outside since they were still unsure as to how sound the lower levels of the Mountain were.

        The work ran nonstop. They did not dare go any slower. Not with winter so close.

        At the entrance to the gates stood a tall horse with a lone rider just swinging down from the saddle. Gandalf's robes were stained with dust and his tall, pointed hat was bent at the tip but his eyes were as sharp and clear as ever. Thorin stepped forward, dropping Dwalin's hand. Bilbo's death was his alone to bear, though none of the Company agreed with him on that. They each blamed themselves for it, in different ways. The dwarrow in the surrounding tents had all stopped to see what was going on. Thorin saw all the members of his Company start to appear from all directions, gathering behind him in front of Erebor's great gate.

        “Thorin Oakenshield,” Gandalf was the first to speak. There was a murmur from the gathering crowd. Thorin saw Dáin push through them to stand to Thorin's right, his cousin glancing between Thorin and the wizard with a deep frown gathering on his face. “I am here to get answers from you at last.”

       Thorin swallowed, feeling a hard lump in his throat for a moment. Then, with shaking fingers he took the simple circlet from his head and knelt before Gandalf, placing it at his feet. There were shocked cries from all around him. Dáin started forward but two of Nori's people stopped him. All Thorin could do was stare up into that dark gaze. “Bilbo is gone,” Thorin said. His voice did not break at least. “After we turned you and the others from the gates in our madness Bilbo tried to reason with us. Tried to explain...” Thorin could not finish the sentence for all the breath had left his body. He sucked in a shaky breath. “Bilbo tried to explain that he had exchanged his part of the gold for your help. That he had a plan ,” this time his voice did break. Thorin closed his eyes for a moment, seeing Bilbo again on that battlement, pale and tired and so sad. Thorin opened his eyes. “I declared Bilbo Outcast then. A Betrayer. A Thief.” He shook his head. “And then in my madness I took him by the throat and dangled him over the gates. Then I let go.”

       “That halfling stole the Arkenstone, of course you –”

       “What stealing could Bilbo have done?” Thorin looked at a furious Dáin and shook his head. “The Arkenstone was trapped in solid gold . There was no way Bilbo could have stolen it. Bofur had to chip it out of that mess himself. Bilbo killed Smaug,” Thorin growled at his scowling cousin. “And I declared him Outcast for it. I have brought shame to my entire people, to my entire line. And now,” Thorin looked back to Gandalf who had not moved a muscle the entire time they were speaking. “Now the Shire is gone,” he whispered. “Gone in dragon fire. Destroyed. And I cannot think but that I am the cause of that as well.”

       Silence settled around them. Still Gandalf did not move. Those aged hands were curled tight about his staff, the joints and veins more pronounced than Thorin could ever remember them being. There was a light to the wizard's eyes that made the hairs on the back of Thorin's neck stand on end. One by one his Company knelt behind him, then dwarf after dwarf copied them, pulling the hats from their heads, still and silent as Gandalf's gaze did not leave Thorin for a second. Dáin was the very last to kneel.

        Then Gandalf sighed and it felt like the whole world sighed with him. “Get up, Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain.” The title should have felt like validation. It felt more like a slap in the face, instead. “There are things you and I must speak of. Get up, King Thorin. If you truly feel that you are beholden to Bilbo and his people then to make restitution you must be on your feet. Rise!”

        Thorin stumbled to his feet, feeling Dwalin surge to his side and take his arm. Thorin did not dare bend to pick up his simple crown, leaving it instead at Gandalf's feet. The wizard looked down at it, the end of his staff moving it over the gravel. Then the wizard bent and picked it up, holding it in one hand, careful and gentle, as he looked it over.

        “An interesting choice to wear, King Thorin. Perhaps there is hope for you, yet.” Then the wizard held it out for Thorin to take. He did so with shaking hands, curling his fingers about the cool metal, not willing to put it on in front of Gandalf or his people. Not yet. Not when it felt like he did not deserve it.

        “We can speak inside the gates,” Balin was the one to say with a quick look at Gandalf. “There are rooms and chairs there a plenty.”

       “Then lead us onward, good sir,” Gandalf said. The dwarrow gathered had not moved, aside from getting to their feet when Thorin did. He had little time to look at Dáin as he fell into step with Gandalf, heading for the gate. Thorin did not know why stories about Bilbo being a thief were circulating the Iron Hills tents. Bilbo was the Dragonslayer. Bilbo was the Savior of Erebor. That was how Bilbo should be remembered. Not as a thief.

        Balin led them to a large room they were using as a council chamber for the time being. It had seats enough for the entire Company and Gandalf too. The wizard took the seat closest to the fire, a sigh leaving him such that Thorin had never heard before. Gandalf set his staff to one side and pulled out his pipe but did not light it, choosing instead to stare into the fire. Thorin stood before him, not quite daring to sit.

       “You have done a grave harm, King Thorin, far more than you think you know,” Gandalf said as the silence went on for a moment too long. “Sit and tell me in detail all that you can remember from the moment you entered the Mountain.”

        Thorin sat and the tale he told was long. Long enough that food had to be brought and drink as well. Long enough that his voice cracked and Dwalin pulled a chair up to his side, not caring that the wizard saw them take hands as Thorin explained the descent into gold-sickness, the madness that they still could not understand, the paranoia and fury that possessed them all. All throughout the long tale Gandalf's expression barely wavered. But, at the end, when Thorin had laid all their sins bare, did the wizard finally sit back with a sigh and run a trembling hand over his eyes.

        “What a wretched mess,” Gandalf said. “What an awful, wretched mess.”

        “Yes,” Thorin agreed.

       Gandalf's hand dropped and Thorin was rewarded by a sharp glare. “You declared Bilbo Outcast,” he repeated. Thorin nodded, frowning when Gandalf's glare grew deeper. “Perhaps it was kinder that you dropped Bilbo from that gate, for if you had not every second Bilbo stayed in this Mountain would cause him agony.”

        “What?” Multiple voices choked the word out, Thorin's included.

        Gandalf sighed and finally reached out for a taper to light his pipe. “Hobbits,” he said after a few deep puffs, “abide by their own Rules. I'm sure you figured that much out on your own.”

       Thorin ducked his head and nodded. It had been so frustrating dealing with Bilbo at first. None of them knew why he acted so strangely. Not until Bilbo began to make offhand comments about his culture and the Shire. Then things had started to come into better focus but they were so deep into the Quest by then that there was nothing they could do about it except forge on. And then when they reached the Mountain...

        Well.

        “Once, long ago, hobbits lived a very different life,” the fire flickered light over Gandalf's face, making him seem...different for a moment. Younger. Thorin blinked and the illusion was gone. “They lived not far from here, in fact, all along these lands. They had Rules they had to live by and any straying from them, any crossing of those lines, was met with swift and permanent repercussions. To be declared Outcast...” Gandalf closed his eyes for a moment. “It would cause them to have physical injuries. Each step would open their feet, as if they were walking on broken glass. If they lingered too long they would start to have other physical injuries. Dislocated joints or even broken bones. They either had to leave the area they were Outcast from – a fate that was often a death sentence – or die by inches in agony until their bodies could not take any more pain.”

        Thorin pressed a hand to his mouth. “We searched,” he said when he had mastered his stomach. “I swear to you, we searched the rocks below the gate. We wanted...we wrote to the Shire. We wanted to give him a hero's funeral, to find out how his kind celebrated the dead. But the ravens...”

        “Yes,” Gandalf sighed again. “All was gone. I went there myself to see. Nothing remains. Not a single dwelling, not even their hidden stores. It was as if every hobbit in the Shire and all their possessions disappeared at the same time and something came in after to make sure they could never go back.”

        “But how?” Balin was the one to ask. All gazes shifted to him. “They did not even know of our dishonor to Bilbo. They wouldn't...they wouldn't blame the lad, would they?”

        Gandalf exhaled a long stream of smoke. For a moment it almost looked like Bilbo's round front door. “No,” he said after a moment. “And yes.”

        Thorin bowed his head.

        “But as I know these people, they would never have done something so drastic to their own homes and fields, not without a meeting of widows under the new moon. Then answers would have been gotten whether Bilbo liked it or not, had he really been worthy of being declared Outcast. But the physical punishment would have started immediately, with or without the widows' interrogation.” Gandalf's gaze went to the fire again, his pipe tapping at his lips. “But there was no body?”

        “None,” Thorin said. “We turned over every stone. There was nothing left of Bilbo there.”

        “Strange,” Gandalf murmured. The light from the fire reflected oddly in his eyes. “And when you lifted your pronouncement?”

        Thorin had to look away.

       “Thorin Oakenshield. You did lift that pronouncement.”

        “We were waiting,” he told the fire, unable to look Gandalf in the face as he spoke. “To know what we must do to honor him in the way of his people. We were waiting for you.”

       Thorin flinched back when Gandalf thrust the mouth of his pipe at him. “Then get up at once. You must lift the title of Outcast from Bilbo immediately. If he lingers...”

        Thorin felt a chill wash over him. “If he...lingers?”

        Gandalf's mouth opened. Closed. Then, “Sometimes, if a death is...painful enough, I have seen hobbits vanish from the face of the earth. Even I do not know where they go. But sometimes they come back and if they are suffering under any such judgments – rightfully so or not – they can become...tormented. Hobbits, you see, are made of far sterner stuff than even I,” Gandalf shook his head, his gaze going distant once more. “They had to be, coming from where they were. It is an awful sight to see a hobbit so tortured, Thorin Oakenshield. It will haunt you for the rest of your days. So get up, right now, and lift this judgment on Bilbo Baggins of Bag End. Perhaps that will allow him to rest, should he linger here.”

       “You think he's here?”

        “Where else would he be?” Gandalf said. “Up you get, King Thorin! Lift this false judgment at once!”

       “But how?” Thorin cried, already on his feet. “What do I do? Do I just say the words? I have said them hundreds of times!” Dwalin was at his side, hands curled into fists. So many times they had come together at night, whispering prayers to Bilbo's spirit, asking him for forgiveness.

        But, perhaps...perhaps they had never forgiven him. Perhaps they had never taken back those words in such explicit terms. Oh, they had mourned their words, Thorin had cursed himself for them so many times, but had they...had he...

        “You must go to the spot where the judgment was given,” Gandalf said. The fire surged in the grate, casting shadows over the wizard's face. “You must repent your words and deeds. You must ask him for forgiveness. And, if you are lucky, he will give it.”

        Thorin closed his eyes and bowed his head. “We will go immediately.”

        “Go. And only say what you truly believe. To lie...would only make things worse.”

        Thorin bowed low to the wizard and turned to leave. Balin and Bofur were already out the door, headed to the battlements, surely to clear the way. The path to the stairs had never felt so long. To think that they – that he – had damned Bilbo's spirit to agony for so many months. That he had hurt his One – their One – so badly with their madness.

        The stairs felt endless. Thorin could not even see them, only Bilbo's face in his mind's eye as he mounted each step. All he could hear was Bilbo's voice. Thorin had been the one to put off the Courting, when Dwalin had wanted to claim their one in Lake-town when they had the chance. Thorin had thought – by their Maker had he been gold-mad even then? – to cover Bilbo in gems, to drape their Burglar in luxuries so fine that he would never think to leave the Mountain ever again.

        Then, faintly, he heard Balin say, “Bilbo?”

        Thorin stumbled on the last step. It was only Dwalin's quick grab that kept him upright at all.

       Then, he heard a wavering voice said, “Don't. Please. I'm sorry. I'm sorry –,” and Thorin broke into a run. All of them did. They tore around the corner that led to the battlements just in time to see Bilbo – so pale and wan and thin it hurt to see – take one step up the rocks, then another, his ankle twisting when Thorin cried out his name along with Dwalin, reaching – reaching –

        Then Bilbo was falling, the silence all the louder for the lack of a scream. Thorin caught himself on the wall, choking on air as he saw Bilbo's body fall into darkness...

        And vanish like a specter.

       “Thorin,” Dwalin was at his side. “Thorin.”

       “What?” He turned to look at him. Then he saw that Dwalin was not looking at him but rather at Thorin's hands, where they rested on the wall. Where they rested in the blood on the wall, warm and wet as it coated Thorin's fingers and palms.

       Thorin stared down at his hands, mind terrifyingly blank. What had he done?

Chapter 5: take our greatness with our bitterness

Chapter Text

        The first time Dwalin set eyes on one Bilbo Baggins he had been thoroughly disappointed. Such a soft creature, so bewildered, so unprepared. The wizard had claimed that their Burglar would be well versed in his duties and the Quest. Instead what Dwalin had seen was a fussy mouse who flinched whenever Dwalin so much as grunted at him. That jumpiness only got worse once the rest of the Company arrived, turning this so-called Burglar into a Bungler instead, as Bifur had grumbled into his ale as the night wore on.

        None of them had expected to see the hobbit once they'd left that strange hole in the ground that next morning. But when he'd shown up, when this Bilbo Baggins had joined their Company, Dwalin had felt some strange pain pierce through his chest. There and gone, it had startled a breath out of him, causing Thorin to glance over with worry. But Dwalin did not know what to say. Surely it was just some strange, little thing. Nothing important. Nothing so great as to warrant a look over by Óin.

        And then, when Azog had them cornered on the cliff, when all had seemed lost, this Burglar, this Bilbo, had jumped down and stood before the White Orc, defending Dwalin's King and partner...Dwalin had felt that pain in his chest once more and in that moment, seeing Bilbo stand, trembling, before their enemy, that was when Dwalin had known.

       Bilbo Baggins was his One. Was Thorin's One. Was their One.

       Dwalin had not needed to tell Thorin when they'd landed at the Carrock. Thorin had known, just as Dwalin had, what Bilbo was to them. It had burned, a little, to think about how they had been so rude to him at first, not knowing hobbit culture and their ways. Bilbo's little comments about disliking ponies...they'd just taken it as the hobbit being fussy or afraid yet again. Later, at Beorn's, Dwalin had tucked their One between them and gotten Bilbo to talk a little about his people and their history. About how ponies were to be used to move things , not hobbits, though the why of that Bilbo had not explained. About how hobbits had seven – seven – meals a day and how each of them meant certain things and if the rules of such order were upturned then there would be Consequences to be paid. All of them had heard the capital letter there. It reminded Dwalin a bit of how the deep-cave dwarrow lived, with the rules that seemed strange to most of the rest of the dwarven clans but which made sense and were there for reasons they who lived in the upper levels could not understand.

        It was at Beorn's that Dwalin had first been able to corral their Burglar, their Bilbo, into a spot between him and Thorin, tucked safe, just where he needed to be. And then later, at Lake-town, when Bilbo had been so ill, it had been their responsibility to keep Bilbo safe and warm, though the hobbit had not seemed to know or remember much of that. Dwalin had wanted to make their first formal Courting gesture there, but Thorin...Thorin had disagreed and at the time his argument had seemed valid. They were dwarves without a home, in the middle of a dangerous Quest to regain their homeland. Wouldn't it be better to make this gesture in Erebor's great halls, where they could take their pick from the treasury and place them upon Bilbo's fair skin, to adorn him in the bright gems of their people so that they could Court their Burglar with the richness he deserved?

       Dwalin had never said it – would never say it – but he cursed himself for not saying something to Bilbo then. But perhaps it was for the best. How much worse would it be for their Bilbo to have them turn from Courting loves to bitter enemies when their Bilbo was being tormented like this when they were not so tightly bound together?

        And now, here, watching their Bilbo fall once more, as the whole battlement seemed to be swallowed up in shadow as something dark moved over the face of the sun. Dwalin felt a cry leave him as his Bilbo – their Bilbo – disappeared over that wall and vanish into the darkness below.

        Just as he had before.

       Dwalin watched as Thorin's face lost all color. As Thorin took one staggering step back. As Thorin fell to his knees, gaze not moving from the crimson blood coating his hands. A bitter gust of wind slid over the battlements, whistling and high, so much like Bilbo's scream it was hard not to think of it. Hard not to think of the first time, when Bilbo's face had been bright red from Thorin's hold about his neck. How Bilbo had clawed at Thorin's hands, lips moving in words he could not speak. How Thorin had simply let Bilbo...drop. As if Bilbo was less than a piece of trash in Thorin's hands. How Dwalin had watched it happen, some hot, angry kernel in his chest bitterly bright and joyful as he heard Bilbo scream. As he heard that scream cut off and the wind take over.

        That same wind made a shudder work its way down Dwalin's back as he went to his knees next to Thorin, taking hold of his partner's wrists, careful not to mar the blood on Thorin's hands.

       “No,” Thorin whispered, barely loud enough for Dwalin to hear. “No. No. Please, this can't –”

       “He's here,” Fíli said, shivering next to his brother, both of them staring with wide, bruised eyes. “Bilbo's really here. He's still...”

        “Thorin,” Dwalin swallowed against a hard lump in his throat. His eyes burned. “Thorin, take it back. We'll all take it back,” he cut a look to the rest of the Company, who all nodded in agreement. “Say it now, Thorin. Say it.”

        “I...” Thorin's voice broke as tears streaked down his face. “I, Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, lift the judgment of Outcast, of Betrayer, of Thief on one Bilbo Baggins of Bag End, a hobbit of the Shire. Bilbo Baggins is forever now to be named a dwarf-friend, as are all his people, welcome in Erebor's halls from here and forevermore.”

        The shriek of the wind vanished. Dwalin felt something in his chest ache. Then he, along with the others, echoed Thorin's words, one after the other, a quiet chorus on the battlements. The shadows on the battlements lifted, a thick warmth beating back the chill of an early fall. It should have felt like a blessing. It should have felt like forgiveness. But to Dwalin it just felt hollow. Would the last they saw of their Bilbo be his fall? Would he not return, just once more, to forgive them in turn? Had they...had they not done this right? Had they bungled it all again?

        But there were no answers for his questions. Just the silence of the battlements and nothing more.

        The sound of boots on stone turned Dwalin's head. He saw Gandalf step from the shadows and out into the light, hat and pipe gone, and looking far older than Dwalin could remember seeing him look. Dwalin turned to him, Thorin as well, both of them looking to the wizard to see if they had failed their Bilbo yet again. But Gandalf was not looking at them. His gaze was for the blood on the battlement walls, where it was drying in the sun and the wind, going from crimson to brick red to brown as it dried. The wizard stopped just shy of the wall, one hand hovering over where Bilbo had stepped.

        “Oh my boy,” Dwalin heard Gandalf murmur. “Oh my dear boy.”

        “I took it back,” Thorin said, voice thick as he broke the silence after Gandalf's words. “I swear to you, I took it back. I named Bilbo a dwarf-friend of Erebor, welcome in Erebor from here and forevermore. All of the hobbits of the Shire, should their spirits need someplace to rest are welcome here. I – I – did we –”

        “Then you did well, Thorin Oakenshield,” Gandalf said. He did not look at them. His hand continued to hover over that drying blood. Even as Dwalin watched that liquid seemed to...fade, to flake away in pieces, far too fast for any normal blood to dry and be carried away by the wind. “Strange,” Gandalf murmured as the blood vanished bit by bit as they all stared. “How very strange.”

        “Gandalf?”

       The wizard gave himself a shake, his hand dropping as the last of the blood disappeared from the wall. All that was left was on Thorin's hands. It was still wet and clinging, not fading in the least. What did that mean? “I need to speak to Elrond of this. He is but a day behind me. I have not –”

        Dwalin looked up to see Gandalf staring at Thorin's bloody hands. Those bushy brows came together. Gandalf stepped before them, going down to one knee before them, staring at Thorin's palms.

        “Gandalf?” Dwalin said.

       “That should not be,” the wizard murmured. Then his hands reached out to cup Thorin's, but when he did the blood on Thorin's palms blazed, strangely blue and purple, crackling like a tiny storm between their fingers for one bright moment...

        And then it was gone. There was not a single trace of Bilbo's blood left on Thorin's hands.

        “What was that?” Dwalin heard his brother ask. Dwalin could not find a single word to say.

        Gandalf continued to stare, hands hovering over theirs for a long, long moment. Then he let out a breath that seemed to echo against the very walls of Erebor as he sat back. “I do not know,” the wizard said. “I do not know,” he repeated, still staring.

        “Does he...does Bilbo not forgive me? Forgive us?” Thorin was the one to ask.

        Gandalf's gaze did not lift from Thorin's now-clean hands. His answer was the one Dwalin feared.

        “I do not know.”

Chapter 6: a certain kind of alone

Chapter Text

         Bilbo let out a yelp when he landed on Bag End's hard floors, feeling the crack as his arm broke under his body. He let out a low groan, the pain making him queasy. His feet ached and stung and his head was still spinning from the fall and all the memories of the last time he was on that balcony. When he had last seen his – Bilbo closed his eyes and ignored the way something hot slipped down his temples and vanished into his hair. He let out a breath, feeling a hot curl of emotion lodged deep in his chest.

         Bag End was silent about him. He was out of the in between, where the world felt cold and strange and back in his own front hall. He could smell the fire, see the ways the banked embers cast a faint warm glow to his sitting room. A part of him wished that he had never gone on this cursed Adventure. That he had not brought all this ruin onto himself and his people. That he was not...

         The door to his smial creaked open, but it was the door that led to the in between , where all their smials were connected through the warren of tunnels that held all the Old Symbols painted and carved onto the walls. Once such a thing was the stuff of tales, or when faunts spoke in hushed whispers about the Fell Winter and what their people had to do to survive it. Now, though, their people moved in and out of the in between with an ease that shocked Bilbo.

         A tall figure appeared over him when Bilbo managed to open his eyes. His cousin, Fortinbras Took II, Thain of the Shire, set his hands on his hips with a sigh that made Bilbo want to curl up into a ball and hide. “No wizard, then?”

         Bilbo turned his face away and said nothing. He heard his cousin mutter a curse and then that tall presence was kneeling at his side, warm hands patting Bilbo down and pausing when he came to Bilbo's broken arm.

         “Ah, lad,” Fortinbras sighed.

         “I fell and broke it,” Bilbo muttered, still not able to face him. “It wasn't – it didn't snap. Not like,” he flicked his fingers, the half formed Sign there and gone. One did not speak of the Outcast in the Shire. Oathbreakers were shunned. Exiled. Blood betrayers were the worst of the lot, the ones that harmed their own families in their homes, in what should have been their safest place. When all this in between nonsense had started Bilbo had been taken aside by a mourning of widows, their golden scissors gleaming in the firelight, to be questioned about just what was going on. All of his people could see the blood trails he left and when the first of his people set foot out into Erebor's cold halls, their feet, too, began to bleed.

         Bilbo had had to answer all their questions that evening. Lay forth all his shortcomings, everything about his silly ring, answer even the questions he had managed to avoid with Gandalf, to bear himself to their Judgment or be thrown out into the cold and the pain and the blood of Erebor's dark halls.

         “Let's get you up, then,” Fortinbras said. Before Bilbo could do more than turn to face him, Fortinbras had an arm under his shoulders and another under Bilbo's knees and was lifting him like he was a faunt and not a grown adult.

         “Fortinbras! Put me down!”

         “Not on those feet, lad.”

         “Don't lad me,” Bilbo sputtered. “You're only twelve years older than me!”

         “A whole decade.”

         “Oh, don't start with that again!”

         “And I'm married,” Fortinbras continued despite Bilbo's protests. “Let's get Lalia to look you over, then. You can occupy Ferumbras at the same time.”

         Bilbo grumbled but there was nothing for it. Once Fortinbras had a hold of someone it was only by his will alone that they would be let go. His cousin's strength had won many a prize at the summer fairs and before he had become Thain Fortinbras had worked at the Took family's smithy, doing all manner of things. Their people did – Bilbo had to stop and breathe through the pain of that thought. Their people had done most of their trade with the dwarves of the Blue Mountains and the Men about Bree for the things they could not make in their own lands. Their excess harvests sold at a pretty penny for them all, despite what they always put away in the emergency stores, and it was enough to keep the Shire's economy healthy through the years. The work Fortinbras had done was more repair work than anything else, plows and wheel rims for wagons and the like. But when his cousin had become Thain such work had stopped and now Fortinbras saw to their people, along with the Mayor, watching over them all as best he could.

         Until the day the dragon fire came and wiped out the Shire and everything that did not get pulled in between when all of Bilbo's people answered his frantic call.

         Bilbo shivered when Fortinbras stepped from the warmth of Bag End and into the in between . They could have taken the dwarven halls but the way was dark and their people had no wish to slice open their feet when they could simply go in between . His cousin's hold on Bilbo firmed as they walked down the old halls. The tunnels had been faint at first when their people had been pulled in between. A strange, half-formed place that many had trouble navigating at first, but the more their people used it the more stable these tunnels became. And, as they became more stable, more and more things began appearing in those strange halls.

         Paintings had appeared on the walls, old hand prints in ocher and brick red and brown and black. A tall black pillar was drawn many times, sometimes cracked and falling down, sometimes blazing with crimson flames, sometimes drawn in an eerie blue that reminded Bilbo of how the world looked when he'd put on his little ring. Sometimes there were long trains of figures that many assumed were hobbits, most of them pulling some sort of wagon. Sometimes, in some of the finer drawings, they could see animals in those long trains, or flowers, or once what looked like a tall figure of a man.

         In between the hallways were lit with some strange glow, warm and yellow like a muted sun. No one could figure out where the light came from. There were a handful of tunnels that connected them all, many of which had appeared like the roads that had crisscrossed the Shire, but the longer they stayed in this strange state the more tunnels began to appear. Some were ghostly pale and the widows had laid down the law that no one was to go exploring those. Some were like how the tunnels had first appeared but branching out at strange spots, sometimes showing carvings on the walls that none in the Shire recognized.

         Bilbo had wondered, long ago, if there were more hobbits out in the world than just in the Shire. Their oldest tales told of how only some clans had braved the mountains and found their way across the Brandywine and into the lush bounty of the Shire. Some liked to whisper in the quarter cross days about the clans that might still be moving from one spot to the next in the Lost Lands beyond the Wilds. Some even whispered that the clans had chosen to go even further east, to where the lands were laid out like long undulating waves and the grasses were tall and the hunting was good.

         Fortinbras was married to one Lalia Clayhanger. Lalia was feared by many in the Took line for her no-nonsense attitude and the way she had taken over the position of the Head Matriarch when Fortinbras had become Thain. It was Lalia who had led the mourning of widows at Bilbo's interrogation, even though she was not a widow herself. It was Lalia who had tended Bilbo's abused feet when he had gone out and done most of the scouting for their people in the first week of their predicament. Many in the greater Took family had Opinions about how Lalia ran her household but Bilbo appreciated her brusque manner and how she did not pander to the Baggins name or status. Lalia was not afraid to tell a body when they were being stupid and Bilbo had been called that a lot in the last few weeks when he was at their smial.

         The Great Smials had formed like a labyrinth in the in between . Only the Took family seemed to know their way through it all. Not even Bilbo had been able to navigate it clearly. He rested his head on Fortinbras' shoulder as he cousin wove his way through the narrowing tunnels, no longer decorated with the old paintings and carvings, but now dotted with ghostly paintings that looked like the Shire they had all left. Bilbo did not know if these images were paintings the Tooks had in their own homes or if this was some conjuring of this strange in between.

         Then they were at a large blue painted door, the color of faded periwinkle and not the eerie ghost light from Bilbo's ring. Fortinbras pushed it open with a foot and they both shivered as they passed from in between to out.

         “Fortinbras?”

         “Here,” his cousin called back. “I've got Bilbo with me as well.”

         Bilbo winced when he heard Lalia crack something together in the kitchen. Fortinbras and Lalia's only child, one Ferumbras, peeked at them from around the edge of a door frame. Bilbo gave the lad a weak wave. Ferumbras went pink and ducked away, still so shy at his tender age.

         Fortinbras took Bilbo into the sitting room, laying him out on the couch. Lalia was good with herbs and the like, more used to the birthing bed than a medic's tent but she and the others of the widows had taken care of all their people who had gone out into the thick of the fighting of the Battle of Five Armies. Or would it be Six Armies? Did Bilbo's people count as an army?

         “You get that dreamer's look off your face, Bilbo Baggins,” Lalia said as she bustled in from the kitchen. “What have you done now?”

         “I broke my arm.”

         He saw her pause and give Fortinbras a look. His cousin shook his head. Bilbo watched as Lalia let out a breath and muttered something under her breath he could not catch. Then she was at the couch, her bag of herbs opening as she looked him over. “I can't do much for your arm but set it,” she told him. “Let's see those feet first, though.”

         Bilbo looked away, not wanting to see the expression on her face when the ruin of his soles were exposed. It was a hobbit's greatest shame to bleed like this, to bear the marks of their failings for all to see with each step they took. Lalia was gentle as she turned his feet to the light and at her sound of surprise Bilbo forced himself to look at her.

         “What is it? Is it worse?”

         “No,” her brows were drawn tight together. Bilbo saw Fortinbras move so he could get his own look and from the way his cousin's expression eased Bilbo knew the wounds hadn't progressed to another level. At least not yet.

         “Then what is it?”

         “They're healing,” Lalia said, still bent to her task. “Fortinbras, be a dear and get me that candle. Thank you, dear.” More light was added as she ordered her family about, bringing in large wooden bowls for Bilbo to dip his feet into. To his relief the touch of water to the wounds did not hurt. But...

         “What does it mean?” Bilbo looked between Fortinbras and Lalia. “They weren't healing before. If the curse is getting worse, then they shouldn't being healing, they should...” He gave a faint gesture to his arm.

         “What exactly happened when you went out today?” Fortinbras asked after a long shared look with his wife.

         Bilbo hesitated but under Lalia's sharp gaze he gave in and told them where he had gone and what he had seen.

         “Strange,” Fortinbras said after he'd taken a seat and lit a pipe as Bilbo told his story. Lalia had finished cleaning Bilbo's feet and a simple splint was made for his arm and then the whole thing was strapped across his chest. “You're definitely healing. We can see it happening while you spoke.”

         “But what...” Bilbo let the question trail off when Fortinbras held up a hand. His cousin's gaze was focused into the middle distance, brows drawn together as he puffed on his pipe.

         “Usually such signs mean that whatever judgment was cast upon you has been lifted,” Fortinbras finally said. “But you said the dwarves still appeared angry?”

         Bilbo burrowed down into the plush cushions of the couch. “Very,” he muttered.

         “Strange,” Fortinbras murmured, gaze still on something only he could see. “Strange.”

         “Perhaps they've come to their senses, then,” Lalia said as she came back in from the kitchen, where she'd gone to dispose of the bloody bowls and other utensils. “After all you did nothing wrong, Bilbo Baggins.”

         He ducked his head at that pronouncement. He well knew that there were some of the widows who did not agree with Lalia but her position as Head Matriarch trumped them all. “I did drag you all here, though,” he pointed out.

         Lalia leveled a spoon at him. “None of that. You gave the answers to a mourning wail of us and passed the tests. Whatever brought us here was no doing of you, Bilbo Baggins. Get that ego of yours under control or I'll do it for you.”

         “Yes, ma'am.”

         “Good.” Her spoon turned to point at her husband. “Have you checked on the Bounders yet? See if their feet are healing like Bilbo's?”

         “Not yet,” Fortinbras gave himself a shake and that distance in his gaze as gone. “I'll do that in the morning. Most have come in from their explorations. Tommy Gilhock ran into a group of dwarves near the main tunnels, though he did not know why they were there. Said they looked a bit dodgy but they're dwarves,” Fortinbras made a face. “And it's black as pitch out there, so who knows what Tommy actually saw. I called all the Bounders back after that. We'll have a meeting tomorrow to figure out what we can do about the doors.” They all glanced over at the smial doors. All of them led to that one tunnel, even in the warren of the Great Smials. There was no where else they could fall back to if the dwarves of Erebor decided to break them down and eradicate them all smial by smial. They could retreat into the in between but then what? Where would they go? Where would they be safe?

         “Remy Oldwalker said that the wizard did arrive today though,” Fortinbras continued. Bilbo perked up at that. “He came in as you were going out I believe Bilbo. Said something about how the dwarves outside are talking about some great party of others headed this way too.”

         “Others?” Bilbo glanced between Fortinbras and Lalia. “Who else is coming?”

         “Elves and Men,” Fortinbras made a face while Lalia made a rude sound in the back of her throat. “Seems like something's gone and happened Outside. We'll need more eyes and ears for when they come. Perhaps these elves can help us if that wizard can't.”

         “Elrond is the wisest being I know,” Bilbo said. “I'm sure he'll have some idea of what to do if Gandalf doesn't.”

         “He'd better,” Lalia muttered, her gaze darting to the door where Ferumbras had been put to bed. “The faunts need the sunlight. It's not good for them to be cooped up in here.”

         Bilbo bit his tongue, looking down at his hands. He was well aware of that worry. They all were. Darkness did...strange things to hobbits. It made them fey. Wild. Violent. There were already rotas of hobbits going out to the mountainside through an old, half collapsed door they'd found, each a small party at a time, just so that they could get some sort of sun once a week. But their people needed full sun, needed to feel the wind in their hair, the soil worked between their fingers, the pulse of the earth beneath their feet.

         “I'll go out tomorrow too,” Bilbo said as the silence dragged on. Fortinbras protested but held his tongue when Bilbo shook his head. “I know the widows cleared me of their own Judgments but I feel that this is something I must do. I'll go out to the tower of ravens and see what I can find out from the birds there. They don't seem to see us very well and they like to gossip. They'll know when the elves are going to show up and maybe Gandalf will be there and I can talk to him.”

         Fortinbras looked to Lalia. Lalia made a face and stayed silent. “If you're sure,” his cousin said.

         “I'm sure,” Bilbo said. Even though he was tired and all he wanted was Thorin and Dwalin and – he shut that thought down hard. His dwarves were gone. Even if...even if they had lifted the Judgment on him by some miracle how could he ever face them again? He had betrayed them. They were still all so angry. He let Lalia and Fortinbras fuss over him for that night, resolving to head out early in the morning once his feet had healed up more. If there was anything Bilbo had learned in these last long few weeks was that there was little rest for the weary. And Bilbo was weary down to the bones but things still had to be done.

         One step at a time. Just one step at a time.

Chapter 7: too lonely for the traffic of the world

Chapter Text

        Thorin stepped out from the shadow of the mountain and turned his face to the sun, closing his eyes against the sharp glare. The warmth felt good on his face. It would be years yet for the interior of Erebor to regain the humid warmth of its heyday, when it would be pleasant even in the depths of winter. The rooms the Company had taken inside the mountain were warm enough with fires roaring in the grates but they would have to be careful with their firewood rationing since the winter seemed to be coming early this year.

        Gandalf was at Erebor's main gates handling the mess of men and elves that had arrived and were about to arrive on their doorstep that morning. Thorin had been determined to be gracious, to be a better dwarf than his forefathers, to attempt to make peace between their peoples when it seemed as though whatever was going on in the world had something to do with Erebor itself, but when Thranduil had arrived...

        Gandalf had been at Thorin's side when the king of the Greenwood had ridden up on his ridiculous moose. He was the only one mounted, surrounded by a number of his green-clad elven guards.

        (And if, perhaps, Thorin had spotted Kíli's Tauriel, well. There had been a number of reasons why Thorin had promised both himself and his nephews to be on his best behavior that morning.)

        Thranduil had already had his nose up in the air and an attitude to match. The elf king had swung down from that mount – where were they even going to stable the thing? – and stood before Thorin and Gandalf with a flourish that even the best midsummer mummers couldn't pull off. Thorin had found himself puffing out his chest before he could stop himself, raising his chin to meet that imperious gaze head on and refusing to back down.

        “Well, if it isn't the King Under the Mountain,” Thranduil's mouth twisted, no doubt trying to smile but Thorin thought the pompous ass couldn't remember how to use those particular facial muscles. “How...gracious of you to meet me in person.”

        Thorin swallowed down the many unpleasant words he wanted to say to Thranduil and instead gave the elf a short nod. “The strange affairs Arda is now facing seem to find their start here in Erebor. I am happy to host all those who wish to find out the cause of all these occurrences, should those who arrive be respectful and come in peace.”

        Thranduil's lip had curled, those pale eyes looking Thorin up and down like he was little more than a clump of dirt beneath that elf king's boot. Then a sharp light had entered the elf's eyes and he'd opened his mouth to say, “Do tell, King Thorin. Where is that little ferret that was scurrying about in your shadow the last I saw? He was so generous to us. Unlike...you.”

       Thorin had not – sadly – punched Thranduil in the face. The sting of the words hit a wound that was still sore and bloody from the sight of Bilbo falling from the battlements the day before. Gandalf had pushed forward then with a stern, “Thranduil ,” and had guided the smirking elf king away. Thorin had been trembling with the need to put his fist through something, though, so instead of creating more hurt he'd taken himself off to a walk instead, Dwalin a vibrating silent guard at his side.

       Balin had promised to take care of the rest of the arriving elves and men. Thankfully they would not have to host the entire lot – no, Elrond had sent word that they would be bringing their own people to set up their own camp so that they did not stress Erebor's already creaking supplies. The leader of the men coming, this Aragorn, had also sent word that they would be setting up their own camps near Elrond, though there had been no word yet from Gondor or Rohan. So instead of dealing with that mess – and Thranduil's...everything – Thorin had let his feet take him where they may...until he realized that they were on a certain path, one that he had been avoiding for all these weeks.

       Thorin had stopped just shy of breaking free of the mountain's shadow, looking out over the path that would take them to the tower where they had seen Bilbo during Thorin's terrible fight with Azog. The area still bore scars of that battle, the broken buildings low on the list of things that needed to be repaired. If Thorin had his way he would have just razed the entire area to the ground and had a garden built there instead but Balin had talked him out of it. For now. Thorin was well aware that by retaking Erebor he had reentered the arena of politics in a way that he had not been in since he was a young prince watching his father and grandfather be eaten alive by the gold sickness that had seemed to swamp the mountain as a whole.

        Ever since the destruction of Khazad-dûm their peoples had existed in their own small nations around Arda, with the Iron Hills being the largest of the lot after Erebor's demise. Many of Erebor's folk had gone to the Iron Hills, swelling their numbers and their artisan clans after the Calamity had driven them all out of their homes. The other bulk of Erebor's refugees had gone to the Blue Mountains and settled there, though the ore was difficult to mine and dealing with the Men of the area had been a constant struggle. Not that Thorin's father had paid much attention to that, so focused as he was on retaking Khazad-dûm and reestablishing a great kingdom for himself full of gold and silver and the ever elusive mithril.

        Thorin had known he would owe his cousin Dáin a great favor for his aid in the Battle of Five Armies. Just what that favor would be, none of them knew. Thorin knew Balin feared that Dáin would ask for all of the artisan clans that had relocated to the Iron Hills be given over to Dáin's rule formally, which would cripple Erebor's rebirth mightily. Glóin thought Dáin might ask for what remained of the treasury. Thorin knew Nori feared that Dáin would try to force some of the Iron Hills nobles into Thorin's court to slowly take over, for they all knew that Thorin had no wife and would have no heir but his nephews. Already Thorin had heard whispers about dwarven maidens being on their way to Erebor to size up both Fíli and Kíli as potential spouses.

        It was going to be a mess, Thorin knew it. So he had to pick his battles, even now, with an eye on politics and how it would play out to both his people and the ever-watching Iron Hills folk that still haunted their halls.

        Which led him here, stepping out into the sunlight for what felt like the first time in an Age, feeling that warmth on his face, on his palms, which tingled faintly, just like they had when Bilbo's blood had vanished in that crackle of strange flame.

        Thorin opened his eyes to look down at his palms, flexing his hands a few times. Perhaps it was his imagination but he thought for a moment he saw a flicker of blue flame between his fingers, there and gone.

        “Thorin?”

        He looked up to see Dwalin staring at him with dark eyes. His partner had held him so tight the entire night, the both of them staring out from their bed to their mourning box where the few trinkets they still had of Bilbo's remained. “It is going to be a long few weeks,” he said to Dwalin's tight expression.

        Dwalin made a face, making Thorin smile at last. “That poncy...” Dwalin trailed off into incomprehensible mutters as he kicked at the stones on the path. Thorin turned, watching those stones bounce over the earth, to finally look at the place where his feet had taken them and where he had least wanted to be. The river had healed the cracks that had been made in its icy surface but the desolation of the ruined towers remained. The broken buildings were still blackened with soot, though whether it was from dragon fire or orcs, Thorin did not know. The patches of snow about the towers and hills were growing from the occasional flurries that swept across the mountain from time to time. The tiny white flowers that had popped up all over the battlefields remained, still flourishing despite the dropping temperatures and the creeping line of snow growing ever lower and lower.

       Thorin gazed over the ruined structures, picking out the spot where they'd found Fíli and Kíli, laid out like they were dead and ready to return to the stone from which their people had come. Where he himself had been laying in Dwalin's arms after his partner had rolled the body of Azog off of Thorin, fearing they were both dead. Where they had both looked to the horizon, seeing the eagles sweeping in from the storm-gray clouds like the miracle they were...only to realize that they were also seeing Bilbo there, indistinct against that angry sky.

        Thorin let his feet take him forward, across that scarred ice, to the black and pitted courtyard that had once been a tower of their people. Dwalin was a silent specter at his side. Neither of them spoke as Thorin came to a stop where his boys had been laid out. Their hands had been folded on their chests, expressions so peaceful and calm. It was still a mystery as to how they had gotten there. The last Thorin knew of the two of them, Azog's orcs were stalking them through the ruins, trying to flush them out to torment Thorin with killing them before his very eyes. Of the orcs that had come with Azog, no bodies had been found. It was as if they had vanished. It had unsettled them all.

        “Do you think...” Thorin had to stop and swallow against a painful knot in his throat. “Do you think it worked? Do you think that Bilbo is at peace, now? That he is no longer...” He could not face Dwalin. Not here. Not now.

        "I hope it did,” he heard Dwalin sigh. “It was...Thorin, you weren't in your right mind. None of us were. You never would have said such things to him, done such things, if you...”

        “Were not gold-mad,” Thorin finished for him when the words did not come.

       “If we all were not gold-mad,” Dwalin's hands turned Thorin so he had to look up into Dwalin's eyes. “We all carry the blame in that, Thorin, not you alone.”

        “But I...”

        “Thorin,” Dwalin gave him a small shake. “Tell me now, then. Do you dream of the gold in our treasury? Do you dream of the gems and riches Erebor will grace us with again? Do you –”

        “No,” the word tore out of his throat. “You know I don't. Why would you –”

        “Then you see?” Dwalin gave him another shake. “The gold-sickness had its hooks in you – in us – for far longer than we knew. Perhaps it had something to do with whatever nonsense these elves think is going on. Who knows? But you, in your right mind, would have never hurt Bilbo. Never. I know this to be true, Thorin. For just as you would not hurt him now, nor would I. And we...” Dwalin stopped and blinked fast but the tears in his eyes did not fall. “We have to hope that Bilbo hears our sincerity. That we never blamed him for anything and that he and all his people are welcome here, for all the days of all their lives, had they lived and even now...wherever they might be.”

        Thorin stared at his partner, his lover, his friend. They had been bound together with the knowledge that they would share a One for as long as Thorin could remember. They had dreamed about it as youths, here in this same mountain, whispering how they would Court their One with all the honors they were due. How they would cherish their One and put them first, before all the gold in Erebor and even the mithril in Khazad-dûm. Then the Calamity had come and all those dreams had gone up in dragon fire and the grind of the wheel of time moving on and no sight of their One to be seen.

        A part of Thorin had feared their One had died in the destruction of Erebor. A part of him had selfishly hoped that their One had survived, was marching with them even as their people were searching across Arda's vast lands, looking for a new home. To think that their One had been one Bilbo Baggins of the Shire, a hobbit of those fertile lands that few ever even saw...even now it seemed like a strange dream.

        “I want him to be at peace,” Thorin whispered, not daring to say the words louder. It felt like a secret he could only share with Dwalin. “For if Bilbo is at peace, then...then maybe he would visit us again. That...that if he is at peace then he won't be so scared of us anymore.”

        “Thorin, you...”

        Thorin didn't hear the rest of Dwalin's words, for just as Dwalin began to speak something hot and wet splashed onto his cheek. It made Thorin flinch back, startled at the sensation. One hand came up, brushing at it. Was he crying? But his vision had not blurred and it did not feel as though his eyes were burning. But when he looked down at his fingertips, expecting something clear, he did not expect to see bright crimson blood staining his skin.

        “What...”

       “Thorin? Thorin?”

        Thorin looked up at Dwalin, seeing his partner take in the streak of blood on his face, on his fingers. Then, as one, they both looked up.

       To see one Bilbo Baggins staring back at them. Their One was seated on the edge of a broken upper floor to the tower, pale and wan, with deep circles under his eyes. And, worst of all, were the deep cuts on the soles of Bilbo's feet, the wounds that had dripped blood onto Thorin's face. That were still dripping blood onto Thorin and now onto Dwalin's hand and arm where he had grabbed at Thorin's shoulders. Then, as Thorin was staring, he could pick out even more details. The thinness to Bilbo's cheeks. The paleness of his complexion. The way his arm was broken and strapped across his chest in a rough splint.

        The wizard's words about the wounds hobbits would bear due to the judgments cast down on them rang in Thorin's ears. All he could do was stare up at Bilbo, at their One, all the words he wanted to say drying up in his throat.

        Then Bilbo, their One, opened his mouth and said in the smallest voice Thorin had ever heard, “You don't hate me?”

        Thorin heard his throat make some strange noise before he found his voice. “No,” he croaked out, needing Bilbo to hear and understand him. “Never. I swear it. Bilbo, I am so, so sorry. I never...” He shook his head, feeling his heart hammering in his chest. He could not bungle this. Not now. Not again. “I will swear upon whatever you wish. I do not hate you. I could never hate you.”

        Then Bilbo's gaze moved to Dwalin and Thorin felt his partner start to tremble from where they were connected. “Never,” Dwalin breathed. Thorin saw the way the words reached their Bilbo, the way his eyes went wide, how he rocked back, as if the words were physical things that could hit him. “I could never hate you Bilbo. I swear it.”

       “But you...” Their Bilbo shook his head, lips pressed tight together for a moment. “I saw you,” he whispered. “On the – the battlements. You were so angry .” He pulled his legs up and the movement caused more blood to splatter down over Thorin's arms and chest. “I'm sorry –”

        “Bilbo, wait –”

        “I betrayed you –”

        “You didn't – Bilbo, I will swear to it, you didn't –”

       “I was just so scared,” Bilbo whispered. It felt like a punch to the chest. All the air left Thorin in a rush. “You had all turned so strange and I couldn't stop it and I –”

        “Bilbo, no, it wasn't your fault –”

        Those blue eyes focused on them once more. “But you're better now. I fixed it. We all did. At least a little. At least a bit. But now...now we – I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to –”

       “Bilbo, wait –,” but just then the tower Bilbo was sitting on gave a thunderous crack and time seemed to slow. It was all Thorin could do to watch as Bilbo's eyes went wide. As he said something Thorin could not hear as the floor Bilbo was sitting on sagged, as the walls of the very tower Bilbo was sitting in started to cave in on themselves. As Bilbo threw himself back, like he had on the battlements, into the collapse of the building, away from them.

        Thorin did not know how he ended up on his knees, Dwalin at his back with his partner's strong arms wrapped about his chest, screaming Bilbo's name at the top of his lungs as the tower crumpled to dust in front of them. Not a single stone hit them. It all just piled up into a hill of rubble that would be Bilbo's grave...if he had been alive.

       “No,” Thorin whispered, tasting metal on the back of his tongue. Dwalin's chest was heaving at his back, great sobs shuddering out of him. “No, Bilbo. Bilbo, please.”

        But nothing answered him. Just the sound of the wind coming off the side of the mountain, sounding like a scream.

Chapter 8: to die into the labyrinth of self

Chapter Text

        Bilbo crept out of the Thain's smial, his feet silent on the warm, worn floors of his cousin's home. The hour was early enough that only the sun-keepers were up, though their usual rituals had been stymied by the position of their people so deep inside the mountain. As he eased the door shut, shivering a little in the chill of the in between, he thought he could hear Fortinbras' snoring coming down the hall. His cousin was not going to be pleased that Bilbo left so early and without breakfast but he had already stayed long enough with them and did not want to stress their stores even though he knew that the Thain and his family would never go without, not with the Took family's reserves still in place.

       Bilbo straightened once the door was closed and he found himself alone in the strange tunnels of the in between. He glanced around, noting for the first time how a strange, angular pattern had started to appear along the curved top of the tunnel and also near ankle-height above the ground. The decoration looked almost like the ones he saw inside Erebor, since most hobbit decoration tended to more natural, flowing lines or flowers and the like. Even their scarecrows were made plump and curved by thick stuffing and sturdy clothes. The pattern was not clear as some of the other decorations in the tunnels were, though, so Bilbo did not know just what it all meant. Was it because they were in Erebor? Was it something he had done? It was frustrating not having any answers.

       With that thought top of mind Bilbo turned to wind his way through the tunnels towards Bag End. Walking was not particularly pleasant – even with Lalia's herbs and the cleansing bath he'd gotten for them last night the soles of his feet felt sore and tender, as if the merest pressure would split open that healing skin. Still they were healing, so that was a blessing, even if Bilbo could scarce believe it himself.

        Never in all his life did he think his Company would forgive him. Not enough to lift such a judgment as had been passed down onto him. He'd wanted it lifted – of course he did – but more for his people than he, himself. Bilbo still thought he held much of the blame with his dwarves going mad. He had seen it, hadn't he? He had seen how strange they'd all become but what did he do? Nothing. Just held onto that silly mathom as if it were a worry stone and hoped that everything would turn out well.

        Look where that had got him.

        Bilbo winced as he shifted his broken arm, trying to tuck it closer to his body as he made his slow way through the halls. He could feel his stomach growling and promised himself a nice cup of tea and some thick toast once he was home. But when he got there he found that most of his stores were gone – of course they were, his Company had eaten most of it up – and not a bite of bread to be seen in the entire smial. He did get his cup of tea, though, and a bit of hard cheese to ease some of the grumbles coming from his middle. As much as he disliked it he would have to see the Thain – not Fortinbras when it came to things like this, he wouldn't abuse that connection, not now – about some stores of his own. He would not be able to make it through winter with what he alone had and he wasn't about to touch the Baggins' reserves. No, that was for their people first, then him. He'd find his own way through this. He had to.

       Shaking off those dark thoughts Bilbo set himself to rights as best he could, rearranging the straps about his arm so that he lay across his chest in a secure hold. He had to find Gandalf today. He had to. The ravens would only be a place to start. He would need to be at his most sneaky in order to speak to Gandalf if the wizard was somewhere in the maze of tents outside Erebor's front gates. If Gandalf was inside...that would prove both easier and harder. Easier for he could slip in between easier inside Erebor. Harder because...well. There were a lot of dwarves already inside the mountain and more coming every day. Their people had already learned that while they could slip in between to avoid a killing blow, some measure of such an injury would still mark them once they came back out of that strange place. And sometimes...sometimes the wounds were quite grievous, though none yet had died from them.

        Bilbo ran his one good hand through his hair in an attempt to tame it and had to sigh. The things he would do for a bath. Then he gave himself a shake and squared his shoulders. He had procrastinated long enough. The sun was surely up and the ravens at Ravenhill would soon be talking with one another about all sorts of things. It was time for him to get out and see what he could learn.

       Not long after his being Outcast from the Company and the arrival of his people to their new situation, Bilbo had found a path that went from a half collapsed door on the side of the mountain – that same entrance their people used to get sun – straight to Ravenhill. Bilbo was unsure why his dwarves had not used this door and instead been so intent on the passage with the key that needed exact conditions in place to be able to be seen and used. Perhaps they had not known of it? Either way it was better for him that none of the dwarves so far had seemed to remember this door or this path at all. With the amount that their people were starting to use that little door and that area it would soon become apparent that something was happening on that side of the mountain. It was just their luck that it was the south side of the mountain, the most sunny and warm, so that their farmers could pick through the soil there and figure out what best to plant with the time they had remaining in the year.

       Bilbo passed a few hobbits on his way out to the door. The tunnel they all used – the one not in the in between but the one all their smials connected to – had at least a few Bounders in it at all times, watching for any angry dwarves headed their way. A single whistle would get everyone into their homes or the closest doors available but it was the uncertainty of what would happen after that kept many of them up at night.

        The half collapsed door was on the other side of the ridge that ran southwest along the base of the mountain. It made the back of Bilbo's neck prickle to be so close to the front gates of Erebor but at least no dwarves had been seen in this area yet. It was almost as if they were avoiding it but surely that was just his imagination.

        Bilbo made his careful way along the narrow path, wincing from time to time as sharp rocks bit into the tender soles of his feet. He felt like a faunt coming out of growth spurt, the soft-soled they were called. He certainly felt like one. Every other step he was biting back curses as it felt like he'd found the sharpest, most pointy rocks he could possibly walk on. If a few of those curses were in his Company's secret tongue...well. Bifur never seemed to pay much attention to how often he used certain words in their language and Bilbo had heard Dori scolding him enough times to know that the words Bifur was using were of the more colorful kind. Using them now when it felt like every rock went out of its way to get under his feet...well. It felt fitting.

        By the time he got to Ravenhill it was later in the morning than he'd meant to get there. The ravens were already up and fluffed up against the chill wind coming down off the mountainside. Bilbo kept to the the long shadows as he drew on the Old Skills, walking silent as a field mouse in a thick meadow, careful and slow and almost invisible. Most hobbits in the Shire had rarely used those old talents, except for faunts who were nipping pies off windowsills which had seemed the only use for them, then. Now, though, the skills were coming back faster than anyone had expected, even to the oldest of them, allowing them all to creep about Erebor's halls unseen.

       Bilbo picked his way up through the ruins, crossing the icy river at the rocks and trying not to look at the scars in the ice where Thorin and Azog had fought their desperate duel. Bilbo had been so afraid Thorin was going to die. Azog was a terror, a giant monster swinging that massive mace with such force that it had caused the earth to tremble each time it hit the ground. Bilbo had kept to the in between, his feet still so tender to the new cuts opening on his soles that he had not been able to stay in the outside for long at all. That was when he had found a strange little tunnel going under the water and with some sort of strange luck on his side Bilbo had managed to collapse that ice under Azog's feet at just the right time for Thorin to cut off that monster's head with one clean blow of his sword.

       Once Bilbo reached the top of the ruined tower he stared down at that river and courtyard for a long moment, lost in those memories. He'd been so desperate to do something – anything – to make up for his betrayal of his Company, of Thorin, of Dwalin. He'd wanted...well. He'd wanted many things. To apologize. To beg for forgiveness. To see them, one last time. To make sure that they would survive, even if it cost him his own life. He had never expected them to see him. Bilbo had stayed in between , where the bitter chill did not cut him to the bone and it did not hurt to move his feet. But they'd seen him. They had seen him, had...had...

        An explosion of ravens made Bilbo flinch and his heel to slip on what felt like ice. He fell back, trying to keep his feet – and his body on the tower – only to feel the soles of his feet lance with pain. Bilbo ended up on his rear, cursing the ravens, the tower, pretty much everything around him as he flexed his toes, feeling warm blood slide down his soles from where he'd surely cut them open once again.

        Lalia was going to cuff him about the ears and he'd deserve it this time. He should have been paying more attention. He needed to be stalking the ravens, not being startled by them. He needed to find out what was going on with Gandalf and the visitors that were coming to Erebor. He needed...he needed...

        “Do you think...” The words came from a voice that Bilbo would know anywhere. “Do you think it worked? Do you think that Bilbo is at peace, now? That he is no longer...”

        Bilbo crawled on one hand and his knees, peering over the edge of the ruined tower ledge, looking down to see Thorin and Dwalin standing below in the courtyard. Bilbo could do nothing but stare, his heart beating high in his throat as he listened to them, as the words rang and repeated in his ears. He did not know when he had swung his feet over the edge, like he was about to jump off and into their arms. As if they would ever...

       Then they were looking up, looking at him and Bilbo froze, forgetting that he was not in between. He saw the way their expressions crumpled. He saw Dwalin's lips move but no sound came. Bilbo did not mean to say what he did, but it just came out, his deepest fear and the terror that would chase him out of sleep five nights out of seven.

        “You don't hate me?”

        Thorin made some strange sound before he said, “No, never. I swear it. Bilbo, I am so, so sorry. I never...” He shook his head and Bilbo traced the way those beads by his face swung, almost as if they were moving through molasses. Bilbo barely heard Thorin say, “I will swear upon whatever you wish. I do not hate you. I could never hate you.”

        Bilbo couldn't help but look at Dwalin. Dwalin, the first of the Company he had met. Dwalin, the one he had been a little bit afraid of, at least until the Carrock and the way Dwalin had hugged him so tight and picked Bilbo right up off the ground with it. “Never,” Dwalin breathed, staring up at him. Bilbo could not look away. “I could never hate you Bilbo. I swear it.”

       “But you...” Bilbo shook his head, lips pressed tight together for a moment, all the words he wanted to say tangled up in his throat. “I saw you,” he whispered. “On the – the battlements. You were so angry .” He pulled his legs up and the movement caused more blood to splatter down over Thorin's arms and chest. Bilbo flushed with shame. “I'm sorry –”

        “Bilbo, wait –”

        “I betrayed you –”

        “You didn't – Bilbo, I will swear to it, you didn't –”

       “I was just so scared,” Bilbo whispered. He wanted to tell them that. He needed to tell them that. So they would understand. “You had all turned so strange and I couldn't stop it and I –”

        “Bilbo, no, it wasn't your fault –”

        Bilbo shook his head, biting at his lower lip. “But you're better now. I fixed it. We all did.” But at what price? He had never meant for any of it to happen. “At least a little. At least a bit. But now...now we – I'm so sorry, I didn't mean to –”

       “Bilbo, wait –,” but just then the tower Bilbo was sitting on gave a thunderous crack and time seemed to slow.

       “I love –,” Bilbo managed to get out before the floor beneath him gave way and it was all he could do to throw himself back, pulling with everything he had, feeling the tower turn to him like metal to a magnet. There was a roar and what sounded like Thorin screaming, a note to his voice Bilbo had never heard before and never wanted to hear again.

       Then, between one blink and the next, Bilbo let his body fall in between and he was gone.

Chapter 9: no accident of peace nor war

Chapter Text

        Bilbo landed in Bag End's front hall, covered in dust and coughing his lungs out, his arm aching, his feet stinging but more importantly than all that his dwarves did not hate him.

        It was possibly the best day he had ever had.

       Bilbo lay there and stared up at the ceiling, feeling a ridiculous smile stretching his face. The bruises that were sure to bloom over his skin from pulling that tower inward with him were going to appear soon and he would be so sore in the morning but Thorin and Dwalin did not hate him . The words kept repeating in his head. The way...the way they had spoke about him. About how they – how they did not blame him, not for any of it, even if he blamed himself. How they...how they had never wanted to hurt him. How they knew now that the gold-sickness had twisted them up like knots. How they wanted him to be at peace –

        Wait a minute.

       Bilbo felt his smile falter as he ran their words through his mind yet again. Why would they want him to be at peace? Why not with them? Why did they look so devastated when he was standing right there...oh no.

       Oh no.

       Bilbo sat bolt upright and then gagged at the pain that swept through him. That was unpleasant. Then he shook that off and concentrated on what was important. There was no way his idiot dwarves thought he was dead...right?

        Right?

       Bother. Snap and blast . Of course they would think he was dead, he threw himself off the blasted battlements in front of them and they never found a body – but then surely they would think he was alive? Unless...did dwarves leave bodies? But of course they did, Bilbo and his folk had seen a number of fallen dwarven warriors on the battlefield despite their best efforts in keeping everyone alive. But did they know hobbits left bodies? But then how...

       Then he wanted to brain himself because he still didn't know where Gandalf was or where the elves and men had decided to camp out and – and – and –

       Bilbo levered himself up and off the ground, wincing his way to the door and out into the in between . Lalia was sure to box his ears but Bilbo needed to speak to Fortinbras immediately. If what Bilbo thought was right, their people might not have to panic about leaving Erebor's halls so quick just yet. But they would have to be smart about it. Bilbo would have to approach them again, safely, to try and figure out just what his dwarves were thinking and how – if Bilbo were not, in fact, dead – they felt about that, then...

       Well. A great many problems Bilbo had felt weighing down on his chest might just be lifted. Just a bit. But they had to be careful. They had to be sure. But first he needed to speak to Fortinbras and Lalia and make a plan. Everything else could wait.

 

 

~*~

 

       Thorin had no memory of how he got back to Erebor's Great Gate. He was sure to look a state. Bilbo's blood was drying on his skin and clothes and a part of Thorin hoped that it would not disappear this time. That he would have something – anything – of Bilbo's to keep. Then shame swept through him. To hold the lifeblood of another dwarf, their One or not, without permission was a grave sin of their people's. But Thorin also could not bear to wipe it away. The blood was Bilbo's . It had been warm when it met Thorin's skin. Warm like life and if that...if that was the closest he would ever get to...

       “Thorin. Thorin.”

        He blinked to see Balin standing in front of him, a faint, worried frown on his face. But in his hands was a white silk cloth, surely given to him by one of their holy people. Thorin took it with trembling fingers and allowed Balin to guide his hands to wipe up the blood on his face with that blessed cloth. Then Balin was turning to Dwalin and was giving Thorin's partner his own piece of silk, watching over them both as Thorin and Dwalin wiped up was few drops were left on their hands and arms, making sure to catch it all onto that holy silk so that none would be able to take Bilbo's lifeblood but them. They would have to cut out the parts of their clothes that had been anointed or else burn them in the Great Forges in the center of the mountain. Thorin would not risk anyone getting their hands on the clothes, not now.

        Thankfully they seemed to be in one of the tents outside the gate when Thorin managed to get his wits about himself once more. His throat felt sore from screaming and he wished he did not have to see Bilbo disappearing into a cloud of dust and rocks as the tower came down around him, but at least he had not watched Bilbo fall to his death off the battlements once more.

        “Ah, Thorin, there you are. We were worried...what has happened here?”

        Thorin looked up to see Gandalf ducking in through the tent entrance, his hat gone but staff in hand. Behind him was that same Elrond Thorin had met in Rivendell all those months ago. It felt like a lifetime ago.

        “We saw Bilbo,” Thorin blinked up at the wizard, still feeling a bit dazed. “We were at Ravenhill. It was the last place we saw him, before...before the battlements. I thought...”

        Warm hands covered his and that was when Thorin realized that Gandalf had knelt before him, putting them at the same height. The wizard was peering at him, his bushy brows drawn tight together. “You are pale,” he said. “Elrond, would you mind looking Thorin over?”

        Thorin rocked back at that, unable to stop a scowl forming on his face. “I am fine.”

        “Nonsense, you look a fright. Elrond?”

        “If I have your permission, King Thorin?” Elrond gave him a bow, which made Thorin feel slightly better about Gandalf's fussing. Thorin glanced at Dwalin and wanted to wince. If he looked half as bad as Dwalin did it was no wonder that his people had put him in a tent and out of sight. Though how Balin knew to have one of their holy ones prepare such measures he did not know. Nor did he know just how long they had been in this tent.

        Perhaps it would be a good idea for the elf to look him over after all.

        After a brief look over by Elrond – who said Thorin and Dwalin were suffering from a shock but were fine otherwise – Thorin had a warm mug of tea in hand and Dwalin's solid presence pressed up against his side. They had been moved from the tent to a room inside the mountain. Thorin had seen Dáin in the press of dwarves outside the tent when they had emerged but there were logistics Thorin had to go over with Balin and Bofur had an immediate concern about one of the central staircases in the main cavern beyond the gates and one of Bombur's assistants had come to them saying that they were getting low on potatoes and the new shipment from Gondor was late by a week and –

        Well. There were many things Thorin had to handle before he could address his cousin's surly demeanor and that strange glint in his eye. As it was Glóin had to peel off to take care of the rest of the parties arriving at their gates. Thankfully Lord Elrond had gone with Thorin's old friend to help organize his own party – though how much of that this Lord Elrond would be doing was anyone's guess. But Thorin could worry about that later. Right now he needed the warmth of a drink in his hand and Dwalin's presence at his side, grounding him in the here and now.

        Gandalf had taken a seat by the fire as Thorin and Dwalin were settled onto the couch. Balin was with them and Ori as well, his ink and journal ready to take notes. The young dwarf had been invaluable during their weeks after the battle, oftentimes trailing after either Thorin or Balin as they went over all the things their people would need going forward to make their mountain livable again.

       “You said you saw Bilbo,” Gandalf murmured from his chair. The wizard's gaze was directed at the hearth, not at them. “How...how did he appear?”

        Thorin looked down at his tea, watching the ripples in the surface for a long moment. “Pale,” he said, thinking back. “Worn. I...we did not even know he was there until...” He had to stop and swallow against a knot in his throat. “His blood fell on us. His feet were sliced open, red and painful looking.” He could hear Ori's pen scratch slow. “He had one arm strapped across his chest. I think it was broken.”

        All Thorin could hear was the crackle of the fire. Then Gandalf sighed, a long, sad sound that turned Thorin's head. He saw the wizard droop in his seat, that gray head bow until his chin hit his chest. His pipe was forgotten in his hand.

        “I see,” Gandalf said. At some point he had closed his eyes. “You spoke to him?”

        “Yes,” Thorin felt Dwalin press into his side. “We – I said I wished him to be at peace and that was when he appeared and – and –,” he had to stop and gather himself. “He said, you don't hate me?” Thorin could not help the way his voice broke on the words. “We swore to him that we did not hate him, Gandalf. I swear it. I would do anything –”

        “Be careful,” Gandalf's hand came up but his head stayed bowed and eyes shut. “Do not make any oaths, Thorin Oakenshield. Not right now.”

        That made Thorin pause. “Why? What is going on, Gandalf?”

        The wizard made no sound for a long, long moment. Then he sighed once more, a soft thing, and his eyes opened. One hand came up to rub at the spot between his eyes. “Much of what I know of hobbits comes from observing them. I have long been a friend to them over the long years on Arda's shores but not even I know all of their secrets. I do not doubt that you lifted your judgment of Bilbo Baggins. Nor do I doubt that you have welcomed all of his people into the mountain, as foolish a decision that could have been.”

        “Foolish?” Thorin glanced at Dwalin, who could only shrug in confusion. “How could that ever be foolish?”

        Gandalf dropped his hand and puffed on his pipe for a moment. “Hobbits have a strange way of making oaths stick, whether you meant to make it or not. As I know it, hobbits came from a place they do not speak of to Outsiders.” Even Thorin could hear the capital letter there. “Their history is a surprisingly long one, if you know where to look. Perhaps almost as old as dwarves.” Gandalf tilted his head to one side, still staring into the fire. Thorin felt a chill touch the back of his neck. Well did he know the history of his people, how the dwarven fathers were allowed to wake only after the Firstborn had awoken in the world before even the sun and moon were created. To think that Bilbo's people could be as old as theirs...

        “Truly?” It was Ori who voiced the question. “Our people have been around since before the moon first rose.”

        “I said almost,” Gandalf pointed the stem of his pipe at Ori, who ducked his head. Then the half smile on his face faded just as fast as it came. “If I am right...and I fear I am...then the race of hobbits have been a part of Arda's history since at least the First Age.”

        “But where were they?” Thorin curled his hands about his mug, holding it tight. “Bilbo said the hobbits have been in the Shire for perhaps a little over a thousand years at most. That does not even span all of the Third Age, much less...”

        Gandalf nodded, tapping the mouth of his pipe to his lips. “Indeed. The hobbits, before they came to the Shire, were a traveling folk, as I told you before. But they did not rise from this area. Even I have not been told in so many words where they came from, but there were songs...” His gaze was focused on some distant thing. “A dark tower and trees of stone. Once I had thought they meant Mordor but now...now I fear a much darker place was their original home.”

        “Then where?”

       “A place that would have been steeped in the magics of the Valar and many other things. A place where, if a body was lucky and smart, they could eek out a life in the shadows, learning how best to make even the most poor soil grow food. Where they would have seen the kinds of things that would put weight to their widows and their judgments, to their Oaths and Rules in a way that you nor I could ever understand, Thorin Oakenshield.” Gandalf sighed yet again. “But that is a mere guess and now none of us might know the answer.” He gave himself a shake and that dark gaze went to Thorin and pinned him in place. “You said Bilbo bled on you? You're sure?”

        “I am,” Thorin swallowed back all the questions he wanted to ask. The silk with Bilbo's blood was tucked close against his heart and he would not allow even Gandalf to see or handle it. Not now.

        Gandalf's mouth pursed. “And it was warm? It felt like living blood?”

        “It did.”

        “Strange,” Gandalf muttered. “What else did he say?”

       Thorin repeated all he could remember from the few moments they'd had with Bilbo. Dwalin added what he could remember as well. And when he got to the part where Bilbo said he – they – had 'fixed it' Gandalf sat up straight in his seat, his pipe forgotten in his hand.

       “You're sure he said it like that?”

        “We are,” Thorin said, sharing another look with Dwalin. Ori's pen was flying over his parchment. “Why? And who is Bilbo talking about? It was he alone here in Erebor. Who else could he be talking about?”

       Gandalf's gaze seemed to track something only he could see. “Hobbits have a knack, I have long theorized, given from where they came from, to be able to fix things. Perhaps it was the reason they were created,” was said softer, as if to himself. “Not in any sense that men or dwarves or even elves would understand the meaning of it. No, they do not fix things so much as...situations, I suppose you could say. And if Bilbo had found what I think he found, and he wanted to fix that situation...”

        “What do you mean, what Bilbo found?”

        “Do you remember, after the mess in Goblin Town, the little ring Bilbo would keep in his pocket?” Gandalf sat back in his chair, pipe back at his mouth. “I have spoken long with Elrond and Galadriel over the news of Mordor's destruction. It is why Elrond has come with his people, why Galadriel has left Lothlórien and is coming here. It is why the Rangers are here.”

        None of that made sense. “Mordor has been destroyed? When? Why would they come here over a simple magic ring when there other such things afoot? There were many made in the Second Age, many yet that linger in the world or in the treasures of trolls and dragons in the north. Why are you so worried about it?”

       Gandalf breathed out a smoke circle, thin and wavering, looking much like a giant ring that turned crimson in the light of the fire before it broke apart into wisps. “Because if what I fear is true, our Bilbo did not find a simple magic ring under the mountains. I fear that what he found and in destroying it, in fixing it, as you heard him say, then our Bilbo has done the one thing myself and my order and the White Council has been working towards for over an Age.”

        “And what is that?”

        Thorin felt Dwalin take his hand as Gandalf spoke, the words ringing in the room like a bell. “That our Bilbo found, and destroyed, the One Ring of Sauron and has thus freed us and all of Arda from the great darkness that yet lingered in our lands.”

Chapter 10: certain beyond dreams

Chapter Text

       Gandalf's words rang in Thorin's ears. It was impossible. It had to be. There was no way their Bilbo, one Bilbo Baggins of the Shire, found the One Ring of Sauron simply sitting beneath the Misty Mountains and picked it up for a lark.

       Of course, should anyone pick such a legendary item up, it would just be their Bilbo's luck that it would be him.

       “You're certain Mordor is destroyed? We had heard rumors, but...” Balin was the one to ask. Thorin's old friend was leaning forward in his chair, gaze intent on Gandalf. Ori's pen had still not stopped as it flew over the parchment of his journal.

       “Elrond received word from Turgon, Steward of Gondor, that a great shaking occurred in Minas Tirith. When they went out to scout the lands about their city they found all of Sauron's foul servants withdrawn from Ithilien and, going further, all of Minas Morgul abandoned. That was when they sent their fastest riders to the Black Gate, only for them to see that all of Mordor was...gone.”

       “Gone?” Thorin said. He looked at Balin but his friend's gaze was still pinned to the wizard. “What do you mean gone? Like...like the Shire?”

      “No. I mean it is gone, Thorin Oakenshield. A great hole had appeared, taking most of that dark land with it. Only the mountain ranges survived. All else just...disappeared.”

       Thorin shook his head. “And you think Bilbo did that?”

       “Yes and no,” the firelight shifted shadows over Gandalf's face. “If Bilbo's ring was the One Ring, then the destruction of it would be the undoing of Sauron and all his machinations. Such a feat would be enough to destroy Mordor as it was. However...”

       “What?”

       One of Gandalf's hands curled into a fist. “With the destruction of the One Ring of Sauron it was thought that the time of the elves would come to an end. That the power of the elven Rings would fade and the time of magic in Arda would have come to a close.”

       “But there has been no sign of –,” Thorin caught himself before he spoke the name. Durin the Deathless was more than a legend to their people. Six had come and six had gone. And, according to prophesy, the seventh would mean the end of their people as a whole. No one looked for his coming. Most feared it.

       Gandalf blew out another smoke ring, this time shaded blue before it disappeared. “I have spoken to the holders of the elven Rings and none say that their power has faded. In fact,” here Gandalf paused, his hand uncurling and there Thorin thought he spied a ring and brilliant crimson gem embedded in it upon one finger. “They seem to have grown stronger.”

       “Stronger?” Thorin echoed. “In what way?”

       “Have you not noticed it, Thorin Oakenshield?”

       “Noticed what?”

       “The very air seems clearer. The waters purer. I feared the winter that was coming for in my bones it felt like a harbinger of the world grown darker and yet...” Gandalf shook his head, gaze still on the fire. “Now though the winter comes, I feel a warmth I cannot name. It reminds me of...”

       “Of?” Thorin exchanged a look with Dwalin. His partner had leaned back on the couch, arms crossed over his chest as he stared at the wizard.

      But Gandalf just shook his head. “It is impossible, now,” he said, soft. Thorin closed his eyes as his meaning registered. The Shire. Of course.

       Then he opened them and said, “If Bilbo really did destroy the One Ring, then why are you all coming here? Shouldn't you all meet in Rivendell?”

      “Perhaps,” Gandalf said. “But something calls us here and with such strange things afoot in the world we must listen to the song that guides us all. Thus I am here, thus Elrond is here, and thus shall Galadriel arrive on the morrow. The Steward of Gondor is sending his son, Ecthelion II, to be his voice in our councils here. A representative of the Riders of Rohan have sent their notice that they will arrive soon. Thranduil, as you have noticed,” Gandalf made a face. “Is here and will stay here. Bard and his people are here. And you, of course, and your people, and your cousin, King Dáin of the Iron Hills, is here. Where else should we meet?”

       “Councils,” Thorin said, eyes narrowing. “What councils do you wish to hold here?”

       “With the destruction of Mordor, our great enemy is gone. There are treaties that are no doubt needed to be made, especially if you and your people wish to re-inhabit your mountain, Thorin Oakenshield. I know that Bard would like to speak to you about Dale and its rebuilding as well, and if you haven't noticed, it's the late fall and your population is only growing. How are you to feed them all? There is much to be discussed and much to be decided. I would have thought you knew that.”

       Thorin leaned back on the couch, taking a belated sip of now-cool tea. He would have rather had ale but Óin would have skinned them all. “And these people arriving on our doorstep, they do know that our stores are already run thin by own people, right?”

       “Elrond has been very clear with his letters,” Gandalf leaned forward to tap out his pipe against the grate. “It is a good thing they are coming here, Thorin. For are they not acknowledging your people's return in a way? And should they recognize you, and you alone, as King Under the Mountain, well,” Gandalf grunted as he stood, hands on his knees and moving like an old man. “Wouldn't that be a good thing?” And with that Gandalf left the room, leaving them to their own thoughts.

       Thorin did not sleep until many, many hours later.

 

 

~*~

 

 

       “Bilbo, you must see sense.”

      “I am seeing sense,” Bilbo flinched when Lalia smoothed more of the bruise paste over his back. From the thunderous scowl on his cousin's face the mottling looked far worse than it felt. “You've seen the proof. Their judgment of me and our kind is lifted. No one has any marks on their feet when they leave their main doors, now. I heard Thorin and Dwalin say –”

       “I'm not doubting that,” Fortinbras held up a hand, even as Bilbo scowled at him. “But two dwarves alone, who feel guilty and remorseful –”

      “Fortinbras!”

       “I'm saying we must be cautious in all this!”

       “And I do not disagree!” Then Bilbo flinched again when Lalia's fingers hit a sore spot. “I'm not saying that we come out of the dark to spook them all. I'm just saying that I need to go see them again. Me, alone. No one else.”

       “I don't like that either.”

       “Fortinbras.”

       “Don't take that tone with me, cousin. I changed your nappies.”

       Bilbo grumbled under his breath but wilted under the steady look his cousin and Thain sent him. “Then what do you propose?”

       Fortinbras folded his arms over his chest and rocked back on his heels. “While I agree that it would be best if you went to go see your dwarves –”

       Bilbo sputtered, feeling his face go hot.

       “I want at least a few Bounders to go with you.”

       “Absolutely not,” Bilbo shook his head. “The dwarves won't know who they are and the Company can be a suspicious lot.”

      “Oh, I'm not saying that they need see the Bounders.”

       Bilbo paused, some of the air taken from his sails on his argument. “You mean...”

      “The Bounders can stay in between while you approach them. Though,” Fortinbras tilted his head to one side. “That is also something I want you to be cautious of.”

       “What do you mean?”

      “I do not want you to be within arms reach of them. Not right now,” Fortinbras let his arms fall when Bilbo tried to stand up, ignoring Lalia's cry of dismay. “No, you stay right there, little cousin.” Strong arms held Bilbo in place. He refused to look at Fortinbras. “You told me how you...how you fell ,” Bilbo hated the way he could feel both Fortinbras and Lalia flinch at the word. He had been half starved and wild when he'd come to them, feet trailing blood in his wake and feeling like such a failure. They had taken him into their arms then and let him spill it all out, the whole journey, Thorin and Dwalin, the dragon, all of it. These two alone knew how much he feared falling, now, even if he was getting rather used to it in some morbid way.

       Fortinbras pressed their foreheads together, despite the way Bilbo screwed his eyes shut. “You stay at a distance to them. You said there are staircases a plenty in that main chamber. You stalk them to there and use that to your advantage. Them on one level, you on another. That way...that way words can be said but they won't be able to lay a hand on you...just in case.”

       Bilbo hated the way his cousin's argument made sense. Many a hobbit had seen how the men in their towns could turn fickle, penitent at first, then wrathful in a flash. Bilbo had been a faunt, trailing after Fortinbras in the Great Smials, when he and his mother had gone there for a Took family meeting. The Thain had always relied on his greater relations to act as a kind of council, something most in the Shire had taken comfort in, for then the widows and the matriarchs would always have a voice in the running of things and the Big People outside of their borders were none the wiser on how their people kept to their own laws. Bilbo remembered that meeting well, since the ladies had taken one side of the argument on a union of a Clayhanger cousin having married into a Bree clan who'd taken to Men's ways a little too well. The first two times the cousin had gone back to her husband when he had come to her on penitent knees, but the third time...well. The third time the Clayhanger lass had lost a child and almost lost her life as well. The widows had been up in arms about it from the get go and had all the Took ladies on their side.

       The resulting shouting match had left quite the impression on a young Bilbo.

       “Fine,” he finally grit out. “I won't go near them.”

      “Just for now,” Fortinbras said softly. Bilbo slumped against him, not wanting to fight with the two hobbits who had not – not even once – looked at him with suspicion in their eyes. Even the Gamgees had been a little leery, even if Hamfast had lost those shadows after a blink. Bilbo didn't blame them, not any of them. Not after what he had done.

       “Come now. Let's get you up and to bed. And no, you're not sleeping out here tonight. I've had enough of you slipping away before breakfast. You can bunk with Ferumbras and you'll have a nice meal in the morning or I'll let Lalia tie you up, just you wait and see.”

       “It's talk like that that gets the gossips going,” Bilbo muttered at them as Fortinbras got him to his feet.

       “Bilbo!”

      “I'm just saying – Lalia! Lalia, stop pinching me!”

 

 

~*~

 

 

       Thorin stalked out of what could loosely be called a council chamber, his hands in fists at his sides. The shouting match between one Thranduil and Lord Elrond had dissolved into whatever elvish language they spoke behind him.

       Thorin had woken to find that Balin had arranged a set of rooms just inside the gates to be used for these councils Gandalf had spoke of. Thorin had put on the simple circlet he'd chosen as his crown and found the least worn clothes they had managed to scrounge up from somewhere to go down and meet with these people, determined to make sure that all of them made sure to acknowledge him and him alone as King Under the Mountain.

      Gandalf's words the night before had stirred quite a lot of talk between him and Balin and then later the rest of the Company. Nori had been the most informed. After all the talk of calling Bilbo a thief, Thorin had put his new Spymaster to the task of tracking down just where these whispers and rumors were coming from. Nori's people were a small number as of yet, so no one had been able to pin down just where exactly such ugly whispers were coming from but from what they had been able to deduce most of it was coming from the Iron Hills dwarves.

      Thorin knew Dáin was concerned about Fíli and Kíli being Thorin's heirs. Dáin's father, Náin, had been rather particular about lines of succession and had had a heavy hand in making sure Dáin remembered such lessons. It was all tangled together with the way the lines of the House of Durin were split between the Iron Hills and Erebor and Thorin's own father and grandfather had their own issues with their cousins. The Iron Hills branch of the family believed that the kingship should pass from father to son and only in such a manner. But Thorin had known since he'd met Dwalin in their youth that they two would share a One and that one would be male and therefore no child would come from that union. It had not been an issue while Thorin's brother Frerin had been alive, but with his brother dead and only Dís' children to inherit...well. There were no few counselors in Dáin's ear about pushing Thorin to name Dáin as his heir instead of Fíli.

       It was a mess.

      As for why Dáin and his people were calling Bilbo a thief though...none of that made any sense. Thorin had told Dáin multiple times that Bilbo was the reason why they were not having to pay wergilds to the men of Lake-town or worse yet Thranduil had the dragon escaped the mountain and rained down fire on those settlements in his rage. Thorin could not understand why Dáin had not stomped down on those whispers...unless Dáin was using those whispers to undermine Thorin's position as King Under the Mountain and that was not what Thorin wanted to deal with at the minute. Not with the stupid elf king in his mountain testing his patience at every moment.

      “Thorin. Thorin, wait,” said Dáin from behind him.

       “Not now,” Thorin growled out, ignoring his cousin as he marched deeper into the mountain. The elves and men would not dare come past the rooms Balin had led them into. Thorin had seen Bard splay a hand over his own face when Thranduil had started with his usual sniping comments. Thankfully Elrond's own counselor, an elf by the name of Erestor, had smiled at Thranduil and said something in that elvish language of theirs that had Thranduil sputtering and Elrond pinching the bridge of his nose.

       The meeting had gone downhill from there.

       The Lady Galadriel had not yet arrived and from everything Thorin had heard from both Nori and what little he'd heard this Erestor saying, the Lady would do much to keep Thranduil in line. Thorin would believe it when he saw it. As for now he would leave this Lord Elrond to deal with Thranduil and his attitude problem.

       “Thorin,” Dáin had caught up to him at one of the platforms that looked over Erebor's central hall. Far above them the staircases were dim lines of gray against a darker background. The day had dawned cloudy and cold, with spats of flurries on the upper reaches of the mountain. He turned to see that his cousin and most of the Company, along with a small herd of other dwarves Thorin did not recognize, had followed him out of the council rooms and onto the platform.

       “I am not in the mood, cousin,” Thorin held up a hand at Dáin's frown. “I've had to deal with Thranduil all morning and we didn't even get past a general acknowledgment of those in the room.”

       “You cannot let that leaf eater talk to you like that,” Dáin said, folding his arms over his chest.

      “I'm aware,” Thorin grit out. “But now is not the time. Thranduil is an ass – even Lord Elrond seems to think so, you saw that mess – and I refuse to deal with him when he brings such an attitude into my kingdom! He can sit and deal with the other elves and I'll meet with him tomorrow – if his attitude has improved!”

      “But you – what is that?”

       Dáin's gaze had moved up and over Thorin's shoulder. He turned, expecting...well. He wasn't sure what he was expecting but it was not one Bilbo Baggins standing on one of the upper platforms, haloed in the the sudden light coming in from the upper shafts of the mountain as the sun finally appeared. “Bilbo,” he breathed, feeling all the air rush from his lungs.

      Their Bilbo still looked wan and pale, and he still had one arm strapped across his chest, but when he looked at Thorin...for a moment it felt like he was there, like their Burglar was back, whole and alive, having just stepped out for a moment and wondering what the fuss was when they panicked about not being able to find him.

       “Thorin,” Bilbo said. The distance between their platforms wasn't great but too far to jump, even with a running start. Thorin almost wanted to try anyway. The sunlight hit his curls just right to turn them a shining gold. “I...I wanted...”

      “The thief,” Dáin snarled at Thorin's side, making him jump.

      “Dáin!” He looked at his cousin. “Bilbo is no thief! He is a dwarf-friend of Erebor! He is the dragon slayer! You know this!”

      “He stole from us – from you! He gave away your treasury! How is he not a thief! Has that simple crown scrambled your brains? Didn't you kill it, anyways? Why is it still here?”

      “Bilbo is not a thing! And he did not steal anything! He saved us all!” Thorin roared at his cousin, drawing one hand back to punch Dáin in the face. Time seemed to slow as he heard Bilbo shout a warning – but a warning of what? That was when Thorin turned to see an arrow streak through the air, far wide of Thorin and Dáin –

       But right at Bilbo where he stood in the sunlight, blind from a bolt from the dark. A shout left his throat – he did not know what he said – but Thorin was forced to watch as Bilbo's pale and frightened expression turned panicked and pained as that arrow flashed into the sunlight –

       And then as Bilbo vanished without a trace.

Chapter 11: a strange and wild restlessness

Chapter Text

        “What in the world,” Bilbo managed to croak out from where he was laid out flat against Holman Cotton, one of the Bounders Fortinbras had sent with him. They had fallen to the floor of a smial Bilbo did not know, with a hobbit lass standing over him, rolling pin in hand. “My apologies,” he told the lass – lady? Mrs? – above him and rolled off Holman who thanked him with a wheeze. The hobbit matron put down the rolling pin – thankfully – but now had her hands on her hips as she looked them both over.

        “I'll go get the Matriarch,” was all she said as she flounced out of the smial door.

        “Now you've gone and done it,” Holman groaned from his prone position on the floor.

       “I didn't know they were going to shoot at me!” Which was an unfortunate sentence and one it turned out he had to repeat.

        Multiple times.

        By the time Bilbo made it before the Thain – Fortinbras could not be his cousin, not here in the main hall of the Great Smials – they had collected all of the widows with Lalia in the lead as the Matriarch. They were seated along one side of the smial wall, where once there had been windows that looked out over a rolling green hill and the dark smudge of the forest across a wide swath of fields. Now those windows looked out into darkness but from time to time it seemed like there were little bursts of color in that void, blues and reds and iridescent white.

       Bilbo had expected to hear many things come out of the Thain's mouth. Things like how the dwarves were not to be trusted. How their people had to double down on finding a way out of Erebor and to someplace safer. He did not, however, expect this.

       “Dragon slayer?” Fortinbras' eyebrows had gone up and stayed up. “They're calling you dragon slayer?”

        Bilbo shifted from foot to foot. “Well. I suppose?”

        “Bilbo.”

       “You all saw...” Bilbo waved his hands, not even sure how to put into words that strange moment of unity between all their people. It was not Bilbo's hands alone that had drawn that bow back, nor his eye alone that had found that dark spot on Smaug's chest. “I know it's not right for me alone to have that title –”

        More than one hobbit in the hall began to sputter.

        “Which is why I need to go back and speak to Thorin! One on one! So that all this might be clarified!”

        “Or for you to get your skull bashed in,” Widow Layflower said, not looking up from her knitting. She was one of the few still focused on the craft in her hands. Just what the widows were making was a mystery to everyone else except them. Not even Lalia would know until she, too, became one of them. “Holman Cotton spoke of what he saw and what danger he dragged you out of. You would have ended up worse than my great granddaughter's fingers with her first sewing project had you stayed there.”

        “But...”

       “Widow Layflower is correct,” Lalia said from her position next to the dignified old hobbit matron. Daisy Layflower was one of the oldest widows of their people. Her people held the north-eastern border of the Shire, around the area near Girdley Island on both sides of the river. “We cannot trust them, not yet. The Bounders have all testified to what they heard and saw and, yes, I do agree that your King Thorin seems to currently view you in good light, but they also think you're dead.” Bilbo fought down his blush even as Lalia gave him a sharp look. “There is something more afoot here and we must find out what that is before we reveal our presence in these halls. Plus there are all the Big Folk about as well. Can we trust that they will not come hunting for us, should they learn of our place in these halls?”

       Murmurs went up and down the hall. Bilbo curled his toes against the floor but could not find a decent argument against Lalia's words. “I don't know. I need to find out where Gandalf is staying and talk to him.”

       “The wizard is in the tents with the elves,” one of the Bounders spoke up. “Some of us went and scouted it out. They seem a little high strung,” the Bounder rocked his hand back and forth. “Old Tom brushed one of them by accident and I've never seen an elf jump like that before. They doubled the guard after that. We'd need to go in between to get there and back again.”

        “That's if the wizard didn't try to fry us on sight if we popped up out of the dark,” another Bounder said.

        “True.”

       Bilbo rubbed at his forehead, feeling a headache coming on. They had to do something. “Then I need to speak to Thorin. And Dwalin,” he tacked on. He fought down another blush. “If I can convince them, then they can go and get Gandalf and we can sit down like civilized people and talk this all out.”

        Bilbo saw Fortinbras look at Lalia. Lalia had her arms folded across her chest, gaze on some far distant thing, a small furrow between her brows. “We need to be careful about all this,” was all she said at last. “There's something we're missing and I'm not sure just what it is. No one should show themselves at all, unless at the very most dire need. At least until we figure out just what strangeness is going on in this mountain.”

       Bilbo bowed his head, accepting her words as the rest of the hall did as well. He didn't like it very much but he saw the sense in it. Better to scout out the lay of the land and figure out just who was shooting at him – if they were even shooting at him – before they risked the whole of their people to one big gamble.

        Now he just had to figure out how to speak to Thorin and Dwalin alone.

 

~*~

 

        Thorin sat before the fire in the rooms he shared with Dwalin, hands linked over his stomach as he watched the flames on the grate. After the disaster in the main chamber of Erebor Thorin had dragged Dáin into one of the smaller council rooms to have a shouting match that lasted for most of the afternoon. Dáin would not budge from his position that Bilbo was some sort of thief, a parasite in the mountain, and that Thorin should commission their holy people to exorcise the spirit – or spirits – from Erebor before someone was hurt. Thorin had been against it but getting any sense through his cousin's thick head was impossible. They'd had to be separated in the end, with the both of them going to their rooms to cool down.

        Which put Thorin here, in one of the few rooms in the Royal Wing that was still usable. Fíli and Kíli both had rooms in this wing, with the rest of the Company as well. Thorin knew Dáin also had some opinions about that – namely the Ur and the Ri families having any rooms in this area at all. Thorin had tried to shut that line of thinking down as well. The Company that had come with him were all going to be part of his councils, in whatever form they wished, for they alone had had the courage to come with him on this Quest when all others had turned Thorin away.

        The evening meal had come and gone. Thorin had to show his face there, at least for a few minutes, but he could not stand to sit at the same table as Thranduil – who was slouched in his chair like the poncy idiot he was but at least he didn't open his stupid mouth this time – or his cousin for long. Thorin had managed to choke down half of his plate and, feeling horrible about the waste if he left then, somehow managed to shovel the rest down. He ignored the sharp looks he was getting from both Balin and Dwalin and had left without a word to anyone once his plate was clear.

        Dwalin was no doubt dealing with the growing King's Guard. Balin had to take care of the political mess Thorin had left behind at that table. Where the rest of his Company was he was not sure.

        With one exception.

        “What news do you have for me today, Nori?”

        The once-thief stepped from the shadows and into the sitting room. The newest Spymaster for Erebor took a seat next to Thorin in front of the fire and matched his low slouch, complete with his hands over his middle, staring into the fire along with him. The firelight made Nori's peaked hair look strange, almost like the horns of the war rams Dáin and his people had road into battle for them. Thorin shook his head at the thought. Again and again he was brought back to Dáin and the problem his cousin presented by lingering here in Erebor.

        “All our people are safe and secure. Bofur is finding more intact rooms beyond the second hall. Looks like the wurm was too big to get his fat ass down into those warrens.” Nori let out a humorless snort. “Things will be a bit tight but we can spend most of the winter working on expanding what areas are livable for now.”

        “Bofur said there are issues in the main cavern,” Thorin sighed, rubbing at the spot between his eyes. “We need those clans back from the Iron Hills. They are some of the few that know how best to fix the support pillars. We could try to fix them with the artisans we have...”

        “And bring down the roof on us all? No thank you,” Nori said. “I'm working on getting information about where those clans are at the moment. Dáin and his people are tight lipped, I'll give them that. Most of my boys haven't got more than a word or two of out of them.”

        “But?”

        Nori sighed and it was so out of character for him that it made Thorin look over at him. “They're spooked.” Nori's gaze stayed on the fire, his mouth pulled down into a frown. “Worse yet, so are the elves and men.”

        “Spooked?” Thorin let his hand drop, turning in his chair to look fully at Nori. “Spooked by what?”

        “I don't know.” Nori's frown twisted for a moment. “No one understands the elves, not since –,” Bilbo the name hung between them like a specter. “But even we can tell when they're jumpy. Two of Dwalin's boys got almost drawn on by some of Thranduil's people, which was going to cause a scene but that one elf, with the gold hair that came with Lord Elrond, he stepped in and stopped it.”

        Finding out that Lord Elrond's Captain of the Guards was one Glorfindel – as in the Glorfindel of the First Age that even Thorin had heard of – had been a shock. Watching said legend get stared at by a slim elf in black, that same Master Erestor, Lord Elrond's Chief Counselor, Erestor's arms folded over his chest as this Glorfindel wilted before him before handing over a honey bottle had been...interesting. And disturbing. Mostly disturbing.

        Bilbo would have loved to see it.

        Thorin closed his eyes at the thought, fighting down the ache in his chest. “What else has been going on?” He opened his eyes to see Nori regarding him with an unreadable look.

        “Things have been...moved, in some places,” Nori began. Thorin frowned. “Nothing obvious, but you know how Bombur has been about the food stores. He swears an entire box of mushrooms appeared in the back of our cold room when I can't remember any of us finding a single mushroom out on the mountain at all.”

        “Perhaps they came with the supplies?”

        “Perhaps. But when have we ever eaten mushrooms as our first choice?”

        Thorin waved a hand. “Our supplies came from Gondor. Perhaps it was a mistake on their part.”

        “Perhaps,” Nori echoed. His eyes glittered in the firelight. “But what about the way half my boys are reporting that they're feeling stalked, Thorin? What about the elves pinching down every flap in their tent and the doubling of their guards? Dáin's people are walking around openly armed in their own section of the camp.” Thorin sat up straight at that. That went against all rules of dwarven propriety. Dáin's people should have peace locks on their weapons at the very least but from the look in Nori's eye Thorin doubted Dáin's people had any at all. “There are eyes on us, Thorin. We can all feel them.”

        Thorin let out breath as he looked away. He, too, had felt those eyes watching as he'd made his way back to his rooms. It had made the hairs on the back of his neck stand on end. “Do you think...” He had to stop and swallow, staring into the bright heart of the fire. “Do you think it is Bilbo?”

        The crackle of the logs was his only answer for a long, long moment. Then, “I don't know,” Nori sighed as well, hands rising from his middle to rub over his face in a hard scrub. “I don't know,” he repeated.

        “But if it's not him –,” then Thorin was on his feet, the sound of a thump just outside his door out of place at this time of night.

        Nori beat him to the door and out it, knives bared as they stepped into the dusty hall. But instead of an intruder all they saw was a nameless dwarf neither of them could name, holding a tray with a spilled cup of wine. The dwarf was alive when Nori knelt to check his pulse. “Looks like he was clipped over the head after he was tripped,” Nori said as he turned the dwarf over. Then he stilled. “Thorin. Isn't this...”

        Thorin looked down and bit back a curse. Laid out in the hall was Payr, Dáin's valet and close confidant. To send Payr to Thorin, with what looked like a peace-cup...well. It was going to be a mess to explain to his cousin when Payr woke up.

        Then a sound made Thorin turn, breath caught in his throat. He scanned the long hall, each entrance closed and shut with heavy doors that made a distinct thud each time they were opened and closed. The hall ran along to a further corridor that was blocked on one end, leaving the only way in or out of the Royal Wing behind Thorin. But even as he looked Thorin realized with a pickle going down his spine that there were no marks in the thick dust that lay on the ground in that hall. There were a few marks from Thorin's boots, Dwalin's, and the boys, but Thorin knew their tread in his sleep. No, whatever he was hearing was light, a soft pattering, like...like bare feet against a stone ground.

        Like Bilbo's footsteps when he had run through the halls of Erebor.

        “Bilbo,” Thorin whispered, hearing the word linger in the hall. But nothing and no one answered him. Instead the footsteps vanished, leaving only silence to fill their ears.

Chapter 12: frenzies bewilder, reveries perturb the mind

Chapter Text

        Thorin stood in front of the fire, hands clasped behind his back, as his council argued with each other around the table in the middle of the room. After finding Payr unconscious in the hall Nori had slipped off to gather his people while Thorin got the guard to help him get Payr to the medic's hall. The peace-cup, Thorin had noted, was also gone when he and the guards on patrol had come back to where Payr was laying. Nori was still no where to be seen, having not come to the council meeting after Dáin's arrival late that evening. His cousin's presence there had been short but his words had kept the rest of them up for the rest of the night.

        Thorin was tired down to his bones but there was no time to rest. Not now. Not when Dáin was demanding an answer as to why his valet had been attacked in Thorin's own Royal Wing, as well as a wergild for it. Not when many in the Iron Hills section of tents outside their gates were putting on armor and watching Thorin's people with hard, glittering gazes. Not when the elves and men were rousing in greater and greater numbers to watch both the Iron Hills and Thorin's people with wary eyes. Not when Thorin knew that he and his people were in a precarious position in the mountain and that one hard push from the Iron Hills folk could cause it all to collapse, in a variety of different ways.

        “Dáin's demand is too outrageous,” Balin was the one to say it. Thorin bowed his head, listening to his councilors speak. “Thorin declared that he has a One decades ago, in front of the council of his own father in this very Mountain! The news was deliberately spread to the Irons Hills so that Náin and his counselors would stop sending their dwarrowdams to Thrór's court! To demand that Thorin marry one of Dáin's noble ladies –”

        More than one of Thorin's councilors growled at that.

       “It is an insult of the highest sort! Dáin knows that! What is he trying to do with this? All it will end with is a fight and the last thing we need is to show our asses in front of the elves and men at this moment!”

        “He's trying to get his fingers into our coffers, that's what,” grumbled on Helv, the head of the banking guild. He was an old dwarf, of the same generation as Thorin's father, but he had been one of the first to arrive from their rough settlements in the Blue Mountains. Thorin privately thought that had Helv been a handful of decades younger, and without a widowed daughter with a young child to care for, Helv would have been part of their Company before Thorin could get the words out of his mouth. Glóin had been apprenticed to Helv since he was young and Thorin had seen how Glóin had picked up many of his mannerisms. The gruff old dwarf's hair was snow white, as was his beard, and a jeweler's eyepiece hung from a chain about his neck. Thorin remembered when that same eyepiece had been dotted with gemstones, a glittering thing given to him by his daughter on his hundred and fiftieth birthday, just before the arrival of Smaug to Erebor. Now it was devoid of gems, all of them having been pried off over the years, a sorry tale in plain sight, a reminder of all the hardships Thorin's people had gone through during their exile from their mountain.

        “Dáin knows his demand is excessive,” Thorin spoke at last. He did not turn around. The dwarves behind him went quiet. “He is waiting for my counter.” This much, at least, had not changed. It had always been Dáin's way to demand for far more than he was due, pushing the bounds of propriety in such matters every time, just to see what he could get out of any deal he made.

        “What are you considering?” That came from Lark, one of the judiciary guild masters.

       Thorin raised his head with a sigh. “What Dáin wants is our artisans, transferred to him formally,” there were hisses of displeasure. “But that is not something I am willing to give.”

        “He knows we need those clans!”

        “And he does not care.” Thorin traced the carvings of the mantle with his gaze, fingers tangled tight together behind his back. “Uncle Náin taught my cousin well. There has to be a profit from this deal or it will make Dáin look weak in the eyes of his council. It is a position he cannot chance.”

        “You think his rule is that unstable?”

        “I think Dáin's rule is very stable,” Thorin turned and looked over his small council. “But there are elements within Dáin's court that have wanted a piece of the ruling pie for longer than the Line of Durin has been split. And with the changes going on in the world as it is, they will be all the more eager to grasp at what reins of power they can get their hands on.”

        There were looked exchanged between his councilors. Dwalin alone sat back in his chair, arms folded over his chest and a deep scowl set on his face. Dwalin had not taken Dáin's original demands that Thorin take a wife from the Iron Hills well at all. It had taken Bofur and Bombur to hold him back. Not that Thorin wanted to hold him back. Thorin rather wanted to punch his cousin in the face himself.

        “You think Dáin wants to unload those problems onto us,” Balin said at last. There was a knowing glint to his eye. “And keep our artisans for himself. A double prize.”

        “Indeed,” Thorin walked forward and folded down into the chair by Dwalin. “I find myself...unwilling to humor him in this regard.”

        “What of the dwarf that Dáin is upset over? Did he come to any permanent harm?” Jor, the head of the scribe's guild, asked from his position down the table.

        “A bump on the head and some dizziness,” Óin answered when all eyes turned to him. “He'll be fine in a day or two.”

        “Then why such an excessive show?” Helv muttered. “He sent a peace-cup, fine. It's not Thorin's fault the idiot fell over his own feet and knocked himself out.”

       “Dáin is also claiming the mountain is haunted,” Balin's tone was as sour as Thorin felt about that particular fact. “He says Payr was attacked by the Betrayer's spirit.” His lips curled at the title Dáin had given their Bilbo. “He still won't see sense about Bilbo.”

        “None of them will,” Thorin ran a tired hand over his face. “Appease him with this – tell Dáin that the holy ones will bless the mountain on the next new moon. We will step into the darkness and accept the will of Mahal that comes to us. Our people and Dáin's will be one at that blessing, so we might all take part in the rite.”

        “The new moon is only two days away.”

        “The holy ones have the forges set up and it will be good for morale for us all,” Thorin ignored the way his fingers were trembling. “Any news on the elves from Lothlórien that are supposed to be arriving today?”

        “The ravens have reported that they'll reach the gates by noon,” Dwalin said from Thorin's side. “You need to sleep at some point before all that. We all do.”

        “It's already almost dawn. I can just –”

        “No, laddie,” Óin pointed a finger at him. “To bed for a few hours for you. We'll get the mountain settled for now. Dáin can stew in his tents until you can speak to him. You've been more than accommodating for his rudeness.”

        From the way the rest of his small council was nodding Thorin knew when he was beat. “Fine. But I'll be the one to inform Dáin about the blessing. I can always punch him in the face if he decides to be an ass about it.”

        “Thorin,” Balin sighed, one hand covering his face.

       “Let's get you to bed,” Dwalin stepped in, holding Thorin's arm as they both got up from the chair. Thorin let him hover, knowing his partner was rattled about Payr's attack in the hall. The Royal Wing was supposed to be safe. All of them suspected that Payr did not simply fall over his own feet, not with the position of that bump on the dwarf's head. No, someone had done that to him, had tripped him, had caused him to spill that peace-cup, and then had clipped him over the head.

        The question was, why?

        They gained a shadow on their way back to the Royal Wing. Thorin noted that Dwalin had posted two sets of his most trusted guards on either side of the hall, even on the part of it that had been collapsed and – to their knowledge – had no way in nor out. There were new tracks in the dust in the hall, boots Thorin did not recognize but when Dwalin did not tense it had to be evidence of those same guards Dwalin had posted. The hall was cold as they made their way to their door and there was a prickling of something, almost like eyes on them, that made Thorin want his sword in hand but he could not say why.

        Thorin took a seat before the now-banked fire in their rooms as Dwalin secured the door behind Nori. Their Spymaster looked a little worse for wear, his peaked hair flattened in one spot and a dark stain on his tunic where there had been none before. Nori took the seat opposite him with a wince that made Thorin frown. Dwalin had come to stand behind him, both of them watching Nori shift in his seat.

        “I don't know where the cup went,” was the first thing Nori said. Thorin had found it was always better to let Nori speak first. “As far as I can tell – and my boys as well – the cup was there when you went to get the guards and then gone when you came back.”

        “You had someone watching me?” Perhaps that was the source of that strange feeling in the hall.

        “Thorin that is my job. There will always be someone watching you.”

        Thorin frowned but set that argument aside for later. Nori had started their Quest already paranoid over their security. It had only gotten worse, since. “Then where did the cup go? Do you think Dáin has his own spies here?”

        “I have no doubt Dáin has his spies here. It's not his spies I'm worried about,” Nori grumbled.

        “What happened to you?” Dwalin was the one to ask.

        Nori's hand stilled where it was pressed against his side. “A knife in the dark,” he let his hand fall. “Just a graze,” he added when Thorin surged forward in his seat. “I was careless. Stupid,” Nori scowled. “It won't happen again.”

        Thorin let himself fall back into his chair and felt Dwalin put a hand on his shoulder. “And you don't think that was Dáin?”

       Thorin felt a chill when Nori hesitated. “I don't know,” he finally said. “If it is...then he's being stupid about it. Why challenge you here and now? Why in front of the elves and men? That the part that makes no sense to me. There are years ahead of us that Dáin could make his move on you, on Dwalin, on Fíli or Kíli. Why now?”

        Thorin looked away towards the embers in the hearth. It was that same question that had been circling in his mind the entire time during the council meeting. He only had one answer. “I do not know.”

        Nori made a face. “Neither do I and I don't like answers like that. We need to figure out what is going on with him and his people.”

        “I'm aware,” Thorin rubbed a hand over his face. “I can't exactly boot them out at the moment either or I would. These councils will have impacts on us all going forward and our people need to present a united front, especially where Thranduil is involved.” They all made a face at the elf king's name. “I'll need you and your people on point during the new moon blessing. The last thing we need is anyone trying to attack Dáin or his people – or make it look like we're attacking him. Dáin can call a king's challenge if he's attacked during that rite.”

        Dwalin let out a low growl but it was Nori who looked over and said, “Do you think one of our people would do that?”

        “No,” Thorin dropped his hand with a sigh. “But Dáin and his lot are acting so strange that I do not want any incidences at all. Nothing that they can use against us.”

        “Consider it done.”

        “Thank you, Nori.”

        Nori left on silent feet and a silence settled over their rooms. Thorin watched the embers burn on the grate, wanting nothing more than to fall asleep in his chair but knew he would regret it in the morning.

        “Come,” Dwalin said from behind him, the hand on his shoulder moving to cup the side of Thorin's head. “To bed with us. The mess will be there in the morning.”

        Thorin leaned into the touch for a long moment, closing his eyes. Then he let out a breath and got to his feet in fits and starts, feeling far older than his years. The candles were doused behind him and when he crawled into his cold sheets he wanted nothing more than to grab and hold onto Dwalin and dream of...

        Well. It was a dream that would never come true. But at least in dreams he had the ones he loved in his arms. So Thorin closed his eyes and let himself drift, thinking for one brief moment that he could smell the scent of Bilbo's pipe in the air...but then sleep took him and he knew no more.

Chapter 13: deaf as a fire and blind as the night

Chapter Text

        Thorin felt his bones ache as he stood out in the thin sunshine of the noonday sun, watching a large group of elves riding towards the gates of Erebor. His dreams had been strange, murky things, with him running through the halls of Erebor, searching...searching for something but in his dream it was as if he could not name it. It was in the waking that Thorin knew what he had been searching for, but he could not bring himself to give words to that wish. For it could never come true. Not after...

        Thorin gave himself a shake, tipping his chin up as the elves came to a halt not far from their greeting party. Thorin could feel eyes on him from all sides. Earlier that morning the men from Gondor and Rohan had arrived, riding together in one party. One Ecthelion II, son of Steward Turgon of Gondor had bowed to Thorin before his men and the other gathered parties. The man was of middling years, the hair at his temples already showing gray in the dark locks, but he was tall and wide of stature and from the looks of things no slouch in the saddle either. The other man with him represented the kingdom of Rohan, though his mouth had twisted as he spoke the name. He gave his name as Thengel, son of King Fengel of the house of Eorl. Both men had been respectful in their words with Thorin, if guarded and reserved. Thorin did not find fault with them since the return of his kind to Erebor was sure to change many things in this part of the world. It was understandable that they were wary and on guard.

        Thorin had let Balin deal with the logistics of where to put another group of men and their people. From the uneasy looks between the newly arrived men and the Rangers of the north Thorin suspected there was some history there that he was not privy to.

        Thorin had only ever heard stories of the Lady of the Wood. While the rumors about her origins were wild and varied, Thorin knew that the Lady was an elf of great age and that even his own grandfather had feared her, if only a little bit. From the way Lord Elrond and the rest of the elves that were already at Erebor straightened it seemed as though his grandfather was right to be wary.

        The Lady had not arrived in the carriage that Thorin had been expecting. Instead the Lady was on horseback, a gray cloak covering her like the rest of her guards, with a deep hood that hid her face in shadows. Thorin pushed his shoulders back when the Lady swung down from her horse, her clothes simple and utilitarian, much like the elves she was riding with and not the fine dress that he had been expecting. A strange silence had settled over the crowd as the Lady passed the lead of her horse to one of her elves and stepped forward, using both hands to push back the hood of her cloak.

        Thorin heard gasps in the crowd when the Lady's face was revealed. She was youthful, as all elves were, but her eyes were such a piercing blue that it made Thorin's breath stop in his throat. Her bright golden hair was bound up in braids and wound around her head in a crown. She was tall, taller than what few elven ladies Thorin had seen in Rivendell all those months ago. At her side hung a sword.

        Thorin stepped forward in that silence and bowed to her, lower perhaps than most of his kind would have gone but the Lady had come to them and not summoned them to her realm. He would return kindness for kindness. He was sure Bilbo would have approved.

        “Lady Galadriel,” Thorin said as he rose. “I welcome you to Erebor. Thank you for coming.”

        The Lady stared at him for a long moment, long enough that the hairs on the back of his neck began to stand on end. Then to the open shock of many in the crowd the Lady bowed back to him, her golden hair gleaming in the sun, looking like spun gold. “Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain. I have seen and heard many things about you. I am glad to see you well.”

       There was a murmur that went through the ranks of his people at her acknowledgment of his rule. Thorin saw Dáin's deep scowl from the corner of his eye. His cousin was standing, hip cocked and arms folded over his chest, as he stared out over the gathered men and elves. Thorin pushed that concern aside as he focused on Lady Galadriel, gesturing towards the tent that Balin had scrounged up from somewhere to host them all as he worked with her guards and entourage to find a place to house them. Though it looked as though they were in luck. Balin had been dreading a large train of servants and maids and any number of persons descending on them. Instead they had just the Lady herself and three guards who had come with her.

        “We have provided food and drink for your arrival, if you will forgive us the simplicity of it all.”

        “I am much obliged,” her smile was a small thing, but warm and kind as she fell into step with him, instead of moving ahead through the flaps of the entrance. “I must also apologize for my tardiness. We were waylaid with a message some days after we left our home and I fear the contents of that message cannot wait.”

        Thorin glanced up at her, finding that piercing gaze already fixed on him. “If that is what you wish. We can wait for your to be refreshed first, if you like.”

        But she shook her head, gaze moving from him to Gandalf and then to Lord Elrond, but lingering last on the pair by Lord Elrond's side, the ones Thorin knew to be Master Erestor and one Lord Glorfindel of the Golden Flower. “No. It cannot wait even a minute more. There is great news that has come to our shores and all here must know of it.”

       Thorin liked little the sound of that but he said nothing as he held the flap for the Lady to enter and stepped in behind her. Dáin would be the last to enter, if Balin had his way. Thorin had wanted to keep Dáin from this council but he knew he could not stop him. It would provoke a fight he did not want to have with his cousin. Not yet. There had been quite the yelling match between them that morning before the men of Gondor and Rohan had arrived. Dáin had taken the offer of the blessing of the mountain far more poorly than Thorin had anticipated. There was something they were missing but Thorin just could not put his finger on it.

        As they settled in around the table and what little wine they had left was served – with Thranduil sweeping in late, as always, with Bard following behind him – Thorin watched as Galadriel gave both Gandalf and Lord Elrond another series of long looks before she folded her hands on the table top and leaned forward.

        “Two days after we left the borders of our forest, Celeborn sent riders to us to deliver a message that had come from an eagle from the western shore.”

        Thorin watched as both Gandalf and Lord Elrond went still at that news. Something in that sentence meant much more to them than him.

        Galadriel looked around the table and even Thranduil was still and focused on her, his wine forgotten in front of him. “Emissaries from Valinor have arrived,” her words felt like weights from a great height, making something shiver in Thorin's chest. “They are coming here, to Erebor, where we all have gathered.”

        “But how did they know to come here?” Master Erestor was the one to ask. He was seated next to Lord Elrond with Lord Glorfindel on his other side. Thorin watched as Lord Glorfindel leaned back in his chair, some emotion washing over his face that Thorin could not read as he stared at Lady Galadriel.

        “I do not know,” the Lady said. “Perhaps Círdan told them where to go. Perhaps...” She shook her head. “There are three that have come from across the sea but their names were not told to me. We are to look for them the day after the new moon.”

        “Then what of our talks?” Prince Thengel was the one to ask. He leaned forward, one elbow on the table as he looked around at them all. “I was sent with specific instructions,” his mouth twisted on the word. “To talk about treaties and what the people of Erebor might be willing to offer in trade with Rohan.” Prince Thengel's brief glance at Dáin was not missed by anyone. “Do we continue these talks or do we wait?”

       It was Thorin's turn to lean back in his seat, tamping down on the urge to raise an eyebrow. From what he knew of the matter both Rohan and Gondor did much trade with the Iron Hills. With the destruction of Mordor it would make sense that Rohan would be interested in expanding their territory east into the lands of Rhûn where the men who had allied with Sauron lived. Dáin, seated between the elves of Rivendell and Mirkwood, scowled all the harder. Thorin ignored his cousin's sharp gaze.

        “Perhaps it would be best to wait,” Lord Elrond began.

        Thranduil scoffed, that pointed chin going up as he looked Lord Elrond up and down. “Always you with the –”

        “Thranduil.”

        It was fascinating to see how Thranduil's mouth snapped shut at the Lady's single word. Thorin also saw how the men at the table all leaned back, watching both the Lady and the Mirkwood king stare at each other.

       “Fine,” Thranduil bit out, snatching up his cup of wine off the table. He leaned back in his seat with an imperious sniff.

        “Thank you,” Galadriel said, watching him for a moment before looking to Thorin. He tried not to sit up straighter in his seat. “If you and your people are willing to host our presence until these emissaries arrive, I and my people would be grateful. We have already arranged for more supplies to arrive, though they will be delayed by some days.”

        Thorin gave her a small bow from his seat. “I agree with you that learning what these emissaries from Valinor wish to tell us is more important at the moment.” He glanced over at the men from Gondor and Rohan. “I would be willing to speak with you, Prince Thengel and Lord Ecthelion, should you wish to start laying out broad terms of trade treaties. Those do tend to take some time to come together.”

        “And perhaps,” Dáin cut in. “The treaties with Rohan and the Iron Hills can be adjusted as well during these talks.”

        Prince Thengel tilted his head to one side. “I was given specific instructions by the King of Rohan,” he said. Thorin made note of that distinction. There seemed to be some sort of rift in the House of Eorl. “I was told not to treat with the Iron Hills dwarves. Only those from Erebor.”

        Dáin's expression went black. “The treaties our people have had with both Rohan and Gondor were renewed at the end of last year. If you think you're going to break them –”

        “Dáin,” Thorin said.

        “I won't have my people starve just because –”

        “Dáin,” Thorin said, sharper. “I would not do such a thing. Erebor and the Iron Hills have historically produced different goods –”

        “My kingdom –”

        “My, my, and so the walking stones start to bicker,” Thranduil sneered at them from over his cup.

        “Thranduil,” but it was not Thorin or a furious Dáin that rebuked him. All eyes turned to the Lady Galadriel. Thranduil's hand had frozen in the air, wine cup inches from his mouth.

        Thorin glanced over to see the Greenwood king and Galadriel glaring at each other. There was a tense moment of silence. Then Thranduil shoved his chair back and stalked out of the tent without a word. Galadriel sighed in the pause after his leaving.

        “My apologies for his temper and his words,” she said with a sigh.

        Lord Elrond muttered something that sounded like, “He's always been a brat,” but Thorin must have mistaken him. Master Erestor had a hand over his face.

        “We will look forward to starting these trade talks,” Lord Ecthelion said. Prince Thengel had sat back in his chair, arms crossed over his chest, but he nodded when Thorin glanced at him. “Shall we start tomorrow?”

        “Of course,” Thorin stood when Lady Galadriel did. When he left the tent Balin was by his side in an instant, pulling him away. “What is it?”

        “I was listening,” Balin's words were soft. They both watched as Dáin stalked past them, shoulders set in a hard line. “We cannot risk cutting the Iron Hills out of any trade deals, Thorin.”

        “I know,” he said, watching his cousin disappear into the maze of his people's tents. There were guards posted outside them, now. “I was not going to. We need the Iron Hills just as much as Rohan and Gondor do. It will be a while yet before we can offer anything besides small craft work.” He scrubbed a hand over his face. “If we had something more to trade, like food...but we cannot even feed our own people, must less others. We will have to figure it out.”

        “About that,” Balin had a strange look on his face when Thorin looked over at him. “Bombur is reporting that more crates of food have miraculously appeared.”

        “More mushrooms?” Thorin couldn't help his wary tone. His people were not fond of such fare but ate it if necessary.

        But Balin shook his head. “Root vegetables. Potatoes and some that we only saw in...” Balin looked away. Few mentioned the Shire these days. “Bombur thinks we'll have enough to stretch until the supplies from Gondor come in.”

        “But where did they come from?”

        “No one knows. They were simply in boxes at the back of the cold room. There is no way in and no way out and Dwalin has guards posted on the doors at all times. They simply...appeared.”

        Thorin fought down a shiver he could not name. Then movement from the corner of his eye made him look up, towards the battlements he could not bring himself to visit anymore but there was nothing there. That prickling sensation was back but even as he scanned the area it was empty and calm.

        “Thorin?”

        “It's nothing,” he shook his head and started towards the gates. “Let us go over our talking points for the treaties. I want to be prepared.”

        That prickling feeling followed him all the way into the chill air of Erebor's halls.

 

 

 

        The night of the new moon came far quicker than Thorin anticipated. The last few days of meeting with the men of Gondor and Rohan had been tiring, if not for the constant circles they would talk in but also for the fact that Dáin had demanded to be included in these talks and that had almost started another fight between them. Thorin could understand his cousin's anger, though, for had the men of Gondor and Rohan done the same to him, with Dáin in Thorin's position, Thorin would be just as infuriated as his cousin. As it was they had to cede the right to create swords and axes for Rohan to the Iron Hills, though Thorin framed it as painful concession and not the fact that Erebor simply couldn't make those items just yet.

        The less those outside their mountain knew about what they could and could not produce the better.

        Dáin had been smugly satisfied by Thorin's concession on the arms deal, so his cousin had left in a better mood after that last round of talks with the men. The fast for the ceremony that night meant there would be a feast after it, when the heart of the mountain would be lit up by the fires of their holy ones and the songs of their people would be sung in the depths.

        The interior steps of the mountain were not as damaged as the ones that crisscrossed the main chamber above them. Thorin stepped out onto one of the lower platforms, coming up to the edge with the rest of his Company in their place of honor. There had been some grumbling from a few of Thorin's own councilors – and much more from Dáin and his – about some of the Company's inclusion there. Thorin had turned a deaf ear to them all. His Company had earned their place by his side and he was not going to take that from them.

        None of them could go down to where the holy forges were lit. That place was for their holy ones alone. The main chamber of the mountain was far above them and to one side. The light of the sun would never reach this place, as it was designed. The platform that Thorin and his Company stood on looked out over one of the deepest crevasses that existed deep in the heart of their mountain. There were others, closer to the outer edges, that were where their miners would enter to gather the ore and gems from the earth. Here, though, it was the closest to the heart of the mountain and the deepest of all the crevasses. To Thorin's knowledge no one knew how deep it went. There had been a legend that when the first of their kind had come to this mountain, this one opening had been glowing crimson, like the heat of a cooling forge, and had been taken as a sign of their Maker that this is where they were meant to be.

        Further below them, on different platforms built out over that dark abyss, were the forges of their holy ones. Their people moved around those roaring fires in gleaming white robes, the gems in their hair and beards shining in the firelight. Thorin went still as their holy ones came together in a circle in the midst of those forges, arms raised as a low thrum came from their combined throats. The song made the very stones under Thorin's feet tremble. He closed his eyes as the prayer began, as was the way of their people, as the ancient Khuzdul washed over them all. He raised his palms as the song continued, murmuring the words their people would say in counterpoint to that rising melody.

        When he was young the rites of his people had seemed like a chore. It wasn't until Smaug came and their mountain was taken that Thorin had begun to appreciate what had been lost. There was something calming about being on this platform in the heart of the mountain, lost in the darkness behind his eyelids as the songs of their people filled his ears. The song grew louder and louder, the echoes building off each other in the chamber, until Thorin could hear nothing but the sound of their holy ones singing in the depths.

        Then, as Thorin drew in a breath to start his people's chorus for the prayer, a hard shove hit him in the center of the back, knocking him forward with such force that he toppled head first off the platform...

        Right into the heart of the abyss below.

        Thorin had no breath to shout. Others were doing that for him. He turned in the air, wind whistling past his ears, arms reaching out but there was nothing he could grab onto. There was nothing that could save him now. He looked up at the platforms, seeing Dwalin being held back by Bofur and Balin, with his boys on their hands and knees as they stared over the edge of the platform, watching him fall. The holy fires blazed, filling the chamber with such light that it stung his eyes and turned him blind for a moment. He wished, in that moment, that his people, the ones he loved, would not have to watch him disappear into the dark. That he could spare them that pain.

        Then, in the midst of all that light, he heard an impossible sound.

        “Thorin!” Bilbo's cry made Thorin blink open his eyes. His Bilbo, his Burglar, his One, was hurtling down towards him, one hand reaching out. “Take my hand!”

        Perhaps it was some kindness from his Maker, to bring Thorin his One for his final trip into the heart of the mountain.

        “Thorin! Please!”

        Thorin reached out his hand. He felt their fingers touch, then palms. He looked up into Bilbo's wide, frightened eyes...

        And then the both of them disappeared.

Chapter 14: a slow low note and an iron bell

Chapter Text

          Getting their hands on Gandalf was turning out to be far more difficult than any of them had thought. Bilbo had been with Fortinbras as the Bounders came in with report after report, talking about the Men and elves that had arrived, about how tensions were rising and how the stores the dwarves had were starting to run low. The Bounders also came back with reports saying that none of their feet were splitting open anymore and that they had heard from some of the cooks in the kitchens that all of the hobbits of the Shire had been named dwarf-friends of Erebor, welcome in the Mountain's halls for now until forever more.

          That information had called a council of the widows – yet again – and in a closed door meeting with them and the matriarchs of the clans, some sort of decision had been made. Lalia had been the one to inform Fortinbras that their Farmers could start to portion out the stores to see what kind of return gifts they could give to their new neighbors. They had also been told that because the dwarves had named them friends, had gifted them a place, like the Shire had been, then it was to Bilbo's Thorin that their loyalty would lay.

         Bilbo had blushed at that. For that wording was how Lalia said the widows had proclaimed it. Bilbo's Thorin. What a dream that would be. He had been forced to inform the ladies that Thorin was by no means his, and that with Thorin came a Dwalin, and. Well. Widow Layflower had given him such a stare that Bilbo had felt his toes curling...right until she had let out such a sigh and went back to her knitting. The project on her lap had expanded much in the day or so since Bilbo had seen it last, with all of the widows beginning to work on it in one of the strange halls that were starting to form in the in between.

          But widow's work was not for him to know, so Bilbo had to set his curiosity aside.

          More worryingly one of the Bounders had came upon a dwarf lingering about Thorin's rooms one night when Bilbo had been in yet another meeting with the Thain and the widows. Bilbo had just agreed to look over the Baggins store rooms when one of the Bounders had come in to report that they had clipped a dwarf over the head outside of Thorin's rooms and then run for it when it had caused a bit of a mess.

          “But why did you hit him?” Fortinbras frowned at the lad.

          “The cup,” the Bounder said, wringing his hands together. “It had a badcap sheen to it. I was told only us could eat those,” he said. “Was I wrong?”

          Bilbo had wanted to run out of the door that moment but Fortinbras held him back. A different Bounder had come back with the cup and indeed there was the sheen of the kind of mushrooms that only hobbits could eat left inside.

         “What is going on,” Bilbo had rubbed his hands over his face.

          “No more interacting with any of them,” Fortinbras laid down the law.

          “But this was an assassination attempt!” Bilbo turned to his cousin.

          Fortinbras made a face. “If they're in need of saving, then we act. Otherwise we leave them alone until we can talk to the wizard and sort this all out, dwarf-friend or not. Something strange is going on in these halls.”

          Bilbo hadn't been best pleased with that, but what could he do? Fortinbras was his cousin, yes, but he was also Bilbo's Thain and Bilbo would never undermine him like that.

          Even if Bilbo wanted to kick him.

          The next day came with even more eventful news. “New report,” came one of the Bounders just as Bilbo was about to leave Fortinbras' smial. The young one was a bit wide-eyed. “It's a big one.”

          Bilbo sat back down in his chair.

          “Go on,” Fortinbras said from his chair by the fire.

         “An elf lady came today,” the Bounder had his hat crushed together in his hands. “She said that some people were comin' from over the sea. Made it seem real important like.”

          “From over the sea?” Bilbo sat up at that.

          “Yessir. She called 'em emissaries from Valinori or something.”

          “Valinor?” Bilbo choked on the name.

          “Yessir, that's it, sir.”

          “Thank you, Nim,” Fortinbras said. The young Bounder bobbed a bow at them and nipped back out the door as quick as he came. “Talk to me, Bilbo.”

         “Valinor?” Bilbo rubbed a shaking hand over his face.

          “Bilbo.”

          “It's the Great West,” he translated for his cousin. He looked up to see Fortinbras miss his mouth with the stem of his pipe and poke himself in the cheek. “Emissaries from the Great West are coming here.”

          “Here,” he breathed. They looked at each other.

          “Lalia needs to know,” Bilbo said.

         “The widows,” Fortinbras blanched. “Oh. No.”

          Bilbo felt much the same. “Things are becoming very strange.”

         “Becoming?”

          “Fortinbras – Fortinbras – hey, hey! Stop smacking me with your pipe! Fortinbras!”

 

 

 

 

         As it turned out Lalia and the widows had been told the news first, which was a relief to Bilbo since it meant that at least he did not have to deliver the news to them himself. Which also meant that he now had the time to try and get close to his dwarves and perhaps even try to pin down Gandalf for a word or four.

          Which was easier said than done.

          Bilbo had crept out with Holman Cotton into the camps, but even he could see that getting any of his Company alone was going to be a Quest in and of itself. They did get a chance to nip some of the herbs from Lord Elrond's stash to help their own healers in their halls, which in turn helped heal up Bilbo's arm in a jiffy. Bilbo had toyed with the idea of popping into a tent with only a couple elves, but even he could tell that it was a bad idea from the way even Master Erestor and Lord Elrond were starting to wear swords buckled at their sides.

          Botheration.

          More and more of their people started to stalk the tents of the men, elves, and dwarves, looking for what was setting them all on edge. No one could spot a thing, which in turn made the widows mutter in ways none of them liked. Bilbo had chewed on his thumbnail as he stood outside a room where Thorin and Dáin were having a very loud argument in, the politics of the dwarven nations starting to become more clear bit by bit. Bilbo had been relieved when he had first seen Dáin and his army come to Thorin's aid during the Battle of Five Armies, but his relief had been swiftly replaced by a growing dismay at the way Dáin was speaking to Thorin.

         And the less said about what Dáin said about Bilbo, the better.

          If Bilbo didn't know better, it almost sounded like Dáin and his people were becoming touched with the gold-sickness that had taken Thorin and his Company. But that was impossible, since the widows had snipped that right out of the Mountain with their golden shears.

          Wasn't it?

         But Fortinbras and Lalia had put their foot down about any of them showing themselves to anyone Outside and not even Bilbo was willing to break that rule. That meant Bilbo and the other Bounders, plus a few Farmers and some of the Cooks, were starting to poke about the encampments outside the gates to figure out just where they could all help, even if they could not be seen. The Cooks had set up grow caves for mushrooms and had separated all the ones edible for Men and the other races for their new neighbors to have. The Farmers were a bit sour about handing over some of their root-stock, but Bilbo had finally had time to go inspect the Baggins food stores and noted that there must have been a bumper crop since all of the cold rooms were packed to the brim.

          “It were a strange summer,” Hamfast Gamgee said, rubbing at his chin as he stood next to Bilbo at the door to the cold room. “Never seen the like of it before. All of 'em stores are just like this, packed to the brim. We'll have to keep a good eye on it, since spoilin' is bound to happen.”

         “And the seed stock?” Bilbo reached down to pick up an apple from one of the crates before he backed out of the door and let it shut with a thunk. Their cold rooms had never been so large before, either. Perhaps it had something to do with being in between.

          “Lots of seed, plenty to start up a'new,” Hamfast sighed. “Pity we lost the orchards, though. That'll take a good while to get back.”

          Bilbo felt his shoulders sag. “Indeed,” he murmured. He looked down at the apple in his hand. “We'll have seeds, at least,” he tossed it to Hamfast who caught it with a snort.

         Except when Hamfast touched the apple a swirl of green something spun about his hands. Hamfast dropped the apple with a shout but as they watched the apple fall the flesh of the fruit shifted and instead of bruised apple that landed on the floor...a small sapling slapped the ground instead.

          “What in all the green hills,” Hamfast said, holding his hands out away from his body, eyes a touch too wide.

         There were a number of other hobbits in the in between hall with them. Bilbo alone was the one to move, kneeling next to the sapling and picking it up with shaking fingers. Even to his own senses the plant felt... alive in a way that felt full of promise and vigor.

          “Perhaps we won't have a problem with the orchards after all,” he said before someone went running for the widows once more.

          After that all the Gardeners were brought to the different storage rooms and put to the test. Hamfast Gamgee was by far the best of them all to coax plants to life from the fruits and vegetables that had been packed away. Fortinbras did not even have to say a word before all the Gardeners were grabbing what fruits and stock they could and heading out onto the hills about Erebor with a fire lit in their eyes. By the turn of a single day the entire southern side of the Mountain had been planted with a vast number of fruit trees and shrubs and who knew what else. Bilbo had joined in the help handing off crates for the other runners that were taking them out to the Gardeners, lending a hand where it was needed most.

          It had been an eventful day or two.

         All that fuss meant Bilbo had little time to focus on his – on Thorin and Dwalin, so when he did get a chance to seek them out once more it was to see all the dwarves gathering deep into the mountain where some sort of ceremony was starting.

         Bilbo had hung back, not sure if he was allowed to see such things. A part of him wanted to step away, to give the dwarves their privacy for their Rites, as he should have...but a stronger part of him kept him there, creeping closer and closer in the in between until he was standing near Thorin and his Company, taking them all in.

         For the first time since they had reached the Mountain Bilbo felt comfortable to be near them once more. Knowing...knowing that they did not hate him, that they did not blame him, that they missed him, even with what he had done...it had soothed some deep ache in his heart that he had been too scared to look at before. A part of him wanted to reach out and touch them but he kept his hands to himself. Instead he had hunkered down at the side of the platform and took in the strange songs and the glowing light, cataloging all the changes that had happened to his Company since he had properly seen them last.

         Thorin and Dwalin looked far too tired. It made Bilbo want to fuss at them, tuck them into bed and feed them properly. Fíli and Kíli were at Thorin's side, fidgeting a bit, but always in place when Dwalin glanced over at them. Balin looked just as frail as Bilbo had seen him last, tired in a way that put a frown on Bilbo's face. Bofur was near the back with Bifur and Bombur, all of them looking a bit uncomfortable but each time one of Dáin's people gave them a look Bofur's chin went up and his shoulders went back. Glóin and Óin were next to Balin, the both of them with their eyes closed as Thorin was, palms upturned as they murmured along with the rest of their people. Ori was sniffing and using his sleeves to wipe at his face as the songs grew louder, while Dori put an arm about his brother's shoulders to pull him close. And Nori...

          Nori was staring right at Bilbo.

         Bilbo blinked, his heart catching in his throat. Had he...had he slipped out of the in between ? But that had never happened before! But just as Bilbo began to panic he realized that Nori wasn't looking at him...but at the dwarf right in front of Bilbo, who had been creeping forward as steadily as Bilbo had before, until he was right behind the boys to Thorin's left.

          That was...odd.

         The dwarf was not one Bilbo recognized but from his fine clothes and the jewels dripping from his neck and in his hair, the fellow was a noble of some sort. Perhaps one of the Iron Hills lot? But why was he trying to get close to the boys? Bilbo did not like that at all. Not with what they had heard about these Iron Hills folk, who were trying to say that Fíli should not inherit the throne of Erebor simply because he was Thorin's nephew.

         Just as Bilbo was trying to figure out how best to pull that noble back – just in case – the worst happened. For it was not the boys that this strange dwarf targeted. Oh, no. It was Thorin. Before Bilbo could move that dwarf darted forward, just as Nori let out a cry when the song swelled and filled the entire cavern with a deafening low note, that dwarf got his hands on Thorin's back...

         And pushed.

         Something cracked through Bilbo like a bell at the sight. Thorin was falling. Thorin was falling. There was no way to catch him, no way to save him from that height. Nothing but Bilbo. Bilbo, who had to fall once more.

         So Bilbo did the only thing he could think to do. He took one step. Two. Then a third. Then he was leaping from that platform, everything lighting up around him as he slipped from the in between and back into the world once more.

         “Thorin! Take my hand!”

 

 

~*~

 

 

          All Thorin could see was Bilbo. His hand was warm in Thorin's, palm to palm, and fingers curled tight. All the world felt...strange about him, like he was spinning, like this strange fall into the heart of the Mountain would go on forever. Perhaps it was a blessing from his Maker. Perhaps there would be no pain when they hit the bottom, that they were given this impossible, infinite fall instead.

          Thorin pulled Bilbo to him, holding his One in his arms at last. “Bilbo,” he whispered, reveling at the warmth of his One against him, at the way Bilbo's arms went about his neck, how they were pressed cheek to cheek in a holy kiss.

          Thorin did not expect his Bilbo to say, “Brace yourself,” and then that strange fall twisted around them, hurling Thorin's stomach into his throat and making his head spin as if he had emptied every barrel of ale in all of Arda all at once.

          “Bilbo,” he managed to gasp out.

         Warm hands touched his face. “Everything is going to be all right,” his Bilbo whispered. Then it felt as if...as if something had grabbed them, some great force just scooped them up in it's hand and then –

          That was the last Thorin knew.

Chapter 15: to wake in golden light

Chapter Text

 

        The world was strange and fractured. Thorin could not open his eyes for more than a few seconds at a time, for every time he tried it felt as though his insides would soon be his outsides and a great dragon had taken up residence in his head.

        “...told you not to...”

       “...but he was falling, Fortinbras! He was...”

       “...can't stay here...”

       “...never said that, just...”

       “...get him back...”

       “...I have a plan for that...”

        All Thorin could do was reach out and find the bright spot of his One and hold onto his hand. Hold onto Bilbo, who had leaped from the dark to catch him. Was Bilbo...was Bilbo arguing with Mahal? But that...that would be impossible. Wasn't it? But then so was Bilbo, catching him, coming to him from wherever it was that hobbits went to –

       “...easy now, laddie...”

       “...wrong with him...”

       “...need a needle...”

       “...but he's not...”

        There was a strange pinching sensation and Thorin drew in a deep, sharp breath as a warmth started to spread through him. He had not realized just how cold he was. It felt like being put in front of a fire after taking a plunge in the dark pools at the bottom of the holy caves in the Blue Mountains. It felt like the blessing waters that had to have a film of ice be broken from them each time their people went in. It felt like...it felt like...

        “Thorin,” Bilbo's face was all he could see. “Hang on. Everything is going to be all right.”

        Then Thorin knew nothing more.

 

 

 

        The next time Thorin woke it was to his name being screamed. It sounded...it sounded like Dwalin, but why was Dwalin screaming his name? All was blurry when he opened his eyes. His hand was cold from where he had held onto Bilbo. And instead of his One's face he saw the roof of...the roof of...

        Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, awoke before the throne of Erebor in front of all of his people to see.

 

 

~*~

 

 

        Dwalin had never been one for the holy ceremonies. He had faith in their Maker, as every dwarf did, but the singing and chanting were so low on his priority list that he would have rather been doing inventory of the guard's armory than stand on the shelf with the rest of his people and try his best to keep in tune with everyone else.

        As Thorin's recognized partner, though, Dwalin knew he had to be at Thorin's side for such ceremonies, and especially so when Dáin and his lot were watching their every move with their little beady vicious eyes. Dwalin knew that Dáin would want something for coming to their aid as he had for the battle before Erebor, but their cousin's intense arguments with Thorin were surprising even to Dwalin. Dwalin had thought Dáin would want some of the base materials stored inside Erebor or perhaps the main rights for producing certain wares. Dáin seemed to want it all though and was fighting tooth and nail over every scrap he could pry from Thorin's hands. Then there were the insults Dáin and his people kept slinging at Bilbo and...well...

        These arguments were wearing on them all.

        Added on to all that pressure was the feeling of being watched that had been ramping up for days. Everyone was on edge, Dáin's people especially, and even the elves and men seemed to feel it too. No one went anywhere alone. Some of their people were reporting that things had been moved, even when doors had been locked and shut tight, with only one key to get in or out of certain places. Bombur swore up and down that none of them had ordered mushrooms from Gondor or Rohan to help bulk out their food supplies, since most dwarves would eat them only as a last resort, yet every time Bombur went into the cold storage rooms – where only he had the key – boxes of them would appear.

        Then the day of the blessing had come and Bofur had come to him to report that an entire cold room had gone from empty to bursting over night. Bombur was still in the midst of taking stock, but from what Bofur had been able to see there were root vegetables and other sundries that would see them well into winter, even without having to rely on Rohan or Gondor for supplies. Dwalin had meant to tell Thorin about it but Dáin had been stalking all of Thorin's time and energy so Dwalin had put it aside for later, for the feast after the blessing, so they could speak in private during the chaos and clatter at the tables.

        Then Thorin had let out that terrible little noise that was still ringing in Dwalin's ears as he fell. Dwalin's fingers had just brushed the back of Thorin's jacket, so close to saving him, forced to watch as his lover, his friend, his partner, the one he had wanted to share their One with, his Thorin fall just like their Bilbo into the dark.

        And then. And then Bilbo came, streaking out of the dark and into the light of the holy forges like a meteor streaking through the sky, reaching out for Thorin...

        And then they both disappeared into the dark.

        Nori had started shouting at something behind him. Dwalin knew there were hands on him to keep him from casting himself into the dark with Thorin, with Bilbo, with the loves of his life. Dwalin wanted to jump in that moment. He did not want to be left behind. But Balin dragged him back with trembling hands that belied the strength in them, giving him a shake hard enough to rattle his teeth.

        “You are the King's Widow now,” Balin had hissed at him then, tears glittering in his eyes but not yet falling. “Dwalin. You have to stay. Please.”

        And that was when Dwalin looked beyond his brother to see Dáin staring down into the dark of the abyss with a strange, blank expression and all the air in his lungs had left him.

        Assassinations among their folk were not common but they did happen from time to time. More often in the elder days, when the kingdoms of Belegost and Nogrod filled the Blue Mountains and mined them bare. The War of Wrath, Dwalin had learned as all the nobles in Erebor did, had wiped out most of those ancient kingdoms and had moved their seats of power to what remained.

        Khazad-dûm. There the fights between the nobles were of a different sort, or so it was said. There were still challenges in the arenas from time to time, and every so often a brother or sister to the heir apparent would suddenly go missing but no actual tales of betrayal and murders between their kin had been told. Even so the ancient customs of the peace cup and many other rites stayed with them, all the way to here, to Erebor, where Dwalin would have to go to the throne room and watch as Dáin tried to take the seat that should have rightfully been Thorin's before his lover's body was cool in the abyss below.

        Dwalin didn't want to go. Nori was still shouting about the noble they had pinned on the ground, some fool from the Iron Hills by the looks of his silks and furs and jewels.

        Then Dáin stepped up and looked down at this dwarf, who stared up at Dáin with wide, pleading eyes. “You murdered my kinsman,” Dáin said and the chaos around them stilled. Dwalin was still kneeling by the edge of the platform, a coldness spreading through his bones as he watched Dáin mete out judgment that should have been Thorin's. That should be his. Dwalin got one foot under him. A second. Then Dáin spoke again. “For murdering my cousin of royal blood, Thorin Oakenshield, you are to be cast out, your name removed from the rolls of our people, no longer dwarrow, no longer kin. Be gone from my mountain and never return.”

        Fury blazed through Dwalin. “He should be put to death,” he began, standing tall before Dáin and his cronies. “He murdered the King!”

        “And now I am King,” Dáin snapped back. Dwalin heard multiple hisses go through the crowd.

        “Fíli is King,” Dwalin said, stepping forward. Dáin matched it, until they were a hairsbreadth apart. “Fíli is the Heir and by the laws of Erebor, he is now King.”

        “And by the rules of the Line of Durin, I am King,” Dáin's chin went up. There was a glittering rage to his eyes that made ice bolt down Dwalin's spine. He knew that glitter. He knew that madness. He had seen it before.

        “The rules of the Line of Durin are followed here,” Dwalin said into the silence left behind Dáin's words. “As Thorin was proclaimed by writ of his father Thráin, as he was proclaimed by writ by his father Thrór, Thorin proclaimed by writ that Fíli and only he would be Thorin's heir. Fíli is King Under the Mountain.” Dwalin saw the young dwarf go stiff, chin inching up as eyes turned to him. “And none other.”

        Dáin's lips pulled back into a snarl. “Such a dilemma can only be solved in one way,” he said. There was a stir of whispers that left the crowd staring at them. “By right of combat I challenge you, son of Dís,” Dáin turned to Fíli and spat at his feet. Dwalin felt his brother's arms go about him so that Dwalin could not throw Dáin off the platform for the insult to their new King. “The holy ones of my Mountain will witness it themselves. I will see you at dawn,” Dáin pointed at Fíli's nose. “As so witnessed by your people and mine, the Line of Durin will go to the winner of the trial by combat.” Then Dáin pulled a dagger – which he should not have on him – and cut a line across the palm of his right hand. “As the blood meets stone, it is set!”

        A cheer went up at his words from the throats of the Iron Hills dwarves that were filling the cavern. Dwalin swallowed down the rage and grief and the heartbreak that wanted to tear him in two and moved to Fíli's side. “Cut your palm, a bare scratch if you can, and echo his words,” he grit out into the lad's ear.

        Fíli's chin went up and he copied Dáin, a few drops of blood meeting the stone at his feet. “I hear you challenge, upstart,” he said. Hisses went through the Iron Hills crowd. Fíli did not flinch. “I will meet you at dawn and the Mountain will judge just who shall be King.”

        Dáin sneered at him and spat at their feet before he swept out of the caverns. Dáin's guards dragged the one who had killed Thorin with them, despite Nori and his people trying to hold them back. It was only a quick grab by Dori that kept Nori on the platform when one of Dáin's people shoved at the Spymaster hard enough to make him fall.

        Then it was just the Company – or what was left of it – left on the platform. Their people were on the tiers about them, less in number than the Iron Hills folk by a large factor, most of them artisans and miners and craftspeople who held a weapon only as a last resort. Náin, Dwalin well remembered, had taken much of their soldiers and army in the diaspora after Erebor's fall. But Dwalin could not let himself crack now, not with Fíli starting to shake, a fine tremor that was visible only to those closest to him.

        “Óin,” Dwalin said, his voice coming out in a croak. “See to his hand.”

        “We should return to –,” Balin's words cut off with a sharp intake of breath. “We should return to the Royal Wing. There are things Fíli must know, things we will have to prepare.”

        Dwalin closed his eyes against the sharp wave of grief that threatened to crash over him. They should have returned to Dwalin's rooms, to Thorin's rooms, to the rooms of the King. The rooms Dwalin would have to clean out before the trial by combat. Rooms that had to be emptied and inspected by their holy ones before the trial could even begin.

        “We will take care of it,” Dori said as they moved off the platform. One strong hand squeezed Dwalin's shoulder. “Stay with Fíli. Ori and I will take care of the rest.”

        All Dwalin could do was nod. Somehow he found himself in the boys' suite and pushed down in a chair by Balin. Fíli was set into the chair at his side. Once behind doors and surrounded just by their Company Fíli's tremors became shakes and even Kíli's embrace could not stop them.

        “How could they,” Fíli whispered, eyes dry but rimmed red as he stared into the fire. “How could they.”

        “They're gold sick,” Dwalin spoke the words at last. All eyes turned to him. He swallowed past the lump in his throat. “It's in their eyes. They're all gold sick.”

        Balin hissed, one hand going to his mouth. “We cannot prove it, not so fast. We would need a rite by the holy ones and they will be busy with the trial by combat.”

        “Which is mostly likely the plan,” Dwalin swallowed again. It was hard to think past the rage and grief that had him by the throat. “Dáin has been keeping us all focused on him, on his pig-headed unreasonable demands. He wasn't like this at the battle. Only after, when they all settled in to clear the rubble and the bodies. They're gold mad and have been for months. It's the only thing that explains it.”

        “And it would explain their preoccupation with Bilbo,” Balin murmured, his hand stroking his beard, even as it trembled. “We all believed...” He shut his eyes and turned his face away for a long moment. Then he drew in a shaking breath and forged on. “Perhaps it is a curse from the dragon. Perhaps it is the gold itself. We should get Gandalf and have him –”

        “We can't and you know it,” Glóin was the one to say. “This is our affairs, witnessed in the holiest of holies. No outsider will be allowed into the Mountain between now and dawn. You know as well as I. If we try Fíli will be declared a coward and will forfeit the match before it begins.”

        Dwalin felt his hands curl into fists but Glóin spoke nothing but the truth. This was their business. To involve others would cast such doubts onto Fíli's rule that it would end before it began. There would be a threat of their own people turning on him from the sheer dishonor of it. “We'll go over Dáin's fighting style. Thorin,” Dwalin felt his throat catch, something cracking through his chest and he had to stop and breathe through the ache of grief. “Thorin and I would spar with Dáin as youths. From what I've seen he hasn't changed his style much. He should still have the same tells.”

        “Uncle,” Fíli said, a term he had used only a handful of time towards Dwalin, turning to him. “You...you're the King's Widow now, you're...you have to...”

        “Don't. Please,” Dwalin closed his eyes. “Just let me...after. After we can...I need to focus on this,” he opened his eyes to see Fíli's stricken expression and Kíli's tears wet on his cheeks. “After,” he said again, gentler. “We will speak after.”

        Fíli bowed his head and said nothing more. Dwalin knew there were things moving about them in the Mountain, the holy ones starting the ceremonies for the trial by combat, casting the incenses into the abyss, and lighting the forges for one lost into the depths. There were orders to be given and things to be done but all Dwalin could do was sit there in the chair next to the boys he had helped raise and ache so deeply that he wanted to slip out the door and go back to that platform and cast himself off.

        But he could not. Not right now. Later...well. After the trial he could do as he pleased. After the coronation he could go anywhere he wanted. Right now...right now he had to help Fíli get through this abomination of a rite and see him through to the other side.

        None of them had slept by the time they all came together at the doors of the Throne Room. The holy ones led the way, their incense censers swaying as they chanted, circling Dáin and Fíli three times as the rites demanded. Dwalin watched as Fíli closed his eyes and breathed in deep, shoulders relaxing as he swayed a little in time with the song of their holy people. They had done all they could. Fíli knew everything Dwalin did about Dáin's fighting style. Fíli was younger, quicker, more agile. Dáin had more power and age and knowledge. It would come down to who had the blessing of Mahal to who would be King Under the Mountain now.

        All of their people, those of Erebor and those of the Iron Hills, had come to watch. Dwalin was sure the elves and men outside their gates were starting to wonder why there were no guards on the entrance and no one in the tents outside. All had come to watch this trial by combat. All had come to see who would become King.

        The Throne Room had been sealed off since the holy ones had blessed it in the deepest hour, guarding all entrances so none could tamper with the room or the combat area before it was time. Fíli and Dáin stepped up together behind the three holy ones who forced open the doors to the Throne Room with a mighty push, sending them crashing back against the walls with a wave of sound. Dwalin was right behind them, his place as the King's Widow, to bear witness to the fight for the throne. They started into the chamber as dawn's first light struck the great windows above, illuminating the Throne Room with a wave of golden light.

        Dwalin saw how that golden light – which should have hit the throne that still shimmered with gold and gems – moved to the ground before the throne, to illuminate...to illuminate...

        “THORIN!” The scream ripped from his throat without a second thought. “THORIN!”

        And, in that golden light, one Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, sat up.

Chapter 16: pierced by gold

Chapter Text

 

        Crashing onto the floor of Bag End with Thorin in his arms was not how Bilbo had thought his night would go. Thorin was pale and still, disconcertingly so. Bilbo rolled the dwarf's greater bulk off of him, trying not to groan when his lungs could finally expand, and then got to his knees to hover at Thorin's side.

        Bag End of the in between was different than it had been when this mess had started. Before, Bag End had been bare, an empty shell of itself, but as time passed – and the more time Bilbo spent in the in between – the Bag End in this realm started to adorn itself with the trappings of the Bag End that now resided in Erebor's dark halls. This Bag End was...warmer now, as the weeks passed and Bilbo found his ease with passing back and forth through the in between growing, as did the other hobbits. No one tended to stay in the in between for long, except for a handful of widows who were spending more and more time there as the days passed. Bilbo had tried to ask Lalia about it but the Matriarch of the Took clan had just shaken her head at him and that was that.

        But here, now, with Thorin pale and barely breathing, Bilbo was grateful that there were widows about in the halls. For even as he scrambled to his feet and tore the door open to call for help there was the sound of rushing bodies and then Fortinbras was there, with Lalia at his side, the two of them barreling into Bilbo and sending them all to the ground.

        “What in the world?” Bilbo gasped out from underneath them.

        “Bilbo? Are you all right? The widows came to us, told us to come here immediately, to Bag End, that there was something...” Fortinbras trailed off and then his weight disappeared, then Lalia's. He took her hand to stand and turned to see Fortinbras standing over Thorin, his hands on his hips and a deep frown on his face.

        “Bilbo,” Fortinbras said. “What is he doing here?”

        Bilbo winced, ducking his head as he ran a hand over his face. “I can explain.”

        “Bilbo...”

        “I know! But he was falling, Fortinbras! He was going do die!”

        “You know he can't stay here. Things go...” Fortinbras flicked his wrist, making a warding sign.

      “I never said that, just...I had to fall with him,” Bilbo flinched at the way both Fortinbras and Lalia turned to him, hands reaching out. His shoulders were still about his ears as Fortinbras folded him into a hug, along with Lalia. “I could not let him die,” Bilbo whispered into Fortinbras' shoulder. “Someone pushed him, Fortinbras. They wanted to kill him. And I couldn't...I couldn't let that happen. I couldn't. Not while I still live.”

        “Ah, lad,” Fortinbras said, one large hand coming up to cup the back of Bilbo's head. “You've gone and bound yourself to those two, haven't you?”

        It was not something Bilbo had ever admitted to, before. Yes, he had explained the journey, the gold-sickness, the mess of the dragon and the way the dwarves had turned strange, but Bilbo had never admitted that he had set his heart on Thorin and Dwalin and could not take it back. Bilbo could not find the words to answer his cousin so all he did was nod.

        He heard his cousin let out a long sigh. “I see. Well, then. We'll...figure that out later. First we have to get your Thorin back, double quick, before...”

      Bilbo pressed his forehead against his cousin's greater bulk and nodded again. Living things that were not hobbits did not do well while in between. Animals miscarried. Plants withered, going limp and strange, not brittle or weak, as if without sun, but almost as if they were coming undone from the inside out. Animals too, would go strange, sometimes foaming at the mouth or going wild, attacking any who came near. They would need to get Thorin back to into Erebor, but how? And where? If they took him to his rooms, perhaps that would be enough, but all Bilbo could see in his mind's eye was the dark look on Dáin's face, on the way the nobles that surrounded Dáin scowled at Bilbo's Company, looking at them as if they had no right to be there.

        Bilbo's mind whirled, thinking through plan after plan as he let himself rest against Fortinbras and Lalia for just a moment. If they were going to do this then they needed a plan. Something that would help Thorin and his people, something that would make a difference in the maze of dwarven politics that the hobbits – and Bilbo – were still learning.

        Bilbo let himself rest against his cousin for one more moment before he pulled away, wiping the back of his wrist against his eyes. “I know Thorin cannot stay here,” he said as they let him step back. Fortinbras had a frown on his face but Lalia took his arm and that frown lost a bit of its edge. “I know that we need to get him back into Erebor immediately. But...” Bilbo bit down on his lower lip and met Fortinbras' gaze. “There is something going on in the mountain. We all know there is. We have to do this very carefully.”

        “Then how do you want to do this?”

        “I think...I have a plan for that,” Bilbo held up his hands at the way Fortinbras' frown grew. “We need to get him to someplace public, someplace that will make a statement.”

        “A statement,” Fortinbras echoed. He looked at Lalia but she was also frowning, not at them but at something beyond Bilbo.

      Bilbo turned to follow her gaze and felt his breath catch. For there, on the old table that his father had made with his own two hands, the same table that Bungo had taught Bilbo how to read maps at, was a crown. It glittered in the strange light of the in between, silver and blue and crimson, the gems at the four corners shining in a way that Bilbo could not explain. “What in the world...?”

      Bilbo approached the crown on light feet, not quite sure if it was even real. But when he reached out the crown itself was cool and solid to touch. Bilbo lifted it to eye level and turned it this way and that, trying to read the tiny carvings along the band. They looked like some of the inscriptions that Bilbo had seen in the mountain and in the tunnels where their smials had made their home. Bilbo had never seen it in the mountain before, not in the treasury or anywhere else where he had explored. And for it to appear here, in the in between... “What could this mean?”

        “I do not know,” Fortinbras said as he stepped up to Bilbo's side. “But it belongs to your Thorin, of that I have no doubt.”

        The door to Bag End banged open, letting in Remy Oldwalker. They all jumped at the sound, with Bilbo almost dropping the crown in his hands. “It's bad,” the old wayfinder gasped out. “The dwarves are going to fight.”

        “What?” Both Bilbo and Fortinbras cried out.

        “Davin heard it from Hal, who was watchin' over your dwarves, Bilbo. They're going to fight for the crown of Erebor in the morning. That Dáin challenged the young one to a duel.”

        Bilbo looked at Fortinbras and then down at the crown in his hands. “A fight for the crown,” he said, his mind starting to flick through plan after plan once more. “Where?” He looked up at Remy.

        “The throne room,” Remy said, wringing his hands together. “They're in the process of closing it off to make sure none can go in or out. It's a mess. The whole mountain is locked in, no one can leave. The elves and men outside are starting to notice.”

      Bilbo drew in a breath and squared his shoulders. “Right, how long has it been?” Time sometimes moved oddly in the in between. A moment could be an hour or a day could be a handful of seconds. There did not seem to be a rhyme or reason to it, so all they could do was keep track through the clocks that sat in their smials in the mountains. Several widows had taken up stations next to them, keeping track of those who came or went, sometimes always knowing who was in between and those who were not.

        “You have a few hours til sunrise,” Remy said.

        “A few hours,” Bilbo repeated. Then, “Right. We can do this.”

        “Bilbo?” Fortinbras put a hand on his shoulder.

      “We need to get Thorin to the throne room,” Bilbo told him. “We'll have to use the in between to get him there, but Thorin needs to be there when they open the doors. And if we put this on Thorin's head...” Bilbo lifted the crown in his hands. Fortinbras' eyebrows went up but he was already nodding along. “Then there will be no fight. It will look like Thorin fell into the mountain and came out at the throne room, already crowned.”

        “Are you sure –”

        “Fortinbras,” Lalia's sharp call had them both turning. Thorin was starting to shake where he was laid out on the ground. “I need your help.” Lalia was next to him, pushing a pillow beneath Thorin's head. “Help me turn him.”

        “What is going on?” Bilbo all but threw the crown onto the table so he could help Lalia turn Thorin to his side.

        “I do not know.” All of Lalia's focus was on Thorin. Bilbo did not want to split her attention for a second. “I need –”

        The sound of the door opening again barely registered in Bilbo's ears. What he did notice was the gnarled hands that reached out and pulled Bilbo's away from Thorin. He looked up to see Widow Layflower peering down at Thorin, her blue eyes sharp and clear and – were they glowing?

        No. That was impossible. Wasn't it?

        “Hold him steady now, Lalia,” Widow Layflower said. “Easy now, laddie. There's a good fellow. You,” her sharp gaze locked onto Bilbo. “Help hold him down now.”

        “But – what is going on? What is wrong with him? Why –”

      “Now, lad.”

        Bilbo did as Widow Layflower said, helping Lalia and Fortinbras to hold Thorin onto his side as he began to seize. An awful, wretched noise was coming from his throat and Bilbo could not help but slide his hand into Thorin's, holding on as tight as he dared.

        “Now, this will need a needle, of that I'm sure.”

        “What?” Bilbo's head snapped up to look at the widow. “But he's not...”

        “Argue with me when you become a widow, Bilbo Baggins, and not a second before,” Widow Layflower said before taking out the biggest needle Bilbo had ever seen. It was as long as his palm and glittering gold. Even the needles some of the widows used on their tapestries were not as large. Bilbo bit his tongue as Widow Layflower bent over Thorin, her thin fingers glancing over Thorin's face, across his hair, and then down to his chest. It was there, just above his heart that she paused, that huge needle glinting in the strange light of the in between. “There it is,” she murmured. Then, faster than Bilbo thought she could move, that golden needle plunged into Thorin's chest, right at his heart.

      A horrified yelp escaped Bilbo before he could stop it. He wanted to pull her hand away. He wanted to knock the widow back, the throw himself over Thorin, to do something to protect Thorin. But then...then Bilbo saw Widow Layflower draw back the needle and instead of blood there was...there was...

      “Is that a shadow?” Bilbo couldn't help but ask.

        “That it is, laddie,” Widow Layflower said. She did not take her eyes off the needle for a second. “Be a good lad and get me one of the pots from the kitchen. Double quick, now.”

        Bilbo scrambled to his feet and threw himself into the kitchen, grabbing the first tin he found. Once it would have had biscuits, bought at a fair in Bree by one of his mother's cousins. The sweets had been a disappointment but the tin itself had been pretty enough to use for odds and ends. Here and now he held it where Widow Layflower directed, locking his body into place as she drew and drew and drew a thread right from Thorin's heart with her glittering golden needle.

        With careful hands she wound that shadow into the tin, the tip of that needle directing its placement. As she worked Bilbo noticed that Thorin had stopped seizing and color was coming back to his cheeks. As Thorin relaxed Lalia and Fortinbras rolled him onto his back, allowing the widow more room to work. “Set the tin down, lad. Go to him, now. Remy, help me with the rest,” Widow Layflower said as the last of that strange shadow thread wound its way out of Thorin's chest.

      Bilbo shuffled his way to Thorin's head, there in time to see Thorin open his eyes for just a moment. He caught Thorin's hand in his own, wondering at the new warmth to his skin. Thorin made a strange sound in the back of his throat but Bilbo shushed him, running a hand over Thorin's forehead and hair. He barely noticed Widow Layflower and Remy pulling the tin full of that strange coiled shadow away, or the way Fortinbras and Lalia had pulled back so that Bilbo could bend over Thorin and meet that woozy gaze.

        “Easy,” Bilbo said as Thorin's eyes started to droop.

        “B-Bilbo,” his ridiculous dwarf said, his hand curling tight against Bilbo's fingers. “Stay. Please. Do...do not leave me.”

        Bilbo had to swallow against the knot in his throat. “Thorin,” he managed. “Thorin. Hang on. Everything is going to be all right.”

        Thorin's eyes slipped closed and his grip on Bilbo's hand went lax. But he was still breathing, far easier now, and still warm when Bilbo rested his hand against Thorin's face.

        “Bilbo,” Fortinbras said from above him.

        “I know,” Bilbo whispered. He sucked in a breath and pulled back his hand, looking up at his cousin. “We're going to need a cart. Dwarves are far heavier than they look.”

        Fortinbras snorted at that, the worry in his gaze easing by inches. “How about a wheelbarrow?”

        Bilbo choked out a laugh at that. “If it will get us to the throne room in time, then I do not care.”

        “Right,” Lalia was the one to say, clapping her hands together and startling them both. “One wheelbarrow and more than just our hands together. Let's get this show on the road.”

        In the end it took six of them to get Thorin into – yes – a wheelbarrow. Bilbo promised himself it would be a funny story when it all worked out in the end. And it would work out or Bilbo would find a way to rewind time and make sure it did. But for now they managed to wheel Thorin into the throne room, with only one panicked run back to Bag End to get the crown Bilbo had forgotten on the table, just before the sun rose over the horizon. They slipped out of the in between as the eastern windows began to glow with light, turning the dusty panes gray and then purple as the sun rose. Bilbo settled the crown on Thorin's head as the rest of the hobbits slipped back into the in between, making sure Thorin's hair was clear of his face and that he was as presentable as they could make him.

      “Be safe,” Bilbo whispered over Thorin as the first rays of light hit the eastern windows. He could hear the heavy tread of the dwarves approaching the far doors. He was out of time. “I will see you again, I promise.” Then he had to scamper as the doors crashed open, diving into the in between before any dwarf could see him lingering there.

      Bilbo stayed just long enough to see Thorin sit up in the light of the sun, with Dwalin's scream ringing in his ears before Fortinbras pulled him away. They could not stay. They did not know if the dwarven holy people could sense them and they did not dare to linger, just in case. Bilbo still stole one last look behind him as they stepped into the maze of the tunnels in the in between, in time to see Dwalin catch Thorin's hand and bring it to his chest. Then the door to the throne room closed between them and Bilbo placed a trembling hand on the worn wood, seeing the dwarven marks start to etch themselves over the portal. Such a door would lead no where else, now.

        “Come,” Fortinbras said, curling an arm over Bilbo's shoulder. Lalia tucked herself against Bilbo's other side. “The Bounders have said the emissaries from the West have arrived. I am going to the balcony above the gates to see for myself. I would have you come with me.”

        Bilbo swallowed several times before he could find his voice. “I will go,” he said, allowing Fortinbras and Lalia to draw him away. He wanted nothing more than to throw himself into Thorin and Dwalin's arms. He wanted nothing more than to tell the dwarves he loved that he was alive and well and safe. But they weren't safe, not yet. Things were moving around them in ways that made the hair on the back of Bilbo's neck stand on end. It was not yet time to tell his two dwarves that all was well. Not yet.

        Not yet.

Chapter 17: a second first breath

Chapter Text

         Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, awoke before the throne of Erebor in front of all of his people to see. For a moment he did not know when or where he was. His head still spun and all Thorin felt was warmth. Bilbo's words echoed in his ears, still strange and impossible, but still Bilbo. Still there. Thorin did not want to open his eyes. He did not want to leave this strange dream. He wanted Bilbo to hold his hand again. He wanted to clutch Bilbo close, so that they would never be parted. There was something...something about hearing Bilbo's words...about holding his hand...

         But the echoes of Dwalin screaming his name in a tone Thorin never wanted to hear again were still ringing in his ears, loud and sudden and there.

         And so, in that golden light, Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain, sat up and opened his eyes.

         Thorin blinked his eyes several times to clear them, turning when he heard a stampede of footsteps to his right. He saw Dwalin in the lead, pale and wan and looking so tired, with Fíli right behind him. Their holy people were hot on their heels and behind them...behind them was Dáin, who had a thunderous scowl on his face, hands curled at his side in a way that Thorin knew meant that Dáin was a half step away from violence.

         What was going on?

         The world felt strange, time disjointed, as Dwalin crashed to his knees at Thorin's side. Fíli was next to him, face wet with tears but the look of joy on his face could not be denied. Thorin felt his throat click oddly as he tried to speak, some rough feeling in his chest building as he held out a hand and Dwalin took it in a crushing grip. “What...” The word came out far rougher than he thought it would. “What has happened? What is going on?”

         Thorin watched as Dwalin and Fíli exchanged a look he couldn't quite read. But before they could say a word their holy people were there, all but forcing Dwalin and Fíli away from Thorin as they all knelt about him in a circle. Thorin watched as these holy ones, these normally serene clerics of their people, bowed low, foreheads touching stone, all of them facing him.

         “What is the meaning of this?” Thorin found his voice, stronger this time. The holy ones stayed bowed low in the golden light streaking in from the windows.

         “Thorin,” Dwalin was the one to say. He still looked wrecked and awful and Thorin wanted nothing more but to pull Dwalin close in that moment. “You fell.”

         Thorin opened his mouth to reply but nothing came. He looked up at the sunlight spilling across him, frowning. He remembered standing on the platform with his Company, his family, his lover, his friends. He remembered holding his palms up in supplication, drawing in a breath to sing with the rest of his people. He remembered...

         “Bilbo...” He breathed out, heart tripping over in his chest. The shove. The fall. “Bilbo.”

         “He came for you,” Dwalin said as he stepped through the circle of the holy ones to kneel again at Thorin's side. “He fell for you.”

         Thorin closed his eyes at that, turning his face into Dwalin's chest. On a quiet breath he said, “I remember.” He pulled back after a moment and met Dwalin's gaze. “He cried out for me to take his hand. I did.”

         “You did,” Dwalin nodded. “And then you disappeared into the depths of the mountain.”

         Thorin paused at that and then shook his head. “No,” he said and the holy ones about him shifted, murmurs rising from the gathered dwarrow around them. “Bilbo took me...somewhere else. I do not remember much of it. Bilbo was...he was...” Thorin frowned, trying to remember. His head had spun so badly and he had been so cold there, right down to the marrow of his bones. Then had come the voices, the argument. “I thought he was arguing or – or pleading with Mahal.” That caused a greater stir. The holy ones sat up around him, eyes wide and staring. “There was...another voice,” Thorin pressed a hand to his head. “It is so muddled, I cannot remember more. Just that Bilbo said...he said that everything was going to be all right. And then I was...he did something and I was warm again. But what has happened here?”

         “Thorin,” Dwalin said as he reached out and curled a hand around Thorin's shoulder. His mouth firmed into a grim line. “You were presumed dead, lost to us into the depths of the mountain. You should know that Dáin challenged Fíli to a rite of combat for the throne of Erebor after you...fell.”

         All the breath left Thorin's lungs. His gaze snapped to Dáin where his cousin stood, well beyond reach, with two massive guards on either side of him. Dáin was dressed for combat, his axe strapped to his side, his armor polished and glinting in the sunlight that illuminated the room.

         “The holy ones sealed the throne room for the rite,” Dwalin continued, his hand tightening on Thorin's shoulder, holding him in place. Thorin could not tear his eyes away from Dáin's glower, from the way his cousin stood, angry and belligerent, before him. “No one could enter. All the exits were guarded. But you are here,” Dwalin's voice shook on the last word. Thorin tore his gaze from Dáin to look back at his partner. “You appeared before us in the sun, before the throne of Erebor, with...”

         Thorin saw Dwalin's gaze go to Thorin's forehead. He reached up and was shocked to find a circlet set about his head. He had worn no such jewelry when he had gone to the rite the night before. He removed it despite the cry of dismay that came from the holy ones to see what it was, for it did not feel like the simple circlet he had been wearing these last few months. And indeed it was not the crown he had chosen, a simple thing that he should have chosen in the first place. No, instead this was a circlet of mithril, etched with the sign of Durin on the four quarters, the ancient symbols of their people carved into the band between the sigils. Thorin would have known the crown anywhere. Any dwarf would, even though it had been lost for Ages.

         The Crown of Durin had returned to them at last.

         “How...” Thorin turned the crown in his hands, all words lost to him. The crown was said to have vanished during the War of Wrath.

         “My king,” Alviss, the head of the holy people bowed low again before Thorin and then rose, settling back on his knees. “This is a sign, a sign from Mahal. You were returned to us after falling into the heart of the mountain. You have returned to us adorned with the first of all our crowns. You, Thorin Oakenshield, are blessed by Mahal to be King Under the Mountain and none other.” Alviss reached out and took the crown from Thorin, his hands trembling and causing bright flecks of color to scatter over Thorin's blue tunic. Alviss then reached up and set the crown back on Thorin's head, such a light thing, a simple thing that Durin I himself wore when the world was young. Then Alviss bowed again, as did all the other holy ones, as an echo of his words were repeated like a wave through the ranks of their people who had come into the room.

         Dáin, Thorin noted with a part of his mind that was not reeling from everything else, did not echo those words.

         “What –,” but Thorin was cut short by the sound of running feet. He looked over Dwalin's shoulder to see Nori catching a young dwarf by the shoulder and bending to hear what he said.

         “My king,” Nori said as he stepped away from the runner. “The elves and men are at the door. The emissaries from Valinor have arrived.”

         Thorin drew in a sharp breath, trying to settle his mind. There were many questions he needed to ask. Many things yet to sort out. Dáin turned on his heel and pushed his way through the crowd, ignoring the cries from those he shoved out of the way. Dealing with Dáin alone would have been a pressing issue, but with the emissaries from Valinor outside, with the gates locked and barred and their allies no doubt wary at best of their people...

         Thorin looked at Dwalin. “Help me up, please.”

         He saw Dwalin swallow, a shadow of grief passing over his face. Such an act was done only by one's spouse in their culture, when such gifts of Mahal had been received. Doing this in front of their people would name Dwalin as Thorin's partner, as his Consort, without anything more needed to be said. But they would not have Bilbo there to be on Thorin's other side to help Dwalin with this task and they both felt that loss in that moment. Thorin took Dwalin's hand and stood on legs that felt like they should be shaking but did not tremble once. He kept Dwalin's hand in his as he looked out over his people, at his Company, who were looking back at him with wide eyes. Then Thorin turned to look at the throne, at the one place he had been avoiding, not wanting to look at such a symbol of kingship when he felt as though he did not deserve it.

         The throne of Erebor stood before him, still tall and regal, still as imposing as Thorin remembered, but there was something...something off about it. Thorin frowned, unable to place the unease that had settled in his heart at the sight of it. The throne was the same as when Thorin had been gold-mad, the wide steps still carved with ancient designs, the shimmer of gold that was inlaid into the armrests glinting in the sun. Above the seat was the Arkenstone, set into place by Thorin himself after Bofur had chipped it out of the melted gold of the treasury.

         Thorin blinked and blinked again when he took a second look at the gem. It almost looked as though a shadow lay over the Arkenstone, but how could that be? The Arkenstone glowed even in the darkest of rooms, the Heart of the Mountain that Thráin I had found when their people had first set foot in Erebor.

         Then, “My king,” Nori said, far closer than he was before. “Thorin,” he said, much softer.

         “Yes,” Thorin tore his gaze away from the gem with a shake of his head. He saw Dwalin and Nori exchange a look but shook his head at them. He did not know how to explain what he saw. He had no desire to horde the Arkenstone again, no desire to keep their doors closed against their allies and lock them all away in the mountain. But he did not know how to explain the shadow he thought he saw and had no desire to have that conversation here and now, before all his people. “Let us go,” he said, louder, looking past Nori to where his people were gathered. All of the refugees from Erebor had come to see the rite of combat between Fíli and Dáin, Thorin was sure, and none of them had left when Dáin had stormed through the doors. They were all waiting for him to lead them forth.

         So, hand in hand with Dwalin, Thorin put one foot in front of the other and walked back out into the mountain, his people parting before him. The path to the gates had never felt so long. He knew he was holding onto Dwalin's hand too tight, some emotion he did not have the time to deal with at the moment thick in his throat. Their people bowed before them both as they passed, hats pulled from heads and skirts brushing low as none spoke. Thorin focused on the warmth that was still settled in his chest, on Dwalin's hand in his, as they stepped out of the shadows of Erebor and into the light of day outside the great gates.

         Before them was a vast array of peoples. Men and elves and Iron Hills dwarves were milling about, the latter with long faces and surly expressions that Thorin had no time to address in the moment. Of Dáin he saw nothing but Thorin would have bet the mountain itself that his cousin was somewhere in the crowd, watching. Thorin shelved that problem for the moment as he focused on the sight before him. In front of the great gates of Erebor was a trio of beings and the one that stood in the center was one that Thorin had only known from myth and legend. For at the center stood Eönwë, the banner-bearer and herald of Manwë, and the one who had led the armies of Valinor to Arda during the War of Wrath. Thorin had seen depictions of Eönwë in the scrolls of their people that had survived the First Age. The Maia was tall, his blond hair braided back at the temples and left loose to spill down his back, bright gold against the dark blue of his cape. He wore silver armor that glinted in the sun and at his side hung a sword that seemed to glow, even sheathed as it was.

         At Eönwë's right was another being Thorin had only seen depicted in books. Maedhros, first born son of Fëanor, stood half a head taller than even Glorfindel of the Golden Flower, his red hair as brilliant as rubies in the morning sun. He too was clad in silver armor, though his jerkin was a red that was far darker than his hair. Thorin caught sight of a sword hanging from his waist as well but what caught most of his attention was the two hands the elf had, when Thorin was rather sure that Maedhros had died with only one.

         Interesting.

         At Eönwë's left was another elf, with dark hair that flowed loose down his back, held back by a simple circlet of silver. Thorin did not recognize him, but the way Glorfindel was staring at the elf made Thorin think that Glorfindel, at least, knew exactly who he was.

         “My apologies,” Thorin said before Gandalf could say a word. The wizard was glowering at him from under his bushy brows, though the frown faltered as his gaze seemed to catch and hold at the sight of the crown on Thorin's head. At his side stood Elrond, though the elven lord was not even trying to hide the way he was staring at Maedhros. Galadriel, too, was staring at Maedhros, though her expression was far cooler than Elrond's. He gave Eönwë a shallow bow, still holding Dwalin's hand. “There was a...cultural rite taking place. It was not my intention to keep you waiting.”

         To his shock all Eönwë did was tilt his head to the side a touch before he bowed back, deeper than Thorin's shallow bow, deep enough that it caused murmurs to arise from the ranks of elves. “King Thorin Oakenshield,” the herald of Manwë said as he rose. “I give thanks that you allow us here.”

         Thorin rocked back on his heels, not quite sure what to make of that. “I welcome you and your people to Erebor,” he said, glancing briefly at Gandalf. He was relieved to see the wizard give him a faint nod. Thorin had not a single clue how this power from the utmost West even knew his name. Something strange was surely afoot.

         Eönwë's eyes were piecing in the same way the great eagles had been. His gaze too seemed to linger for a moment on Thorin's crown. “This is Lord Maedhros,” he said, glancing at Maedhros, who bowed, “and Lord Ecthelion.” He gestured to the other elf, who also bowed. “They were chosen to come hither to these lands with me. There is great news from Aman that all the peoples of Arda must know. I would speak of it now to you all.”

         Thorin drew in a slow breath. “Would you rather speak in the privacy of a tent or here, in front of all our peoples?”

         Eönwë's eyes were bright, far too bright for the slant of the sun even in that early morning hour. “I believe,” the herald of Manwë said, “that such news is owed to all who live on these far shores.”

         Thorin nodded, slowly. “Then speak, please,” he swept out his free hand. “And we will listen.”

         Eönwë tilted his head to one side again, briefly, before he also gave one slow nod. That strange, sharp gaze did not once leave Thorin's face. “Once,” Eönwë began, “Ages ago, Mandos delivered a prophecy to those of us in Aman. He spoke of the end of Arda and how the world will be healed of Morgoth's evil shadow.” At last that gaze left Thorin, sweeping across the gathered men and elves and dwarves. “The Second Prophecy of Mandos states this: When the world is old and the Powers grow weary, then Morgoth, seeing that the guard sleepeth, shall come back through the Door of the Night out of the Timeless Void; and he shall destroy the Sun and the Moon.”

         Whispers broke out at that, with several men in the crowd curling their fingers into signs that would ward off evil.

         Then Eönwë's gaze was back on Thorin, who could only raise his chin in the face of that strange stare. He was still not sure why Eönwë was so focused on him. “Several weeks ago Mandos came before Lord Manwë and said that this prophecy has been shattered by hands other than our own. The ultimate fate of Arda has been changed so completely that not even the Valar now know its fate. Once it was believed by our Lord Manwë that only the Sons of Men and the Ainur would sing before the throne of Eru Ilúvatar to create the Second Music that would reshape the world. But now...” His gaze drifted beyond them, to the mountain, to perhaps only something he could see. “Now the Song has changed and not even Lord Manwë knows what will happen next.”

         Eönwë continued before anyone could speak. “It was believed by the Powers in the West that only one of the Maiar could defeat Sauron and bring him low, to throw off his shadow on the world and free the peoples of Arda from his presence. But now...” He shook his head. “Sauron is gone. Defeated not by one of our own powers but by a race on Arda that none of us have ever heard of before.”

         Thorin felt Dwalin's hold on his hand tighten to the point of pain and then relax. Thorin felt a knot gather in his throat. “A race you have never heard of,” he echoed. Thorin could only think of Bilbo in that moment, of the Shire, of the hobbits who had vanished from the face of the earth.

         “Yes,” Eönwë said, that gaze sharp and still as he stared at Thorin. “Do you know of such a race, King Thorin Oakenshield?”

         For a moment all Thorin could hear was the whistle of the wind as it screamed over the battlements. For a moment all he could see was Bilbo's eyes, wide and frightened. But then his chest warmed and he thought he could feel Bilbo's hand in his once more. That he could hear Bilbo's voice in his ear. “Yes,” he managed to say, his tongue thick in his mouth. “I do.”

         Eönwë's eyes brightened, his gaze as sharp as ever. “Would you tell us of them, of what happened here in this place to cause such ripples that have changed the very Fate of this world?”

         Thorin looked at Dwalin, who met his gaze with a grim look. Then Thorin turned back to Eönwë and raised his chin. “Our mountain had been taken by a dragon, scattering my people to the winds,” Thorin began. “Then came our Quest and the retaking of Erebor. We were thirteen together, that was all who would answer my call.” Thorin turned to look at his Company, still so proud of them. The Ur brothers shifted on their feet but Glóin, Óin, and Balin stood proud and tall before them all, with the Ri brothers hiding a bit behind the three dwarves. Fíli and Kíli held each other's hands and smiled back at him. He turned back to Eönwë. “Gandalf told us of a possible fourteenth member,” Thorin said and couldn't help his smile. His heart ached at the memory of their first meeting. “A hobbit, by the name of Bilbo Baggins, from the Shire. He came with us, he saved us.” Thorin had to stop there, his throat tight with emotion. “He killed the dragon that had driven out my people and bought peace when my madness would have put us on the precipice of destruction. He –,” Thorin caught sight of the sharp shake of Gandalf's head and paused. Thorin held the wizard's gaze for a moment before looking back to Eönwë. “But in Bilbo's saving of us,” Thorin had to stop again, blinking away the burning sensation in his eyes. “The Shire was destroyed and I let Bilbo fall to his death. The hobbits are gone and – aside from Bilbo's passing – we do not know why or how.”

         Eönwë's bright gaze never left Thorin's face. “They and he are gone, you say?”

         Thorin bowed his head. “Yes.”

         The herald of Manwë sighed then, his shoulders falling. “Then it will be a struggle to find the answers that are needed.” He shook his head then, his gaze sweeping over the gathered crowd. “Lord Manwë and Lady Varda are certain of one thing, that with the shattering of the Second Prophecy of Mandos, it is possible that the ultimate fate of the world has begun far sooner than it had ever been expected. The very enchantments that have separated Aman from Arda are unraveling as we speak.” A shock of murmurs swept through the crowd. Thorin looked to Gandalf but the wizard now only had eyes for Eönwë. “My Lord and Lady believe that some power we do not know is moving in the world, a power that may be changing the very Song we servants of Eru Ilúvatar once heard in the Timeless Halls. They also fear that this may be a ruse of Morgoth's, some ploy of his to return to the world far sooner than he should.”

         “But his servant Sauron has been destroyed,” Galadriel was the one to speak. “He is gone.”

         “Not completely,” Eönwë said, canting a look in her direction. “His shadow, like that of his master's, still remains in the world. It is feared that they have planned this, perhaps from the beginning, to bring back Morgoth for the final battle of them all.”

         “But that is impossible.” Galadriel shook her head, a frown marring her ageless face. “They are gone. The world feels...cleaner now. Lighter. Even our rings have not faded as we were told they would.” She raised her hand and a bright flash of light sparkled on her finger. “They are growing in power, instead.”

         Eönwë gave her a slow nod. “That is the fear, daughter of Finarfin. That the powers are gathering now, beyond our control, as the barriers between Aman and Arda fray, coming together here, for some final move.”

         “Powers?” Gandalf said. His gaze then moved to Maedhros and the wizard rocked back, his hands tightening on the staff that he had planted on the ground next to him. “You believe that the Silmarils lost in Arda will return. That Sauron will have some final plan to bring them forth?”

         Maedhros stepped forward, giving Gandalf a small bow. “Yes,” he said when he rose. “We do.”

         “Of course you would believe such a thing,” Galadriel said. “Well do we know what Oath you and your brothers swore! You –”

         “Peace, Lady Galadriel,” Eönwë held up a hand. He look at Maedhros and then back to the lady. “There are things that the Valar have learned in the long Ages since the War of Wrath. Things that none but those sons of Fëanor would have known. Things even they did not understand until they were in the keeping of Mandos.”

         Galadriel's chin went up. “And what was learned? What secret was revealed that all our long years and strife in Beleriand did not uncover?”

         “That Morgoth cursed the Silmarils,” Maedhros was the one to say. Gasps arose from all around them. Galadriel went pale, shaking her head at the words. “When Maglor and I, in our madness – in my madness,” he closed his eyes for a moment, a deep look of pain passing over his face, before he forged on. “When we stole the two Silmarils from Eönwë after the capture of Morgoth, we found the gems to be...strange. Darker.” He shook his head. “They burned our flesh for the horrors we had inflicted on the peoples of Beleriand in our madness, yes, but there was something darker, harsher, to the gems that we had never felt before. At first I thought it was simply a reflection of the corruption of my fëa.” He pressed his lips together in a thin line for a long moment. “But...it was not that. It was not until we spoke of such feelings to our father while we were in the Halls, and then to Mandos and the Lady Varda herself, about what we felt in the gems that we found the problem. That the Silmarils themselves had a – a shadow on them, like a film of oil on a still pond. We believe that Morgoth cursed the Silmarils in an effort to have some sort of safety net, a way to bring himself back to the world should his minions fail in their duties.”

         Murmurs rose up from the gathered crowd. “What would such a shadow do to the Silmarils?” Thorin was the one to ask.

         He watched as Eönwë and Maedhros looked at each other. To Thorin's surprise Eönwë nodded to Maedhros and the elf was the one to answer. “To be frank, we do not know for sure,” Maedhros said. “But we do know that when I returned to the Halls of Mandos the shadow of corruption that lay upon me was much darker than even the worst betrayer of our peoples, for reasons that Mandos himself could not explain. It was not the curse of our Oath,” he held up a hand when Galadriel opened her mouth to speak. “The darkness on my fëa was compared to Caranthir's and Celegorm's. Mine was worse and when Maglor finally returned to us it was the same with him. The only thing different between us was our handling of the Silmarils.” He shook his head. “They have never been found, in all the long years that they have existed here in Arda. I fear that a darker power has had a hand in that.”

         Galadriel's chin went up, her hard stare never leaving Maedhros. “And there is no worry that you will be bound by the Oath you once made? That in coming here you risk yet another Kinslaying?”

         Maedhros ducked his head at that, his shoulders coming up about his ears as murmurs swept over the crowd about them. Then he knelt before Galadriel and bowed low, his hair hanging in the dirt about his face. “I am sorry, cousin,” he said into the stunned silence that was left. Even Galadriel's eyes had gone wide and her face paled. “The things I and my brothers have done are cruel beyond measure. The concern over the Oath we took is one of the reasons why I was sent with Eönwë, so that should the curse still be connected to the madness of so many Ages ago, then I and I alone will bear the brunt of it...and that I alone would hand those gems of my father to the Valar once and for all, severing our connection to them at last.”

         All was silent. All was still. Then Galadriel let out a long breath and she bent, pulling Maedhros to his feet. Her hands lingered on his arms as she studied his face, the cool disdain that had been lingering in her gaze finally gone. “Perhaps it is time that I, too, learn to forgive the hurts of the past,” she said. “You regret them.”

         Maedhros' chin dipped in a nod. “More than you know.”

         Her hands flexed on his arms and then dropped, but her smile was kind when she slid her arm through his, trapping him in place next to her. “Then that is a place to start between you and I.”

         “Glad I am to see such things,” Eönwë said as he gazed at them. There was a faint smile on his face, a strange expression for a being that seemed so grave. Then the herald of Manwë turned back to Thorin and bowed again. “All signs that my Lord and Lady have seen and heard point to this mountain as the place where all of this has begun and where it may all end up taking place. I have sent a summons to all of the Istari to come here, so that we might find the answers we have been seeking. Will you allow this, King Thorin Oakenshield?”

         Thorin bowed back to the being. “I will,” he said as he rose. “Though you may have to suffer your stay in a tent outside the mountain for the time being. Erebor is...dangerous for those who are not dwarves at the moment.”

         “Of course,” Eönwë said.

         “I will host them,” Elrond said, stepping forward. His gaze had never once left Maedhros and the tall elf seemed to shrink in on himself under that steady gaze. “If...if that would be acceptable?”

         Maedhros looked at him at last. “If you would be comfortable,” he said.

         “I would.” Elrond's hand rose, reaching out to touch the tall elf's arm but drawing back before he made contact. His gaze finally left Maedhros and went to Eönwë and then Ecthelion. “If you two would also be accepting of such plans?”

         “We thank you, Lord Elrond,” Eönwë said. Ecthelion simply bowed low and rose with a smile.

         “You spoke of summoning the members of my Order,” Gandalf said and all eyes went to him. The wizard had a deep frown on his face. “When did you send such a thing?”

         “Before we stepped off the boat from Valinor,” Eönwë said. “Why?”

         Gandalf rocked back at that. “I have not received such a summons. Were you aware of my presence here?”

         That caused Eönwë's pleasant smile to vanish. “I sent it to all of your Order, you included, Olórin. That you did not receive it is troubling.”

         “Very troubling,” Gandalf agreed. “Saruman should not be far off, for he resides now in Isengard the whole year round, and it will not be a long journey for him to come here. As for the others...” Gandalf's hands curled about his staff. “Radagast I have seen in the last year, though he spends much of his time in the wilds. Of the others...it has been an Age since I have heard anything from them.”

         “I am sad to hear such news, and concerned,” Eönwë said.

         “Yes,” Gandalf sighed. “As am I. Have you received any acknowledgment from the others? Anything at all?”

         At that Eönwë shook his head and Gandalf's shoulders sagged. “It is my hope that they will arrive soon. I am bound to return to my Lord and Lady to report on all that I have uncovered here. It is my hope that the mysteries of what has happened may be solved and that we might yet be able to stop whatever plot of Morgoth's this may be.”

         “If it is a plot of that dark power's and not one of his minions,” Gandalf said.

         Eönwë nodded at that. “There are many questions that need be answered. There is yet time,” he said with a sigh. “All will be revealed at some point.”

         “Indeed,” Gandalf bowed his head at that. “I –”

         But whatever the wizard was about to say was stopped short by the sudden turn of Maedhros. It spooked many in the crowd, causing them to draw back from where he stood with Galadriel and Elrond. But it was not the crowd that seemed to have Maedhros' attention. Indeed, the elf was not looking at anyone at all. No, his gaze was beyond them, up and over their heads, towards...

         Thorin turned, following his gaze, and felt a chill run down his spine. Maedhros was staring at the balcony above the gates, where Thorin had held Bilbo and let him fall.

         “Maedhros?” Galadriel was the one to ask. “What is it?”

         Thorin turned back to see Maedhros' gaze still on that empty balcony, a deep line between his pinched brows as he seemed to scan the area again and again. “I feels like...” His frown deepened and he took a step towards the gates but Galadriel's hold on his arm held him back. That seemed to snap him out of it, for he began to blink and put a hand to his head. “Forgive me,” he said at last. “I thought I saw someone standing there but it must have been a trick of the eye.”

         Thorin looked up at Dwalin, whose expression was grim. Dwalin shook his head at Thorin's silent question. “There is no one up there,” Thorin told them, looking back at the elves. “The mountain was...in a state of lock down earlier, for our...rite. There would have been guards at the stairs and all other ways to that balcony are unusable. It must have been a...shadow.” Thorin wanted to wince at his choice of words.

         “A shadow,” Maedhros echoed. He did not smile. “Indeed.”

         Thorin did not jump when Balin appeared at his other side, giving him a subtle nudge with an elbow. “Our cooks have learned of your arrival,” his old friend said to the gathered emissaries and other leaders that had been watching on from the crowd. “We would be honored to have you all join us in a feast this evening.”

         “We would be grateful for such a kindness,” Eönwë said. Thorin let Balin take over the coordination of the feast, stepping back with Dwalin as Balin and the elf named Erestor came together in a way that should have been alarming. As it was all Thorin could focus on was the balcony above the gates and the way the mountain's shadow seemed darker there for reasons he could not name. But surely it was nothing, just a trick of the eye? For the mountain had been locked down by their holy people, blessed by their songs and by their prayers. The dragon was gone and the gold madness had not set its teeth into any of Thorin's people as they arrived.

         But...his gaze slid to the side where the Iron Hills dwarves were slinking away. There were other factions in the mountain now, and one in particular that Thorin would have to deal with very soon. Perhaps Maedhros did see something on the balcony. Perhaps there was a shadow there, just not one of Morgoth's working.

         “I need to speak to Dáin. As soon as possible,” Thorin said to Dwalin as they made their way back towards the mountain.

         “I know,” Dwalin said. “But I fear he will not be so agreeable to such a meeting, now.”

         Thorin felt a muscle tick in his jaw. “Then we shall have to make him agreeable,” he said. “Sooner rather than later.”

         Dwalin's sigh was all the answer Thorin needed. There were many answers that needed to be found, not only the ones sought by the emissaries from Valinor but by Thorin himself. What had Dáin been thinking? What was going on with his cousin?

         “We need to speak, alone,” Dwalin said after a moment, guiding their steps towards their rooms. “I may know part of the problem with Dáin and the others. And if I am right...”

         Thorin did not sigh but for a moment he felt every tiny ache in his body. It felt like a month had gone by in the span of a candlemark, from his waking in the throne room to his return to the mountain. He wanted to sleep. He wanted to pull Dwalin to him and curl up with what few pieces of Bilbo they had left, to carve out a moment of peace with them both. But that was not to be his lot. At least not right now.

         “Then let us talk,” Thorin said as he curled his fingers tighter about Dwalin's. “Come. We will figure it out together. As we always have.” They stepped into the cool darkness of the mountain, leaving the morning sun behind. They would figure it all out. They had to.

 

Chapter 18: a certain shift of shadows

Chapter Text

 

        Thorin pressed at the spot between his brows, trying to will the dull headache away. He could hear the stomp of Dáin's boots as he stormed off, the growl of his voice loud as it echoed in the hallway outside of Thorin's state room.

        “I take it the talk did not go well.”

        Thorin let his hand drop to pin Balin with the look he deserved. Thorin sat back in his chair as Balin slid into the seat that Dáin had occupied, a stack of papers thick in his hands. “It did not,” Thorin said as Balin flipped open the first leather-bound folder. “Is that...”

        “The register of the artisan families currently residing in the Iron Hills territories, yes.”

        Thorin let out a long sigh and let his head thump back against his chair. “I see.”

        “Do you have a list of which ones will be returning?”

        Thorin swallowed then, shifting his jaw as the urge to growl swept over him for what felt like the hundredth time that evening. “All of them,” he finally said. Balin's head snapped up, his pen dripping ink onto the white paper. “I got all of them back.”

        Balin blinked at him and then looked down at the paper, swearing at the smear of black across the neatly printed page. “All of them?” Balin said as he set his quill aside. “How did you manage that?”

        “Well, his attempt at trying to kill Fíli was a rather large bartering piece.” Thorin ran a hand down his face as Balin scowled at the memory. It had been a day since the push, the fall, and Thorin's return in the throne room. It had been filled with far too many meetings, far too many conversations full of pit holes Thorin had to maneuver, and not enough sleep. But sleep was something he did not have the time to indulge in, since Eönwë had told them all that evening that the rest of the wizards in Arda would be arriving the next day. How, exactly, the herald of Manwë knew such information Thorin did not know but he trusted that such a powerful spirit had his own ways of knowing things. Eönwë had been reluctant to speak more to any of the leaders gathered at Erebor until the rest of the wizards had arrived, for reasons he would not say. “Dáin tried to deny any knowledge or connection to the...” He couldn't say it, not even now. “But we both know he had to have known something was going to happen.”

        Balin's scowl deepened at that. “We still have not found the one who pushed you,” he said.

        “I know. Nori is furious about it. But it did help.”

        “Help?” Balin frowned at him.

        Thorin tipped up one shoulder. “I pointed out to Dáin that his immediate loss of the dwarf who would have murdered the rightful king of Erebor would be an...unfortunate piece of news to be spread among his allies and trade partners.” Thorin slid down in his seat, just a little. He was so tired. He hated to be at odds with his cousin, even now, when Dáin was so full of fury and a strange madness that Dwalin had been quick to point out once their Company was alone and behind closed doors.

        “Ah, lad,” Balin said on a sigh as he sat back in his own chair. “I know you are worried for Dáin. We all are.” He made a face. “In our own way.”

        “I'm rather sure Nori is going to try to push him off one of the ledges,” Thorin said with a laugh he did not feel. Balin snorted. “Did the holy ones agree to the rite?” Thorin forced himself to sit up and put his arms on the table. He could rest later. There was work yet to do, now.

        Balin's faint smile faded. “They have,” he said as he stayed in place, his sharp eyes studying Thorin. “They will do the cleansing ritual on the full moon.”

        “Less than a fortnight away, now,” Thorin murmured, tapping his fingers on the table. “That is still too long for my taste.”

        “Mine as well,” Balin said as he sat forward once again. “And with Dáin agreeing to give back all the artisans...that concerns me.”

        “Yes,” Thorin agreed, hating to voice the thought aloud. “He should have fought me more on it. Even with the threat of exposing his lack of action against the dwarf that would have killed me...” Thorin shook his head. “He gave in too easily. He is planning something. I can feel it.”

        “Do you think he will try to have you murdered again?”

        Thorin felt his shoulders go tight at the question. “I do not think Dáin ordered such an action.” He held up a hand when it looked as though Balin would disagree. “He seemed truly happy for a moment, when we first sat down. That I was alive. But it...there was something...” Thorin curled his right hand into a fist. It was the one he had held Bilbo's hand with, the one that still tingled from time to time in memory. “He seems...shadowed. Unlike himself, yes, but not quite gold-mad. Does that make any sense?”

        Balin's quill ticked back and forth as he made a note on a clean sheet of paper but after a moment he set it aside again. “Yes,” Balin said as he met Thorin's gaze. “While I agreed with Dwalin at first about the gold-sickness after your...” He looked away for a moment and then back before Thorin could say a word. “Dáin is not acting like...like we did, when we went...mad. He is not hording anything to my knowledge in his part of the camp, nor is he attempting to access the treasury at all. I do not know what to call what he is doing but it is not madness, not in the sense that we can understand at least.”

        Thorin let out a breath at that. “Yes,” he said. “Exactly.” He rubbed a hand over his mouth. “Nori has watchers on Dáin's part of the camps for now. What of the elves and men? I know you have had meetings with them both.”

        “With Thranduil, yes, but Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel have declined any meetings so far. I believe they are not leaving Lord Maedhros' side at the moment. As for the men, they seem wary at best at the news that has been given to us by the emissaries from Valinor. I have seen Lord Ecthelion – the elven one – and Lord Glorfindel walking together when I go out to the tents but I have heard little of what Lord Ecthelion's business is here in Arda.”

        “And of the wizards? Has Gandalf said anything?”

        “That he has not,” Balin sighed. “He is most often with Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel these days. Even Thranduil has joined them a handful of times, or so I have been told. Whatever is going on there we will find out when everyone else does.”

        “Wonderful,” Thorin muttered as he leaned further onto his elbows. “What other problems do we need to solve tonight?”

        Balin paused a moment too long, causing Thorin to look up at his old friend. “I think that is enough for tonight,” Balin said as he closed the folder he had been writing in.

        “But...”

        “Thorin, you have barely slept. You look worn through, even I can tell as much, and I know Óin is about half a moment from pouring one of his concoctions down your throat to get you to sleep.”

        Thorin made a face at that. “I would sleep if I could, but there are things to do before winter comes. The Long Night is less than a month away and the mountain is not yet inhabitable. If we do not sort out Dáin and the necessary goods that will get us through winter...” He trailed off as Balin held up a hand.

        “I know, lad,” Balin said. “I know. But none of that will be solved tonight. What's best right now is if you go and get a good night's sleep and start fresh tomorrow. We need you at your best, Thorin. Too much depends on it.”

        Thorin looked away at that but he could not argue the point. “I will sleep,” he said instead.

        “Soon.”

        Thorin huffed out a laugh. “Soon,” he promised. “Go on, then. I am sure Dwalin will be on his way back soon.”

        “I will send word to him that you've seen sense,” Balin said as he plucked his folders up from the table. Thorin rolled his eyes at him. “Get some rest, Thorin. I will see you in the morning.”

        “Good night,” Thorin called after Balin's retreating form. He knew the entire Company had been fretting over him since he had returned in the throne room. He was not sure if they believed what Thorin had heard in that strange place or whether they thought that it was something Thorin's mind had made up. None of them could deny, though, that Bilbo had saved him, that their Burglar had fallen with Thorin into the heart of the mountain and somehow pulled him out alive. But whether Bilbo's spirit had lingered with Thorin, had taken him somewhere else...that was not something Thorin could prove.

        Restless, Thorin pushed himself out of his seat and paced through to the bedroom. The fire had been banked but the air was still full of warmth. He crossed the room to where the stand for his crown now sat, slipping the crown of Durin I from his head and setting it aside. He stared at it for a moment, lips pressed together, and then turned away.

        As he made his way deeper into his rooms he tried to set his worries aside and focus on the present. The bedroom was warm as he shed his outer layers and laid them over the back of one of the chairs. Thorin had never remembered the royal wing being this warm before, but perhaps that was just his memory being faulty. The scattered memories of this room he did have was full of studying at the desk or running through drills in the front room, long after he should have stopped for the night.

        Since their return Thorin's childhood suite had been reconfigured so that it could become the main residence of the king of Erebor. The rooms on either side of his old chambers had been converted into an audience chamber and a more informal sitting room, with his and Dwalin's bedchamber at the very back. A more defensible position, both Nori and Dwalin had agreed. Thorin had remembered this area as rather cold and drafty but now it was snug, warm and inviting, like Bilbo's –

        Thorin had to stop and close his eyes, one hand pressed against the wall. No, he should not think of such things, not compare it to Bilbo's warm home in the Shire that was now ashes and crumbling away.

        “Thorin?”

        Thorin opened his eyes at the sound of Dwalin's voice. He turned to see his partner step into the room, his sword held in one hand but off of his belt, ready to be set aside. “Here,” he said, voice a touch rougher than he meant it to be. Dwalin was quick to strip his off his armor and weapons and set them on their stand before he crossed the room to Thorin's side. Thorin had not realized his feet had taken him to the small altar that sat on the east side of the room, set with candles that burned night and day.

        Thorin let out a long breath when Dwalin's warm palm settled at his nape. They leaned into each other as they stood before the altar and the small box where the holy silk that contained Bilbo's blood and a handful of other little objects of their One was kept. “I passed Balin on my way here,” Dwalin said into the quiet that had settled between them.

        Thorin just let out a long, tired sigh.

        “Are you still going to go through with the rite?”

        Thorin blinked at Dwalin's question, glancing at him and then looking back at the altar. “Yes. Why?”

        Dwalin's mouth flattened into an unhappy line. “Dáin does not deserve it.”

        Thorin swallowed down his first and second responses to that, knowing full well how Dwalin still shook at night sometimes when he held Thorin. Thorin could not imagine how Dwalin had felt on that ledge, seeing Thorin fall into the dark with Bilbo. It was a wonder that Dwalin had not thrown himself off after them. “He is still our kinsman,” Thorin said after a tense moment. “We have to try. If this is indeed some other force working upon him, then we have to try.”

        “I know that.”

        “Dwalin.”

        “I don't like you down there alone with him,” Dwalin shook his head. “I know the holy ones will have a few of themselves down there, but...”

        “I know,” Thorin said. “There will be no ledge for Dáin to push me from and we both know Dáin will not go into water deeper than his knees. I will be safe from him there.”

        “If the waters do not take you.”

        Thorin drew in a slow breath and let it out just as slow. “They will not take me,” he said, feeling the truth of it down to his bones. “I am meant to go into the waters beneath the mountain. There is something for me there. I can feel it.”

        Dwalin's hold tightened for a moment and then eased. “We will get through this,” Dwalin slid his hand down so that he could curl his arm about Thorin's shoulders. Thorin leaned into his warmth as they returned to contemplating the altar in front of them. He took the statement as the peace offering it was. They both knew that Thorin had to go through with the rite that he had asked of their holy people, both for their sake and for their people...and for Dáin.

        The candles on the altar were getting low. Thorin knew they would have to change them out soon but they would last through the night at least. The flickers of the candle flames did strange things to the shadows on the wall. For a moment Thorin thought there might have been a third body next to him, smaller than both he and Dwalin, just like...“Do you think Bilbo would have liked our rooms?” Thorin did not know where the question came from. He blinked and that shadow was gone.

        He felt Dwalin's pause, the slight tensing of his body. They rarely spoke of Bilbo, though they always spent time each night before what little they had left of him. “Maybe,” Dwalin said after a moment, his voice gone rough as well. “Might have wanted a balcony though.” His tone turned dour at that.

        Thorin couldn't help his laugh, a mere breath of a thing. “He would,” he agreed. “Full of flowers.”

        “And vegetables.”

        “And vegetables,” Thorin nodded. “You would complain endlessly about it.”

        “Oh like you wouldn't.”

        Thorin tipped his hand back and forth, laughing as Dwalin pushed at his shoulder. They came back together after a moment, pressed shoulder to knee against one another before the altar. He drew in another breath, to say what he did not know, but then a scent hit his nose. It was...strange. Odd. Out of place. It smelled like...it smelled like...

        Thorin twisted out of Dwalin's hold, turning to scan the room. “Bilbo?” His voice was little more than a whisper.

        “Thorin?” Dwalin's brows were drawn down into a deep frown but Thorin held up a hand, still scanning the room. It was by pure chance that he saw Dwalin pale and stagger back a step, one hand coming to cup his mouth and nose.

        “Do you smell that?” Thorin still could not speak above a whisper.

        “...Yes,” Dwalin croaked. “I do.”

        Thorin turned in a slow circle but the scent of Old Toby pipeweed was fading with each breath he took. They had all long ago run out of Shire pipeweed, something Bilbo had complained about when they had stayed in Lake-town. Dwalin had managed to find a pouch of something that might have once been the dregs of a pipeweed barrel long ago, just enough to get them through to the mountain and inside. After that...

        Well. The Shire was gone and the fields of pipeweed they were so known for along with it.

        “Perhaps it is coming from Bilbo's pouch?” Dwalin said after a long, strained moment. His hand dropped back down to his side.

        “Perhaps,” Thorin said, still scanning the room. The hairs on the back of his neck were standing on end. It felt like...it felt like...He reached out, not sure why, as if he could almost feel Bilbo near them. As if he tried hard enough he could touch Bilbo once more.

        “Thorin?”

        His fingers hit nothing but air and Thorin felt all the breath leave his lungs in one rush. “I thought...it felt like...” He had to stop and shake his head. He ran a hand over his eyes. “Perhaps I am just overtired.”

        “Perhaps,” Dwalin said. “Come. It has to be a scent from the pouch. We know he used to keep his pipeweed there.”

        “...Yes. Yes, of course.” Thorin let Dwalin draw him from the altar. They settled into bed and despite his exhaustion Thorin found that sleep did not come quick. He lay there as Dwalin drifted off, breathing deep every now and then, but not even Thorin knew if he was still hoping for a fresh scent of that familiar smell or not. Sleep, when it did take him, found him on a bench outside a round, green door, sitting in the sun in a place that no longer existed.

        What neither of them would realize, until days later, was that a full pouch of Old Toby would be found inside Dwalin's coat where it was hung up on the armor stand in the front room. Neither of them would know where it came from. It was at the very bottom of one of the deepest pockets. Perhaps Dwalin had forgotten about it. Perhaps it was some strange stroke of luck that had made Dwalin forgetful of its existence. Either way they put it on the altar along with Bilbo's other possessions they still had and did not touch it.

        (They did not look inside, for if they had, they would have realized that that particular pouch of Old Toby was fresher than any they had ever had. As if it had just been harvested that fall, while they were on their long journey to Erebor. But that was a mystery they would unravel much, much later.)

 

 

~*~

 

 

        Morning found Thorin marginally more rested, though sad in a way he could not name. He had a vague recollection of being somewhere that made him happy, happy in a way that also made grief tighten his throat, but he could not hang on to just where that place was. Still, he must have looked a good deal better if the way Balin nodded and hustled them off to breakfast was any measure.

        Thorin had just finished eating when a runner came to tell him that riders had appeared on the horizon. Thorin nodded at Dwalin and stood, trailing much of his council behind him as he made his way to the gates and out into the chilly morning air. The elves and men were stirring from their tents, many looking as though they, too, had just finished their morning meal, as they gathered on the far side of the strange encampment that had taken shape on Thorin's front lawn.

        Thorin caught sight of Dáin in the crowd but his cousin did not look at him. Instead he was surrounded by his own council members who had arrived in the weeks following the battle. Thorin cursed himself as a fool to have not seen the problem building earlier. Perhaps he had been too focused on clearing the area before the gates, trying to find what was left of Bilbo, to see what was in front of his nose. Perhaps Dáin had been hiding it better. Thorin did not know but now that he had seen it he could not ignore the way the Iron Hills dwarves were clustered together under the shadow of the mountain, all scowling and surly to any who came close.

        Thorin did not know what to expect when it came to the arrival of the missing wizards. Radagast they had met before, though Thorin was still not quite sure that the wild being they had met really was a wizard. He seemed too strange and odd to be considered the same as Gandalf or even Saruman, who Thorin had only heard of in passing from his father and grandfather. That there were even more of these beings had been a bit of a shock to hear. That they even had an Order was news to Thorin and his council. So when they came out of the gates to see four riders approaching it was a shock not only to Thorin but to many in the crowd as well it seemed.

        Thorin saw how Gandalf's head went back and the way his hands tightened on his staff. Galadriel and Elrond shared a look Thorin could not read. The four beings were quick to cross the distance, coming close enough that Thorin could see them clearly. The lead rider was a stern-faced older man, with dark hair that was graying at the temples. There was something...strange about his face that Thorin could not place. Almost as if only his eyes were set into shadow while the rest of him seemed to shine a bit too bright. On either side of him were two men in blue, one was smiling and nodding to the people they passed, his robes a robin's egg blue, while the other was dressed in dark navy robes that made his own dour expression that more severe. They were both blond, though the one on the left wore his short, falling just about his shoulders. The other wizard in blue had his hair pulled back in a low tail that made his narrow face look hawkish. Behind those three came Radagast, his own horse lagging well behind them, and the strange fellow looked as wild as Thorin remembered him. His hat was tilted to one side and there were leaves and sticks poking out of the nest of his hair.

        The wizards came to a halt before Eönwë, with the one in the front swinging off his horse first. Thorin saw the way Gandalf stood up straighter, his shoulders going back and the hold on his staff going tight. The others followed suit, with Radagast the only one to stay seated on his mount, looking as if he was half a second from running off into the wilds.

        “Curumo,” Eönwë said as he stepped forward, hands outstretched. But instead of taking them this Curumo bowed instead, deep enough that the tips of his hair swept the ground. It brought Eönwë up short.

        “Pray forgive our tardiness, Lord Eönwë,” this Curumo said as he straightened. “For just as your summons reached me, I received another message from our long-lost brethren. Alatar and Pallando have long been lost to the furthest reaches of the East and have only now returned to our western lands. I do not think this is something that has come about by chance.” The wizard tucked his hands into his long sleeves as the two wizards in blue bowed low to Eönwë on either side of him. “And of course you know Aiwendil.”

        Radagast blew a raspberry at them all, which caused a wave of whispers to rise from the gathering crowd.

        “Saruman,” Gandalf said before Eönwë could speak. “Do not be rude.”

        “I am not the rude one here,” Curumo – or Saruman said with a sniff. “You know better than to speak out of turn before such powers, Olórin. Lord Eönwë is the one who has summoned us here and it is to him that we answer and none other.”

        “Saruman!”

        “Peace,” Eönwë held up a hand, calming them all. “Glad I am to see you again Curumo...or do you prefer Saruman now?”

        Saruman bowed to Eönwë again, his dark hair hiding his face for a long moment. “I am comfortable with either name. Call me what you wish.”

        “I see,” Eönwë said, a faint frown marking a line between his brows. Then he turned to Thorin and made his own bow. “King Thorin, the wizards have come. I believe it is time for a longer conversation of the things that have happened in this place to be had between all the leaders that have gathered here.”

        “Yes,” Thorin said and gestured to the tent to his right. “I believe this will fit us all, though we may have to find a few more seats.” He glanced at the other wizards. “We did not expect so many, gentlemen, my apologies.”

        The two wizards in blue nodded to him, which made Balin bristle a bit at Thorin's side. He nudged his old friend but did not look at him. “I'm sure there are some of us who are willing to stand for this meeting,” the wizard with the hawkish features said, exchanging a glance with the other wizard in blue. “Aiwendil has not stopped complaining since we found him on the road.”

        “I am not made to ride such an animal,” Radagast said as he slid from his horse's back at last. He patted down his robes, causing tiny puffs of dust and dirt to escape his clothes. “Gandalf, why did you send me to Saruman's old tower if you wanted me here in the first place? I was visiting with Beorn and his people, I could have come straight away and not backtracked so far.”

        That caused a stir. Thorin saw Gandalf share a look with Galadriel, both of them frowning. “It was not I who sent you there, Radagast,” Gandalf said. “It was Eönwë who called us all here.”

        “Indeed,” Saruman said, his hands still hidden in his sleeves. “As I have told him multiple times. I fear he has been indulging in those mushrooms he likes too much. Again.”

        “But that is not so,” Radagast said as he looked between them. “I got a moth from you, Gandalf. You said to go to Isengard, to Saruman.”

        All eyes turned to Gandalf. “I did not send such a messenger,” he said. His bushy brows had come together in a deep frown. “I will swear upon it, if needed.”

        Eönwë held up his hand before anyone else could speak. “Strange it is that my own summons have found but one of your Order and not all of you. I worry that it is a consequence of the changes that have been made to this world. But let us speak now, for there is much to tell you all of what changes are happening in the far West.”

        Thorin glanced at Balin before he made his way inside the tent, making sure he was the one to lead the way. Dáin, he had noted, had come out of the crowd to join this meeting, though he was forced to keep his guards outside. Thorin settled into his chair and to his surprise it was Lord Elrond who sat at his right, while the Lady Galadriel sat on his left. Thranduil, thankfully, was on the other side of the Lady, with Bard to his left. The rest of the men settled about the table, with Dáin between Bard and Prince Thengel of Rohan. Lord Glorfindel and Lord Ecthelion sat on Lord Elrond's other side. Eönwë sat on the opposite side of the round table from Thorin, with Saruman and Alatar taking the seats on either side of him. Gandalf managed to slide into the chair next to Alatar while Pallando took the last seat, leaving Radagast standing behind them. Thorin glanced back at Balin, who gave him a shallow nod. It was the work of moments to get a stool brought in for Radagast to perch on, which the wizard seemed to appreciate more than an actual chair.

        As they settled at the table wine was brought in. It was from one of the deep caves under the mountain, where Smaug seemed to have never gone. Thorin did not know how the bottles were still intact or how the wine was still sweet, but Bombur had been careful with all of the provisions found inside Erebor, testing them all to make sure it would not make any sick from consuming it. It was a sweet blend, one Thorin did not remember their people bottling, though they must have since the racks were full when Bombur had shown Thorin the chamber. Thorin noted the way many of the elves seemed to savor the wine as they sipped at it. Even Eönwë seemed surprised by it. Thorin made a mental note to try and find the old vineyards on the mountainside. Perhaps they would be able to use such a wine as an export as Erebor got her feet under herself once more.

        There were a number of other stools brought in for those who did not have a seat at the table. Lord Elrond's councilor, Erestor, was perched on his own seat, with a lap desk set up so he could take notes. Thorin saw how Balin set up his own seat next to the elf, the two of them bent together and talking quietly as Bombur had his runners bring in platters of finger foods. Thorin also noted the way both Lord Glorfindel and Lord Ecthelion sat together, their chairs pressed as close as they could get to one another...and the way both elves were glancing at Erestor as they whispered to each other.

        Interesting.

        Thorin waited until everyone was settled and looked to Eönwë, a bit startled to find the herald of Manwë already looking his way. He had thought that Eönwë would have wished to speak first, but...Thorin glanced at Gandalf, who was also looking to him with dark eyes. Yes, there were things that still needed to be said about what happened inside Erebor that Thorin had not spoken of. Thorin set his hands on the table and glanced around at the faces, seeing everyone turn their attention his way. “I have told you all of what happened here, briefly, the day before. What I did not say then was that it is believed that during our Quest to retake Erebor it is believed that Bilbo Baggins somehow gained possession of the One Ring created by Sauron in the Second Age.”

        There was a stir from about the table.

        “I did not speak of it before, since we are not completely sure of this fact. But what we do know is this; that at some point Bilbo found an object that allowed him to turn invisible, a ring that he became reluctant to show any of us as the weeks wore on. We know that Bilbo wore the ring to investigate the mountain. We know that he wore it while Smaug hunted him through the treasury and turned it all into a river of molten gold. We know that at some point during that event that Bilbo lost his ring.” Thorin had to stop for a moment, his throat gone tight. “It was explained to us later, by Gandalf, that sometime during these events that Mordor was destroyed by the eruption of Mount Doom and that the whole of that black land was wiped out, and Sauron along with it.”

        “Strange it is that such a creature as a halfling would find such a valuable item by chance,” Saruman was the one to say. His hands were still hidden in his sleeves as he sat back in his chair. His dark eyes were fixed on Thorin. He fought down a shiver at that intent stare. He did not know why the hairs on the back of his neck were prickling. “There were many rings made during the Second Age. Assigning such a find to be the One Ring is irresponsible, Gandalf. You should have come to me with your concerns over it.”

        “Perhaps,” Gandalf said, leaning forward in his chair. “But the facts fit the timeline. No other object would have that kind of power to destroy both Mordor and Sauron. And I did not know what kind of ring Bilbo had at the time, for he became secretive of it, very quickly. It...concerned me, but we had other problems at the time.” Gandalf's bushy brows twitched as he pulled out his pipe but did not light it. “Or did you forget the issue with the shadows we fought at Dol Guldur?”

        “I did not forget,” Saruman's nose went up at that. “We fought those shadows and defeated them, as you remember Gandalf. To say that this halfling then found a way to completely destroy the powers that we of the White Council had problems merely banishing back to shadow is laughable. You know as well as I do that there is only one place where such a ring of power could have been destroyed and that was inside of Orodruin. I cannot see how this halfling could have had the One Ring.”

        A stir swept over the table at that. Thorin had not known that it would take such a fire to destroy Sauron's ring of power. There had been whispers about the dwarven rings for centuries, how they could pass through the hottest of forges and come out clean, without a dent or scratch on them.

        “I know what has been said about the One Ring,” Gandalf began after the stir quieted. His hands were laid out on the table, spread wide, pipe forgotten. “And I know that there are things that not even we, servants of that secret fire though we are, know about hobbits and their abilities. I, perhaps, have known them longest and even I have not been privy to the most secret parts of their society.”

        “Society,” Saruman scoffed, his lips twisting to one side. “Do not give it more airs than what it is. They are a simple folk, who lived simple lives, turning the soil and feeding the nations about them with their produce. What is so secret about that?”

        “Do you not find it strange that in all the years that the hobbits have worked the land of the Shire, they alone have had the largest harvests in all of Arda? That from them came more than half the herbs that fill the boxes of the healers across the lands? That – aside from the elves – in all the peoples in Arda the hobbits are – were,” Gandalf's expression twisted with grief for a moment, “better at fixing the ills that plagued both body and land?”

        “Surely you exaggerate, Gandalf. Your fondness for these little creatures is well known.”

        “Bilbo was no creature,” Thorin bit out, cutting off Saruman's words. All eyes turned to him. “He is – was – a hobbit. Not a halfling, not a creature, not an animal. A hobbit.” Thorin curled a hand into a fist in his lap. “I would not have him disrespected, not here, where he has saved us all.”

        “If he has done such a thing,” Saruman said. His dark eyes were glittering like fractured obsidian. “You say this Bilbo killed a dragon. How on earth could such a little creature do such a thing as that?” Saruman leaned forward in his chair. “No, something is amiss in this, I fear. Something that we are not seeing. There is some greater plot afoot that is moving right under our noses. Are you a party to this, Thorin Oakenshield? Are the dwarves of Erebor hiding something from us even now?”

        “What? No, of course not!” Thorin surged up out of his chair. “We have been truthful to you all, to our own fault, laying bare our sins that we committed while mad when we could have kept such dishonor secret to save our pride. Bilbo is the one who killed the dragon Smaug. Bilbo is the one who somehow destroyed the One Ring of Sauron. Bilbo is the hero that all should know his name!”

        “All we have is your word, Thorin Oakenshield! Even I have heard of the madness that took your Company all the way in Isengard. How can we trust your word?”

        “Peace, Saruman,” Eönwë said before Thorin could try and launch himself across the table and punch that wizard right in the nose. “That was unkind and unhelpful. I – we – came to this far land to find out what has changed the Song of Eru in Arda and bickering between ourselves does not solve this pressing problem. If Gandalf says that these hobbits have gifts that even members of your Order do not know of, then I believe him. It still remains that we must try to figure out what these powers are – or were,” he amended, “and if they were in any way under the command of Morgoth or his servant Sauron. The world is changing,” Eönwë looked about the table, meeting each gaze, “in ways that not even the Valar can now predict. It is vital that we understand what is happening so that should this be a plot of the Great Enemy's then we are able to move in time to counter it.”

        “Then what would you have us do?” Ecthelion II of Gondor asked. He and Prince Thengel had been leaning together for much of the meeting, speaking in soft voices with one another.

        Thorin met Eönwë's gaze when that spirit looked to him. “I would ask of you, King Thorin, that you allow myself and the Istari entrance to your mountain, so that we might see where these events took place, and,” Eönwë tilted his head to one side. “That we might better ascertain if what was destroyed in your mountain really was the One Ring.”

        Thorin swallowed down a biting reply, breathing through his anger at Bilbo's accomplishments being so openly questioned. He understood their confusion. He had felt the same when he had first heard Gandalf's claim. But to allow so many strangers into the mountain was a tricky thing, especially with Dáin's challenge so fresh in the memories of his people. Their mountain was theirs, the sacred space given to them by their Maker, to live in, work in, the create in, like Mahal before them. But if they did not allow them entry then it would seem as though they had something to hide when they did not. “I...”

        A cry and the sounds of a commotion came from the entrance of the tent. Thorin turned with the others to see Nori burst inside with two of his dwarves holding another between them. “My king,” Nori said, going to one knee in front of him. “Forgive my intrusion but this could not wait. We found this one, a dwarf of the Iron Hills, trying to steal the Arkenstone from your throne.”

        “What?” Thorin couldn't help but sputter.

        “You dare!” Dáin was on his feet, red faced and furious. “My people would not do such a thing!”

        “He was trying to pry the Arkenstone from its mounting,” Nori said, his gaze never leaving Thorin's. “The throne has been marred by this dwarf's hands.”

        “That is preposterous!” Dáin cried.

        “Show me,” Thorin said, uncaring of the eyes on him. He cut a look at his cousin, who was already shaking his head. “I would see the damage that has been done to my mountain by hands that are not ours.”

        “This is a clear lie, Thorin, my people would never –”

        “Just as none of your people would dare push me from a ledge?” Thorin turned on him. “Truly?”

        Dáin shut his mouth and looked away.

        Thorin looked back to Nori. “Keep that dwarf with us at all times,” he said. Then, “Show me.”

        Nori bowed over his bent knee and stood, snapping his fingers at the two dwarves holding the one struggling between them. “Tie him up,” Nori said as he stalked from the tent, Thorin hot on his heels. Thorin could hear the rest of the table rise as one, with most of them following in his wake. This Thorin did not dispute, since Nori had made the matter so public. Thorin could well guess why Nori had dragged out their dirty laundry to air it in front of their allies and trade partners. They were all worried about Dáin's next move. Perhaps this would place a crack in whatever plan Dáin had in the works. Thorin hoped it would derail his cousin altogether but he had little hope of that happening.

        And so, as one, the party of elves, men, and dwarves stepped into the shadow of the mountain, heading for Erebor's throne room and what might lie within.

Chapter 19: rust and riddles

Chapter Text

 

        The mountain seemed darker as Thorin stalked through its airy chambers. “Thorin! Thorin, wait!” Dáin's cries echoed from behind him but Thorin did not slow a single step. Dwalin was at his side, had been from the moment Thorin stepped out of the tent, with Glóin on his other side. The men and elves trailing behind him were stretched out in a line, since the path through Erebor was a tricky thing. Smaug had done so much damage to the front part of the mountain that the areas immediately in front of the gates had to be reinforced right after the battle had ended. The ugly wood and rusted metal frames on the columns were a necessary evil for the time being, though from the way Bofur was talking these last few days, the damage may have been overestimated. They still kept those braces in place for the time being and Thorin was well aware how they gave the mountain an ominous look to those unfamiliar with such spaces.

        Once, when Thorin was young, the great gates stood open to let in the light and illuminate the grand chamber that had been hollowed out of the mountain. The airy staircases and ramps that soared over the depths had been carved with runes and sigils of their people, sometimes inlaid with metals and gems so that they would catch the light of the sun. The great chamber used to be the fastest way to the throne room, where a special ramp had been installed, large enough for every race to be able to use it. That ramp had been cracked in several places, leaving Bofur leery of having even his own people look at it any closer, at least until the proper artisans could come and see what repairs could be made. That meant that Thorin had to take the crowd of beings behind him through a side passage, where at least Maedhros would have to duck his head more often than not to avoid hitting his head on some of the lower doorways.

        The path Thorin took was the quickest to the throne room, up a right-hand set of stairs that were once used by the royal servants. As they twisted their way up the steps, the crystals set into the side of the stone walls began to glow. Thorin paused at one of the landings, staring at them. In all their time in the mountain these particular crystals had not once sparked to life. They did now, though, glowing brighter and brighter as Thorin passed each small lamp.

        “Thorin,” Nori's voice was a bare whisper.

        “Yes,” Thorin said, just as soft. They could investigate why the crystals were glowing later. Thorin shook his head and started up the stairs once more, winding around and around until they came out on the floor above the royal wing, where many of the more formal council rooms had been carved out of the mountain, and where the throne room held pride of place. The hallway that led to the throne room was clean, the polished floors glittering under the sparking lights of the crystals that were lighting along the walls. The throne room itself sat in a great chamber that had been smoothed out by countless hands over the long years of their residence. The long, narrow bridge that led to the throne was a natural feature, where the small island that held the throne had been formed by some stroke of luck or divine hand. The windows had been cut into the sides of the mountain, positioned so they were invisible to any outside eye, and numerous enough to fill the entire chamber with light when the sun was out.

        Thorin nodded to Nori's guards as he stepped through the great doors that were open to the throne room beyond. The morning light streamed in through the eastern portion of the windows, leaving the western half in pools of shadow. There should have been no reason for any dwarf to be in this part of the mountain, much less this level of Erebor this early in the morning. Thorin did not hold his councils in these chambers, preferring the smaller rooms in the lower levels, so that his older councilors did not have to puff their way up so many stairs in their advanced age. Ever since Thorin's return to this very same chamber their holy people had been gathering in the chamber below the island that held the throne, where once musicians played and their holy people held rites during the longest day of the year. Now that area was dark, with many shadowed doorways that led in and out of the lower levels, all of which should have had a guard on them to stop any curious – and not so curious – beings from going where they were not meant to be.

        Even from the doorway Thorin could spot the damage to the throne. He felt a growl rumble through his chest as he stalked forward, his boots coming down hard on the solid stone of the walkway. The gold on the arms of the throne had been cut, the sigils of his forefathers slashed through, disgraced. The gold filigree around the Arkenstone itself had been pried up, as if this would-be thief had taken a knife to it in his haste, trying his best to pry the gem from the mount with sheer brute force alone. There was a smear of what looked like blood along one side of the Arkenstone's mounting, where perhaps the thief had slashed his hand open on the jagged metal there. The blood had darkened to the color of rust and something about it made Thorin's chest go cold.

        He stopped in front of the throne and took in the damage, seeing where this thief had scraped away the names of Thorin's grandfather and great grandfather, where even the carved stone itself looked damaged from a careless hand.

        “Bofur,” Thorin called.

        “Here I am,” Bofur said, pushing through the crowd to come to Thorin's side. A low whistle left his lips. “Well, that's a mess, now ain't it?”

        Thorin turned his head to look at Nori. “How did you find him?”

        “The guards did,” Nori shook his head. “They heard a ruckus coming from inside and when they opened the doors he was striking the Arkenstone with a knife, trying to free it from its mounting.”

        “It's mine,” the dwarf hanging from between Nori's minions snarled, his legs kicking out as he thrashed in their hold. “It be mine! Let me go!”

        “Bofur, check the throne please,” Thorin said. Bofur bobbed his head and scrambled up on the steps, going to his knees before the ruins of the inlaid gold on the arm rests. “Hragr,” he turned to look through the crowd. His head of the jeweler's guild slipped through the press, coming to his side. “Please check the Arkenstone to make sure that it has not been damaged.”

        “Yes, my lord,” Hragr gave him the briefest of bows before scrambling on top of the throne with Bofur.

        “This is how you would honor our forefathers, Thorin?”

        Thorin closed his eyes at the sound of Dáin's voice. Then he turned to look out over the crowd of beings that had followed him to the throne room. Dáin pushed his way to the front, his brows drawn tight together in a ferocious scowl. His guards had forced their way in with him, flanking him on either side. Thorin saw Dwalin move to stand between them and reached out to stop him, one hand light on his arm. “Dáin,” Thorin said when he looked back to his cousin. “What I do in my own mountain is no business of yours.”

        “Not my business? Do you forget, cousin,” Dáin spat the word, “that it was I who came to your aid to defend this mountain? That had it not been for myself and my army your mountain would have been overrun, if not by orcs and goblins, then by men and elves? Did you forget that part?”

        An angry rush of whispers broke out through the gathered crowd. Thorin squared his shoulders to face Dáin, planting his feet in front of his throne, not about to back down now. “I will always be grateful for your aid,” he said, lifting his chin. “You and I have spoken more than once about what I will give to you for that aid as well, or did you forget that in your strange madness, cousin?”

        “Mad? You think I am mad?” Dáin cried out. “You, who holds the blood of the traitor on the holy silks of our people, you say I am the one sick? You, who would not lock the gem of your people away where it belongs? You, who mourns a thief who got what he deserves? You think I am sick? No! It is you who are sick!” Dáin pointed at Thorin's nose, his hand trembling. “Look to yourself for the one who is mad, Thorin Oakenshield! You do not deserve to be King Under the Mountain!”

        Hisses rose up from the crowd. The men and elves drew back as Erebor's holy people pushed forward, surrounding Dáin and his guards before they could draw arms. “Bilbo's life blood was given to us after his death, a blessing that even our holy people have proclaimed.” Thorin stepped towards Dáin, forcing his hand to drop. “Bilbo is a hero. He killed the dragon. He saved us all. I will not have you disparage him thus. Alviss,” he looked to the head of their holy people, who gave him a grave nod. “I believe my cousin Dáin is unwell. See to him. Please.”

        “My lord,” Alviss bowed low to him before turning to Dáin. “Come, King of the Iron Hills. You have heard the word of the King Under the Mountain, the heir of Durin. You are unwell.”

        “I am not! It is he who is unwell! He fell! He is some foul spirit brought back from the dark! Some trick of the traitor! Unhand me!” Dáin's shouts, as well as the shouts of his guards, faded as their holy people pulled them through the crowd and out the door. Nori and what seemed to be a few of his minions had the guards on the ground and disarmed before Dáin's dwarves could pull their axes from their belts. Nori's boys hauled those dwarves up and marched them out of the room as Nori returned to his side. Thorin watched them go with a long sigh, knowing that it would be chaos in the Iron Hills tents soon if something was not done. They could not keep Dáin against his will, not with his people in their camps, but if Thorin had their holy people contain his cousin for now, under the guise of Dáin being unwell it might buy them at least a little time to get in front of any problems from that quarter.

        Added to that was the entire crowd of spectators who had just watched this farce of a scene. Thorin turned to Eönwë and the other lords who had come to the throne room and bowed low. “My apologies,” he said to the floor. “Things have been...fraught between myself and my cousin. He is...”

        “Unwell,” Eönwë's voice said, far closer than Thorin expected. When he rose it was to see the herald of Manwë before him, his entire being glowing just a bit in the shadows of the room. “How is he unwell, King Thorin? Can you explain it?”

        Thorin paused, glancing at Dwalin, who shrugged back at him. Thorin looked back at Eönwë. “It is true that I and my Company experienced gold-madness in this place, yes, but Dáin is not acting as we did, then. He is...paranoid. Suspicious in a way that...makes no sense. He keeps calling Bilbo a thief,” he shook his head. “I do not understand it.”

        There was a clatter from behind Thorin before Eönwë could respond. Thorin turned to see both Bofur and Hragr stepping down off the steps that led to the throne. Bofur had a rag in his hand and a pensive look on his face. “Bofur? Hragr?” Thorin looked between them. “How is it?”

        “Well the throne has been defaced but good,” Bofur said with a shake of his head. “We'll need a clan of artisans to repair it. It almost looks like he took a mace to the back of the chair, trying to break it in half. I can not tell if there are any fractures in the stone just yet. I'll need the rest of my gear to do that.”

        Thorin pinched the bridge of his nose and then let his hand drop. “Very well. Hragr?”

        “The Arkenstone is not damaged, my lord,” Hragr said when he came to Thorin's side. “Not a scratch on it.”

        “No, there wouldn't be,” a voice said from the crowd. Thorin turned to see Maedhros step forward, his eyes not on Thorin but on the throne...on the Arkenstone.

        “Lord Maedhros?” Thorin looked from the elf, to the stone, and back again.

        Maedhros' lips moved for a moment, but no sound came out. Then he cleared his throat, giving himself a short shake of the head and then his gaze was on Thorin. “A Silmaril does not chip. Not even Morgoth's evil powers could scratch the surface of them, when that enemy of ours put the gems into his vile iron crown.”

        Gasps and murmurs arose from the gathered crowd. Thorin looked to Dwalin, who looked as shocked as Thorin felt. “A Silmaril?” Thorin looked back to Maedhros. The elf had not moved, though his gaze was back onto the Arkenstone. “But that cannot be. The Arkenstone was found beneath the roots of Erebor, when King Thráin I founded our kingdom here. How could this be a Silmaril?”

        Maedhros' hands curled and relaxed at his sides, his eyes strangely shiny in the morning light. “After the War of Wrath, after we...I stole the remaining Silmarils, I could not hold the gem in my bare hand. It would burn and torment me, as I have said.” Maedhros shook his head. “Afterwards...after, I wandered long and far during those wild years, blind with madness and perhaps more. The pain became so much that I cast myself into a fiery chasm, though where I cannot tell you.” His gaze lifted from the Arkenstone to gaze about the chamber, then up towards the vaulted ceiling high above. “Perhaps it was here that I met my demise. I do not know. But of this I am sure,” his gaze went back to Thorin and he felt in that moment struck breathless by the intensity of Maedhros' gaze. “The gem you call the Arkenstone, the gem that your people have held holy for all these long years, is one of the three Silmaril that were made by my father's hands.” He swallowed, his throat bobbing, gaze flicking past Thorin and then back again. “I would know it anywhere.”

        More murmurs arose from the crowd. Thorin drew in a long breath, studying the elf's face. “And do you feel...compelled to take it, now?”

        There was a long stretch of silence. Thorin saw how Elrond moved through the crowd to Maedhros' side, staring up at the elf with a mix of emotions too tangled for Thorin to read. Then Maedhros drew in a stuttering breath, blinking away the shine of tears in his eyes. “No,” he finally said, shaking his head. “I do not.” There was a strange note of wonder and...perhaps relief in his voice. “But,” he continued and Thorin felt a chill touch the back of his neck. Maedhros stepped forward, a frown drawing his brows together as he peered at the Arkenstone. “There is something...wrong with the Silmaril.”

        “Wrong?” More than one voice echoed the question, Thorin among them. He turned to look at the throne, at the Arkenstone, trying to see what the elf saw. The Arkenstone looked as it ever did, shining in the room that was slowly filling with morning light. But, just as he had seen on the day of his return, there seemed to be a strange film over the shining gem, almost like a... “A shadow,” he said, turning back to Maedhros. The elf blinked and looked at him, dipping his head in a short nod. “There is a shadow that lies upon the stone.”

        “Yes,” Maedhros said. “You see it as well?”

        “I do,” said Thorin. “I saw it for the first time when I returned from the depths of the mountain.” He felt Dwalin take his hand. He looked to Gandalf and Eönwë, who were next to him. “Do you not see it?”

        The herald of Manwë stepped forward, his eyes narrowed as he looked at the Arkenstone. “I do not,” he murmured. “Olórin?”

        Gandalf was slower to move, his eyes dark as he looked at the Arkenstone and then at Eönwë and back again. “I have never seen the Arkenstone before,” he said after a moment of study. “The kings of Erebor never displayed it upon their throne as it is now before any visitors to their realm, or so I was told.”

        Thorin glanced back at the gem, his chest going tight at the memories it evoked. “I had it placed there after Bofur chipped it from the melted gold in the treasury,” he told them. “I would have sat curled about it like a dragon had Bilbo not shocked us out of such madness. The only time I have come back to this room is when I...returned from the dark.”

        “Returned from the dark you say,” Saruman was the one to speak. The wizard stepped forward until he was almost abreast with Thorin, though his gaze never left the gem set into the throne. The two blue wizards were close on his heels, though Thorin did not see Radagast anywhere. “What does that mean, exactly?”

        Thorin felt the way Dwalin's hold on his hand went tight for a moment. Thorin squeezed back, also put off by the lack of courtesy in the wizard's tone but what could he do about it? Now was not the time nor the place to fuss about such niceties. “On the night of the new moon, the day before the emissaries from Valinor were set to arrive, our people held a holy rite in the depths of the mountain.” Thorin looked at Dwalin, whose jaw was set and a muscle was flexing in his cheek. “During that rite a dwarf from the Iron Hills pushed me from the ledge and into the heart of the mountain.” Whispers arose from the crowd. “I...fell, but I was caught.” He couldn't help his smile. “Bilbo came for me,” he said, looking at Gandalf. The wizard twisted to look at him, his bushy brows raised high. “He caught my hand and took me some place...else. I cannot explain it more than that. When I woke I was here,” he swept out his free hand to the space before the throne. “I was found the very same morning that you arrived.” This he said to Eönwë, who had also turned to look at him.

        “I see,” Eönwë said with a thoughtful frown. “And you did not see such a shadow on the gem before now?”

        “No,” Thorin shook his head.

        “How strange. And do you, master dwarf,” Eönwë then looked at Dwalin, who stood up straighter at Thorin's side. “Do you see a shadow upon this gem?”

        Dwalin looked over his shoulder at the throne and then back at Eönwë. “I do not,” he said. “It looks as it ever has, but...”

        “But?”

        Dwalin's mouth twisted to one side for a moment. “It does not seem as...bright as it was in my memories.”

        That was news to Thorin. He canted a look at Dwalin, who just shrugged back at him.

        “Would it be possible,” a voice said from the crowd, which parted to reveal Master Erestor. He glanced around at the sudden attention, but continued. “Would it be possible that the attempted destruction of the Arkenstone...of the Silmaril is what caused the darkness you see upon it now?”

        Maedhros frowned, turning to look at the smaller elf. Thorin did not miss the way the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion slid to stand behind Master Erestor, with each of them crossing their arms over their chests as they stared back at Maedhros. A humorless smile pulled Maedhros' mouth to one side. “Which attempted destruction do you mean, good sir? The one in which I cast it and myself into a fiery chasm or...” His frown deepened and then Thorin found himself on the end of that same look. “You said you had to...chip the Silmaril out of solid gold?”

        “Yes,” Thorin said after a moment. “When Smaug attacked Bilbo in the treasury.” His throat closed for a moment, the memory of his terror rendering him mute. He shook his head, trying to get the smell of dragonfire out of his nose. He cleared his throat and continued. “When we came in, afterwards, to see if we could...help in any way, we found the dragon dead and the floor still boiling hot, and all of it gold.”

        Maedhros tipped his head down, his frown still in place. Thorin saw the way Master Erestor was chewing on his lower lip, one arm wrapped tight about his waist. Lord Elrond moved to his side, the two of them sharing a look Thorin could not read.

        “You think the attempted destruction of the Silmaril is what is causing the protections about Valinor to fail as well, Erestor?” Lord Elrond's question caused a stir in the crowd.

        Master Erestor looked at Elrond and then back at Maedhros. “I do not know if that is the case or not,” he said as Eönwë stepped up to Maedhros' side. “But you have said that you fear that this strange shift in the Song is some ploy of Morgoth's. And if Morgoth cursed the Silmarils...”

        “Then perhaps they are connected,” Eönwë nodded slowly. “Yes, I could see how that may be a reason. But,” he turned to look at the Arkenstone and then back at Thorin. “We do not know this for certain and I will not take such a symbol of your people from you, King Thorin, no matter its origins.”

        Thorin bowed to the Maia. “I thank you, Lord Eönwë,” he said as he rose. He knew what he would say next might cause a rather large stir. “But I would hand it over to you this moment if you felt it proper. I will not be the reason why Arda is torn apart by Morgoth's evil plans, even if it means to hand over the gem that has signified the kingship of our people here in Erebor.”

        Thorin was right. It did cause a stir. A very large stir. Even the wizards exchanged words together, with Saruman stepping forward after a hushed conversation with one of the blue wizards. “Perhaps taking the Silmaril would be the most wise move,” he began.

      “No,” Eönwë held up a hand, silencing the entire crowd. His gaze had not moved from Thorin for a moment. “I do not believe it is necessary to take this item from King Thorin.” Eönwë glanced at Saruman who bowed his head at the Maia, his hands folding into his sleeves. “I do appreciate the gesture,” Eönwë's tone warmed when he looked back at Thorin. “But let us not get ahead of ourselves. We do not know for sure if the Silmarils have any part to play in this, though my heart tells me that they do. As such the Silmaril, your Arkenstone, King Thorin, should remain in your possession until such a time as it may be needed.”

        “In such an open spot? In a place where it has already been attempted to be stolen?” Saruman's nose went up in the air. “Perhaps it should be moved to a...safer place.”

        “The treasury is gone,” Thorin couldn't help his dry tone. “Lost in the destruction of Smaug's fury and his own death.”

        “About that,” Gandalf spoke at last, stepping forward to stand shoulder to shoulder with Eönwë and Maedhros. “Would you allow us to see this place, where the dragon died and the...Arkenstone was found?”

        Thorin frowned and looked at the crowd. “Bofur?” His friend stepped out from behind Lord Glorfindel. “Is the area safe to bring them into?”

        Bofur pulled at one of his braids, his mustache twitching back and forth before he gave a slow nod. “Should be. As long as you don't go up onto any of the balconies and maybe stay away from the eastern halls. The columns looked a bit dodgy there.”

        “But they will hold?”

        “Oh, they'll hold unless another dragon comes along or we have an earth shaker pop off.” Bofur's hand curled into a warding sign, as did several other dwarves' in the crowd. “Other than that, yeah, I'd say it would be safe enough.”

        Thorin looked back to Gandalf. “Then I will show you,” he said. Thorin led the crowd back the way they came, leaving a pair of guards to stand watch over the throne itself when they left. Nori, he knew, would have more than a few of his minions hiding in the shadows of the throne room from here on out. None of them would be comfortable leaving the Arkenstone alone now that they knew of its true origins.

        The treasury was a level below the main floor of the mountain. Bofur had shown them all how Smaug had used the central cavern to snake his way down to that area, forcing the halls and doors open with his great armored bulk. Thorin again led the crowd down a circuitous route to the treasury, bypassing the cracked stairs in the central area. It was a bit amusing to see even the elves leery of the deep chasm that opened up on one side of the stairs that Thorin led them down, though he had been told by Bard that most beings other than dwarves were a touch nervous when there were no handrails to be seen on such structures.

        The doors to the treasury had long been broken off. As Thorin stepped down from the final stair and onto the hall that would lead to the treasury the floor began to be uneven, as the entire hall had been covered in that river of molten gold. Small lumps still existed in that now cooled metal lake, remains of gems or weapons, perhaps. Thorin had not allowed any of his people here since the battle had ended and they had handed over Bilbo's portion of the gold to the men and elves for their payment. Thorin glanced over his shoulder to see most of the gathered men and elves staring up at the cracked stone and the dark smudges of soot that still blackened the walls and ceiling of the area.

        Thorin pointed to the eastern half of the long hall, when they came to a crossroads. “I would have you all stay out of that area.” He lifted his gaze and saw many others look up as well. Above them were the hasty structures Bofur and his crew of miners had managed to put into place to help stabilize the area. “The Arkenstone was found through here.”

        Thorin led the way into the melted ruin of the treasury, his boots steady on the slippery gold, but others were not so lucky. Saruman slipped more than once, almost falling on his rear a number of times. Thorin forced himself to look away from the flailing wizard before he let out the laughter that was stuck in his throat. His mirth dimmed the further into the treasury they went, as memories of the time during their gold-madness began to slip back in. He felt Dwalin take his hand and knew his partner felt the same.

        Thorin rounded one of the large melted mounds of gold and stopped, his nose wrinkling. The dragon's carcass lay where Bilbo had killed it, spread out over a mess of melted gold and shattered gems, pressed against the back wall of the treasury as if it had been flung backwards, hard enough that thin, spiderweb cracks had formed in the stone above Smaug's body. Gasps rose from behind him and it was only a brave few that came to Thorin's side to stare at the corpse of his people's great calamity.

        “You have left it here,” Gandalf said as he came to a stop next to Thorin.

        “Yes,” Thorin looked up at the corpse. “When we were gold-mad it did not seem...necessary to remove the gems that still adorned the dragon's body.” Thorin made a face at those hazy memories. “Now that we are of sound mind once more it has become more of a concern about logistics on how best to remove it.”

        “Indeed,” Gandalf said, placing his staff in front of him and leaning on it. “It is a very good thing that you have not touched the corpse, King Thorin Oakenshield.”

        Thorin gave the wizard a sharp look at that. “Why?”

        Instead of answering Gandalf tapped the butt of his staff against the ground once, twice, and then a series of three sharp beats. It seemed to...echo oddly in the cavernous room. “What can you tell us of how Bilbo killed this dragon? Did he say anything at all about it?”

        Thorin opened his mouth, paused, and then looked at Dwalin. He slowly shut his mouth as he thought back, trying to remember just what Bilbo had said about that harrowing moment. “Bilbo said that Smaug could sense him, somehow,” Thorin began after a long moment. Dwalin nodded at him. “At the time...I think Bilbo said he thought Smaug could smell him?” Thorin turned to look at the crowd, where the rest of his Company had gathered. “Do you remember anything else?”

        Nori was the one to step forward. “We were outside the mountain,” he began. “We heard a roar and it sounded like a great voice speaking. It was not Bilbo,” he shook his head. “It must have been the dragon.”

        “Long it has been since the dragons of Morgoth have spoken. They lost that ability Ages ago,” Saruman said as he stepped forward from the crowd, with one of the blue wizards holding his elbow.

        Nori glanced at the wizard and Thorin watched his Spymaster narrow his eyes at the tall figure. “I'm telling you what we saw and heard. A voice spoke. It was not Bilbo, that's for sure. So it had to be the dragon.”

        “Or you were already mad,” Saruman looked down his nose at Nori. “Is that not also a possibility?”

        “Maybe,” Nori did not back down from the wizard's look. “But I know what I heard.” Nori then turned to where Eönwë had moved to stand next to Gandalf. “The mountain trembled, like an earth shaker had gone off right under our feet. It caused land slides to come down around the door we had used to get into the mountain.” His mouth pulled to one side. “We had to dig out the entrance and when we did we found Bilbo on the other side, shaky and pale and crispy in places. He said that the dragon was dead, that it had melted the treasury and that he had not been able to find the Arkenstone in the chaos of killing the dragon. We did not believe him.” Nori looked down at that. Thorin had to look away. “We dragged him back into the treasury but even for us it was too hot to stand. Bilbo fainted from the heat and Óin took him out of the tunnel.”
“Bilbo told me later that he had found a bow in the treasury,” Thorin finished the tale as he looked back up. Dwalin pressed their shoulders together. “He said that he had found an arrow in the piles of gold and gems and while he was running from the fires and the melting gold he fired at the dragon and somehow hit Smaug in the only empty spot on his chest.”

        “Did he now,” Gandalf said, soft, leaning heavily on his staff.

        “Yes,” Thorin said. “That is what he told us.”

        There was a long moment of silence and then Gandalf let out a long sigh. “Do you believe he spoke the truth, King Thorin?”

        Thorin looked at Gandalf, at the set of the wizard's shoulders, at the way his mouth was drawn down into a tense line, and then looked out over the treasury. It looked nothing like it had when he was young, when the heaps of gold stood twice his height, when his grandfather would wander through the piles, running his fingers over the gleaming metal, the gold-madness shining in his eyes. Thorin closed his eyes for a moment and let out a long breath before he opened his eyes and looked to Gandalf once more. “You know as well as I do that there are no bows kept in dwarven treasuries. Not even for princes who hunt, who would like to use it as their main weapon of choice.” He saw Kíli duck his head from the corner of his eye. “I do not know where Bilbo got a bow or an arrow to strike down a dragon. What I do know is that the arrow that did kill the dragon is unlike any that I have seen before.”

        Gandalf's head came up at that. He sent Thorin a sharp look Thorin could not quite read and then was off, picking his way across the uneven surface of the solidified gold, trailing the rest of them in his wake. Halfway there he came upon the spot where Bofur had chipped out the Arkenstone, the gold peeled back like the rind of a fruit in places from his haste. There was a strange cast to the gold there, almost green, like the scum that would form on the top of still ponds.

        “What happened here,” Gandalf murmured as he stopped to stare down at the discolored metal.

        Thorin joined him, his boots well away from the greenish metal. “We do not know,” he shook his head. “Bofur?” He turned to look at the miner. To his shock Bofur was backing away from that spot, face pale and sweating. “Bofur!”

        “I don't like it,” Bofur's voice shook. Óin was on him in a flash, turning the other dwarf away so Óin could check him over. “I didn't remember until now. It felt...it felt wrong when I was chippin' it out. Like...like I was half dunked under the coldest water or – or being pulled apart by two teams of carts. I almost put the chisel through me own hand twice. It felt like something...something bad was tellin' me I had to.”

        “Take him from here,” Gandalf's voice rang through the room. It made Thorin's ears ache. Eönwë was shining at his side. The two of them stood on either side of that discolored metal, their hands held out over it.

        “What is it?” Thorin refused to back away, to retreat.

        “I believe,” Gandalf's tone was grave, his eyes dark as he focused on the spot before him. “We have found where the One Ring was destroyed.”

        “On top of the Arkenstone?” Thorin couldn't help but say.

        “Indeed,” Gandalf said.

        “If that is the case,” Saruman somehow appeared at Thorin's elbow. He had not heard the wizard move. “If the One Ring really was destroyed here and it somehow interacted with the Silmaril...then yes, yes, I see.”

        “What can you tell us, Saruman?” Gandalf did not look up from the discolored metal.

        Saruman was silent for a long, long moment. He knelt down despite the way whispers erupted from behind him. His robes almost brushed the edges of that large patch. Thorin wanted to draw him away for a reason he could not name. He did not want anyone to go any closer to it. “Sauron's Ring was a physical manifestation of much of his own power,” the wizard said at last. His hand was curled tight about his staff, the veins on the back of his hands standing out in stark relief. “Sauron himself was tied to Morgoth in many unnatural ways. It is...speculated that Sauron's own power was borrowed from his Master.”

        “That is not something I have ever heard,” Gandalf said.

        One of Saruman's shoulders tipped up and dropped. “Many things have been written in the long Ages of our world.” He bent closer to the metal, his dark eyes sharp and intent on the gaping hole where the Arkenstone had been lodged. “It looks as though the Ring was destroyed right on top of the Silmaril. If that is true, and if there is some bit of truth to the...rumors that Sauron's own powers were tied to his Master's, then such a meeting of magics would have strange and unknown repercussions to the world about us...and beyond.”

        That earned Saruman a sharp glance from Gandalf. Eönwë was still focused on the discolored metal, a deep frown etched between his brows. Then Gandalf rocked back on his heels, his hand dropping at last. “The protections about Aman,” he said.

        “Indeed,” Saruman agreed with a slow nod.

        “How would this affect such a distant place?” Thorin looked between them.

        It was Eönwë who answered him. “The protections about Aman, that have separated Valinor from the realm of Arda, was done much by the Maiar. The legends that it was done by Eru Ilúvatar Himself are wrong, for He has not touched this realm or ours by His own hand since the creation of Eä. When the Valar decreed that Aman would be separated from Arda the Maiar were the ones tasked with the shaping of the protections that kept the two realms apart. The Lady Varda and Lord Ulmo were the only two Valar that put their powers forth into the separation. So far it is only their two spells and magics that are holding. The rest are failing.”

        Saruman nodded again at this, his head dipping for a long moment. “Yes. Yes, that would make sense,” he said. “If the Ring, which was the physical form of a Maia's might, met the power of the Silmaril that was cursed by Morgoth's own hand, then yes, I could see how the protections about Aman are now failing.”

        “How so?” Thorin frowned down at him.

        “The Silmarils contain what remains of the Light of the Two Trees. They were formed in the youth of the world, in Aman, which is their home, which is where the remains of the Trees still stand.” Saruman stood in fits and starts. Pallando the blue wizard was at his side, sliding a hand under his elbow to help him up. “If they were cursed by Morgoth, then they remain connected to him in some way, drawing them from this realm to the utmost West, to where Morgoth has been banished. If Sauron's Ring was destroyed, unleashing the contained might of his power to sweep over this place, to combine with the power of the Silmaril, then it would also touch the very spells that have shaped this world...and disrupt them.” His gaze went to where Smaug lay, curled against the far wall of the treasury. “Perhaps it was not even this Bilbo's arrow that killed the dragon, then.”

        “But we've seen the arrow,” Thorin said. “It pierced the dragon's heart.”

        Saruman sniffed, his lip curling for a moment. “I do not belief such a little thing could kill a dragon of such power that it could speak.” He shook his head. “No, the release of Sauron's power, combined with the Silmaril must have been what killed the dragon in the end.”

        “But Bilbo –”

        “Is a halfling,” Saruman flicked his hand and Thorin set his jaw and his feet, trying to keep a hold of his temper. “He must have lied to you about his actions here. It would take something far larger than even an average arrow to kill a dragon.”

        “But the arrow –”

        “I said –”

        “Saruman,” Gandalf stepped between them, his bushy brows drawn down. “You are being unkind. Again.”

        The other wizard huffed out a breath through his nose and looked away, tipping his chin up. “You and I both know that killing a dragon is something that few have ever managed, Gandalf. Do you really believe your little pets could achieve such a feat?”

        “They are not my pets, Saruman,” Gandalf's voice rang with something that made a shiver work its way down Thorin's spine. “And,” he turned to look at Thorin. “I would see this arrow, King Thorin, if you would allow.”

        Thorin frowned at the phrasing of the question but nodded. “We have not touched the dragon's corpse,” he gestured at the still form laying along the wall. “It is not rotting, which surprised us. We do not know why.”

        “Dragons were the creation of Morgoth,” Gandalf said as he stepped away from the discolored metal. Eönwë stayed for a long moment before looking up and moving with him. “No one knows how they were created, nor what they were created from. The wurms that have ravaged the northern parts of Arda now are bare echoes of the scourges that used to burst forth from Angband. Smaug the Golden was perhaps of an older line that even I had guessed.” Gandalf's voice began to echo oddly the closer to the dragon he went. “There was much thought about dragons and their creations in the Ages before I came to Arda. Some claimed that Morgoth formed them out of stone. Some claimed that they were formed out of Morgoth's own magic.”

        “And what do you believe?” Thorin stayed close to Gandalf's side, with Dwalin right behind him. They had lost much of the crowd behind them as they stayed to study the strange colored metal and where the Arkenstone had been found. Only a handful of the lords that had come to Erebor went with them, along with the gathered wizards.

        Gandalf came to a stop before the corpse of Smaug. Thorin stepped to his side, staring up at that terrifying creature that had caused so much pain and suffering for his people and more. It almost looked as though the dragon was sleeping. Thorin felt his fingers curl into a warding gesture. His gaze tracked down to the dragon's chest, where a large, golden colored arrow protruded from the dragon's belly, right where a missing scale left him open for attack.

        “Once I would have agreed with my brethren about the origins of dragons but no more.” Gandalf shook his head, his fingers curling and uncurling at his sides. “Morgoth has never been able to create anything on his own, therefore he must have taken something that already existed and twisted it to his own uses.”

        “What could he have used, though?” Thorin looked up at him.

        Gandalf stood for a long moment, his gaze distant. “The first time Morgoth was contained by the Valar it was at his first fortress, Utumno, which still exists in the far northern reaches of this world, buried under thick layers of ice and debris. It was where Morgoth's powers were strongest, where he set to corrupting many of the Maiar and other spirits that had come to this world, and...” Gandalf tilted his head to one side, eyes narrowing. “Where the magics of the Valar came together in a great battle, ripping that fortress to pieces to expose Morgoth who was hiding in the very depths of his dungeons. It was not thought of at the time, but when the Valar left, Utumno was not cleared out completely, not of Morgoth's own foul projects, but also of the Valar's own magic which lingered in that place.”

        Thorin frowned up at the wizard. “The magic of the Valar is such a physical thing?”

        Gandalf gave a slow nod. “It can be, when used with such force and in such volume. I believe that Morgoth did not create his dragons from nothing, but rather returned to the ruins of Utumno to gather what was left of the Valar's own magic to form his own foul creatures instead.”

        Thorin felt his eyebrows rise and shared a look with Dwalin, who looked as surprised as Thorin felt. “Would the Valar's magic have stayed in one place so long?”

        Again Gandalf paused, his brows drawn together. “The magic of the Valar is unlike anything you can imagine, King Thorin Oakenshield. If it lingered there it could have done many things, things not even we can imagine.” Then he took in a sharp breath and shook his head, as if clearing it. “But all that is conjecture. We will never know for sure. But what I do know for sure is this – that arrow is unlike anything I have ever seen before.”

        “Indeed,” Bard said from behind Thorin. He turned to see the man approach with Thranduil, the two of them stopping not far from the dragon's corpse. “I have never seen its like.” He nodded to Maedhros when the elf held out his hand when Bard almost slipped on the gold. It was Thranduil, instead, who took Bard's arm to help him the rest of the way to their side. “I do not know how Bilbo Baggins could have shot that arrow,” he said as he came to a stop in front of the dragon's chest. “It is almost larger than he is...was.” Bard ducked his head for a moment.

        “Indeed,” Gandalf said with a frown. “I did not expect its size. Is it...made of gold?” He leaned forward, peering at it.

        “No,” Bard was the one to say as he raised his head to study the arrow once more. “It is...if I did not know better I would have said it was made of...”

        “Made of what?” Thorin took a step closer to the man.

        “Wheat,” Bard said, his head tilting back. “It looks almost as if it was made from woven wheat.”

        “Wheat?” Thorin echoed, shaking his head. “That is impossible, surely. How could –,” Thorin stopped when Maedhros moved, spinning in place with his hand falling to his sword. Thorin set his feet and looked up, trying to find what Maedhros was staring at. All he could see was the shadowy hallways that ran above the treasury, where the very floors were too fragile to walk on and no stairways existed to reach them anymore. “What is it?”

        The silence stretched as Maedhros studied that dark area. He slowly stood, his hand still lingering near his sword. “I do not know,” he said, still frowning at the balcony. “I thought...”

        “More jumping at shadows?” Saruman said as he came to a stop by Gandalf's side.

        “Saruman,” Gandalf sighed.

        “I do not think they were shadows,” Maedhros said, still staring.

        Thorin shared a look with Dwalin and then turned to find Nori but his Spymaster was gone from the crowd. “Perhaps it was one of Nori's boys.”

        “Perhaps,” Maedhros said, though his frown did not ease. “Perhaps.” At last he turned away.

        Thorin glanced back up at the balcony, trying to see what might have caught the elf's eye. From his vantage point he thought...he thought for a moment there were two small shapes, almost like hobbits, perched near the edge of the wall, but when he focused on them the shadows seemed to...shift, in a way, as if someone had opened a door beyond them and caused the darkness there to recede for just a moment. Then he blinked and he could make out the forms of broken pillars in the resettled darkness. Surely that was what he had seen, his mind making shapes of out shadows and letting Thorin see what he wanted to in that formless space. For that was all it could have been. Bilbo was gone. His people were gone. All Thorin was left with was staring at shadows and wishing they were Bilbo instead.

        Thorin turned away from the balcony, blinking away the burning in his eyes. He felt Dwalin take his hand again. Bilbo was gone, yes, but his memory would always remain. They would hold onto that for the rest of their lives. And if...perhaps...Thorin imagined Bilbo in the shadows, smiling at him? Well. No one else needed to know. That was for Thorin and Dwalin alone. No one else.

        No one else.

Chapter 20: shadows lengthen

Chapter Text

 

        Bilbo chewed on his lower lip as he slipped through the strange tunnels of the in between, stepping back into half-formed shadows of a few of the intersections to hide from a passing hobbit or two as he left their more familiar area and ventured off into parts unknown. Bilbo had never used the tunnels to travel this far before, and to his knowledge no one else had, either. The further he got from the main tunnels that now encompassed all of the Shire hobbit homes the more and more indistinct the in between got...but he never came to an end. Instead it was a little like walking into one of the deep root cellars that used to hold the fermented vegetables in the Great Smials, where not even a single fleck of light could be found. Each step he took seemed to reveal yet another part of the in between, where the rough hallways were full of strange painted symbols on the walls that Bilbo could not read but could have only come from hobbit hands.

      Bilbo paused at an intersection, the hairs on the back of his neck prickling in the quiet. When his people had come to Erebor through the in between there were few of these intersections, at least not ones that they did not forge out of their own understanding of the Shire and how their homes should be laid out. But as they had all started to explore, more and more of these branches kept appearing, much like the tunnels that Bilbo was now exploring, and none of them knew why. Bilbo had seen the gathering of widows grow day by day in front of the fires in the Great Smials, some of them...shadowed and strange and unlike any hobbit Bilbo had seen before. He had wondered if they were perhaps from Bree or another enclave of hobbits not from the Shire but had been pulled with the rest of them when the fires that had destroyed the Shire had come. Lalia would not answer his questions and Bilbo had had to duck away from a stern wooden spoon chasing him out of his cousin's home for asking one too many times about them and if the widows knew anything more about the tunnels that they were not admitting to.

        This solo trip into the unexplored tunnels would upset his cousins, Bilbo was sure. Fortinbras and Lalia were busy with their people's coming Longest Night rites and trying to figure out how to bring about the normal festivities their people engaged in during this time of the year. The late fall weather was still mild enough that the hardy greens were growing on the mountainside, even without the new magic of the Gardeners to see them through the frosts of the morning. There were already unhappy mutterings of the matrons of the family clans about not baking the traditional foods for the coming Longest Night. In the Shire the air would have been full of sweet scents, of baked goods cooling on the windowsills, of thick fruitcakes being steeped in brandy to be broken open during the longest night, when even the youngest was given the pieces of that cake, full of the bite of alcohol and the sweetness of dried fruit.

        Bilbo paused in a pool of shadows, his throat tight as he remembered his mother singing in the kitchen at Bag End, her hands and apron full of flour, some of it even dusting her hair and cheeks as she rolled out gingerbread for Bilbo to cut with her prized shaped tins. The tower and the star were always Bilbo's favorite to decorate as a faunt, his icing often a tangled mess of lines compared to his mother's intricate designs. Bilbo patted himself on the chest as the memory came and went, with even the scent of that spiced dough lingering in his nose. It had been decades since he had made gingerbread. Perhaps this year he would unearth his mother's shaped tins and recreate those memories once more. Perhaps, even, if this mess with his dwarves was solved, he could even –

        No. No, he could not put that particular stubborn horse before the cart. Not when Fortinbras wanted none of their people near the dwarves until they figured out just what was going on in the mountain. Not until they could get their hands on Gandalf and try to figure out just what their old friend knew – and if the wizard could help them as well.

      Bilbo gave his chest one last pat and shook off his wool gathering, not about to linger in these shadowy halls for longer than he needed to. He had woken that morning with the strongest urge to go see his – to go see Thorin and Dwalin. To see them, to make sure they were both alive and well. He did not know why but his dreams had been dark and full of shadows that were stretching across the ground, like a great hand spreading across the sky. Bilbo had woke gasping, slick with sweat as he panted in the darkness of Bag End, his heart thundering in his ears. Ever since then he had been antsy with the need to move, to go, to see Thorin and Dwalin once more, even if he could not properly speak to them, not now, not until they were absolutely sure their people were safe in Erebor.

        Bilbo stepped back out into the hall and looked both ways, his nose twitching as his gaze swept over the strange ash drawings on the wall opposite him. The great tower was broken in this one, fallen to pieces in strange geometric shapes, while what looked like lightning bolts rained down from above. Bilbo rubbed his fist against his mouth as he turned to his left, his feet guiding him forward, as their oldest tales told, finding his way through these maze of tunnels until he began to see signs that he recognized.

      Traveling through the in between was always strange. Sometimes it felt like he had been walking for miles when it turned out he had gone perhaps a dozen steps down a hall in the outer world. Once one of the Bounders had gone a little too far down the tunnels and found himself in the ruins of Dale. It was that unexplained adventure that had caused Fortinbras and the widows to put their foot down about exploring the expanding tunnels of the in between. Hopefully Bilbo could get there and back again before anyone noticed he was missing.

      Bilbo had only been to the royal wing once when he was still 'alive' to his Company. Thorin and Dwalin had brought him there one evening, the two of them hazy and half speaking in Westron and the rest in that secret language of the dwarves. Bilbo was not sure why Thorin and Dwalin had taken him there, showing him dilapidated rooms that were drafty and cold and rather sad. After...well after, Bilbo had spent some time trying to fix up those same rooms that Thorin and Dwalin had taken as their own. But then the cuts on his feet began to bleed too much and he had been forced to stop sneaking through the halls of Erebor to visit his dwarves for the time being.

      But now, with his feet healed and his arm only a little sore, Bilbo stepped through the tunnels of the in between as the designs on the walls became decidedly more dwarven. Finding the right door to step out from, while staying within the in between was always a risk. To Bilbo's surprise, though, the area that he thought was his destination had not one of the imposing rectangular doors that his dwarves favored, but rather a round door, painted green, just like...

        Bilbo blinked at a replica of his own front door and looked right, then left, frowning. There was no way he had gone so far through the tunnels only to return back to Bag End once more...right?

        Right?

      Bilbo bit down on his lower lip as he put a hand to that round, green door. It opened under his palm, showing not Bag End, but the very same rooms that Bilbo had once been shown by Thorin and Dwalin. He blinked away the wetness in his eyes and set aside the ache in his heart as he stepped into those chambers, moving careful and slow even if he stayed inside the in between.

      Bilbo did not think his dwarves would see him – they never had before when Bilbo was near them inside the in between – but when the elf had turned to look up at the battlements where Bilbo and Fortinbras had been hiding, watching the arrival of the emissaries, they had both ducked away, afraid that the elves could see them and their presence inside the mountain would be exposed at last. None of the Bounders had mentioned any of the elves being able to see them, before. Fortinbras had ordered that no one go near the elves now, and especially no where near the emissaries from Valinor, just in case these spirits could see their people while they were in between. As it was everyone was being their sneakiest while they moved anywhere outside of their little warren of tunnels, even inside the in between. Just in case.

      Bilbo glanced around the rooms he had not been back to in weeks, noting the changes that had been made in his absence. Thick rugs were spread over the cold stone floors, the colors and designs clearly of dwarven make. The rooms felt warmer, which was a relief to Bilbo, considering all the fussing he had done to make sure the drafts had been eliminated. His father, Bungo, had shown Bilbo how to fix such cold spots in Bag End once Bilbo was through his tweens, wanting to make sure that Bag End could be kept up with Bilbo's own hands in the future. And in case Bilbo ever took a spouse. But he shook that thought off double quick.

      The first room was empty, save for the crackling fire on the hearth and the large table that was scattered with notes and books that had seen better days. Bilbo glanced over the papers but all of it was in the writing of the dwarves and unintelligible for Bilbo to read. He slipped through to the next room where Thorin and Dwalin's armor stands were set up. On a table between the stands was the crown that Bilbo had found when he had taken Thorin in between. Bilbo glanced around and then padded over to it, looking at the crown now that he did not have a dwarf and a wheelbarrow to worry about.

      The gems in the crown were a blue that reminded Bilbo of Thorin's eyes. Bilbo reached out to touch it, his fingers pausing just before he could brush the metal of the crown. This was a symbol of Thorin's rule over his people, of his place in Erebor. What right did Bilbo have to touch such an object? It was one thing to pick it up and put it on Thorin while they were in between but it was quite another for Bilbo to poke and prod at it like a mathom found in a field. Bilbo let his hand drop and stepped away, his fingers curling to his palm in an effort to keep his hands to himself. He had come all this way to see Thorin and Dwalin, not to become the thief they had once called him in their madness.

        (What Bilbo did not see, when he turned away, was how the crown of Durin I caught the light of the fire crackling on the hearth, glowing for a moment before it settled.)

        Bilbo slipped through to the deepest room, where Thorin and Dwalin shared a bed and tried – and failed – to keep a flush from taking over his cheeks. In the Shire such an action would have been talk of the year had Bilbo been found out. There would have been Conversations had between the families. There might have even been Restitution made, if the hobbit Bilbo had been sneaking on had not wanted his attention. Even now, with his...with Thorin and Dwalin being dwarves, Bilbo might still be subject to a Discussion from the widows if his trip here was found out. But Bilbo had to come see them. The urge to go to them was too great for him to ignore and so he was here, slipping through Thorin and Dwalin's private rooms, just to get a glimpse of them.

        (And, perhaps, maybe, to leave something for them. Just a little thing. Not really a gift! Not like that at least. But something...something they would appreciate. Something they enjoyed. That was all.)

        Anyways.

        He caught the murmur of voices coming from the far side of the bedroom. All of the dwarven living spaces were larger than what hobbits favored, perhaps because so many of his people preferred to be outside rather than in a bedroom, which was most often used just to sleep in. Bilbo eased into the room after slipping his present into Dwalin's jacket pockets, as quick and quiet as he dared. He had to bite down on the urge to laugh for a bright moment. He really was the opposite of a burglar now, wasn't he? Then he glanced into the room and felt his smile falter and then drop.

        Hobbits did not have altars to their gods, not like Bilbo had seen of men and now dwarves have. He had thought that his people were more like elves, serving their chosen higher powers in the songs they sang and in the deeds they did day to day. The one and only time Bilbo had been in these rooms, before, he had seen the long altar set up along the east side of the wall. He had not asked any questions of his – of Thorin and Dwalin then, for they were already fey and strange by that point – but from what Bilbo had gathered during the first few days in Erebor before it all fell apart was that the dwarves kept altars in their rooms and put upon them things from those they held dear or things that they felt had come from their Maker to bless them.

        Bilbo drifted closer to where Thorin and Dwalin were standing, pressed hip to shoulder together in silence before their altar. The candles were new, as was the open box that sat between them. Bilbo held his breath as the flames flickered, causing shadows to slide across the wall. For a moment he thought he could see his own shadow, standing right next to Thorin and Dwalin, which should not have been impossible. The fire behind him was low, ready to be banked for the night, and even then Bilbo had never seen himself or his people bend light while they were in between. They should have been completely invisible, allowing for nothing to interact with them all.

        Bilbo froze when Thorin spoke, his heart thumping hard in his chest.

        “Do you think Bilbo would have liked our rooms?”

        Bilbo staggered back a step, his eyes starting to burn.

        “Maybe,” Dwalin's voice was rough. Bilbo wished for a wild moment that he could see Dwalin's face. “Might have wanted a balcony though.” Bilbo felt his feet stick in place. All he could do was stare at the large warrior, wondering how he could have possibly...

        Thorin's laugh was soft. “He would,” he said. “Full of flowers.”

        “And vegetables.”

        “And vegetables,” Thorin nodded at Dwalin's words. Bilbo put a hand to his throat. “You would complain endlessly about it.”

        “Oh like you wouldn't.”

        Bilbo frowned at them, about to put his hands on his hips. There was no call to be like that about his gardens! They were perfectly well done, if a bit wild at times, but then his dwarves should have liked that about him, considering –

        Bilbo flinched back when Thorin spun around, his eyes wild and wide. His heart hammered in his chest as Thorin scanned the room, taking deep breaths, as if...as if trying to...trying to...

        “Bilbo?” Thorin's voice was a bare whisper.

        “Thorin?” Dwalin's brows were drawn down into a deep frown. Bilbo saw Thorin hold up a hand, still scanning the room. He saw by chance the way Dwalin went pale and stagger back a step, one hand coming to cup his mouth and nose.

        “Do you smell that?” Thorin's voice was still a whisper of itself.

        “...Yes,” Dwalin croaked. “I do.”

        Bilbo held his breath as he froze in place, trying not to make a single sound as Thorin's gaze swept over his spot again and again. Each time Bilbo felt an ache go through his heart, doubly so when Dwalin began to do the same thing.

        “Perhaps it is coming from Bilbo's pouch?” Dwalin said after a long, strained moment. His hand dropped back down to his side but Bilbo could see the way he kept flexing his hand.

        “Perhaps,” Thorin said. Bilbo felt his eyes go wide as Thorin reached out, further and further until Thorin's hand was right in front of his chest, almost close enough to touch. If Bilbo just leaned in, they could...

        “Thorin?”

        Bilbo flinched back at the sound of Dwalin's voice. He took several steps back, his heart hammering in the hollow of his throat. What had he been thinking? He heard Thorin say, “I thought...it felt like...” Bilbo saw Thorin shake his head. “Perhaps I am just overtired.”

        “Perhaps,” Dwalin came to Thorin's side then. “Come. It has to be a scent from the pouch. We know he used to keep his pipeweed there.”

        “...Yes. Yes, of course.” Thorin let Dwalin draw him from the altar. Bilbo stayed in place, looking down at his hands and calling himself a lucky fool. The Old Toby he had brought them was the last of its kind from the sweet Shire fields, aged just enough to be able to be smoked, if that. Still it was more than his dwarves had at the moment and Bilbo hadn't been thinking and he could have...he could have...

        Bilbo slipped from the room as fast as he dared, darting into the tunnels of the in between quick as a cat and just as quiet. He did not dally on his way back to Bag End. It felt like the shadows in the tunnels were just a little bit longer, a little bit stranger as he hurried through those long corridors, never chancing a look behind. And behind him the tunnels he traveled lingered, staying lit longer, the edges of those old paths gaining definition bit by bit as the days wore on, even if Bilbo did not go back. And in them the shadows cast by that strange light slid across the floor, there and gone – or there and back again – between one blink and the next. Then everything settled and was still.

        For now.

 

 

~*~

 

 

        The next day found Bilbo with Fortinbras, the two of them being foolish Tooks together as if they were faunts once more. Fortinbras claimed that since he had called all their people back, to avoid being noticed by the powers of the West, that it was only right that he was the one to go out and risk himself trying to listen in on just why these powers had come to Arda's far shores. Both Bilbo and Lalia had called him a fool of a Took – with Lalia trying to box Fortinbras' ears – and had Bilbo sent off with his cousin, since according to everyone now in their new home, Bilbo was the one with the most experience Adventuring. Not that Bilbo thought going to sneak up on some elves and men and whatever the wizards were was an Adventure exactly but –

        Well. That was about the time when Lalia had turned to Bilbo to box his ears and he had scampered off with Fortinbras to escape her.

        Now, hiding with Fortinbras inside of a tunnel of the in between, with a door that would have led out to where the camp of men and elves had been set up open, Bilbo felt that – perhaps – this was a little bit like an Adventure. Bilbo chewed on his thumbnail as they listened to the talk about the table, feeling his frown grow deeper and deeper the more that Saruman spoke. They had not dared to get close to the wizards when they had arrived in front of everyone, choosing to stay on the balcony above the gate, instead. They still did not know if the emissaries from Valinor could see or sense them, as Maedhros – Maedhros, son of Fëanor – had seemed to be able to. Adding to that was that the main emissary seemed to be an actual spirit from the Greater West...well.

        Neither Bilbo or Fortinbras wished to take their chances with that being. At all. Thank you and good morning.

        Fortinbras had pushed Bilbo forward to be the one to lead them down to the tents and into the bustling press of men and elves and dwarves. They went the long way around the tents, staying well away from the Iron Hills camp, since all of those dwarves made each and every hobbit that came near them shiver. Bilbo had not understood what their Bounders meant until that day when he got too close to a particular knot of what looked to be Dáin's royal councilors. Bilbo felt like he had been dunked in a winter pond, his teeth almost chattered as he backed away, every hair on his body feeling like it was standing on end. After that Bilbo had given all of those dwarves – and really any dwarves that were not his Company – a very wide berth.

        Listening in on the council going on inside the tent was...interesting. Bilbo felt his shoulders start to inch up when his little ring was brought up for the first time. He had been forced to give a full accounting of all his deeds and all his finds to a mourning of widows, so Lalia knew much of what Bilbo had done during his Adventure. Fortinbras knew as well, but hearing the perspectives of these other races was...eye opening. Very eye opening. Bilbo felt the weight of Fortinbras' stare more than once during that long discussion in the tent. The only good thing to come out of their listening in was the words of praise that came when their wine was brought in for everyone to drink. The offering of the frost wines had been one of their first gifts to their new home and Bilbo knew Fortinbras would be proud to hear how well it had been received. There was already talk from their Gardeners about establishing new vines here on Erebor's sides, with more than a few of their Gardeners wanting to try planting their crops higher on the mountainside to see if they could get an even sweeter vintage in the coming years.

        Bilbo felt his brows draw down when this Saruman began to scoff at even the idea of hobbits being able to do anything, much less destroy the One Ring of Sauron. Bilbo had not known that his pretty little mathom had been that important when he'd dropped it in the mixture of dragonfire and molten gold. He'd been rather focused on not being killed by the enraged dragon, thank you.

        Hearing that a dwarf from the Iron Hills had tried to steal the Arkenstone had made Bilbo look at Fortinbras, who looked as shocked as Bilbo felt. They had turned as one as Thorin led the group of leaders out of the tent, closing the door that led back into the tunnels of the in between, and then cutting through the depths of the mountain far quicker than Thorin and the others could make it to the throne room. Bilbo and Fortinbras laid on their bellies above the throne, peering down over a lip of stone to see Thorin come marching into the room, fury all but radiating off of him.

        Bilbo curled his fingers into the cold stone beneath him as Dáin shouted at Thorin. He pressed his lips together, wanting to do something to make it better but not knowing what.

        “Do you see it?” Fortinbras' whisper made Bilbo jump. He glanced at his cousin, who was pressed up against his side, but all of Fortinbras' attention was on the spectacle below.

        “See what?” Bilbo looked back, trying to see what Fortinbras had spotted.

        Fortinbras' finger inched out, pointing at...something. Bilbo frowned, leaning hard into his cousin's side to see what he was focused on. It took Bilbo a long moment to finally pick out what Fortinbras had seen. There, under the feet of the wizards and the crowd of people who had come trailing after Thorin, was a shadow. It was not a normal shadow, cast by the growing illumination of the sun coming in through the windows. No, this was a shadow that looked almost like snakes twisting about the feet of the crowd, thick about Dáin and his people, but growing more and more around the others.
“What in the world,” Bilbo murmured as he squinted at it.

        “I don't like that at all,” Fortinbras muttered.

        “Me either,” Bilbo agreed. He squinted down at the crowd that was strung out along the narrow walkway that led to the throne, chewing on his lower lip. His fingers tapped against the cool stone beneath him. What could they do? Nothing for the moment, that was for sure. He was so focused on trying to figure out how he could fix this strange shadow that Bilbo almost missed it.

        “The Arkenstone is a Silmaril?” He couldn't help the way he breathed out the word.

        Fortinbras had a hand pressed over his mouth. Bilbo knew his cousin was aware of just what had been revealed in the room below. Few hobbits knew – or cared to know – about the distant past. Most of their people were...had been content with their lives in the Shire, on looking towards the future, towards the next weather forecast, the next crop, the next round of preserving the fruits of their land. There were a few, however, that were always taught about the Old Things, the histories of the world, of the former Ages as best they could get their hands on the tales and actual accounts written by those who had lived through it. The Took line always held that knowledge, as had the Brandybucks, along with the Baggins. There were a few other family lines that held other pools of knowledge – and then there were the widows, but that wasn't for anyone to know until they became a widow themselves.

        The history of the Silmarils was something Bilbo had learned at both his mother and his father's knee. His father's line held the knowledge of the curse of Fëanor and the horrors that happened around those gems. His mother's line spoke of their magic, of their hope, of the way those gems glowed in the darkness, giving light even in the darkest of hours. Bilbo had heard from what news their people had been able to gather from that initial meeting of the emissaries that they were concerned that the Silmarils would somehow reappear in Arda by the machinations of Morgoth or Sauron. But Bilbo had never thought, not for a single, wild second, that the Arkenstone he had seen Bofur chip out of the molten gold was an actual Silmaril.

        Whatever in the world was going on?

        “Did you know...”

        “Never,” Bilbo hissed at his cousin. Fortinbras rubbed a hand over his mouth. They had missed something in their shock, for when Bilbo turned back to the crowd below them he saw most of them staring at Elrond's councilor, Master Erestor.

        Bilbo strained his ears just in time to hear Lord Elrond say, “You think the attempted destruction of the Silmaril is what is causing the protections about Valinor to fail as well, Erestor?”

        Bilbo could not miss how Master Erestor looked at Elrond and then back at Maedhros – nor how the Lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion seemed to stand even taller at his back. “I do not know if that is the case or not,” he said as Eönwë stepped up to Maedhros' side. “But you have said that you fear that this strange shift in the Song is some ploy of Morgoth's. And if Morgoth cursed the Silmarils...”

        “Then perhaps they are connected.” Bilbo strained to hear Eönwë's words. “Yes, I could see how that may be a reason. But,” as the spirit turned to look at the Arkenstone Bilbo noted how the shadows about his feet...shifted. “We do not know this for certain and I will not take such a symbol of your people from you, King Thorin, no matter its origins.”

        Bilbo closed his eyes for a long moment at that.

        He opened his eyes to see Thorin bow to the Maia. “I thank you, Lord Eönwë,” he said as he rose. Bilbo saw the way Thorin's hands flexed at his sides and couldn't help but tense. Before...before it was the Arkenstone that Thorin's madness had fixated on. Now that they knew it was a Silmaril it made more sense, but if it was a Silmaril and they were cursed, then would that madness return? Thorin's next words stole the breath from Bilbo's lungs. “But I would hand it over to you this moment if you felt it proper. I will not be the reason why Arda is torn apart by Morgoth's evil plans, even if it means to hand over the gem that has signified the kingship of our people here in Erebor.”

        Bilbo squeezed his eyes shut and put his head down on his hands, breathing through the relief and the strange grief that took hold of his throat. He felt Fortinbras put a hand on his shoulder, the two of them silent as the stir of the crowd swept through the room.

        Then they heard Saruman say, “Perhaps taking the Silmaril would be the most wise move,” he began.

        Bilbo's head came up sharply. He narrowed his eyes at the wizard. Fortinbras' hand tightened on his shoulder.

      “No,” Eönwë held up a hand, silencing the entire crowd. Bilbo let out a breath. “I do not believe it is necessary to take this item from King Thorin.” Bilbo eyed the way Saruman bowed his head at the words, his hands folding into his sleeves. “I do appreciate the gesture, but let us not get ahead of ourselves. We do not know for sure if the Silmarils have any part to play in this, though my heart tells me that they do. As such the Silmaril, your Arkenstone, King Thorin, should remain in your possession until such a time as it may be needed.”

        “In such an open spot? In a place where it has already been attempted to be stolen?” Saruman's nose went up in the air. Bilbo hated the fact that he agreed with the wizard. If only a little. “Perhaps it should be moved to a...safer place.”

        Bilbo shared a look with Fortinbras. They could think of one very secure spot for said Silmaril, if it came to it.

        “I'll get a Bounder to keep their eyes on the room at all times,” Fortinbras whispered.

        Bilbo nodded back. “Perhaps a few, just in case something or someone comes in to try and take it.”

        “Yes.”

        “The treasury is gone.” Bilbo heard Thorin's words as he looked back to the crowd below. “Lost in the destruction of Smaug's fury and his own death.”

        Bilbo's breath caught. His shoulders went up about his ears. He felt Fortinbras still against his side.

        “About that,” Gandalf said as he stepped forward. “Would you allow us to see this place, where the dragon died and the...Arkenstone was found?”

        “Bofur?” Bilbo saw the miner step out of the crowd at Thorin's call. “Is the area safe to bring them into?”

        Bilbo saw how Bofur pulled at his hair. Bilbo looked at Fortinbras, who leaned in to whisper, “I do not think the Carpenters have been to that area of the mountain yet.” Bilbo made a face but that made sense. Their people had been working out from their maze of tunnels and further into the mountain as they went as more and more of the Old Talents began to emerge in their people. They were just starting to work on the bridges of the main chamber, now.

        Distantly Bilbo heard Bofur say, “Should be. As long as you don't go up onto any of the balconies and maybe stay away from the eastern halls. The columns looked a bit dodgy there.”

        “But they will hold?”

        “Oh, they'll hold unless another dragon comes along or we have an earth shaker pop off.” Bilbo frowned at that. What was an earth shaker? “Other than that, yeah, I'd say it would be safe enough.”

        Thorin looked back to Gandalf. “Then I will show you,” he said. Bilbo pressed his palms to the stone as the crowd followed Thorin back out of the room, with only a few lingering to stare at the Arkenstone set into the throne. It took Bilbo and Fortinbras longer to get to the treasury than Thorin and the others. The tunnels surrounding the treasury were...strange, rough things with sharp, black stones that cut open the side of Bilbo's foot at a careless moment.

        By the time they got to the treasury Thorin and the others were standing in front of a spot of discolored metal, but with Bofur being led away by Óin. With the way the tunnels had woven through the in between, and with how...strange the area was, Fortinbras had kept them both on the balcony above the treasury. The in between itself was...difficult to stay inside in this area, so they both stepped out into the shadows of the balcony, creeping close to the edge to try and hear any of the conversation below. This far away they could not hear what was being said but Bilbo cringed away from the look his cousin was pinning on him. Bilbo...may have not explained in great detail just how large Smaug had been, nor how terrifying the dragon was.

        “Bilbo...” Fortinbras said on the quietest of whispers.

        “I know,” Bilbo hissed back, his shoulders up about his ears. “It's dead now, though.”

        “Bilbo.”

        Bilbo ducked his head and looked back to the treasury in time to see Thorin and the others step away from that strange, discolored metal after what looked like a rather intense conversation. Bilbo wished they could have gotten closer to hear what had been said. Then his gaze caught on that strange discolored metal and the way there seemed to be a...shadow lingering about it, a shadow that almost seemed to reach out towards the group of beings that were moving away from it. Bilbo blinked and the shadow was gone. Perhaps it was a trick of the eye? Then his attention was drawn back to where the shadow had seemed to originate. There was something...something about that spot, about that discolored metal...ah, that's right. That was where the Arkenstone had been found. Bilbo remembered that. It was also...wait a minute...

        Bilbo leaned over to grab Fortinbras' shoulder. “I dropped the ring there,” he said into his cousin's ear, pointing at the spot.

        “Where the Arkenstone was?” Fortinbras frowned at him.

        Bilbo nodded. “I remember it well. I was running from the dragon.” He pressed his lips together for a moment. “And it slipped off my finger, letting the dragon see me. I threw myself into the in between, hoping it would save me.”

        “And it did,” Fortinbras' frown did not ease. “And then you reached for us.”

        “I did.” Bilbo's mouth was dry. He did not like to think of that desperate flight, of reaching for his people, of causing all this to happen. “I wanted...I did not know what I was doing.”

        Fortinbras leaned into his side. “I know that, I do,” he said. “You've told us all enough times about what happened here. But,” his gaze tracked up, towards the dragon, and Bilbo followed it. He swallowed at the sight and at the way Thorin and the others were looking at the large arrow that had pierced the dragon's belly, killing him. “That's a Hunter's Arrow, Bilbo!”

        “Hush!” Bilbo pushed them both flat as one of the group – Maedhros again – turned sharply to face their hiding place. They dove backwards into the in between, the door that separated the tunnels and their hiding spot sliding into place without a sound. It made the hairs on the back of Bilbo's neck stand on end.

        “Bilbo!”

        “Do not take that tone with me! I told you I shot an arrow at the dragon and it killed it!”

        Fortinbras took his shoulders and gave him a shake. “You never said it was a Hunter's Arrow!”

        “Because it is not!”

        “Bilbo! I saw it clear as day! That was a Hunter's Arrow!” Fortinbras let him go and sat back.

        Bilbo opened his mouth, closed it. “Impossible,” he said at last.

        “Bilbo!”

        “It cannot be!” He threw his hands into the air. They were sat on either side of the tunnel's long hall. The strange half-light of the area made everything look strange. “I am a Baggins!”

        “You are,” Fortinbras said after a moment of silence. “Born of a Took mother, though.”

        Bilbo drew in breath to argue and then let it out in a rush. “Mother was always good with her throwing stones.”

        Fortinbras leaned his head back against the wall of the tunnel, his gaze never leaving Bilbo. Fortinbras resembled their grandfather in many ways, with his messy blond hair that was turning darker as the years went on. “You reached for us,” he repeated, a furrow still between his brows. “Do you think...”

        Bilbo let out a breath and leaned his own head against the walls of the tunnel. “It felt like a – a spiderweb or a – a loom, all interconnected inside of me,” he said. “I reached and...everyone else reached back. It was not me that killed the dragon. It was all of us. I told you that.”

        “You did,” Fortinbras said slowly. His gaze had gone distant. “But the Hunter's Arrows were from...” He made a curled motion with one hand. The Dark Years were never spoken of, not directly. It was only during the Longest Night puppet plays that they were even alluded to. The broken stones and the pools of light had always been a favorite one of Bilbo's. He wondered about that now. Then his gaze tracked up to the wall above Fortinbras and he felt the very air in his lungs go still.

        “Bilbo?”

        All he could do was shake his head and stare. Fortinbras got to his knees and turned, looking up at the wall behind him. Bilbo could taste metal in his mouth and did not know why. All he could do was stare at the image coming into focus on that pale wall, like the shadow plays of his youth, when the widows would sit with the youngest faunts down in the Great Smials and play out the silent stories against a screen lit by a candle.

        On the wall there were moving drawings, done in what looked like charcoal. Bilbo saw two tall poles, with lines radiating out from the top of them take shape. Then a dark figure broke the poles down, stomping on the remains as the lines from the tops of them went out. Then that dark figure was running as a herd of other figures chased it, right into a large...a large...

        “Is that...” Bilbo glanced at Fortinbras. His cousin nodded, never taking his gaze away from the strange shadow play taking place on the wall.

        The Dark Tower was a whispered tale, told only by faunts during the celebrations that took place after the Longest Night was over. It was the place where their oldest tales came from, where their wandering days were born. The shadow plays always spoke of a great storm coming down on the Dark Tower, but this...this was different. For the strange images being sketched against the wall showed a great fight between the dark figure and the others that had chased him into his hole, with great bolts of lightning tearing the hiding spot apart, leaving thick pools of black charcoal to fill the area where the dark figure had been hiding. Even after that dark figure had been dragged out by the ones chasing it the image did not follow that figure but stayed on the broken hole and the thick pools that filled it. Then the image faded and Bilbo was staring at a blank wall once more.

        “What,” said Bilbo. “Was that.”

        “I do not know,” Fortinbras said.

        “It was a piece of our history you were not to know,” said another voice. Bilbo scrambled to his feet, along with Fortinbras, his heart thundering in his chest. He turned to see Widow Layflower step out of the darkness of the tunnel, coming to a stop a few paces away. Her dark cane was planted against the ground and her expression was severe. “You were told not to travel so far in the dark tunnels. Not even you, the Thain, were to break these rules.”

        Bilbo stepped in front of Fortinbras. “It was my fault.”

        “Bilbo!” Fortinbras tried to pull him back.

        “No,” Widow Layflower pointed a gnarled finger at Bilbo's chest. “It was not your fault alone, young one. You need to do better. Taking all the hurts onto yourself makes more of a mess in the end when those who love you are hurt by such actions. Remember that.”

        “Yes, ma'am.”

        “Good.” She tapped her cane against the ground and studied them both for a moment. Then she sighed and her shoulders dropped. It felt like the very light in the tunnel around them brightened. “It was always coming to this,” she murmured after a moment. Then she drew in a sharp breath and straightened, her cane coming down with a crack against the black stones of the tunnel floor. “Come along, you two. It is time.” Then she turned and walked into the shadows, opposite the way they had first came.

        “Time? Time for what?” Bilbo asked as they followed her.

        “Time for all hobbits to hear the history of our people,” she said, not turning around. Bilbo shared a look with Fortinbras, who shrugged back at them. “Come along,” her tone was sharp. They hurried to keep up with her, despite her age. “There is much to be told and not much time to do it, I fear. But what must be done will be done. Come.”

        And so they followed her into the dark. They did not look back, for if they had they would have seen more scenes starting to form on the walls behind them, following them all the way back to the halls where their people now lived, in darkness once more. And when they followed Widow Layflower into the largest hall of the Great Smials Bilbo saw that the circle of widows sitting about the fire had grown...

        And that looked as though they had been waiting for them both.

 

 

Chapter 21: a gift that is given

Notes:

There is some question as to Aragorn's actual age, between book and movie 'verse, and since I'm kind of playing with both, I've decided that Aragorn is basically a teenager/young man in this fic.

Chapter Text

 

          Thorin frowned down at the sheaf of papers stacked in front of him, exhaustion weighing heavy in his bones. His privy council was over the for the evening, with supper being served soon and Thorin would have to make his appearances there as well. The joint meals with the elves and the men were making connections with their peoples far more than the stuffy meetings that they had managed to have over the last few days. The once easy talks had grown strained, with the men becoming more and more curt with each passing day and the elves more aloof. Thorin didn't know what had changed, only that something had and that they needed to figure out what was going on.

          The murmur of dwarven voices out in the hall had Thorin pausing, listening. The familiar tones of his people made his breath come a touch easier. All of the Iron Hills dwarves had pulled out of the mountain completely, moving to a different spot in the camps, away from the elves and men, and closer to Ravenhill. No one knew why. Thorin's holy ones had no way to keep Dáin in the lower halls of the mountain and if they had tried to keep another king against his will...well. That would have opened up even more problems that Thorin did not need to deal with at the moment.

        An added stress to the entire situation was the wizard Saruman's constant demands to be taken to the treasury to inspect the area around where the Arkenstone had been found and the One Ring destroyed. Thorin had allowed it once, the day after their first visit to the area but had not allowed it since. His council was grumbling about the wizard's demands and Thorin himself was none too pleased about it, either. He did not like the way this Saruman would look down his nose at them, or the way the two blue wizards seemed to hover at Saruman's sides, more like lackeys than the wizards they were supposed to be. Gandalf was trying to be a buffer between this Saruman's more caustic remarks and the rest of the peoples in the camps but even Gandalf could not be at Saruman's side every minute of every day. And as for Radagast, Thorin had not seen him since he had first arrived.

          Thorin rubbed at the back of his neck as he made his way down to the large communal tent that had been set up for the evening meals. The combined kitchens of the dwarves, men, and elves were putting out a truly impressive amount of food for the stores they all had, and making delicious meals with rather more humble ingredients than Erebor had boasted in the past. There were still food stores turning up out of the blue and Bombur – and Thorin to some degree – were starting to wonder if it was not the elves who were gifting this largess to them, since a great deal of what was showing up were root vegetables and pickles and other such items. Dwarves, as a whole, tended to eat more meat, both fresh caught and cured, due to their dietary needs, but few outside of their own people knew such details. For such gifts to be showing up, and being vegetables at that, pointed more towards the elves, who ate far less meat on a whole than even men. If Shire had not been –

          Thorin paused on the last step before he entered the main hall that led to the great gates and breathed through the still thick grief that would clog his throat when he thought about Bilbo's homeland. The Shire was gone. The hobbits were gone. And – as much as it made his gut churn and shame curl down his spine – the production of that lush land was gone. There were no exports coming to aid the dwarven colonies in the Blue Mountains. There were no wagons of produce to feed the small towns that dotted the western shore and the Grey Havens. Even Rivendell would feel the pinch, or so Lord Elrond had told him during an evening spent drinking the sweet wine from Erebor's cellars. Gondor, too, would feel the loss of the Shire's exports, if not in the fresh produce than in the preserved pickles, jams, and other such long lasting foodstuffs.

        Thorin had been sitting with Balin when word had come from the colonies in the Blue Mountains, seeing if there was space yet in Erebor to support a larger number of their people. It was still unknown if their people in the west would even have enough food to see them through winter. And as for any attempt to plant in what remained of the Shire, it was Gandalf who had told them that the very soil of that land seemed to be almost barren, burnt and sterilized from the dragon's great heat. It went on for the entirety of the Shire, for leagues and leagues, and no one, not any of the wizards, nor even Lord Eönwë, could say how such a thing was possible.

          It seemed as though the thoughts of the Shire was on more than just Thorin's mind that night, for as he sat among the men and elves and Maiar, talk turned to that land – and the hobbits who had once inhabited it.

          “It will be a blow for sure,” Prince Thengel said as he pushed food around on his plate. Thorin tried not to frown at him. The prince had been polite in his manners up until the wizards had arrived and after that the prince – and others of the men who came to these dinners – would often not finish the food on their plates. Even Lord Ecthelion II of Gondor, who had been open to more favorable treaty terms with Erebor, had pulled back since the wizards came. Thorin was not sure why. It was possible that Saruman had his own understandings with Gondor and their imports and exports, but why or how Erebor's own relationship with Gondor would affect Saruman's small holding of Isengard was a mystery that neither Thorin or his council could crack.

          “I have heard that there is some possibility for new trade relations opening with the peoples of the southern lands,” Pallando said as he sipped at his wine. The blue wizard had barely touched his food. Thorin tried not to glare at him.

          “The southern lands?” Lord Ecthelion II looked up from his plate. At least he had eaten most of it. “They have been historically hostile to Gondor.”

          “Perhaps,” Pallando tipped his cup to the lord. There was a faint smile on his face. “But in those far lands money talks louder than history and there are deals to be had among the merchants there.”

          “Are there,” Lord Ecthelion II sat back in his chair. There was a faint furrow between his brows. “I will take it under consideration.”

          “The markets for food in those lands would be a far swifter trip for Gondor...and Rohan,” Pallando continued. “Perhaps it is serendipitous that such a change had to happen in the western lands to open up contact between two nations that have had strained relations for so long.”

          “You would call the raids on the borders of Gondor and the attacks at sea on Gondor's navy strained relations?” A young Ranger was the one to speak up. He had been the one that all the other Rangers had looked to, their entire time they had been in the camp. Thorin had been skeptical that such a youth could be a leader of these northern people but even Lord Elrond would stop and listen when the young man spoke. The other Rangers around the youth all stopped and turned to him, listening.

          Lord Ecthelion II frowned at the young Ranger, the corners of his mouth turning down. “Gondor has a long history in this part of the world,” he said. “I know your people are of the old northern and western peoples that were once a part of our lands. You should surely be aware that Gondor has had, at times, friendly contact with the peoples of the southern lands. Would it be so wrong to hope for such friendly terms to return once more?”

          The young man sat back in his chair, frowning back at Lord Ecthelion II. He – and the rest of the Rangers – had finished his plate completely. “Our peoples were once of one nation, yes. Have the Stewards of Gondor forgotten that at almost every turn, when Gondor has had treaties with the southern lands, these treaties are broken by the very same hands that pleaded for them and Gondor is left to either defend themselves from renewed raids or have her people ration their food until other partners could be found? It was why the treaties signed with the Shire were made in the first place and why we who remain in the northwest guarded those borders for our relations to the south.”

          A stillness had come over Lord Ecthelion II. “I would have you remind me of your name,” he said, voice soft. “Forgive me.”

          The Ranger's eyes were dark when he met Lord Ecthelion II's stare. “I am Aragorn, son of Arathorn.”

          “Aragorn,” Lord Ecthelion II repeated. Thorin looked between them, something about the young Ranger's name, and that of his father, catching his attention. There was something about those names...he knew those names...they were...

          It was Thorin's turn to sit back in his chair. He glanced around the table and it was Lord Elrond who caught his gaze. The lord of Rivendell gave him a faint nod, while at Elrond's side Maedhros was looking between the men with a frown of his own on his face. Thorin turned back to the men, looking between Lord Ecthelion II and Aragorn. “Forgive me,” he broke the tense silence that had settled over the table. All eyes turned to him. Thorin kept his gaze on Aragorn. “I was not aware that the young lord of the Dúnedain had come to Erebor. My apologies.”

          Aragorn's dark eyes lightened with what might have been mirth. “I am a Ranger of the North, like my father before me and his father before him. I need no title or acknowledgment but I thank you for the courtesy.” Then Aragorn gave Thorin a brief bow from his seat, which Thorin returned.

          “I had heard that the Rangers were often tasked to guard the borders of the Shire,” Saruman said. His gaze was on his goblet of wine and his plate of food untouched. “And yet the Shire is now gone and there is now the possibility that many of the small villages left in your once vast lands will now starve.”

          Silence swept over the table. Thorin saw Prince Thengel wince and go back to his food, picking at it with his head down. Lord Ecthelion II also looked back at his plate, his frown never leaving his face.

          “I cannot see how you can blame them for something that even we do not understand,” Thorin said into that silence.

          The wizard's dour look had Thorin raising an eyebrow back at him. “They were still tasked to protect that productive area by one of my – our Order,” Saruman's nose went up in the air. Thorin saw Galadriel's faint sigh and eye roll in his periphery. “The Shire is gone. They failed in their duties.”

          Thorin couldn't help his frown at the wizard. “The Shire was destroyed by dragonfire,” he said. “Dragonfire that no one knows how it got there. There was no sign of dragons in the area, no sign of an army, nothing. The Rangers cannot fight what they cannot see.”

          “King Thorin is correct,” Lady Galadriel said before Saruman could open his mouth again. “There have only been a few who have ever been able to kill a dragon in all the Ages of this world. We cannot heap blame onto the Rangers for this matter. The mystery of the Shire's destruction is still something that bothers me.”

          “I as well,” Thorin agreed, nodding at the lady when she looked to him. He glanced back at Aragorn. “I was told that the Rangers went over the whole of the Shire after...well. After.” He shook his head. “Would you tell us what your people saw of the area? If there was anything that could explain the destruction at all?”

          Aragorn tapped a finger against the table, his gaze going to Lord Elrond for a long moment before coming back to Thorin. “I went with my people to the Shire,” he said after a moment. Thorin raised his eyebrows at that. “From the West March to the Old Forest, from the North Farthing to the South Farthing, all was destroyed. No tree, not even a shrub survived. The grasses would turn to ash as we walked over them. What was stranger was that each home we went to was...empty. Nothing remained.”

          “Nothing?” Prince Thengel looked up at that.

          “Nothing,” Aragorn shook his head. Prince Thengel winced and went back to pushing food about his plate. “Each home was blackened too, as if this dragonfire ate at them from the inside out. Or...”

          “Or?” Gandalf leaned forward at that.

          Aragorn pressed his lips together for a long moment. “At times it seemed as if...almost as if the fire that had destroyed the Shire came from the homes.”

          “But how could that be?”

          “I do not know,” Aragorn lifted a shoulder and let it fall. “We managed to make our way into the Great Smials,” this he told to Gandalf. “Nothing was left, even in the deepest of cellars. Not a single scrap, no melted metal, no brass button, nothing.”

          “Strange,” Gandalf murmured, sinking back into his seat. “Very strange.”

          “You seem quite knowledgeable of these hobbits,” Saruman said to Aragorn with a dour twist to his mouth. Thorin wanted to punch it off of him.

          There was a wistful smile that slid across the young Ranger's face, there and gone. “There was a hobbit matron by the name of Belladonna that I met as a child. She was very kind to me on her visit to Imladris.” Aragon leaned back in his seat. “I believe she was the mother of your Bilbo Baggins, King Thorin.”

          Thorin had to close his eyes at that.

          “Indeed she was,” Gandalf said as Thorin opened his eyes. “Belladonna Took was one of the three remarkable daughters of the Old Took. She had many adventures in her youth, some that took her to Rivendell, yes, and once to the Grey Havens, though she did not speak much of it to me. Then she married Bungo Baggins and settled down to have Bilbo.” He tapped his pipe against his lips, a sad smile lingering on his face.

          Thorin had to look away at that. “I was aware that Bilbo's parents were...had passed, before he came with us on our Quest.” He curled a hand into a fist, rubbing his thumb over the knuckles of his hand, the very same hand that his Bilbo had taken in their fall. “He did not speak much of his family or his past.”

          “No, hobbits do not speak much of the faded,” Gandalf sighed.

          “The faded?” Prince Thengel looked up from his plate. He had eaten more than half of what he had left before. “I thought only elves faded. My apologies,” he looked at the elves at the table. “That is what is told in the tales that are sung in Rohan.”

          “Hobbits are...were a peculiar folk,” Gandalf said, his gaze locked onto some distant point. “I met them when I first came to this land, many, many years ago now. They were different then.” He made a vague gesture with one hand. Thorin was not sure what it meant to convey. “They were a wandering folk, with secrets they would not tell to...” A sad smile tilted Gandalf's mouth. “Strangers.”

          “So then you admit to not knowing your favorite pets as well as many would assume?” Saruman's question made the smile slide from Gandalf's face.

          “As I have said before, Saruman, the hobbits were not my pets and I would thank you to stop referring to them as such.” Gandalf pointed a long finger at the other wizard. Thorin wanted to point his knife at him.

          “So defensive over a race that is now gone, Gandalf. Perhaps you protest too much?”

          “Saruman...”

          “Enough,” Lady Galadriel said. She put her goblet down with more force than necessary. All eyes turned to her. “I am uneasy at the squabbles breaking out between us in this place.” She swept a look over the table. Few could meet her gaze.

          “Indeed,” Saruman said before anyone else could speak. “It is...troubling.”

          “Indeed,” Lady Galadriel echoed back at him. “If you would –”

          “I find it troubling that such friction is arising in this place, a place where the Song was changed.” Saruman spoke over the lady's words, his gaze on the contents of his goblet and not on the expression on Lady Galadriel's face. “I fear that Morgoth's darkness is spreading, causing mere mortal minds to become...confused.”

          “Saruman.”

          “As such, I do believe it best to remove the Silmaril from its position in this...dwarven mountain and put into a more secure location.”

          Several of those seated about the table began to speak at once. Eönwë held up a hand and it began to quiet, albeit slowly. “I have already said that I would not have the Silmaril taken from King Thorin's possession. It appeared here, for whatever reason there may be, and so it shall remain, unless it be absolutely necessary to move it.”

          “I thank you,” Thorin said before anyone else could speak. He kept his gaze on Saruman, who was still contemplating whatever was in his glass.

          “My father,” Maedhros said, turning heads, Thorin's included. The elf had his hands linked on the table, his gaze resting on them, and his plate – completely finished – pushed away. “Created the Silmarils. There were many who demanded he do this or that with the gems, even before the lies of Morgoth began to splinter our people and poison kin against kin. After...” Maedhros pressed his lips into a bloodless line for a long moment. “When we met in the Halls of Mandos, Father never spoke of the Silmarils again...except for one time.” He lifted his eyes and looked about the table. No one spoke. “The night before I was to leave the Halls and return to Arda, Father said that it was his greatest wish to release the gems into the world, to go where they need to be, rather than return them to the Valar, for he believed the gems belong to those who live in Arda and not to those who would cage the Light of those gems in Aman.”

          “I see that Fëanor's pride has not lessened even in the Halls of Mandos!” Saruman slapped a hand against the table as he sat up in his seat.

          “Saruman!” Gandalf leaned forward, pointing a finger at the other wizard. Others began to speak over each other, creating a rising cacophony of sound.

          “Enough!” Eönwë's voice rang out over the rising voices that had sprung up about the table. The raised voices dimmed. Saruman and Gandalf continued to glare at one another. “Enough,” Eönwë repeated, softer. He put a hand on Gandalf's arm and that caused the wizard to break his stare from Saruman. “I myself spoke with Fëanor before we came to these far shores.” There was a rustle of movement about the table. “I agree with him on this matter, as do my Lord and Lady.” That evoked a murmur from those gathered. “Fëanor's gift of the Silmarils to those in Arda is a selfless act, a gift to all those on these far shores. The Silmarils will stay here, in Arda, unless something unforeseen takes place. That includes the one that is in King Thorin's mountain.” Thorin met Eönwë's gaze and nodded. “In these strange times we must trust in each other, and not allow Morgoth's shadow to divide us.”

          Just as Eönwë said the word shadow, Thorin saw something shift over the table, like a drape of the thinnest gauze, there and gone. He jerked back in his seat, his elbow catching his plate and sending it clattering to the floor. Maedhros, too, threw himself back from the table, his chair falling over as he sprang to his feet.

          “Thorin?” Gandalf stood as well. “Maedhros?” He looked between them.

          Thorin met Maedhros' gaze. “Did you see it?”

          Maedhros gave him a slow nod, a grim expression flattening his mouth. “A shadow,” he said, looking to Eönwë. “It swept over the table.”

          Most of those gathered pushed away, some with their chairs spilling over in their haste, as Maedhros' had. Saruman and the blue wizards were the last to stand. Thorin looked at Gandalf but the wizard was frowning down at the table, his eyes dark and focused.

          “Morgoth's shadow is moving among us,” Saruman was the one to speak. “Do you not see how his influence is already affecting us? Do you still think it wise to keep the Silmaril in the mountain of the dwarves, away from Lord Eönwë's keep? Should it not be taken as a precaution?”

          Thorin set his jaw but it was Eönwë who answered him. “I will not take it, Saruman. I will not say it again.” He glanced at Maedhros. “The Silmarils are for the people of Arda and so they must remain. I do not think this sighting of Morgoth's shadow merits the removal of it, if it was Morgoth's shadow at all. I do believe we must be conscious and aware of such movements of Morgoth's...or his minions. This is perhaps one of the clearest signs that whatever happened here is connected to Morgoth in some way...and that we must take all possible care to make sure that Morgoth and his minions do not attempt to use our fear against each other. There are powers moving in Arda that I have not seen outside of Aman. We must be together in facing this darkness, for if this is a plot of Morgoth's to break free of the Door of Night then we must be ready to face his return.”

          “But what are we to do if Morgoth is going to break free from his prison?” Prince Thengel stepped forward at that. “What good do we do sitting here, speaking of treaties and idling the time away? What can we do?”

          Thorin saw Saruman draw himself up to speak but it was Eönwë who held up a hand and the murmurs about the table quieted. But just as he drew in breath to speak Nori burst in through the front of the tent, eyes a bit wide and wild.

          “Nori?” Thorin stepped towards the once-thief.

          “Gardens,” Nori gasped out. There was a strange tilt to his mouth that Thorin could not place. “My boys, they found gardens on the mountainside.”

          “The old terraces? From –”

          “No,” Nori shook his head, strands of hair escaping his peaks. “Proper gardens, not of our making. Hobbit gardens,” he swallowed and more than one person exchanged looks. “They look like the gardens we saw in the Shire, but they are all over the mountain.”

          Thorin curled his hands into tight fists. “Show me,” he said, ignoring the rest of the room. “Take me to them right now.” Thorin did not wait for anyone else as he followed Nori out of the tent. The sun was setting in the west, turning the clouds crimson and gold above them. By the time Thorin made it up the ridge and onto the side of the mountain the sun was just setting, giving them all enough light to see what could only be gardens spread out across the mountainside, not in the neat orderly rows Thorin had seen in the Shire, but wilder...yet still, undeniably, gardens. Gardens that none of their people planted. Gardens that none of their people had ever seen before.

          Thorin stepped forward, alone among the lush greenery, even as the temperature began to drop as the sun began to dip below the horizon. Yule was close, mere days after the rite that was to take place in the depths of the mountain and – despite the cold, despite the snow line creeping ever downwards – the gardens before him were thick with food. Thorin felt the hair on the back of his neck stand on end as he scanned the hillside, picking out more and more trees and plants that he had never seen in his people's gardens before...but would not have been out of place in the Shire.

          “Bilbo?” He whispered the name as the wind came whistling over the ridge. It did not scream as it would near the gates, an echo of the scream that sometimes chased Thorin out of his nightmares. It was...warm. Far warmer than the wind at the gates would be. Thorin stood in the quiet as the crowd of observers grew behind him but still that prickling sensation did not go away. “Bilbo?”

          Only silence answered him.

Chapter 22: that which was hidden

Chapter Text

 

        Bilbo had not known what to expect when he and Fortinbras had been brought before a full mourning of widows. Perhaps a dressing down. Perhaps a proper scolding. It was not to be sat in that same circle of widows and being told about a part of their history that very few outside of the widows themselves knew.

        Widow Layflower seemed to be in charge of this circle. Lalia was there as well, but she seemed as surprised as Bilbo and Fortinbras when Widow Layflower began to speak.

        “There has been a long argument about whether or not to tell our people of our history,” the widow began. Bilbo folded his hands together, locking his knuckles tight against each other. The widow tapped the end of her cane against the floor, one, twice, and then three times. Bilbo frowned at that. Gandalf had done the same thing. “It has been decided that some of that history will be told to you three, now, and the rest...” Her lips pressed together for a moment, a tight, bloodless line. “The rest will be told to everyone else on the eve of the Longest Night.”

        Bilbo looked at Fortinbras but his cousin's attention was solely for Widow Layflower.

        “Long were our people a traveling folk,” the widow said. Her voice almost seemed to echo in the room. “It is knowledge even among our faunts that once, long ago, we were visited by a Stranger that came from a fallen star. That Stranger would become Gandalf the Grey.” Bilbo rocked back at that. “The Stranger was...strange, then,” an odd smile pulled at one side of her mouth. One of the shadowed widows ducked their head but Bilbo could not focus on that hobbit, his gaze sliding away from them before he could make out their features. “He was confused. Almost like a faunt himself.” The widow's words drew Bilbo's attention back to her. “Sometimes he would break things by accident. He could not always control his powers, but on more than one occasion he saved us...and we saved him.”

        There was a strange rattle that went about the room. Bilbo could not pinpoint from whence it came.

        “It was our ancestor's interactions with this stranger, this,” her mouth quirked up again, “grand-elf as we called him then, that some of us, the widows, learned things about our own people and our gifts.” Her faint smile vanished. “We never told Gandalf of our gifts, or much at all of our people, beyond what he himself saw and experienced. He has always known us as a hearty folk, as a...people who are hard to corrupt, set in our ways, as many have claimed. And that is how we have always wanted Outsiders to know us, to think so little of us that most do not even remember us, in the grand scheme of things. It was safer that way.”

        Bilbo found that his mouth had gone dry. He did not know why.

        Widow Layflower's gaze sharpened as she focused on Bilbo. He sat up straighter in his seat. “None of this would have come to this if you had not found that mathom under the mountains.” She raised a hand when Bilbo's shoulders came up about his ears. “That, too, was not your fault. There are greater hands in this than even we can see, something that reaches beyond the utmost West and out into the darkness beyond. But whether that hand is fair or foul...that remains to be seen.”

        Bilbo felt a bit faint at that. Why would any great Power choose him to find such an object? To pick it up on a lark? It did not seem possible.

        “Whatever power is at work, it does not matter now. What is done is done. There is no going back.”

        Bilbo swallowed hard at that. The Shire was gone. Their people's home was gone. All because of –

        “You,” Widow Layflower pointed a long finger at Bilbo. “Need to stop that right there.”

        “Yes, ma'am.” The words came out of him before he could stop them.

        Widow Layflower wagged that finger at him. “Enough of that, or I'll have young Lalia here box your ears, understood?”

        Bilbo nodded.

        “Good.” Widow Layflower let her hand drop back into her lap. She studied him for a long moment. Bilbo fought not to fidget under that sharp gaze. “When you threw yourself into the in between, several things happened all at once. It had been a generations since any of us had been able to cross over into this broken space and it had been thought by the widows before this event that our people's magics were finally running out. We always knew they would one day.” She shook her head at their gasps. “But we never knew when. But then,” she leaned forward in her chair and Bilbo forgot to breathe. “Then you destroyed the Ring of Sauron right as you opened yourself up to every last bit of our people's magic. The power of that Ring was connected to you, by that power from the West, and so it flowed through you, to us, to every single hobbit in the Shire and beyond.”

        Bilbo blinked at that. “We...we're all here? Even the hobbits from Bree? But I've not seen them.”

        “All hobbits are here now, yes,” Widow Layflower said. “But us widows have been keeping you all apart. Only those of the Shire came to this section of the mountain. The others are...elsewhere,” she waved one hand. “And that is all you will get to know about them for now.”

        “Why do you tell us this?” Fortinbras asked. The widow's attention turned to him. All of the widows turned to him. “Why just us three? Why now?”

        “Because a part of it was already told to you, by hands that are far older than our own,” Widow Layflower said. She sighed, her hands smoothing out her dress on her lap. “We also tell you because you are the Thain, the leader of all our peoples, through a line that is far older than you know. We tell young Lalia because she is your wife and is the matriarch of your clan. And we tell you, Bilbo Baggins,” her gaze went back to him, “because you are the reason why our people will survive.”

        “What? Me? What do you mean survive?” Bilbo felt a bit faint.

        An expression of grief passed over the widow's face, there and gone too fast for Bilbo to do more than blink at it. “Our people were never meant to be,” she said. Bilbo jerked back at that. “Our creation was not planned, not desired, not even known of for many, many years. It may just be that only Gandalf, of all the powers of the West, ever truly knew of us. What made our people is something that will be explained on the eve of the Longest Night, but for now I will say this; our people were dying before you picked up that mathom, Bilbo Baggins, and because of you, because of this strange sequence of events, our people will now survive.”

        Bilbo swallowed at that. He felt Fortinbras and Lalia take each of his hands. He held on tight to them and they held on just as fiercely to him. “I don't understand.”

        “I know,” Widow Layflower sighed. “You will, though, soon enough. The powers of our people are waking up, growing with each day, with each breath, stronger and stronger the longer we stay inside the in between. Even now our faunts are skipping in and out of it, easier than anything, as if they had always been able to do so. This is something that was not done for Ages, since before the light of the Sun rose in the East.”

        Bilbo opened his mouth. Closed it. “But we cannot be so old,” he finally said.

        “Older still than that,” Widow Layflower shook her head at him. “But that is for later.” Her gaze slid to Bilbo's left. “For now we need you, Fortinbras, to embrace our magics before our people, to bring back the Old Ways, for all to see.”

        “I...thought I was already doing so?” Fortinbras frowned back at the widow. “I have never disparaged the gifts that have blossomed in our people since we have come here. I never discouraged their use. What –,” he stopped as the widow held up a hand.

        “You have not discouraged it, yes. Now you must embrace them, and have all our people do so as well.”

        “But the Gardeners already have! I –”

        “Our people were never meant to be,” Widow Layflower repeated, voice sharp enough to make Fortinbras snap his mouth closed. “We exist because of an accident, and we are allowed to stay as long as the magic in our people is used to help others. To fix things. That was the bargain that was struck and the bargain we will keep,” she sat back in her chair. “And so that is what we must do now. It must be more than just crates of food slipped into empty rooms. If we are to survive, if we are to use this chance that was given to us, then we must fix what is wrong about us in the world. Do you understand me?”

        Fortinbras stared at her for a long moment. Then, “No,” he said slowly. “I do not.”

        Widow Layflower nodded at that, slow and solemn. “This is our home now, given freely to us with no expectation of reciprocation. A gift given that we must now return. The home that was given to us is broken, shadowed by a dragon's curse and a gem that has a connection to a being who would try and pull this world apart at the very seams if he could. We must fix this,” she stabbed a thin finger at them. “And as Thain it is your responsibility to lead the way.”

        Fortinbras sat up at that. “What must I do?”

        For a moment it almost looked as though the shadows shifted and swelled about the widows before they settled. “We will tell you how we begin,” Widow Layflower said as she lowered her finger. “It is up to you to make sure we finish that which we start.”

        Fortinbras bowed his head at that. “I am listening,” he said.

 

 

~*~

 

 

        Many things had been said that night, things that Bilbo did not completely understand, but much that he did. Fortinbras kept his word to the widows and that very night his word went out to every hobbit in the mountain, passing on some of the history that the widows had told them but more than that, he sent out word that all their people were now allowed to fix anything – and everything – they could get their hands on.

        As one of the Baggins line, Bilbo had set to work with his clan to help strengthen the tunnels they were connected to, feeling out the cracks and fractures in the stone that surrounded them and mending all that they could reach. The Gardeners had taken Fortinbras' words and ran with them, spreading out over the mountainside, further and further with their gifts, spreading the gardens they had started into a sprawl of wild plants mixed with cultivated strains that worked well together. From what Hamfast had babbled at Bilbo over a hasty evening meal in the Great Smials where all the heads of the different professions came together to report to the Thain, the style of gardens spreading down the sides of Erebor had not been put to use for an Age, not since their people had wandered these lands long ago.

        It was a grand idea, along with all the others that were taking shape inside the mountain itself, but in their enthusiasm, their people may have gotten a little...carried away.

        Which was how they found themselves in their current predicament.

        Bilbo bit down hard on his lower lip as more dwarves poured into the lower gardens. The area had been where their Gardeners had been experimenting with more and more of the seeds and other stored vegetables from their cold rooms. Bilbo had been out with a handful of the Gardeners when the hue and cry went up from the dwarven scouts along the ridge. Bilbo and the others had managed to slip into the in between just as the dwarven guards had reached the lower area, their eyes wide and spooked as others went to rouse the tents below.

        “What do we do?” Hamfast whispered to him.

        “Has someone gone to alert the Thain?” Bilbo bit down on his lower lip, flinching as a shout went up from the dwarven scouting party.

        “They have.”

        “We need to make sure the doorway isn't found.” It was their only way in and out on this side of the mountain, well above their current hiding place.

        “But it be a dwarven door,” Hamfast shook his head. “Surely they know of it!”

        “Perhaps,” Bilbo could taste blood in his mouth and ran his tongue along his sore bottom lip. “But we cannot chance it. That tunnel leads to all our smials.”

        “I know that!”

      “Then we will make sure they do not find it,” Bilbo pushed away from the rock he was hiding behind, even if a larger part of him wished to stay and look his fill of Thorin in the setting sun. They moved as quietly as any hobbit could, even in the in between. Bilbo pulled the twist of fern and hellebore from behind his ear as they slipped away towards the door that sat above them. He tucked the twist of plants into his front pocket as they passed a trio of Gardeners wearing full crowns of of their own. It was a little strange to see them, since their people had only worn such items at Midsummer and Midwinter. But with the knowledge that had been given to their people from the widows, such sights were becoming common once more.

      By the time Bilbo and Hamfast reached the door there was a trio of Bounders already at work on it. Remy Oldwalker was painting tiny symbols in a mix of charcoal and some sort of sticky paste along the top of the entry. Stylized fern fronds twisted their way up the sides, with other small flowers peeking out from the design. The Bounders were not inside the in between, but risking the chance to paint the door out in the open. Bilbo paused outside the tunnel as Hamfast slipped past him and into the dark. Even as Bilbo watched, the dwarven door began to fade from sight, looking more and more like a simple outcropping of stone by the time the Bounders were done with it. Bilbo saw Remy glance at him more than once but all Bilbo could do was nod back at him. The Bounder had done all that he could do and unless one of the widows came out to do the fixing, that was all they could hope for at the moment.

        Bilbo hoped very much that they would not need a widow to come out to fix the problem. He hoped that there would be no problem at all, even if the doorway was found. But they could not rely on hope, not right now when things were changing faster than any of them could have anticipated.

        “Bilbo?”

      His cousin's voice made Bilbo's breath come a touch easier. If Fortinbras was here then the widows had deemed it safe enough for the Thain to come. “I'm here,” he said as Fortinbras stepped out of the darkness of the tunnels of the in between. “They are down below us.”

        “So I heard,” Fortinbras had a twist of flowers behind his right ear. Bilbo thought they might be gladiolas, their petals a mix of white and blue. The small flower gardens that had sprung up about the mountain, despite the season, had been another change, one brought on by the widows themselves. “Have they seen any of us?”

        “No,” Bilbo shared a relieved look with his cousin as they turned to look down the mountainside. “Do you think they will come up this way?”

        “And find the door?” Fortinbras frowned at that. He glanced at the now-hidden door and shook his head. “The Bounders have been practicing their craft since word went out. I've not seen their work take shape like this ever before. If we're not careful they'll make half the mountain vanish and bamboozle the dwarves right out of their home.”

        Bilbo ran a hand down his face at that, trying not to laugh at the thought. As more and more of the Old Gifts were being used freely – and exuberantly – many answers to old questions were being found. Answers to questions like, why in the world did Outsiders find the Shire so confusing to navigate? As it turned out, their Old Gifts – namely those of the Bounders – had much to explain for that.

        When their people had come to the Shire, they still practiced the old arts, even if more and more of the knowledge of just what they were – and what they could do – was being lost each with each new generation. When the Shire had been claimed, the Bounders had gone out and marked the edges of their lands in the same runes and sigils that their people had used on their paths through the wildernesses of the east and beyond. Those runes and sigils had done much to keep their people safe through their long walks from camp to camp, along with hiding their wild gardens along the way. When those same protections had been put up throughout the Shire they had done the same work as those had that had come before...if a bit more potent, considering that their people now lived in that land the whole year round. From what had been told to them now, since their magics had been fading, more and more Outsiders were finding their way into the Shire and navigating it with more ease. But now that their magic was back, as strong as it was when their people were first created, they had to be very careful with how and where their Bounders placed their sigils now.

        A hobbit lad came running up to Fortinbras and whispered something in his ear. Fortinbras nodded and the lad ran off, just as fast. “The Fixers have finished with the hallway,” his cousin said, a distracted frown still on his face. “The Bounders have made the entrance to it vanish, or so it is being reported. We'll have to check on it later.”

        “The entire hallway?” Bilbo had to ask.

        “The entire hallway,” Fortinbras nodded. A muscle jumped in his cheek. “I don't like some of those wizards, Bilbo. They make my teeth itch. I won't have anyone finding our hallway if I can help it.”

        Bilbo pressed his lips together but could not argue his cousin's point. Aside from Gandalf – and Radagast to some degree – Bilbo did not like the other wizards either. “Have the Bounders come back from the treasury yet?”

        “They are on their way,” Fortinbras said. “I would make that whole area vanish if I could get away with it.”

        Bilbo shared a look with his cousin, agreeing wholeheartedly with him. Ever since he had laid eyes on the area where the Arkenstone had been found and the Ring destroyed, his dreams had been strange, full of blue fire and a hissing voice that would spiral up into screams as the Ring bounced off that lake of fire, spinning and spinning, before it fell into the liquid metal and was consumed. Bilbo would jerk awake each night with that strange, hissing scream filling his ears, but sometimes that same scream would be echoed by another, a deeper voice full that was terrible in its rage and fury. Bilbo did not know what those dreams meant and had yet to go to a widow about them, hoping they were just products of his exhaustion and stress.

        As for the treasury itself, the widows had decreed that the dragon was not one of the broken things their people had to fix, that in fact all of their people had to stay away from that carcass, on pain of Banishment. It had been generations since such a punishment as that had been enacted and no one wished to see just what a Banishment could mean with their Old Gifts returned to their full strength once more. As for the treasury itself, the area where the Ring had been destroyed was too far in the open – and too closely watched – for their people to work on at the moment. Nori's boys had not left the area once, stretched thin between their shifts in the throne room and in the treasury but all of them seemed determined to hold their posts. Fortinbras had added their own people to watch over both areas, along with Nori's lads, but all of their people were inside the in between and could do little to help the dwarves, should something happen.

        Bilbo crossed his fingers and looked to the north. Nothing had better happen.

        A distant shout had Bilbo looking back towards the south, where the gardens were spread out over the hillside. He shared a glance with Fortinbras but it was Bilbo alone who stayed inside the in between and crept towards the sounds of heavy boots tromping over the earth. Bilbo spotted a few Bounders also near, all of them with twists of plants either tucked behind their ear or settled on their head like a wedding crown.

        Bilbo got as close to the group of dwarves, men, and elves as he dared and then laid flat on his belly on a large rock that overlooked the missing crowd. He spotted Thorin and Dwalin in the press of bodies and bit down on his lower lip, an ache spreading through his chest at the sight of them. But he stayed still, not wanting to risk all of his people's safety until all the mess of mysteries surrounding them all was sorted through. So with the setting winter sun peeking out through the clouds and warming his back, even as a gust of wind howled over the ridgeline, Bilbo pressed himself to the rock and strained his ears to hear just what was being said down below.

        And if, perhaps, his attention was more for Thorin and Dwalin? Well. That was for Bilbo alone to know.

 

Chapter 23: vines and vows

Chapter Text

 

       Thorin turned in a slow circle, picking out plant after plant that had no right being on Erebor's hillsides. There stood a thick, leafy green that Thorin had only seen in the markets of the west, sometimes sold in the colonies of the Blue Mountains, though few of his people ever ate such fare. There was a thick, ferny edge of a plant the hobbits had called asparagus, that Thorin had tried once and never again. Beyond those were the fruit trees, tucked in snug against the warm earth of Erebor's sides, tall and bare of leaves, but alive and healthy. There should have been no possible way for such fruit trees to even exist at such an altitude and yet there they were. An impossibility made real.

       “Thorin,” Gandalf's voice was soft, just for his ears alone. Thorin turned to see the wizard standing behind him, his face lined and eyes sad. “Did you order all of these to be planted here?”

       Thorin shook his head at that. “I am surprised as you to find them here.” He looked beyond the wizard to see the rest of those who had been in the meal tent with him come closer. “Some of these I have seen no where else except...”

       “The Shire.” A deep sorrow had settled onto Gandalf's face. “Yes.”

       Movement from the corner of his eyes had Thorin turning to see Maedhros stepping up next to them. The elf had a deep frown on his face as he turned in a slow circle. “What is it?” Thorin asked him. “Is there something wrong?”

       Maedhros did not answer for a long moment. Then he shook his head, but his gaze was still on the gardens about them. “There is nothing wrong.”

       Thorin looked to Gandalf but the wizard had moved forward, his staff parting the plants in front of him with gentle care. “You seem concerned,” he said as he looked back at Maedhros.

       The elf paused again, his gaze tracking something only he seemed to see. Thorin tried to follow that gaze but all he could see were the rocks on the hillside above them, shading into shadow as the last of the sun slipped over the western horizon. According to old records there should have been another door into the mountain somewhere above them. Thorin had seen the brittle plans himself when Balin and Ori had pulled them out of the royal library that they had unearthed a few days prior. Ori had all but made his bed in the room, persuaded by Dori to at least come out of the dust at times for meals and a bath.

       “It has been a long time since I have been on the side of a mountain and felt like this,” Maedhros said with a strange twist to his mouth that Thorin could not quite read.

       Thorin thought back to his lessons as a child, to the facts and figures all those of the line of Durin were forced to memorize. “I thought you once had a fortress upon a hill of your own in Beleriand,” he said, glancing up at the elf. “Surely it was not so different than this?”

       Maedhros' faint smile did not fade. “Himring was the largest hill in the area that Maglor and I claimed as our lands in Beleriand,” he said as Galadriel came to his side. The lady was staring around in wonder at the gardens and paused at Maedhros' words. “Ever-cold it was named and it was true to its naming.” A wider smile lit his face. “Fingon hated it.”

       “He would have,” Galadriel said with her own smile. The cousins looked at each other and their expressions tilted a bit towards sorrow before evening out. “Fingon always did love the warmth.”

       “He did and still does,” Maedhros said.

       “You have seen him, then?” Galadriel's eyebrows went up.

       “I have,” Maedhros' smile dimmed just a bit. “He refuses to leave the Halls, much to his father's ire, though.”

       “Why does he refuse to leave?”

       Maedhros' smile fell away at that. “I do not know.”

       “Perhaps it is best that all who were slain in Arda stayed in the Halls until the Healing of the world,” a new voice said. Thorin felt his jaw go tense at the sound of Saruman's voice. Galadriel's smile vanished and Maedhros looked away so that all Thorin could see of his face was the line of his cheek. Saruman appeared with both blue wizards at his side, the three of them picking their unsteady way through the brush. They were not very good at it. Thorin had to fight down the urge to smirk at the way all of their robes kept catching on every twig and rock in the area.

       “That decision is not yours to make, Saruman,” Eönwë said as he appeared behind the wizards. Saruman and the blue wizards stopped in their attempts to force their way through the brush and bowed to the herald of Manwë. Thorin had noted that every time the wizards met with Eönwë they bowed low, a display of subservience that even Eönwë seemed to find odd if Thorin was any judge of the spirit's frown at the trio of wizards.

       “My apologies,” Saruman said with another bow. There was a displeased slant to his mouth when he rose. “I only meant to point out that the Halls have many purposes for the Firstborn and allowing them to leave too soon could be a detriment to them in the long run.”

       Eönwë's frown eased as he nodded at Saruman's words. “A wise thought and kind,” he said. “That is the purpose of Námo's Halls and he attends to those inside them with utmost care. You do not need to worry for them, Saruman.”

       “As you say,” Saruman said as he planted his staff in front of him. He frowned as he glanced about. “I thought such gardens were how the dwarven peoples fed themselves in their own nations.”

       Thorin blinked at that. “I did not know you were such a scholar of my people,” he said.

       Saruman shook his head. “I am not,” he admitted. “But I have read much and seen much of this world,” a faint smile slid across his face. Thorin felt a shiver go down his back and did not know why. “I have had few interactions with your kind, King Thorin, and only in the past Ages. They were brief, at best.”

       Thorin tried to think back to when Saruman could have ever had contact with his kin. Their records in Erebor only ever spoke of Tharkûn – Gandalf – and none other, but there were large gaps of their history missing since their flight from Khazad-dûm. Whatever he could have said in response to Saruman was cut off by ruckus coming from behind them. Thorin turned to see Dáin and his two favored guards forcing their way past Dwalin's own people, with dark expressions on their faces. Thorin fought down the urge to curse. Dáin was the last dwarf he wished to see in this place.

       “Cousin,” he said before Dáin could say a word.

       “Do not call me that now,” Dáin was out of breath as he came to a stop a handful of steps away from Thorin. Thorin noted with alarm that Dáin had tremors running through him, causing his hands to shake and even his head to tick back and forth. “You know what you did!” Dáin continued before Thorin could take a step towards him.

       “Another fight between your kinsmen, King Thorin?” Saruman said from the side. “How shocking.”

       “Saruman!” Gandalf snapped at the other wizard. “Enough!”

       Saruman's nose went up in the air. The two blue wizards were tucked tight against his sides, both of them glowering back at Gandalf. Thorin saw Galadriel frown at them, a darker look than he had ever seen on her face before, even when she had been staring at Maedhros when he had first appeared. But his attention was brought back to Dáin as his cousin stomped forward, pushing into Thorin's space.

       “You,” Dáin growled, his finger shaking as it pointed at Thorin's nose. “Such gardens are not done by our people,” his voice shook. “It is the work of something else, something that should be torn out at the roots and burned in the depths of the mountain!”

       Thorin grabbed for his wrist, holding Dáin in place as Thorin took a step towards him. “That is not your decision to make,” he growled back at his cousin. “These gardens are a gift. I will not touch them.”

       “A gift? Have you lost your mind? They are a curse! A sign of –”

       “A sign of what?” Thorin stepped forward, forcing Dáin back. “A sign of what, Dáin!”

       “A sign of the thief! That little weasel and all his people,” Dáin seethed, setting his feet and pushing back against Thorin's hold. “The world has been wiped clean of them and yet you would welcome even a hint of them in your lands! It is obscene!”

       “You are obscene!” Thorin drew back and hit his cousin in the face before he could stop himself. Dáin's guards surged forward but Dwalin and Nori had them on the ground with their arms behind their backs before they could draw any weapons. Thorin stood over Dáin and heard his blood rushing in his ears. Dáin was covered in shadows cast by the stones above them, his eyes glinting in the last rays of light that lingered in the twilight.

       “The hobbits of the Shire – no,” Thorin stopped himself, his chest heaving. “All hobbits are named dwarf-friends of Erebor by my decree. Erebor is their home now, since the Shire is gone and they have no where else left to call their own. This land is as much theirs as it is ours, from now and until the healing of the world and beyond. Where the people of Erebor make their home, the ones known as hobbits will always be welcome. I swear this now before our Maker myself.” Thorin laid open his palm and drew a dagger, slicing a clean line against his skin. The blood welled dark and ruby red, spilling off his hand to drip to the ground. For a moment it felt like a deep bell had gone off in Thorin's bones, causing shivers to run down his spine.

       For a long moment silence reigned. Dáin stared up at him, eyes wide and disbelieving. Then a snarl curled his lips as he surged to his feet, hands curling into fists at his sides. “You are mad,” he said, voice low and shaking. “To think you would allow your people to be brought low with you...you are no king. You do not deserve to wear the crown of Durin. You should have stayed lost in the dark!” Dáin spat at Thorin's feet, causing a cry to go up among Thorin's people.

       “I was returned to our people from the depths of the mountain, in front of our holy people and yourself,” Thorin snarled back. “A gift that was given in part by the very one you keep insulting! Bilbo saved me and nothing you can say or do will change that.”

       “That thief is long dead, killed by your own hand,” Dáin spat back. “You dropped him from the gates of Erebor like he deserved and now you think he would save you? No,” Dáin shook his head. “No, whatever came out of the dark to steal you from the depths of the mountain is some sort of evil spirit, some sort of madness brought about by the calamity.”

       Hearing Dáin throw Bilbo's death in Thorin's face made a sharp ache spear through Thorin's chest. “You do not get to say such things to me,” he ground out.

       “I will say such things,” Dáin returned. “That little ferret is dead, dead and gone and good riddance! It is you who should kneel before our Maker and ask forgiveness for allowing dark spirits to enter my – to enter Erebor and desecrate it so!”

       “You shut your mouth! Bilbo is a hero of Erebor! He will always be a hero of Erebor! Nothing you say or do can change that!”

       Rage twisted Dáin's face into a mask that Thorin could almost not recognize. Thorin saw the dagger a second too late, flashing out from Dáin's side and heading straight for Thorin's gut. There was no way for Thorin to avoid a blow from so close a distance. Any block he could have made would have cut deep into his arm or hand, potentially maiming him. The dwarves Nori and Dwalin had pinned gave a great roar, surging up and out of the holds on them with a surprising strength that knocked both Dwalin and Nori back. They, too, were armed, the thin daggers strange in their meaty hands. Thorin had never known their Iron Hills people to use such weapons before. That was the fleeting thought that went through his mind as Thorin tried to twist out of Dáin's deadly strike. Even as he tried Thorin knew that he would not be able to miss a potentially killing blow from his cousin.

       But before those thin knives could find their targets a power moved over the hillside. It crackled over them all and Thorin should have flinched from it, like the elves and the men did, but for a moment...for a moment it felt like sitting in front of Bilbo's hearth in Bag End, smoking his pipe and watching the flames dim to coals on the grate. It felt like the warmth of the sun while they rode out of the Shire, their hopes high as their Quest began. It felt like the press of Bilbo's palm against his as they fell into the heart of the mountain.

       Then Dáin was jerked away before his blade could touch Thorin's side. Vines made up of long, twisted leaves that had a pale green edge and a darker emerald center wrapped around Dáin and pulled him away, swarming over his body to pin him – and his weapon – to the ground. The same was done to both of Dáin's guards, their legs pulled from under them as they were covered in those strange vines. All Thorin could do was stare as Dáin thrashed on the ground before him, foam coating the corners of his mouth.

       “Thorin!”

       He turned at the sound of Dwalin's panicked shout. “I'm fine,” he said as Dwalin reached him. There were thin cuts along Dwalin's arms and hands, rough, ragged things that made Thorin frown. “What is this?” He reached for Dwalin, taking his hands in his own.

       “I'm fine, just scratches,” Dwalin shook his head, pulling his hands free. He took Thorin by the shoulders and looked him up and down. “Did he wound you? Thorin?”

       “I am fine,” Thorin said, feeling strangely faint. There was an odd ringing in his ears. He thought it was in his head until the others around him began to wince and hold their hands up to their ears, trying to cover them. Thorin looked up and around, trying to place the sound. There was no obvious source for it. Just a ringing, almost like the aftermath of lightning, like –

       Movement caught Thorin's eye. He turned to see Eönwë step forward, his eyes glowing bright blue in the fading twilight. He followed Eönwë's gaze to see a strange arc flaring above them, the same bright blue as the Maia's eyes. As he watched that cerulean arc crackled above them, the ringing growing loud enough to make Thorin think of Erebor's smithies in full force, before that arc snapped above them, washing the entire area with a wave of iridescent light. Thorin felt Dwalin's hands grab him but that strange power did not hurt him. It felt...it felt warm, like...

       Thorin closed his eyes for a long moment, breathing through the grief that never fully left him. “Bilbo,” he murmured.

       “Thorin,” Gandalf said, far closer than Thorin remembered the wizard being. He opened his eyes to see Gandalf standing near them, his eyes dark as he stared down at Dáin and the other two dwarves that had been subdued by those strange vines. “Do you know what this is?”

       Thorin frowned at him, looking down at Dáin but his cousin had passed out at some point, as had the other two. “I had no hand in this,” he said. “Dwarves do not have such powers.”

       “Not...” Gandalf made a strange motion with one hand that Thorin could not understand. “The vines,” he said after a moment. “I have never seen their like.”

       “They are snake grass,” another voice said. Thorin turned to see Pallando join Gandalf where they were staring down at Dáin and the others.

       “Snake grass?” Thorin looked between them.

       “Indeed,” Pallando stroked his chin. “An ominous sign.”

       “Ominous?” Maedhros said as he joined them. “I would not say so.”

       The blue wizard sniffed at him, nose turning up. “I have traveled to the far reaches of the world where such grass grows in abundance. I know it well.” Thorin glanced between the wizard and the elf, studying the way Maedhros had his hands clasped behind his back and his gaze lowered to where Dáin was laid out, half wrapped in those same strange vines. Of the other wizards there was no trace. Saruman and Alatar had vanished at some point. How strange. The elves were lingering, though, and a few of the men – namely the young Aragorn – stayed as well.

       “I know it as well,” Maedhros said. His gaze never lifted from the dwarves before him. “I heard it be called swordgrass,” he tilted his head to one side. “Long ago.”

       “Be that as it may –”

       “And nor was it an ominous sign,” Maedhros continued, speaking over the wizard as Eönwë joined the elf to stare down at the dwarves at their feet. “It was worn as twisted vines, much like these,” he nodded to where the vines had wrapped about Dáin, trapping his arms at his sides. In the distance Thorin could hear the calls of his people – mostly Alviss and the rest of their holy ones – as they made their way up the side of the mountain in the falling dark. “It was a symbol of protection, of strength, and of resilience. It is stronger than you know and was used, once, as a charm for good luck and purification.”

       Pallando folded his hands into his sleeves, his mouth pressed into a flat line. “Perhaps that was what it was known as in Beleriand, but I have known it for longer to be a sign of disease and deceit.”

       “Have you,” Maedhros said, soft.

       Thorin had to turn away then as Alviss and the other holy ones came bustling into the area. Thorin had to put his foot down as some of Dáin's other nobles tried to bully their way into taking Dáin from the holy one's possession, but with Óin's help – and with a few of the elven healers, namely Lord Elrond – they got Dáin and his two guards back down into camp and then into the depths of Erebor where Thorin knew Alviss and the others would keep Dáin safe, both from others and from himself. He left the elves and the others on the mountain as the last of the light slipped away in the west, turning the sky dark until the stars began to spark into life above them. By then Thorin was deep within the mountain, sitting with Dwalin and Nori as their Spymaster spoke of how Dáin's councilors had come to protest their taking of their king but Alviss and his holy ones had been the ones to shout them down in the end. Dáin's council had retreated...for now, but Thorin had to ask Nori to stretch his lads even thinner to watch over their cousins and make sure none of them were making darker plans that could ignite the whole encampment into arms. At least the rite planned for the full moon was soon, a handful of days until they could purify their kinsmen in the waters deep under Erebor.

       None of the dwarves saw the way Maedhros went to the gardens on the hillside again and again, sometimes pacing through the plants and the thin trails that might have been made from wild game or might not. Nor did they see the way Eönwë would sometimes join him, watching from afar as Maedhros looked over those spreading gardens, his own gaze lingering high against the mountainside, with a frown often on his face.

       And, bit by bit inside the mountain, the damage done to Erebor's grand halls began to disappear.

Chapter 24: bright waters bring truth

Chapter Text

 

         Far under the towering mountain of Erebor were deep, still pools of clear and cold water. The area was forever in darkness, where not even a single speck of light reached. In the distance Thorin could hear the trickle of a waterfall, where the still pools spilled over into some deeper cavern that his people had not yet found – and would not look for. For this place had been claimed as a holy site by their first king, where all the kings of Erebor would go on the full moon before the longest night of the year and allow what visions from their Maker to come. Thorin had been schooled in such knowledge by his own father but had never been to these sacred pools. That was a privilege for the king alone, along with their holy people.

         Thorin breathed in that cold air, feeling his skin prickle in the quiet. Behind him Dáin and his two guards that had been wrapped up in the vines from the mountainside struggled against their bonds, their mouths stuffed with rags when they had refused to stop shouting vile insults or spitting at those who came close. They had tried to remove the vines from Dáin and his people that first night when they had contained Dáin and his Iron Hills contingent in their own tents, but the vines themselves refused to budge and Thorin had not allowed anyone to cut through them. It felt...wrong to him to do so, so when he had explained himself to Alviss, their head holy one had agreed with Thorin's decision and left the dwarves tied up as they were.

         There had been quite the stir from the Iron Hills dwarves when Dáin and his guards had been taken into Erebor for safe keeping. Several of Dáin's councilors had tried to get their king back from Thorin but Alviss, as virtue of being the head of the holy ones in Erebor, had overruled them. It would take time for the Iron Hills holy ones to find a way to fight back against Alviss' own words – and much less to get to Erebor to do so – so there was no outright attempts at violence against Thorin's people to get Dáin back – for now. Thorin knew that it was only a matter of time before something caused the Iron Hills dwarves to revolt against Thorin's rule. It was his dearest hope that this rite would work and whatever strange evil was plaguing his cousin and his people would be washed clean.

         There were other issues that needed to be addressed once Thorin emerged from the waters. The men were getting restless, wanting to return back to their lands but had not yet had authority from their kings and leaders to do so. The Ranger Aragorn seemed to be a sticking point with Lord Ecthelion II, who had withdrawn his people into their own tents and was rarely seen outside of them. Nori had reported that Saruman had been seen going to and from Lord Ecthelion II's tents several times but none of Nori's lads had been able to get close enough to hear just what was being said.

         A muffled curse from behind him had Thorin looking over his shoulder. Dáin had wriggled onto his side, his eyes almost black in the dim light of the cavern as he glared at Thorin. It also looked as though his cousin was attempting to chew through the gag in his mouth.

         “My lord,” Alviss said as he appeared from the dark shadows that existed outside the small circle of light that Thorin stood in. The holy one was dressed in a plain white robe, his gray-streaked beard reaching his waist. Alviss has been one of the holy people in Erebor that Thorin remembered from before the Calamity came. “It is time.”

         Thorin drew in a slow breath and nodded. He ignored Dáin's increased attempts at shouting through his gag and allowed Alviss to help him out of the simple robe he had been given when he had been brought down to this place. The path to the waters of reflection started in the heart of the mountain, in the deepest parts of the central cavern where the holy ones made their home. It had made Thorin shudder a little to go back down to the place where he had been pushed off into the heart of the mountain. Dwalin had come with him to that point, pale and withdrawn, and holding onto Thorin's hand with a strength that made Thorin's fingers ache.

         They had been led into a different area that Thorin had never been into before once they had reached the lowest tier. Alviss had brought them into a small, bare chamber where Thorin had been given the simple white robe to wear. Dwalin had helped Thorin out of his clothes, holding onto Thorin tight for a long moment once Thorin was dressed and Alviss was waiting for him at the door. None of their kings had ever been lost to the waters in any of their reigns in Erebor, but there were always stories of those who had tried to visit those same pools and who had never returned. Thorin was of the mind that those who had tried to go to the pools had been taken by the Spymasters of Erebor rather than the waters themselves but the rumors never faded away about them, even during their long exile. Thorin did not know why Dwalin was so worried about Thorin going into the pools but his partner would not speak of it and Thorin did not wish to push the topic, not now. Not when everything was still fraught and they had more immediate concerns that both of them had to focus on.

         Later, Thorin had promised himself, when all of the mysteries that were swirling about their mountain had finally been solved, he would press Dwalin on this strange fear. Until then they had to hold each other close and let go when they must.

         Thorin had to leave Dwalin in that bare chamber. He knew Dwalin would not leave until Thorin returned once more, pacing that small space back and forth the entire time. Thorin had followed Alviss through the narrow door that had been carved out of the mountain's bones and down a steep set of stairs cut into the rock. The further down they went the cooler the air got, until Thorin could feel it down to his bones. And still further down they went, lower than even some of the mines in the mountain, far below until the air began to smell like water and Thorin could hear the tinkling sound of a waterfall.

         Dáin had already been in the chamber when Thorin and Alviss had arrived. Dáin had been unconscious – or asleep – as Thorin stood over his body, staring down at the cousin he had grown up with. Then Alviss and a few other of their holy people had come with candles and lit crystals that began to illuminate the immediate area and Dáin had woken – as had his mouth. It hadn't been long before Alviss had gagged him quiet.

         Thorin let the robe fall, standing naked as the day he was born in the flickering light of the candles and crystals around them. He fought down a shiver as a sliver of wind brushed past him. He heard the sound of the holy ones stepping into the chamber and as one he heard them let out a low thrummmm that he could feel in the marrow of his bones. The sound filled the chamber, making Thorin's ears ache from the intensity of it all. Thorin closed his eyes as he listened to the rising song of his people, the ancient words spilling over each other in a type of round chant that made his head spin. Thorin opened his eyes when he was ready, feeling it in his chest as he stepped forward into the waters, one step, two –

         And then there was nothing under his feet at all. Thorin plunged into the depths with a single, desperate breath filling his lungs and let the waters take him.

         There had been no preparations for this particular rite. Alviss had said that Thorin would learn what he must in the waters or he would not learn at all. Thorin's father had never faced the waters, since his kingship of their people came to him when they were exiled. Thorin had never heard his grandfather speak of the rite at all. Thorin had learned of it during his studies as heir to the throne but nothing of significance had ever been said about the rite. Just that a new king would come to the waters on the full moon before the longest night of the year to receive the blessings of the waters and that was all.

         Thorin had read in the histories of their people of rites going back almost to their very beginning. It was said after Durin I woke from the sleep of their Maker that he had gone into the bones of their first kingdom and found great still pools of water there. It was from Durin I that most of their rites – and especially the blessing of the waters – came. It was said that all of the first fathers of their people went through the same rites, that they had all found the same still pools under their mountains and each of them received the blessing of the waters when they first took the throne of their peoples. Thorin had not quite believed such tales in his youth, thinking that perhaps these strange pools had been creations of their ancestors, that perhaps only Durin I was the one to find such a vast reservoir of water under his mountain but now...now Thorin wondered.

         The shock of the frigid water felt like a slap to the face. Thorin kicked his feet, an instinctual response, but it still felt like he was falling in the water, deeper and deeper until even the faint light of the candles and crystals on the shore above faded away and Thorin was left in complete darkness, cold, naked, and alone.

         Thorin's lungs began to ache with the need to breathe far quicker than he had anticipated. He kicked his feet harder but the darkness did not change. In fact it felt like he was falling faster, somehow, as if some strange power had taken him in its grasp and was drawing him down, down, down into the depths. For a wild moment Thorin reached out with a hand, feeling the drag of water against his palm, the very same palm that Bilbo had caught in their wild fall into the heart of the mountain. But unlike then all Thorin was left with was the swirl of that freezing water sweeping past him and nothing more. Thorin was alone. There would be no Bilbo to catch him, now.

         Thorin's head began to pound with the need to draw in a lungful of air. He began to thrash against that cold blackness, kicking his feet and sweeping his arms through the current, trying to find some purchase against the pull of that water that was dragging him down. There was nothing he could find. No outcropping of rock, no stray tree limb in the water to slow his descent. Bubbles escaped his mouth as Thorin fought against the instinct to breathe, even as tiny dots of light began to bloom in front of his eyes.

         Thorin's chest ached. He stopped thrashing, allowing him limbs to go limp in the water. Down, down, down he went, as tiny bubbles began to escape his lips faster and faster. He wanted to breathe. He wanted to draw in a breath, even if it was full of smoke and ash and dragon-stink. He wanted Dwalin. He wanted Bilbo. He wanted to see his family again. He wanted to see his Company again. He wanted to see the sun. He wanted to fall asleep with Dwalin and Bilbo on the hillsides of Erebor, surrounded by impossible plants in impossible gardens in an impossible dream.

         The blooming lights grew brighter and brighter. Thorin blinked against the dark waters, realizing with a kind of detached interest that the lights were not coming from himself, but were in the waters with him.

         The pull of the waters eased. It felt like he was hanging suspended in darkness, with no up or down, just darkness everywhere about him, save for the tiny bursts of light that were growing closer and closer. In that moment Thorin also felt something brush past him, something soft, almost like strands of silk, brushing his face, his arms, his chest.

         It no longer hurt to hold his breath. Thorin did not know why. Those silky strands began to wind about him, under his knees, across his chest, about his arms. It felt like a cocoon, wrapping tighter and tighter about him. The urge to breathe had left him. No more bubbles escaped his mouth. All his fears ebbed away, leaving him in a strange kind of peace as he hung in the waters, waiting for what would come.

         Brighter and brighter those bursts of light came. Bright blue, like the flowers Thorin had seen in the Shire, like the color of Bilbo and Dwalin's eyes. More bursts came, crimson like the dragonfire that had spilled over the sides of Erebor during the awful night that had changed all their lives forever. But it was also the same ruby red of the coals in Bilbo's beloved Bag End, warm and so inviting. Thorin wished he was there now, that they had never come on the Quest though he could not deny his people's happiness at the retaking of their home. Then came the bright bursts of iridescent lights, like the tiny flashes Thorin had seen in Rivendell during their stay. He and Dwalin had seen Bilbo there, staring up at one of those massive waterfalls, the tiny droplets glittering in his hair like a crown of diamonds.

         It took Thorin a long moment to realize that he was no longer alone in the water. A shadow was weaving in and out of those bright bursts of light, almost dancing with them. The strange strands that had wrapped around him shifted and moved as that shadow drew closer and closer. The strands did not hurt as they moved, rather it felt more like an embrace, a kindness or reassurance instead of confinement. All Thorin could do was watch as that strange shadow came closer and closer, until he could start to make out details of the creature that was coming right for him.

         At first the creature seemed to be a pale, twisting figure, but as Thorin watched, the long, flowing streaks turned into graceful limbs and the flick of trailing, iridescent fins. Closer and closer it came until Thorin could tell that it was no creature at all, but rather a woman of some type, the pearls about her neck trailing down across her chest to hide her nakedness. Gems glittered in her hair, even as the same iridescent scales that were on her fins framed her eyes. Her hair flowed out around her like a pale cloud, spreading out into the waters around her...

         And, Thorin realized, to him as well.

         It was her hair that had stopped his descent into the darkness. It was her hair that held him close, like a mother to a child.

         All Thorin could do was watch as the woman – spirit? vision? – spiraled closer and closer until she floated right in front of him. She was far larger than Thorin first thought, taller than even Lord Maedhros and Lord Glorfindel. All around her the tiny bursts of light were growing in size and frequency, looking a little like the fireworks that Gandalf was so known for. Her eyes, he also realized, were full of lights as well, much like the blooms of color that were surrounding them...but different, richer. Stronger. Lights that reminded Thorin of Bilbo the last time he had seen him, falling through the mountain together into the darkness below.

         The woman – spirit? Maia? – hovered in front of him, a slow smile spreading across her face. It made a fission of fear slide down his spine but there was no where for Thorin to run. No way to hide. He was trapped in this spirit's grasp. Whatever she decided was to be his fate.

         The spirit's smile grew. With one large hand she reached out and covered Thorin's eyes. All went dark. All was still. But in that darkness Thorin began to see...flickers. Flickers that became images. That became –

         His Company running through the halls of Erebor, herding the dragon towards the smithies and trying to kill the dragon there.

         Smaug escaping the mountain and turning Lake-town to ash. It was Bard who fired the great iron arrow that pierced Smaug's side and killed the dragon with a single blow.

         The Battle of Five Armies swept across the plains before Erebor, already broken and blackened by the dragon's wrath. Thorin saw Dáin's arrival, his Company's eruption from the gate, he saw Bilbo in the melee, still alive and fighting and not a broken body before the great gates of Erebor.

         Thorin was screaming as he saw Fíli hang from an orc's blade before he was dropped like trash to the ground below.

         He saw Kíli fall trying to defend his elf from Bolg, cutting his way through countless orcs before being struck down and killed as he tried to protect the one he loved.

         Thorin saw himself face Azog on that ice-covered river. He heard Dwalin's scream. He saw Bilbo's anguish as Thorin fell to that pale orc's final strike. He saw himself die in their arms.

         Thorin saw Bilbo leave Erebor and never return. He saw Bilbo grow old but untouched by age in the Shire. He saw Bilbo grow strange and fey. He saw the way the Ring began to wind shadows about Bilbo's heart. He saw how Bilbo had to be forced to give up the Ring. He saw how the world grew darker and darker, as the magic of the elves and dwarves and hobbits began to fade.

         Thorin saw Bilbo, old and frail, die as the world turned black around him and the powers of Mordor exploded across the world.

         Then that hand was lifted and all Thorin could see was the bright flashes of light about him. He saw Bilbo as he came streaking out of the darkness to save Thorin. He saw the spreading gardens over Erebor's hillsides. He saw the power of the elves growing, a Light that pushed back against the shadows coiled about Erebor like great snakes. He saw figures flitting across Erebor's walls, not the same shadows that touched Thorin's heart with ice, but something far more familiar, if impossible.

         Thorin's eyes cleared to see that same spirit in front of him, the Lights in her eyes blazing as she watched Thorin's every move. He did not know what she was looking for. He did not know if this was some sort of test. But, finally, that spirit began to smile, showing rows of razor-sharp teeth, all gleaming like pearls in the light that began to surround them.

         The spirit raised her cupped hands between them. Thorin felt the strands that had held him in place coil close for a moment and then release, leaving him floating free before that spirit. He looked down at her cupped hands and felt his heart thump hard in his chest. For there in her hands was a gem much like the Arkenstone, glittering with blue and turquoise jewel tones in the dark water. The spirit held out the Silmaril, her long, webbed fingers spreading wide. Thorin caught the jewel as it tumbled from her grasp, his clumsy, calloused fingers wrapping tight about it. The gem was warm in his palms, his skin tingling like it had after Bilbo had taken his hand during their fall.

         Thorin looked up at the spirit to find her still smiling at him, the scales on her face glittering in the dying bursts of light about them. She darted forward, too fast for Thorin to flinch away, her cool lips pressing against his cheek, there and gone. She pulled back and winked at him before swirling about Thorin, faster and faster. The water about him began to churn, turning him around and around, making his head spin. It was all he could do to hold onto the Silmaril, clutching it close to his chest. His lungs began to ache again, his temples throbbing with the need to breathe. He closed his eyes tight, trying to kick his feet, trying to fight for the surface, trying to live with every last bit of his resolve left in his body.

         Thorin emerged from the waters with great, gasping breaths. He sputtered out water as shouts filled his ears. He kicked and kicked against the waters until blood-hot hands landed on his chilled flesh, pulling him back to the stony shore.

         “My lord!” Alviss' voice filled his ears. Thorin coughed out more water, his chest and body aching as he fought to open his eyes. All was blurry at first, his eyes unable to focus as he got his knees under him. Hands put a thick cloak about his shoulders. Thorin blinked his eyes clear to see almost all of Erebor's holy ones surrounding him, some with soaked clothes and others with tears on their faces.

         “My lord,” Alviss said again. “My lord,” he repeated, kneeling before him. “You have returned to us yet again.”

         Thorin felt his throat work but no words came out. Instead he looked down at his cupped hands and let his fingers unfurl from the hard gem that he was clutching. The sparkling light of the Silmaril filled the darkness, turning the black pools cerulean and catching the crystals that were embedded in the walls of the cavern, making them glow almost as bright as the sun.

         A muffled shout caught his attention. Thorin saw Dáin wriggling on the ground, his face contorted with fury, eyes red and bloodshot. Thorin stumbled to his cousin's side, ignoring the cries of his holy ones as he brought the gem to Dáin's chest. Dáin's shouts rose to a fever pitch as Thorin placed the gem to Dáin's skin. As it touched him a great flash of light lit the cavern. Thorin could see after-images of it as he blinked. A pale blue fire swept over Dáin, crackling about his head and heart for a furious moment before Dáin's eyes rolled up and he went slack in his bonds.

         But it was not his cousin's sudden faint that stayed with Thorin as his holy ones rushed about him. It was not how that pale fire seemed to surge through the cavern and beyond that lingered in his mind. It was not even the wonder of the Silmaril that kept his attention as Thorin made his way back up the long, winding stairs with Alviss and into Dwalin's waiting arms.

         What stayed with Thorin, through the frantic meeting of his councilors that was called, through the news that all of the Iron Hills dwarves had fainted en mass, no...no, what stayed with Thorin was the sight of shadows lined up along the walls, too numerous to count, too small to be dwarves, surrounding him in that holy place when he brought the Silmaril to Dáin to cleanse him of whatever shadows were eating at his heart.

         Thorin was not sure how he knew, but he was sure that Bilbo – or Bilbo's people – had saved him in that chamber, helped save Dáin, had helped to save them all once more.

Chapter 25: recovery and reconnection

Chapter Text

 

        “Glad, I am, to see you safe and well, King Thorin,” Eönwë said from the doorway. Thorin looked up from the sheaf of papers spread out before him and nodded at the Maia. The herald of Manwë stepped into the room, taking one of the empty seats across from him as Thorin gestured to the chair. Eönwë sat back, his hands braced before him, his bright eyes gleaming in the light of the fire.

        The Silmaril sat on the table between them, glittering in the light.

        Thorin sat back in his own chair, every limb feeling heavy and aching. The climb back to the entry level of Erebor had sapped what was left of his strength but there had been no time to rest, no time to sleep. His own meeting with his councilors had dragged on until morning. Then there were the men who were almost up in arms with the rushing about that had gone on in the camps during the early morning hours as those from Erebor went to help their cousins in the Iron Hills tents, pulling them out of fires and away from sharp knifes that they had been previously tending or using. Thorin had heard Saruman's strident voice demanding answers from outside their gates but Thorin was not letting just anyone into his mountain. Not right now. Not with yet another Silmaril delivered into his possession.

        Thus was Eönwë asked to come as the morning light spilled over the sides of the mountain, to see with his own eyes the wonder that Thorin had plucked from the depths of their holy waters. And with Eönwë came...

        Thorin slid his gaze back to the door, where Maedhros stood frozen, his face pale and a bit drawn as he stared at the gem sitting on the table, casting blue and purple lights across the worn wood as the flames refracted against the Silmaril.

        Maedhros' lips moved but Thorin could not understand the whisper that left the elf as he took a step towards the table. Maedhros stared down at the Silmaril, the gleam of tears thick in his eyes but they did not fall. “I remember Maglor holding that gem,” Maedhros finally said. He did not look away from it for a moment. “Blue was always Maglor's favorite color. When we...when I had us steal the gems for the last time, he picked this gem to carry as his part of our father's legacy, and I the red shaded gem. I never thought I would see it again.”

        Thorin glanced down at the Silmaril and then back up at Maedhros. “Would you wish to hold it once more?”

        Maedhros flinched away from Thorin's words, one hand coming up – his right – as if warding off a blow. “No,” he rasped, shaking his head. “No, thank you. I do not.”

        Thorin looked back to Eönwë to find the Maia staring at Maedhros with a sad smile on his face. “It is not a test,” Eönwë said before Thorin could. Maedhros' shoulders came up about his ears. “If you do not with to touch it, then do not. But I would not have you keep yourself from the legacy of your father out of some misguided sense of punishment.”

        Maedhros' head hung then, his hands going limp at his sides. There was a long moment of quiet, broken only by the crackle of the logs on the hearth, the quiet popping of the wood as it broke down into coals that would be banked for the night. Thorin watched as Maedhros took in a stuttering breath, his fingers curling and relaxing once, twice, and then on the third repeat he reached out, the tips of his fingers hovering just over the gem.

        Thorin watched as Maedhros let his hand touch the surface of the Silmaril. The tears that had been threatening in the elf's eyes finally fell.

        “It does not hurt,” Maedhros whispered, his voice broken as he knelt next to the table. His fingers were still just barely touching the Silmaril, as if afraid to let go. “It does not burn. It is...sweet,” he blinked more tears free from his eyes. “It feels as it did when Father first made them and Mother would dance with him in their light.”

        It was Thorin's turn to close his eyes. He opened them to see Maedhros pull his hand away, some color returning to his cheeks. The elf dashed the back of his hands against his cheeks as he stood, settling into the chair next to Eönwë as Thorin caught sight of Balin poking his head in through the door.

        “Balin?” Thorin saw the way both Eönwë and Maedhros winced at the rasp of his voice. “Is there something wrong?”

        “No, laddie,” Balin, too, was tired enough that he did not mind his words when there were guests before them. “I just came to tell you that Lord Elrond has seen to Dáin and his people. They are well and settling into a healing sleep, now.”

        Thorin let out a relieved breath at the news. “Thank the Maker,” he rubbed a hand over his face. Balin let out a grunt as he was pushed from the door and Dwalin stalked inside. Thorin could not help but smile at his partner. Dwalin had not left his side for hours, not until duty made him, and Dwalin was forced to meet with the King's Guard as they dealt with Dáin's people and making sure they were all safe and protected. Dwalin did not spare either elf a glance as he sat in the seat next to Thorin, pushing their chairs as close together as he could, and pulling Thorin's hand to his, lacing their fingers together.

        “My lords,” Balin said as he glanced at the two lords sitting on the far side of the table. “I'll leave you to it, then,” he added, looking back at Thorin. Thorin gave him a nod and Balin gave him a tight-lipped smile before stepping out of the room and closing the door behind him as he went.

        Thorin let the silence settle for a moment before he broke it. “This gem is not shadowed, like the one set into the throne.” He saw Eönwë look at Maedhros, who frowned back at him. “Do you not see the difference?”

        “I do,” Maedhros said with a slow nod. He looked back to Thorin, his frown not easing an inch. “It...worries me.”

        “I am the same,” Thorin transferred his stare to the Silmaril. “I cannot tell you much of the rite I performed in the depths of my mountain, but I can tell you this. When I went into the waters I was to look for a sign from our Maker, the one you know as Aulë, the one who made our people and that we believe guides us to this day.” He saw Eönwë move forward in his seat from the corner of his eye but did not wait to see what the spirit would say. “But it was not Mahal that came to me in the depths. There was another spirit there, a female who wore pearls as clothes, and who had fins that glittered like gems. Her hair was spread throughout the waters. It was only by her grace that I survived...and it was from her that I was given this gift.”

        Thorin heard Eönwë draw in a sharp breath. He looked up to see Eönwë's lips press into a thin line before he sighed. “Uinen,” he said on that breath. “The one you describe would be Uinen, the Lady of the Seas.”

        “Uinen,” Thorin echoed. He leaned back in his chair. He curled his fingers tighter against Dwalin and felt his partner return the pressure.

        Eönwë nodded at that, gaze going distant. “She is the wife of Ossë and is much beloved of mariners. Little have I heard of her coming so deep into the waters of the land,” he shook his head. “But she is connected to all water, everywhere, much as Lord Ulmo is.”

        “Maglor once spoke of singing on the edge of the sea,” Maedhros said, his gaze still on the Silmaril. “He sang of his torment, of his regret, of...many things, or so he told us. Perhaps it was to the Lady that he gave his Silmaril, or perhaps she found it where he cast it into the waters in his despair. Maglor could not say for certain exactly what happened to his gem. Only that one day it was gone.”

        “Perhaps,” Eönwë said, his gaze sharpening as he looked back at Thorin. “But you say that you do not see a shadow upon it, as you do the other Silmaril?”

        “I do not,” Thorin said. He glanced at Maedhros and then back at the gem. It seemed to almost sparkle brighter in that moment, making Thorin think of the blue fire he had seen flash through the cavern when he had pressed the gem to Dáin's skin, to the shadows he had seen on the walls there. “I...” He did not know how to explain his suspicions. “When I named Bilbo as a dwarf-friend of Erebor, I also said that all the hobbits were welcome in our mountain, that Erebor would be their home, should they wish it, since theirs was gone.” He blinked away the stinging in his eyes. “I tell you this now, because I...I do not fear, so much, but almost hope, that the spirits of the hobbits, of Bilbo,” he had to stop and press his lips together for a moment. “I believe that they are here, in the mountain, and that these spirits have some part to play in the mysteries that surround us even now. Do you...” He looked up at Eönwë, “Can you feel them? Can you...see them?”

        Eönwë tilted his head to one side, a faint frown creasing his brows. “You believe they did something to the Silmaril?”

        Thorin hesitated, not quite sure how to explain what he had seen. “Gandalf once said to me that hobbits have...had a knack to fix things.” He swallowed. “Well, Gandalf did not say they fixed things, but situations. But...” Here he had to pause again. “I wonder if Gandalf was wrong about that.”

        “Gandalf said that hobbits...fix things?” Eönwë leaned forward at that. “In what manner? Did he say?”

        Thorin cast his mind back, trying to remember. To his surprise it was Dwalin who answered Eönwë first.

      “Gandalf said that he thought hobbits had been around since the First Age,” Dwalin's voice was rough with exhaustion. There were dark circles under his eyes that Thorin wished he could wash away. “He said that the hobbits once sang of a dark tower and trees of stone. I've been thinking about it.” Dwalin's gaze was locked onto their linked hands. “Gandalf said that hobbits would fix things. That they made their rules and oaths to keep themselves safe. What if...” He pressed his lips together and looked up at Thorin. “What if they were –”

        The door slammed open. Thorin found himself on his feet, Dwalin pushing in front of him as both Eönwë and Maedhros stepped in front of them, with Maedhros' hand resting on his sword. But it was no enemy at door but rather a young dwarf that Thorin recognized as one of Nori's lads.

        “M'lord,” the youth was tugging at the braids on either side of his head. “M'lord, King Dáin's woken up. Master Nori said to come get you at once when that happened.”

        “Balin was just here, saying that they had settled into a healing sleep,” Thorin said as he stepped out from around the table.

        “I don't know, m'lord, but King Dáin's awake and askin' for ya.”

        Thorin looked to Eönwë and Maedhros and sighed, running a hand over his face. “Forgive me,” he said to them. Then to Nori's lad he said, “Go tell Óin I will be there in a moment. Dáin can wait a few more minutes.”

        “Yes, m'lord!” And the lad was off, the beat of his boots loud in the hall.

        Thorin looked to Dwalin but his partner just shook his head. “It can wait,” he said. “Bilbo...” An echo of the grief that Thorin felt passed over Dwalin's face. “Bilbo and his people, where they came from, it doesn't matter. Not right now.”

        “I should see to Dáin,” Thorin said after studying Dwalin's expression for a long moment. He turned to Eönwë and Maedhros. “If we could pick this conversation up later, I would be much obliged.”

        “And the Silmaril?” Maedhros asked as the door opened again. Thorin could see Gandalf standing in front of it, blocking someone's entrance. Blocking...Saruman's entrance, Thorin noted after a second glance. Thank the Maker for Gandalf. “I do not mean to question your ability, but...it will be safe?”

        “Of course,” Thorin said, most of his attention still on the door. “It will be kept with that which we hold most dear.” He looked away to reach out and pick up the Silmaril, cupping it in his palms. Then he turned to Dwalin and held it out. “I think it should be with Bilbo's silk.”

        “What is this?” Saruman said as he somehow managed to push past Gandalf's guard. “You would store such a treasure as this with some sort of common silk?”

        “It is holy silk,” Dwalin straightened as Saruman paced around the table towards them. Thorin curled his fingers about the Silmaril, not wanting to hide it, exactly, but...he did not wish for Saruman to touch it, either.

        Saruman's mouth twisted as he came to a stop near the fireplace, the logs crackling to life a bit as he stood there. “First you refuse to move the Silmaril that is mounted above your throne like a hunting prize being put on display and now you would hide another Silmaril with some sort of holy cloth of your kind? Would that not be considering hording such important and sacred gems?”

        “I am not hording them,” Thorin said. He resisted the urge to pull the Silmaril to his chest. “There is no where safer than the throne room of Erebor or my own rooms in this mountain where this Silmaril will be kept. Both spaces are under guard at all times.”

        “Under guard,” Saruman repeated, one eyebrow lifting. “Are you so suspicious of us all, then?”

        Thorin let out a short breath through his nose. “First I am careless with the Silmarils, now I am suspicious. Which is it?”

        Saruman's eyes narrowed to slits, his lip curling. It was Gandalf, though, who stepped in front of the other wizard and gave him a look that Thorin had never seen Gandalf use before. Saruman sniffed, his nose going up yet again as he looked away. “I'm sure Saruman is as worried as the rest of us about the mysteries that continue to plague us all during this trying time,” Gandalf said, his gaze still on Saruman. The other wizard seemed to refuse to meet that steady gaze. “Some of us have even been guarding their own minds from those who have been long-time allies, even called friends.” That last part seemed particularly pointed.

        It made Saruman face Gandalf. “I am worried, yes,” the wizard said. His dark brows were pinched together as he drew himself up to his full height. “We have all seen a shadow working its way through our peoples here,” he said. “I am worried that Morgoth is attempting to divide us from within. I am worried that Morgoth or a follower of his is trying to use these holy gems against us, to turn us on each other. I am concerned that you would allow your mind to be open to any touch, Gandalf, right now. So yes, I have placed protections about my mind so that I might be clear headed as we face what might come!”

        That seemed to deflate Gandalf a bit. “I see,” the gray wizard said with a sigh. “Forgive me, old friend. I was...worried, when you would not open your mind to myself or Galadriel.”

        “Long have you known me, Gandalf the Grey,” Saruman rapped his staff against the ground and pointed a finger at Gandalf's chest. “Have I changed so much?”

        “You have changed more than you suspect, old friend,” Gandalf said. “Come. I know you worry for the Silmarils and for us all here in this place, but King Thorin will not allow anything to happen to the Silmarils and we, along with Eönwë and the others gathered here can protect ourselves. We will all protect this place until we can figure out just what Morgoth's plans with the Silmarils are.”

        The wizards stared at each other for a long, long moment. Thorin felt Dwalin put a broad palm to his back, pressing close. Thorin did not know why he wanted to – to flee from the room for a moment, clutching the Silmaril to his chest all the while. Was Saruman right, then? Were they – was he being manipulated by the gems now in his possession? Was he...was he going to –

        Then Saruman sighed, long and loud, his shoulders sagging as he seemed to lean on his staff for support. “Forgive me,” the wizard murmured, passing a hand over his eyes. “You are right, Gandalf. I am worried. Very worried.”

        “Come,” Gandalf said as he took Saruman's arm. “Let me take you to Lord Elrond so that he can look you over.”

        “No, thank you,” Saruman pulled away at that, shooting Gandalf a sharp look as he stood up straight. “I will retire to my tent for now. A good rest is all I need.”

        “But Saruman...” Gandalf trailed off as the other wizard left the room, his staff thumping against the floor like giant footfalls in his wake. Thorin caught sight of blue robes out in the hall and guessed that one or both of the blue wizards had come to Saruman to help him back to their set of tents on the far side of the encampment on Thorin's lawn. Gandalf let out a huff of his own as he stalked out after them.

        Thorin let out a breath he hadn't realized he was holding and looked down at the Silmaril still cupped his hands. “Perhaps Saruman is not wrong,” he said into the quiet that was left. “Perhaps I am too covetous of these gems?”

        “Thorin,” Dwalin said.

        Thorin looked to Eönwë and Maedhros. “Would it be better to give them up, then? To give the Silmarils for you to hold?”

        Eönwë and Maedhros shared a look Thorin could not read. It was Maedhros who answered him. “The very fact that you make this offer tells me that you are not being affected by any shadow or lingering curse on my father's gems. It would ease my own worry if they were kept in your possession, wherever you find it best to keep them, King Thorin. I truly believe you will keep them safe.”

        Thorin bowed his head at that. Dwalin's warmth was pressed against his side. “Thank you,” he said as he lifted his gaze. “I promise to keep them protected as best I can. They will be guarded at all times.”

        “That is all we can ask,” Maedhros said with a bow. “I know you have other matters calling for your attention. Might we speak later, then?”
“Of course.” Thorin watched as both Eönwë and Maedhros left the room. There were many things that they still needed to speak about – the shadow on the Silmaril in the throne room, as well as the lack of a shadow on the Silmaril in his hands, but that would have to wait. There were no answers for them at the moment and Thorin had Dáin and his people to look in on in the aftermath of whatever the Silmaril did to free them from whatever madness that was possessing them.

        “Perhaps the lack of a shadow on this Silmaril is to help with whatever is going on in the mountain,” Thorin said as he and Dwalin made their way back to their chambers. Thorin could not see Nori's lads in the shadows but the back of his neck prickled with the feeling of being watched. He had no doubt there were unseen guards in every hall.

        “Perhaps,” Dwalin said. They entered their rooms and Thorin made his way to the altar and the box that held all that was left of Bilbo there. Dwalin was the one to open it. On either side of the acorn found in Bilbo's pack was the remains of his pipe, broken in two when they found it in Bilbo's pack. On top of it all was the white silk that Thorin and Dwalin had used to soak up Bilbo's blood that they had been anointed with. The white silk seemed to glow in the light of the banked fire and the bloodstains were a strange ruby-red. They had never faded to the rust color that Thorin was more familiar with and no one knew why. Perhaps it was because of the holy silk. Perhaps it was because of Bilbo's spirit, physical in that moment when Bilbo was clearly gone. Thorin did not know the answer, nor did Alviss or any of their other holy ones, but Thorin was glad for it. It had made his chest ache to think that what was left of Bilbo would fade like other bloodstains, but with this new development it almost felt like they had a living piece of Bilbo with them at all times.

        Thorin set the Silmaril on top of the white silk, as gently as he could. He had expected the gem to sink into the silk but instead it seemed to almost float on top of it. Thorin stared at it for a long moment, the way the gem had gone dark inside the box and against the silk, but even then there were almost...almost like tiny bursts of lights that flickered in the heart of the gem.

        “Thorin?”

        He shook off the feeling and looked up at Dwalin. “I should see to Dáin,” he said. He laughed as Dwalin pulled a face. Sobering he glanced back at the Silmaril and then back at Dwalin. “Would you...stay here for the rest of the day?”

        “Thorin,” Dwalin's brows pulled together.

        “Please.” Thorin glanced at the altar and then back to Dwalin. “Just for today, until Nori can get a constant set of eyes on the hall and our rooms while you handle the guards that can be seen.” He pressed his lips together for a moment. “I admit I am...concerned that something will happen to it.”

        Dwalin's hand curled around Thorin's shoulder and he leaned into the touch. “You are not going to go mad again.” Dwalin gave him a small shake. “I will punch you right in the face if you do.”

        That startled a laugh out of Thorin. It felt rusty and odd in his mouth. He could not remember the last time he had laughed so loudly. It had to be well before...Thorin felt his smile slip but took a deep breath against the grief and reached up to squeeze Dwalin's wrist. “I will hold you to that,” he said. Then, “I should go. Dáin has waited long enough, I am sure.”

        “He can stand to wait longer,” Dwalin grumbled but let go after sweeping his thumb along Thorin's neck. “I will stay here,” he said when Thorin met his gaze. “I promise. I will not allow anyone in.”

        The relief that washed through Thorin was a surprise but he managed a smile for his partner and a nod. “I will return soon.”

        “Bring food!” Dwalin called after him as Thorin made his way back out through their rooms.

        “I will!” Thorin called back as he let the door close behind him. Another laugh left him, for a reason he could not name, but the second he was alone in the hall the lightness left him and the feeling of being watched was back. Thorin looked right and then left, scanning the empty hallway. To his right the hall ended in a wall of rubble they had not yet had time to dig out and clear away. Bofur had deemed the area structurally safe even with the damage, with an added bonus of having only one way in or out of the royal wing, making it even safer for Thorin and the others.

        To his left lay the only way in or out of the hall. Thorin looked down at the floor, where there was still a layer of dust in places. He could see where a path had been tread into it, clearing it down to the once-shiny marble that lined the hall. The dark stone had veins of gold running through it, just enough to catch the light of the torches that used to line the walls when Thorin was young. The walls were a gray marble, with dark veins of ore running through them instead of gold. Set above Thorin's head height were the glow-crystals that once used to light every hall and chamber in Erebor in its early years. Thorin did not know when they had begun to fail but by the time he was born none of them worked anymore.

        But, as Thorin was looking up at those crystals, one by one they began to spark to life. The crystals themselves were the size of Thorin's fist, formed into rectangular cut mountings by artisans long ago. They were a faded yellow, or so Thorin had thought, expecting the light cast from them to be the same. Instead a brilliant white light sparked from them, clear enough that it caught the gold veins in the floor below, even through the thick dust that had gathered at the edges where the wall met the floor. Up and down the hall the crystals sparked to life, chasing away the shadows that had long lingered. Thorin looked to his right once more, where the fall of rubble should have been and felt his feet freeze in place.

        Some of the rubble was gone.

        Thorin stepped back and opened the door to his rooms. “Dwalin!” He did not wait for his partner to call back before he turned to the right, walking a few careful steps down the hall.

        “Thorin? What is it – what in the world...” Dwalin said from behind him. “Thorin, stop. Do not go further.”

        “I will not,” Thorin stopped well shy of the fall of rubble. Before, the rubble had been a complete wall, floor to ceiling, full of stones and what looked like a partial collapse of an upper floor. Thorin had been leery at first of taking his old rooms so close to such a collapse but Bofur and Bifur had both agreed that all of the main support pillars for the rest of the royal wing were holding true. There was another suite of rooms to Thorin's right, where his sister Dís had once called home, but half of those rooms had been compromised and closed off. “We need Bofur and his crew here immediately.”

        “Yes,” Dwalin said. “I will go.”

        “No,” Thorin held up a hand, hearing the sound of Dwalin's boots pause. “No, just call for them. Do not leave our room, please.”

        “Thorin?”

        “The ceiling is repaired,” Thorin pointed up to the top of the pile of rubble. There, where the ceiling had caved in, was now an arched vault of wood. Not stone. “That is no dwarven work,” he said.

        He felt more than heard Dwalin come up behind him. “That cannot be,” Dwalin breathed.

        Thorin swallowed hard. “Yet it is.” They stared up at the same type of woodwork they had only seen in one place in all of Arda, an impossible piece of repair when those who had once crafted such works were gone. Thorin had seen such work only in Bag End, all those long months ago. “Call for Bofur but do not go beyond the door to our rooms.”

        “Thorin.”

        “I want to believe that this is a sign of Bilbo and his people,” Thorin turned his head to look at Dwalin from the corner of his eye. “But with the strangeness that is going through the mountain, with the shadow we have seen with our own eyes, I would rather us be safe than sorry when it comes to such strangeness happening here, so close to our rooms, to...” He jerked his head at their rooms and the gem that lay within.

        Dwalin closed his eyes for a moment before opened them with a nod. “I will call for Bofur now.”

        “Good.” He heard Dwalin's call and the rush of steps behind him. Thorin looked back to the hallway, unable to take his gaze from it. It was impossible. And yet...and yet if it was Bilbo, or his people, if their spirits were here, protecting them, how blessed were they? But if it was not Bilbo or his people, if it was something trying to pretend to be them instead...

        “Here I am...oh,” Bofur's cheerful call died out quick. Thorin stayed in place as Bofur joined his side, the two of them staring up at the repaired section of the ceiling. “Now that's not something you see everyday.”

        “No,” Thorin agreed. Together they stared up at the hall. “Can you assess it?”

        “That I can do,” Bofur said, his mustache twitching back and forth as he pulled on one of his braids. “It'll be better when we get the artisan clans back. I know my shafts and braces but hallways like this are for specialists.”

        “But you can do it.”

        “That I can,” Bofur nodded.

        “And...the wood?”

        At that Bofur let out a noisy sigh. He rubbed a fist over his mouth as his gaze tracked over the ceiling. “Bifur would be the best of us right now to look at it,” he finally said. “Not many of us these days work with wood but Bifur...he would be the best for now.”

        “Until the clans come,” Thorin said.

        “Until the clans come,” Bofur echoed. “We'll do as we can.”

        It was the best Thorin could hope for at the moment. Or else let one of the elves into his halls and that was not something he wanted to do just yet. He thought about summoning Gandalf to see this new impossibility but he hesitated on the impulse. Where Gandalf went the other wizards, save for Radagast, would go. They had finally located the wayward wizard only the day before in the wilds about Erebor, poking at the plants that were growing up out of the desolation that the dragon had brought on the area. Even the winter chill was not stopping the new plants from emerging through the dark earth.

        “Keep me appraised,” Thorin said as he finally turned to leave. Dáin would have to forgive him for the long wait.

        “Will do,” Bofur said as Thorin left him.

        Thorin passed Dwalin in the hall, where his partner was speaking with a pair of Nori's lads in hushed tones. Thorin noted the two King's Guard that joined him at the end of the hall. He also noted that the prickling feeling of being watched never left him as he made his way down to the level below the main entrance, where Bofur and his crew had cleared out an entire floor of old barracks for the Iron Hills dwarves to be placed in as they recovered from whatever had infected them all.

        Thorin heard Óin before he saw him. The old dwarf had damaged his ear horn to the point where they could not repair it anymore, much to Óin's displeasure. There were plans to replace the ear horn as soon as possible but with the mess going on in Thorin's mountain at the moment, such items would have to wait for the moment.

        “...and stay there!” Óin's shout was loud enough that Thorin heard him from the end of the hall. When Thorin made his way into Dáin's room his cousin was glaring back at Óin but still in his bed, arms crossed and a scowl drawing his brows together. “Ah, Thorin, there you are,” Óin said as he noticed Thorin's entrance. “Keep this idiot here while I go check on the others.” And with that Óin stomped from the room, grumbling not so quietly about idiots and fools all the while.

        “I'd forgotten what he was like in a strop,” Dáin said before Thorin could speak. The scowl had eased on Dáin's face but his arms were still folded tightly over his chest. Thorin also noted the way Dáin could not quite look at him. “He hasn't changed a bit.”

        “No, he has not,” Thorin said as he grabbed a chair and dragged it closer to Dáin's bedside. “I hope you can forgive the wait,” he said as he sat down. “How are you feeling?”

        A muscle ticked in Dáin's jaw as he looked away. His arms stayed folded over his chest. “Better,” his cousin said.

        “I am glad,” Thorin sat back in his chair.

        “I...” Dáin pressed his lips together for a moment, so tight they went white. Then, “I am sorry.”

        Thorin blinked at that. “What?”

        “I tried to kill you,” Dáin still would not look at him. “I don't...I do not know why.” At that his arms loosened from his chest. Dáin ran a hand down his face. He was far paler than Thorin liked to see. “I was...I do not remember much of the last few weeks,” he said as he looked down at his hands. “Everything feels...strange.”

        Thorin stared at his cousin, taking in the new lines on his face. “Strange, how?”

        Dáin sighed and rubbed at his face again. “Like...like I can see again.”

        “Like you can...see again?” Thorin repeated, frowning.

        Dáin nodded. “It felt like there was a – a shadow over my eyes.” He rubbed at them for a moment and then let his hands drop, blinking repeatedly. For the first time in weeks Thorin realized that he could see his cousin's blue eyes clearly. “Everything felt shadowed and...and dark. It felt like I was standing two feet behind myself at all times. I could hear words coming out of my mouth. I could see myself walking around and giving orders but it did not feel...it did not feel like me.” He shook his head. “I cannot explain it clearer than that.”

        Thorin let out a long breath, sagging back in his seat. “There has been more than one shadow seen here, these last few weeks,” he said.

        Dáin nodded, gaze going back to his hands. “I swear to you I did not order that dwarf to push you from the ledge.”

        Thorin leaned forward at that, putting a gentle hand on Dáin's arm. He hated that he could feel Dáin flinch from the contact. “I never thought that you did.”

        “You would be the only one,” Dáin said with a grunt. “How I acted...afterwards...I don't know why I said all those things. I don't know why I did all those things. I do not even know where we got those daggers.” He rubbed at his face again, but with the arm that Thorin's hand was not on. “Fíli is a good lad. He will make a good king. I know this. I know this. I have my own kingdom. I don't know why...” He shook his head again. “I am sorry.”

        “You scared us.” Thorin saw the way Dáin winced at his words. “It will take time for Dwalin to forgive you,” he also warned. Dáin's head dipped at that. The three of them had always been close when Dáin would visit Erebor in their youth. “But he will forgive you,” Thorin added with a squeeze to Dáin's arm as he let go and sat back in his chair. “And now?” He watched as Dáin's head came up and met his gaze for the first time. “How do you feel about the Arkenstone, now that you know it is a Silmaril?”

        Dáin frowned at him, his gaze sliding away as he stared at the far wall. “It does not seem real,” he said after a minute. “That the Arkenstone is a Silmaril. It has always been a symbol of the kings of Erebor. To think that it has such a history...” He pressed his lips together and then sighed. “Have they taken it from you?”

        “No,” Thorin said, watching Dáin's face carefully. “Lord Eönwë has repeatedly denied the wizard Saruman's...requests for it to be removed from my mountain. Lord Eönwë wishes for the Arkenstone to stay where it is, unless it becomes absolutely necessary for it to be taken away. Even then...” It was Thorin's turn to look away. “I do not know if he would take it.”

        “Small mercies,” Dáin muttered as his shoulders drooped. Thorin looked back at him at that. “It could cause a riot if it was out among the elves and men.”

        “How do you mean?”

        Dáin opened his mouth, closed it, opened it again and then paused. “I do not know what evil is here,” he began. “Perhaps it is a curse from the dragon. Perhaps it is Morgoth, as the wizards believe. But there is some sort of darkness here, Thorin. It takes a hold of you, it...changes you.” He lifted his gaze and Thorin felt almost pinned by his stare. “You must take care,” he said. “Whatever darkness is moving in the world, I think it is here...or is going to come here.”

        Thorin studied his cousin's eyes. They were clear, brighter than they had been since Thorin had seen Dáin on the battlefield before Erebor's gates. “And Bilbo? The hobbits? Do you still think they are some sort of evil that I have let into the mountain?”

        Dáin closed his eyes as an expression of shame passed over his face. He sighed again. “No,” he said as he opened his eyes to stare at his hands once more. “I do not.”

        “You have been more furious over Bilbo and his people than most anything else,” Thorin pressed. He saw Dáin wince at that. “Do you know why?”

        Dáin shook his head as he leaned back against the pillows. “I do not,” he said. “Every time I thought about Bilbo, about any of the hobbits, this rage would come over me. All I could think was that this Bilbo was a thief. That he – he...” Dáin put a hand to his head. “That he had taken something from – from me and that...that...”

        “Dáin!” Thorin lurched forward as he saw blood start to drip from his cousin's nose. “Óin! Someone come!” He held Dáin's shoulders as Dáin began to cough out some strange black substance. He was forced to let go of Dáin as Óin and his healers crowded about the bed. At some point Lord Elrond was brought in and with him came the Lady Galadriel. Thorin hovered at the doorway, joined by Balin, as the healers worked over Dáin. His cousin was eased back at some point, eyes closed but breathing peacefully, as Óin's healers hovered near his bedside.

        It was Óin who led them to a small room near the hall that the old dwarf had taken over as an infirmary for the mountain for now. Thorin saw Glóin standing guard at the far end of the hallway, speaking with Lord Eönwë and Lord Maedhros there. Thorin caught his eye and gave Glóin a nod. But it was not Lord Maedhros or Lord Elrond that came with Thorin into the room Óin had led the rest of them to. Only Lord Eönwë and the Lady Galadriel joined them. Óin did not sit, though Lady Galadriel sank into one of the chairs that were grouped about a table in the center of the room.

        “How is he?” Thorin was the first to speak. He made sure to pitch his voice loud, so that Óin could hear him.

        “Bad,” Óin shook his head and put his back to the banked coals in the fireplace. “I don't know what that black stuff was but his lungs seem almost full of it.”

        “It is a type of corruption,” Lady Galadriel said as Thorin tried to keep himself calm.

        “Corruption?” He looked to the lady. “What kind of corruption? Will he recover?”

        Her smile was kind. “He will,” she said. “But the corruption...” Her smile faded. “I have only seen the like once, long ago, and in a land far from here.” Thorin watched as she turned to look at Eönwë. “I believe you would know it as well.”

        The Maia stared back at the lady, his pale eyes piercing, before he sighed, bowing his head. “You believe it is the work of Morgoth.”

        “I do,” Lady Galadriel said.

        “Morgoth,” Thorin looked between them. He heard Óin shift behind him, no doubt getting closer so he could hear better. “How would Dáin be corrupted by Morgoth?”

        “It is something we saw when Morgoth fled from Aman after the destruction of the Two Trees,” Eönwë said as he joined Lady Galadriel at the table. “Many Maiar and lesser spirits came to Lord Manwë then and knelt before him, pleading for forgiveness, for they had believed Morgoth's lies and evil whispers. After they would kneel and speak their piece, many would collapse and begin to vomit out the same black substance that came from your cousin's lungs.”

        Thorin was slow to join the two at the table but when he settled into his own chair he said, “But that does not explain how this corruption could have gotten to my cousin.” He looked at them both. Only Lady Galadriel met his gaze. “He seemed...normal when we met on the battlefield. It was only afterward that he became...strange.”

        “Afterwards,” Eönwë echoed, exchanging a look with Galadriel. “You are certain?”

        “I am,” Thorin looked between them. “Why?” He saw Óin sit at the table at last, leaning forward as he listened.

        Lady Galadriel tapped one long finger on the table, her youthful face somber as she stared off at a point only she could see. “In Aman, when Morgoth plied his whispers and lies to the Noldor and the Maiar, it was a...slow process, you could say.” A line formed between her brows. “The rumors would spring up year by year, but it was a careful plot, looking back. This...” She shook her head. “This has none of that subtly.”

        “I agree,” Eönwë said. “This is far more of a hammer to glass rather than a careful sculpting of intent.”

        “Then...do you think it was not Morgoth who did this to Dáin?” Thorin frowned at them. Óin let out a loud hrumph! next to him.

        Galadriel drew in a sharp breath and let it out on a harsh sigh. “It fits far more to a different spirit I knew once,” she said. Her lips pressed into a thin, hard line for a moment. “When he wore an illusion of a hot-headed young king who had lost his kingdom.”

        “...Who do you speak of?” Thorin pressed his palm to the table.

        Galadriel looked away, her face in profile against the glow of the banked fire behind her. She blinked fast, a quick sheen to her eyes, there and gone. Then, “Sauron,” she said as she turned back to Thorin. “I speak of Sauron at his most reckless. He would do something as drastic as what was done to your cousin, King Thorin.”

        “Sauron,” Thorin repeated. “But he is gone.”

        “He is not,” Eönwë held up a hand. “His kingdom is gone, his Ring has been destroyed, and what little was left of his physical presence has been wiped away. He exists now only as a shadow that still lingers in the world.”

        “A shadow?” Thorin sat forward, both palms pressing against the table now. “Like the ones we have seen? Could that have been him?”

        “Perhaps,” said Eönwë.

        “No,” said Galadriel.

        Thorin raised his eyebrow at them.

        Eönwë and Galadriel locked gazes for a long moment. Then Eönwë nodded at her. “Your thoughts, my lady?”

        Galadriel pursed her lips together, a frown pulling down the edges of her mouth. “I have known Sauron in many forms,” she began. “I have seen him pretend to be good, to...perhaps even believe his own lies in his goodness. I have seen him at his most cunning. I have seen him in many moods and attitudes.” She shook her head. “I have even seen him as a shadow that I fought in Dol Guldur...and that shadow is not like the ones we have seen here.”

        “Then what do you think these shadows are?”

        She let out a long breath as she sat back in her chair. “Those I do believe are Morgoth's power rippling over the world.” Thorin fought down a shudder at the thought. “The spells keeping Aman from Arda are unraveling faster than we think. The world is changing around us. I can feel it in the water. I can feel it in the earth. I can smell it in the air. Others I have spoken to feel the same. I believe the shadow we have seen reaches out to us from beyond the Door of Night...but the corruption of your kin, King Thorin,” her eyes were a piercing blue when she looked at him. “That comes from Sauron, and he alone.”

        “Do you believe that he is...here? In my mountain?” A cold chill prickled down Thorin's back.

        Galadriel opened her mouth to answer but the door burst open before she could speak. Óin was standing in front of Thorin before he could blink. Nori came to a stop before them, his front covered in drying blood, his face streaked with it. Thorin's Spymaster said, more grim than Thorin had ever seen him, “My lads are gone, dead, their throats slit. Dwalin's guards are dead, too. The throne has been destroyed. The Arkenstone, the Silmaril, it is gone. It has been stolen.”

        Thorin was on his feet before Nori finished speaking. “Show me,” he rasped. Then they were all moving out of the small room in the healer's hall, following Nori back to the levels above.

        They did not see the shadows shifting around them as they picked up more dwarves and several elves and men as they ran through the corridors and to the throne room above.

Chapter 26: hidden hands and hidden histories

Chapter Text

 

          There was a crowd hovering around the doors to the throne room when Thorin arrived. He left the elves and men they had gathered behind, stalking past two of Nori's most vicious recruits and into the room beyond. Nori never left his side for a moment. Two steps beyond the door Thorin almost stumbled when he caught sight of the throne.

          “How...” He could not finish the sentence. Thorin put a hand to his chest as he stared at the ruins before him. The throne itself, carved out of a single block of stone, was in pieces. He could not see even half of the rubble that should have made most of it up on the dais that the throne sat on. He swallowed hard as he approached, Nori all but vibrating next to him, picking out details of the destruction the closer he came.

          “No dwarf could do this,” he murmured as he came to a stop before the throne.

          “I agree,” Nori said, voice grim.

          There was a chorus of shouts from behind them. Thorin turned, his hand falling to his empty side, cursing himself for not belting on his sword before he left his rooms. Nori edged in front of him, two curved daggers Thorin had not seen before in his hands, as they looked toward the door. Thankfully it was Bofur pushing his way through the gathered crowd, intent on getting inside.

          “Well, that's a problem,” Bofur growled as he skidded to a stop at Thorin's side. “First the hallway and now this?”

          “What hallway?” Nori snapped.

          “The hallway outside the royal wing is repairing itself,” Thorin said as Nori growled low in his throat. Thorin lowered his voice and leaned closer to his Spymaster. “It looks to be hobbit work.” He frowned and looked at Nori head on. “Your people did not tell you?”

          Nori pressed his lips together as he shook his head. “I was outside,” he jerked his head to where the gardens had been found. “Someone said they saw someone lurking about out there but when I got out there, there was no one on the mountainside. I...”

          “Nori?”

          Nori leaned closer to Thorin, his voice going soft. “If I had to guess I think someone was trying to get us to go this way and that.”

          Thorin looked at Nori and then at the throne. “To distract us,” he said.

          “Yes.”

          Thorin looked back at the throne and curled his hands into fists. He stepped forward with Bofur and Nori at his sides, circling around the ruins of what had once been the pride of their people. The entire top of the throne was gone, reduced to rubble no larger than Thorin's combined fists.

          “How is this even possible?” Thorin leaned over part of the throne's back, where it looked as though something or someone had ripped out the ornate metal gilding and flung it halfway off the side of the dais. “How did the guards not hear this happening?” He turned to look at Nori. “Their bodies were found outside,” he said slowly, thinking it through. “Your lads?”

          Nori pointed to a gallery above the throne and down into the shadows below. “One each, though there should have been more watching the room.”

          Thorin rocked back at that. “Find them.”

          “Already looking.”

          Thorin watched as Nori stalked to the long walkway, where two bodies hauled themselves up from below it – somehow, Thorin wasn't quite sure how – and crowded close to Thorin's Spymaster. He turned back to Bofur who was frowning at the throne, squatting down next to a large chunk of what might have been the part where the Arkenstone was housed. “What do you see?”

          Bofur tugged at his braids, his mustache working back and forth as he hummed a song Thorin couldn't place under his breath. “No pickaxe did this,” he said. He reached out to move one of the stones and a crackle of something went between his finger and the stone. Bofur jerked back with a shout, tumbling back onto his rear. Thorin lunged for him before Bofur could fall off the dais, dragging him away. Nori was there in a flash, getting between them and the throne.

          “What is it? What happened?”

          “Get the wizards,” Thorin said, shaking his head. “Bofur? Bofur?”

          “I'm good, I'm good,” Bofur said but he was trembling in Thorin's grip. Thorin pulled the other dwarf back to his chest and looked around for a healer. The Lady Galadriel was there before Thorin could call out, kneeling next to them as she bent over Bofur's shaking form.

          “Lie back,” she said as she set one hand over Bofur's forehead. Bofur stared up at her, still trembling, but kept his mouth shut as the lady looked him over. Thorin saw Óin pushing his way through the crowd, followed closely by Gandalf and the rest of the wizards, even Radagast.

          “Thorin?” Gandalf called as soon as he got near. “What has happened?”

          “Some sort of power attacked Bofur,” Thorin nodded at the throne. “From the rubble.”

          “From the rubble?” Saruman scoffed. Radagast pushed past the other wizard, earning a scowl from Saruman as Radagast came close to the ruins of the throne. “That is impossible! How –”

          A blinding blue arc of light snapped off the rubble, hitting Radagast in the chest as he poked at one of the larger pieces with his staff. Cries filled the throne room. Thorin blinked hard, trying to clear his eyes of the black and white after image of Radagast being thrown back to the ground. Gandalf was hovering over the other wizard, half bent over him as if to protect him, as the two blue wizards pulled Saruman well away from the rubble.

          “Stay back!” Thorin cried out over the shouts filling the room. He drew in a sharp breath and tried again, pushing his voice as he did on the training fields, cutting through the noise. “Stay back!”

          The cries and shouts dropped as soon as his voice filled the room. Thorin blinked again, his sight clearing in time to see Galadriel crawling over to where Gandalf was curled over Radagast. “Let me see, old friend,” she said as she reached the wizards. “Let me see.”

          Thorin watched as Eönwë pushed his way towards Galadriel and the wizards as more elves and men began to stream into the room. Thorin could barely make out where Thranduil was standing with Bard, pressed close to the archer as he peered into the room. Maedhros was in the lead of those who came further into the throne room, with the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion at his side. The other wizards did not move back far, just enough so that they were well clear of the destruction surrounding the throne.

          Thorin looked down at Bofur. “All right there?”

          Bofur made a face but pushed up and out of Thorin's arms. “I feel like I've been dropped a dozen levels and laid flat out on me back,” he said as he pulled at the flaps of his hat. “I'll live, though.”

          “Are you dizzy? Does anything hurt?” Thorin looked him over.

          “You answer me that, young one,” Óin barked as he got to their sides. The older dwarf left the wizards to the Lady Galadriel and Lord Elrond, who had also arrived with the other elves.

          “I am fine,” Bofur grumbled as Óin pulled the other dwarf back from the wreckage of the throne. Thorin stayed where he was, close enough to see the destruction but not close enough to risk touching it.

          “I'll be the judge of that, laddie. Now take off your hat.”

          “I will not!”

          “Bofur!”

          Thorin tuned out their squabbling as he narrowed his eyes, trying to see if he could pinpoint where this strange energy was coming from. Was it just from the stone of the throne? Was it from the metals? Was there a trap?

          “What do you see?”

          Thorin turned and looked up at Maedhros as the elf went to one knee next to him. “Rubble,” he said with a twist to his mouth. “I cannot see where this strange energy is coming from.”

          “And the...Arkenstone?”

          Thorin appreciated the elf's use of the gem's new name. “I cannot see it. I believe what Nori said, that it is gone.”

          Maedhros let out a hard breath at that. “Gone,” he repeated.

          They shared a grim look.

          “Gone,” another voice said, far closer than Thorin liked. He shoved down the urge to flinch away from the sound and turned to see Saruman standing behind them. When had the wizard gotten there? And where were the other two wizards who were guarding his side? “As I predicted.”

          Thorin curled his fingers tight and then forced his hands to relax. “No one could have predicted this.”

          “I did,” Saruman's nose went up. It was a distressingly common sight. Thorin wanted to break that nose. “I warned you all,” his tone dropped and Thorin fought down another shiver. That dark gaze slid from Thorin to the throne and then to the elf beside him. “And what of you, Maedhros, son of Fëanor?”

          “Me?” Maedhros leaned back from the wizard. Thorin heard the noise of the crowd drop as more and more attention was focused their way. “What of myself?”

          “You claim to know nothing of this matter?”

          Someone behind them gasped. Thorin saw an elf push his way through the crowd, coming to a stop at Maedhros' side. It was Lord Elrond's councilor, Master Erestor. “You would accuse Lord Maedhros of stealing the – the Arkenstone?”

          Saruman's dark eyes glittered as they stared down at Maedhros. “His history makes a compelling point in such matters.”

          Thorin saw a muscle tick in Maedhros' jaw. “I –”

          “It is impossible that Lord Maedhros stole the Arkenstone,” Master Erestor spoke over him. He stepped forward, halfway between the wizard and Maedhros.

          “And how do you know that?”

          Thorin did not miss the lack of title or even name the wizard used for Master Erestor.

          “Because Lord Maedhros was with me,” Erestor raised his chin at the wizard's dark stare.

          “Was he, now.”

          “Yes,” Erestor did not budge an inch. He was smaller than many elves Thorin had met, his dark hair pulled back in a simple braid. He wore no embellishments as Lord Elrond did, preferring simple clothes it seemed. Thorin also noted the way both lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion seemed to almost trip over themselves at Erestor's words as they came to Lord Elrond's side.

          “You would lie for one such as him?” Saruman took a step closer to Erestor. The elf did not step back. They were almost chest to chest. Saruman's staff was planted at his side, the sharp angles of the top of the staff catching the light in the throne room oddly. Thorin frowned at it but his attention was pulled back to the two in front of him before he could figure out what had caught his eye.

          “It is no lie,” Erestor's fingers curled and relaxed at his sides. “Lord Maedhros was with me this entire morning.”

          “And the evening before?”

          “Saruman,” Galadriel said as she rose. She put her hands on her hips. The wizard turned his face away but he stepped back from Erestor as Glorfindel and Ecthelion came to a stop just outside the small dais the wreckage of the throne sat on.

          “Come along, lad. Let's get you out of here,” Óin muttered from Thorin's left. He saw the healer help Bofur up, one arm slung over his shoulders, as the two of them edged their way around the rest of them on the dais. Thorin thought he heard Bofur mutter thank the Maker but he could not be sure. Thorin almost wanted to join them but he was not about to allow these elves and wizards to be alone before his throne without himself or another dwarf present. It felt...wrong to do so.

          “Someone stole the Silmaril,” Saruman said as Óin and Bofur left the platform. Galadriel was still staring at him, eyes narrowing as she looked him over. “I was with Pallando and Alatar. This...Erestor,” Saruman's gaze swept up and down Erestor's form, “claims he was with Maedhros. Could it be...” That dark gaze was on Thorin then. “Your kin, Thorin Oakenshield? Your cousin has already made a claim for your throne once already.”

          Thorin surged to his feet, hands curled tight at his sides. “Dáin is not behind this.”

          “So quick to defend him now, are you?”

          Thorin drew in a long, calming breath. “Dáin was unconscious the whole night through and I was with him just now,” he said. “Óin can confirm this. His apprentices can confirm this. He could not have done such a thing.”

          “But he could have ordered it.”

          “How? He was unconscious and furthermore...”

          “Furthermore?”

          Thorin narrowed his eyes at the wizard. “No dwarf would have or could have done such a thing.”

          “Oh?”

          Thorin pointed at the rubble of the throne. “Even with a mallet and the strongest of our kin, there is no possible way for one of us to destroy such a carving. The throne was made of heartstone – granite,” he added at the way Saruman's brows drew together. “Perhaps one could have chipped off the edges, perhaps at best caused a crack in the thinnest spots. But to do this?” He swept a hand out, encompassing the entire wreckage of the throne. “Impossible.”

          “Then that leaves but you,” Saruman's stare went back to Maedhros. The elf had yet to rise.

          To Thorin's shock Maedhros instead instead knelt fully, both knees to the stone. He pressed his right hand to his chest, eyes bright as he stared back at the wizard. “I would never do such a thing,” he swore. “I would not steal the Arkenstone or any of the Silmarils ever again. I would never do such a thing in a place so touched by the ones who once helped me in my greatest time of need.”

          A rise of murmurs swept through the watching crowd. Galadriel stopped short, staring at her cousin. “Maedhros?”

          But it was to Thorin that Maedhros looked next. Thorin rocked back, staring at the elf as Maedhros searched his face for something Thorin could not name. Whatever it was, Maedhros seemed to find it. “Long ago,” the elf began, “I was a fool to think that I could outwit Morgoth and steal away a Silmaril when they feigned to offer one as a sign of peace. Driven by the Oath we took with our father, I was blinded to many things.” He shook his head. There was a sheen of tears to his eyes but they did not fall. “Instead of stealing away a Silmaril, I was stolen instead, taken by Morgoth and made to kneel before him. The Vala was as cruel as he once was beautiful, and I will not go into the torments he put me through for his entertainment. When he grew bored of me, Morgoth put a shackle about my right wrist and pushed me from the precipice of Thangorodrim, letting me dangle there for years and years.”

          Maedhros ducked his head for a moment, a shaky breath escaping him. His left hand came up to cup his right. Galadriel came to stand by his shoulder but she did not speak. “I should have died there,” Maedhros continued. He looked up and Thorin was struck by the look in the elf's eyes. “Elves can exist for long periods of time without food or water, it is true, but for longer than a month? A year? No. I hung by my wrist for decades.” His voice shook. “I should have died there. But I did not.”

          “How did you survive?” Thorin said when it seemed as though Maedhros needed the question to continue.

          At that Maedhros' gaze tracked beyond Thorin, to the galleries above them and to the shadows below. “At first I despaired,” he said, gaze far distant. “I screamed myself hoarse, until I spat up blood and could barely breathe. It hurt so much to dangle there by one wrist. I tried to pull myself up, tried to climb the chain but each time one of Morgoth's minions would kick me back, breaking my wrist too many times to count.”

          Galadriel put a hand over her mouth, her eyes squinting shut as she listened to Maedhros' words.

          Maedhros' breath was still shaky as he gazed at something only he could see. “The cliff I lay against was not completely flat. There were small outcroppings I could sometimes brace myself against and find some ease of pain. But I could never perch like that for long, for Morgoth would make sure that I was tormented as much as possible by his creatures. Sometimes his evil bats would flash by me, tearing at my skin or trying to blind me. Sometimes others would pour foul liquids from the top of the cliff or boiling water. Anything that would cause me pain. I thought I would die there. At one point I wished to die there. And then...”

          Maedhros sat back on his heels as his gaze returned to Thorin. Those blue eyes were piercing bright. “At my weakest, when I thought death would take me at last, I was...lifted.” His brows came together, his gaze flicking up and to the left. “I did not understand it at first. The pain in my arm went away and it felt as though many hands were holding me up. Those same hands brought something warm to my mouth and urged me to drink. At first I fought it.” A small smile tugged on one side of his face. “I was scolded, sternly, and told to drink. And so I did.” His gaze focused back on Thorin. “When I could open my eyes again there were many small beings about me. I was not quite laying flat and there seemed be some sort of plants or wood holding me up. The one that stayed by my side was one of the older beings. She called herself a widow.” His smile grew by a few degrees. “She wore rags that had been dyed black and her hair was covered by a cloth. She had the most amazingly blue eyes I have ever seen, save for one other.” Maedhros then looked to Eönwë. “They were the same color as Lord Manwë's.”

          A stir went about the room.

          Saruman cracked his staff against the ground, making Thorin flinch at the sound. “What nonsense do you claim here?”

          Maedhros' smile vanished as he turned a sharp stare onto Saruman. “The beings I met on that cliff were the only ones who kept me alive, even when I wept for them to leave me for dead. They refused. They said it was their duty to help me, to...fix me, though there was nothing they could do to free me. Several tried.” Grief twisted his features. “They all died. I begged them after the third to die at the hands of Morgoth's minions to stop, to let me be, to not risk themselves anymore. The widow, she called herself Widow Minona, refused, though they did stop trying to free me. They were the ones who fed me, who cared for my wounds as best they could, who were there for me until Fingon came and rescued me from the cliff face.”

          “And what does this preposterous tale have anything to do with what is happening here and now?” Saruman banged his staff against the ground once more. “Do you tell us this tale so that the ones who helped you steal the Silmaril flee ever farther from our grasp?”

          “No,” the word tore itself out of Maedhros' throat. “I would not steal the Silmaril, the Arkenstone. Nor would I ever harm this place or bring harm to it. For the same creatures that saved me on that cliff face, the same creatures that cared for me, the same creatures that kept me alive, they are here.” He blinked and the tears in his eyes finally fell. His gaze went back to Thorin. “They were a small race, smaller than even the dwarves I met in the years following my release. A hardy folk.” Gandalf looked up from where he was curled over Radagast, his face pale. “A simple folk, who only wished to do good, trapped in a place where the very darkness about them fought back against any simple comforts they could give. I feel them here,” his gaze tracked up and around the room. “All over the mountain and beyond. I could never forget the way their magic felt, as it kept me alive. They are here...or their spirits are, and I think you, King Thorin Oakenshield, know why.”

          It was Thorin's turn to close his eyes against that bright gaze. “You speak of hobbits,” he managed to croak, his throat dry and tight with the threat of tears.

          “Yes,” Maedhros said on a whisper. “I do.”

          “Impossible,” Saruman sputtered.

          Thorin opened his eyes but his gaze was only for Maedhros. “When you first arrived,” he said, thinking back. The sharp look the elf had turned on the gates. The very same gates where Thorin had...where Bilbo had...

          “I felt something then, yes,” Maedhros said. He swallowed, dashing the back of his wrists against his cheeks. “I did not understand it at first. It was...familiar, but I could not place it. Not at first. But then...” He pursed his lips and shook his head. “The food,” he said at last.

          “The...food?” Thorin repeated.

          Maedhros nodded. “And the wine. It tasted so sweet, so familiar...I did not think it could be those that I once knew. I had hoped...” His expression fell. “But then I heard of what had happened here, to your Bilbo, and to the other hobbits in this land.”

          “You...” Thorin could not quite wrap his head around it. “You claim that there were hobbits in Angband? That...that they, what? Served Morgoth?”

          “No!” Maedhros exclaimed. “They would never.”

          “But then how...how would hobbits even be there?” A memory of Gandalf speaking about the origin of hobbits had him looking over at the wizard. Gandalf looked as old as Thorin had ever seen him, wan and grey and tired. “You...suspected this?”

          “Yes,” Gandalf said after a pause. Radagast stirred in his arms, one hand coming up to grasp Gandalf's shoulder. “I did.”

          “A dark tower and trees of stone,” Thorin murmured, remembering what Gandalf had said.

          “That was part of one of their songs,” Gandalf said, clearer as he helped Radagast sit up. “They had many of them.” Grief shaded his expression once more.

          “You believe in this nonsense, Gandalf?” Saruman's staff struck the stone once more. “It is preposterous! Completely unbelievable! We would have known of such creatures!”

          “How could we have known of them?” Gandalf shook his head at the other wizard. “No one knew of the hobbits until the I found them in the Second Age and only in the Third Age did they become more widely known of. They could have easily existed for far longer than any of us know.”

          Thorin looked back at Maedhros. “What happened to them? The hobbits you once knew,” he clarified.

          Maedhros sighed, bowing his head and closing his eyes for a moment. “When Fingon came...when I was rescued, I wanted more than anything to take those who had been so kind to me with us. But they were not there when Fingon came and I...” His shoulders inched up. “When Fingon was trying to free me without...harming me, the guards above us noticed him. There was not much time.” He opened his eyes and there was much grief there. “Fingon had to sever my hand from my wrist and I passed out from the pain and shock of it all. When I woke I was in Fingon's tent and there was no way to go back.”

          Thorin looked to Galadriel but the lady only had eyes for her cousin. “Did you ever tell anyone of the – the hobbits that helped you?”

          Maedhros shook his head. “No,” he said with another sigh. “I think...I think I tried, when I was first rescued.” A faint frown pinched his brows. He looked up at Galadriel. “Were you there, cousin? Do you remember anything that I said then?”

          Galadriel put a hand to his shoulder then, some deep sorrow shading her eyes to the darkest Thorin had ever seen them. “You called out for someone yes, but we could never understand the name. Now I do.”

          “The...name?” Thorin looked between them. “Minona?”

          “Minnónar is the word for first-born in our language,” Galadriel said, still staring down at Maedhros. “We did not understand who he was asking for, since Maedhros is the first born of my uncle.” A faint smile pulled at one side of her mouth. “Fingon thought perhaps Maedhros was asking for him, but Maedhros would always call him by name.” That smile curved into something kinder, a bit softer, before it faded. “Now I understand who you were calling for.” She then knelt next to Maedhros and put her arms about his neck, much to the other elf's surprise if Maedhros' expression was anything to go by. “I am sorry, cousin.”

          “You could not know.” Maedhros put a trembling hand on her back. “I never went back, either. It is my burden to bear.”

          A sudden shower of pebbles made Maedhros flinch, throwing himself backwards with Galadriel in his arms, putting himself between her and the tiny stones that were scattering over the polished stone of the walkway. Thorin backed up, careful not to touch the ruins of the throne, staring up at the shadow-dark ceiling. “We need light up there!”

          Gandalf was the one to stand, his staff in hand, as he looked up with them. “Light,” he murmured and raised that staff, the tip of it starting to glow in a way that Thorin had never seen before. The lingering shadows in the throne room were pushed back by that light, revealing the tall pillars and the ornate carvings that were etched over almost every surface. The grey stone began to sparkle, the flecks of ore and minerals picking up that light coming from Gandalf's staff and reflecting it back.

          It had been decades, far longer than Thorin wished to think about, since the throne room was lit as well as this. The sun was often enough to illuminate the room but there had been no time between the battle and now to find time to get a crew out to both inspect the great windows cut into the mountainside, along with finding those who could clean them. It left the light a little muted when it came streaming in, just enough so that the veins on the walls did not shine in that light.

          But now...oh now those veins sparkled as Gandalf held up his staff. The hidden metal mirrors Thorin knew about caught that illumination and amplified it, brighter and brighter until it felt like standing inside a lit crystal. It made tears stream from Thorin's eyes, even as he squinted through the glow, trying to look up at the ceiling to see where those stray pebbles had come from.

          “If you had not claimed that the hobbits were gone,” Maedhros murmured at Thorin's side. He had not heard the elf move, much less join him. “I would have said that was one of them.”

          Thorin's breath caught. He blinked away wetness he was blaming on the brightness of the room as he kept his eyes on the space above them. “You have had them throw pebbles at you before?”

          A huff of laughter met his question. “Yes,” Maedhros said. Thorin glanced at him from the corner of his eye. The elf had tear tracks on his face as well, even as he looked above them both. “Minona was very good at throwing them. She could fell a bird with a single stone, her aim was so sharp.”

          Thorin returned his gaze to the ceiling, his gaze tracking over the geometric designs his ancestors had carved into the stone above. He could see no opening, no place for anyone to be hiding, no hidden beams or cracks the vault above. “Bilbo said much the same about his people.” Thorin had to stop and clear his throat. “That they had excellent aim and were best with ranged weapons, stones, and arrows and the like.”

          Maedhros nodded, a slow motion as his gaze seemed to catch and hold onto one part of the space above them. Thorin tried to track it, seeing only an oddly shaped shadow above that would not fade even with Gandalf's light shining brighter and brighter. “Do you see it?” The elf's voice was pitched low.

          Thorin squinted at that shadow. “It looks to be a piece of stone shading an area...but you do not agree?”

          Maedhros let out a breath. “I do not know,” he said. “I do not know.”

          Movement on the walkway had Thorin glancing down in time to see Saruman stalk to where the doors to the throne room were open, lifting his own staff to create a light as bright as Gandalf's. His, though, felt...colder. It had an almost blue tinge to it where Gandalf's was warm and bright, like a fire crackling on the hearth. But with Saruman's staff illuminating that part of the room the shadows on the ceiling above them resolved into a tricky bit of carvings, made out into the sigil of Durin I, that once Thorin saw the pattern to it he realized that it was repeated through much of the decorations about the room as a whole.

          There were no openings above them. No cracks in the stone, no hidden doors that Thorin could see at all. There was not even damage done to the ceiling that could have accounted for the pebbles. There was nothing there at all.

          Thorin let out a breath he did not realize he was holding. He glanced over in time to see Gandalf's expression fall. The wizard lowered his staff as the crystal that sat atop it began to dim. Saruman's staff also winked out, quicker than Gandalf's, leaving spots behind in Thorin's vision.

          At his side Maedhros bent down and picked up some of the pebbles that had pelted him. They were tiny, colored pink and black, and shiny with age or use. The elf turned the stones in his palm with one finger, his brows pinching together. “Do you know what this is?” Maedhros glanced up at him and then back down at his palm. He tilted his hand so Thorin could see them better and Thorin felt his eyebrows go up.

          “I do,” he said. He reached out and picked up one of the pebbles, tilting it towards the light now coming in through the western windows. It was barely past noon and Thorin felt the ache of it all deep in his bones. “Once it was called raspberry ore, because of the coloring,” he tilted the stone and tiny flecks of minerals made it shimmer in his hold. “Later, though, it was called something else.”

          “And what was that?”

          Thorin looked up and met Maedhros' gaze. “Rescue stone,” he said, soft. Maedhros closed his eyes against that for a long moment.

          “Why...” Maedhros had to stop and clear his throat. He opened his eyes to meet Thorin's gaze once more. “Why is it called that now?”

          Thorin couldn't help his smile. “Because it rescued us,” he said and held out the stone for Maedhros to take. The elf took it with trembling fingers, dropping the pebble into the small pile in his palm. “When our people fled Khazad-dûm we left behind much of what made our people so prosperous and rich. Veins of this stone were found in several places across Arda where our people founded colonies. They are easy to mine and easy to make into pretty jewelry, cheap enough for villagers of Men to buy and support our people until we could remake our kingdoms once more.”

          “I see,” Maedhros said softly. “Rescue stone,” he whispered, thumb smoothing over the pebbles. “Rescue.”

          “Yes,” Thorin agreed, glancing up at the ceiling and then back down at the elf. “They do not seem...shadowed.” He could not help his glance at the throne.

          “No, they do not,” Maedhros said, following his gaze. He took a step closer to Thorin and his voice was barely above a whisper as he said, “There is perhaps one or two elves in all of our camps who could break the stone that your throne is carved of and I am one of them. The other is Lord Glorfindel and I can swear that neither of us would have done such a thing.”

          Thorin glanced back at the broken throne once more. “I know,” he said. He pressed his lips together for a moment, glancing at the long walkway where the wizards had been gathered by Eönwë. Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel were now at Radagast's side, helping him stand. “I do not think a single man in the entire camp could do such a thing, either.”

          “I agree,” Maedhros murmured.

          “ – not care that it is rude!” Saruman's raised voice had them both turning. The wizard had moved a step apart from Eönwë and Gandalf, with both the blue wizards at his sides. “The Silmarils must be protected! They should have never been allowed to sit about like objects on display!”

          Thorin drew in a slow breath to tame a sudden surge of fury. Before he could speak, though, Eönwë held up a hand, halting Saruman's next words. “Peace, please, Saruman. I understand your concerns –”

          “Do you, oh herald of Manwë?” Saruman's staff thumped against the ground. “Because it does not seem that you do! The Silmarils must be protected. They are the vehicle with which our future is to be created! To allow them to be used as tools for those here on Arda's shores is reckless. How do we even know if the second Silmaril is even safe? No one has let me – us see it!”

          That was when all eyes turned to Thorin. He felt his back go stiff at the piercing stares. He saw Eönwë's mouth press into a flat line. There were mutterings rising through the growing crowd of men gathered at the door. Thorin saw Thranduil pull Bard to his side and away from the other groups of men. Thorin glanced back at the throne and then back towards the crowd, looking for Nori, but his Spymaster had vanished at some point. “I will show you where the Silmaril that was given to me is now kept,” he began slowly. He saw some flash of emotion pass over Saruman's face, there and gone too fast for Thorin to place just what it was. The blue wizards at Saruman's sides were more obvious in their looks, the cant of their mouths and the dark looks they turned on Thorin full of suspicion. “But I will not have it removed from my possession unless Lord Eönwë deems that such an action would be best.”

          “You –,” began Saruman.

          “Peace, Saruman,” Eönwë snapped, the most forceful Thorin had ever heard the spirit speak yet. Then he turned to Thorin and bowed low, an unhappy twist to his mouth when he rose. “If you would reassure Saruman that the Silmaril is safe and protected, I am sure that will be fine.”

          “I wish to see it for myself.” Saruman all but stamped his foot like a toddler.

          Thorin set his jaw but managed a grim smile at the onlooking crowd. “The Silmaril is being held in my own rooms, behind layers of guards seen and unseen. Surely that is protected enough?”

          “No,” Saruman sniffed. “It is not. It must be kept secret. It must be kept safe.”

          Thorin felt his stomach twist when he saw a few of the men behind the wizard nod along with him. “Then come and see for yourself,” he said as he let out a breath. He caught Balin's eye at the door, his old friend and councilor held back by the crowd there. Balin nodded at him once and then was gone, quicker than anyone around him. It was more than just Saruman and the blue wizards who came with Thorin to his rooms, though, for Maedhros fell into step with him, giving Thorin a solemn nod as he did so. Lord Elrond and Lady Galadriel stayed with Radagast, Thorin noted, and he also saw how Galadriel gave Maedhros her own subtle nod, though what that could mean between the cousins he did not know.

          There were far more guards stationed near the Royal Wing than there had been, before. Thorin's neck prickled with that same feeling of unknown watchers, so he assumed that Nori's lads had doubled as well. He spotted his Spymaster as he rounded the corner to the final hall that led to his rooms and stopped when he looked beyond his door.

          “Is there a problem?” Maedhros had stopped as well, looking down at him and then back up at the far end of the hall. A hall that was now completely rubble free. A hall that had elegant wooden beams holding up the ceiling, marked by traditional dwarven etchings...and something else Thorin could not quite make out.

          “No,” Thorin said after a moment. He forced his feet forward. Saruman was almost on his heels, a looming presence at his back. Thorin did not want to tell the wizard of the changing hall he realized in that moment. Gandalf, he would tell. Perhaps even Eönwë he would tell. But none other. Not even Maedhros, not right now. Not yet. Though by the way the elf's gaze lingering on that woodwork, Thorin had to wonder if Maedhros suspected the same thing that he did.

          Thorin opened the door to his rooms to find Dwalin standing on the other side, his axe in one hand and a sword in the other. He looked a bit wild about the eyes. “Dwalin?” He stepped forward. His partner threw his sword onto a nearby chair and closed the distance between them. “What is wrong?”

          “I do not know,” Dwalin said, still too pale for Thorin's liking. “The wall...rippled,” he said on a whisper, his mouth just brushing Thorin's ear as they embraced.

          Thorin turned his head just a bit. “The hallway outside is repaired,” he whispered back. He felt Dwalin's arm tense around him. Then Thorin stepped back when Saruman let out a loud hrumph behind them. “The wizard Saruman wishes to verify the safety of the Silmaril.” Thorin met Dwalin's gaze and knew by the lack of shock in his partner's expression that Dwalin had been told of everything that had been going on so far. “Are your guards searching the mountain?”

          “Every inch of it right now,” Dwalin agreed as he moved back, though he did not allow Saruman to sweep forward when the wizard made to do so.

          “Any leads?” Thorin led the crowd behind him into their inner rooms. It itched at him to do so but he knew rumors and whispers would spring up if he did not. They could not let such mistrust fester in their camps. Not right now, not when they needed to be allied closer than ever before.

          “Nothing,” Dwalin's tone was grim as they came to the altar at last. “All the guards near the throne room have been killed.”

          That stopped Thorin's feet. He turned to Dwalin. “All of them?”

          Dwalin nodded, expression set and grim. “All of them.”

          Thorin closed his eyes against that for a moment. “We will have to hold ceremonies for them.”

          “Yes.”

          “The Silmaril, if you please,” Saruman cut in from behind them.

          Thorin shared a look with Dwalin and stepped forward, sweeping one hand out to encompass the altar. “Here it is,” he said, turning to look at the wizard. He held up a hand when Saruman went to approach. “Please, no further.”

          Saruman's staff thumped against the ground. Again. “I wish to see the Silmaril!”

          “And see it you are,” Thorin frowned back at him. He pointed at the box that held Bilbo's holy silk. “For it is right there.”

          “In an open box? On top of a table? This is madness!” The wizard turned towards Eönwë. “Surely you understand that!”

          “Saruman,” the note of power in Eönwë's voice made Thorin take a half step back. Dwalin moved part way in front of Thorin, his knuckles white about his axe. “That is enough!” The herald of Manwë drew himself up as he stared down at Saruman. The wizard was quick to look away, shoulders coming up about his ears. “I understand your concern. We are all worried about the developments going on! But your lack of kindness, your display of distrust and suspicion is harming the very one that the Silmarils have been given to!”

          “...Yes, my lord,” Saruman muttered. His head was canted down, his dark hair falling about his face.

          “Saruman.”

          At that the wizard's head came up, eyes bright and mouth set in a firm line. “The world is changing,” he said with a small shake of his head. “There are forces beyond our understanding shifting the very song we once heard in the Timeless Halls. How can I not be uneasy in such times? How can I not be suspicious of every little thing that shifts the very world as we know it? We do not even know why the Silmarils have come to...us again. All we have is the world of an elf who once tried to steal them, of an elf whose very father created an Oath that caused kinslayings and almost tore apart Beleriand from the inside out. I am worried,” Saruman said, slumping against his staff, his shoulders rounding. “There is so much change. So much unknown. So many answers we do not have.”

          Eönwë's expression softened. Thorin's did not. “I understand your worry,” Eönwë said, stepping forward to place a careful hand on Saruman's shoulder. The wizard went stiff and Eönwë was quick to pull his hand away. “But to react instead of making rational, calm decisions is just what the enemy would want us to do. The Silmaril will be safe here, safer than it would be if it were out in open tents and too few guards.”

          “The Silmaril in the throne room was said to be safe too,” Saruman sniffed and then stalked right up to where Thorin was standing, though no further. Thorin grit his teeth at the wizard's rudeness, pressing a hand to Dwalin's arm when he heard his partner's huff of displeasure. “Why do you have it displayed thus?”

          Thorin glanced at Dwalin, then at Eönwë, and then back at the wizard. “This is our altar to Mahal. Do not touch it,” he let his voice sharpen when Saruman's staff inched forward. “Aside from the depths of the mountain where only our holy ones may go, it is the most sacred space we have.”

          “An open table in a room? And what is the Silmaril on?”

          “Holy silk,” Thorin said.

          “Holy silk? But it is dirty.”

          “It is not dirty!” Thorin drew himself up, glaring at the wizard. “It holds the blood of Bilbo when his spirit visited us! It is all we have left of him, of any of the hobbits!”

          “It holds his...blood?”

          “Yes,” Thorin narrowed his eyes at Saruman. “Why?”

          Those dark eyes were fathomless as they stared at the box that contained the Silmaril and the silk. “He bled for you after he was killed?”

          Thorin fought down a shiver. “Yes.” He could not place the expression on the wizard's face. “Why? It is strange, true, but it was Bilbo's blood that anointed us. I will swear it to whatever power you wish.”

          “Make no oaths here,” Gandalf said as he pushed forward through the crowd. He had been near the back, speaking to someone Thorin could not see. Now both he and Maedhros moved forward to join Saruman before the altar.

          “More superstitions when it comes to your pets, Gandalf?” Saruman sniffed.

          Gandalf's eyes were narrowed as he met Saruman's gaze. His staff made a loud thunk on the ground as he planted it between them. “You have heard that the hobbits' history goes further back than any of us knew. We do not know of their origins or just what magics they truly have.” He paused and a look of grief passed over his face. “Had. I have known them to be powerful when it comes to oaths and oath-making. Make none now, when far too much is not understood.”

          Thorin bowed his head at that.

          “Strange that such a spirit would bleed for you, Thorin Oakenshield,” Saruman said. Thorin's head came up quick, glaring at the wizard. Saruman was not even looking at him, all of his attention on the Silmaril before him. “Are you sure he was a spirit?”

          Thorin blinked at that, glancing at Gandalf. He had to clear his throat before he could speak. “I dropped Bilbo from atop the gates of Erebor,” he said. “I do not know if even an elf...or a wizard could survive such a fall. Not when there were such razor sharp rocks below.”

          Saruman's eyes narrowed as he stroked a hand over his beard. “How strange,” he murmured. “And yet a spirit bleeding...” He shook his head. “I have never heard the like.”

          The stiff set to Gandalf's shoulders eased a little. “Nor have I.”

          Saruman's sigh seemed to almost echo in the room. He stepped back and Thorin blinked at how the altar seemed to almost brighten away from the cast of his shadow. “There are guards on these rooms, King Thorin?” The wizard then turned to him.

          Thorin drew himself up straight. “More than you can see. Yes.”

          “And on the hall?”

          “Of course.”

          Saruman then looked at Gandalf. “Perhaps we should take our own turns of these halls.”

          Gandalf frowned back at him. “How do you mean?”

          “Placing our own protections here will only add to the security and,” he glanced at Eönwë, “allow for the Silmaril to stay here. As you have all said, multiple times,” Saruman's expression went sour, “we all must be a part of this, whatever it is that is going on here. So let us do our own parts.”

          Thorin raised his eyebrows at that. It was possibly the first suggestion of Saruman's that Thorin agreed with. “You are right,” he said, which drew everyone's attention. “The Silmaril is for all of us here on Arda, not just the dwarves of Erebor.” He knew that to his bones but he could not say why. “Not only the wizards should put down their own protections, but perhaps we can incorporate the elves and men into guarding the entrances of the mountain?” He glanced over at Dwalin. His partner made a face at the suggestion but nodded, chewing on his lower lip as he cast a long look over the crowd.

          “We'll need a roster,” Dwalin said as his axe finally relaxed at his side. Thorin had not noticed that Dwalin had kept it at a guard position for so long. Strange. “We'll need to be organized about it. There will be parts of the mountain where the others can't patrol.”

          “And why not?” Lord Ecthelion II said as he stepped forward from the crowd. Thorin noted how Bard stared at the man. Thorin also tried to ignore how Thranduil was looming behind Bard like a giant bat. And in their shadow was young Aragorn, watching on.

          “Because parts of the mountain are too dangerous for your folk to traverse.” Dwalin's voice was flat as he gave the man the look he deserved. “Parts of the mountain are too dangerous for even some of our own folk to walk through. The dragon did far more damage than we can explain.”

          Lord Ecthelion II frowned but did not look as abashed as Thorin thought he should have. “Surely our people can be taught,” the man said.

          Thorin raised an eyebrow at that. “Can your people see in the dark as dwarves do?” He saw the man look away. “Dwalin is the Captain of the Guard. He and Bofur will know where best our allies can patrol, where it is safe for them – and us – to do so.” Thorin swept his gaze over the crowd and then back to Eönwë. “Is that acceptable, Lord Eönwë?”

          The herald of Manwë gave him a deep bow. “More than. You are a wise ruler, King Thorin Oakenshield.”

          Thorin tried not to stand straighter at the praise. “Thank you.”

          “While I cannot speak for all of the elves outside of your mountain, I am more than willing to place myself under Lord Dwalin's guard and patrol where I am permitted,” Maedhros said with a bow. Thorin caught the wrinkle of Dwalin's nose at being addressed as a lord. His Dwalin had always hated that.

          “Well, I can speak for some of the elves outside,” Thranduil spoke up, still not moving from his place behind Bard. “We are willing to work with our...allies,” there was a slow smile to Thranduil's face that Thorin wanted to punch off on principle. “Are you willing...Lord Dwalin?”

          Thorin put a hand on Dwalin's arm while he noted the way Bard's elbow made contact with Thranduil's midsection. “We would be willing, of course,” Thorin did his best to smile back at the elven king. From Thranduil's smirk it probably looked as forced as it felt. He saw Lord Ecthelion II and Prince Thengel exchange looks and then both the men were bowing to them as well.

          “We are willing as well,” they said together.

          “As would the Rangers,” Aragorn said as he stepped forward at last.

          Thorin nodded, drawing in a breath and letting it out slowly. “Good. We will finalize a rotating roster tomorrow. Perhaps the wizards can lay their spells tonight, so that we might have that first layer of protection put in place as soon as possible?”

          Gandalf was the one to step forward and bow his head. “We will do that immediately. Perhaps the Lady Galadriel could join us?”

          “As you see fit,” Thorin said. He noted the way Saruman's nose wrinkled when the lady's name was mentioned. Interesting.

          “Gentlemen,” Balin's welcome voice said from the back of the crowd. “This way, if you please.”

          Thorin let out a breath as the last of the crowd trickled out of their rooms. The wizards were last – namely Saruman – casting looks back at where the Silmaril lay, but under Gandalf's gentle prodding they all left.

          Finally.

          Dwalin's warm hand settled on his shoulder. “What a day,” he said.

          It startled a laugh out of Thorin. He ran a hand down his face as the laughter came bubbling out of him. “Yes and it is barely noon at that,” he said, sobering as he thought back to the throne room and the missing Arkenstone. “I thought I would be furious,” he said as the laughter died away. He looked up at Dwalin. “At the loss of the Arkenstone.”

          “But you are not.”

          Thorin paused and then shook his head. “I am angry,” he said slowly. “But more for the wreckage of our mountain. I am worried that the Arkenstone has been stolen. I am very concerned about it. But...”

          “But?”

          Thorin pressed his lips together and frowned, trying to sort through his thoughts. “The Silmaril that was stolen – the Arkenstone – was shadowed.” Dwalin nodded at his side. “The one here is not. It feels...” He growled, not sure just what he wanted to say. “I am concerned,” he repeated. “But not scared. Not anxious. It feels as though the loss of the Arkenstone is not something that will break us, or that will bring about the end of the world.”

          “And if we lost the one here?”

          Ice slid down his spine. Thorin's breath caught. “That cannot happen,” he turned to look at the stone, a faint glow coming from the deep blue gem. “It cannot be taken.”

          “Or?”

          Thorin looked to Dwalin then. “That, I fear, is when things will take a turn far to the worst.”

          “But you are not...possessive of it?”

          Thorin blinked at that. Then he blinked again and had to look away. “I will not horde it like a dragon,” he said, voice rough. “I swear it.”

          Dwalin's arms came about him, holding him tight. “We were all affected by the gold madness,” Dwalin whispered into his hair. “I worry that some dark force is trying to infect us all once more. That is all. I do not mean to doubt you or have you believe that I am.”

          Thorin leaned into his warmth, the tension draining out of him. “I know that,” he said just as soft. “It is good to be vigilant. Something is moving about us, some shadow or dark force that we cannot see or predict. But I think...”

          “Thorin?”

          “I think if the Silmaril is kept here, in the mountain, under the blessing of...” He could not finish the sentence. Dwalin's arms tightened around him. “I think they will watch over us,” he said on a breath of a whisper, for Dwalin's ears alone. “I think Bilbo will watch over us, and keep us safe.”

          Dwalin said nothing in return. He just held Thorin all the tighter in the quiet of their rooms, they two alone.

 

 

~*~

 

 

          Bilbo was running with Fortinbras down the tunnels of the in between, a stitch forming in his side. The Bounders who had been keeping an eye over the throne room had cried out, loud enough to catch the attention of others inside the in between, but when the other hobbits had come to check on them, all the Bounders had been found unconscious where they lay. A runner had come to inform Fortinbras and Bilbo had been with his cousin when the news came in. So together they followed that same runner to the tunnels above the throne room, a low panic tightening Bilbo's throat.

          They turned the last corner and almost fell over a crowd of hobbits. Bilbo caught his cousin before Fortinbras could fall, the two of them panting, hands on their sides, as they looked over the mess of hobbits spread out before them. Bilbo blinked and then blinked again as he realized that most of those in the hallway were widows and not the concerned hobbits that had been alerted by the Bounder's cries.

          “What's happened? Are they alright?”

          “Be still,” a veiled widow snapped at him. Bilbo closed his mouth so quick his teeth clacked together. The veiled widows had been appearing more and more outside the Great Smials, coming to their people in ones and twos, and spreading old tales as they did so. Bilbo had a theory about these veiled widows, a theory that made him shiver at night when Bag End was quiet and still about him, a theory he did not try to think long on. It was a theory he would learn was either right or wrong on the eve of the Longest Night, which was coming upon them far too quick for anyone's liking.

          Now, though, the hallway was all but filled with these same veiled widows, far more than Bilbo had ever seen before. They were all checking on the Bounders, their hands glowing with a magic that Bilbo had not encountered yet. Some of their midwives had experienced strange bursts of magic, as well as a few of their doctors, when small bumps and bruises arose after their feet had begun to heal. There was also another knot of widows huddled around an open door that led from the in between. It was...strange and almost made Bilbo's eyes cross when he tried to focus on it. There was one widow in particular who was braced against the edges of the door, her knuckles white as she stared at something below.

          Then her head turned and that black veil was directed at...him?

          Oh no.

          “You,” the widow said, one finger pointing at his chest. “Come here.”

          Bilbo's feet were moving before he could say yes or no. He knelt where the widow pointed and then her hand was on the back of his neck, pushing him forward, causing him to catch his own hands against the edge of the door before he fell through it.

          “Do you see?” Her voice was rough though the hold on the back of his neck gentled.

          “What – I don't – is that...is that the throne?” Bilbo couldn't help but gasp. “Where – where is the Arkenstone?”

          “The stone,” the widow echoed his words. “Has been taken.”

          “Taken?” Bilbo couldn't help the way his voice cracked on the word. Fortinbras was also hauled forward to kneel next to Bilbo, the two of them staring out through the strange portal the widow had made. “How? By whom?”

          “Were one'a them blue ones,” a wavering voice to Bilbo's left said. He turned to see one of the Bounders – Remy Oldwalker – laid out with his head in the lap of a widow as another held his hands over the Bounder and healed what looked like strange black wounds on his body. “They come in an' just blasted the stone t'bits.”

          “Blue ones,” Bilbo repeated, blinking at the Bounder. Then, “Wait, do you mean one of the blue wizards?”

          “Them robe wearin' ones, ya,” Remy's eyes blinked slower and slower.

          “Is he – Remy? Remy!”

          “He will be fine,” the hand on the back of Bilbo's neck gave him a shake. “Eyes front, lad. Tell me who is who down there.”

          “Me? What –”

          “Bilbo of the Baggins clan,” the hand shook him again. “Name the ones down there for me to know!”

          Bilbo glanced up at the widow, his breath coming short in his lungs. This close all he could make out was her eyes, glowing a deep blue. Bilbo gulped and looked back down through the strange portal, naming all that he saw, stumbling only once as he named Thorin. When he named Maedhros the hand on his neck tightened and Bilbo went quiet.

          “Maedhros,” she murmured. “So it is you.”

          Bilbo glanced at her from the corner of his eye. “You...do you know him? But he's – he's...”

          “That's widow's business, young Bilbo of the Baggins clan,” she said as she let her grip drop from his neck.

          “But –”

          “You'll shut your mouth, young one, or I'll shut it for you.” She flicked his ear, causing Bilbo to flinch back from the door. Then her attention caught on something the ones below them said – Bilbo couldn't quite make it out – but her displeased hiss was enough to fill the entire hallway. Bilbo felt Fortinbras' arm come about his waist and haul him back as the widow reached out into...somewhere...and came back with a handful of black and pink stones, casting them out of the portal and down onto...yes, onto Maedhros below.

          Bilbo saw the scramble that caused on the crowd in the throne room just as the widow sat back and the portal closed, sealing them back into the tunnels and out of sight of any curious and powerful eyes. Bilbo exchanged a look with his cousin as the widow stood in fits and starts, one hand pressed against the wall when she got to standing.

          “The blue wizards are unwelcome in our home,” her voice rolled over them like a thunderclap. Bilbo shivered at the power in it. “We cannot drive them out and we cannot tell the dwarrow of what we know, but the blue ones are to be watched at all times.”

          There were immediate “Yes, ma'ams” up and down the hall.

          “But if the dwarrow do not know, if the elves do not know, then how can we protect them?” Bilbo pushed to his knees, ignoring the way Fortinbras tried to haul him back.

          “That,” the widow pointed a long finger at him, “is widows business.”

          “But!”

          “Enough!” Her hand cut through the air. Bilbo flinched back, feeling Fortinbras' hand settle against his shoulder. “Enough,” her tone was gentler this time as she dropped her hand to her side. “I understand your worry and echo it, young Bilbo of the Baggins clan. It is too dangerous to tell the dwarrow or any of the spirits below what we know, for the shadow is growing too thick in the mountain to attempt that, now.”

          “The...shadow?” Bilbo found his voice to ask.

          “You know of what I speak,” she sighed and it felt like the whole hall sighed with her. “We must make ready. The eve of the longest night falls upon us in three days time. Something comes,” her head turned and with her turned all the widows, all as one. It made Bilbo's skin prickle with unease. “A dark power we have not felt for...a very long time is trying to draw near. It is trying to break what we have tried to fix, ever since we were created.” Her head came up and Bilbo felt a prickle of something sweep over them all. Even the Bounders seemed to feel is, stirring where they lay, some of them opening their eyes long enough to reach out a hand towards the widow. “No,” the widow said, voice hard as she gathered her skirts up close to her. Many of the other widows rose as well. “No, this time...this time we will fix it all.” And with that the widow swept from the hall, several of the others following her, while others stayed with their Bounders, healing them where they lay.

          “Well, then,” said Fortinbras from behind Bilbo.

          “Well, then,” Bilbo agreed. They shared a look and got to their feet, careful of the tangle of limbs about them. “You need to tell Lalia about all this.”

          Fortinbras made an immediate face. “Oh, come now, surely someone else would have told her?”

          Bilbo just gave him a look.

          Fortinbras sighed and his shoulders slumped. “Right. Yes. Let's go tell my wife that there is even more to prepare for during the longest night rites, but that we don't know just what that is.”

          Bilbo blanched at that. “I'll just leave you to it, shall I?”

          A hand caught the back of his shirt before Bilbo could bolt to freedom. “Oh, no,” Fortinbras was as grim as Bilbo had ever seen him. “You're with me, lad. We both get to tell her.”

          “But!”

          That hand holding the back of his shirt gave him a rattle hard enough that Bilbo thought some of his teeth would come loose. “Nope,” Fortinbras said as he began marching Bilbo on ahead of him. “We're in this together. Come along.”

          “But Fortinbras!”

          Their voices echoed down the hallway even as Fortinbras marched them onward. Behind them other hobbits streamed into the hall, helping the widows as they healed the last of the Bounders. They were stopped a number of times to allow Fortinbras to pass on the widows' message and each time a runner would take his words onward to another section of their tunnels. It was by far the most hobbits Bilbo had ever seen in the in between, all of them wearing bits of flowers or vines tucked about their persons, their old magics all but sparking from their fingers at times.

          Then the door to the Great Smials was before them and Bilbo made one last valiant attempt to flee for his life. Fortinbras caught him with ease. Defeated, Bilbo lay limp in his cousin's arms, allowing himself to be dragged into the room and to face Lalia's wrath. His cousin's wife did not like surprises or to have her plans changed at the ninth hour. Bilbo knew it was going to be a mess. But it was a mess they would have to face. The widows' words were law, more so now than ever before.

          They would face what would come and they would fix it or die trying. There was no other way out, now. And Bilbo would far prefer to live after all this, thank you and good morning. So.

          It was time to get to work.

 

Chapter 27: on the precipice

Chapter Text

 

         Thorin looked up from the report spread out on the table to see Gandalf and Maedhros duck into the tent where Thorin had settled into. The loss of the Silmaril had hit the encampment hard, causing unrest throughout all who had gathered on Thorin's front lawn. The wizards had spent much of the rest of the day – and some of the night – going up and down the hallway of the Royal Wing, muttering and doing whatever business wizards did in the world. Thorin had requested that Gandalf do most of the warding about Thorin and Dwalin's rooms while the other wizards, save Radagast, did the rest. He knew Saruman had a bit of stink about it but Thorin didn't much care. He trusted exactly one of those wizards and Gandalf was it. Thankfully Gandalf had agreed and the protections about their rooms and door were laid double quick.

         “How goes the search of the camp?” Thorin said as he looked back down at the report. He had come out to the tents to be with the rest of the encampment, so that no one could accuse him of hiding inside his mountain or hording the Silmaril. There had already been mutterings of that going about the tents of the men, though not with the Rangers, Nori had whispered to him on his walk outside. Thorin had left Dwalin in their rooms once more, though he knew Dwalin hated the idea of it, unwilling to allow the Silmaril to be left alone for a minute. If Dwalin was not there then Thorin would be, until whatever strangeness that had settled on the world came to an end.

         “Slow,” Gandalf's tone was grim. He sat with a sigh in a chair opposite Thorin, looking a bit wan and pale. “Lord Ecthelion II is refusing to allow anyone but his own people to search their tents.”

         Thorin frowned at that, sitting back as he glanced between the wizard and the elf. “We have already said we do not believe a man could do such damage to the throne by themselves,” Thorin pointed out. “A search is to make sure no one – or no strange power – is attempting to set us upon one another.”

         “And that is the issue,” Gandalf shook his head, his mouth twisted down into a frown. “Lord Ecthelion II claims that by insisting to search their tents with your people – or even by my Order – is claiming that there is already division among our ranks.”

         Thorin had to pause there, because Lord Ecthelion II did have a point. “There is some legitimacy to that.”

         “Is there?” Maedhros raised an eyebrow at him. “Ecthelion of the Fountain and I have already allowed our tents to be searched, both by your own people and by Lord Ecthelion II's people. Thranduil is allowing his people's tents to be searched but only by Bard's small contingent with your King's Guard watching on.” He smiled a bit. “I am told that your nephew Kíli is helping them.”

         Thorin slid the palm of his hand down his face with a noisy sigh. “You mean he's too busy mooning at that elf of his to do more than glance at the tents they pass.”

         Maedhros' smile was small but true. “He does seem rather...enthusiastic when Tauriel is near.”

         Thorin closed his eyes against that. “You mean he's showing off and being an idiot.”

         “Perhaps,” laughter was thick in Maedhros' voice at the word. “Is it so wrong? He clearly...cares for her.”

         Thorin made a face at the thought of what nonsense was going to come out of Thranduil's mouth in the coming days. “I have no objection to my nephew's choice in partners. I worry,” he slanted a long look at the still-smiling elf. “That their ages might be a problem, and that Tauriel may be hesitant to accept Kíli's suit, considering...”

         “Yes,” Maedhros' smile faded at that. “There is that.”

         “But,” Gandalf said as he got his pipe out and began to light it. “You have not considered a very pertinent fact.”

         “And that is?” Thorin raised his eyebrows at the wizard.

         Gandalf leaned back as he puffed out a series of large smoke circles, each bigger than the last. The final circle was...strange, not perfectly round, but flat on the bottom, looking almost like a door. “If the Healing of Arda is truly upon us,” the wizard said as that final smoke circle began to wisp away. “Then we do not know what that shall do to all who live on these far shores.”

         Thorin glanced at Maedhros but the elf looked as confused as Thorin felt. “What do you mean?”

         Gandalf tapped the stem of his pipe against his lips, his eyes focused on some far distant point. “I do not have clear memories of the Timeless Halls,” he began. Thorin curled his fingers into a loose fist on the table. He had known, of course, that Gandalf was no mere mortal man, and Eönwë's presence in Arda had confirmed that. But to hear that Gandalf was...that he was...

         “The Song that Eru Ilúvatar showed all of the spirits in His Halls was a creation I cannot explain.” Gandalf puffed out a series of strange shapes that made Thorin's eyes cross when he tried to focus on them. “In the beginning...” A strange smile tugged at Gandalf's mouth as he shook his head. “In the beginning,” he continued, “we did not sing as a chorus as we later did. We sang one by one, or rarely two together, while all listened and hearkened to the Song that only Eru alone knew. But bit by bit, as we listened to the songs of our brethren, we began to...see a vision that was given to us by Eru Himself.”

         As the wizard spoke more and more figures began to slip into the tent. There was Lord Elrond, followed by the Lady Galadriel, along with Balin and Master Erestor right behind him. Following the slight elf came the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion, who took seats on either side of Erestor, placing themselves between Lord Elrond's councilor and Maedhros. Thorin had to bite down on his cheek to keep from smiling at the sight.

         “Eru Ilúvatar then declared to us a mighty Theme,” Gandalf said as silence settled over the table. Thorin saw Prince Thengel and Lord Ecthelion II slip in, alongside Bard and Thranduil, taking their own seats at the table. “He sang to us,” Gandalf's voice dipped into a murmur, his eyes glowing in the light of the crystals that Thorin had brought out for the tents. The iron fire pits held banked coals in the corners of the room, pushing away the growing cold of the winter days. It was two days to Yule and it was starting to feel like it at last. “The Song He sang unfolded before us as a great vision, one that grew and grew in our minds until we could comprehend it no more. It was after such a song that Eru Ilúvatar had us join in to that great Song, adorning His theme with our powers and delight.” His smile faded. “It was in that chorus of voices that Morgoth – then Melkor – began to sow discord and dissent among the Ainur, trying to take over the theme and ruin the Vision that had been laid out before us.”

         Gandalf seemed to give himself a shake and his gaze swept over those who had gathered in the tent. “I tell you this, because never before had such a Song been sung in the Timeless Halls and never since. But.” His gaze swept over them again and it made something shiver down Thorin's spine when that gaze settled onto him. “It has been said that a greater music shall be made by the choirs of the Ainur and the Children of Ilúvatar after the end of days.” He puffed on his pipe for a moment. Then, “Should that day come. And what happens after that day, to the length of the lives of those who live on Arda's shores as compared to the Eldar, we do not know. But first,” Gandalf blew out another smoke ring. “Morgoth must be defeated.”

         “I was of the impression that Morgoth's defeat had been foreseen by Eru Ilúvatar Himself,” Lady Galadriel said into the silence left by Gandalf's words.

         “Was it from Melian that you heard such words?” Saruman's said as he ducked into the tent. He stared down his nose at the full table, a twist of distaste to his mouth present until Balin had someone bring in another seat. The wizard settled himself near one of the banked fire pits, something Thorin had noted that the wizard often did.

         “The Lady did speak to me of such things, yes,” Lady Galadriel said.

         Saruman made a huffing sound as he drew out his own pipe and lit it with a taper thrust into the coals. It scraped back some of the ash, leaving the red-hot coals exposed like a gleaming red eye in the corner. “She would do such a thing,” the wizard grumbled as he began to puff out his own smoke rings.

         “She is not wrong,” Gandalf said.

         “She is also not right,” Saruman pointed his pipe at the other wizard. “Morgoth's defeat was prophesied, as Lord Eönwë has said. But,” he thrust the stem of his pipe at Gandalf. “That prophecy is now defunct.”

         “It is,” said the herald of Manwë himself. Eönwë held up a hand as many made to stand at his appearance. He took the seat that Erestor offered with a bow. The elf stepped back to stand against the edge of the tent, his papers clutched close to his chest. Thorin noted the way both lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion went tense as Erestor left them.

         Interesting.

         All eyes had turned to Eönwë. “As I said when we arrived,” he glanced at Ecthelion next to him and then to Maedhros, “the Song has changed. The protections about Aman are almost completely broken.” Murmurs rose up around him. “Late last night I received message from my Lord Manwë that very soon the realm of Valinor will return to the world that Is and what happens after that...” Eönwë shook his head, small lines appearing about his mouth and eyes. “We do not know. Already there are reports of great waves starting to wash upon the western shores of Arda.”

         “It is true,” Lord Ecthelion II sat forward then. There were dark smudges under his eyes. “We received word that Gondor's ports are being broken down by these waves and that the trade ships are having problems finding safe ports to dock in.” He shared a look with Prince Thengel that Thorin could not read. “The winter grains that Gondor imports have taken a large loss, both by the destruction of the Shire and now with issue of the ships being unable to unload.” His expression turned grim. “There is already talk of possible rations until the summer crops come in.”

         “My father is planning to send Riders to help with guiding and protecting the overland caravans from the southlands to Gondor,” Prince Thengel spoke up then. “But the way is long and there is much spoilage in the trip. More so should that grain make its way to Rohan. And that is saying nothing of possible attacks from bandits or hungry villagers that they pass.”

         Thorin curled his hand into a fist in his lap. He could almost see the divide starting to form around the table.

         “And the search for the Silmaril?” Saruman said from his spot near the brazier. Thorin saw how several of the lords went stiff at his words.

         “It is still missing,” Thorin said, forcing his hand to relax in his lap. He placed it on the table, palm flat, as he swept a look over the gathered lords and lady. “All of the encampment has been searched. I thank you for your patience and your cooperation,” he gave the lords Ecthelion II and Thengel a half-bow from his seat. He was pleased to see some of the tension leave them at that.

         “Someone in this encampment stole the Silmaril,” Saruman snapped, thrusting the stem of his pipe at Thorin. “The fact that you cannot find them concerns me. Especially since you still have possession of the second.”

         Thorin took in a slow breath, keeping a firm hold on his temper. “I am aware,” he said, tone as dry as dust. “Since you have pointed out that fact many times in as many hours.”

         Saruman let out a loud huff as he went back to puffing on his pipe. His dark brows were drawn down into a fearsome scowl.

         “And we will find the Arkenstone,” Thorin continued, keeping his gaze on Saruman. He saw the way the wizard's mouth drew down even further. It was a wonder he even managed to smoke his pipe with a scowl like that on his face. Then Thorin transferred his attention back to Eönwë. “You say that great waves are breaking against the shores of Arda,” he said. The herald of Manwë nodded. “What will happen when all of Valinor returns to this world?”

         “That,” Eönwë said with a grave expression. “Is something we do not know. Perhaps nothing. Perhaps more of the same. And perhaps...”

         “A great wave,” the young Aragorn said from his seat by the door. He had been one of the last men to arrive, slipping in without a word said to anyone. His eyes were shadowed as he glanced about the table.

         “Perhaps,” Eönwë sighed. “We can only hope that Lord Ulmo will help calm the seas should that happen.”

         Mention of that Vala made Thorin think back to his own time in the waters under the mountain. “Would the Lady Uinen help as well?”

         Eönwë looked at him. “All of those who serve Lord Ulmo would do as he asked.”

         Thorin frowned down at his hand, tapping his fingers against the table. “Would...would the Silmaril that was returned to us, the one from the waters,” he looked up at Eönwë. “Would it be best to take it to the shores and see if it would help against the waves that are breaking now and that which might come in the future?”

         That caused more than one murmur to ripple around the table. Even Eönwë looked shocked at his words. “I do not know,” Eönwë said and glanced at Maedhros.

         “The Silmarils are not mere toys to be played with,” Saruman spat as he sat up in his chair. The brazier next to him seemed to glow brighter with his anger. “They are not to be waved about at the seas like some kind of tool!”

         “Then why are they here?” Lord Ecthelion II frowned back at the wizard. “Surely they can help us!”

         “They are to be kept safe!” Saruman's grip about his pipe was so tight his knuckles had bleached white.

         “Safe for what?” Lord Ecthelion II shook his head. “Things are changing.” He nodded to Eönwë. “The very herald of Manwë has told us so. Two of the three Silmarils have returned to Arda. Surely this is a sign from the Valar that they are to be used?”

         “Then Lord Manwë would say as much!” Saruman shook his head. “They should have been given to me – to the wizards and to Lord Eönwë the second we realized what the stone in that throne was and when King Thorin returned with a second from the depths of his mountain.”

         “To what purpose?” Lord Ecthelion II pressed. “To be kept safe? Fine. But safe for what? To what purpose would you use them?”

         “For what might come!” Saruman surged to his feet. Thorin blinked at how the fire behind him flickered back into active flame. “I fear we are perilously close to the breaking of the world,” Saruman's dark gaze swept across the table. “The Silmarils have long been thought to be the tools with which the world is then healed after the great battle that was to take place. But that, too, is changing. The prophecy of Mandos is no more. But the Silmarils have still come, so therefore,” his gaze went back to Lord Ecthelion II. “They still have some role to play in what might come. And to whose use they should come under,” he shook his head. “That is yet to be seen.”

         “I agree with you, that the Silmarils have some part to play in what might come,” Eönwë said after a moment. All eyes swung to him. “But fearing that they might be used by Morgoth to achieve his own plans, and thus hidden away, would defeat the purpose of having them here.”

         Saruman scoffed at that, turning away. “You think he would plan for such a thing? That my – my own wisdom is not enough to account for such a thing and then dismiss it? No.” He shook his head. “I fear that Morgoth's hooks are not just in these holy gems but also in the people here on Arda.” His shoulders slumped and he sank back down into his seat. “The shadow of Morgoth's evil has ever been long. His mark has been left on this world whether we like it or not. It cannot be erased until that evil spirit is gone for good.”

         “Well,” said Gandalf as he lowered his own pipe. Thorin had noted the way Gandalf's gaze had not left Saruman for a minute. “I would argue that point, old friend.”

         Saruman's head came up. “What point?”

         Gandalf lowered his pipe. “Have you not felt it?”

         Thorin saw the way Saruman shifted back in his seat, frowning back at the other wizard. “Felt what?”

         Gandalf looked at the Lady Galadriel, who nodded, then at Eönwë, who frowned at him, tilting his head to one side. “Lady Galadriel said it best. That the air has become clearer, the waters sweeter, but only here, at Erebor.” Gandalf looked back at Saruman. “Morgoth's shadow has been seen, yes, but it is fighting something, I believe. Something that is pressing back against that darkness and corruption that Morgoth left on the world and...fixing it.”

         “Fixing it?” Saruman snorted, turning his face away. “What nonsense. There is no fixing it. Only Eru Ilúvatar can do such a thing. To imply otherwise is blasphemy.”

         “Blasphemy,” Gandalf murmured, pressing his lips together for a moment. “You know that He would not care for such words, old friend. Have a care for how you speak.”

         Saruman's shoulders came up about his ears. His arms were folded across his chest. “I am a creature of order,” he said, still not meeting the other wizard's gaze. “I understand patterns, how things work. None of this makes sense and you are ready to go haring off on strange half-baked ideas that sound more like something Radagast would think up in the depths of one of his mushroom-induced dream states!”

         Small lines seemed to ease about Gandalf's eyes and mouth at that. “I know how you desire for the world to make sense, to be orderly and methodical. But I am afraid that is not how the world works.”

         “It should work like that,” Saruman muttered, still curled in about himself.

         “Saruman,” Gandalf sighed, leaning forward to place a hand on Saruman's knee. The other wizard moved away from his touch. A look of sadness passed over Gandalf's face, there and gone, as he leaned back in his chair. “How can we make this easier for you, my friend? You placed your own protections about the hallways that lead to the Royal Wing. What else can be done to ease your worry? And perhaps,” Gandalf cast a glance about the table. “The worries of the others here?”

         Thorin followed that gaze, taking note of the signs of concern on many of the men's faces.

         Saruman's sigh drew Thorin's attention once more. “I would have King Thorin show me more of the mountain. If you can,” the wizard added on, his arms dropping from his middle. “You can explain your theory of some strange spirits fixing things to the others while I go do something productive,” he sniffed at that. Gandalf rolled his eyes at the other wizard, but the look he turned on Thorin was a touch pleading.

         “King Thorin, would you be willing to do that for Saruman?”

         Thorin did not want to leave the tent. Thorin wanted to hear about Gandalf's theory and how it possibly pertained to the spirits Thorin was increasingly convinced were inside Erebor. But he also knew that there was a delicate line he needed to walk here. The men were already staring at him with suspicious eyes. He could not risk more distrust being sown here.

         “I will take you were it is safe,” Thorin said with a nod. He caught Balin's eye and his old friend gave him a strained smile. He knew Balin would tell him all that Thorin would miss as he played a glorified guide to a wizard he would rather boot in the rear.

         “I wish to see all of the mountain,” Saruman said with a huff as he stood. Thorin stood as well, hating how the wizard towered over him.

         “All of the mountain you cannot see,” Thorin held onto his patience with both hands. “The mountain is not completely safe for even my people as I have said. Multiple times,” he pinned the wizard with a look. “But I can take you were it is safe, and there are more places than you have yet seen that can be examined. Would that work?”

         “If it must,” Saruman said as he all but flounced from the room.

         “Thank you, King Thorin,” Gandalf said as Thorin passed him.

         “You owe me,” Thorin muttered at the wizard, just low enough for the two of them alone. And perhaps the elves.

         “As you say,” Gandalf's smile was far more amused than it should be. “I will speak to you later of my theories, should you wish,” he added, his smile turning gentle.

         “That would be most welcome,” Thorin said.

         “King Thorin!” Saruman's called from outside the tent.

         “Yes, coming,” Thorin gave Gandalf one more look and then stepped through the tent door to find Saruman already stalking towards Erebor's gates. His shadow seemed to stretch back almost to Thorin's feet but the sun was setting and the mountain's own shadow was starting to loom large over the encampment as well.

         Thorin did not jog to catch up to the wizard. He was pleased to see how the guards at the gates kept Saruman in place until Thorin could reach his side, smiling up at the wizard as Saruman huffed and puffed and leaned on his staff as he glared at the guards. “This way,” he told Saruman as he gave the guards a nod and stepped ahead of the wizard and into the darkness of the mountain beyond.

         In Thorin's youth the entrance to Erebor was once full of light and busy with people at almost every moment of the day and night. There were visitors from Dale and beyond, along with traders coming in from most of the known world. At times there had even been envoys from the southlands, places like Harad and Rhûn, though they had been few and far between. The main gates opened up to a grand hall that had suffered much damage when the dragon came. The tall statues of their forefathers had been cracked in half at some point, with the one on the right missing its head completely. They still had not found it.

         The granite floors had once been polished so fine that they would reflect the light of the torches that illuminated the hall. The thick pillars that held up the ceiling far above their heads had also been damaged by Smaug's arrival, which had led to the iron bars being fastened to the most obviously broken areas. Both Bofur and Bifur had agreed that the central supports of those thick pillars had not been damaged and that most of what was seen was cosmetic, but they preferred to err on the side of caution. Thorin had gotten word that all of their artisan's clans would be arriving in the weeks following Yule, so perhaps more repairs to their mountain could be had sooner rather than later.

         But, as Thorin walked with the wizard through the quiet hall, Thorin had to admit that the pillars were looking far better than Thorin remembered. The thick cracks in the stone almost seemed to have...not vanished, exactly, but gotten smaller, thinner, as if they were disappearing.

         Or being fixed.

         Thorin let out a breath at that, pushing the thought away for now. As they walked deeper into the hall, the crystal lights began to spark to life, their glow catching on the gold inlays set into those towering pillars and bringing the details of those reliefs to life. Thorin avoided the deep gouges that Smaug's claws had carved into the granite floors as he led the wizard past the pillars and into the central chamber of Erebor.

         “Most of this floor is damaged to some degree, but many of the support pillars are still holding.” Thorin pointed to the arching pathways and the stairs that used to crisscross the deep cavern before them. “All of these are suspect and a few, as you can see, are destroyed. I cannot take you on them.”

         “I see,” Saruman's voice was deeper than Thorin had heard it before. He stepped up next to Thorin on the edge of the chasm, his staff planted before him as he glanced down. “And below us?”

         Thorin followed his gaze. “The mountain has many levels,” he said, able to pick out old hallways that lay in the shadows. “Many made their homes above and below this central chamber.”

         “And what was this chamber used for?”

         Thorin glanced up at the wizard, a little surprised at how interested Saruman sounded. “Food,” he said after a brief pause. He pointed to the ledges that lined the southern edge of the chamber and then over to the smaller areas on the east and western sides. “Great mirrors were set up when the mountain was first inhabited to allow more light into this area.”

         “So this was natural?” Saruman squinted at the areas Thorin had pointed out.

         “This chamber?” Thorin saw Saruman nod. “Yes.”

         “How interesting,” Saruman muttered, leaning forward on his staff. Thorin put a hand on the wizard's arm, which earned him a sharp look.

         “There are no handrails,” Thorin said. “And the fall is steep.”

         “A wizard has many abilities. Such a fall would hurt but I would survive such a thing.” But the wizard did lean back – and away – from the edge of the chasm. “Do you know how this mountain was formed?”

         “Originally? No,” Thorin gestured to the left, leading the wizard away from the main hall that came from the gates. “It was suspected that it was a volcano, once.”

         “A volcano,” Saruman echoed. “How interesting.” Thorin frowned at that but Saruman did not seem to notice. His gaze was for the central chasm and the bridges and stairs built over it. “Are you quite sure of this?”

         Thorin paused, not wanting to impart more lore of the mountain to the wizard but Saruman was a member of the same Order as Gandalf. Surely it could not hurt. “It was said that when our people first came here, there was still a glow at the very depths of the mountain.” He stopped at a ledge where they could step out onto a point, looking out over the chamber. The light of the sunset was barely making it into the mountain, the huge mirrors still too dusty and grimy from smoke and soot from the dragon to reflect much at the moment, if they were still intact. They were yet one more thing on the long list of things that Thorin needed to have his people check on, clean, or repair in the mountain. He swept a hand over the cavern below them. From their vantage point the pit seemed bottomless. “Here is where our first king of Erebor stood and looked below and beheld that glow,” he said.

         “Was it still warm? Was that recorded at all?”

         Thorin blinked at the question. “It was warm,” he said, glancing up at the wizard. “The chamber stayed warm for many centuries. It was said that warmth helped the gardens carved into this chamber grow and feed our people, until we could fashion another system that made up for the heart of the mountain going cool.”

         “How fascinating,” Saruman stroked his beard, his dark eyes shadowed in the dim light of the chamber. “And was this heat in the belly of your mountain...used for anything?”

         Thorin had to think about that. “As in a smithy?”

         “Yes.”

         “No,” Thorin shook his head. “It was considered sacred, a sign from our Maker. We would not use it in such a fashion.”

         “I see,” Saruman stroked his beard again, but there was a thoughtful tilt to his mouth that Thorin had never seen before. “And this Bilbo Baggins,” the wizard's words made Thorin want to shiver but he didn't know why. “You have seen him before in this very same chamber?”

         Thorin peered up at the wizard. “You heard about that?”

         “I did.”

         Thorin waited but the wizard would not meet his gaze, staring down into the darkness as if it alone held all the answers. “I did see Bilbo here,” Thorin said slowly, watching the wizard's face. “I was with my cousin Dáin and several others. They all saw him.” And someone tried to kill him, Thorin did not say.

         “Here, above the chasm? Hanging like a specter?”

         “No,” Thorin could not make out why the wizard was so intent on this. “He stood there,” Thorin pointed up at one of the walkways.

         Saruman drew himself up, his hand dropping to his side. “I want to go up there.”

         “You cannot,” Thorin was quick to say.

         “And why not?”

         “All the ramps leading to that area are damaged,” Thorin held onto his patience with all his might. He pointed to the right, where the ramp led down to an area that was almost completely destroyed, with only the bare metal rods that had once held up the sides of the ramp were exposed. “The stone will crumble under my feet, much less yours.”

         “Then we can get to it from above!”

         “Again,” Thorin drew in a slow breath. “The ramps above are just as damaged.” His finger moved to the gaping hole in the stairways and ramps that once crisscrossed the space like the most delicate of lace. “It looks as though the dragon tried to fly out of the central chamber at least once and could not. But his attempt left the walkways broken beyond our current ability to repair.”

         Saruman's staff thumped against the ground, sounding strangely hollow. “Nonsense. There must be a way to get there.”

         Thorin frowned up at the wizard. “Why are you so intent to see the area? The balcony above the gates is a place that Bilbo was seen as well.”

         That got the wizard's attention. “Was he, now?”

         “Yes,” Thorin tried to see just what Saruman's interest in Bilbo was but he could not make it out. “Would you like to see that instead?”

         “Yes. Show me.”

         Thorin raised his eyebrows at that.

         The wizard huffed, dark brows drawn together in a scowl. “Please.”

         Thorin left his eyebrows up as he turned and led Saruman away from the central cavern. He kept quiet the entire walk, not about to be pleasant to a wizard who refused to use basic courtesies when even the most wild of his Order did. At least Radagast said please and thank you. Most of the time.

         The wind was biting as Thorin led the wizard out into the twilight-lit balcony. The sun was setting fast this close to Yule, the dark stretch of the mountain's shadow reaching out over the land. Thorin tugged his jacket closed as the wind came screaming past him, blowing his hair in his face and making his raise his hands to shield his eyes. Saruman strode forward, his dark hair waving like a banner, his robes flapping about his body. The bulk of that heavy fabric made his silhouette strange for a moment, outlining not a man but some strange mass that looked like a man with perhaps too many limbs. Then Thorin blinked and he could see how the wizard was wearing possibly every single robe he had, plus perhaps thick woolen trousers underneath it all. Thorin could only guess that the wizard felt the cold more keenly than his brethren, which would explain why he was forever haunting the braziers in the tents and elsewhere.

         “The hobbit was here?” Saruman's words could barely be heard over the scream of the wind.

         “Yes,” Thorin had to stop and cough, his breath taken away by that frigid air. He had never felt it be so cold on the balcony before. He pushed against the battering wind until he was at the wizard's side. Thorin could not look down, for right where the wizard had stopped was where Thorin...where he had... “Bilbo appeared here when we...when we came to take back our – my – pronouncement of Exile. It was here we named him a dwarf-friend of Erebor, for now and forevermore.”

         “I am certain Gandalf had much to say about that,” Saruman sounded as sour as his expression.

         “Gandalf did have much to say about it, yes,” Thorin shivered as the wind gust eased, but the chill had cut him right to the bone.

         “Where exactly was the hobbit?”

         “Bilbo,” Thorin stressed the name. “Was here,” he pointed at the bit of the railing where Bilbo had last touched. “This is where he bled for the first time.”

         Saruman's dark gaze went to him and Thorin wanted to shiver again. “A specter bleeding. That is most unusual.”

         “Yes,” Thorin said. “It is.”

         “And this is the blood you...kept?”

         “No,” Thorin looked away, picking out the shadows of Ravenhill in the distance. “That was from a later meeting.”

         “So you have met this spirit multiple times?”

         “Three, well, no. Four,” Thorin had to stop and think about that for a moment. “At least four.”

         “Four times for four quarters,” Saruman murmured. The words made Thorin want to shiver yet again.

         “What was that?”

         The wizard gave himself a shake and did not answer. Instead he held out a hand over the balcony's railing, muttering strange words under his breath that Thorin could not make out. For a moment Saruman's hand turned into a claw, the veins and bones prominent against the thin, pale skin. Thorin thought his ears were ringing. Then Saruman pulled his hand back as if burned. There wasn't a single mark on the stone before him.

         “Strange,” Saruman said at least. Thorin shook off the strange feeling in his ears. The wind was howling over the ridgeline. That had to have been the sound he had heard.

         “What is strange?” Thorin felt a sudden stab of pain through his head, hissing as he closed his right eye against the ache.

         “King Thorin? Is something the matter?”

         “No...no, I am fine.”

         “You do not look fine. You look rather pale.”

         Thorin blinked away wetness from his eyes to see Saruman standing too close in front of him. Thorin wanted to step back but it felt like his feet were stuck to the floor. “I am...fine.”

         “Are you?” Dark eyes studied him and Thorin felt like a bug under that cool gaze. “Are you sure?”

         “My lord!” Nori's cry broke the strange moment. Thorin jerked back, feeling something crack in his neck as he did so. The wizard stepped away and Thorin shook his head, rubbing at his temple as the pain faded away as fast as it came.

         “Nori?” He stepped around Saruman to see...nothing. “Nori?” Thorin looked back and forth but the balcony was empty, as was the hall when Thorin stepped out of the wind.

         “King Thorin?” Saruman trailed after him and it made the back of Thorin's neck start to itch to not have the wizard in his sights. “What is the matter?”

         “You heard Nori's call,” Thorin glanced at the wizard. “So where is he?”

         “I heard no call,” Saruman said, raising one dark brow. “I thought you saw your kinsman. That is all.”

         “You didn't hear...” Thorin closed his teeth on the rest of the words he wanted to say. “It is getting dark,” he said instead. The urgent desire to get the wizard out of his home burned through him. “The mountain is not safe. If you wish to see more of it tomorrow I can arrange another tour.”

         “I think I have seen what I need to see,” Saruman said as he swept past Thorin. Thorin pushed down hard on the urge to trip the wizard down the stairs that led to the front gates. Saruman said not a single word more to him as Thorin led the way out of the mountain. The two blue wizards were waiting at the gates when Saruman emerged, the two of them converging on the other wizard like Thorin had tried to spirit Saruman away against his will.

         “Thorin,” a whisper said from behind him. All the hairs on the back of Thorin's neck stood up at once. He turned on his heel, heart beating hard in his throat to find...

         Nothing. He stood alone in front of the gates of Erebor, as the sun set and the stars began to come out one by one above them. That prickling sensation did not leave, not until a troop of Dwalin's guards came by, illuminating the area and banishing the shadows that Thorin wanted to pretend were something – someone – else. He stayed there until another dwarf came to him, this time definitely one of Nori's lads, and he went back to the council chambers inside the mountain to hear what he had missed in the tents outside from Balin. But that whisper stayed with him, as did the strange voice on the balcony, all the way until he returned to his chambers and Dwalin's arms. That prickling sensation only left when the door was locked tight behind him and he could stand in front of the altar and see what was left of their Bilbo, the only tangible things he could hold now of the one they loved.

         And when he dreamed that night, Thorin dreamed of shadows moving along the wall, wild and graceful at turns, with music he could not remember drumming in his bones when he woke the next day.

 

Chapter 28: a long and winding past

Chapter Text

 

        “Bilbo!”

        Bilbo paused at the doorway, glancing back to see Fortinbras in a veritable crowd of hobbits, all of them talking over themselves, trying to get the Thain's attention. Bilbo flashed him a sign and pointed at Bag End's door. Fortinbras' nod looked relieved, even as he was a bit wild about the eyes.

        The eve of the longest night was almost upon them. There were far more rites and rituals happening this year than Bilbo ever remembered but since their circumstances had so changed, it made sense. Bilbo slipped into Bag End and then out of the in between, the change between the two coming as easy as breathing, now. He went to the kitchen and put on a kettle, fussing with the fire to bring it back to life. How, exactly, their chimneys worked in the mountain, with no clear exit for their smoke, Bilbo did not know. It was enough that no one had seen the evidence of their kitchens and come looking for them, yet.

      Bilbo put his hands on the counter and tried to shake off the uneasy feeling that had been plaguing him since he had seen Thorin standing with Saruman alone on the balcony. It had been pure chance that Bilbo had been out that way, running an errand for his cousin, when he caught sight of the two. Something had stopped him from revealing himself before them, even if it was Thorin and a wizard. Ever since word of what the blue wizards had done had gone through their ranks, none of the hobbits had stayed long outside of the in between if they weren't in their own section of the mountain. Bilbo had taken the chance, though, and pitched his voice to the best mimicry of Nori's, calling out to Thorin. It had seemed to work, though, since Thorin had stepped away from the wizard and the two of them were soon to leave that balcony Bilbo so disliked. He hadn't meant to whisper Thorin's name later, either, but Thorin had looked so strangely forlorn in the hall that the name had tumbled from Bilbo's lips. Then he had vanished before Thorin could turn, heart in his throat the whole way back to Bag End.

        It was longer than Bilbo expected for a knock to come at the door. He opened it to see both Fortinbras and Lalia on the other side. He ushered them in and to the kitchen where he had a hearty stew going and bowls for three already laid out. He'd had a feeling that he might get both of them on his doorstep instead of just the one.

        Fortinbras fell onto the food like a starving beast, not even looking up at them as he ate as fast as he could. Lalia wasn't much better. Bilbo was concerned by the dark smudges under both their eyes.

        “Better?” Bilbo asked once Fortinbras had stopped after his third bowl. “And where is Ferumbras? I should have thought to ask earlier.”

        “He is with his grandparents,” Lalia said as she finished off the last of her own bowl. “Thank you, cousin. That was much needed.”

        “You both look positively run through,” Bilbo took their bowls and came back with cake. “Can I help?”

        He watched as Fortinbras looked at Lalia, who looked down at the table instead. “Not on my end,” she said as she took the thick slice of cake Bilbo held out. “It's widow's business.”

        Bilbo looked over at Fortinbras but his cousin was just looking at his wife with an even stare. “It is intense this year,” he said as he reached out and brushed a lock of hair behind her ear. That got Lalia to look up at last, a faint smile on her face as their gazes met and held. “It will get easier,” he told her.

        “That it will,” she smiled back at him and then her shoulders went back and her chin came up. It was the Lalia Bilbo was more used to seeing. “We have most of the usual preparations in place. All of the...new ones are taking the longest to get right, but there is still time. And if they are not right the first time, well.” A wry smile tugged at one side of her mouth. “We can always fix it later.”

        Bilbo shared a smile with Fortinbras and they went back to their slices of cake. “I heard that the Gardeners are getting a special task this year,” Bilbo said as he cut through the winter-spice frosting. “They want me as the Baggins to oversee it. Are they really going to shout at the gardens?”

        “And the orchards,” Lalia said with a laugh.

        “I would have thought the Tooks would take that over. Or the Brandybucks.”

        “The Brandybucks are going to be busy with the stills,” Lalia shook her head. “And we Tooks have our hands full with everything else. They widows...” She faltered until Fortinbras put an arm about her shoulders. She sat up straight again. “The widows have decided that the Thain must be more involved with the organization of our people.”

        “But the Thain always was?” Bilbo looked to Fortinbras and then back to Lalia. “The Thain has always had last say in most matters. What else do they want?”

        Lalia's mouth opened, closed, and then she went back to her cake, pushing crumbs about the plate. “The widows believe the Thain should take over the Mayor's position...and more.”

        “But...” Bilbo frowned at that. “The Mayor's position was made because the Thain was too busy to oversee everything?”

        “I know,” Lalia shrugged but still would not look up from her plate. “But that is what the widows wish.”

        “But how...”

        “I do not know, Bilbo!” Lalia threw her hands up at that, looking up at last. “I know that the position of the Thain is going to be much more burdened, but the widows do not seem concerned about that. I do not know why, either!”

        Bilbo raised his hands and sat back in his chair. “I am sorry,” he said. “I just want to help.”

        Lalia looked away, her shoulders rounding. “I am sorry, I do not mean to shout.”

        Bilbo knew that the rumors and whispers of Lalia being a harpy or scold or any number of other unkind things had long made the rounds of the entire Shire. He also knew that such whispers hurt her far more than she let on. “You are as busy as Fortinbras,” Bilbo reached over and covered her hand with his own. “I do not mean to make more work for you or frustrate you. I am sorry. All will be well. The widows will tell us when and how they want things to work in their own time. It will all be well.”

        “...Thank you,” Lalia's voice was a touch watery when she turned her hand over and laced their fingers together. “I know you are busy as well. I thought the Baggins clan had more members than just yourself?” Her head came up and Bilbo knew she would not appreciate mention of her wet lashes. “Put that cousin of yours to work.”

        Bilbo made a face at that, squeezing her hand once before letting go. “Otho? Goodness no, he would be useless. Lobelia has her hands full with him, especially since little Lotho has just come along.”

        “Now there would have been a wife for you,” Lalia pointed her fork at him and began to laugh, most likely at the horrified look on his face. “Oh, come now. You two were always squabbling like an old married couple. She even stole from you!”

        “After she was married!” Bilbo waved his hands at her. “Do not speak that into existence! She'll hear!”

        “Who will?”

        “Lobelia!”

        “Bilbo.”

        “I swear she has ears in my walls,” Bilbo leaned forward and hissed at Lalia, just to see her start to turn pink with laughter. Even Fortinbras was laughing now. “She does! I don't know how else she finds my spoons!”

        “Perhaps because you always keep your spoons in the same locations?” Lalia said through her giggles. “Could it be that?”

        “Nonsense, of course not. Lobelia clearly has spies in the walls.”

        Laughter rang out in Bag End and it felt like the very air warmed with their mirth. Bilbo kept up the theatrics until Lalia's eyelids began drooping and Fortinbras had to scoop her up into his arms to take her home. He knew his cousin still wished to speak to him, no doubt about the upcoming longest night eve's celebrations but that would have to be done in the morning. Fortinbras had more important things to concern himself with, first. Bilbo would just get up early to see him.

        And that is what he did, breaking his fast before dawn began to blush against the eastern horizon. He was knocking on Fortinbras' door soon after, eyeing the way the shadows seemed to...clump at the end of the hall that their portion of the tunnel led to. There had been changes going on in their section of the mountain as their old gifts began to spread and grow. Bilbo could have sworn the section of tunnels that the Great Smials had taken over were even more confusing now, and far off the main tunnel all of their doors once led to. But part of that might have to do with the hiding that the Bounders had been doing in their rush to protect their people against any curious eyes that looked their way.

        The longest night's eve dawned cold and clear, with a chill to the air even down in the belly of the mountain that made Bilbo shiver as he waited for Fortinbras to open the door. He rubbed at his arms, dreaming a little about the great fires that were most likely roaring in the Royal Wing but was shaken out such thoughts when his cousin opened the door.

        Fortinbras held a finger up and stepped outside, already dressed for the day. “Lalia and Ferumbras are still sleeping,” he said as he led Bilbo away from the door. “The day will be hectic enough for Lalia, I want her to rest as much as she can.”

        Bilbo chewed on his lower lip as he followed Fortinbras down to the main hall of the Great Smials. At that early hour few were awake but there were already sounds of people rattling about the kitchens. Fortinbras led them over to one of the two great hearths that sat on either end of the main hall and sank down into one of the seats there. A young hobbit lass came out with a tea tray before either of them could call for it, setting it by Fortinbras' elbow without a word before she scampered away.

        “They know your habits,” Bilbo pointed out as they both fixed a cup of tea. Their stores of the best black teas were rationed for the moment but the Gardeners were already growing sprouts in the dark rooms to have the bushes ready for the spring. All hobbits were down to one scoop of tea a day for adults while the children were not given any at all, making due with herbal teas until they had their tea gardens up and growing again. There had already been talk with some of the Gardeners about attempting some higher elevation teas on Erebor's slopes.

        Bilbo hoped that Thorin and the rest of the dwarves would allow such experiments to happen when the presence of hobbits in the mountain was finally revealed. He thought they would be but he had learned to be careful with his hope.

        Fortinbras sighed as he sat back, inhaling the steam as he cradled the cup between his palms. Bilbo copied him, the two of them savoring their first, and strongest, cup of the day. They were allowed to reuse the leaves of a pot as much as they wished but Bilbo had found that anything after that first, lovely cup could taste...lacking. But it was enough to get their people through, for now.

        (They all, very carefully, ignored the fact that none of them had seen a drop of cream in weeks. Bilbo knew there had to be some hobbits in the mountain that were either planning a cattle raid on some unsuspecting neighbors or else trying to figure out how to hide a pen of dairy cows on the mountainside, purchased from...somewhere. Lake-town maybe? The elves? Wait. Did elves consume dairy? Bilbo had no idea.)

        “Bilbo.”

        Bilbo blinked out of his thoughts at the sound of his cousin's voice. “Sorry, what was that?” He opened his eyes to see Fortinbras shaking his head, but he was smiling a bit as he finished the last of his tea.

        “I said,” Fortinbras slanted him a look that Bilbo promptly ignored. “That the Baggins clan will need to get the last of the mystery bags done today.”

        Bilbo tipped back the last of his tea and set his cup down with a sigh. “They should be done by sunset,” he said, thinking through what was left to do. “The widows are still planning to hold their meeting?”

        Fortinbras nodded, slow and thoughtful. “As soon as the moon rises.” They both looked to the east. “About an hour after sunset, which will give the children enough time to go through their holiday favors and settle down.”

        “There won't be as much as usual,” Bilbo warned, feeling a bit bad about it all.

        Fortinbras waved a hand, a faint frown stealing over his face. “That is understandable, considering...” His hand swept out and Bilbo nodded. “A few less toys will not harm the faunts for a year.”

        “No, they won't,” Bilbo said, thinking back to the Fell Winter and the bare bones festival that had taken place then. From the twist to Fortinbras' mouth his cousin was remembering it as well.

        “Anyways,” Fortinbras gave himself a shake and poured them a second, weaker cup of tea. They both wrinkled their noses at it but they both remembered during the Fell Winter that such second cups of tea had been a little luxury few had. Many had used and reused their tea leaves until they disintegrated into mush that had then been made into soup. Bilbo clearly remembered digging into the hard earth with his mother, searching for roots of whatever plants that were safe enough to eat, just to get them through the week. “With the mystery bags done, all that's left is the stages to be brought in for the Yule night plays.”

        “And the other rites?”

        They shared a look at that. Fortinbras stirred in some dandelion syrup that had been canned that spring. “The widows have said that there should be more wrestling matches, along with the dances at midnight. They also want everyone in flower crowns so the Gardeners will be hard at work the next few days.”

        “They will enjoy that,” Bilbo said.

        “They will, if we can pry them out of their sprouting rooms,” Fortinbras sighed. “The Singers will have their time to teach the faunts the Old Songs, while the widows have also asked to have a blessing of the waters.” He frowned at that, his spoon slowing as he stared at some point only he could see. “Lalia said the widows were speaking about great pools beneath the mountain, so maybe they meant those, I do not know. There are the other rites that the widows have asked for, but I'm sure we'll find out more tonight.”

        Bilbo looked down at his own cup, swirling the cooling tea clockwise, watching the tiny dregs that had escaped the pot settle at the bottom. “I find myself...worried,” he said to his cup, not brave enough to meet his cousin's eyes. “There have been more and more widows appearing.”

        “Yes,” Fortinbras sighed. “I have seen them too.”

        “Have they even said where we are all to gather?” Bilbo looked up and then around at the hall. “This space won't hold all of the Shire. It can barely hold the Tooks and their married relations.”

        “I have been told,” Fortinbras began with a sour twist to his mouth, “not to worry about that either.”

        “But...”

        “Oh, I know and I agree.”

        Bilbo closed his mouth at that, sitting back in his chair with a grumble. “I dislike not knowing such things,” he muttered.

        “You and I can agree on that. Though,” Fortinbras slanted him a look that made Bilbo want to squirm in his seat. “I have a suspicion you have come by this desire not-so naturally.”

        Bilbo looked away at that and did not answer. It was admission enough.

        “But enough of this,” Fortinbras said as he drained the last of his cup with a slight wrinkle of his nose. “Let us get up and going. The day waits for no hobbit and there is much left to do.”

        Bilbo drained the last of his tea as well and stood with his cousin, the list of things to do that day already running through his head. The bulk of what would be happening that night was the great meeting that was going to be held by the widows. It wasn't until noon that Bilbo found out that this meeting would be taking place in the in between and not in some physical space inside the mountain. It made sense, when he thought about it, since the whole of the Shire was to be present and that meant a lot of hobbits.

        The whole of their interconnected tunnels in the mountain had been done up with festive decorations for the season; bows of greenery and ribbons were tied to anything that could bear the weight. Bilbo had to wade into a thick knot of his relatives before a fistfight could break out over the small stages being set up in one of the large halls that had somehow appeared next to where the Great Smials were located. Bilbo was starting to think that perhaps some of their people were getting a little too comfortable with their old gifts since he was absolutely sure such a space had not existed before that morning and a part of him was more than a little worried about how safe the whole area was.

        (Bilbo had cornered one of the Bounders to get some answers and what he had been told had just confused him more. The Bounder, a chap by the name of Tad Rockwell, was very enthused about stone and had a lot to say about what he had learned from the dwarves he had been stalking for weeks on end. What Bilbo did understand was that the large spaces were safe and structurally sound and may, perhaps, give the dwarves conniptions should they ever find them. Bilbo filed that for a later problem and let Tad scamper away to do...something that had to do with making more of these large spaces. Or something.)

        (Bilbo was very much looking forward to the strong punches that were always served during Yule. He really was.)

        Anyways.

        By the time sunset rolled around Bilbo was ready for something far stronger than weak tea and a hearty meal or two. He gathered with his Took cousins and many of the other Old Families from the Shire in the Great Smials for a longest night eve supper that had them all wearing crowns of greenery while they ate. The faunts had all dug into their mystery bags with delight and there was not a single sour face so far that Bilbo could see about the somewhat meager contents. There were no widows with them at the table, which was odd, since during a normal year such a feast would be overseen by the head widow of the Tooks. Lalia, as the matriarch of the clan, was stepping in for the missing widow, an old Aunt Lily that Bilbo had spoken perhaps a handful of words to in his entire life. As he remembered, Aunt Lily was a cousin of the Old Took, though the actual connection to him was a bit dodgy on Bilbo's part. Bilbo found himself sat next to Fortinbras, much to his shock, since in years past he had been sat perhaps halfway down the table at best during such feasts. He was not sure who had made the change but Bilbo suspected either Fortinbras or Lalia had put their foot down on the topic and thus he was sat far closer to the head of the table than any of his family ever had before.

        While most of their people had been rationing their stores, despite what the Gardeners were being able to do with minimal preparation and much more enthusiasm, the feasts of the winter season had always been sumptuous things. Thick roasts and glazed hams dotted the table, along with many a roasted root vegetable dressed in a variety of ways. Warm buttery rolls and herb butters were a necessary part of such feasts, along with the sweet and tart jellies that could start a fight if one liked such fare or not. Bilbo had seen courting pairs fall out over such disagreements. It was always a source of entertainment during the darkest parts of the year.

        This year the tables were a little leaner than in the past but the laughter was still bright and the chatter loud in the hall. Bilbo avoided the sharp looks from some of the more nosy – and mean – members of his Baggins clan and focused instead on Fortinbras and his Took relations. Bilbo had always enjoyed his summers at the Great Smials, playing with his cousins in the woods and creeks about their vast home, running back for supper when the last of twilight had faded from the sky. It had been a magical time, the summer nights warm and his cousins loud, with all of them laughing well into the night, sprawled out by the fires in the hearths of the great hall.

        The structure of the Great Smials were much the same as they were when they had existed in the Shire but the lack of actual windows looking out into the quiet nights was something Bilbo could not ignore. There was a tension to the air that none of the adults could shake off. Bilbo saw more than one hobbit at the table turn their gaze towards the doors that had appeared in the wall of the hall in the Great Smials, doors that had not been there before. They were the doors they were all to enter through when the bells began to ring and the widows were ready for them.

        The dessert plates had just been pushed back when Bilbo heard the faintest tinkling noise. He stilled, as did many along the table, all of them looking up and around for the sound. Louder and louder the tinkling came until it could be denied no longer. The bells were ringing. It was time.

        Bilbo looked to Fortinbras. His cousin only had eyes for the doors on the far side of the wall. Doors, Bilbo noted, that were now starting to glow along the edges, full of light. It was Fortinbras who stood first, then Lalia, then Bilbo at his cousin's sign. One after the other the hobbits along the table stood, all conversation and laughter gone.

        It was time.

        It was Fortinbras who led them to the doors. They opened without a touch, swinging inward without a sound. The step into the in between was made between one breath and the next. It felt a little like being caught out in a warm, summer's shower, but even then it made him shiver as he stepped through. Bilbo blinked away wetness as he entered the chamber, fighting to keep his mouth from falling open in shock as he looked up and around, unsure just where to focus his attention first.

        The chamber was larger than anything Bilbo had seen before. It was at least as large as the main chamber in Erebor, but where the center of the mountain seemed to plunge down forever, the bottom of this chamber was clear to see. For there, in the center of this vast space, sat circle upon circle of black-garbed hobbits, all of which had thick veils over their faces.

        Bilbo followed Fortinbras and Lalia down the long steps, careful on his feet since much like the staircases and ramps in Erebor, there were no handrails. As he followed his cousin Bilbo could not help but glance up at the other tiers, blinking in shock when he saw line after line of hobbits all coming down from the doors at the top of the chamber. There were more hobbits than Bilbo could believe. Certainly more than what the Shire could hold. As he stared he could start to make out some of those strange hobbits. They were...different than those from the Shire. The hobbits to Bilbo's right wore thick furs and were all dark haired, often with darker skin, and dressed in blues and white. The hobbits to Bilbo's left wore sandy-colored clothing, their hair bright gold or light brown at best. Many of them wore skirts and Bilbo could hear the chime of bells as they walked.

        From all over the chamber Bilbo picked out different kinds of clothing and hair color and more. There were hobbits whose skin looked as though it was molded from the richest of soils. There were other hobbits that looked almost as if they had been formed from ice. One after the other they all filed down into the chamber, filling in the seats in silence as they all looked at each other in shock and surprise. It seemed as though the others were as shocked as Bilbo felt at the sight of so many different kinds of hobbits filling the room.

        Once the faint sound of shuffling had died away silence filled the chamber. The chiming of the bells had whispered out, leaving only the sound of thousands and thousands of hobbits breathing in the quiet. Then, from the circle of veiled widows, the one in the center stood. They turned in a slow circle and when the widow's gaze swept over the Shire section Bilbo felt the urge to duck his head and...well, not hide, exactly, but it felt almost as if the widow was able to look right into the deepest part of his soul.

        “For the first time since our people were created, all of our kind have been gathered together at last.” The widow's voice rolled over the room, powerful like the crackle of thunder and lightning. Bilbo felt the hairs on his arms stand on end. “On this eve of the longest night, it is time, at last, to speak the truth of our people's origins, of how how we came to be.” The widow finished her spin and Bilbo fought down the urge to slide down in his seat when he realized that the widow had stopped facing the Shire's section. Facing him.

        The widow paused there and it felt like there was a presence in the room that Bilbo could not name. Then the widow reached up and lifted her veil, revealing a face that was neither young nor old, but her eyes were like the blue fire Bilbo had seen with his Ring, a blazing blue that glowed even in the rich light of the chamber.

        “I am the oldest of our kind, the first formed, and the one who holds the all the memories of our people,” the widow's voice broke the tense silence. “I am Minona of the Ærest clan.” Her gaze swept across the silent room. “The first to wake, the first to form, the first to understand who and what we are. And it is now time for me to tell you who have come after, you who have forgotten, who have been made to forget, just what and who we are.”

        Bilbo found himself holding his breath for reasons he could not name.

        That bright gaze went to Bilbo and all the air in his lungs went still. “Long ago,” her words rang through the chamber, though she did not look away from him. “A vision was given to the spirits of the Being That Is, the one the Eldar call Eru Ilúvatar, the One, and He who possesses the Flame Imperishable.”

        The widow looked away and Bilbo put a hand to his chest, feeling his heart stutter under his palm. He felt Lalia put a hand on his back and leaned into her touch for a moment, needing the grounding.

        “It was from that Flame Imperishable that all the races of Arda were created,” Minona continued. “Even,” one side of her mouth ticked up, “the dwarves who worship Aulë as their Maker. All of them come from Him...except us.”

        That caused a stir to ripple through the room.

        “We, the creatures now called hobbits, come not from Eru's careful planning, nor from Morgoth's corruption that has crept over Arda.” It was so still Bilbo thought he could hear a pin drop. “Long ago, when the world was made, Eru placed that Flame Imperishable into the center of the earth and then sent the Ainur into the world, to guide and build all that they had seen in the Vision that was given to them long ago. The Valar were the leaders of this group but Morgoth too came to the world, claiming to have repented from his revolt during the first Song that was ever sung.” The widow turned in a slow circle again, meeting eyes throughout the gathered hobbits. “Like the songs we sing during the longest night, the Song that was sung in the Timeless Halls of Eru Ilúvatar laid out the future of the world through every Age. All was planned. All was set in place. Until Melkor, Morgoth, began to influence the Song and thus change was given a place in That Which Might Be.”

        Those bright blue eyes scanned the chamber as the widow continued to turn in place. “None could know that it was that element of change that was given to the Song that would be the catalyst for our creation. For, as the Ainur entered the world and began to form it, Morgoth came too and tried to ruin all that the Ainur touched and formed. Many battles were fought between them. Many times the world was raised and then cast down, mountains lifted high, then brought low, the seas rising and falling, covering the world at times and at other times receding to almost nothing. Little survived these great battles. And then,” she stopped, facing Bilbo once more. He tried not to flinch away from that bright gaze. “Then came the battle that created us all.”

        A murmur washed through the chamber. Bilbo pressed his lips together as the crowd quieted, unable to look away from the widow's bright and sharp gaze.

        Minona gave a small nod as the chamber went silent once more. “The Valar commanded all the spirits in the world that were under their power to fight against Morgoth and his minions, his slaves. They called it the Battle of the Powers, where the Valar and Morgoth strove against one another to the point of almost ripping the world in two. The Valar chose to move then for the first of Eru's children had woken, the Eldar, the elves, and the Valar wished to keep them from falling under Morgoth's tyranny. To that end they attacked Morgoth and his minions with such strength and fury that they pushed Morgoth back to his first fortress, Utumno and there they besieged the evil Vala until the gates of Utumno were broken and its halls peeled open from the top. Deeper and deeper did Morgoth burrow into his fortress, reaching down into the heart of the earth, trying to hide from the Valar who were raining down their magics to pry that spirit from his hole. In the end the magics of the Valar won the day, striking Morgoth again and again until he lay dazed and helpless in the deepest pit of them all.”

        Bilbo felt his hands curl into fists in his lap. He could not look away from that bright gaze.

        “What the Valar did not know at the time,” Minona continued, “was that their might had pushed Morgoth so deep that their magics were pushed against that very same Flame Imperishable that Eru Ilúvatar commanded in the Timeless Halls. The Valar did not know that while they pulled Morgoth from the ruins of his fortress, their magic...lingered. All of the Valar and the spirits they commanded had rained down their powers on that spot and that magic pooled and mingled, seeping down into the very crust of the earth to interact with that same Flame Imperishable that Eru Ilúvatar placed in the heart of Arda.”

        Minona's bright blue gaze swept over the chamber once more. “The leftover magics of the Valar met the Flame Imperishable and what happened then we can only guess. What we know, what I know, is that I woke in the ruins of that broken fortress, unknowing of who or what I was, only that I Am.” The word rang out in the chamber, echoing. “I woke with the knowledge that I, that we, are the remnants of power that had come to guide and build the world, and then to fix that which Morgoth twisted with his lies and hate. I...we...are that which came out of the union of the magics of the Valar and the Flame Imperishable itself. We were born with a purpose, to fix that which was broken, to create a Song that was once seen. And that is what we have done since the very first of us drew breath in those dark halls, when all we had was a singular purpose. To fix that which was broken. It is a task that we have continued to do for years beyond count.”

        Bilbo blinked away tears he could not explain. He had put one fist against his chest, feeling his heart thundering under his skin.

        The widow's gaze went back to him. Bilbo went still. “Long ago we knew that our powers would fade. Long ago we knew that we had a limited time on this plane, that our presence was allowed by Eru Ilúvatar because we fixed that which should have been dealt with by his own spirits long ago. We widows, we who have lingered in the space in between, the space between that which Is and that which Might Be, the space between the Timeless Halls and the World Itself, we watched our people grow into something that not even we thought we could be. A People, with customs and clans and homes and love. We allowed the truth of our making fade with time, as we moved through the world, fixing what we could. We allowed the memory of our making to fade as we saw our people lose more and more of their magic, of our memory, of our being, even as we as a people healed that which we could in the world. We, the widows of the First Clans, watched from the shadows of the in between as our people began to fade. We made our peace with the knowledge that our people's time had come to an end.”

        “And then,” her gaze did not move from Bilbo. “One our own found the largest break in the world and fixed it too.”

        Bilbo could not breathe. He could not move. All he could see were those bright blue eyes staring into his very soul.

        “Our people's gifts are the echoes of the powers that the Valar left behind in that dark fortress of Utumno. Those powers found different ways to be expressed in our people. The green growth of Yavanna for our Gardeners. Those who could watch the weather and know the winds,” her smile grew by degrees. “The powers of Manwë echoed there. Each of the Valar fought in that battle, leaving their magics behind. Even Mandos took part in that battle, the one who would be given a prophesy by Eru Ilúvatar about the End of All Things, and how that would come about. But what Eru Ilúvatar did not expect was that the very powers of his servants would be brought to life...and by those same powers choose to fix that which we saw what was broken. And the Song itself was broken. And so,” she finally smiled and it felt like a warm breath of spring air swept across them all. “We have fixed it.”

        Minona took a step forward, a step towards Bilbo. “You, Bilbo of the Baggins clan, were guided to the Ring of Sauron. The Ring was made long ago, in the fires of Mount Doom, where Morgoth's shadow and malice had mingled with Sauron's to corrupt the very Flame that helped give us birth. The Ring was a break in the fabric of the world, a corruption where none should be. By finding it you changed the Song, changed the world itself. Once, had you found it but not destroyed it, it would have passed to kin of yours, to be destroyed in the very same corrupted fount that created it. But in stepping into the in between, by opening yourself to the Flame that was brought forth in that place, corrupted or not, you knit the very fabric of the world back together when the Ring was destroyed in front of you, turning the prophecy of Mandos moot and changing the very Song that had once been seen.”

        Bilbo shook his head at that, though he did not know what he was denying. It felt...it felt too large of a thing for him to have done, too impossible. He was just a hobbit. A creature of comfort and home and peace and – and –

        Oh.

        “You, Bilbo of the Baggins clan,” Minona continued. “Have brought the magic of the Valar and of the Flame Imperishable back to the World That Is. It is by your actions our people are now knitted into the very fabric of the world as we know it. We are the in between. We are part of the world as the Song knows it. We no longer exist to fix things, though that will undoubtedly be something we do for a very long time. There is so much damage still to be brought into alignment, so many things that Morgoth tried to ruin that we can help, that we can bring into life and into the fabric of the Song. But,” her smile faded and Bilbo felt a chill work down his spine. “As much as you have changed the world, as much as we are now part of it, Morgoth, too, has seen the changes in the world and now works to take advantage of that before the powers in the West can stop him.”

        Here her gaze moved from Bilbo at last. He sagged in his seat, feeling Lalia push her shoulder against his in support. He leaned back against her, feeling how she took his hand in hers and laced their fingers together.

        “Morgoth has little time to move,” Minona's words echoed out over the chamber as she swept her gaze across them all once more. “If the Healing of Arda is to come, then Morgoth himself must be sent back to the Timeless Halls, so that he may not be able to influence the world anymore. Change and chance, as well as deception and deceit, are now woven into the very fabric of the world. We cannot fix that, for even we come from part of that twisted power that was sunk into the Flame that gave us life. But it is Morgoth's desire to use this last shift in the world, as the magics that have long been asleep wake once more, to take this moment and in this moment of chance try to rip open the portal he was once exiled through and return to the world so that he might conquer it once and for all.” Her gaze seemed to grow brighter as she looked over them all. “We will not let that happen.”

        Bilbo found himself on his feet with the rest of the hobbits, all of them lifting their voice in one in agreement. He quieted with the others as Minona raised her hand, a faint smile returning to her face.

        “The Song itself is changing as our people settle into the Melody of That Which Will Be.” Her words rang out over the murmurs still echoing through the chamber. All went quiet once more. “Tomorrow it is the longest night, the point where the Dark is strongest and the Light furthest. It is a day that we need to remember our origins, where we remember from whence we came. It is the night when Morgoth will move, for it will be his last chance to return to the world and remake it in his image. So tonight we will gather together and greet our kin from across the world, for tomorrow we will listen to the songs as the Ainur once did. We will wrestle like Tulkas, we will set to flight the paper birds that whistle through the air, seeing further than any others, as Manwë does. We will pour out the cold waters to connect ourselves to Ulmo, we will remember Yavanna as we crown ourselves with flowers. We will dance for Nessa, weave together the bright strands of the winter webs for Vairë. Each of our rites and rituals remember those from whom we came, for their powers are ours, tempered by that Flame Imperishable that burns bright within us all. It is by these very same powers that Morgoth's minions wish to bring him back, that Morgoth himself wishes to use to return to this plane. But these powers are ours and ours alone!” A cheer went up at that. Bilbo found himself among them, crying out with every single voice in the chamber.

        Minona then clapped her hands and as one the widows about her stood, each of them pulling off their veils. Each of the widows resembled the different sections of hobbits that had come into the chamber.

        “Tonight all our clans meet,” Minona's voice rose above the growing din. “Tonight we dance and sing and learn the rites of all the clans. For tomorrow we will face our fiercest battle yet and finally fix that which we were born to do. Go forth and fear no darkness! For we will always carry the light no matter where we go!”

        The cheer of the hobbits was loud enough that Bilbo felt it in his bones. He could almost feel the energy of their people in the air, see it swirling around like ribbons in the wind. Hobbits began to stream down from the different tiers, meeting in the middle as the widows moved among them, speaking to what looked like the leaders of each clan. And, Bilbo noted, each of those leaders began converging on Fortinbras, who looked a little like a startled hare facing down a hunting pack of dogs. Bilbo did not envy him.

        Then Bilbo turned and found himself almost nose to nose with Widow Minona. His breath caught and his feet felt stuck to the ground.

        “You,” she said, quiet enough for just the two of them. “Come with me.”

        “Me?” Bilbo squeaked, much to his horror.

        “Yes. You.” She smiled and while it was kind there was a firmness to it that Bilbo could not deny. “Morgoth is coming,” she said, soft enough that Bilbo had to strain to hear her words. For a moment he wished he had not. He looked away, the good cheer of before draining away. A finger under his chin lifted his head so that he was looking at the widow once more. “We cannot stop that part of the Song,” she said, just as soft. “That part was already written, long ago. We just changed the when and how. But that does not mean that Morgoth gets to win. For we know how to fix things. But sometimes,” her smile turned sad. “Sometimes you have to let them be broken, first. That was a lesson I had to learn myself, long ago. Now come, Bilbo of the Baggins clan. There are things you must learn to allow to happen, things I must tell you in private, before the Darkness comes to us all once more.”

        Bilbo nodded, his throat too thick to find words to answer her. He followed the widow out of the chamber, as twelve others surrounded him, through a door in the back that appeared between one blink and the next, darker than pitch or obsidian or any substance Bilbo had ever seen before. The widows moved through it, one by one, without a flinch. Bilbo hung back until it was just himself, looking over his shoulder at his cousins. Fortinbras and Lalia were surrounded by hobbits of all different shapes and colors and sizes, looking a bit dazed and wild about the eyes.

        Then Bilbo turned back to that dark door, took in a swift breath, and stepped through. He would face whatever the widows had for him. To protect his family, his people, his Thorin and Dwalin, and his Company, all of the peoples he had ever met. He would do whatever it took.

        What Bilbo did not see was the black door that he entered vanish as he stepped through, turning back to a gray wall with not a single carving in sight to mark its space.

 

Chapter 29: from the darkness

Chapter Text

 

         The day before Yule dawned cold and rimed with a thick frost that glittered on the ground. Thorin shared a quick breakfast with Dwalin and his privy council before heading out to the tents on his lawn. He was joined by Gandalf as Thorin made his way towards Ravenhill, intending to both stretch his legs and check on the ravens there. Dwalin's King's Guard was trailing him and Thorin had no doubt that at least one of Nori's boys was somewhere slinking through the rocks unseen. Thorin could feel the press of unseen eyes on him, now, at all times.

         Each puff of breath created blooms of white clouds in front of his face. It was the coldest Thorin could remember it being and a part of him mourned for it, since surely the gardens on the hills would soon die under such conditions. But perhaps they would come back the next spring and he could walk among the greenery and think of –

         No. Thorin could not think of Bilbo. Not today. Not when his dreams had been filled of dancing with Bilbo and Dwalin, the wild piping and drumming so different than his own people's music and yet familiar all the same. Bilbo had been smiling at them, taking their hands as he led them through rounds of dancers, some bare-faced, some veiled, all clapping and singing in a language Thorin could not understand. Not when in that dream Bilbo had drawn them close and whispered words Thorin could not remember upon waking, but they had made Thorin so happy that for a moment when he had woken he had reached out in their bed, expecting...

         Well. It was a dream. And all dreams must end when the sleeper wakes.

         Thorin rubbed at his face, trying to push away such sad thoughts.

         “Troubling dreams, Thorin?”

         The wizard's voice made Thorin sigh. “I dream of...of something that can never be,” he said. He refused to look at Gandalf. “That is all.”

         He heard the wizard sigh and a long stream of smoke swept out in front of them. For a moment it almost formed hills and valleys, with small round doors set into the sketched-out land. Then the wind picked up, whistling over the ridgeline and the image was gone. “I dream as well,” Gandalf said as they walked on towards Ravenhill. “Of things that can no longer be.”

         Thorin pressed his lips together and put one foot in front of the other as they approached the ravens. That early in the morning many of them were still in their roosts, fluffed up to keep warm, muttering to each other in low croaks that sounded far too strange for that particular morning. Thorin spotted the leader of the ravens, Roäc, perched on the ledge on the far side of the tower. There were not many of the ravens scattered inside, for the young that would travel far distances were still gone from the roost.

         “Roäc,” Thorin said when he came close to the giant bird. The raven turned his head to peer at Thorin with one dark eye. The gray feathers were starting to outnumber the black but Roäc's eyes were as sharp as ever.

         “King Thorin,” the raven croaked. His massive beak bent down and pecked at the stone by his feet, though at what exactly the raven was looking for Thorin did not know. He scattered some of the old cram that had been soaked in water before the raven and watched as Roäc pecked at that instead. “Come you have,” the raven said after he was finished with what he wanted. Thorin could see other ravens start to turn and stare at what was left.

         “I have,” Thorin said, clasping his hands behind his back. At his side Gandalf stayed quiet and still as a statue. “What news of the world do you have for me today?”

         “News was given to the little ones every night,” Roäc clacked his beak together, feathers fluffing up as a breeze slipped through the roost. “No more do I have to give.”

         Thorin let out a breath at that, gaze going beyond the raven and to the vista beyond. The slopes leading up to Erebor's gates were still barren from the repeated dragonfire. The winter grays and browns dominated the landscape. In the distance Thorin could see the glimmer of Long Lake, though he could not make out the town that sat upon it.

         “Do you have news of movement in the area?” Gandalf was the one to ask. Thorin slanted a look at the wizard but Gandalf did not look away from Roäc for a minute.

         “Movement?” Roäc pecked again at the stone near his feet. “There is much movement, all around. Men, elves, and dwarves and others as well. Some coming, some going. Much movement, yes.”

         “Much movement?” Thorin frowned at that. “When? You did not report that.”

         Roäc's dark eye studied Thorin for a long moment. “This news was given to one of the young ones with the knot upon his shoulder.” The raven let out a sudden loud caw and a series of grumbles that Thorin did not understand. “Two nights ago it was given.”

         Thorin rocked back on his heels and looked up at Gandalf. The wizard looked as worried as Thorin felt. “We did not receive that news,” he told Roäc when he looked back at the raven.

         That dark eye stared at Thorin without blinking. “Much movement,” Roäc repeated and clacked his beak together again, softly this time. That great head tilted, still watching Thorin. “Much like the battle before, such movement grows. Mirkwood is too full of shadows and my people cannot go near it, now. Fires have been seen in the mountains, sometimes torches, snaking through the land at night. Those who go near do not always come back. This was told to the young ones who came to us.”

         Thorin curled his hands into fists. “That information was not passed on to us.” He looked up at Gandalf. “I must speak to Nori and the rest of my council. The other leaders must be told as well.” He looked back at Roäc. “You said there was movement of both men and elves. Near us?”

         The raven bobbed his head in a nod. “Elves of Mirkwood are trying to contain the shadows. Some are already headed to the mountain to their king. Parties of men are also on the road, overtaking the caravans of dwarves from the Blue Mountains. Many are coming to your gates, King Thorin. You must prepare.”

         Thorin let out a short breath at that. “We will,” he told the raven. Roäc let out a loud caw as he flapped his wings and then burst into flight, with several other large ravens trailing him. As soon as Roäc was gone a number of smaller ravens came in to peck at the remains of the cram left on the ledge.

         Thorin let out another breath when he stepped back out into the early morning light. The sun was warming the sides of the mountain, the shadows short for the day before Yule. The snow line had come down further he noted, almost to the tops of the gates. His gaze drifted to the side, where the gardens had been found, and then forced himself to fall into step with Gandalf as they made their way back down towards the sprawling encampment of tents.

         “This is troubling news,” Thorin said into the silence that had fallen between them.

         “Very troubling.” Gandalf stroked his beard, his pipe gone, eyes on some far distant point.

         “I do not think Nori would keep this news from anyone,” Thorin frowned at the sight of the mountain. His steps slowed to a stop. Gandalf halted with him. “In fact Nori has said that the ravens have had no news for us at all the last few days. That when his boys came to talk to them...wait.” Thorin twisted around to look back at where the ravens were roosted. “Roäc said the news was given to the young one with the knot on his shoulder.”

         “Yes?”

         Thorin shook his head. “Nori does not use that sigil for his lads.” He looked up at Gandalf. “The last Spymaster of Erebor did.”

         Gandalf's bushy brows had come together in a fierce scowl. “You are certain?”

         “Completely.”

         “Then this must be addressed as soon as possible.”

         “But...” Thorin did not move as he looked back at the mountain. “It could not be Dáin's people...unless we have missed some when we gathered all who had collapsed. And if it is not Dáin's people, nor Nori's...then do I have a traitor in my own mountain?”

         “Do not be hasty in making such conclusions,” Gandalf shook his head. “We do not know enough to start guessing who this figure could be.”

         Thorin scowled at that. “If it is a dwarf, then I must know who it is.”

         “If it is a dwarf,” Gandalf said.

         Thorin stared at him. “What?”

         Gandalf looked away, his face in profile against the gray winter sky. “I am worried,” the wizard said as he stared at the mountain...or at the encampment that lay before it. “Things are unsettled. There is growing mistrust between all the parties and it is getting worse with each passing day.”

         Thorin swallowed at that. “Could it be Morgoth's shadow?”

         Gandalf paused for a long moment before he gave a slow nod. “Perhaps,” he said. His gaze was still distant, though there seemed to be a faint glow to his eyes that Thorin had never seen before. “Morgoth would do much to hinder all those who would rise up against him. But...” Gandalf tilted his head slightly. “There is another shadow that would try to do far more.”

         “Sauron,” Thorin said. As he said the name the wind died down and all was silent about them. Thorin felt his skin start to prickle. The King's Guard, who had held back at the start of the trail at Thorin's command, looked over to them, frowns on their faces. Perhaps they felt it too.

         “Perhaps,” Gandalf murmured, bowing his head. “I feel that things are starting to move faster and faster. The bonds holding Aman from the world are snapping. I can feel it in my bones now. And when Aman and Arda come back together...”

         “You think the Door will be opened.” Thorin swallowed at that.

         “That and more,” Gandalf said as he raised his head. “But that is not something we two alone can discuss and decide over.” The wizard gave himself a shake. “Come, we should return to the camp and inform the others of this news. And I believe your Spymaster should be alerted as soon as possible.”

         “Yes,” Thorin agreed and signaled for one of the King's Guard to join them. A quiet word to him had that guard running for the gates, leaving his fellow guard staring at his back in shock. The second guard joined them as Thorin began to lead them all back towards the encampment, his thoughts spinning in his head.

         “How warm is everyone staying?” Thorin asked more to hear someone speak than to know the facts and figures of what this prolonged visit by so many peoples of Arda were doing to his fuel stores that were supposed to get his own people through the roughest parts of winter.

         “Everyone is warm enough, though to hear Saruman speak, you would think his tent was located in the depths of the Helcaraxë instead of snuggled between several other tents and full of warming basins that make it feel like a spring day.” Gandalf seemed to rouse himself from his own troubling thoughts. His shoulders went back as his head came up.

         Thorin managed to keep his expression from twisting with displeasure. Saruman's – and the blue wizards' – insistence on several of the warming braziers had been a pain to secure and supply. They had finally unearthed a cache of them in one of the halls that had been miraculously repaired during the night. More and more of the mountain was, for want of a better term, waking up each time they went to sleep. Hallways were repaired. Rubble vanished. The great pillars that held up the front of the mountain, that they had wound the ugly metal about to keep them stable, no longer had a single crack in them. It was as if the damage Smaug had done to their mountain never was.

         “I am not sure how much more clean-burning coal we can supply him,” Thorin told Gandalf as they began their descent into the maze of tents. “Our supply was already low,” he lowered his voice as he slowed their steps. “There are three caravans of the old and other families coming over the mountains soon enough. They will need warmth more than a wizard who I am relatively sure can summon his own fire to warm himself. And with what the ravens have reported...we may need all the fuel we can ration to keep those who cannot fight safe inside Erebor.”

         Gandalf's laugh puffed out large white clouds in front of them. “You've got me there,” he said, patting at his chest. “Saruman can make due with a few less warming braziers in the coming days, I am sure. One of us can persuade him.” His amused expression slid away. “It shows your character, Thorin, that you would worry about those who cannot fight, that you would shelter them inside your mountain even now, when your own people are short of supplies, in the face of this danger. Your father would be proud of you.”

         Thorin looked away at that. He did not want to think about what his father would have thought of his rule, of Thorin's own brief stint with the gold-madness, of what Thorin had done with his – with –

         “Thorin,” Gandalf stopped them with a gentle hand on Thorin's shoulder. “You are a good king. A good soul. Bilbo has forgiven you. Now you must learn to forgive yourself.”

         Thorin closed his eyes against that. “I do not know if I ever can.”

         The hand on his shoulder tightened, just a bit, before it lifted. “Then you would make Bilbo sad.”

         Thorin's eyes flew open at that. He glared up at the wizard. “That is underhanded.”

         “And yet something a hobbit would do,” Gandalf smiled down at him, though there were shadows of grief in his eyes that Thorin thought might have matched his own.

         Thorin grumbled under his breath as he began to stomp his way towards the main line of tents. “Make sure Saruman understands the severity of our stores,” he said to change the subject.

         “Myself and Radagast will do what we can to persuade him and the others.”

         Thorin pursed his lips, not liking that Saruman would need to be persuaded to allow the old and the children to be warm but he decided that he had pushed the issue enough. Gandalf could handle his wizard Order and if worse came to worst then perhaps Thorin could appeal to Eönwë's own good sense to knock Saruman into being a marginally better creature.

         Then again, perhaps it was the lack of tea making Thorin grumpier than usual. Surely it was that. Of course it was.

         “I am not sure what the men or elves do for Yule,” Thorin said as they came to a stop by the first line of tents. There was a bit of a crowd forming in front of one of them. They were full of Thranduil's people and the tents furthest away from Erebor's main gates. “There are rites that my people deem sacred that must be done at the correct times but I do not think our holy ones would allow any others into them. Only...” He looked away. There were no more hobbits in Arda and therefore no way to include them. “Do you,” Thorin had to stop and clear his throat. “Is there anything that we should...do? For them?” He was sure Gandalf knew who he meant.

         The wizard was silent for a long moment. They stood together in the warming sun as more and more bodies began to move about the tents before them. Thorin had no idea what was going on with Thranduil's people but it looked as though some of Bard's people were mingling with them as well. Wonderful. “I had only ever been to celebrations in the summer,” Gandalf finally said. Thorin chanced a look at him and saw a sad smile on the wizard's face. “Once I would come almost every year to let off fireworks on Midsummer. They had always enjoyed color and good cheer, good food and plenty of it, and flowers. Ah, the flowers, Thorin,” Gandalf sighed, one hand coming up to rest over his heart. “At Midsummer there would be a riot of color all across the Shire. More flowers than I can...name.”

         Thorin looked up at Gandalf, noticing the fading smile on his face. “What is it? What is wrong?”

         “Nothing...wrong,” Gandalf shook his head, brows coming together as his eyes tracked something only he could see. “Just...I had never paid it much mind, then,” his head cocked to one side. “All the flowers. How warm and beautiful it was. How...familiar.” His lips pursed.

         It was Thorin's turn to frown. “I do not understand.”

         “I'm sure it is nothing,” but the frown that remained on Gandalf's face belied that. “It is just –”

         “Gandalf? King Thorin. There you are.”

         Thorin turned to see the young Ranger Aragorn striding up to them. “Aragorn,” he greeted the young man with a bow. Behind the young man were several other Rangers, all older and far rougher looking. “Is everything well?”

         “No,” Aragorn's expression was almost grim as he looked between them. “Might we speak somewhere more private?” He nodded back towards the path that Thorin and Gandalf had just come down.

         Thorin exchanged a look with Gandalf but they allowed the young man to lead them up the ridge at some distance, perhaps even far enough that Thranduil's keen ears could not listen in. Though with the crowd starting to form about Thranduil's tent, Thorin thought the nosy elven king would not have been able to hear them over the growing noise.

         “Aragorn,” Gandalf said when they were alone at the top of the ridge, voice grave. “What is the matter?”

         Aragorn looked down at the field of tents, his face in sharp profile. This way Thorin could see just how young the lad was, perhaps not even twenty, but there was a sad kind of wisdom that shaded his eyes dark. “There has been several...confrontations between several groups of men in the encampment,” he said as he turned back to them. “My people have kept themselves out of it and have tried to separate those we could, but it is starting to spiral out of control.”

         Thorin felt a bolt of ice shoot down his spine at that. “Fighting? But why?”

         “That's just it. There does not seem to be a spark that ignites it,” Aragorn shook his head. Long strands had slipped free from the tie at the base of his skull, casting dark hair over his cheeks as the wind picked up and whistled past them. “The latest was between some of the guards of Lord Ecthelion II and Prince Thengel's men.”

         “But they are allies,” Thorin frowned at that. He glanced out over the sea of tents, picking out the flags that marked the two leader's areas. “Or at least gave the impression of being so.”

         “They are allies, for the most part,” Aragorn's mouth was pressed into a thin line. “Which is why it was so surprising. But even Lord Ecthelion II and Prince Thengel are becoming...estranged from each other.”

         Thorin didn't like the sound of that at all. “Why?” He could see pockets of men milling about their separate areas but all seemed calm at the moment. “When did these happen?”

         “Last night,” Aragorn said. “After the last meal. Perhaps there was ale involved, but...” Aragorn shook his head. “They did not fight as though they were intoxicated. More like...”

         “More like what?”

         Dark eyes pinned Thorin in place. “More like they had been instigated to ire, to anger, to bitter words and sore feelings.”

         Thorin curled his hands into fists. “As if a shadow had provoked them?”

         Aragorn nodded, slow and solemn. “Exactly like that.”

         Thorin let out a slow breath. “There is more news that needs to be told to everyone gathered,” he said. “Gandalf and I have just now realized that the news from our ravens has not been reaching myself or my council. Someone – perhaps a dwarf, or perhaps something...other,” he cut a look at Gandalf. “Has been reaching the ravens first and taking that news. Although...” Something occurred to Thorin then and he looked back up at Gandalf. “If Nori sent out other runners, then why did the ravens not repeat their news? Why did all of Nori's lads say that there was no news at all?”

         Gandalf's expression grew grave. “Then either the ravens or Nori's boys have been made to forget what they either said or heard.”

         “Is that even possible?”

         Gandalf nodded, slow and thoughtful. “It is,” he said. “Though it would take a great deal of power to do so.”

         “What kind of power?” Thorin shifted on his feet.

         Gandalf did not answer for a long moment, those dark eyes studying him, though Thorin could not say just what the wizard's expression meant. “The kind of power seen only in the oldest of the elves, those who had been born and nurtured in Valinor when the light of the Two Trees still shown...or by a Maiar.”

         Thorin opened his mouth, closed it, looked at Aragorn who had gone as pale as Thorin felt, and then said, “Then either the Lady Galadriel, Lord Glorfindel, Lord Maedhros, Lord Ecthelion, or...” He stopped and swallowed. “Lord Eönwë and the others like yourself could have done this.”

         “Indeed,” Gandalf said.

         “But...” Thorin shook his head. “Why would they do such a thing? Unless...” He rocked back on his heels. “Unless they were agents of Morgoth.”

         “Yes.”

         Thorin looked back over the sea of tents that were spread over his front lawn. “It would explain the shadow we have all seen move through the camp.”

         “It would.”

         Thorin drew in a long breath and let it out just as slow. “And if we go down and say such a thing, it would only ignite tempers further. Which would lead to more dissent and suspicion when we need unity the most.”

         “Yes.”

         Thorin ran a hand over his face, fighting back the urge to growl. “I need to speak to Nori. He can find his boys and perhaps we can see what they remember or what parts of their memories have been changed. Or made to forget.”

         Gandalf leaned on his staff next to them. Aragorn had looked away, his face in profile against the winter sky. “That would be a start, yes.”

         Thorin glowered at the wizard. “Then what else would you have me do?”

         Gandalf stayed silent for a long, long moment. Then he sighed and his head bowed, the brim of his tall hat hiding his face until he looked up once more. “You are right,” the wizard said, surprising Thorin. “Speaking to Nori would be the best and most logical first step. We must know what has been said to your people before we start suspecting those among us.”

         “I do not think Lord Eönwë could be behind any of this,” Aragorn was the one to say. “He is the herald of Manwë himself. There would be no way for such a spirit to hide any allegiance to Morgoth from the leader of the Valar.”

         “I agree,” Gandalf said. “Lord Eönwë must be informed, as well as Galadriel. We have been in contact with each other since she arrived. I would know if her mind was touched by evil, and she I.”

         “At the very least the news that Roäc gave me this morning must be given to all who are here,” Thorin said. “There is movement in the world, all of which seems to be coming here.”

         “Movement?” Aragorn's dark gaze did not waver.

         Thorin nodded at him. “Men and elves, plus what might be orcs and the spiders of Mirkwood.” Thorin glanced down at Thranduil's section of tents. The crowd there had grown, with the Woodland king himself standing among them now with Bard at his side. Thorin still had no idea what was going on down there.

         “But there was just a large battle with such evil forces,” Aragorn's head came up, brows coming together. “There cannot be enough left in the world to form another army to march upon Erebor.”

         “The ravens have seen what they have seen and I do not doubt them. That such information has been suppressed by either someone or some force we have not found adds credence to that outcome. Add in the fact that the Arkenstone, the Silmaril, has not yet been found...” Thorin shook his head. “I fear that more is moving in the world than we think.”

         “This knowledge cannot be kept to just a few,” Aragorn said. “It would create more friction and divide than to allow whatever power or person among us to be kept in the dark. That shadow already knows of the movements headed this way. Everyone else must know as well.”

         “I agree with you,” Thorin said. He looked to Gandalf then. “And you, old friend?”

         Gandalf bowed his head at that. “We must tell them all,” he agreed. “Immediately.”

         Before Thorin could say more he spotted a blur moving on the plains beyond the encampment. His attention drew Aragorn and Gandalf's, the both of them turning with sharp concern, watching as that blur became a rider on a pale horse, pulling up short just outside the ring of tents before throwing himself off and darting into the maze tents beyond.

         “That is Haldir,” Gandalf was the one to say. “His brothers were the ones to accompany Galadriel here. It must be dire news for Celeborn to have Haldir leave his side.”

         They started down from the ridge as one, with the wizard and Aragorn's long legs making Thorin almost trot to keep up. He did not ask for them to slow, eager himself to see just what kind of news would send such a rider galloping up so fast. A crowd was already gathering about the lady's tent when they arrived. Lord Ecthelion II stood apart from Prince Thengel for the first time since Thorin had seen the two together, both of them pale and with deep shadows under their eyes. Eönwë and Maedhros were just arriving as Thorin and the others came to a stop outside Galadriel's tent.

         It was Lord Elrond's councilor, Master Erestor, who opened the tent flap. He was as pale as Thorin had ever seen him. The lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion, who were standing by Maedhros, started forward but stopped when Erestor spoke. “My lords,” the elf said, sweeping his gaze over the growing crowd. “You are needed.” Then he stepped aside and held up the tent flap for them to enter.

         Thorin pushed down a shiver those words provoked. He looked towards the mountain, just for a second, and thought for a wild moment he saw someone standing on the balcony above the gates. Then he blinked and the figure was gone. Thorin pushed all thoughts and hopes of who that figure could have been to the back of his mind. He could not linger on hopeless dreams, not now. Then he drew in a breath and focused his gaze forward, on the problems he could clearly see, and what steps they would need to take to meet these dangers head on and without fear.

         Thorin had made a silent promise to Bilbo when he had woken up from the gold-madness that had ruined his world. A promise that he would protect those who could no longer protect themselves, that he would do his best to fix all that he had broken and more. So with that thought Thorin faced the problem in front of him and let everything else go. It was a promise Thorin intended to keep, no matter what.

 

Chapter 30: great horrors bring great bravery

Chapter Text

 

         Thorin entered the tent with Gandalf, thanking Erestor as he passed. The elf seemed surprised but graced him with a strained smile. It did not bode well for the news they were about to hear. Thorin found the lady's tent sparsely furnished, with only a small table for the lady and a few others to sit at. Lord Elrond was already seated, as was Lord Eönwë and Maedhros, and there was one more chair, which Thorin found himself sitting in, a little to his shock. He would have thought that Gandalf would take it. As he sank into his seat the other wizards came bustling in, Saruman between the two blue wizards, the three of them glowering at the table and lack of chairs as if it were an insult just for them.

         The Lady Galadriel held up a hand before anyone could speak. Her eyes swept over the crowd, stilling murmurs and closing mouths. “Grave news has come from the borders of Lothlórien,” she said, her voice rich and full of a power that made Thorin want to shiver. Her gaze went to the elf kneeling before her. His pale hair was a tangle down his back and he was streaked with dirt in places. It was perhaps the most disheveled Thorin had ever seen an elf be. “Haldir,” Galadriel said. “Tell them the news that comes from our far forest.”

         The elf, Haldir, bowed his head to the lady before he turned to face the room. He still knelt, but from the way his hands were trembling on his knee, Thorin thought it might be more out of exhaustion than respect. “Grave news I bring,” Haldir began. Thorin thought the elf's gaze lingered on him the longest, but why he could not say. “A fortnight ago strange sightings began to be seen in the mountains near our home. A patrol of scouts were sent out but only two made it back. It was from them that we then learned that the entrance to Moria had opened.” A shocked murmur stirred through the room. “More scouts were sent then and what was learned had my Lord Celeborn sending me hence. For not only was the entrance to Moria opened, a great host of goblins and orcs were seen gathering at the gates, were smoke began to stream out, as if fires had been ignited in the belly of the mountain once more.”

         Thorin closed his eyes at that, his heart feeling like a lead weight in his chest. “You think Durin's Bane has woken,” he said as he opened his eyes. Haldir met his gaze and gave him a grave nod.

         “That is our fear,” the elf said.

         “But only a fear,” Lord Ecthelion II said as he stepped forward. His brows were drawn down tight together. “Smoke can be only that. Smoke.”

         “Perhaps,” Haldir said as he looked up at the man. “But it is a foul smoke, unlike many of our people have scented in the ages since Moria was abandoned. The sheer amount of goblins and orcs are to such numbers that we have not seen since the dwarves of Erebor attempted to retake their ancient home.”

         Thorin leaned forward at that. “There was just a large battle here,” he swept out a hand, towards where the mounds of the dead orcs and wargs and goblins had been buried. “Azog was said to have rallied all of the orcs in the mountains for this push. Surely that would have decimated their numbers?”

         “Indeed,” Gandalf said on the heels of Thorin's words. The wizard had his arms crossed tight across his chest. “I saw with my own eyes the numbers of goblins in the mountains and the orcs that came to fight here before Erebor. How could there be such a large number of them still?”

         “I do not know,” Haldir said as he looked to his lady. “I can only tell you what our scouts have seen, what I have seen, with my own eyes. There are thousands of them,” Haldir said and a great murmur swept through the tent. “All of them gathering at the entrance to Moria, as if waiting for something.”

         “Waiting for what, then?” Prince Thengel said. He, too, was frowning. “And forgive me, but this sounds more of a problem for the elves of Lothlórien than we here before Erebor.”

         Angry voices were raised at that. Lady Galadriel held up a hand, her gaze sharp as she met Prince Thengel's eyes. “Do you think the orcs and goblins near Lothlórien are massing on their own?”

         Prince Thengel's eyes narrowed as he glanced about the gathered leaders in the tent. “Then what do you believe is going on?”

         “Have we not been speaking of Morgoth's plans in this new and changing world?” Galadriel's eyebrows went up. Prince Thengel shifted on his feet but the mulish expression on his face did not fade. There were a few agreeing whispers through the crowd. Galadriel's gaze swept over them all. “We have seen the shadow of Morgoth moving in the land, even here.” Everyone went quiet. “I believe this is part of his plan as well.” Her gaze went back to Haldir and her expression softened. “Lothlórien will hold for as long as we can, though I fear that it will fall under a concentrated onslaught by Morgoth's darkness. But it is not just the orcs and goblins that are gathering that fills my heart with dread.”

         Thorin saw Glorfindel look to Ecthelion. The two elves had gone pale.

         “If the balrogs of Morgoth have woken once more, then I fear both for my people...but also for the world as a whole,” Galadriel looked to Eönwë then, whose expression had become drawn and grave.

         “Young were the powers of the West when Morgoth was dragged from his first fortress of Utumno,” the herald of Manwë said. “The Valar did not understand the scope of Morgoth's depravity for years untold, until he moved against the Valar and the Eldar in Aman with the help of Ungoliant. It was only after that terrible betrayal that the Valar realized the depths of his evil...and what that evil could do to the spirits that followed him. Later, Oromë would ride forth to see what trails were left of those minions of Morgoth's and what the Hunter found was startling. The fire spirits, those which are called balrogs on these far shores, are perhaps the most well known of Morgoth's vile lieutenants.” Here Eönwë looked to Glorfindel and Ecthelion. “As many of the Eldar would learn to their despair during the First Age in Beleriand, and then later, when the forces of Aman came to cast Morgoth out once and for all. It was in that War of Wrath that we faced many of these evil spirits...and thought them all defeated. We were wrong.” He shook his head, lips twisted down into a frown. “Very wrong.”

         “Long has it been known that some few of these fire spirits escaped our armies at the end of the First Age,” Eönwë continued. He glanced at Galadriel and then back at the gathered crowd. “And until the spirit had been woken in your ancestors' kingdom,” Eönwë nodded to Thorin, “we thought they were lost or asleep, until the breaking of the world. That, perhaps, there was only one.” He shook his head. “I now believe we were wrong.”

         Thorin leaned forward then, catching Gandalf and Aragorn's eye. “There is more news to be heard,” he said. All eyes swung to him. “I learned this morning that the reports from our people's ravens have not been making it to the mountain.” He saw Nori slip into the tent, his expression as dark and serious as Thorin had ever seen it. “The leader of the ravens told me himself that he had been giving his reports on the area to a youngling with a knot on his chest.” Thorin shook his head. “Such a sign has not been seen in our mountain since we fled from Smaug's arrival. Nori,” he turned to his Spymaster then. “Have you learned more?”

         “I have,” Nori said, voice grim. “It's worse than we thought.”

         Thorin breathed in deep at that, bracing. “Tell us. Please.”

         Nori gave him a short nod and then glanced around at the crowd, but kept facing Thorin as he spoke. “I am missing at least four of my boys,” Nori began. Thorin closed his eyes against that for a moment. “The last one to see the ravens was found after the King's Guard brought me the message from King Thorin. He was curled up in bed, barely alive. Óin has him now in the healer's halls but does not know if he will make it.”

         “And the others?” Thorin said. “Where were they found?”

         “I had sent two of them to scout the north side of the mountain,” Nori's mouth was pressed into a bloodless line. “There were mentions of a possible door on that side in one of the records Ori found. When they did not check in as they were supposed to I sent out another pair to find them. They were found dead under a pile of rocks at the base of the mountain, far from where they should have been.”

         Thorin curled his hands into tight fists under the table. “Any sign of who murdered them?”

         Nori shook his head. “There were no tracks, nothing to follow. We do not even know how they were killed, only that they were. They had no wounds on them. They looked asleep aside from the way they were rotting.”

         “And these were the same dwarves you sent to speak to the ravens?” Galadriel asked, leaning forward on the table.

         “Yes, my lady,” Nori gave her a shallow bow.

         “And the other two you mentioned?”

         Nori's mouth slid into a scowl for a moment. “Gone. I do not know where they are.”

         Murmurs broke out at that. “This is troublesome news,” Lord Ecthelion II said. “How can we trust that any of the information you have given us these last few weeks is true?”

         “I agree with you,” Thorin hated to admit it, but it was true. He lifted his hands and spread them out on the table. “I do not know how much of what we were given as information is the truth. I can only set up a relay of dwarves from the ravens to the mountain, though that would put a large strain on my people.”

         “And the Silmaril?” Saruman demanded. “Is it safe?”

         “The Silmaril,” Thorin said with all the patience he could muster. “Has never been out of anyone's sight for a moment.”

         Saruman sniffed and looked away.

         “The news from the ravens that I and Gandalf heard today, though, is much like what you have told us,” Thorin forged on, looking to Haldir. The elf blinked at him, glanced at his lady, and then looked back at him. “Orcs and goblins swarming in the mountains when we thought that they were all but wiped out, as well as spiders growing in numbers in Mirkwood.” Thorin looked through the crowd to find Thranduil. The elven king had a sour twist to his mouth. “Were you aware of this?”

         “I was not,” Thranduil said. He shared a look with Bard, who was at his side. “Although I admit to have been...distracted these last few days and did not notice that I had not received word from my people.”

         “Distracted?” Prince Thengel raised an eyebrow at them. Thorin wondered why. Then he saw the faint flush on both Bard and Thranduil's faces and promptly decided he did not want to know. At all. Ever.

         “Be that as it may,” Thranduil said as he drew himself up to his full height.

         “Peace, Thranduil,” Galadriel held up a hand and it stopped whatever nonsense was about to come out of the elven king's mouth. Thankfully. “We can congratulate you on your nuptials later.” That made Thranduil sputter. “As for now,” the lady's eyes went to Thorin. “What else did your ravens say?”

         “Just that there was much movement, the likes of which the ravens had not seen since the battle here before Erebor,” Thorin said, ignoring the nuptials part of the last statement. He did not have time for that insanity. “They have lost their own people trying to see just what this movement is.”

         “And do they think these forces are coming here? To Erebor?”

         Thorin looked to Gandalf. The wizard closed his eyes as he nodded. “Yes,” Thorin said, agreeing with him. “We do.”

         Murmurs broke out at that. “We are exposed out here,” Lord Ecthelion II said as he looked about the tent. “If there is an attack at night we will have no warning but for the guards about the encampment.”

         “Which is why,” Thorin had to raise his voice over the growing noise of the gathered crowd. “Which is why,” he repeated when things quieted. “I would have you all move your people into Erebor itself.”

         There was a rustle that moved through the tent. “Forgive me for being wary, King Thorin,” Prince Thengel said after a moment. “But have you not said on multiple occasions that the mountain itself is not safe for those who are not dwarves?”

         “I have said that,” Thorin said. “But there are spaces, just inside the front gates, that are safe enough for now. The central cavern...” He hesitated, not wanting to explain or mention how things had been repairing themselves on their own. “Would not be as safe. But there are barracks just inside the main gates that we can move our own people out of and into deeper areas where my people are safe to traverse.”

         “And you would do that for us?”

         Thorin frowned at the man. “Of course,” he said. “We are all here for a common reason. It is my duty to protect all who have come to my kingdom. I would have you protected more by the deeper rooms but I worry that they are not habitable for anyone but my own kind. I apologize.”

         Prince Thengel held up a hand, his gaze dark as he studied Thorin. “Thank you,” he said after a moment. “As for my people, we will accept this offer.”

         “As will mine,” Lord Ecthelion II said after a moment.

         “There is more to consider,” Gandalf said as the murmurs died away. The wizard had his arms crossed over his chest and a dark frown on his face.

         “Such as?” Saruman asked, one eyebrow raised.

         Gandalf looked over at the other wizard and his frown did not ease. “Such movements speak to an organization I have not seen since...” He shook his head. “If the orcs and goblins are swarming, even with the losses they took after the battle here in Erebor, if the orcs and goblins in Moria are starting to move out of the darkness of the mountain itself...it is possible that these forces of darkness are aware that the bonds connecting Aman and Arda are close to fraying...and when those bonds snap, I fear these creatures' dark master will return through the Door of Night.”

         Silence swept through the tent. Eönwë bowed his head then and sighed. “I agree with you, Gandalf,” the herald of Manwë said.

         “The Door of Night is on the far western edge of the world. It too resides in Aman,” Saruman said as he stood up straight between the two blue wizards. His brows were drawn tight together. “As much as it aches me to say it, the Valar will have to be the first to face Morgoth's wrath when he comes through that dreaded Door.”

         “Will they, though?” Gandalf's head went back. Thorin did not know why Gandalf seemed almost...closed off when he faced the other wizard, now.

         “Of course they will,” Saruman's frown grew deeper. “What is wrong with you, old friend? You know where the Door is placed. The might of the Valar will meet Morgoth and keep him there. It is they who will defeat this darkness, not us.”

         “You seem certain of this.”

         “Gandalf, what is wrong with you?”

         Gandalf sighed then and looked away and it felt like Thorin could breathe again. Strange. “We do not know what will happen to the world when the spells that keep Valinor separate from Arda snap. Already we have seen the waves on the shores grow in size and number as parts of the old defenses of Aman reenter the world.”

         Saruman leaned back at that, his mouth moving a few times but Thorin could not hear what he said. “You think the Door will not travel to the same place as Aman,” he finally said.

         Gandalf's head dipped at that. “Yes.”

         “Then where...where would it appear?” Prince Thengel was the one to ask.

         Ice slid down Thorin's spine when Gandalf's gaze went to him. “I do not know for certain,” the wizard said, his dark eyes never leaving Thorin. “But we have seen signs of Morgoth here at Erebor. We have seen the passing of such mysteries that even I, once a spirit of the Timeless Halls, have never seen before. And I do not think it is by chance that all of us were called here. That the the powers of old have been given to us in this place.” He let out a sigh that seemed to echo in the room. “I fear that the Door of Night will not appear in Valinor as you hope, Saruman.” Gandalf's gaze finally left Thorin. “I fear it will come here.”

         Many voices spoke at once. All Thorin could hear was a faint ringing in his ears. It was true, he thought. The Arkenstone had been revealed as a Silmaril. A second had been given to him under the mountain itself. “But the third,” he said, his voice lost in the chaos growing around him. He stood and banged a hand on the table. All eyes turned to him. “What of the third Silmaril?” He turned his gaze to Eönwë. “We only have one left, the first is lost, stolen from us. Would the third Silmaril...could it come here, to help us?”

         At that Eönwë blinked and then looked...to Maedhros. “I do not know,” Eönwë said after a moment.

         “The last Silmaril is not in our possession,” Maedhros said when he looked away from Eönwë. “It resides with Eärendil in the West, where he sails through the skies upon his ship.”

         “And will he not return as Valinor returns?” Saruman's tone was sharp as he looked between the two. “Valinor will return. The Valar will return to the world. Thus Eärendil must return, and with him the final Silmaril.”

         “It may,” Eönwë said, spreading his hands before him as he shrugged. “But what he will do with that gem, I cannot say. And nor can we force him to give it over,” Eönwë frowned at Saruman. “You know this.”

         “Be that as it may,” Saruman began.

         “No,” Gandalf cut him off. “We cannot begin with such demands. A gift of a Silmaril must be exactly that. A gift.”

         “A gift that was given to a dwarf,” Saruman's mouth twisted as he spoke. “As the first Silmaril, that was also in his possession, was lost due to his carelessness!”

         Thorin drew himself up at that, even as others protested the wizard's words.

         “That is not the full truth of the matter, Saruman,” Galadriel said. She leaned forward to put a hand on Haldir's shoulder and the elf, who Thorin now realized was trembling, leaned into her touch. “Might we send Haldir to your healing halls, King Thorin?” He met the lady's gaze and nodded. Two other elves stepped up to help Haldir to his feet and guided him from the room. Her gaze was cool when she looked back to Saruman. “I am worried about your focus on the Silmarils, Saruman. It is true that they have been given to us here, to all of us, as King Thorin has said, but they are not a weapon to be used against the darkness that rises against us. They are the Light which is to break upon the world when the Healing of Arda begins.”

         “If it begins at this rate,” Saruman snapped back at her. The men about him drew back, except for the two blue wizards standing just behind him. Thorin narrowed his eyes at the way one of them – Pallando – put a hand on Saruman's shoulder. Saruman seemed to relax at that and then went stiff. Strange. “Forgive me,” Saruman said, surprising Thorin. The wizard put a trembling hand over his face.

         “Saruman?” Gandalf leaned forward at that, some of the fierceness gone from his expression. “What is wrong?”

         “I feel...” Saruman stopped and shook his head. His hand remained over his face. “Do you not feel it, Gandalf?”

         Thorin looked to the other wizard but Gandalf's gaze did not leave Saruman. “I do not know what you mean,” he said.

         Saruman's hand dropped and gasps arose. The wizard's eyes were blood-red. “The shadow,” Saruman croaked. The two blue wizards all but pushed the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion out of their way as they crowded close to Saruman. “It – it is –”

         “All is well,” Pallando said as he and his partner took Saruman's arms. “All is well, old friend. It is the stress of it all, I am sure.”

         “N-no, it is – I cannot –”

         “Let me see him,” Galadriel said as she stood from her chair.

         “No,” there was a sharp note to Pallando's voice that made even Thorin rock back on his heels. “You have all disregarded Saruman's warnings again and again and here we are.” The blue wizard looked up, his dark eyes furious as he swept his gaze over those gathered. “All of you who call yourselves members of the White Council sit with open minds and open hearts to the very shadow that is crawling all over this encampment. Allowing dwarves to hold the Silmarils!” Thorin bristled at the sneer directed his way. “Well do even we who traveled to the far reaches of the East know that the dwarves of Moria delved too deep and disturbed the sleeping minions of Morgoth. What is to say that they have not done so here as well?”

         Thorin curled his hands into fists. “There has never been any sign of Durin's Bane in Erebor.”

         “Yet Saruman said you told him of the great heat that once existed in the belly of your mountain,” the other blue wizard, Alatar, spat. “What else but the balrogs of Morgoth could cause such a thing?”

         Gasps arose at that. Thorin tilted his chin up, facing those stares now. “The heat in the heart of the mountain was a natural thing. The depths of the earth have such pockets of heat, that is what causes volcanoes,” he couldn't help but add at the skeptical looks on a few faces.

         “It is true,” Gandalf added after a beat. “Aulë himself spoke of such features.”

         “As did many of the spirits who were under him, like Sauron,” Pallando shot back. “Just as there was a volcano in Mordor and now one here? And it is infested with dwarves? Why can you not see how Morgoth's shadow has already corrupted these creatures?”

         “I am no creature,” Thorin could feel his nails bite into the palms of his hands. He held onto his temper with all his might. “I am a child of Eru Ilúvatar, just as you all are, though we also acknowledge our Maker as well, for it was Mahal who first brought us forth. We are no agents of Morgoth, nor of Sauron. But I will agree with you on this point, the shadow of Morgoth is moving through us, turning ally against ally, and causing bitter words and bitter hurts to be spoken and fester. We cannot allow that to happen.” He looked from leader to leader, his heart beating hard as both Prince Thengel and Lord Ecthelion II paused before they met his gaze with clearer eyes.

         “You are right,” Prince Thengel said. He scrubbed a hand over his face and glanced at Lord Ecthelion II for a moment. “Things have been...tense between us. I apologize.”

         “Apologizing...” Pallando began.

         “Enough!” Eönwë rose, his hand cracking down on the table loud enough to make everyone jump. “Do you not see how your own words are causing more divide? That you, Pallando, are encouraging that same shadow you claim to hate to grow?”

         “I would never!”

         “Peace, please,” Saruman mumbled from Pallando and Alatar's arms. “Peace,” he murmured and went limp.

         Cries went up but neither Pallando or Alatar would allow anyone near. “We will look after him,” Pallando said as they wrestled Saruman's weight between them. Thorin did not see how they were struggling so much. Saruman was not a large man. “Send your healers if you want but no one who has allowed their minds to be opened and polluted by the shadow of Morgoth is allowed to go near him!” Then they were gone, staggering away with Saruman between them.

         Thorin looked to Gandalf but the wizard had a hand over his mouth and his brows pinched together. “Something is wrong here,” he said.

         Gandalf's nod was grave. “I agree with you, my friend.”

         Thorin then looked to Eönwë, but the herald of Manwë was still staring at where the wizards had disappeared. “If the Door of Night comes here,” Thorin said and all eyes returned to him. Eönwë's gaze was last, but his eyes were brighter than Thorin had ever seen them. “If Morgoth returns here, then there is every chance that his minions are already on their way to meet him.” Thorin swept a look across all who were gathered. “The spiders of Mirkwood,” he looked at Thranduil, who tipped his chin up. “The orcs and goblins of the Misty Mountains and beyond,” he looked to Prince Thengel and Lord Ecthelion II. “Perhaps even the balrogs of old,” he then looked to Galadriel. The lady bowed her head in a slow nod to him. “We do not know what will happen, only that something will and at this point we cannot chance division among us. We must fight together to banish this shadow from the world or it will consume us all. There is no way to escape it.”

         “Your words are wise, King Thorin,” Galadriel said.

         “It is clear that Morgoth's shadow is trying to divide us. Hopefully now that we have seen it, that we have been brought closer together by this knowledge, that whatever may come, we will face it all as a force united.” Thorin swept a slow look over the gathered crowd.

         It was Aragorn who stepped forward first. “I will stand with you, King Thorin.” In that moment the young man did not look like an untried youth, but like man standing before Thorin, wise and somber and steady in his belief. “The Dúnedain of the North will gladly fight at your side.”

         Thorin bowed to him at that.

         To Thorin's surprise it was Thranduil who stepped forward next, with Bard at his side. “We have already fought together once, you and I, though it was by chance.” His mouth twisted and Thorin thought he saw the elf wince as Bard's arm moved away from Thranduil's side. “This time we will fight together from the start and let there be no more ill will between us.”

         Thorin met and held the elven king's stare for a long minute. Then he could not help his own half-smile. “This time I will be there from the start,” he said. Thranduil smirk almost made Thorin want to take the words back. Almost. “And from this moment may our two peoples wash the slate clean.”

         Thranduil bowed to him. Thorin bowed back.

         Bard looked a little uncomfortable as Thorin turned to look at him. “There aren't many of us left,” he said. His hand came up and rubbed at the back of his neck. “But the people of – of Dale,” he blinked a bit at that. “We'll help. As much as we can, at least.”

         Thorin bowed to him as well. “There is much that the people of Dale can do to help,” Thorin said. “As I remember, your family is great in their capabilities. We will need all forms of help in Erebor, should the fight come to us in the end.”

         There might have been a faint blush on the man's face but the stubble on his face hid much of it. He ducked his head in a half-bow and stepped back.

         Then the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion rose as one. They bowed to Thorin, low enough that Thorin felt his eyebrows go up. When they rose Lord Glorfindel said, “Thel and I have faced the horrors of Morgoth once before. We will face them again, should it come to it. We will not hide from him now, nor ever again.” Behind them Thorin saw Master Erestor go pale and then duck his head, the papers in his arms hugged tight to his chest.

         As one the rest of the elves in the room stood. Lady Galadriel, Lord Elrond, and Lord Maedhros all bowed, not just to Thorin but to the tent as a whole. “We all will fight,” Maedhros said as they rose. He looked to Lord Elrond for a long moment before a sad smile pulled at one side of his mouth. “Even if I would have some of us hidden away for their own safety.”

         “You've never been able to hide us away for a minute,” Galadriel said, tone light even as Lord Elrond rolled his eyes at Maedhros.

         “Our people will fight,” Prince Thengel said before Maedhros could finish sputtering at Galadriel. He looked at Lord Ecthelion II, who nodded at the other man and stepped forward with him.

         “We will fight as well,” Lord Ecthelion II said. “Though our forces are not an army and I do not know how well we can take up arms against such a power. But we will fight,” his chin came up. “To the last man.”

         Thorin bowed low to them both. “I thank you,” he said as he rose. He met their gazes squarely. “For none of us can do this alone.”

         “Truer words have never been said,” Gandalf said. Thorin looked to the wizard when Gandalf put a hand to his shoulder. Gandalf was smiling at him, though there was a sad slant to the expression Thorin could not explain. “Such unity in the face of darkness is something that Morgoth and his minions do not understand. Theirs is a life of fear and desperation, of betrayal and deception. This,” his other hand swept out, encompassing them all. “Is a Light that no darkness can ever snuff out. It makes my heart glad to see it.”

         “As done mine,” Eönwë said. His eyes were brighter than Thorin could remember them. “Know that even in the far reaches of Valinor the Valar will know of your words and pledges. My Lord Manwë will do everything he can to help us, as will all of the Valar. Have faith, if not in the Valar then in yourselves, for within you burns the same secret fire that burns in us all. That is a Light that Morgoth can never defeat.”

         Thorin bowed to him, unable to say more. When he rose he looked about the tent, at the fragile peace and trust that had settled among them once more. He knew they would have to act fast before those tenuous bonds were tested too soon. “We should start to immediately transfer everyone into Erebor's halls,” Thorin said. He looked for Balin, finding his old friend near the tent entrance, standing next to Nori. “Can we clear out the barracks just inside the gates?”

         “I have already sent runners to begin the process,” Balin said as all eyes turn to him. “It should take the rest of the day but there should be enough room to get everyone inside Erebor by sundown.”

         Thorin hesitated but there was no way around it. Those inside Erebor would know something was happening whether he and his people liked it or not. “And the Yule rites?”

         There was some shifting that went through the tent. “We can move it to the lower levels,” Balin said. “I will speak to Alviss.”

         “Please do,” Thorin said, a knot of worry lifting off his heart. The only year their people had not done any rites for Yule was when they had been driven out of Khazad-dûm. Thorin could not fathom not doing something for the longest night of the year, but if Balin could get Alviss to shift their rites to the lower levels then there should be no concern of interruptions. He hoped. He looked back to those gathered in the tent. “I do not know all of your Yule customs,” he said to the tent at large. “But myself and my people will try to accommodate you all as best we can.”

         “That is all anyone can do in such trying times,” Gandalf said before anyone else could speak. “Thank you, King Thorin.” There was a chorus of thanks after him. Thorin nodded at them all. “Come,” Gandalf continued, raising his voice over the low murmur that had broken out in the tent. “It will take all of us working together to get everyone behind Erebor's great gates. Let us waste no time.” That seemed to spur everyone on, with many ducking out of the tent after Balin as the crowd began to dissipate. Gandalf's hand on his shoulder kept Thorin in place, even when Lady Galadriel left with Maedhros and Lord Elrond.

         When they were alone Thorin looked up at the wizard. “What is the matter?”

         Gandalf paused for a long moment and then patted Thorin's shoulder once, twice, and then let his hand fall. “I am worried,” the wizard said at last.

         Thorin looked from Gandalf to the entrance where the wizard's gaze had caught and stayed. “About Saruman?”

         A long sigh left Gandalf. “Yes.”

         Thorin nodded at that. “I am worried as well. Something seems...off with him. Or,” he frowned, “the other ones. I cannot tell. You have known Saruman longest. What do you think?”

         Gandalf's pause was long. Thorin could hear the rise of voices outside the tent, people calling to one another as the tents were organized and cleaned out. There was much to do. “Saruman was a spirit that served under Aulë,” Gandalf said to Thorin's surprise. “He has always been a creature of order, with a vast desire to understand how things work, sometimes to his detriment. He has always been guarded, sharp in speech, but never...never this unkind. Or...strange.” Gandalf shook his head.

         “Could it be the influence of the others?” Thorin looked to the entrance and then back to Gandalf. “They seem to be glued to Saruman's sides.”

         “They do indeed,” Gandalf's brows came together. “Would you...I do hate to ask this of you,” Gandalf looked down at him at last. “But is there any way for young Nori or his people to keep an eye on both Saruman and the blue wizards?”

         Thorin nodded at that. “I will have Nori assign someone to watch over their rooms at all times. They might be stretched a bit thin to follow them everywhere, but with the way things are going,” Thorin pursed his lips as he paused. “I fear that whatever will happen will happen soon.”

         Gandalf's shoulders sagged. “Yes,” the wizard said. “I agree.”

         “But we will face it together,” Thorin said as he looked up at Gandalf. The wizard smiled at him then.

         “We shall,” Gandalf said. Then, “Come. Let us go out before Thranduil tries to start a fight with Balin over his rooms.”

         Thorin pulled a face at that and was a step in front of Gandalf as they went out the door. They would face what would come together, yes, but if Thranduil tried to complain about anything one more time...

         Thorin never saw the way the tent flap behind them rustled once and then fell flat, as if smoothed out by invisible hands. Then all the tent was still as the encampment burst into life about them, men and elves and dwarves going to and fro. None of them saw the extra supplies slipped into different rooms, nor how a certain hallway inside of Erebor shimmered once and then vanished without a trace. But that was for later. For now the halls of Erebor came to life bit by bit as the men and elves moved into rooms not occupied for decades. The sound of laughter and good cheer soon filled the mountain as the sun began to set on the eve of the longest night.

         And, outside the mountain, now devoid of tents, a shadow slipped across the land, darker than night itself, there and gone between one breath and the next.

 

Chapter 31: the longest night

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

         News of the men and elves moving into Erebor's halls reached Bilbo while he was with Fortinbras and Lalia, the three of them sitting in the front hall of the Great Smials with a pile of lists at each of their elbows. The tangle of threads about Bilbo's wrist and hand warmed in one part. He glanced down to see two of the threads that stretched across the back of his hand go from white to yellow.

         Interesting.

         “Bilbo?”

         He looked up to see Fortinbras also staring at the threads that were now tangled about Bilbo's left hand. Bilbo wasn't sure just how long he had been gone with the widows after the reveal of so many hobbits all gathered in one place but Bilbo was rather sure it wasn't as long as it had felt on his end. “It's nothing,” he said, running a finger along the thread. There was a flash of annoyance and a sharp-tasting fury that was there and gone that made Bilbo wrinkle his nose. “Someone's in a state, that's all.”

         “A state,” Fortinbras repeated, giving the threads one last dubious look. Bilbo knew his cousin wanted to know what they were and what they were for but Bilbo could not tell him, even if he wanted to. His tongue was still sore from the prick of the widow's needles, thank you and good morning.

         “Things are moving,” Bilbo shrugged at him. “I will need to step away come midnight.”

         Fortinbras frowned at him at that. “But it's the longest night. You're to spend it with family.”

         “And I will,” Bilbo reached forward and patted Fortinbras' hand. “I just want to...check in.”

         “Check in.”

         “Yes.”

         “Check in on who.”

         Bilbo looked away at that.

         “Bilbo.”

         “I won't be going out of the in between,” he hand up his right hand to halt his cousin's concerns. “I just...I want to make sure they are safe.”

         That seemed to take the wind out of Fortinbras' sails. “You'll not step an inch outside, you got that?”

         “I do.”

         “Good.” Fortinbras grumbled a bit, shuffling the papers around him with a bit more vigor than necessary. Then, “Are you sure –”

         “I cannot tell you a thing,” Bilbo wanted to throw his hands up in the air. He really did.

         “But...”

         “Take it up with Widow Minona if you like.”

         That got Fortinbras to snap his mouth shut on whatever else he was about to say. “No, thank you.”

         Bilbo snorted at that, which got Fortinbras to shove his shoulder, then Bilbo was shoving his shoulder and by the time Lalia pried them apart they were rolling about on the rug like faunts.

         “Enough of that,” Lalia said as she stood over them, hands on her hips. “Really. What an example to be setting.”

         “Well,” Bilbo said, drawing out the word.

         “No,” her finger came up.

         “We are wrestling like Tulkas, so...”

         “I said, no!”

         Bilbo was breathless with laughter by the time he and Fortinbras peeled themselves off the yellow and red stripped rug. Lalia was tutted at them the entire time, though Bilbo could see how she was also trying to fight off a smile of her own. It was good to see a bit of levity in his cousins when so much had been changing around them.

         The reveal of the different hobbit clans from all over the world had well and truly shaken up the hobbits from the Shire. As it turned out – Bilbo had learned later – the Shire was indeed the highest concentration of hobbits in Arda. The rest of the clans had been scattered across the world, from north to south, east to the Shire's west, each of them stemming from that one point in Beleriand during the time of the Two Trees. From what had been learned, later, was that while most of their people had stayed in Utumno, not knowing anywhere else to go, after some time clans began to escape from the wretched wastes and find their way east to better lands and easier lives. These hobbits had all adapted to their different lands, with most of them hiding from the civilizations about them, carving out their own cultures and lives without most having a clue they were there.

         The widows, Bilbo had also learned, had been watching this slow creep of their people across Arda since the beginning. They had chosen not to interfere with their descendants, only interacting with those widows of their people who retained the history and memory of the old gifts and what little fading knowledge of what their people used to be. The widows had also been in the process of closing up the in between when Bilbo had made that last desperate leap.

         And then, well. Things changed.

         Bilbo dusted off his clothes as they all got to their feet. The table was still a mess of papers and cups of cooling tea. His smile wobbled a bit but was firm enough when he turned to see Fortinbras with his arms about Lalia and the two of them holding each other tight. “I think it is time for bed,” he said, clapping his hands together loud enough to make the pair of them jump. He grinned at the sour looks that earned him. “Go on now,” he made shooing motions with his hands, ignoring the way the threads about his wrist were turning blue and green. “Ferumbras is sure to be missing you.”

         “Ferumbras is passed out in bed,” Lalia said, wagging her finger at him. “But it is late.” She dropped her hand and looked around. They were the last up in this part of the Great Smials. “I suppose this will all keep.” Her expression wobbled a bit before Fortinbras slid an arm over her shoulders and pulled her close.

         “Make sure to come home to us,” Fortinbras said as he began to guide Lalia away. “We'll wait up for you.”

         “It's talk like that which starts the rumors!” Bilbo couldn't help but call after them as the pair made their way out the door. His cousin didn't bother to turn, just waved at him as they disappeared from view. Within moments Bilbo was alone in this part of the Great Smials for the first time in what felt like forever. At least since all of his people had been pulled into the in between and then on to Erebor.

         Bilbo looked over at the papers and then down at the threads wrapped about his hand. He traced one of them that wrapped around the base of his thumb and around his finger, before it stretched across the back of his hand to join the tangled web there.

         The place Widow Minona had led him to had been...strange. He could not, now, remember much of it, though he did remember the way the widows wrapped his hand in threads to match theirs, after...well. After. All had been dark. All had been so strangely still. It had made his ears pop. There had been strange bursts of light in the darkness, like tiny fireworks full of so many colors that Bilbo could not count them. He ran the edge of his nail against part of the web that stretched across the back of his hand and felt a shiver run down his spine. Soon, the threads whispered. The main hall of the Great Smials wavered in front of him, like a too-thick fog that had half-formed shapes walking through it, there and gone.

         The chiming of the sand-clock in the corner made Bilbo jump, his hands falling apart as he blinked the world back into focus. The Great Smials were quiet but not like the place he had been taken. Here he could still hear the odd shuffle of a hobbit in the hall, most likely on their way to bed since the longest night would be upon them in...

         Bilbo cast a glance at the sand-clock and calculated the time. By Shire reckoning the longest night would not begin until sundown of Yule, when the Sickle would appear in the northern skies, bright and beautiful, and a call to them all.

         Bilbo had always wondered why their winter rites would start at the rise of the Sickle. He knew now why. It made a smile pull at his mouth to think that he had looked upon that same Sickle when he had first come to Long Lake, seeing it glittering in the waters before he ever saw it in the sky. Perhaps it had been a sign. Perhaps it had been chance.

         Bilbo gave himself a shake and glanced about the hall. There was little time for woolgathering. Not if he wanted to get there and back again before his cousins came to drag him back by the ear themselves. And wouldn't that send more tongues wagging? Bilbo wrinkled his nose at the thought and turned to the side, slipping into the in between right there in the middle of the hall.

         The long walk to the Royal Wing was silent. The tunnels of the in between were growing more and more decorated with every hour as the longest night came rushing towards them all. The closer he got to Thorin and Dwalin the more the decorations turned more angular, just like those inside Erebor. He had not been able to ask any of the widows about why they changed or what it meant but in the end, did it matter? This part of the in between would also hold a part of the dwarves of Erebor, since it was they who had reached out and gave them a home when the fires of Morgoth's minions had tried to burn them all to ash and dust. But Morgoth – and his minions – had never been very good at being small, at being hidden. They did not know how to wait out a winter for the promise of spring, nurturing small life in the palms of their hands until it could bloom on its own without their help. No. Morgoth and his minions knew none of that.

         Bilbo shook off those thoughts as he slipped down the angled hall, stopping in front of Thorin and Dwalin's rooms. He had been a bit...overzealous with his own fixing here in these halls. The curved wooden beams were most likely too dark and too hobbit-ish for the dwarves but he hoped they would allow it to stay. Only time would tell, now. He avoided the glowing lines that marked the floors and walls, and even the ceilings. Such protections could not reach into the in between but Bilbo had learned to be better safe than sorry. The last thing he needed was to tip their hands before anything could begin.

         Bilbo shivered as he stepped into Thorin and Dwalin's rooms. He knew there were other watchers in the hallways outside, both seen and unseen. The King's Guard were patrolling the halls, their boots stomping out a rhythm Bilbo could feel in his bones. Nori's boys were harder to spot, finding little nooks and crannies that were hidden from plain sight. It made the knots about Bilbo's chest loosen to know that his dwarves were so well looked after and protected.

         Especially now.

         Bilbo slipped through the rooms until he reached the shadowed bedroom. It made his cheeks heat as he crept closer to the bed, one silent step at a time. A fire was banked in the hearth, the coals fighting back the chill as winter began to settle in for certain. There was a storm on the horizon, the weather-wise had said at sunset, when Bilbo had come stumbling out of that strange no-where place the widows had taken him to. Fortinbras had been in a strop when Bilbo had finally returned to his side, though few had been able to tell, Bilbo was certain. The addition of the threads about Bilbo's hand had not lessened that worry in his cousin's eyes but there had been no way for Bilbo to explain. Even Lalia had looked at him with wide eyes when she had caught sight of them.

         Things could come clear soon, Bilbo knew. He pressed the tip of his sore tongue to the roof of his mouth. Very soon. They just had to get there, first.

         On a table near the hearth sat the crown Bilbo had found inside the in between. He paused in front of it, studying the glittering blue gems that dotted the crown of Durin. Thorin, to his knowledge, had only worn it the once. Otherwise it sat on the stand that had been made for it, like a mathom out on display. Bilbo's fingers hovered over the metal, feeling the tingling feel of the threads pull across his skin. There was no shadow in that item, not with how the threads wrapped about the tips of his fingers stayed the same color. He still was not sure just why the crown had come to them inside the in between but it had been a stroke of luck for Thorin in that tricky patch of plots going on about them all.

         Bilbo gave himself a shake and let his hand drop. He was not here to look at mathoms. He should not even be here at all, except he could not help himself. He looked over to the bed, his face feeling like he could fry an egg on it, and crept even closer, even though neither Thorin or Dwalin could possibly hear him inside the in between.

         Thorin and Dwalin's bed was a massive thing, larger than almost any bed Bilbo had seen in the Shire. Certainly bigger than any Bilbo had slept in, though perhaps the bed in Rivendell came close. Thorin lay on his left side, Dwalin on his right, the pair of them facing each other in that massive bed. Their hands were almost touching in the space between them, a space just big enough for...

         Bilbo blinked hard and gave himself a small shake. No. He could not think of that. Not right now. Not when things were still so unsettled and the future was still a murky patch of knotted threads that no one could yet untangle.

         Bilbo crept as close as he could to the bed, studying the pair, and counting each breath. They were as quiet as Bilbo had ever heard them, since the majority of his silly Company snored like the dickens. Especially the Ur family. Thorin and Dwalin had always been silent sleepers though and now Bilbo found himself holding his own breath as he watched them breathe.

         Bilbo froze just as he went to take a step back from the bed. For there, staring at him from across the space of Thorin's slumbering body, was Dwalin's open eyes. Panic shot through Bilbo. His limbs felt like ice. For all that he suspected that his dwarves didn't really hate him, that they meant every word they had said to him, that they – that they might love –

         “Bilbo?” The word was little more than a breath above a whisper. Bilbo could not move. He could not breathe. His whole body felt like it was locked in place. Dwalin pushed up to his elbow and Bilbo blinked hard at the sight of lines from the pillow pressed into his cheek. Bilbo wanted to cup that skin, feel the indentations against his fingers. He wanted...

         “Bilbo?” Dwalin blinked those blue eyes as his gaze slipped past where Bilbo stood frozen, scanning the entire room. There was a...wobble to Dwalin's voice that made Bilbo's chest ache. Dwalin's lips moved again but no words came out. Bilbo thought it might have been his name again. He thought it might have been something else. He still could not move as Dwalin reached out a hand, stretching across Thorin's still body, but the distance was too far for Dwalin's hand to reach Bilbo. Then those rough fingers curled inwards and Dwalin's expression...it did not crumple, but the hope that was there faded to a sadness that made Bilbo want to crawl onto that bed and into Dwalin's arms.

         Soon, he had to tell himself, curling and uncurling his hands at his sides. He could feel the way the threads pulled with the movement, the way some of them warmed and some of them cooled. Soon.

         Dwalin's hand dropped back down to the bed and that was when Bilbo realized that Thorin was also awake. Thorin took Dwalin's hand in his own and pressed a kiss to the back of it. It was the first of such gestures between them that Bilbo had seen and a part of him felt guilty at standing there, watching them like a thief they had once so labeled him.

         “I am sorry,” Dwalin said as he looked down at Thorin. “I did not mean to wake you.”

         “All is well,” Thorin did not move from where he was curled up. He slotted their hands together and tugged until Dwalin was laying down next to him once more. “What woke you?”

         Bilbo held his breath at Dwalin's long pause. “I do not know,” Dwalin said at last. Bilbo let out a sigh at that. It was silly to hope... “I thought...” Dwalin's voice turned rough. He shook his head, just a bit. “I thought Bilbo was here,” he said, softer. He closed his eyes and Bilbo's chest ached all the more.

         Thorin used their tangled hands to pull Dwalin closer, until they were touching from head to foot. Bilbo knew he should creep away, that this was not for him to see, that his own silence was causing this grief to linger, but he could not lift this pain from his dwarves. Not yet. Not until everything was fixed and there were no more shadows slipping about the mountain, threatening those who Bilbo loved most.

         “Bilbo is here,” Thorin said and it felt like a bolt of ice down Bilbo's spine. He watched with wide eyes as Thorin let go of Dwalin's hand to reach up and put a hand to Dwalin's cheek. “He is always with us.”

         Bilbo squeezed his eyes shut and had to turn his face away.

         “Thorin,” Dwalin sighed and there was a rustle of sheets. When Bilbo was able to open his eyes again he saw that Thorin had pulled Dwalin to him, the two of them tangled together in the bed, arms wrapped about each other.

         “Gandalf said that he did not know how the hobbits celebrated Yule,” Thorin's whisper felt too loud to Bilbo's ears. Still he could not look away from the pair. “We will bring him with us in our rites and he will be with us there. He will be with us each day and each night. He is here, I believe it.”

         Dwalin said nothing but he turned his face into Thorin's chest. The two of them went quiet, the bedroom settling about them once more. Bilbo stayed silent and still, watching them drift back to sleep, the slow rise and fall of their chests in sync with one another. Bilbo watched them for a long moment before creeping close to the bed. He lowered himself until he was level with them and put a hand to the covers, not daring to touch them. Not yet. The hand that was woven with threads lay so close to them that if Bilbo or they moved even a bit, they would touch. It was there Bilbo closed his eyes and let the words he had heard the widows whisper leave him, silent in the quiet room, a plea for the powers that watched over the world to look after his silly dwarves. That he would see them soon.

         Then Bilbo forced himself to his feet and to slip away, not allowing himself to look back. If he had he would have seen his dwarves stir on the bed, both of them reaching for the spot where his hand had lain, and then resting there as if they could feel the remnants of his touch even in their sleep. Then the room was still once more.

 

 

~*~

 

 

         Yule morning broke too early for Bilbo but he forced his tired eyes open as the chiming of the sand-clock continued to ring in the outer room. He grumbled more than a little, hiding his head under his covers until he could stand to hear that chiming no longer and hauled himself out of bed. The floors were too cold, it took too long to get the kettle on, and he burnt his toast. Bilbo plopped himself down at his kitchen table, a table that held so many memories now, a table that had seen all of Bilbo's life, from a babe til now, still standing in the most unlikely of places. By the time he finished his tea his mood had improved, if only a little, mostly by the memories that had been made where he had been sitting.

         Bilbo rubbed the heel of his palm into his left eye and bit back a sigh. He had lingered too long with his – with Thorin and Dwalin and had made it back late enough that his cousins had fallen asleep on their couch, waiting for him. It had taken Bilbo a bit to get them both into bed and then slipped out himself, wanting the quiet of Bag End for this Yule morning.

         He let his hand drop and looked at the threads that were wrapped about his skin. The intricate knots did not bother him, which had been a surprise, and for reasons he was not looking into very closely. He did not mind the way the threads would tighten or ease, heat or cool, and nor did they make the hairs on the back of his neck stand on end. They felt, instead, like something he had known would be his one day. Or that they had always been there, but now he could see them.

         “I guess I really do have string in my pockets now, don't I?” Bilbo murmured to an empty Bag End. The riddle game he had played not a few months before felt like a lifetime ago.

         (An added shock to the system during his private meeting with the widows was finding out that the creature he had bested in that game had been a hobbit once. A hobbit who had been corrupted by the shadow, albeit, but a hobbit nonetheless. This poor creature, who was calling himself Gollum, had been found by one of the Bounders at some point, sniffing about Erebor and trying to find his way in. Or to Bilbo. One of the two. This Gollum was now with the widows and they would not allow anyone to see him, not until he was fixed, as Widow Minona told Bilbo. Which, apparently, might take a while.)

         Anyways.

         Bilbo drained the last of his tea and got to the business of getting ready for the day. No matter how grumpy he might be it was still Yule, and the first Yule of its kind for their people. A Yule with no lingering worries about their people coming to an end. A Yule that was more full of magic than had been seen in literal Ages. A Yule that was going to be the first that brought together all the different clans of hobbits from all over Arda into one place.

         Bilbo already knew it was going to be a long and wild day. Just from the celebrations of their people alone. And when night fell...

         Well. They would face that when it came.

         Bilbo's first stop was the Great Smials, where a massive first breakfast was spread out over the long tables that had been pulled into the great hall. Thick pancakes leaned in massive towers, dotting the length of the table. Poached eggs, scrambled eggs, and what looked like eggs cooked into the center of toast was one of the main ingredients for this first meal. Dandelion syrup, along with the flowers themselves, dotted the table as well. Yellow – or gold – foods to bring back the sun was the traditional way to start Yule mornings. The cooks had gone all out this year, with more and more plates being brought in from the kitchens as fast as the gathered Took clan could eat what was offered.

         Bilbo slid into a chair next to Fortinbras and tucked into his own perfectly poached eggs, chasing the runny yolk with a piece of toast. He ignored the look he got from his cousin as well. Bilbo was not about to talk about why he had gotten back so late in front of the entire Took clan, thank you and good morning. He would never hear the end of it.

         (As it was, Bilbo knew Fortinbras and Lalia were going to hold it over his head forever.)

         Immediately after breakfast it was time for the faunts to open their midwinter gifts. They were often little mathoms bought from traders that would visit the Shire in the months leading up to Yule, but with the way things were the children received small toys or knitted gifts from the elders in their families. Following that there would be sweet buns served and the children – in years past – would have gone out to play with their new toys or mathoms in the snow about their homes. This year the children were brought into several large, plant-filled spaces that were of questionable origin. Bilbo knew that the Gardeners had been working on something for the children for Yule and it looked like this was it. How, exactly, the Gardeners got someone to build them out such large spaces was a question for another day, since it seemed that not even Fortinbras knew of the existence of these spaces, if his surprised expression was anything to go by.

         As noon started to edge on, glowing doorways appeared in the large gathering spaces. Bilbo had felt his heart trip in his chest at the sight of them but Fortinbras and Lalia were calm, so they must have known such a thing was about to happen. Bilbo watched as those glowing doorways settled into actual doorways, that were flung open to expose other large spaces – though there was no possible way such areas were actually seated side by side with each other. Bilbo would have suspected some use of the in between but they were in the actual mountain for this, for their rites would take place later inside the in between and they were to stay out of it until sundown.

         Bilbo hung back as Fortinbras and Lalia stepped forward. They were met by the other heads of the hobbit settlements, whose names Bilbo had not had the opportunity to catch just yet. The first to take Fortinbras' hands was a hobbit whose skin was as dark as fresh earth, his hair braided back in neat rows that were dotted with beads. They reminded Bilbo of the same way his dwarves wore their beads and wondered if their peoples had met before at some point. It would be something to ask about, later, when everything was fixed for sure.

         The second hobbit leader to take Fortinbras' hands was one of the clans that hailed from the far north. Bilbo had heard about them, later, after his own meeting with the widows. They were the clans that had lingered the longest about the fortress of Angband and Utumno and who had stayed north after the destruction of Beleriand at the end of the First Age. They were the most...Bilbo did not want to use the word feral, exactly, but they were the most armed of all the hobbit clans Bilbo had yet seen. They were also, aside from the hobbits of the Shire, the largest clan of hobbits. All of them wore long knives strapped to their sides, even in the relative peace and safety of their section of the mountain. They had also, apparently, been in the slopes above them this entire time, preferring to live in the colder climes of the higher elevations on the mountain.

         They were also keen observers of the sky. Bilbo was close enough to Fortinbras to hear the leader of this clan of hobbits, the Ascomanni, say to Fortinbras, “The star is moving.”

         Well that was ominous.

         Bilbo took a glance at Fortinbras but his cousin did not seem surprised by this sentence. “We will watch for him,” Fortinbras said back to...Bilbo frowned. He hadn't caught the other hobbit's name.

         “Haakon,” Bilbo blinked when he noticed that the hobbit had turned to look at him. He was tall, all of that particular clan was, with dark hair that fell into striking blue eyes. They reminded Bilbo of Thorin's. He shook that thought off and took the hands that were held out to him.

         “Bilbo,” he said back. Haakon tilted his head to one side as those blue eyes studied him. Haakon's hands were rough but dry and warm, and the hold he had on Bilbo was firm.

         “Bilbo,” Haakon repeated, the name sounding a little strange in his accent. “It is good to meet you on this day.” Then he let go of Bilbo and turned back to Fortinbras. Bilbo blinked again at the other hobbit but let it go. All of their new cousins were a little odd in their own ways. Bilbo was sure they would all get to know each other in time.

         He slid over to Lalia as Haakon and Fortinbras continued to speak in hushed tones. As nominal head of the Baggins clan now Bilbo had his own part to play in the day's festivities. Lalia was surrounded by other hobbit matrons and was looking a bit wild about the eyes. These other matrons were all from the other clans as well and some of them were speaking with such thick accents that it was difficult for even Bilbo to understand them. He peeled off three of them and saw Lalia's shoulders drop an inch. By the time they got everything sorted out – there had been some sort of mishap with the kitchens that were off these newly made halls, though Bilbo didn't understand how they could have brand new halls and not new kitchens – Lalia was alone with Fortinbras near one of the grand fireplaces that had also appeared in these new halls, the two of them linked arm in arm as they watched the halls fill with faunts.

         “Cousin,” Fortinbras said as Bilbo came to a stop next to him.

         “Cousin,” Bilbo said back. They both pulled faces at the same time. “Holding up?”

         “About as well as I can,” Fortinbras ran a hand down his face as Lalia leaned into his side.

         Bilbo took a glance around and lowered his voice to ask, “Any news about the stolen – the stolen Silmaril?”

         Fortinbras' mouth turned down as he shook his head. “Not even a peep,” he muttered low enough that Bilbo had to lean in to hear him. “I had a few of the Hunters snoop about the wizards rooms.” He shook his head again. “They could not get in. They said even inside the in between it felt like they ran into an invisible wall every time they tried to enter them. Plus it seemed to set those two blue ones off when they tried. Had them stirring about like a kicked wasps' nest.”

         Bilbo frowned at that. “So it could still be in their possession?”

         Fortinbras lifted a shoulder and let it fall. “Perhaps. We have eyes on them at all times, as the widows have demanded.” At that he glanced down at Bilbo's hand. He curled it into a fist, wanting to hide it behind his back but didn't. What was done was done. “We shall see what happens to the two of them since they've come inside the mountain. Widow Minona was quite specific that they were unwelcome.” They both shuddered at that. They had all lived through the repercussions of the Old Ways being crossed. What such a pronouncement would do to a wizard none of them could say.

         “Even if they have stolen it, who's to say what they'll do with it?” Lalia said. There was a faint furrow to her brows as she tracked something in the room. Bilbo glanced over his shoulder but all he could see were the faunts playing by the other large fireplace. “They've taken it but have not spirited it away, unless they've done so right under our noses. So it is here. We just have to nip it back.” Her mouth flattened. “Excuse me,” she muttered as she slid her arm free of Fortinbras and stalked off to the far side of the room.

         “What's that about?” Bilbo watched as Lalia came to a stop in front of a circle of other matrons from the Shire.

         Fortinbras made an unhappy sound in the back of his throat. “Some of the other mothers don't want their children playing with foreigners.”

         Bilbo blinked, blinked again, but no, those words did not change in his ears. “What?”

         “Exactly,” Fortinbras' gaze stayed on Lalia as his wife put her hands on her hips. The matrons were now ducking their heads, shoulders rounded, looking properly scolded. Good.

         “That's ridiculous!” Bilbo turned but Fortinbras caught his arm before Bilbo could join Lalia in giving those matrons a piece of his mind.

         “Lalia has it under control. And besides, you have to watch your words these days, cousin-mind.”

         Bilbo stilled under Fortinbras' hold. “I...”

         He heard Fortinbras sigh and then he was tugged back, his cousin's arm sliding over his shoulder. Such a sign of favoritism by the Thain should have been a concern but Bilbo was trying to pick his battles these days. Fortinbras had made it very clear where he stood with Bilbo, even at the beginning of all this, and refused to budge. Bilbo just had to make his peace with it. “You could not say no, I know that,” Fortinbras pressed his lips to Bilbo's temple in a rough kiss. “I just worry for you. That's all.”

         Bilbo's eyes burned at that. “It's been an adventure,” he managed to say, voice a touch weak and wobbly.

         “Quite the adventure,” Fortinbras grumbled, leaning into Bilbo hard enough that it made him stagger a step sideways. “There but not come back again. We're all learning how to do so these days.”

         Bilbo tried to duck his head but Fortinbras just leaned harder into him. “Would you – Fortinbras! Fortinbras – would you stop? What is wrong with you – Fortinbras! No!” Then they were on the ground and wrestling before the hearth, just like a number of other faunts. In fact they collected a herd of them quick enough, the whole lot of them imitating the two of them as they rolled about on the rugs, laughing as they tried to pin the other. By the time they had finished they were both laying out on their backs, breathless with laughter and red in the face, with Lalia standing over them, hands on her hips as she tutted and got them both standing once more.

         The afternoon seemed to linger, with tea being brought in for the faunts as older hobbits came and went from the halls. Bilbo took his own tea and began to wander through these new chambers, seeing just what their people had been up to in the build up to Yule.

         As it turned out, it was far more than Bilbo had expected.

         Each cavern connected to a series of others, a strange labyrinth of pathways that all seemed to lead back to one another. It made Bilbo's head hurt trying to map them out after the first two he wandered through, so he let the matter slide.

         The cavern that Bilbo had first been in seemed to be almost like an entryway into the others. The doorways that appeared led Bilbo first into what looked like another large hall for eating, if the long rows of tables and benches was any clue. There also large fireplaces roared and on each hearth sat a Yule log. This year small rounds of a tree brought from the Shire had been given to all their peoples – though Bilbo was not sure if that also included the other clans – to be placed under their beds for good luck until twelfth night where, usually, they would all be burned in a large bonfire in the center of their various hamlets. Bilbo was not sure just where their little rounds would be burned this year but that was a problem for later. For now it was a time of celebration and good cheer.

         For now.

         Bilbo sipped on his tea and avoided the large punch bowls he saw going up in the rooms as he wandered through them. No doubt they would be heavily laced with the most potent of liquors by the time night fell. (There were special punch bowls for the faunts though it was always a Yule tradition to try and sneak a cup from the adult's portion. Bilbo had gotten his first taste of such fare in his tweens and he could still remember the headache he'd had when he'd woken up the next morning. And, looking back, the amusement in his parents for the whole day afterwards.)

         Bilbo followed a vaguely left handed path through the interlocking caverns as he wandered. The first cavern beyond the ones with the benches had stages at either end, which made Bilbo smile. The shadow plays had been a staple in the Shire, though looking at the decorations on the right hand stage, that one had come from one of the desert enclaves of hobbits. The gold and olive green draperies had symbols stitched into them in gold thread that looked familiar enough for Bilbo to puzzle out the good luck charms and a handful of other sigils that the Shire used on their own shadow play drapes. Such entertainment would not start until the sun went down, so for now Bilbo wandered on after finding a place to put his tea cup with other discarded plates and dishes.

         Beyond that room looked to be one of the dance halls. Bilbo looked to his right to see a large opening that led into what looked like another dance hall. The walls were decorated with holly braided with thick red ribbons. Here and there were potted evergreen trees, mostly likely the Gardeners' works, the seeds no doubt from the storerooms that had come with them to Erebor. Each of them were decorated with tiny ornaments of various colors, shapes, and sizes. Many looked to be blown glass, something Bilbo had only ever seen in the Great Smials. He stopped to look at several of the trees, enjoying the way whomever had decorated them tried to stick with different themes. One entire tree looked to be made up of stars, all glittering with an iridescent sheen under the large hanging lights that were full of candles.

         Beyond the dance halls looked to be the drinking rooms. In the past it was only really the Great Smials and perhaps a few of the larger family homes in Buckland that would have its own room set aside for the oath-drinks. It had mostly fallen out of favor, or perhaps purposely forgotten, by the time Bilbo had become an adult. He looked down at the threads wrapped about his hand and plucked at one that crossed his inner wrist. It stayed cool to the touch as he wandered through the oath-drinking room, so Bilbo let it go. Everyone had become leery of making oaths in their new circumstances, especially since the widows had laid bare some of their oldest history and just what their people had come from.

         Smaller doors led into the reflection rooms, where circles of mirrors and candles had been set up. Lush pillows were strewn about the floor and the air smelled sweet, like wildflowers. Bilbo spotted tall sticks stuck into vials full of liquid that contained the distilled essences. He remembered that his aunts had made such vials in his youth but had stopped after the Fell Winter. It made him smile to see them again.

         Back into the dance halls led Bilbo through another series of interconnecting rooms that led to where it looked as though the games were to be had. Booths set up for faunts occupied three of the larger halls while more spaces had been set aside for the balance games and the wrestling matches that were to start after the feast at sunset. It looked as though the Crafters had been hard at work for the faunts that year, since each of the booths had small figurines carved from wood for the lucky winners. Bilbo kept a wide berth from the wrestling mats – while he would indulge his cousin in such matters Bilbo had seen some of the strapping tweens and young adult hobbits who were eyeing the space with far too much enthusiasm for Bilbo's liking.

         By the time he got back to the main hall he had started in, it was getting close to the time when the Yule feast would start. Bilbo was soon kidnapped by Lalia, since something had happened between two of the cooks – one of which being a hobbit who had married into the Baggins clan – so they had to sort that out before fisticuffs could break out in the kitchens. By the time they had that sorted out it was time to find their seats. Each year a different clan would take over the hosting and serving of the meals and this year it was the Tooks for their portion of the halls. The reasoning, or so the widows had decreed, was that as Thain, Fortinbras' family would take over for the first year and after that the leaders of the other hobbit enclaves would take their turns.

         The table Bilbo took his seat at was full of the leaders of those different enclaves. Across from him sat Haakon and his partner, a hobbit by the name of Sev. Technically, by the Old Rules, the chair next to Bilbo should have sat empty for his spouse but instead it was filled by one of the other enclave leaders, Faris of the desert clans. Next to Faris was his wife Amina and Bilbo was amazed to see that she had a large ring pierced through her nose that was connected to her dangling earrings. Every time she moved she chimed and her eyes were outlined in dark kohl. Farin, too, had pierced ears, and many golden bracelets about each wrist.

         Further down the table sat one of the leaders from a point south that Bilbo had ever heard of, a place where even the stars were strange, according to Amani, who was the head of that enclave. Amani spoke of how her people lived in a place of towering trees and made their homes up in the boughs, far away from the forest floor where the predators ruled. Her husband, Baraka, was their best Hunter and had gone out with a party of their people to take down as much game as they could in the desolate lands about Erebor. It was impressive that they had found as much as they did, considering the logistics of not being seen by the dwarves that were guarding the different entrances to the mountain and the sheer fact that the encampment of men and elves before Erebor's gates had been doing their own hunting to supplement their meals.

         Beyond Amani and Baraka sat Len and Ren, whose enclave of hobbits had the strange habit of changing their names when they paired off to something that rhymed. Their people had lived on a vast grass plains to the east that saw great storms that could decimate huge swaths of land as they passed. As such they, like the Shire hobbits ancestors, had been nomadic until their arrival in Erebor. Their people also held the customs of Dreamers, something that Bilbo had not known of until he had been introduced to a veiled widow who had been part of their enclave long ago. The Dreamers, Bilbo had heard, had known something was coming, that some great change was to happen to their people. Len and Ren's people were also the only enclave of hobbits who had not lost as much of their Old Gifts as the others.

         Sitting opposite of Len and Ren were Jal and Vellam, who led the hobbits that had lived at the edge of the sea somewhere to the south and east, beyond even the forests where Amani and Baraka's people lived. They were the only hobbits who were avid boaters, worse than the insane Brandybucks who used to take trips out onto lakes or the Brandywine. They made their homes in the tall cliffs that overlooked a wild sea that they made their livings from. Bilbo had seen several of their enclave in the dance halls, setting up different decorations, all of them wearing the long, multilayered skirts their people favored. They had also brought many spices that Bilbo had never even heard of before but was keen to try.

         The last leaders sitting at the table were Mikel and his wife Anna, who rarely spoke to anyone, as Bilbo was told, but had brought such hot peppers with them that no few Gardeners were threatening to start fights with their particular Gardeners just to get their hands on the seeds. It had been a bit of mess with those folks who were already elbow deep in attempting to coax plants to life in the limited space they all had. It had already been a challenge to grow such peppers in the Shire, so Bilbo had no idea how they were to manage it in Erebor's different climes, but he had stepped out of that particular fight once one of the Gardeners had hissed at him. Hissed. Like a snake. Bilbo had no idea what was going on there and was content to let the Gamgees sort it out in the end.

         (Bilbo may have also been on a bit of a campaign to get the Gamgees noticed as a Trade Head. They were the best Gardeners and Farmers the Shire ever had, few disputed that, so his plan was going forward with little objection. But should the Gamgees themselves find out...well. That would be a different fight, one that Bilbo hoped he had won before Hamfast even knew there was something to fight about.)

         Anyways.

         They had all finished dinner as the lights above them flickered, once, twice, then a third time. The silence that fell over the tables felt charged, prickling along Bilbo's skin and making the hairs on his arms and the back of his neck stand on end. It was Fortinbras who stood first. All eyes swung to him. Bilbo watched his cousin fade away and the Thain appear. Fortinbras lifted his chin as he met the gaze of each hobbit at their table, even Bilbo, though he did not know what his cousin – what the Thain – was looking for. Then, once Fortinbras had met and held Lalia's gaze for a long moment, the Thain looked up once more and gave them all a single, solemn nod.

         “Tonight is the Longest Night,” his voice almost seemed to echo in the hall. “It will be the most important night our people have ever faced. Since our creation our people have worked to fix that which has been broken in this world, even when we lost that knowledge and believed ourselves to be something ordinary and small. Tonight we will remember where our people came from. We will revel in our origins. We will dance. We will sing. We will wrestle and drink and tell tales of Ages long ago. We will speak of our dreams, we will shout and dance with all of the green growing things. Tonight,” his voice rolled over them all, “we bring back the light!”

         A cheer went up, with Bilbo's voice with them. Tears pricked in his eyes but he pushed them back. Now was not the time for tears. Now was the time for joy and hope and all the bright things that burned against the grasping Dark. Fortinbras led the way into the halls beyond their tables, with all of their people trailing in behind him. Bilbo could hear the musicians start to pick up their instruments and tune them. He heard glad calls and laughter coming from almost every corner. It made something breathless lodge in his chest, something almost too big to name. It felt, perhaps, like hope, like seeing the end of a too-long tunnel when one had thought that they had forgotten what sunlight even looked like.

         It felt, in that moment, like home.

         When the dancing started, it was – at first – much like the celebrations that Bilbo had seen throughout his years in the Shire. The round dances were perhaps a touch too quick, the circles of their people spinning in time to the music, everyone with their heads thrown back in high cheer. Then, as the night began to grow long, as the music got wilder and wilder, other dances began to dominate the floor. Wild leaping, spinning, long chains of hobbits hand-in-hand as they snaked their way through the growing chaos of the halls. It felt, for a moment, as if Bilbo had been drinking the heavily spiked punch, his head reeling from the cacophony of the music, of the cries and cheers, of the wild tales being played out on the shadow puppet stages, all of it coming together in a song that made his ears ache. He, too, had joined in on the wild dancing, passing hand to hand with hobbits he did not know and some that he did, all of them with bright eyes and barred teeth that could have either been smiles or snarls.

         It was the wildest Bilbo had ever seen his people. It was the wildest even he had ever felt, Adventure and all. And with each beat of the music, with each step in the dance, with each chorus of the songs cried out in the hall, it felt like something was building. More and more pressure seemed to bear down on them and they as an entire people met it with all the fire and light in their hearts.

         And then, as the stars aligned and the world held its breath, the Dark arrived.

         Screams and cries went up as all of the lights went out as one. Bilbo stood alone on the dance floor, staring up into that darkness, feeling his heart beat hard in his throat.

         It was time.

         Then, above the din, he could hear Fortinbras roaring. “Come, hobbits of the world! Morgoth has made his move and it is time for us to answer it! It is time for us to fix this, once and for all!”

         One by one lights began to flicker into life about the halls. Each of them was held by a veiled widow...but now those veils were pushed back, exposing their faces and their glowing eyes. Bilbo fought his way through the thick crowd to his cousin's side, finding Fortinbras standing with Lalia and a handful of Bounders.

         “Bilbo, good, there you are,” Fortinbras said before Bilbo could say a word. “This Darkness has swept over the mountain as a whole. The watchers inside the in between say that it has reached even there.”

         Bilbo closed his eyes for a moment, breathing a prayer that his dwarves would survive the night, and then opened them again. “Do we know where Morgoth will appear?”

         A muscle jumped in Fortinbras' jaw. “No,” he shook his head. “But there's more.”

         Bilbo drew in a breath. Of course there was. “What is it?”

         Fortinbras looked at one of the Bounders and then back at Bilbo. “Spiders,” he said, grim. “Great spiders are appearing in both the mountain and inside the in between. We do not know how or why.”

         “I do,” another voice said. Bilbo turned to see Widow Minona at his elbow. He had not heard her arrive. “Those creatures are the spawn of something far more ancient than most know. They will not stop until all of the light has been eaten, inside and out. They found their way in through the corruption of the blue ones, but that too, was allowed.”

         “Allowed?” Fortinbras scowled at her. “How –,” he cut off when the widow held up a hand.

         “There are reasons for what we do in the dark, oh Thain,” she then looked to Bilbo. He tried not to flinch when Fortinbras turned that same look onto him. “It is time,” she told him.

         Bilbo bowed his head to her. “It is,” he said.

         A faint smile slid across her face. “Go then,” she said and it was the kindest he had ever seen her expression. “And know no fear. We will see you again, Bilbo of the Baggins clan. This I know in my heart.”

         Bilbo couldn't help but bow to her, to his cousin, to all of his people. “I will see you again,” he said as he rose. Then he turned and slipped through the crowd as Fortinbras cried out his name. Bilbo could not stop then, could not turn to comfort his kin. For instead of towards the light, Bilbo pushed towards the halls that had gone black, towards the darkness that was creeping towards them step by skittering step. He found the black door that Widow Minona had shown him, passing through it and into the in between from one step to the next.

         There, in the darkness, there was no up nor down. There was nothing, not even a single breath of light in all the world. Bilbo could hear nothing, see nothing, feel nothing. He felt, in that moment, like a piece of string pulled too taut, like butter scraped over too much bread, thin and wan and so small that it felt impossible that their people could do anything more than be wiped out by one careless swing by the Power that had come to destroy them all.

         Then Bilbo remembered Thorin and Dwalin and the way his two silly dwarves would hold each other before the box they believed held all that was left of Bilbo in this world. He remembered the way they had reached out to him, how they loved him. Bilbo straightened shoulders he had not realized had curled in, pulled himself up to stand straight and fearless before that vast Dark.

         Bilbo did not know what he was waiting for. He did not know what he was supposed to do. Widow Minona had only said that he would know the way forward when he saw it. That he alone, for reasons she would not say but they both now knew, could accomplish this great unknown thing in the very Dark that had broken into the world. And in that moment, of staring in the Dark with his head held high and all of his love singing through his veins, he felt something like a spark ignite in his chest. Brighter and brighter it burned, so hot that he thought he should burn himself when he put a hand to his chest. But instead of heat all he felt was the thundering of his heart.

         And then, in that Darkness that surrounded Bilbo, a Light appeared.

 

Notes:

There is a poll up at my tumblr about which fic I should work on next. I ends next Tuesday, May 26, 2026!

Chapter 32: the shadow returns

Notes:

here. we. go! Also, one day left on the vote on which fic I finish next is up on my tumblr!

Chapter Text

 

          The pounding on their door brought Thorin out of a strange dream. In it he was dancing, hand in hand with Bilbo and Dwalin, in a hall that looked as if it was a part of Erebor...yet strange. Different. And Bilbo was strange in that dream too, wilder, with teeth barred and an uncanny light to his eyes. Thorin woke to that pounding that sounded almost like the drums in his dreams, feeling sweat slicking his brow.

          “Thorin!”

          That was Nori's voice. Thorin threw back the bedcovers, Dwalin at his side and sword in hand, as they went to the door. It was indeed Nori when they opened the locked and barred door. “Nori?” Thorin stepped out into the hallway, looking back and forth. The hall was as black as Thorin had ever seen it, with a deep shadow reaching down from the ceiling. The crystal lights that had been lighting the mountain had all gone out.

          “Thorin,” Nori said, drawing his attention back to the once-thief. “It's begun.”

          Thorin stared at the other dwarf, the words echoing through his mind. “What?”

          Nori shook his head, a single fierce shake. “The fires of holy forges have gone out,” he said. “A shadow has fallen over the entire mountain and the stars have gone out. It's begun.”

          Thorin's breath caught. He felt Dwalin take his elbow, holding on tight. They had just been down in those holy forges not hours before, for their own Yule rites. And now... “Get everyone up,” he said after finding his breath. “Find Gandalf and Eönwë and the rest of the elves and men. I want everyone in the main council room off the entry hall.”

          “On it,” Nori sprinted off without another word.

          “Thorin,” Dwalin said as they ran back into the room and reached for their clothes.

          Thorin stopped and turned to his partner, taking Dwalin's face in his hands so that he could kiss him. He felt Dwalin's hands curl about his as they stayed there in that moment, forehead to forehead, breathing in each other's air. “I love you,” Thorin whispered. “I always will. You have always been a part of me, you and Bilbo both, and when this is done,” his voice cracked on the word, “we will see him again.”

          Dwalin kissed him again then, a hard press, there and gone. “I love you. We will.”

          There was nothing more to say. Thorin threw on his clothes and armor, belting on his sword and axe. He looked to the altar, heart stuttering in his chest. “Someone needs to stay here to guard the Silmarils.”

          Dwalin stepped in front of him. “Do not ask me to leave you now. I will be at your side until...” He shook his head. “Until whatever comes.”

          Thorin curled a hand over Dwalin's shoulder, anchoring them together. “Then who –”

          There was a knock at the door. Before Thorin could call out to see who it was, the door opened and slight figure stepped inside. Thorin frowned at the sight before him, for there, standing in armor that Thorin did not recognize, was Master Erestor.

          “My lords,” Master Erestor said as he bowed to them. His hair was braided back and on the leather armor over his chest was an eight pointed star. “It has occurred to me, in the suddenness of this attack, that there are none to guard the Silmaril. I will.”

          Thorin exchanged a look with Dwalin. “Forgive me, Master Erestor, but I thought you were...not one so proficient at might of arms.”

          A faint, pained smile crossed Master Erestor's face. “I am indeed proficient,” he said. “My father made sure of it.”

          “Your father?”

          “Yes,” Master Erestor's smile returned, sadder now. “His name was Caranthir, son of Fëanor. He made quite sure that I could defend myself and I will use all that he taught me to protect the Silmaril that was given to you from all that would dare take it.”

          Thorin had read that only one son of Fëanor had a child of his own, who became Celebrimbor, a name well known in his people's histories. “I...”

          To his shock Master Erestor then knelt, pressing a fist to that eight-pointed star. “I, Erestor, son of Caranthir, swear to you, King Thorin Oakenshield, that I will protect the Silmaril with my dying breath. I will allow no Darkness to take it while I yet still live. This I swear upon my fëa and to the Valar themselves. I...” A strange smile curled up the corners of his mouth. “I would even make you an Oath of it.”

          Thorin stared down at the elf, his mind whirling. He had no reason to say yes and yet...

          A warm wind swirled through the room, making both Thorin and Dwalin turn back to back. Master Erestor rose from the floor, his hand on the pommel of his sword, though he did not draw it. Thorin could not see where this warm wind came from, but on that wind...on that wind was a scent that was...strange. Familiar. Very familiar. It was...it was...

          “Bilbo,” Dwalin whispered.

          Thorin closed his eyes for a moment. Yes, the scent was of the Shire on a spring day, much like they had experienced when their Company first left Bilbo's home. The sun had been shining and the grasses lush. Gardens were being planted out, the trees so green they rivaled the emeralds Thorin's people drew from the earth. There had been such a deep sense of peace in that place. Thorin had understood why Bilbo would not want to leave such a home. And yet...and yet Bilbo had come running after them, his contract signed, barely prepared for the adventure they were to have.

          Thorin opened his eyes and looked to Master Erestor once more. “I believe you will protect the Silmaril,” he said. He drew in a breath, trying to imprint that fading scent into his mind, as if he could hold what little they had of Bilbo inside himself for as long as possible. “I will have Nori's lads watch the halls and help you as much as they can. The wizards have laid their own protections, so that should also give you an extra layer of defense against all who would try to force their way in.”

          Master Erestor bowed low to them both. His braid swung over his shoulder, the tip of it fastened with yet another eight-pointed star charm that dangled from a leather tie. “I will not fail you,” he said as he rose.

          A great shudder rocked the mountain before Thorin could respond. Dust rained down from the ceiling and Thorin could hear someone in the hall cry out.

          “We need to go,” Dwalin said as he started forward.

          “Yes,” Thorin agreed. Master Erestor passed them as they made for the door, setting himself before the altar, his sword drawn and held in one hand. Thorin glanced back as the door closed behind them to see Master Erestor standing with his eyes closed, mouth moving in silent words Thorin could not make out. Then the door swung shut behind them and it was time for them to run.

          The hall of the Royal wing was starting to fill with bodies running towards the entrance of Erebor. They had moved more dwarves into the old royal section to give the rest of the gathered peoples more room in the mountain. Guards and even the artisans who had arrived in caravans from across Arda were swarming out of their rooms, all of them armed and ready to face whatever darkness had come. Thankfully Thorin had asked for very little spirits to be consumed during their own Yule celebrations just hours before, so there seemed to be none of his people stumbling with too much drink as they all ran down the stairs to Erebor's main hall.

          It was there that Thorin saw the great fire pillars being set alight. It was Balin who had a torch in hand as he lit the ancient device, something the first king of Erebor had fashioned after an earth shaker had caused damage to the mountain and many of the crystals that had lit the way had cracked or broken altogether during the event. The massive pillar was made up of old ore that was slow-burning, stacked in such a way that they would continue to stay lit and provide illumination for days if need be. It was only after Balin lit the pillar that Thorin could start to see the gathered crowd of men, elves, and dwarves.

          “Thorin!”

          Thorin blinked at the sound of Dáin's voice. He turned to see his cousin limping through the crowd, fastening his armor as he made his way to Thorin's side. “What are you doing?” He caught Dáin as he stumbled, keeping him upright.

          “I'm not about to lay in bed while a fight's on,” Dáin struggled against his hold. “Let go.”

          “I will not,” Thorin retorted, trying to hold his cousin still. “You shouldn't be out of bed!”

          “I am not going to lay there like a ninny while whatever this is attacks us all,” Dáin struggled out of Thorin's grip. “I can fight!”

          “You can barely stand!”

          “Thorin!”

          Thorin turned at the sound of Gandalf's voice. He saw the wizard push his way through the growing crowd to his side. Gandalf's hat was gone and he held his staff in one hand and had the sword they had found in the troll horde belted on. “Gandalf,” Thorin said when the wizard reached him. “What is happening? What do you know?”

          “There is a shadow –,” was all Gandalf got out before a great darkness swept over them all. Cries rose from the gathered men and dwarves, though Thorin did not hear a single elven voice in the cacophony. Thorin curled a hand about his sword and looked up, trying to see what could have caused such a shadow in the middle of the night and inside of a mountain at that.

          Odd, echoing, skittering sounds made the hairs on the back of his neck stand on end. He felt Dwalin curl a hand about his elbow, holding on as they both looked up. The fire pillar was struggling to light, the flames just licking about the base of the pillar, casting just enough illumination for Thorin to make out the hastily clad men and dwarves about them. They could see no great spiders inside the mountain, though. Then, out of that strange shadow, a Light appeared. Thorin winced at it, squinting as that light came close, revealing Eönwë in armor Thorin had not seen before.

          “King Thorin,” the herald of Manwë said. He was pale and his expression was as grave as Thorin had ever seen it. “The last of the spells keeping Valinor from Arda have failed. It has begun.”

          The echo of what Nori said made Thorin close his eyes for a moment. Then he opened them and asked, “Are there any injuries? Óin!” He turned, looking for his old friend.

          “I am right here,” Óin stomped out of the darkness and leveled a long look at Dáin, who just raised his chin and glared back at the healer. “I'll get the halls set up. I hold that area, have no fear. Nothing will get by my.”

          “I know it,” Thorin said, clasping Óin on the shoulder. Then he turned and drew in a deep breath. “Balin! Bofur! Get the other pillars lit!”

          “Aye!”

          Thorin looked to Gandalf and then to Eönwë. “Where are –,” he did not have time to finish before Aragorn appeared next to Eönwë, and right behind him were Lord Ecthelion II and Prince Thengel. It wasn't more than a breath after they arrived that both Thranduil and Bard appeared, both looking rather rumpled and still buckling on parts of their armor. “Good,” Thorin said, sweeping a look across them. “What does it look like outside of the mountain?” He turned to look for Balin or Nori.

          “All is black,” Aragorn said, bringing Thorin's attention back to the young Ranger. All eyes turned to the young man. Lord Elrond stepped up next to him, Lady Galadriel and Lord Maedhros right after him. All of their expressions were grim. Behind them were the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion. “There are no more stars,” Aragorn continued. Nori had said as much, Thorin remembered. The young man's hands were curled into fists. “I had a small party scouting the area. They said the shadow swept over all of the land, blotting out the sky from west to east. They also said there was a strange sound arising from the west.”

          “The west?” Thorin echoed. Then he looked to Thranduil, whose mouth was turned down in the most severe scowl Thorin had ever seen the king wear. “What kind of strange sound?”

          “They said it sounded like many legs skittering over the ground,” Aragorn said. Thorin closed his eyes against that.

          “Like spiders,” he said as he opened them. He met Thranduil's grim gaze.

          “Yes,” Aragorn said. “Like spiders.”

          “If the dark vermin that has been spreading through the Greenwood is coming here then we will need to prepare,” Thranduil said as he stepped forward. He looked every inch the icy king that Thorin remembered from their stay in Thranduil's cellars. “They are vicious even when they are sated and fat with the remains of their kills inside the forest. For them to be driven here they must either have wiped out all that was left in my kingdom or,” a muscle moved in his jaw, “they were called here.”

          “I think we can assume that they were called here,” Gandalf said.

          Just then the great pillars finally caught and light bloomed over them. Thorin winced at the sudden illumination, glancing about the crowd. His people were moving through the entrance hall, many buckling on armor and weapons. Further on he could see the small party of men that Lord Ecthelion II and Prince Thengel had brought, all of them also in various stages of getting dressed for battle. The elves all looked prepared, all of them carrying their weapons at their sides.

          (Thorin ignored the way Kíli had gone to stand next to Tauriel. That was a problem he would deal with later, when they all survived whatever fight had come to their front door.)

          “Is this what we have been fearing?” Lord Ecthelion II was the one to ask. “Are they the monsters that Morgoth is using to try and defeat us?”

          “I do not think so,” Eönwë said. All eyes turned to him. His gaze was not for the gathered crowd but turned upward, to the great pillars that were full of flame and fire.

          “Then what else could they be?”

          “The first assault,” Eönwë said as his gaze lowered. His eyes were glowing even in the growing light. “The spawn of Ungoliant have served the minions of Morgoth since they were vomited forth upon Arda. I do not doubt that they come to serve him again.”

          A stir went through the crowd at that. “Then let us prepare,” Thorin said over the murmurs that had broken out. “Thranduil?” He saw the Greenwood king blink as Thorin addressed him. “You know these creatures best. Would you take command of those who would face these spiders outside our gates?”

          Thranduil's chin went up and a smirk tugged at one side of his mouth. “Easily,” he said. Then he looked to Bard. “Shall we make a competition of it?”

          Bard rolled his eyes at the elf and shook his head. “We will hold the line,” he said instead to Thorin.

          “Good,” Thorin ignored the way Thranduil had turned Bard to him to focus on the others. “We –,” was as far as he got before another, stronger shake rattled the mountain. Shouts rose up from around him. Ominous cracking sounds came from the great fire pillars as sparks rained down on them. Then came a bone-rattling roar from the great gates. Thorin did not stop to call out to the others as be broke out in a run, heading for the thick darkness that seemed to almost be crawling over the entrance to Erebor.

          A hand caught the back of his armor before Thorin could try and pierce that black veil. He growled as he turned, only to see Gandalf standing there, expression set and grim as he stared at the darkness beyond them. “Gandalf, what –”

          “Do not go charging into that darkness so heedlessly, Thorin Oakenshield,” Gandalf shook his head, gaze never leaving the space between the gates. “There are things far beyond you or I moving in the world this night.”

          Thorin looked from the wizard to that strange blackness, a prickle of unease skittering down his spine. “Then how else are we to fight that which would attack us?”

          “By letting those of us with the power risk a little light.” Gandalf raised his staff then, the tip glowing like it had in the throne room, but brighter now, almost fiercer. The glare of it stung Thorin's eyes and he had to look away, towards the gates, and felt his stomach freeze at the sight of what that light revealed.

          For there, at the gates, was a great mass of writhing bodies, all of them trying to force their way in through the cracked open doors at once. They were the same spiders Thorin had seen in Mirkwood, the vile creatures that stank of rot and poison, their mouths clicking as they hissed and barred their fangs. One of them gave a violent shudder and ripped off one of its own legs as it pried itself forward, falling free of the pile. That seemed to break the dam, since once that first spider began to race forward the rest of those spiders that had been jammed into that narrow space began to flood into Erebor's entry hall, one after the other.

          Thorin did not have a moment to shout a warning as those vile creatures were upon them. Thorin pulled his sword as the first of those massive spiders hit them, feeling Dwalin press against him as they stood back to back against the horde. A cry came from behind them, the voices of men and elves and dwarves all shouting at once as everyone scrambled to pull their weapons and protect themselves.

          There was no time to think. No time to panic. There was only the hack and slash of survival, of sweat and burning muscles as the rush of these massive spiders went on and on. Thorin kept Dwalin either at his back or in his sights at all times, not wanting to be separated from him in the mad rush of the melee. Gandalf was somewhere to his left, the light of his staff leading the way as he batted down the oncoming spiders. Only later did Thorin see Gandalf with his sword pulled, using both staff and weapon to defend himself against the vicious creatures.

          A cry came from behind them and then the elves were there, followed soon by the men, with Thranduil leading the way. Bard was at the Greenwood king's side the entire time, the two of them fighting together as one seamless unit. Thorin caught glimpses of Kíli with Tauriel, along with the rest of his Company, and then Aragorn and the rest of the men were there, fighting side by side with them all as wave after wave of giant spiders kept coming at them.

          A ferocious roar was all the warning Thorin got before Dáin came crashing down from some height, right into the center of a thick knot of the spiders, his axes spinning as he cut them down one after the other.

          “That idiot,” Thorin growled but he could not move forward to get to his cousin's side. Not when he and Dwalin were trapped behind a line of those creatures, doing everything they could not to fall to their multiple legs or their wicked fangs. What was even stranger – than giant spiders attacking their mountain that is – was that all of the foul creatures seemed almost crazed, heedless of the wounds they took. All of them fought down to their dying breath, snapping and clawing at whatever they could get a hold of. So far none had fallen to their sharp claws and poisonous fangs but Thorin could already see how one section of the men was being pushed back, close to overrun by the oncoming horde.

          Thorin didn't have breath to curse when he saw that line of men give way, two of them falling beneath the monstrous spiders with cries that rang out over the din. Then, from behind that point, came a Light. It was only then that Thorin realized how dark everything was, as if a shadow had come and settled over them all.

          It was Eönwë, striding out from behind the fallen men, a shining sword in one hand and in the other a strange, glowing ball of blue light. It was Eönwë alone who pushed back the spiders that were crawling over the men, with Thranduil's elves rushing in to pull the fallen out of harm's way. Eönwë held that glowing ball of light high, the piercing rays causing the spiders to rear up on their back legs, exposing their hideous, hairy white bellies. Arrows streaked out from the mountain, taking out row after row of those spiders as Eönwë and his Light pushed them back step by step from the entry hall of the mountain.

          A ragged cheer went up then. Even Dáin, no longer trapped as he was in front of Thorin and Dwalin, raised his axe at the sight of that Light, a roar leaving him that sounded far more like Thorin's cousin than he had in the months since the Battle of Five Armies. Then his roar was cut short as a different sound answered their cheer. It started as a rumble, thick enough to make the very ground under them start to shake. It was then that Thorin could see that there was as shadow moving across the front lawn of Erebor, where the tents of men and elves had been pitched. Most of that shadow was made up of those vile spiders that had come pouring out of Mirkwood but also...there were other bodies moving in that darkness. Smaller bodies, lithe and pale, with worm-pale skin that Thorin would know anywhere.

          The last of the goblins and orcs had arrived. Pouring out of the Misty Mountains and what remained of Mordor, they must have been on their way to Erebor for weeks. Yips and howls began to fill the air behind that rumbling, even as torch after torch began to be lit, spreading out over the slopes of Erebor like a wave. Thorin felt his breath catch at the sight. He had thought the armies of Azog and Bolg had been vast. This, though...this far outnumbered those armies.

          “Thorin!” He heard Aragorn call his name. He turned to see the young Ranger fighting towards his side, a streak of blood marring one cheek. “Can you close the gates?”

          Thorin cast a glance behind him and shook his head. They had all moved with Eönwë as the spiders were pushed back, until they were outside the front gates. “They were damaged by Smaug when the dragon first came,” he said. “I do not think they can even...” His words died in his throat as those same doors he was speaking about, the doors that had once been the pride of his people, the great doors of Erebor, began to glow. The edges of them seemed lit by a silver light and all of the cracks and damage that had once marred the surface melted away, like snow in a warm patch of sunlight. It was impossible. And yet...

          A cry had Thorin turning yet again. He saw Dáin surrounded on all sides, one arm hanging limp, his axe still raised as the spiders and orcs closed in about him. Thorin lurched forward, his heart in his throat, already knowing that he would be too late to save his cousin. His cousin who was still fighting, his cousin who had stood behind Thorin during their Yule rites, who had bowed low before the holy forges and asked forgiveness from their Maker. His cousin who had hugged a shocked Fíli and apologized to him in front of all of the Iron Hills nobles. A cousin who was going to die before Thorin's eyes because he could not get to him in time.

          Then, impossibly, the very ground about Dáin exploded. Great vines shot forth from the earth, forming a protective circle about Dáin who staggered to a stop, staring at the vines that were pushing back the spiders that tried to reach him. There was also, possibly, one vine that smacked the back of Dáin's head as it settled into place. Then more and more vines began to emerge from the earth, thick ropes full of thorns that began to fight back against the spiders and orcs and goblins that were streaming across Erebor's front lawn and right to where they were trying to hold the line against them.

          Thorin set his shoulders and pushed forward, Dwalin at his side, as they tried to get to Dáin. To his shock the vines parted before them, allowing Thorin to grab Dáin and haul him back, passing him along to Balin and the rest of his Company who had come to stand with Thorin and Dwalin in this fight once more. Thorin thought that with the help of the vines – and the miraculously repaired gate – they would be able to fight off this first rush of Morgoth's minions and then get behind Erebor's defenses and see what options were available to them.

          It seemed like a good plan, right until Thorin saw a glow appear far down the slopes of the mountain. It was too large to be a single torch, too narrow to be a line of them. Thorin squinted at the glow, unable to get a clear view of it with the spiders and orcs and goblins that were still throwing themselves at Erebor's gates, but that glow...it was large. Too large. It could not be...

          Thorin looked up when Lord Glorfindel came to a stop next to him. The elf was pale, his golden hair pulled back in a tight braid. His sword was dark with the thick black blood that oozed from the spiders when they were cut down. “Impossible,” Lord Glorfindel breathed as he stared at the base of the slopes.

          Thorin looked from the elf to the glow and back again. “What is it? What do you see?”

          Glorfindel's jaw worked as he gave his head one sharp shake. “Balrogs,” he said. Many who were near them turned in shock to stare.

          “That is impossible!” Prince Thengel cried.

          “Were we not just speaking of such spirits when it came to the depths of Moria?” Lord Glorfindel shook his head again. “No. I know such evil when I see it, for they were the cause of my death in our flight from Gondolin. And now they have come again.”

          “Balrogs,” Thorin repeated. “More than one?”

          Lord Glorfindel met his gaze and gave him a solemn nod. “Many,” he said as he turned that sharp look back to the slopes. “Not as numerous as those who destroyed Gondolin but enough.”

          Thorin swallowed hard, his hand tightening on his sword. There was no way he or his people could kill a balrog. Only a few of the elves among them had ever been able to. “Gandalf!” He turned, calling for the wizard. Surely they could do something? Eönwë and the wizards were spirits much like the balrogs themselves. That was when Thorin realized that while he had seen both Gandalf and Eönwë fighting with them, he had not seen any of the others. “Gandalf!”

          “I see them,” the wizard appeared through the throng. The thick vines were doing more than their people had been able to do, keeping the spiders and orcs and goblins back with their thick thorns and swift strikes. “We need to get everyone back behind the gates.”

          “Yes,” Thorin agreed. But – “Where is Saruman?” He saw Gandalf start at that, turning to look at Thorin. “Where are the blue wizards? Have you seen them?”

          “I –,” Gandalf got out before a shout from behind had them both turning.

          Radagast pushed his way through Thorin's Company, his face a mask of blood from a long cut over his eye. He was holding his side, hand painted red, as blood soaked his robes all the way to the hem. “Gandalf,” Radagast said as he fell to his knees. Gandalf was at his side in a flash, arms going about the other wizard. “Gandalf, there is something wrong.”

          “What happened, my friend? Who did this to you?”

          “Pallando,” Radagast gasped out as he sagged in Gandalf's arms. “They have Saruman, Gandalf. There is something wrong with them. They struck me down when I tried to stop them. I fear,” he coughed and blood stained his lips. “I fear they have been corrupted by the shadow.” Radagast fell limp then and Gandalf cried out for Elrond and Galadriel to come.

          “Pallando,” Gandalf said once Elrond had taken Radagast from Gandalf's arms.

          “The blue wizards,” Thorin said, glancing up at the wizard and then out at the mass of massive spiders and orcs and goblins still trying to force their way past the vines that were still defending them. And beyond those hordes was that growing glow. “Gandalf...”

          “We must find them,” Gandalf held up a hand and shook his head. “We must trust that the others will hold the line here. We cannot allow Pallando and Alatar to harm Saruman. We do not know what their plan is.”

          “Yes,” Thorin agreed.

          “We will hold the line,” Lord Glorfindel said as he stepped up next to them. Lord Maedhros was still fighting near the vines, his sword reflecting the glow of the fire pillars that were still burning inside of Erebor, the only light that was illuminating the area now. Lord Ecthelion nodded along with Lord Glorfindel's words. “We have fought this darkness once before,” the elf said with a sad smile. “We shall do so again.”

          Then Eönwë came to them, his glowing eyes growing brighter as the fight wore on. His gaze was a distant thing, focused on something only he could see. “Go, Olórin,” he said. Thorin saw Gandalf's head go back at that name. “I will not let these corrupted spirits enter Erebor. You must stop them. I fear...” He shook his head, blinking and some bit of awareness reentered his gaze. “I fear that they will try to do something far worse than harm Saruman inside the mountain.”

          “Eönwë? What do you mean?”

          The herald of Manwë just shook his head. “I do not know what fear lays upon my heart but this I know; whatever dark plan Pallando and Alatar have concocted must not be brought to fruition. It could mean the end of all things should they succeed.”

          “We will go,” Thorin said. All eyes turned to him.

          “Thorin,” Dwalin said.

          “Only our people know the mountain best.” Thorin shook his head as he faced Dwalin. “We must guide them or they could fall into the mountain's depths. You know this. So we will go,” he turned back to Eönwë. He looked out over Erebor's front lawn. “I do not know how long this gift can defend us.” Even now he could see where the thick vines were being hacked away by the orcs and goblins. “But if we are quick we may have enough time. Hold the line,” this he directed at Aragorn and the man. Thranduil and Bard were still fighting alongside Maedhros. Arrows from the archers rained down on any enemy who dared come close. “We will find them and stop whatever evil plan they have.”

          “We will not fail you,” Aragorn said. Thorin gave the young Ranger a sharp nod and turned with Gandalf and Dwalin, heading into the heart of the mountain.

          None of them saw the shadows that flitted over their heads, along stairs and balconies that had long been repaired by invisible hands, hurrying along with Thorin and the others into the depths of Erebor, into the darkness that not even the great fire pillars could pierce.

 

Chapter 33: lies and truth

Chapter Text

 

         Thorin led the way deeper into the mountain, the flickering light of the fire pillars turning the familiar paths strange. Dwalin was on his left while Gandalf was a step behind them, keeping pace with ease. The central chamber was shrouded in shadow, thicker than Thorin had ever seen it before. The light from the entrance pillars barely reached the area and with the stars and moon gone it felt more like being in one of the deep mines than in the main cavern of Erebor.

         Thorin came to a skidding halt in front of the deep chasm, holding out a hand to keep Gandalf from running right off the edge. He looked right and saw nothing but darkness. He looked left –

         All Thorin's breath left his lungs. For there, standing on the very same lip that he had shown Saruman, were the three wizards, outlined in a blue fire that made the hairs on Thorin's neck stand on end. Saruman himself was on his knees, head bowed low, looking strangely small between the two blue-robed wizards on either side of him. Both Pallando and Alatar had their arms raised above them, faces tilted up, eyes glowing bright red as they chanted words that made Thorin's ears ache.

         “No,” he heard Gandalf gasp from next to them. “No!” He lunged forward but Thorin caught the wizard before he could slip from the edge of the chasm, hauling him back by the belt with Dwalin's help. “Saruman! Saruman, fight back!”

         “It is too late for you, Gandalf!” Pallando cried as he looked at them. Thorin shuddered at the blood that was running from the wizard's eyes. “We know what you have been doing! We know what you have tried to do! We will not allow it!”

         “What – what are you saying? I have done nothing! It is you who are in the wrong!” Gandalf raised his staff but Alatar said something that made the very air between them go strange. There was a cracking sound and a bolt of blinding lightning hit Gandalf in the chest, throwing the wizard back far enough that he hit one of the support pillars and slumped to the ground, unconscious.

         “Corrupted fool,” Pallando sneered as his hands rose in the air again. “Begone from our holy work!”

         “Gandalf!” Thorin ran to the wizard's side, Dwalin helping him sit the wizard up. Gandalf woke with a groan, blood streaking from his nose as he blinked at them. “Gandalf, can you hear me?”

         “That I can, Thorin Oakenshield,” Gandalf said after a moment's pause. An unsteady hand gripped Thorin's shoulder, looking far too frail in the dim light. “Help me up, now.” Gandalf's gaze went beyond them, to where the chanting from the blue wizards was rising in pitch and tempo. “We must put a swift end to this.”

         “What are they trying to do?” Thorin braced the wizard on one side while Dwalin was on the other. With their help Gandalf got to his feet, swaying between them, but he pulled his staff to him in a rare show of power.

         “They are trying to summon something,” Gandalf said, voice grim. “Or someone,” his tone dropped and Thorin clenched his jaw.

         “They are trying to summon Morgoth? Here?” Thorin braced the wizard as they stumbled forward.

         “Yes,” Gandalf said and pulled away from them as they came around the side of a wide stone pillar. The point where Thorin had shown Saruman the breadth of Erebor's central chamber was directly in front of them. Saruman himself was still kneeling between those two wizards, head bowed and hands hidden in front of them. Thorin was not even sure if the wizard was awake. Or alive.

         “What can we do?” Thorin had his sword and axe in hand as he set his feet next to Gandalf.

         “Be brave, Thorin Oakenshield,” Gandalf's voice was still a touch thready as he raised his own staff. The tip of it began to glow once more. This time, though, the light seemed fiercer, brighter, a shade of red-gold that reminded Thorin of angry dawns before a storm. “This will get worse before it gets better.”

         Thorin set his feet as Gandalf began his own chant. Alatar swiped one hand outward and Thorin braced for that power to hit them. But instead of being thrown back like Gandalf, the gray wizard's staff came jutting out before him and that strike of power split, whistling past them to slam into the pillars behind them. Thorin heard an ominous cracking sound from the stone.

         “They risk bringing the mountain down on our heads!” Thorin looked up, seeing cracks start to spiderweb out from where that strike hit the pillar, spreading up the rock to be lost into the darkness above.

         Gandalf grunted something that might have been an answer but Thorin did not understand it. He watched as Gandalf held out his staff before him horizontally and then took a step forward. It looked almost as if the wizard was trying to push something before him, some great weight that took all of his might to move. Thorin moved with him, Dwalin at his side, step by step with the wizard until Gandalf seemed to be forced right once more, to where they had first been standing, near the edge of the chasm in the heart of the mountain.

         It was there that Thorin got his first good look at Saruman. The wizard was on his knees, the front of his robe dyed dark from blood. And in his hands...in his hands...

         “No,” Dwalin breathed, lunging forward. Thorin caught his shoulder, holding him back as Gandalf growled at them.

         In Saruman's right hand was the Silmaril that had been in Thorin and Dwalin's rooms. And in his left hand was the silk that had been anointed with Bilbo's blood weeks before. “Erestor,” Thorin murmured. He knew the elf would not have given up that gem or that silk just because it had been demanded. The blood on all of the wizards' robes also said as much. More worrying, though, was the fact that Saruman seemed to be unconscious where he was slumped, head bowed so that his chin was on his chest, almost curled over those hands that held the two items.

         “Saruman!” Gandalf shouted then. His arm trembled and his staff wobbled from side to side. Thorin could see sparks start to flare off of the staff, golden and glowing, streaking past them like embers from a too-hot forge. “Saruman, you must wake up!”

         “Be silent, Gandalf!” Alatar spoke at last. His face was set in a deep grimace, the shadows from the glow about his hands causing his face to look disfigured, jaw too long and his eyes too wide and red. “We will allow no one and nothing to stop us now!”

         “What can we do?” Thorin spoke low enough so that the other wizards could not hear him. He hoped.

         “We must stop their spell,” Gandalf flinched as a great wave of power hit his staff. The sparks made Thorin raise his arm, blocking his eyes. When he lowered it he saw that Saruman's head had raised and that the wizard's eyes were barely open. “Look!” He pointed.

         “Saruman!” Gandalf cried out again. “Fight back!”

         “Too...late...” Blood dripped from the wizard's mouth.

         “It is not too late! Saruman, please!”

         “Be silent!” Pallando screamed at them, the glow in his hands turning a deep bloody red.

         “No!” Gandalf roared back at them, shoving his staff forward. A great blue burst of power came from him, streaking towards the wizards like a wave. Alatar dropped his hands with a snarl, hand flat as he cut it through the air, causing that blue wave to pass them, though it did drive Alatar to one knee.

         “Gand...alf...” Saruman's moan sounded strange. Thorin shook his head as a buzzing seemed to fill his ears. “You must...”

         “Saruman!”

         Those dark eyes went wide for a moment. Saruman's head jerked up, as did his hands. The Silmaril and the silk were still clutched in his grip, though his limbs were trembling so much that Thorin did not know how he kept a hold of them. “Gandalf!” His voice was clear once more, much like his eyes. That was when Thorin realized that he had never seen the wizard's eyes that clearly, nor had he ever seen such an expression on Saruman's face. “You must –”

         “Saruman! You must not speak! You –,” Pallando cried as he looked down at the kneeling wizard.

         “Gandalf!” Saruman cried out, bending over his lap. Blood began to stream from his nose. “You must kill me!”

         Thorin's breath stuttered in his throat. What? What did Saruman mean? What –

         “No!” Gandalf cried back at him. “I cannot – what do you mean? Saruman, what –”

         “Gandalf, please!” Saruman's whole body started to shake. His dark eyes did not leave Gandalf. “You must!”

         “But I...”

         “You will not touch him!” Pallando screamed, one hand sweeping out before him. Gandalf hissed as a red wave of power came streaking towards them. Thorin threw himself to the ground, along with Dwalin, as Gandalf's staff redirected the strike into the chasm, lighting it the darkness as it streaked into the depths of the mountain.

         “Stop this madness!” Gandalf took two staggering steps forward, staff braced before him. “You will be the destruction of us all!”

         “The destruction! No!” Pallando shouted back at them. “This is the only way we will survive!”

         “Survive? Do you think Morgoth will reward you with his return? He is the master of lies and deceit!”

         Pallando's laugh sounded high and crazed as Thorin go to his knees. His heart was thundering in his chest and it felt hard to breathe, as if the very air was turning thick, like water, around them. “You know nothing, Olórin! It is not Morgoth we are summoning! That is your plan, not ours!”

         Thorin looked at Dwalin. His partner looked as surprised as Thorin felt.

         “I have no plan to summon that dark spirit!” Gandalf cried back at them. “Let Saruman go!”

         “No!” Saruman's shout seemed to startled the blue wizards. “Kill me! Gandalf! You must kill me!”

         “But Saruman, I –”

         “Kill me before it is too late!” Saruman rose up on his knees, his entire body almost convulsing on the stone. “Now! You must do it now!”

         “No!” Both Pallando and Alatar shouted as one. “You will not harm him! It is your corruption that is causing him to say such things! Get back! We will not allow you to stop our work!”

         “Fools!” Saruman's body began to shake, his head snapping back and forth as blood continued to stream from his nose, then his eyes. “Gandalf, if you ever called me a friend, you must kill me now!”

         “I...” Thorin saw Gandalf's staff dip, just a touch. It was enough of a distraction that Alatar's next strike brought Gandalf to his knees, his staff snapping in two in his hands. Thorin ducked to avoid the worst of the shards, looking up in time to see both Pallando and Alatar grab Saruman's shoulders, holding him in place.

         “No...” The word died in Saruman's throat as a fountain of blood spilled down the front of his robe.

         “Saruman!” Gandalf was on his knees, blood dripping from his own nose as he reached for the other wizard.

         A red glow enveloped all three wizards on the jutting point over the central chasm of Erebor. Thorin watched as Saruman's body arched back, his hands still clenched around the Silmaril and the holy silk, his fingers looking like bloodless claws. He heard Gandalf gasp but Thorin could not take his gaze from the three wizards. Pallando and Alatar had gone rigid, their mouths open in silent screams as that red glow settled over them, the chords of their necks standing out in stark relief. That was when Thorin realized that Saruman was no longer convulsing. The wizard was still, head tipped back, but there was a slow smile spreading across his face that made Thorin's stomach twist with dread.

         “Ah,” Saruman said. The word seemed to echo through the mountain, making the very stones tremble. His head tilted back down and instead of the dark eyes Thorin expected, Saruman's eyes were glowing a deep crimson. “What a pathetic last gasp.” He laughed, the blood on his chin glinting in the strange red glow that had surrounded the three wizards. He grinned and his teeth were stained red as well. All of his attention was on Gandalf. “Hello again, fool.”

         Thorin looked from wizard to wizard as things started to fit together in his mind. “No,” he said, shaking his head.

         “Ah, does the little clay golem think he has figured it out?” Saruman's smile grew, too wide for his narrow face.

         “It cannot be,” Thorin shook his head again. He brought up his sword. “It is impossible.”

         “Impossible? Oh, no.” Saruman – no. The being who had possessed Saruman got to its feet in fits and starts. His hands were still clutching the Silmaril and the holy silk tight. “It is far more possible than you can even know.”

         “Sauron,” Gandalf whispered the name and it felt like all the breath left Thorin's lungs at once. “Let him go.”

         “Let who go?” The wizard – no. Sauron tilted Saruman's head to one side, just a touch too far to look natural. “The fool you see in front of you had long ago fallen to my seductions, Gandalf the Grey. Oh, you should have seen his fall,” Sauron licked the wizard's lips and Thorin shuddered at the sight. “He was so hungry for knowledge, for the want of more.” Sauron barred his teeth again, leaning forward between the two frozen blue wizards. “Did you know that your precious Saruman had a palantír inside Orthanc that he used almost every day? Did you know that he was looking, searching day after day for my precious Ring? That he wished to be the one to find it and use it? Ah, Gandalf. You should have seen the greed growing in him. But then again,” more blood began to drip from the wizard's chin. “You always were a blind, hopeful fool.”

         “Sauron!” A voice Thorin did not expect cried out. He turned his head to see Lady Galadriel skid to a stop next to them. Her clothes were torn in places and there was blood splashed on her cheek but she did not seem grievously harmed. “Let him go!”

         “You,” Sauron's growl seemed to fill the whole mountain. “Always poking about where you are not wanted! Go back to the battle outside the gates, little elf, or else I will deal with you as I should have the first time we met!”

         “You have never been able to deal with me, Sauron!”

         “Silence!” His snarl was accompanied by another wave of crimson power. This time Galadriel stepped forward, one hand raised, and a power of her own seemed to meet that crimson strike, the two crashing together in front of where Thorin knelt next to Gandalf, causing sparks to blind his eyes for a long moment. When he blinked the spots from his eyes he saw Sauron bent forward, with blood starting to run from Saruman's eyes.

         Galadriel herself was braced, both hands out as if warding off a blow. Her face was paler than it had been before. “Enough, Sauron,” she said. “Let Saruman go and vanish back into the shadows as you should have, nothing more than a whisper of what you once could have been.”

         “Fool,” more blood spilled from between his lips. “Silly little fool. You should have taken my hand. Maybe that would have saved you.” The skin of Saruman's face seemed to be stretching – no. It was melting, Thorin realized, his stomach heaving in horror. “Nothing will save you now!”

         “Sauron!” Galadriel cried out, surging forward but the sheer drop of the chasm before her halted her in place. “Stop what you are doing!”

         “Stop?” There was a sibilant note to Sauron's voice now. Thorin struggled to get to his feet, the pressure in the air almost beating him back down to his knees. “I will never stop.” Sauron raised Saruman's arms, his gaze going to the items in his hands. “It is almost time,” his voice rang with power, the crimson glow growing about the three wizards. “At last my Master will return,” the glow about them grew brighter. “He will remake the world in his image and wipe away you worthless pests like the plague you are. Everything will be ours!”

         “You think Morgoth will share his power, Sauron? You know he will never do such a thing!” Galadriel held up a hand towards the wizards. “Stop this. Please. You must stop this. Morgoth knows nothing but destruction and evil! He will rip the world apart in his madness!”

         “He will restore this world to order!” Sauron screamed back at her. The flesh on Saruman's face began to crack and bleed about his mouth and eyes. “All the useless worms cluttering up the world will be wiped away so that my Master might start anew!”

         “You know Morgoth cannot create anything!” Galadriel shouted back at him. “All he can do is ape what Eru Ilúvatar has made! Morgoth's madness will bring about the end of everything and you know it!”

         “I know what Mandos prophesied,” Sauron hissed at them, his lips splitting as he spoke. “I also know from watching behind this fool's eyes that that prophecy is now destroyed!”

         “Sauron –”

         “My Master now has a chance! A chance to take this world that should have always been his!” There was a strange flash of blue light behind the wizards, there and gone. Thorin squinted at it but he could not make out what could have been behind them. The shadows about the three were also growing thicker – or the crimson glow was growing to a point that made the darkness inside the mountain look all the deeper. Thorin could not tell. “With these Silmarils and the blood of the weasel that destroyed my Ring I will bring him back! I will return my Master to the world, whole and complete, just as he should have always been!”

         That was when Thorin realized that there was not one, but two Silmarils in Sauron's hands. They began to glow inside that crimson aura, shining brighter and brighter with each beat of Thorin's heart.

         “Sauron, no!” Galadriel cried out. “Stop this madness! Please!”

         “Come forth, servants of Morgoth! Come forth my brethren, here and now!” Sauron lifted Saruman's hands, the Silmarils glowing so bright they brought tears to Thorin's eyes. They were also starting to burn Saruman's hands, the flesh turning black and smoking where he held them. The crimson glow about them grew but it was also...flickering? Thorin squinted at it, trying to make out the strange dark shapes that almost seemed to be looping about the aura, as if...containing it? But how was that happening?

         “Alatar! Pallando! You must fight him!” Gandalf shouted leaning forward on his hands as he stared at the two motionless wizards on either side of Sauron. “Do not give in to his lies!”

         “My lies? Oh, yes,” Sauron's laugh sounded crazed as he spat out thick globs of blood into the chasm before him. “Well did they believe my lies,” the laughter grew as Sauron raised his hands even higher. “They believed the little whispers a slid into their ears. How you were corrupted by the shadow, Gandalf, how you and Galadriel were blinded by the evil that had infected you through your long years on this land. How eager they were to listen. How eager they were to believe Saruman.” Sauron tilted his head down once more. Thorin felt bile burn the back of his throat at the way the wizard's face was cracked and bleeding, the flesh peeling back to reveal a deep crimson glow, like lava peeking through an obsidian crust. “These fools listened and listened and ah, was it easy to deceive them! And now they are my puppets, tied by blood and power to my command!”

         “Pallando,” Gandalf's whisper sounded strange, too loud for how soft it was spoken. “Fight him. I know you can do it. Alatar. Throw off his control and fight.”

         “Oh, they are trying,” Sauron laughed again, tilting a glance up at the wizards that stood on either side of him. “I can feel their minds writhing in horror. Oh, their despair tastes as sweet as sugar,” Sauron licked his cracked and peeling lips again. Then the sneer on his face faltered. “Ah, they are trying to fight back. To think they would listen to you now, Gandalf, when before they truly believed that it was you and your elf that wished to open the Door of Night here in Erebor. That only we three would be able to stop you from destroying the world.”

         A snarl took over his sneer as Sauron jerked Saruman's head to the side, as if being struck by some invisible blow. “Enough of this,” the evil spirit spat as the two blue wizards began to jerk in place. Thorin thought he saw Pallando try to raise his hand, his eyes wide and face wet with tears, lips trembling through words Thorin could not make out. “You will bow to my will or I will find a better use for you both!”

         That was when Alatar threw his head back, the crimson glow around him faltering. “Kill us!” His scream echoed in the chamber. Thorin saw the way Gandalf flinched from it. “Kill us now before he –”

         “No!” Sauron's own scream drowned out the blue wizard. His eyes blazed brighter, the blood starting to smoke and more cracks appearing on Saruman's face. “If you will not comply then I will make use of your blood instead!”

         “No!” Both Galadriel and Gandalf cried out at the same time. Thorin could do nothing but watch as Sauron struck, quick as a snake, his hand forming a blade of power as he swung at the two blue wizards. Thin red lines appeared on Pallando and Alatar's necks, the lines spreading, growing thicker, as the skin opened and the blood fountained over Sauron's borrowed body, bathing him in thick, crimson liquid. The two blue wizards' bodies crumpled to the ground, the light in their eyes fading as they fell line puppets whose strings had been cut.

         “No!” Gandalf cried out, all but collapsing on the ground at the sight. Galadriel also staggered, her face going stark white as she shook her head and stared.

         “Sauron!” Thorin turned to see both Glorfindel and Ecthelion running towards them. “Stop!”

         “Ah, more heroes to save the day,” Sauron said. A slow smile spread across his face. “Always too late, the two of you. Your little Erestor also fought to stop me from taking what was rightfully mine.”

         Thorin saw Glorfindel stumble, with only Ecthelion's quick catch keeping Glorfindel on his feet. “No,” Glorfindel gasped out as they came to a stop near where Thorin was kneeling.

         “Yes,” Sauron hissed back at him. “He was no hero of Gondolin, I will tell you that. But he did try to stop me and he failed, just like his family failed to retake the Silmarils from my Master.”

         “What – he – he what...”

         “Ah, did the little bastard never tell you?” Sauron's laughter was cruel. “The bastard born son of Caranthir and a human wench in the First Age, an elf of the line of Fëanor, hiding right under your nose. No wonder he never told you.” Sauron's tone took a mocking edge. “Well is it known that you both detested the sons of Fëanor and all of their kin. The welp would never have dared to tell you of his origins, not when he trailed after you, Glorfindel, like the pathetic worm he was!”

         “No,” Glorfindel stretched out a hand, shaking his head. “You are lying.”

         “Oh, I am not. He was the son of Caranthir and told me so himself when he tried to stop me,” Sauron laughed again. “Ah, the look on your face! It is delicious.”

         Glorfindel drew himself up, a golden glow starting to shine around him. Thorin set the point of his sword to the stone floor and tried to push himself to his feet to join him. It felt like the very air about him was thick, heavier than even the holy waters below the mountain and just as cold. “I will end you,” Glorfindel growled, his sword coming up.

         “You will be too busy to fight me, little elf,” Sauron's voice started to echo oddly. Thorin forced himself to his feet, breathing hard as he saw Galadriel help Gandalf to his feet from the corner of his eye. There was something...something strange to the glow surrounding Sauron, something that did not make sense. It was...it was...

         “No,” he heard Glorfindel gasp. That was when Thorin realized that there was a secondary glow starting to surround Sauron, a glowing coming up from the chasm between them. The frigid air was also warming, getting hotter and hotter.

         “Thorin,” Dwalin said.

         “I see it,” Thorin told him. His grip tightened on his sword, though what good it would be he did not know. For there, emerging from the chasm, were the great forms of Durin's Bane, one after the other, the burning bodies and great horns limed with that same strange crimson glow.

         The glow about Sauron grew brighter, the dark bands crackling away as the evil spirit raised his smoking hands high. “It is time!” Sauron's voice seemed to swell in the space between them. It was all Thorin could hear, even over the crack of the balrog's whips and their roars as they climbed out of the pit. “It is time my Master! It is time to break the world and start anew!”

         That was when Sauron brought his smoking hands together and all the world went white.

 

Chapter 34: hope is a spark in the dark

Chapter Text

 

         Bilbo ran as fast as he could, tearing down the long tunnels of the in between, his breath scraping in his lungs and a sharp stitch in his side. Still he did not stop, did not slow, but continued forward, one destination in mind. He had to get to Thorin. He had to get to Dwalin. He had to make sure that they were alive.

         Bilbo put a foot to a wall and used his momentum to propel him around a corner. The angular designs on the surfaces of the tunnels near the Royal Wing were a welcome sight. Still he did not slow. He rounded the last corner and all but tore the door open from the in between to the real world, stumbling when he found the entrance to Thorin and Dwalin's rooms already ajar.

         Bilbo tried to catch his breath and still his thundering heart as he stepped into the room. It felt, for a moment, like his whole world had stopped when he saw the blood streaking the floor and the overturned furniture. The table that held the Durin's Crown was broken and the crown itself lay on the floor on its side. And, just beyond it, was a pale, still hand.

         All the breath left Bilbo's lungs at once. He scrambled forward to see Master Erestor laying in a pool of blood, his face pale as cream, and the eight-pointed star on his chest coated in blood. Bilbo had never seen the elf wear armor before, yet Master Erestor's looked well worn and well looked-after. He had been kind to Bilbo during the Company's stay in Rivendell and had gladly shown Bilbo the massive library there when he had asked to see it. Bilbo had thought at the time that should he ever wish to leave the Shire after his Adventure of there and back again, Rivendell and that library would be his choice to come and stay. Master Erestor had been kind the entire day he had shown Bilbo around, arranging for a tea tray to be brought to them on the wide balcony outside the library's windowed doors that looked out over a lovely garden full of wild flowers.

         Now Master Erestor was pale and still, one hand flung out as if trying to ward off a blow. Bilbo knelt next to the elf and put a hand to Master Erestor's face, holding his own breath and hoping...

         There.

         Bilbo drew breath to shout for help but a hand on his shoulder caused him to let out an embarrassing squeak. He looked up to see Widow Minona staring down at Master Erestor with a faint frown on her face. “You are not supposed to be here,” she said, not looking at him.

         “I know, but –”

         “Enough of that,” she gave him a shake. “There are places for you to be and things for you to do and little time in which you must do them. Go now, Bilbo of the Baggins clan. I will watch over this one.”

         “But he –”

         “Is kin to one I helped long ago, which makes him mine,” she gave him another shake. This time her gaze shifted to him. Her expression softened then. “Go now, young Bilbo. Look for the ones you have claimed and see if you can find them in the time that is left. But do as you were meant, as you were always meant.” She let go of him and knelt next to Master Erestor, lifting the elf's head with a steady hand. “Go,” she repeated.

         Bilbo went.

         At the doorway he stepped back into the in between, passing a line of veiled widows as he went. He had only a handful of guesses as to where his dwarves could be, so to the gates of Erebor he first went.

         Halfway there it felt like the tunnels of the in between dropped out from under his feet. Bilbo stumbled and went to his knees, his palms stinging, the threads wrapped tight about his left hand all constricting at once. Bilbo found the thread of twisted yellow and green strands, pressing his own finger against it and holding his breath. The thread warmed under his touch and Bilbo let out a relieved sigh. Fortinbras and Lalia were alive. That was all he could tell at the moment. It would have to be enough for now.

         Bilbo looked up to see that there were cracks running through the tunnels of the in between. Some of the ceiling had fallen too, showing not dirt or rock, but a strange void that filled Bilbo with dread as he stared at it. The longer he stared at it the more that dread seemed to grow, until Bilbo was scrambling to his feet and flying past that strange hole and down through the tunnels towards Erebor's gates without looking back.

         The tunnels near the gates showed more damage than where Bilbo had come from. Whole sections of the walls and ceilings were gone, showing more of that dark void that made Bilbo's breath catch each time he passed them. As he stepped out onto the balcony where he had fallen, Bilbo had to duck behind the thick rock wall as a roar swept the area, making his ears ache with the sound.

         Bilbo peeked over the top of the wall to see a sea of blackness sweeping over the front lawn of Erebor. Where the tents of the men and elves had once been now crawled legions of those same spiders Bilbo had once battled in Mirkwood. They looked larger now, though, and far more numerous. On and on the waves of them came, looking like a pile of ants swarming once their hive was disturbed. Bilbo looked out beyond them to see a crimson glow advancing on the mountain. At first he thought it came from the torches of whatever army was making its way to them...but on closer inspection that glow came from no torch Bilbo recognized. No, the glow came from line after line of massive beings, black and crimson, who wielded swords and whips as they drove hordes of goblins and orcs before them.

         Bilbo looked down as the threads about his left wrist went cold. There, at the bottom of the network of the webs, was a thick band of black threads. One after the other they went cold, the chill spreading up Bilbo's arm to his elbow. He cursed, looking back up at the battle raging before the gates of Erebor. He was running out of time.

         Bilbo pressed forward, his palms digging into the hard angles of the stone wall. To his right he saw Bard and Thranduil fighting together, with a knot of Thranduil's elves – and Kíli – fighting with them. They were the only knot of fighters pushing forward through the oncoming hordes, the precise movements of the elves shining against the darkness of the spiders and their flashing fangs.

         To the left of the gates Bilbo could see Lord Elrond fighting with Maedhros, the two of them back to back as the spiders surged around them, dying in droves as they tried to get to the pair of elves. In that knot of fighters Bilbo also saw the young Ranger that one of the Bounders had claimed had almost caught them when their people were sneaking about the tents of the men and elves. He was almost as graceful as an elf, fighting with ferocity and strength with the rest of his people. A little behind the young Ranger were the lords of Rohan and Gondor, who Bilbo only recognized from the way the other men around them were drawn tight to protect them.

         Just below Bilbo he could make out most of his Company, along with Dáin and a large number of the Iron Hills dwarves blocking the main entrance of the gates. He saw Bofur standing between Bifur and Bombur, the three Ur brothers fighting as one unit. Glóin was near them, cleaving through his enemies with the power Bilbo had become well acquainted with during their Adventure. There was no sight of Óin but Bilbo guessed that the older dwarf was guarding the healing halls with every once of breath in his body. Fíli was next to him, a golden whirlwind of the battlefield, and Balin was never far from his side. Bilbo could see Dori standing in front of Ori, the older dwarf's axe a blur as Ori fired stone missiles from behind his brother. Bilbo leaned forward, squinting, for sure where Dori and Ori were, there should be...

         “Bilbo?”

         Bilbo froze, breath stuttering, before he slowly turned to see Nori standing behind him. The once-thief had a heartbroken expression on his face, one that Bilbo had never seen on him before. Nori's hands curled and uncurled at his sides. “Bilbo,” he repeated. “You...you're here.”

         “I am,” Bilbo found his voice to say. There was a careful amount of space between them. Bilbo's back was pressed against the very same wall that he had been both dropped over and had jumped from.

         “Are you...can you...” To Bilbo's shock there was a sheen to Nori's eyes. “Can you get my brothers out of here?”

         “I...”

         “It is going to be a rout,” Nori shook his head. “The spiders are just the first of it. Someone has been stealing the news the ravens gave my boys, right from their minds. They didn't remember the ravens repeating it, didn't even know that Roäc had told multiple of my boys that they had seen double messengers for weeks. Someone here wanted this to happen. They helped make it happen. There are orcs and goblins and Durin's Bane coming – balrogs. They are all headed here.” Nori swallowed hard. “We cannot stop them, as few as we are. So can you take my brothers? Please.” He took a step forward. “You saved Thorin, once. Can you save my brothers now? Please. Please.”

         “Nori,” Bilbo surprised himself by surging forward and wrapping the dwarf in a hug he once would have never dared. “It is going to be all right.”

         “...Bilbo?”

         The threads about Bilbo's left hand were growing tight enough to make the tips of his fingers tingle. He was out of time. “It is going to be all right,” he repeated as he let Nori go. The dwarf's eyes were huge and staring as he looked at Bilbo. “I promise. Ori and Dori will be all right. You will all live through this day.” Then he had to go. Bilbo stepped back into the in between, uncaring if Nori saw the shift of his body go from there to not-there. Bilbo was still uncertain just what the dwarves or the other races saw when they looked into the in between.

         “Bilbo!”

         Nori's cry followed Bilbo into the tunnels. Bilbo closed the door on Nori's outstretched hand and had to run, the threads going so cold against his skin that it almost felt like a brand. Bilbo ran, tearing down the halls of the in between, noting that more damage had been done while he had been out on the balcony. The deeper into the mountain he went the more hobbits he began to see. Bounders were hurrying to their posts. Bilbo stopped at Remy Oldwalker's side, one hand pressed to his ribs were the stitch from before had returned. “Remy,” he panted. “Is everyone in place?”

         “That they are,” Remy bobbed his head. “Are you –”

         “I need you to make sure everyone is where they need to be,” Bilbo cut him off. His mother would have twisted his ear for his rudeness but time was of the essence.

         “Everyone is moving,” another voice said. Bilbo turned to see one of the northern hobbit clans come to a stop next to Remy. “I have seen it myself.”

         “Thank you,” Bilbo remembered his manners at the last minute.

         “It is as it should be,” the northern hobbit had dark hair that fell into dark eyes. His white teeth shown against his nut-brown skin as he grinned at Bilbo. “You are the Holder, after all.” Then the hobbit pressed a carved stone into his hand that Bilbo tucked into his pocket without looking.

         Bilbo snapped his mouth shut at that, feeling his cheeks heat. “Yes, well, I'll be off then,” he managed to stammer out before he hurried on his way. He had thought his meeting and task from the widows had been private. The very last thing he needed was even more infamy.

         Bother.

         Bilbo shook off the thought and picked up the pace, going from group to group, checking to make sure all was in place. At the Gardeners he got a crown of flowers shoved onto his head by a distracted Hamfast. The twist of hellebore flowers, elderberry, and rowan branches and berries were nothing like Bilbo had ever worn before. The Singers tucked a bell into a buttonhole without a by-your-leave but they were also distracted and half of them had eyes that were milky white and already looking into realms and spaces that Bilbo could not ever conceive of. He nipped through the kitchens and got a spoon thrown at him for good measure, but not before he managed to nick a small pie off a counter and shove it into his mouth.

         Down in the larger halls Bilbo spun with three of the Dancers, despite the stitch still in his side, and came away with a ribbon that was wrapped about the wrist without the threads. The chill from those threads was still there but not growing, and with each portion of his people he passed one or two of those threads would warm again. The threads themselves were changing color as Bilbo went through his people, the strands gaining a glow as he passed through the groups of hobbits and moved on.

         By the time he had made his rounds of all the different groups of hobbits, Bilbo had a feather hanging from a clip in his hair, sparkling rock dust shaking off of him with every step, a braided rope about his neck, a quiver of arrows on his back – but no bow – his ears stinging with new earrings dangling from each, the blue stones blazing. All of the threads wrapped about his left hand were glowing, save for the black bands about his wrist.

         It was time.

         The Gardeners were huddled around a variety of doors that Bilbo passed. The Singers and Weavers were in the deep halls, Bilbo had been told, and had to trust that they would find their way there safely. Fortinbras and Lalia were sure to be busy in the heart of their section of the mountain, directing everyone where they needed to go as the widows...well.

         Bilbo knew what the widows were about to do.

         Another lurch went through the tunnels, causing more than one hobbit near Bilbo to cry out and cover their heads as dust and debris rained down on them. Bilbo still did not pause, tearing around corners as he went deeper and deeper into the mountain. The further in he went the more damage the tunnels had, until he was sometimes running on a cracked path with that strange, blank void all around him. Still Bilbo ran on, deeper and deeper, as the path narrowed until he felt like he was a stone skipping across a deep, black pond, with a starless night stretched out over him. He ran until he could run no more, until a single, deep green door singled the end of his path.

         Bilbo hit it at a sprint, not caring how he tore out of the in between and back into the world that Is between one breath and the next.

         Bilbo fell to his knees on one of the platforms that was still perched over the central chasm in the heart of Erebor. The mountain was as dark as Bilbo had ever seen it. It reminded him of the times when he would first sneak out of the halls where his people had been settled, deep in the belly of the mountain, down a path that Bilbo had only recently come to know that led to more of the holy places that Thorin's people had not yet come to use.

         High up on his platform Bilbo could see where the three wizards were perched on a jut of rock that overlooked the central chasm. Bilbo looked down and had to suck in a breath, for there, far, far below him, was an angry glow that made shivers go down his spine. When he looked up he saw where Gandalf was kneeling...and where Thorin and Dwalin were on their knees next to the wizard, all of them staring at where Saruman and the blue wizards stood.

         Bilbo closed his eyes for a long moment, his stomach plummeting. This was the last place he wanted his dwarves to be. For here and now would come the final fixing, the last great work their people would have to do, the last promise delivered from their creation long ago. He opened his eyes as he let out a breath. They had come this far. Bilbo would have to trust that his dwarves could keep themselves safe for a little while longer.

         And then.

         Bilbo slapped a hand over his mouth when Saruman's form began to...shift. The two blue wizards – who were clearly suffering from the widow's pronouncement from what Bilbo had heard – seemed to stiffen, as if held in place by an invisible hand. Bilbo's fingers curled around the edge of the platform as he drew himself closer, eyes narrowing as he took in the spectacle below.

         That was when he saw the two Silmarils in Saruman's hands. But no, it was not Saruman, he realized, barely able to hear the wizard talking over the rushing sound in his ears. He watched as a crimson aura enveloped the three wizards, pulsing oddly, as if it was fighting something. And it was, Bilbo realized, when he looked up to see line after line of black clad and black veiled widows standing on every ledge possible above the wizards below. Their hands were raised, palms facing out, and it was their power that was fighting the crimson glow about the wizards, trying to contain it. Trying, Bilbo realized, to buy time.

         For him.

         Bilbo bowed his head at that, breath harsh in his throat. A part of him shivered at the thought that this was happening at all. That he, some small hobbit in this vast world, was in this place, at this time, about to do something that was so much bigger than he could even truly comprehend. Then his gaze landed on the threads wrapped tight about his left hand, the strands all glowing different colors, the hope and the power of their people gathered there, and his heart steadied.

         Bilbo had not known what to expect when the widows had led him away on that eve of the longest night. He had not thought he was getting a dressing down, since they were all too solemn for that. Perhaps told that...well. His fancies had run a bit too free for a while, until the widows had led him down and down and down such a length of stairs that it felt like they were walking into the center of the earth.

         Then they had gone through a tall, black doorway that led into a large chamber. It was shadowed to the point that Bilbo could not see where the walls were, but in the center was a raised dais and on that dais was a woman seated with her back to door where Bilbo and the others had walked through. She was not a hobbit, Bilbo could tell at a glance. Her dark hair was loose down her back and her gown was a gray that shifted in the light, sometimes lighter, sometimes darker, ever changing. The widows brought Bilbo forward, right up to the edge of the dais, and stopped.

         “Bilbo Baggins,” the woman said, her back still to him. She had a loom in front of her, Bilbo realized then, the strangest Bilbo had ever seen, and his eyes refused to focus on it. “Long have I waited to meet you.”

         Bilbo swallowed at the words, his feet glued to the floor. “My lady has me at a disadvantage,” he managed to get out.

         The woman's hands stilled on the loom and a laugh escaped her. Her right hand rose, swinging out to her side, palm facing up. “Come to me, Bilbo Baggins. I would see your face.”

         Shivers had run through Bilbo then but he had obeyed the lady, stepping up onto the dais and coming to her side. Closer he could see that the lady was not like those of the race of Men and nor was she an elf. She looked...different. Like them but not. She was, Bilbo came to realize, not like anything he had ever met at all.

         Her gray eyes were like a kaleidoscope that the traders from the East would bring through Bree and then the hobbits there would trade them to their people in the Shire. Her dark hair was also threaded through with gray, though he did not think it was from age. The lady's face was as smooth as a maiden's and her smile was kind when he chanced a look up at her.

         “Take my hand, Bilbo Baggins,” she said. What else could he do but take it? He laid his left hand in hers and immediately her long fingers wrapped about his hand, trapping him in place. He did not dare to try and pull away, feeling frozen where he stood. He could not seem to look away from her strange eyes.

         “You have now learned about your people's creation,” she said. A faint smile lingered on her mouth. “How all the powers of the Valar were brought to bear against Morgoth and then left there, to mingle in the depths of Arda, so close to the Flame Imperishable...and more.”

         “More, my lady?” Bilbo croaked out when she did not continue.

         “More,” she nodded. Those gray eyes darkened, as did her raiment. “For it was not the Valar's powers alone that lingered there.”

         Bilbo could not look away. “What else lingered there?”

         Her smile grew, kind and soft and as hard as steel. “The Darkness,” she said. “Morgoth's own powers lingered there.”

         Bilbo wanted to look away. He wanted to shake his head in denial. Instead he heard himself ask, “Then are we too born of his powers?”

         Her smile stayed in place. “Yes.”

         Bilbo had felt a tremor go through him, right down to his bones.

         “Morgoth had tried for years beyond count to create something of his own, to birth into the the world that Is something that was his alone. Little does he know that he did, in fact, manage to do so...but not by his own desires, nor by his own design. It was by chance...something that Morgoth did not realize was his part in the Song that once was sung.”

         “You,” the lady said, her voice as soft as a whisper yet loud enough that it seemed to ring in his ears, “Bilbo of the Baggins clan, are of the line that carries that power that Morgoth once held. You and your line alone hold the possibility of chance, the pure form of Morgoth's powers, the power that he should have wielded for the good of the world and instead squandered it.” Her smile grew by inches. Her hand tightened on Bilbo's. “And I believe you now know what your role in all of this is to be.”

         “My lady,” Bilbo whispered.

         “Vairë,” she said. Her smile was spreading, warming her eyes and expression.

         Bilbo's throat was tight as he managed to say, “What would you have me do, Lady Vairë?”

         “Ah, always so polite, no matter where you are,” her smile was strange and Bilbo did not understand her words. Bilbo winced as her grip about his left hand went bruising tight. “As you were once before, so shall you be again,” she said and let go of him. When Bilbo looked down to his hand he found the threads there, wrapped tight to his skin, more numerous than he could count at first. “You, Bilbo of the Baggins clan, have one chance to fix this all. Are you willing to try?”

         “I...” Bilbo's voice had failed him then. He'd taken in a slow breath, his heart beating so fast he could feel it in the hollow of his throat. He met the lady's strange gaze and raised his chin. “I will fix it,” he swore then. “By hook or by crook, no matter what I must do. I will fix it.”

         “Ah, young one,” her smile turned sad then. “You are as you ever are. I am glad to have met you this time, Bilbo Baggins. Go forth and fear not the darkness that you and your line carries. For it is something that was always supposed to be part of this world. Chance,” her smile warmed once more. “Now, go.”

         And go he did. The threads about his left hand had never left him. There did not seem any way to get them off, except by snipping...and Bilbo knew, somehow, that should he try such an act it would be the scissors that broke first and not the threads.

         And now, here he was, watching as Saruman – no, as Sauron – killed the two blue wizards on either side of him. There was no way to save them. The threads had said as much. The wizards had both a role to fill and a price to pay for the actions they had committed. It had been a harsh lesson to learn as Bilbo had tried to understand just what this gift from the Lady Vairë had meant. Bilbo could do nothing but watch, a silent witness, as Sauron used the power of those wizards' deaths to bolster whatever spell or rite he was attempting.

         The black bands about Sauron's crimson aura broke one by one. Bilbo could hear them like threads snapping right by his ear. He barely paid attention to the arrival of Glorfindel and Ecthelion, for all of his attention was now on the growing glow that was making its way up the central chasm of the mountain. He glanced up to see the widows all staring back at him, waiting. They would only have one chance at this. But they had to wait. They had to allow things to break before they could fix it all, once and for all.

         And so Bilbo waited on that high platform, watching as Sauron brought Saruman's smoking hands together as the balrogs rose out of that pit, and the whole world went white.

 

Chapter 35: The Door of Night

Chapter Text

 

         When Thorin could see again it was to the sight of a great circle, edged in stone, having appeared in the center of the mountain. The mountain itself looked as though a black void was trying to swallow it whole. The strange door in the middle of the central chamber almost filled the space, far larger than anything Thorin had seen built, even by the hands of their ancestors. The strange circle inside the stones rippled like water touched by wind, the shining blue like the silks Thorin had seen imported from the East.

         The great stones that ringed that shimmering circle had seen far better days. Many were blackened in places, others cracked and flaking, while others were missing altogether. Each of the surviving stones, even those that were discolored or broken, had gleaming silver runes on them, though Thorin could not tell how they were attached. He did not recognize the runes but from the way Gandalf gasped at the sight of them, he was sure they meant something of importance to the wizard.

         “The Door of Night,” Gandalf said, his voice breaking on the last word.

         “Gandalf! What is – oh,” a voice from behind them cut out. Thorin heard Eönwë's heavy steps stop next to them. Thorin could not look away from the vast Door in front of him. “Oh,” Eönwë said, softer. “Oh.”

         “Behold,” the distorted voice of the husk that had been Saruman said. Most of his flesh had burnt away, showing instead a figure that looked both like a deep shadow and also like a burning pillar of fire. “All your plans are put to waste,” Sauron hissed at them, the last of Saruman's face flaking away. “My Master comes and with him a new world to be made to His order!”

         “Sauron,” Eönwë said, reaching one hand out. “Stop this.”

         “There is no stopping this now! Come, spirits of fire! Come, blood drinkers of the air! Come, wolves made in men's forms! Come now and make way for our Master! Come now and clear the world of the vermin that never deserved it! Come! COME!”

         That was when Thorin saw the great claws that came crashing down on the lip of the chasm, the black and crimson balrogs pulling themselves out of the depths. He saw how Glorfindel and Ecthelion stepped forward to meet them. Then the metal affixed to the stones about the Door began to glow and then some of those great stones shattered, causing razor-sharp shards to rain down on all of them. Eönwë raised a hand and most of the damage was pushed aside, though Thorin thought he saw figures – more like shadows, really – about the chamber flinch back at the explosion. Were those more enemies, more minions of Morgoth's hiding in Thorin's mountain? Had he been so blind?

         Then there was no time to think as large shadows came winging down from above them, bats the size of which Thorin had never seen before, and more – they looked more like men with bat-like wings than the actual creatures Thorin had seen in many a cave. Their long fingers were tipped with thick, black claws that curved down to a needle's point. Then howls filled the air as after those blazing balrogs came a swarm of hairy creatures that Thorin thought at first were wolves or perhaps wargs. But when they stood on two feet, their long faces half that of a wolf's and half that of a man's, Thorin knew he was staring at the spirits Morgoth had corrupted during the First Age, brought to Erebor by some vile magic of Sauron to fight for their Master one last time.

         Thorin held his sword in a tight grip as those bats and wolf-men came rushing at them. Dwalin was at his side, with Gandalf and Galadriel fighting together, seeming to try to push through the rush and get to where Sauron stood on the jut of rock. Glorfindel and Ecthelion met the line of balrogs, their swords flashing in the crimson light given off by the great bodies.

         The battle was on.

         Thorin did not know how they could possibly survive this rush. Then more cries came from behind them and Thorin saw Lord Elrond throw himself in line with Glorfindel and Ecthelion, Maedhros a half step behind him, as the four of them fought with a might Thorin had only heard of in stories in his youth. More battle cries came from behind them as more men and dwarves and elves came to their aid. A great roar rang in Thorin's ear as Dáin cut down one of the wolf-men who was about to set his teeth into Thorin's arm.

         “Come now, cousin!” Dáin's voice was full of laughter despite the blood on his face. “Do not go down so easily!”

         “Dáin!” Thorin threw himself forward to protect his cousin's side from one of the great winged bats. “Mind your own defense and worry less of mine!”

         More laughter met his words as Dáin whirled into battle, the frenzy of their line coming over him. Thorin had never seen Dáin so consumed by it, before.

         “Uncle!”

         Thorin blinked away the sting in his eyes as his nephews appeared at his side, along with the rest of their Company. “Who is guarding the gates?” Thorin managed to grit out as they held their ground against wave after wave of strange bats and wolf-men.

         “More elves came out of the west!” Kíli called. The elf Tauriel was at his side. Beyond them Thorin caught sight of Thranduil and Bard fighting together. “They cut through the spiders and orcs to hold the gate!”

         “But the balrogs!”

         “Gone!” Fíli was the one to answer, his expression grim as he surged up to Thorin's side. “Though I think I can see where they have gone.”

         Indeed, Fíli was correct, for a greater glow was starting to appear in the chasm in front of them. Thorin felt his stomach sink as more of those great beasts began to haul themselves up and over the edge. They were smaller in form than the first few that had clawed their way out of the abyss. Thorin had no idea where they were coming from – there had never been a single hint of such horrors lurking in the depths of their mountain. Even the waters under Erebor had been icy cold. If such creatures of evil fire slumbered there then the waters should have been steaming and full of a wretched stink that would drive most of their kind away.

         As Thorin stood his ground against such evil creatures, he could not help but notice how the stones that still surrounded the Door were starting to glow. Most of them had been shattered by whatever power Sauron had used to bring forth Morgoth's other minions, but not all of them had been broken. Through ducking and swinging at the creatures trying to kill them all, Thorin could see Sauron standing before that great Door, the remnants of Saruman still flaking off of him, now more of an outline of a body than anything truly physical. Sauron still held the Silmarils in his fiery grip, but what caused an ache to go through Thorin's chest was the sight of the holy silk still in that evil spirit's clutches. Thorin wanted to rip it out of Sauron's hands, to hold it close to his own chest and protect what was left of their Bilbo from any taint by that vile creature.

         Thorin winced as a deep growling voice began to fill the chamber. From the way Gandalf and Eönwë stumbled and looked to Sauron, it was either the spirit doing something...or that was the voice of Morgoth coming through the Door. Thorin did not know which to hope for, or which to fear more. They were barely holding against Morgoth's minions as it were...what could they do against the Vala himself? How could they even compare? Thorin tried to shake off the growing despair, his sword dipping.

         Then, “Thorin!”

         The sound of Bilbo's voice broke through the fog that had been stealing into his mind. Thorin looked up and barely managed to parry the blow that would have taken off his head. He blinked clear his eyes to see many of his Company and their allies around him faltering as well, all of them with slack expressions, and some with tears on their cheeks.

         This had to be a power from either Sauron or Morgoth. Thorin drew in a breath and beat off the huge bat that was trying to scratch out his eyes. Then he tipped his head back and howled with every part of his body, “KHAZAD-DÛM!”

         By some chance – or perhaps something more – his roar seemed as loud as that growling voice that was filling the mountain. He saw it jolt through his Company and his cousin Dáin, and then Dáin's own people. Then, to his shock, he saw it hit the Men and even the elves, one after the other, their eyes clearing and the slack despair on their faces hardening to resolve.

         First Glorfindel, then Ecthelion, lifted their swords and a song came from them then, in their own language, that was faint at first, but grew as more voices joined them. Lord Elrond, Maedhros, Lady Galadriel, all of them joined in. Then Gandalf and Eönwë, and Thranduil too, all started to sing. Thorin did not know the words or the melody but he joined in too, words to the holy songs of their people rolling off his tongue. The Men too began to sing, Prince Thengel clashing his sword against his shield as his men all began their own chant. Lord Ecthelion II raised his own sword, the men of Gondor singing with him. It should have been a riotous cacophony. It should have grated on the ear, a harsh, discordant thing that made no sense. Instead each part seemed to fit together, its own part of a greater melody that began to wind about the mountain like a song chanted in rounds.

         The song seemed to incite Morgoth's minions. The bats screeched as they dove with more wild daring, their wicked claws outstretched for any target they could shred. The wolf-men howled but their own cries were drowned out by the singing of Thorin and their allies.

         A glow caught Thorin's eye at a pause between attackers. He saw how the intact stones about the Door were starting to glow, the metal still fused to them starting to gleam. Even the black rot that was on the surface of the stones seemed to fade with each word out of their mouths.

         “NO!” Sauron howled from his spot on the edge of the chasm. His left hand was glowing brighter and brighter as the song grew louder about the chamber. “Impossible!” He raised his hands higher, his body stretching in ways no physical body ever could. Then Sauron snarled something in a language Thorin did not know, loud enough that it caused their own song to falter as a thick, black aura began to surrounded Sauron. Within that aura were crackles of blue lightning, starting at his feet and then surrounding his entire elongated body.

         “No!” Thorin heard Gandalf shout. The wizard was on the edge of the chasm, the remnants of his staff held in both hands. He seemed heedless of the sharp fall right at his feet. “Sauron, stop!”

         “My Master!” Sauron screamed as their song faltered more. The bats and the wolf-men surged against them in response, fighting with a wild abandon that was heedless of their own survival. Their only desire seemed to be to kill as many as they could before they were slain in turn. Blood made the stone slick under Thorin's boots. He saw several fallen men and dwarves and even a few elves, though none Thorin could name by sight.

         The thick darkness about Sauron swelled. It looked...bloated, swollen, bulbous as it grew. It bubbled up about Sauron's feet, licking away at the bright crimson light of Sauron's form, even as the blue lightning seemed to almost try to fight against it. Thorin thought he saw more shadows above them, flitting about faster than Thorin could track. He thought they might be enemies but...Thorin shook off the painful thought, ducking a wild swing and slicing one of the stooping bats in half as it streaked past him. He did not want to think about Bilbo here in this awful melee, in this last stand before the Door of Night that was sure to open and kill them all.

         The thick black aura continued to grow about Sauron's blazing form. Ribbons of that aura, so dark that they seemed to swallow up the very light about them, began to wrap about Sauron. The blue lightning grew larger, as if it was fighting against those ribbons. Sauron himself did not seem to notice either happening. Where his head should have been was a crimson blob, like a pillar of fire come to life. It had the vague outline of a man but that was all. All the while he was intoning that same spell, over and over again, his hands with both the Silmarils and the holy silk with Bilbo's blood on it raised high.

         Something burned in Thorin then. Sauron should not be touching what was left of their Bilbo. That was for Thorin and Dwalin alone. It was something that had been given to them and to see it so fouled by Sauron's touch made Thorin want to rip that spirit apart with his bare hands.

         With that thought burning through him Thorin began to push his way forward through the rush of enemies. He did not have to look for Dwalin, for his partner was at his side. They exchanged a look and Thorin could see the same determination in Dwalin's eyes as well. They would get what was left of their Bilbo back from Sauron or die trying.

         As they fought their way forward they passed Lord Elrond and young Aragorn, the two of them fighting back to back against a ring of wolf-men. Thorin paused, thinking to help them, but then Lord Elrond threw off two of the wolf-men who had been pressing down on his sword with a great heave, and then raised his right hand. The ring on his finger blazed, the blue light cutting through the darkness like a beam of sun through the clearest sapphire Thorin had ever seen. It caused the wolf-men about them to fall back with a cry, their clawed hands covering their faces as their exposed skin began to smoke. The blood-sucking bats also veered away, screeching as they winged into the dark.

         Thorin shared a look with Dwalin and used that moment of confusion of their enemies to push forward. Together they hacked their way towards Sauron, towards the last bit of Bilbo they had, the only goal in their minds. They passed Maedhros spinning through a thick knot of wolf-men, his sword flashing as he struck down any who reached towards Elrond. At his side was Galadriel, a shining light of her own gleaming on her hand as she stood back to back with Maedhros, the two of them fighting as if they were of one mind.

         Thorin ducked a flying severed body part and glared at Thranduil, who had caused it. The elven king paid him no mind as he fought next to Bard, guarding the archer as the man's arrows hit each target with precision. Near them were Kíli and Tauriel, the two fighting back to back as Kíli took down the blood-sucking bats as Tauriel's sword cut through any wolf-men who got close.

         “For the Iron Hills!” Thorin saw Dáin lead a charge of his own people into a thick knot of wolf-men. At his side was Balin, along with Glóin and the Ur brothers, all of them bloodied and battered, but alive. Thorin could see Fíli fighting with Dori and Nori, with Ori in the center of them, his sling shot taking out the bats as they came close. Thorin could not see Óin in the rush of fighting but he thought he heard his old friend shouting about dirty claws and infections somewhere in the din.

         A flash out of the corner of his eye had Thorin turning to see Aragorn saving Lord Ecthelion II from one of the diving bats. The lord of Gondor gave the young Ranger a tight nod before they both moved to help Prince Thengel and his people with a heavy knot of wolf-men that were surrounding them.

         Thorin gave himself a shake and looked for Dwalin, finding his partner close at his side. They shared a look before they moved as one. Closer and closer they pushed, until Sauron was a mere handful of steps away. They were almost there. Almost.

         Thorin cursed as great spiders exploded out of the chasm in front of them. The growing glow and heat was enough to make his skin slick with sweat. He heard Dwalin hiss and then saw his partner go down to one knee as the horde of spiders seemed to grow in front of them. Thorin lunged to get in front of Dwalin, to meet that rush with the edge of his blade, when another being stepped to his side.

         “Master Erestor!” Thorin gasped out. The elf's face was covered in blood and he had bandages wrapped tight about his middle.

         “King Thorin,” the elf still managed to smile at him. “May I help?”

         Thorin did not have time to respond as even more spiders spewed forth from the chasm. The glow was getting bright enough that it illuminated most of the central chamber, enough that Thorin could see...he could see...

         His blade faltered as he spied hobbits standing on most of the bridges and steps that crisscrossed the central chasm, some brightly dressed while others were all in black, with thick veils over their faces. The hairs on the back of his neck stood on end. He heard Dwalin's gasp from behind him. Thorin reached back and felt Dwalin take his hand, standing with a staggering step as they stared up at the impossible sight above them.

         “It cannot be,” Thorin murmured, uncaring of the spiders that were swarming towards them, of the evil spirit still chanting, of even the Door of Night looming over them all. All of his attention was on the impossible sight of a people who had been wiped out, a people that were gone, standing like specters inside Erebor, helping him – them – one last time.

         And there, on the bridge closest to the Door of Night, was their Bilbo, outlined with a light that Thorin could not name.

         His Bilbo looked healthy and whole, a far cry from the battered vision they had been gifted at the tower near Ravenhill. His hair was a bright gold in the growing light, crowned with what looked like flowers and berries. Thorin thought even Bilbo's eyes were glowing, a bright blue the same shade as the lightning that was licking about Sauron's strange form. He was dressed differently than Thorin had seen him last. Gone were the tattered clothes Bilbo had worn on their adventure and in its place was a crisp white shirt, with a pair of suspenders that held up what looked like a...skirt? It was thick and brightly patterned in blues and greens, the angles looking, to Thorin's heart, like the same designs inside Erebor.

         The crash and roar of the melee about Thorin faded away to almost nothing. All he could do was stand there, hand in hand with Dwalin, staring up at their One. At Bilbo. And then...and then Bilbo turned to look at them and the smile on his face was bright and open, something Thorin had only seen a handful of times on their journey and it was directed right at them. Thorin thought he saw Bilbo say something but his words were lost in the rush and roar about them. The spiders spilling out of the chasm were growing in number. The glow that followed them was now accompanied by a howling that made Thorin's ears ache. Sauron's chanting had turned to screaming, the Silmarils in his hands burning so bright they looked like the hottest fires of the deep smithies, where the hardest of metals were forged. The Door of Night itself was glowing, the spells on the remaining intact stones shattering one by one the longer Sauron chanted.

         Still Thorin could do nothing but stand there and stare. Stand there and watch Bilbo watch them, a smile on his face that made something settle deep inside Thorin's chest. He knew, then, that no matter what happened, they would see Bilbo again. That their One would be with them, in whatever world they would pass to after the Darkness came.

         Then Bilbo looked away from them, back to Sauron, dragging Thorin's attention back to that evil spirit once more as well. Sauron's form was bleeding away at the edges, the fire of his spirit struggling with the dark ribbons that were wrapping about his body. Where Sauron's eyes should have been were two points of light that Thorin could not look at they were so bright. Sauron's screaming reached a fever pitch and there was nothing Thorin could do to stop that spirit from bringing his hands together, the Silmarils and the holy silk with Bilbo's blood igniting in a burst that made Thorin shut his eyes and turn his face away for one long moment.

         When he looked back all was silent. All was still. It felt, in that moment, like all the world was holding its breath. Then as one the last of the stones in the Door of Night shattered, raining down shrapnel around Thorin and Dwalin but not a single shard hitting them. The shimmering blue pool of light that had been covering the encircled Door grew brighter and brighter until that glimmering light winked out and all that was left was a void. A chill rushed over Thorin like a wind, causing him to shiver even in the growing heat by the glow that was making its way up the central chasm. He felt Dwalin squeeze his hand and could do nothing but hold on just as tight as that Door of Night opened at last.

 

Chapter 36: The Return of Light

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

         For one long moment, Thorin could not comprehend what he was seeing. The being that surged out of the Door was more in a way that made Thorin's head ache and his eyes want to cross. It was vaguely man-shaped, if on a scale that would make giants look small. As that being – as Morgoth – burst through the black void and into the heart of Erebor, it looked as though veils of darkness were being ripped off of him as he took physical form once more.

         Thorin had never seen any of the Valar before, though he had read much about what they were supposed to look like. He had not expected such a feared entity to look so familiar. As Morgoth stepped forward, somehow standing on the darkness pooled about the Door of Night, though Thorin did not know how, the longer he looked the more details Thorin could make out. The great enemy was...shrinking, strangely, until he was as tall as the Door of Night and no longer a towering spirit filling the central cavern of Erebor. As Morgoth's body continued to fill in, it became clothed in armor as dark as the void the spirit had just stepped out of.

         That black armor was all jagged edges and angles, to the point that Thorin had no idea how Morgoth managed to wear it. Thorin had made many a set of armor in his years as a traveling smith for their people and he had never seen the like as what was in front of him. Morgoth's face was as pale as a corpse, with thick scars about his forehead as if he had been branded. He also had scars down his gaunt cheeks, as if he had been raked by great claws. Morgoth's hair reached his shoulders, almost as black as the armor he wore, stringy and matted in places. He looked, to Thorin, less like a great spirit that should have filled him with fear and more like a wastrel Thorin had seen in many towns in Eriador, drunk by noon and belligerent when they were awake enough to move under their own power.

         Then Morgoth stood to his full height and the visage of a useless wastrel was gone. In its place was a vicious spirit whose power began to bleed into the space about him. His right hand flexed and out of the darkness surrounding him a great mace began to form, piece by piece until it fit to his hand.

         Movement from his left had Thorin glancing over to see Sauron's spirit, now almost completely bound by those thick, black ribbons, on his knees before Morgoth, bowed low enough that his forehead touched stone. “My Master,” Sauron's voice was a ruin of what it had been. “You have returned.”

         “Sauron,” Morgoth said. Thorin winced as the spirit's voice seemed to vibrate through his body, right down to his bones. “You have succeeded in the task I gave you at last.”

         “Master...”

         “I have tolerated your constant failures enough, worm.” Morgoth's hand lashed out and a wave of black power swept over the jut of rock where Sauron was bowed low. “I will pay my own dues with what is left of your spirit. Take him, Ungoliant, and consider my debt paid!”

         Sauron jerked up or at least attempted to. “Wha-” was all he managed to cry out before those black ribbons surged around him. “Master!” Sauron struggled against those strange bonds, the blue lightning crackling brighter and brighter about him but it was not enough to save him. Sauron was swallowed whole by that thick black aura, an echo of a whistling scream all that was left of him once he vanished from sight.

         “Now,” said Morgoth, turning his glittering gaze to the rest of the mountain. His mace came up in his hand. The wolf-men and blood-sucking bats had paused in their attacks, most of them kneeling before Morgoth. Even the balrogs had stopped their advance, their heads bowed before their Master. “My time has come!”

         “No,” came Eönwë's voice. Thorin looked over to see the herald of Manwë struggle forward, stopped by the fiery swords of the balrogs as they were crossed in front of him, halting Eönwë in place. Thorin could also not help the way he looked up to where he had seen Bilbo, to where he had seen all of the hobbits and felt his heart sink.

         They were gone.

         “Eönwë,” Morgoth's laughter rang out in the chamber. “Did you think you would be able to stop me now, little spirit? My time has come,” his growl made the stone under Thorin's boots shake. “There is no army now that can defeat me. It took you years and the host of the West to best me, before. You have none of that here, little spirit. Better for you to lay down your sword and kneel to me as your new Master than to face my wrath should you try and defy my rightful rule!”

         “I will never bow to you!” Eönwë shouted back at him. A bright glow surrounded him. His golden hair shown in the light. “This world is not yours, Morgoth! It never was!”

         “It always should have been mine!” Morgoth's roar made Thorin stagger back a step. Dwalin's hold on his hand kept him upright. “The very prophecies that once ruled the future of this world have been severed! My time has come! All that should have been mine has now come to me, as it always should have! Kneel or I will destroy you!”

         “I will never kneel to you!” Eönwë lifted his sword. It blazed with a bright blue light that made Thorin's heart lift for a reason he could not name. A wind stirred through the chamber, blowing a few strands of Thorin's hair into his eyes.

         “Then you shall meet your end under the might of my mace!” Morgoth thundered back. He raised his arm high. Thorin could not move, the pressure in the air so thick about him that it felt like he was frozen in place.

         The mace came whistling down.

         “No!” Maedhros' tall form stood before Morgoth, his sword above his head and braced with the flat of the blade against his palm to block that terrible blow. Eönwë had fallen back, his sword raised, but even he looked surprised at Maedhros' action.

         “Ah, the firstborn fool,” Morgoth's voice took on a mocking, crooning note. “So eager to betray a peace talk that you were blind to the trap I laid before you. How sweet your screams were. Are you so eager to return to your place at my feet?”

         “A fool I was then,” Maedhros grit out. Thorin could see blood start to trace over the elf's hands and then drip down his arms. Maedhros' head came up, his gaze never leaving Morgoth's face. “But a fool I am no more. I will never trust any word or deed of yours, Morgoth the defiler! I will never kneel to you, nor will anyone else in this world, for it is not yours to command!”

         “Fool,” Morgoth snarled and raised his mace once more.

         But before he could bring it down again another body threw itself next to Maedhros with a cry of, “Uncle!”

         Erestor tackled Maedhros to the ground, out of the way of that terrible blow. Maedhros stared at Erestor then, a frown on his face giving way to a startled surprise. “You – you are –”

         “That is for later!” Erestor yelped out as he pushed Maedhros aside as Morgoth's mace changed direction at the last moment, heading right for them.

         Thorin found his feet were no longer glued to the ground then. He sprang forward with Dwalin to help pull both Erestor and Maedhros away from that blow, feeling the entire mountain shake around them as the mace made contact with the ground. Great ships of granite flew past them and Thorin felt a sting on one of his cheeks.

         It seemed as though everyone and everything in the mountain went into motion once more. The wolf-men howled as they began to leap at the gathered elves, men, and dwarves. The blood-sucking bats began to stoop down on them once more. Morgoth himself drew himself up to his full, towering height, a cruel laugh booming out of him as he watched his minions throw themselves at the dwindling defense inside Erebor. And, worse, more balrogs began to crawl up out of the central chasm, one after the other, their whips snapping high over their heads as they prepared to charge Thorin and his allies' lines.

         Thorin could not see how they could possibly defeat them all.

         The balrogs' roars were louder than Morgoth's laughter as their great black and crimson forms flared bright for a long moment. Then they lowered their horned heads and looked as though they were about to charge like the bulls Thorin had seen in the settlements of men when the most curious thing happened. Just as the balrogs took a single step forward a great glowing blue net was thrown over them all.

         Immediately the balrogs began to scream. Thorin ducked a wild swipe from one of the wolf-men and cut the creature in half, turning away from the spray of blood to see the balrogs being pinned down by that glowing blue net.

         “Impossible!” Morgoth roared out over the din.

         Thorin looked to Gandalf, for surely it was the wizard who managed such a feat – or perhaps Eönwë, working together with Gandalf. But instead he found both Gandalf and Eönwë staring at the pinned balrogs in shock, with the Lady Galadriel at their side.

         Then more and more nets began to appear, sweeping up the bats from the air and pinning them to the ground, shrieking. Other nets were tossed over the wolf-men, wrestling them to the ground. Thorin came up short when he realized that it was no invisible hand doing the netting of these creatures, no. It was hobbits, all of them strange and shadowed and looking far wilder than Thorin had ever seen a hobbit before, working together as they used those strange nets to incapacitate Morgoth's minions.

         “Impossible!” Morgoth's roar was so loud it seemed to crackle in Thorin's ears. “What trick is this! Do you think these little bits of broken song can defeat me and mine! No! Rise, my spirits! Rise, thralls of my power! By the oaths you swore to me, by the words of Power I carved into your spirits, do as I command! RISE!”

         Then those spirits trapped by the spectral hobbits began to buck and strain against the nets holding them in place. The hobbits trying to hold them down were dragged to their knees, some to their stomachs, being knocked flat as they tried to hold down Morgoth's creatures. Thorin felt his breath catch at the sight.

         No. No, not again. He would not see the hobbits, Bilbo's people, be hurt again for him. For any of those still living. Not while Thorin still lived and breathed, he would not stand by and see this happen again.

         “To me! To me!” He did not know if his voice would be heard over the screams and shouts of Morgoth's thralls, or the way the very air itself seemed almost overfull of noise, some sort of static or – or just sound that Thorin could barely make out though it made his head dizzy – but somehow he saw others turn to look at him. Thorin did not wait to shout more orders. He moved, charging towards those snapping nets, his sword held high, Dwalin in step at his side. He could have sworn he heard his and Dwalin's name being called by an impossible voice but he set that ache aside. Thorin had one mission and he meant to complete it or die trying.

         The nets did not hurt to touch. Thorin was expecting them to burn or shock him but instead the threads felt...warm. Comforting. He tried not to linger on the thought as he brought down his sword, killing the minions trapped beneath him. He saw out of the corner of his eye Dwalin doing the same...and then Aragorn was there, along with Prince Thengel and Lord Ecthelion II and then Bard, and even Thranduil. More and more of those who had come into the heart of the mountain joined them, Dáin's wild laughter ringing out as Thorin's Company and the Iron Hills dwarves worked together to flatten net after net of trapped creatures.

         “Useless worms! If you cannot best these insects then I shall do it myself!”

         Morgoth's roar washed over Thorin but there was no time to look at that evil creature. Morgoth's minions had gone into a frenzy at his words, thrashing and biting and clawing at the nets without heed to the damage being done to themselves. It was all Thorin could do to keep those creatures from breaking free. There was no way to face both threats and besides, Thorin did not know how any of them could possibly face Morgoth in battle. Maedhros had barely been able to stop a single blow. How could any of them manage to stand against him?

         The answer came from an impossible place...but perhaps a place Thorin should have expected. For when the shrieks of Morgoth's minions rose to a peak, when their thrashing grew so wild Thorin was forced to fall back with Dwalin, he looked up to see that Morgoth had moved forward from the Door of Night but not far. For a Light had come, stopping that evil presence in his tracks.

         “You will go no further, Morgoth,” Bilbo Baggins said. He stood before that evil being, haloed in a Light that was shining from his right hand. For there Bilbo held the final Silmaril, held high over his head.

         Morgoth's laughter rang out, cruel and cold. Thorin had to drag his attention back to the minions still attempting to escape their nets, cutting down any who dared break free. He still heard Morgoth say, “What is this before me? A mongrel? A little weasel? Shall I show you, little ferret, what Powers such as I do to such little things like you?”

         There was nothing Thorin could do to protect Bilbo. There was no way for him to rush Morgoth, no way for Thorin to throw himself before that being and protect Bilbo from Morgoth's wrath. Thorin was forced to watch their Bilbo face that evil Power all by himself.

         “Then come, Morgoth!” Bilbo cried out, his hand still raised high. “Strike me down if you dare!”

         “No,” the word was ripped from Thorin's throat.

         Darkness wreathed Morgoth as he advanced on Bilbo. His mace was raised high. The very Door of Night looked like it was pulsing with a darkness that was edged in blue lightning. Thorin heard Dwalin cry out Bilbo's name as that great Power began to bring his weapon down. Thorin could not say a word, his throat dry and his eyes burning. He did not want to see this. He did not want to witness Bilbo's destruction when Thorin had already seen Bilbo die by Thorin's own hand once before. He wanted...he wanted...he wanted...

         From the darkness all around Morgoth more small shadowed figures appeared. All of them were dressed in black and all of them were veiled. And in their hands was a great golden net that they tossed as one...

         Right over Morgoth before he could bring his weapon down on Bilbo's lone form.

         Roars rang out from all over the chamber. Morgoth's shriek of fury shook the stone beneath them. The balrogs' flames grew brighter as they too roared, breaking free of their nets and rearing up to their full height as they turned to free their Master as one. The blood-sucking bats screeched as they wheeled around, tearing out of their own traps, turning on those small, shadowed figures. The wolf-men howled as they tore through the nets that bound them and began running on all fours towards those shades who were protecting Thorin and his people, his allies, the world itself, one last time.

         “No,” Thorin managed to croak. His throat felt tight and it felt hard to draw in a complete breath. “No!” He looked to Dwalin, who gave him a single nod. Then he looked left, then right, and raised his sword. “To me! To me!” His voice gained strength as he cried out. “Whatever you can do, protect the hobbits!”

         A ragged cheer went up at his words. Thorin charged then, hacking down every wolf-man he could as Dwalin did the same at his side. Soon Gandalf was there, then Maedhros, Galadriel, Aragorn, and more. But even then Thorin could see it would be too late. The hobbits had no weapons on them. They stood there, holding that great golden net over Morgoth as Bilbo stood alone before him, hand still raised with its shining Light, but only that. Bilbo held no sword, no weapon that could strike Morgoth down and defeat him.

         Morgoth reared up against that golden net, the threads straining and already snapping in places as he thrashed against its hold. “Little worms!” His mace swept out and a hole in the net appeared. “I will destroy you all! How dare you try to tie me down! Maggots! Vile filth! You are nothing compared to me!”

         “Maybe not,” Bilbo's voice rang out, clear and bright. “Perhaps one of us alone is no match to you, Morgoth the Enemy. But a hobbit is never alone, not now!” The Light in Bilbo's hand began to shine brighter, bringing tears to Thorin's eyes. “It is time!”

         That Light in Bilbo's hand seemed to stir Morgoth's minions into a frenzy like none other. Morgoth, too, howled as it shone brighter and brighter. Before Thorin could even cry out a denial, that darkness that had wreathed Sauron and was bubbling around the Door of Night itself began to spit out hordes of bulbous spiders, thicker and larger than those that had thrown themselves at Erebor's great gates. There was nothing Thorin could do to stop them from turning their dripping fangs onto the hobbits, nothing he could do to stop the balrogs already reaching for those veiled figures still struggling with that great golden net, still trying to hold Morgoth in place.

         Then, like fireworks against a moonless night, other hobbits appeared. But they were nothing like Thorin had ever seen before. For they wielded magic as their weapons, great arcs of blue and gold and crimson and emerald as they leaped out from the darkness, their light a lesser echo of the one in Bilbo's hand but powerful against the monsters that were attacking their own people. In one hobbit's hand lightning emerged, striking down a great spider before it could snatch him out of the air. From another hobbit's hand vines exploded from bare stone, wrapping up the wolf-men that ran towards it until the wriggling bundle soon went still. Thorin saw hobbit lasses come dancing out of the dark, each step creating a rainbow shower of sparks as they spun about the blood-sucking bats and threw them out of the air, one after the other. Thorin let out a shout when he saw hobbit youths throw themselves at the balrogs barehanded, a golden glow surrounding them as they laughed and tackled those fiery spirits to the floor. Arrows winged out of the dark, taking down the bats that were not corralled by the lasses. And above them all still stood Bilbo, his Light flaring bright in his right hand as Morgoth's shrieks rose and rose around them.

         Thorin threw all caution to the wind when Morgoth gave a violent jerk and the net holding him in place tore asunder. He dove forward, sword leading, intent to take a running start to leap into the dark to Bilbo's side. Dwalin was in step with him, axe and sword cutting down any of Morgoth's creatures that tried to get in their way. Bilbo still stood alone before that evil Power, not moving an inch. Thorin's heart was thundering in his throat as they got closer and closer, until the edge of the chasm was right before them.

         “DIE!” Morgoth's scream ripped through the mountain, his mace whistling through the air as he swung at Bilbo's still form.

         “No,” Bilbo's own voice thundered as loud as Morgoth's. Thorin felt his legs give out under him, spilling him to the stone with Dwalin at his side. The Light about Bilbo pulsed oddly, iridescent and crimson and cerulean in turns. Morgoth's mace stopped a body's length from Bilbo's head, held there by some other power that Morgoth seemed to strain against but could not best.

         “What madness is this! What trick! There is nothing stronger than me! Nothing!” Morgoth's screams grew frenzied as he tried to move his arm back, to swing his mace again but it did not budge.

         “I am not stronger than you,” Bilbo's voice rang out. The Light about him grew. “For the power that was to be yours in this world is now ours.”

         “Impossible!”

         Thorin's breath caught as Bilbo lifted his left hand. It was wreathed in darkness, but unlike the thick aura that had swallowed Sauron whole or the darkness that was bubbling about Morgoth, this darkness reminded Thorin more of a dark mine, ready to be explored. A darkness that was not cold or foul or rank, but a darkness that heralded change.

         “You were given the power of chance,” Bilbo spoke again, lifting his left hand as high as his right. “The power of potential, of growth, of possibility. A power that was almost as great as Eru Ilúvatar's yet you threw it away...for what? For this?” Bilbo's head tilted back to stare up at Morgoth. “You, who were once more beloved than all the other Ainur, could not see the gift that was given to you. And so you no longer have it.”

         “You speak of things you do not know little worm! I am Melkor! Greatest of the powers! Greater than even He who thought He could command us! I am greater than them all!”

         “You have lost it all, Morgoth,” Bilbo's tone gentled, even as he stood firm against that great Power. “It is time to go home.”

         “Never!”

         Another hobbit appeared next to Bilbo then. She was dressed all in black, though she had no veil over her face. Thorin heard a choked-off cry to his right and looked over to see Maedhros fall to his knees, staring up at the hobbit. The hobbit raised something gleaming and golden. Morgoth threw his head back with a snarl as that hobbit advanced on him.

         “Stop! What are you doing! Get away from me!”

         “As I said, Morgoth,” there was a new note of strain to Bilbo's voice as Morgoth began to struggle in earnest. “It is time to go home.”

         “I will never return to that place! You cannot make me! I have come through the Door of Night to take possession of what should have always been mine! Get away from me!”

         “Your actions have forfeited your right to be in this world,” the other hobbit's voice rang out. She lifted that golden gleaming thing – a needle, Thorin now realized – and reached for Morgoth. A shout left Maedhros as Morgoth tried to kick out at her but more hobbits materialized around him, all of them holding those same glowing golden needles. Blue lightning began to crackle around Morgoth's form, arcing from Bilbo to Morgoth and back again.

         “You little maggots were dead! Burnt out by my minion's fire! Sauron made it so! This is impossible! Impossible!” Morgoth raged as he tried to twist away from those hobbits, sending one flying and then vanishing into the dark. Thorin felt a shout leave his throat at the sight but when that hobbit vanished another took their place. More and more hobbits, all dressed in black and most of them veiled, came forward with those glowing needles and as Thorin watched they began to stitch at Morgoth, each pass creating a golden outline around that evil power.

         “You broke the Song,” Bilbo's voice was even more strained now. Thorin ached to go to him, to help him, but there was no way to get to Bilbo's side. Not now. Not with the spiders bubbling up and the balrogs roaring, trying to free themselves of the laughing hobbits who had wrestled them to the ground, or the way the wolf-men were trying to chew their way out of the vines holding them or the blood-sucking bats trying to fly back towards their Master. “Now it is up to us to fix it.”

         A surge of Light came from Bilbo's right hand. As if answering it, a second and then a third Light burst into being, where Sauron's form had been swallowed whole. The blue lightning ripped that darkness apart, spitting out not one but two forms, lying limp and motionless on the ground. And from one of those forms tumbled two shining gems.

         The Silmarils.

         And with the Silmarils came the holy silk that Thorin and Dwalin had guarded in their rooms for so many weeks. It lay next to those glowing gems and the blue lightning crackled over it, growing brighter and brighter as Morgoth's minions were whipped into a frenzy.

         Before Thorin could move towards that precious silk another was there. Master Erestor knelt next to all three, lifting the silk with careful hands as he scooped the gems into it, kneeling on the stone before the edge of the chasm, hands raised and completely still. Thorin heard someone shout, “Erestor!” and then the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion were there, standing on either side of the kneeling elf, their swords flashing and cutting down any of Morgoth's minions that tried to reach the gems in Erestor's hands.

         Hobbits appeared on either side of Erestor, the veils turning them faceless and strange in a way that made the hair on the back of Thorin's neck stand on end. The hobbits took that silk from Erestor, while one stayed and leaned forward, pressing what might have been a kiss to the elf's forehead. Then Thorin's attention was taken by a cry from above him. He looked up to see Bilbo brought down to his knees, blood starting to slide down his arms as a deep crimson aura began to surround Morgoth.

         “Fool,” Morgoth snarled and it rumbled like an earthshaker through the mountain. “Did you really think you could best me with my own power? That such little things like you could ever face me and win? I will grind you back to dust and salt the earth so that you and your kind will never rise again!”

         “We are not here to beat you,” Bilbo's voice was a thread of what it was, yet it still rang out through the mountain. “We are here to fix it.”

         “There is nothing to fix! This is the way things always should have been! It is my destiny!”

         “No,” Bilbo grit out. His arms were shaking, now. Thorin lurched to his feet, finding Dwalin at his side, both of them at the very edge of the chasm. There was no way to reach their One. Not now. “It was your destiny to be a part of the world, not the master of it. You were to be given the greatest gift of all! The power of choice and you squandered it! So now,” blood had turned Bilbo's arms red, “let it all be fixed once and for all!”

         As he spoke the hobbits that had been stitching at Morgoth's form all leapt away. That evil Power was outlined in the shining golden glow. The hobbits that had taken the other Silmarils appeared next to Bilbo, putting that bundle of silk and gems into Bilbo's right hand before they stepped back and faded away. Thorin watched as Bilbo curled his hands tight around all three gems, his head going back for a moment. Then Bilbo gave a great cry and seemed to heave Morgoth's mace up and away from him, knocking Morgoth back further into that glow.

         “Fool! I will destroy you now! I will – I will – no! NO!”

         The blue lightning that Thorin had seen cover Sauron and seemed to be connected to the holy silk with Bilbo's blood began to fill the whole mountain. It wreathed the Door of Night, growing thick and brighter as it circled that portal around and around, faster and faster. Morgoth was also being covered in it, starting at his feet and then crawling its way up his massive form. That blue lightning began to branch off of Morgoth, cracking up towards the far ceiling, to the walls, to the stairways and ramps that once crisscrossed that vast chasm. And, as Thorin watched that lightning, he saw that everywhere it touched the mountain was healed, the stairways forming and the ramps returning to one solid path of rock over the depths.

         Thorin saw Bilbo stand on shaking legs, his head held high as Morgoth struggled in vain against the golden stitches and that blue lightning that kept crawling higher and higher up Morgoth's pinned form. The mountain itself seemed to grow lighter and lighter, illuminated both by that blue lightning but also by some other Light that had no definite point of origin. It allowed Thorin to see how Morgoth's minions were being put down, one after the other, by their allies. Thorin saw how Maedhros ran to Erestor, the hobbit matron at his side, the two of them kneeling next to a now collapsed Erestor. Thorin had not seen him faint. Prince Thengel and Lord Ecthelion II were back to back as they commanded their troops as the men began to out number the minions inside the mountain. Thranduil and Bard were still cutting down the fat spiders that lingered, even as arrows from the dark took down their targets before either man or elf could hit them.

         Thorin squinted when that Light began to grow brighter, enough that it felt like a small sun was starting to form inside the mountain itself. That Light began to crawl over everything, illuminating the whole of the central cavern. It was then that Thorin saw the rank up on rank of hobbits lining the upper tiers, where Thorin's own people had yet to explore and restore the damage done to the mountain. Many of the hobbits were unlike any Thorin had ever seen before. Each of them were haloed in that Light as it swept over them, bringing their ghosts into stark relief. Where the Light touched Morgoth's minions they let out a shriek and then went still. Thorin did not know if they were even breathing. That Light grew and grew until Thorin had to look away, his face wet by tears that Light brought.

         Out of that Light something stepped through and into the mountain. Thorin found himself on his knees, breathless and his head ringing, his body shaking, as he stared up at something he could not comprehend. Big was all his mind could conjure up. The All and the Everything. He felt Dwalin take his hand, shaking as much as Thorin was, the two of them helpless before that Being.

         Melkor, my son, that Presence said. It is time to come home.

         Morgoth, held in place by that crawling blue lightning and those golden stitches, seemed to shimmer in place. For a moment he was as Thorin saw him, a giant being in rusted armor, and yet at the same time there was another form there, shapeless and dark, but full of sparks of different colored lights.

         “No,” Morgoth moaned, his form flickering between the two faster and faster. “No!”

         Ah, my son, that Presence sighed and for a moment Thorin thought he saw another Being, shaped much like Morgoth, tall and stern, yet with kind eyes that looked like Thorin's grandfather's when he was not in the depths of his gold-madness. So long you have struggled against your very nature. You struggled to see the great gift I once gave you. You misused it. You tarnished it, broke it, and it abandoned you. It is time to come home, my son. That Presence sighed again and one hand reached out and settled on top of Morgoth's head.

         Morgoth gave a great scream, loud and wailing, filling all of the mountain with a pulse of agony and pain and fear and desire and a thousand other emotions that hit Thorin in the chest with the power of an arrow drawn from a war-bow.

         I know, my son. I know. That Presence then moved forward, no longer in the shape that Thorin could comprehend, enveloping Morgoth like a cocoon. Let us go home. All will be well. Soon, you will see and understand, my son. All will be well.

         Morgoth's voice vanished with a whimper. His entire form blurred for a moment, the golden stitches growing brighter, even with that all-encompassing Light filling all of the mountain. Thorin blinked away more tears to keep his eyes open and watching as Morgoth's form began to wisp away, shattering like the fine crystal into a thousand different sparks of light. The Presence wrapped around Morgoth's form seemed to surge, sweeping up all those little lights and then they were spinning, sweeping away back through the Door of Night as that shimmering blue field seemed to part and show a void that made wind whip through the central cavern. Everywhere Morgoth's minions lay they dissolved into tiny sparks as well, being swept out into that void along with that Presence and Morgoth. Even Sauron, where he lay still and silent, shattered into crimson sparks and was swept away as well.

         Thorin stayed on his knees as all those bright sparks were drawn back through the Door of Night...and then the Door itself began to fold back into itself, bit by bit, stone by stone, metal-wrought spell by metal-wrought spell, until it winked out with a bright flash that left black spots in Thorin's sight.

         Then all was silent. All was still. And yet...and yet...Thorin swallowed hard as he stared at Bilbo, who stood on one of the repaired ramps, staring back at them. All of the hobbits were still there, not fading away as Thorin had expected, but still as statues as they stared back at all who were staring at them. Thorin struggled to his feet, Dwalin at his side. There was a ramp that would lead up to where Bilbo stood a handful of steps to his right. Thorin stumbled over to it and even then no one spoke. It felt like the whole world was holding its breath as Thorin and Dwalin started to run up that ramp until they were before Bilbo, alone in the center of the mountain with their One.

         “Bilbo,” Thorin said. He forced himself to keep his hands at his sides. He did not know how he could bear it if he reached out and found that his fingers went through Bilbo instead of touching him. “Bilbo,” he said again. He did not know what else to say.

         “Thorin,” Bilbo's smile was trembling. There was still blood dripping down his arms. Thorin could see a strange tangled darkness about his left hand. His right was empty, the gems gone. “Dwalin,” Bilbo's gaze flicked between them. “I...” He stopped and pressed his lips together, giving a small shake of his head. “I...”

         “I am so sorry,” Thorin said, the words bursting out of him. He saw Bilbo blink and then tears slid down his face. “I can never express how sorry I am for what – for what I did,” his voice broke on the words. “I...all we want is for you to be happy,” his voice broke again. He felt Dwalin take his hand once more. “To be at peace,” he ended on a whisper. “I love you.” It had to be said. He could not hold it in any longer. If this was his last chance to see Bilbo then he would speak the words that he had kept hidden in his heart for so long.

         “I love you,” Dwalin echoed. Thorin could feel his partner's hand trembling in his own. “I am so sorry for not protecting you.” It was Dwalin's voice that broke then. “I am sorry. I love you. We love you. We always have.”

         “Oh,” Bilbo's voice was little more than a whisper. He stared at them with wide, wide eyes. “Oh,” he repeated, softer. Then another trembling smile broke over his face, even as fresh tears wet his cheeks. “I love you both as well,” he said. The words settled inside of Thorin's heart, the ache to reach out and touch Bilbo building, but he refused to give in. He would receive only what Bilbo gave, no more, no less. “My silly dwarves,” Bilbo said then and a gasp left Thorin's throat when Bilbo threw himself at them.

         Thorin raised his arm, Dwalin with him, expecting...well. He wasn't sure what to expect. Perhaps an impression of Bilbo, perhaps a last, fleeting touch as Bilbo's arms came about their necks. Thorin did not expect to be tackled to the ground, the weight of a full-grown hobbit on top of himself and Dwalin, as Bilbo's tears wet their cheeks as he pressed his face to theirs. “B-Bilbo?”

         “Silly, silly dwarves,” Bilbo muttered from between them. His arms tightened around their necks. “I love you. I will always love you. And,” Thorin could barely breathe as he felt Bilbo's chest expand against his own. “I...ah. I am not dead. So. There's that.”

         “Bilbo!” Thorin got out before both he and Dwalin got their arms about the very real, the very warm, and the very alive hobbit that lay on top of them. Laughter came them, mixed with tears, as more voices began to ring out. Hobbits began appearing, hopping down from the high ledges and moving to help the injured. Thorin thought he saw the lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion sweep Erestor into their arms before Maedhros came to try and pry them apart. The elven lord was stopped, though, by the hobbit matron at his side, who just stared up at Maedhros with her hands on her hips.

         A cry from the mountain's entrance had them all turning, but it was to see Eönwë leading in a large group of shining beings, along with what looked like half a town's worth of elves.

         There was much more to be done, answers to be had, explanations given, and then...well. Whatever else came next after such revelations. Thorin did not care what happened next. All he cared about was Bilbo, tucked safe between himself and Dwalin, alive and whole at last, where Thorin vowed Bilbo would never, ever be hurt again.

         And, above them all a new day dawned, the light coming in through the great windows of the mountain, bathing them all in a golden glow.

 

Notes:

The next fic that is going to be completed is the wrath, the ruin, and the promise kept! I've made a few minor changes to the posted story just FYI and after the passing of mysteries has been completed wrath and ruin will take its place. Thank you all so very, very, very much!

Chapter 37: epilogue

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

 

          Bilbo looked down at his left hand as one of the threads across his wrist went warm and then cold. He bit back a sigh and set his book aside and stood, slipping into the in between as he followed the pull of the thread towards the entrance of Erebor. There he found one of his silly dwarves chasing another silly dwarf around the front lawn, roaring in anger. Bilbo stepped out of the in between and into the sunshine that soaked the balcony above the great gates and leaned his arms onto the wall to watch the chaos going on below.

          “Stand still you little –,” Dwalin's roar cut off as Dáin twisted out of the way of a particularly vicious strike with a cackle that would have done a Bracegirdle proud. Bilbo leaned his chin on a palm and smiled as Dwalin dropped his weapons and ended up just tackling a still-cackling Dáin to the ground.

          The soft sound of skirts sweeping across stone reached his ears just as a shadow passed over his face. He glanced to his left and then pushed up, standing straight so that he could bow low to the one who had joined him. “Lady Vairë.”

          “Bilbo Baggins,” she said, voice rich with amusement. A gentle hand touched his head. “Rise, please.”

          Bilbo rose to see the Lady smiling at him. She turned to lean against the balcony wall where Bilbo joined her. Together they looked out over the busy front lawn, full of tents and beings of all races of Arda coming and going.

          The caravans from the Blue Mountains would be arriving in the next few days. There were hobbit fixers inside Erebor still working to get the different living levels habitable for the influx of dwarves headed their way, though some of those artisans who had arrived from the Iron Hills were in tears about how such fixes were done. Bilbo had been told of the many, many shouting matches that had gone on in some of the guild halls. The mountain was still being repaired bit by bit, though, no matter how much shouting was done.

          The winter winds still whipped over the mountain but even then the cold was not the harsh, killing freezes of years past, but gentler in this new world that was being brought forth. There had been a snow storm the night before, leaving most of the upper reaches of Erebor covered in white, while the lower ranges had a mere dusting that had melted quickly in the morning sun.

          After Morgoth's removal from Arda and the Door of Night vanishing, many things had happened. Valinor had indeed returned to the world, bringing with it a host of elves from all prior Ages as the Halls of Mandos opened and those who had been healing there were released. Valinor's return to the world also brought much chaos and when Morgoth had broken through into Erebor, many of the spells that had been stretched to their limit had snapped at last. The resulting wave of destruction that reached Arda's far shores had wiped out many communities and caused unknown amounts of damage.

        Later boats in the shape of swans had come to the wrecked shores with the Teleri people vowing to help rebuild all the settlements on the coast...after Beleriand had been risen from the sea, along with the island of Númenor. After that more boats had come, full of elves from all Ages of the world, with King Finwë of the Noldor in the lead. His sons – all three of them – came in later boats, with Finarfin being the first to land.

          (Bilbo had heard a rumor that Finarfin had left a squabbling Fëanor and Fingolfin behind due their incessant arguing.)

          The resulting reunions had been a sight to see. Bilbo had been on this very same balcony with his dwarves when a rider had come pelting up to the gates on a shining white horse. The elf had black hair that was shot through with gold strands, with most of it braided back from his face. Maedhros, who had been on the balcony with them, had taken one look at the rider and let out a yelp that Bilbo thought only tweens in the Shire had made at the sight of their first crushes. Later he would learn that the elf who had come riding up was none other than Fingon, son of Fingolfin, and beloved of Maedhros long ago. The reunion between the two had been quite the sight, with Fingon climbing Maedhros like a tree and the two of them locked in a passionate embrace that made quite a number of eyebrows raise. As it was the two did not separate until Widow Minona had whacked Maedhros in the knee with a stick to get his attention.

        As for the hobbits in Erebor, they had all been embraced by Thorin's people as a whole. Bilbo was rather sure Nori was recruiting from some of the Bounders to fill in his ranks as his eyes and ears all over the mountain while the other trade heads of Erebor were slowly integrating hobbits into their own ranks. The Gardeners and Farmers had been given free reign over the outside of the mountain, with terraced gardens starting to go up as fast as they could be built. It would be months yet before the beds could be planted but that didn't seem to stop Bilbo's people in the least. The last Bilbo had heard was that a whole new artisan branch was being coordinated between the dwarves and the hobbits to help build more of these gardens out.

          (Bilbo had also heard that Dáin had come to speak to the head of the Gardeners for help with his own mountain. The Iron Hills seemingly relied much on trade with their neighbors and wanted a more secure food source that they could control. Bilbo had also heard that Fortinbras was thinking about sending a team of Gardeners to the Iron Hills after everything inside Erebor was figured out.)

          Anyways.

          Many of the men who had been in the battle inside Erebor had left to return to their own kingdoms. Gondor was in a state of turmoil since the men of Númenor had returned, along with the first kings of Gondor to Arda's far shores. No one was sure if the Stewards would continue to rule or if young Aragorn would take over the throne of Gondor, or if Elendil or even Isildur would take up the crown once more. Last Bilbo had heard young Aragorn was looking a bit wild about the eyes while Lord Elrond's daughter Arwen had arrived to launch herself into Aragorn's arms. What, exactly, would happen there was something that Bilbo looked forward to seeing what happened. Arwen was a delight and got on like a barn on fire with Lalia, which had been an unexpected bonus.

          As for his cousins, poor Fortinbras was in it up to his ears. As Thain for all of the hobbits in Arda his days were packed from sun up to sun down. If there were not squabbles breaking out in the kitchens with the Cooks then there was a slap fight between the Gardeners that needed to be mediated, and much, much more. Fortinbras was swamped and others in the Took and Brandybuck families had to step forward to help with some of the older tasks – along with Bilbo, who had been taken by the ear by Lalia and marched right back into the Great Smials when he had tried to make a break for it in the first week after everything had happened.

          As for the hobbits and Erebor, there were things changing there as well. Bilbo had worried that Thorin or the other dwarves would take affront at the thought of all the hobbits taking over part of the mountain. Quite the opposite had happened, instead. The hobbits had been embraced by Thorin and his entire council, formally ceding over the section of tunnels their homes had first appeared in. That entire section had once been part of a hall that was connected to the dwarves' holy rites and festivals. Even Thorin's holy people had not raised a single complaint at the gift of such an area and in turn Bilbo knew that Fortinbras had had a word with the widows to help Erebor's holy ones with the repairs to their own areas.

          As for the widows that had shown themselves to all of the hobbits on that longest night's eve, many of them had chosen to fade, as they called it, returning to shadow and memory. Not all of them, though, for the first of all the widows, Minona, had chosen to remain for the time being, if only to watch over Maedhros with the kind of gimlet eye that Bilbo had only seen in the most tenacious of grandmothers in the Shire, before.

          (Bilbo might – might – have heard that Minona had plans for Certain Others in the line of Finwë. Perhaps even Finwë, himself, though Minona would not admit to anything. Bilbo just hoped he got to see some of it, if from afar, to avoid the fall out that was sure to come from such an explosive meeting.)

          As the weeks wore on after Morgoth's return to the Timeless Halls many things had changed. Saruman's own physical form had returned out of the dark after whatever had swallowed Saruman's possessed body had separated the wizard from Sauron. As for the wizard himself he was still asleep and under Gandalf and Radagast's care, though the latter wizard did not seem terribly enthused by the situation. Gandalf would not leave Saruman, though, and Radagast would not leave Gandalf, so for the time being it was what it was. As for Saruman himself it seemed as though whatever trial the wizard had gone through in that darkness had been enough to wash himself clean of whatever darkness lingered in him. Bilbo was not so sure about that part himself but he considered it wizard business and let it be. They had ways of dealing with wizards now, so if Saruman decided to revert to any dark ways they could fix that, too. No word had been spoken about the missing blue wizards, though, so Bilbo was keeping a close eye on that as well.

          The Lady Galadriel had decided to stay in the area as more and more elves from Valinor were making their way to Erebor. Her own family was on the way and Bilbo had heard that Celeborn was coming to join his wife in the coming weeks. Thranduil had tried to steal Bard away from the chaos about the mountain but Bard himself would not leave, hammering out agreements with Thorin and his council about the rebuilding of Dale in the coming years.

          (Thranduil's sour face was payment enough for such deals Thorin had said while Bilbo had to just laugh at it all.)

          As for Bilbo and his dwarves...well. After Bilbo had tackled them to the ground – and after everyone else began to pick themselves up from where they had fallen – things had been awkward for a handful of moments until Nori had appeared out of nowhere to do some tackling himself.

          “Thank you,” the once-thief had breathed into Bilbo's hair before he was abandoned on the ground once more, blinking at Nori's receding back.

          Then Thorin and Dwalin had been there, helping him up and crowding close as if to warn off anyone else planning the same type of welcome back. To be fair Bofur had looked close to doing the same as Nori and Bombur had cried all over Bilbo when they had been reunited. Balin had given him a gentle head-butt, with the softest, “Welcome back, laddie,” Bilbo had ever heard. Bifur had patted him on the head. Ori had cried all over Bilbo as well, while Dori had picked them both up in a hug that had both Thorin and Dwalin huffing from behind them. Glóin had given Bilbo a harder head-butt, which had caused Dwalin to growl at him, but Glóin had just laughed long and loud at them both as he stepped away. Bilbo had almost been tackled by both Fíli and Kíli, but Thorin and Dwalin had caught them out of the air before they could reintroduce Bilbo's back to the hard stone ground. Óin had caught Bilbo by the shoulders and turned him this way and that, looking for wounds, tutting over the cuts on Bilbo's palms and slathering one of his ointments all over them before Óin would let him go. All in all his Company had all seemed truly happy at Bilbo's apparent not-death and had welcomed him back with open arms.

          There had been something that went on between Thorin, Dwalin, and Balin the second day after everything had shaken out. Bilbo was still not sure quite what it was but since Thorin and Dwalin had not been allowed to be alone with Bilbo since then, he had a sneaking suspicion just what that long 'meeting' had been about. Bilbo did not have the heart to tell Balin that he had taken one glance at these new chaperons – usually one of Thorin's councilors or another of Dwalin's King's Guard – and had to swallow the urge to laugh. Then he'd gone into the in between and stepped out inside Thorin and Dwalin's rooms after their formal good-nights before their chaperons, quite surprising his dwarves, and, well...

          Bilbo had quite won over his silly dwarves with the hobbit way of things, in the end. Not that they were going to tell Balin about that part, of course not. Things had to continue apace for dwarven sentiment and Bilbo was content to allow that to happen.

          “Erestor! Erestor! Look!”

          Bilbo glanced down to see Ecthelion holding up...something. Bilbo was not quite sure what it was but from the way Erestor's face went bright red and he charged Ecthelion and tackled him to the ground, it had to be embarrassing to some degree. Bilbo still not exactly understand just how that particular courting was going – if there was one, since Lord Elrond was in a strop over Glorfindel and Ecthelion doing something or other, Bilbo still had not heard the particulars for that piece of gossip just yet – but news had come that Lord Caranthir was on his way to Erebor post haste to see his son...with Erestor's mother, a lady by the name of Haleth. Bilbo had promised himself to get the story out of Maedhros at some point since when the elven lord had heard that bit of news he'd gone rather pale.

          Anyways.

          Bilbo had once heard about the Healing of Arda when he was young and it had seemed like such a fanciful concept then. Some grand event that would sweep over the world, transforming it with a snap of the fingers and life would be effortless and grand for ever and ever. The reality was rather different. There was no snap of the fingers that would fix the broken shorelines, though somehow no lives were lost in the chaos and destruction. Beleriand was no garden risen from the waters of the sea, nor was Númenor an island paradise that came with homes and castles and livestock. The bare rock and settling land still lurched from under the feet of those exploring the new lands, or so it was reported from the ravens that came to Erebor daily. Fortinbras had already sent out clans of hobbits who were willing – eager, really – to go out into those new lands and help fix them so that they would be habitable for all who would wish to live there.

          (The widows had also sent a party of their own to those lands, specifically to where Angband had been, so that their people would be the first to explore that place and fix whatever was needed there. Bilbo also knew that such a decision had not been run by the Thain and he had no intention of getting into the middle of that fight, should that information ever come to light, thank you and good morning.)

          The Being at Bilbo's side let out a soft breath as she leaned her elbows against the rock wall, staring out over the busy lands about Erebor's front gates. “You did well, Bilbo of the Baggins clan,” Lady Vairë said.

          “Thank you, my lady,” Bilbo said. He glanced at her from the corner of his eye. “You knew it would turn out like this, didn't you?”

          “Did I know it could happen? Yes.” Her smile was a small, secret thing. “But the skeins of time and life are ever changing. I exist to see all that was, is, and could be. It is not my place to direct it.”

          Bilbo turned to look at her fully, one eyebrow raised.

          Vairë tilted her head into a shallow nod. “Most of the time.” Her smile grew a touch as she glanced at him. She held a finger to her lips. “Yes?”

          Bilbo couldn't help but laugh then. “As my Lady says,” he said dipping his head in a brief bow to her. She laughed then, still a soft sound, but it chimed against the stones of the balcony where this all began. Bilbo felt his smile waver as he turned back to look out over the winter-gray lands about Erebor. It would be months yet before spring came and the hillsides turned green and lush, planted more and more by the Gardeners and the Farmers with each week that passed.

          “Be not so sad, Bilbo of the Baggins clan,” Vairë sighed as she turned back to the view as well. “The Song always had many endings,” she said, softer, just for his ears alone. It made the hairs on his arms and the back of his neck prickle. The threads still wrapped about his left hand tingled. “This is but one of them and not even the true end of it all at that.”

          Bilbo had to swallow several times to find his voice and speak the words that had been weighing on him. “And will I be there to see that final end?”

          A gentle hand was put on his arm. He glanced at the lady and then away. “Only if you should so choose,” Vairë said. “What path you take now is yours alone to walk. Well,” she said as Bilbo turned sharply to look at her. “Perhaps not yours alone to walk.” She smiled at him then, a truly bright expression and then was gone between one blink and the next.

          “Bilbo?”

          Bilbo turned to see Thorin and Dwalin step out of the shadows of Erebor and into the warm sunlight that spilled over the balcony. He couldn't help smiling at them. He couldn't help the way he held out his hands to them. Dwalin took his right hand, Thorin his left, and in that moment, even with their chaperons, even with the long list of things that still had to be fixed in the world, in that moment, with the two dwarves he had loved for so long, all was right in the world. The mysteries that had been swirling about them had finally passed. They had come out triumphant against the press of fate. The Healing of Arda had begun.

          “Come,” Bilbo said as he drew his dwarves close. “Let us go home.”

 

Notes:

I want to thank you all for coming with me on this journey!!!! Thank you all for the wonderful reviews, all the kudos, and all the well wishes. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Up next is the wrath, the ruin, and the promise kept. You can find me at https://www.tumblr.com/blog/jezebel-rising for updates on what I'm working on next, polls for which fic gets finished next, and updates on my writing. Thank you all again so very, very, very much!!!

Notes:

you can find me at https://www.tumblr.com/blog/jezebel-rising