Chapter Text
The day before Yule dawned cold and rimed with a thick frost that glittered on the ground. Thorin shared a quick breakfast with Dwalin and his privy council before heading out to the tents on his lawn. He was joined by Gandalf as Thorin made his way towards Ravenhill, intending to both stretch his legs and check on the ravens there. Dwalin's King's Guard was trailing him and Thorin had no doubt that at least one of Nori's boys was somewhere slinking through the rocks unseen. Thorin could feel the press of unseen eyes on him, now, at all times.
Each puff of breath created blooms of white clouds in front of his face. It was the coldest Thorin could remember it being and a part of him mourned for it, since surely the gardens on the hills would soon die under such conditions. But perhaps they would come back the next spring and he could walk among the greenery and think of –
No. Thorin could not think of Bilbo. Not today. Not when his dreams had been filled of dancing with Bilbo and Dwalin, the wild piping and drumming so different than his own people's music and yet familiar all the same. Bilbo had been smiling at them, taking their hands as he led them through rounds of dancers, some bare-faced, some veiled, all clapping and singing in a language Thorin could not understand. Not when in that dream Bilbo had drawn them close and whispered words Thorin could not remember upon waking, but they had made Thorin so happy that for a moment when he had woken he had reached out in their bed, expecting...
Well. It was a dream. And all dreams must end when the sleeper wakes.
Thorin rubbed at his face, trying to push away such sad thoughts.
“Troubling dreams, Thorin?”
The wizard's voice made Thorin sigh. “I dream of...of something that can never be,” he said. He refused to look at Gandalf. “That is all.”
He heard the wizard sigh and a long stream of smoke swept out in front of them. For a moment it almost formed hills and valleys, with small round doors set into the sketched-out land. Then the wind picked up, whistling over the ridgeline and the image was gone. “I dream as well,” Gandalf said as they walked on towards Ravenhill. “Of things that can no longer be.”
Thorin pressed his lips together and put one foot in front of the other as they approached the ravens. That early in the morning many of them were still in their roosts, fluffed up to keep warm, muttering to each other in low croaks that sounded far too strange for that particular morning. Thorin spotted the leader of the ravens, Roäc, perched on the ledge on the far side of the tower. There were not many of the ravens scattered inside, for the young that would travel far distances were still gone from the roost.
“Roäc,” Thorin said when he came close to the giant bird. The raven turned his head to peer at Thorin with one dark eye. The gray feathers were starting to outnumber the black but Roäc's eyes were as sharp as ever.
“King Thorin,” the raven croaked. His massive beak bent down and pecked at the stone by his feet, though at what exactly the raven was looking for Thorin did not know. He scattered some of the old cram that had been soaked in water before the raven and watched as Roäc pecked at that instead. “Come you have,” the raven said after he was finished with what he wanted. Thorin could see other ravens start to turn and stare at what was left.
“I have,” Thorin said, clasping his hands behind his back. At his side Gandalf stayed quiet and still as a statue. “What news of the world do you have for me today?”
“News was given to the little ones every night,” Roäc clacked his beak together, feathers fluffing up as a breeze slipped through the roost. “No more do I have to give.”
Thorin let out a breath at that, gaze going beyond the raven and to the vista beyond. The slopes leading up to Erebor's gates were still barren from the repeated dragonfire. The winter grays and browns dominated the landscape. In the distance Thorin could see the glimmer of Long Lake, though he could not make out the town that sat upon it.
“Do you have news of movement in the area?” Gandalf was the one to ask. Thorin slanted a look at the wizard but Gandalf did not look away from Roäc for a minute.
“Movement?” Roäc pecked again at the stone near his feet. “There is much movement, all around. Men, elves, and dwarves and others as well. Some coming, some going. Much movement, yes.”
“Much movement?” Thorin frowned at that. “When? You did not report that.”
Roäc's dark eye studied Thorin for a long moment. “This news was given to one of the young ones with the knot upon his shoulder.” The raven let out a sudden loud caw and a series of grumbles that Thorin did not understand. “Two nights ago it was given.”
Thorin rocked back on his heels and looked up at Gandalf. The wizard looked as worried as Thorin felt. “We did not receive that news,” he told Roäc when he looked back at the raven.
That dark eye stared at Thorin without blinking. “Much movement,” Roäc repeated and clacked his beak together again, softly this time. That great head tilted, still watching Thorin. “Much like the battle before, such movement grows. Mirkwood is too full of shadows and my people cannot go near it, now. Fires have been seen in the mountains, sometimes torches, snaking through the land at night. Those who go near do not always come back. This was told to the young ones who came to us.”
Thorin curled his hands into fists. “That information was not passed on to us.” He looked up at Gandalf. “I must speak to Nori and the rest of my council. The other leaders must be told as well.” He looked back at Roäc. “You said there was movement of both men and elves. Near us?”
The raven bobbed his head in a nod. “Elves of Mirkwood are trying to contain the shadows. Some are already headed to the mountain to their king. Parties of men are also on the road, overtaking the caravans of dwarves from the Blue Mountains. Many are coming to your gates, King Thorin. You must prepare.”
Thorin let out a short breath at that. “We will,” he told the raven. Roäc let out a loud caw as he flapped his wings and then burst into flight, with several other large ravens trailing him. As soon as Roäc was gone a number of smaller ravens came in to peck at the remains of the cram left on the ledge.
Thorin let out another breath when he stepped back out into the early morning light. The sun was warming the sides of the mountain, the shadows short for the day before Yule. The snow line had come down further he noted, almost to the tops of the gates. His gaze drifted to the side, where the gardens had been found, and then forced himself to fall into step with Gandalf as they made their way back down towards the sprawling encampment of tents.
“This is troubling news,” Thorin said into the silence that had fallen between them.
“Very troubling.” Gandalf stroked his beard, his pipe gone, eyes on some far distant point.
“I do not think Nori would keep this news from anyone,” Thorin frowned at the sight of the mountain. His steps slowed to a stop. Gandalf halted with him. “In fact Nori has said that the ravens have had no news for us at all the last few days. That when his boys came to talk to them...wait.” Thorin twisted around to look back at where the ravens were roosted. “Roäc said the news was given to the young one with the knot on his shoulder.”
“Yes?”
Thorin shook his head. “Nori does not use that sigil for his lads.” He looked up at Gandalf. “The last Spymaster of Erebor did.”
Gandalf's bushy brows had come together in a fierce scowl. “You are certain?”
“Completely.”
“Then this must be addressed as soon as possible.”
“But...” Thorin did not move as he looked back at the mountain. “It could not be Dáin's people...unless we have missed some when we gathered all who had collapsed. And if it is not Dáin's people, nor Nori's...then do I have a traitor in my own mountain?”
“Do not be hasty in making such conclusions,” Gandalf shook his head. “We do not know enough to start guessing who this figure could be.”
Thorin scowled at that. “If it is a dwarf, then I must know who it is.”
“If it is a dwarf,” Gandalf said.
Thorin stared at him. “What?”
Gandalf looked away, his face in profile against the gray winter sky. “I am worried,” the wizard said as he stared at the mountain...or at the encampment that lay before it. “Things are unsettled. There is growing mistrust between all the parties and it is getting worse with each passing day.”
Thorin swallowed at that. “Could it be Morgoth's shadow?”
Gandalf paused for a long moment before he gave a slow nod. “Perhaps,” he said. His gaze was still distant, though there seemed to be a faint glow to his eyes that Thorin had never seen before. “Morgoth would do much to hinder all those who would rise up against him. But...” Gandalf tilted his head slightly. “There is another shadow that would try to do far more.”
“Sauron,” Thorin said. As he said the name the wind died down and all was silent about them. Thorin felt his skin start to prickle. The King's Guard, who had held back at the start of the trail at Thorin's command, looked over to them, frowns on their faces. Perhaps they felt it too.
“Perhaps,” Gandalf murmured, bowing his head. “I feel that things are starting to move faster and faster. The bonds holding Aman from the world are snapping. I can feel it in my bones now. And when Aman and Arda come back together...”
“You think the Door will be opened.” Thorin swallowed at that.
“That and more,” Gandalf said as he raised his head. “But that is not something we two alone can discuss and decide over.” The wizard gave himself a shake. “Come, we should return to the camp and inform the others of this news. And I believe your Spymaster should be alerted as soon as possible.”
“Yes,” Thorin agreed and signaled for one of the King's Guard to join them. A quiet word to him had that guard running for the gates, leaving his fellow guard staring at his back in shock. The second guard joined them as Thorin began to lead them all back towards the encampment, his thoughts spinning in his head.
“How warm is everyone staying?” Thorin asked more to hear someone speak than to know the facts and figures of what this prolonged visit by so many peoples of Arda were doing to his fuel stores that were supposed to get his own people through the roughest parts of winter.
“Everyone is warm enough, though to hear Saruman speak, you would think his tent was located in the depths of the Helcaraxë instead of snuggled between several other tents and full of warming basins that make it feel like a spring day.” Gandalf seemed to rouse himself from his own troubling thoughts. His shoulders went back as his head came up.
Thorin managed to keep his expression from twisting with displeasure. Saruman's – and the blue wizards' – insistence on several of the warming braziers had been a pain to secure and supply. They had finally unearthed a cache of them in one of the halls that had been miraculously repaired during the night. More and more of the mountain was, for want of a better term, waking up each time they went to sleep. Hallways were repaired. Rubble vanished. The great pillars that held up the front of the mountain, that they had wound the ugly metal about to keep them stable, no longer had a single crack in them. It was as if the damage Smaug had done to their mountain never was.
“I am not sure how much more clean-burning coal we can supply him,” Thorin told Gandalf as they began their descent into the maze of tents. “Our supply was already low,” he lowered his voice as he slowed their steps. “There are three caravans of the old and other families coming over the mountains soon enough. They will need warmth more than a wizard who I am relatively sure can summon his own fire to warm himself. And with what the ravens have reported...we may need all the fuel we can ration to keep those who cannot fight safe inside Erebor.”
Gandalf's laugh puffed out large white clouds in front of them. “You've got me there,” he said, patting at his chest. “Saruman can make due with a few less warming braziers in the coming days, I am sure. One of us can persuade him.” His amused expression slid away. “It shows your character, Thorin, that you would worry about those who cannot fight, that you would shelter them inside your mountain even now, when your own people are short of supplies, in the face of this danger. Your father would be proud of you.”
Thorin looked away at that. He did not want to think about what his father would have thought of his rule, of Thorin's own brief stint with the gold-madness, of what Thorin had done with his – with –
“Thorin,” Gandalf stopped them with a gentle hand on Thorin's shoulder. “You are a good king. A good soul. Bilbo has forgiven you. Now you must learn to forgive yourself.”
Thorin closed his eyes against that. “I do not know if I ever can.”
The hand on his shoulder tightened, just a bit, before it lifted. “Then you would make Bilbo sad.”
Thorin's eyes flew open at that. He glared up at the wizard. “That is underhanded.”
“And yet something a hobbit would do,” Gandalf smiled down at him, though there were shadows of grief in his eyes that Thorin thought might have matched his own.
Thorin grumbled under his breath as he began to stomp his way towards the main line of tents. “Make sure Saruman understands the severity of our stores,” he said to change the subject.
“Myself and Radagast will do what we can to persuade him and the others.”
Thorin pursed his lips, not liking that Saruman would need to be persuaded to allow the old and the children to be warm but he decided that he had pushed the issue enough. Gandalf could handle his wizard Order and if worse came to worst then perhaps Thorin could appeal to Eönwë's own good sense to knock Saruman into being a marginally better creature.
Then again, perhaps it was the lack of tea making Thorin grumpier than usual. Surely it was that. Of course it was.
“I am not sure what the men or elves do for Yule,” Thorin said as they came to a stop by the first line of tents. There was a bit of a crowd forming in front of one of them. They were full of Thranduil's people and the tents furthest away from Erebor's main gates. “There are rites that my people deem sacred that must be done at the correct times but I do not think our holy ones would allow any others into them. Only...” He looked away. There were no more hobbits in Arda and therefore no way to include them. “Do you,” Thorin had to stop and clear his throat. “Is there anything that we should...do? For them?” He was sure Gandalf knew who he meant.
The wizard was silent for a long moment. They stood together in the warming sun as more and more bodies began to move about the tents before them. Thorin had no idea what was going on with Thranduil's people but it looked as though some of Bard's people were mingling with them as well. Wonderful. “I had only ever been to celebrations in the summer,” Gandalf finally said. Thorin chanced a look at him and saw a sad smile on the wizard's face. “Once I would come almost every year to let off fireworks on Midsummer. They had always enjoyed color and good cheer, good food and plenty of it, and flowers. Ah, the flowers, Thorin,” Gandalf sighed, one hand coming up to rest over his heart. “At Midsummer there would be a riot of color all across the Shire. More flowers than I can...name.”
Thorin looked up at Gandalf, noticing the fading smile on his face. “What is it? What is wrong?”
“Nothing...wrong,” Gandalf shook his head, brows coming together as his eyes tracked something only he could see. “Just...I had never paid it much mind, then,” his head cocked to one side. “All the flowers. How warm and beautiful it was. How...familiar.” His lips pursed.
It was Thorin's turn to frown. “I do not understand.”
“I'm sure it is nothing,” but the frown that remained on Gandalf's face belied that. “It is just –”
“Gandalf? King Thorin. There you are.”
Thorin turned to see the young Ranger Aragorn striding up to them. “Aragorn,” he greeted the young man with a bow. Behind the young man were several other Rangers, all older and far rougher looking. “Is everything well?”
“No,” Aragorn's expression was almost grim as he looked between them. “Might we speak somewhere more private?” He nodded back towards the path that Thorin and Gandalf had just come down.
Thorin exchanged a look with Gandalf but they allowed the young man to lead them up the ridge at some distance, perhaps even far enough that Thranduil's keen ears could not listen in. Though with the crowd starting to form about Thranduil's tent, Thorin thought the nosy elven king would not have been able to hear them over the growing noise.
“Aragorn,” Gandalf said when they were alone at the top of the ridge, voice grave. “What is the matter?”
Aragorn looked down at the field of tents, his face in sharp profile. This way Thorin could see just how young the lad was, perhaps not even twenty, but there was a sad kind of wisdom that shaded his eyes dark. “There has been several...confrontations between several groups of men in the encampment,” he said as he turned back to them. “My people have kept themselves out of it and have tried to separate those we could, but it is starting to spiral out of control.”
Thorin felt a bolt of ice shoot down his spine at that. “Fighting? But why?”
“That's just it. There does not seem to be a spark that ignites it,” Aragorn shook his head. Long strands had slipped free from the tie at the base of his skull, casting dark hair over his cheeks as the wind picked up and whistled past them. “The latest was between some of the guards of Lord Ecthelion II and Prince Thengel's men.”
“But they are allies,” Thorin frowned at that. He glanced out over the sea of tents, picking out the flags that marked the two leader's areas. “Or at least gave the impression of being so.”
“They are allies, for the most part,” Aragorn's mouth was pressed into a thin line. “Which is why it was so surprising. But even Lord Ecthelion II and Prince Thengel are becoming...estranged from each other.”
Thorin didn't like the sound of that at all. “Why?” He could see pockets of men milling about their separate areas but all seemed calm at the moment. “When did these happen?”
“Last night,” Aragorn said. “After the last meal. Perhaps there was ale involved, but...” Aragorn shook his head. “They did not fight as though they were intoxicated. More like...”
“More like what?”
Dark eyes pinned Thorin in place. “More like they had been instigated to ire, to anger, to bitter words and sore feelings.”
Thorin curled his hands into fists. “As if a shadow had provoked them?”
Aragorn nodded, slow and solemn. “Exactly like that.”
Thorin let out a slow breath. “There is more news that needs to be told to everyone gathered,” he said. “Gandalf and I have just now realized that the news from our ravens has not been reaching myself or my council. Someone – perhaps a dwarf, or perhaps something...other,” he cut a look at Gandalf. “Has been reaching the ravens first and taking that news. Although...” Something occurred to Thorin then and he looked back up at Gandalf. “If Nori sent out other runners, then why did the ravens not repeat their news? Why did all of Nori's lads say that there was no news at all?”
Gandalf's expression grew grave. “Then either the ravens or Nori's boys have been made to forget what they either said or heard.”
“Is that even possible?”
Gandalf nodded, slow and thoughtful. “It is,” he said. “Though it would take a great deal of power to do so.”
“What kind of power?” Thorin shifted on his feet.
Gandalf did not answer for a long moment, those dark eyes studying him, though Thorin could not say just what the wizard's expression meant. “The kind of power seen only in the oldest of the elves, those who had been born and nurtured in Valinor when the light of the Two Trees still shown...or by a Maiar.”
Thorin opened his mouth, closed it, looked at Aragorn who had gone as pale as Thorin felt, and then said, “Then either the Lady Galadriel, Lord Glorfindel, Lord Maedhros, Lord Ecthelion, or...” He stopped and swallowed. “Lord Eönwë and the others like yourself could have done this.”
“Indeed,” Gandalf said.
“But...” Thorin shook his head. “Why would they do such a thing? Unless...” He rocked back on his heels. “Unless they were agents of Morgoth.”
“Yes.”
Thorin looked back over the sea of tents that were spread over his front lawn. “It would explain the shadow we have all seen move through the camp.”
“It would.”
Thorin drew in a long breath and let it out just as slow. “And if we go down and say such a thing, it would only ignite tempers further. Which would lead to more dissent and suspicion when we need unity the most.”
“Yes.”
Thorin ran a hand over his face, fighting back the urge to growl. “I need to speak to Nori. He can find his boys and perhaps we can see what they remember or what parts of their memories have been changed. Or made to forget.”
Gandalf leaned on his staff next to them. Aragorn had looked away, his face in profile against the winter sky. “That would be a start, yes.”
Thorin glowered at the wizard. “Then what else would you have me do?”
Gandalf stayed silent for a long, long moment. Then he sighed and his head bowed, the brim of his tall hat hiding his face until he looked up once more. “You are right,” the wizard said, surprising Thorin. “Speaking to Nori would be the best and most logical first step. We must know what has been said to your people before we start suspecting those among us.”
“I do not think Lord Eönwë could be behind any of this,” Aragorn was the one to say. “He is the herald of Manwë himself. There would be no way for such a spirit to hide any allegiance to Morgoth from the leader of the Valar.”
“I agree,” Gandalf said. “Lord Eönwë must be informed, as well as Galadriel. We have been in contact with each other since she arrived. I would know if her mind was touched by evil, and she I.”
“At the very least the news that Roäc gave me this morning must be given to all who are here,” Thorin said. “There is movement in the world, all of which seems to be coming here.”
“Movement?” Aragorn's dark gaze did not waver.
Thorin nodded at him. “Men and elves, plus what might be orcs and the spiders of Mirkwood.” Thorin glanced down at Thranduil's section of tents. The crowd there had grown, with the Woodland king himself standing among them now with Bard at his side. Thorin still had no idea what was going on down there.
“But there was just a large battle with such evil forces,” Aragorn's head came up, brows coming together. “There cannot be enough left in the world to form another army to march upon Erebor.”
“The ravens have seen what they have seen and I do not doubt them. That such information has been suppressed by either someone or some force we have not found adds credence to that outcome. Add in the fact that the Arkenstone, the Silmaril, has not yet been found...” Thorin shook his head. “I fear that more is moving in the world than we think.”
“This knowledge cannot be kept to just a few,” Aragorn said. “It would create more friction and divide than to allow whatever power or person among us to be kept in the dark. That shadow already knows of the movements headed this way. Everyone else must know as well.”
“I agree with you,” Thorin said. He looked to Gandalf then. “And you, old friend?”
Gandalf bowed his head at that. “We must tell them all,” he agreed. “Immediately.”
Before Thorin could say more he spotted a blur moving on the plains beyond the encampment. His attention drew Aragorn and Gandalf's, the both of them turning with sharp concern, watching as that blur became a rider on a pale horse, pulling up short just outside the ring of tents before throwing himself off and darting into the maze tents beyond.
“That is Haldir,” Gandalf was the one to say. “His brothers were the ones to accompany Galadriel here. It must be dire news for Celeborn to have Haldir leave his side.”
They started down from the ridge as one, with the wizard and Aragorn's long legs making Thorin almost trot to keep up. He did not ask for them to slow, eager himself to see just what kind of news would send such a rider galloping up so fast. A crowd was already gathering about the lady's tent when they arrived. Lord Ecthelion II stood apart from Prince Thengel for the first time since Thorin had seen the two together, both of them pale and with deep shadows under their eyes. Eönwë and Maedhros were just arriving as Thorin and the others came to a stop outside Galadriel's tent.
It was Lord Elrond's councilor, Master Erestor, who opened the tent flap. He was as pale as Thorin had ever seen him. The lords Glorfindel and Ecthelion, who were standing by Maedhros, started forward but stopped when Erestor spoke. “My lords,” the elf said, sweeping his gaze over the growing crowd. “You are needed.” Then he stepped aside and held up the tent flap for them to enter.
Thorin pushed down a shiver those words provoked. He looked towards the mountain, just for a second, and thought for a wild moment he saw someone standing on the balcony above the gates. Then he blinked and the figure was gone. Thorin pushed all thoughts and hopes of who that figure could have been to the back of his mind. He could not linger on hopeless dreams, not now. Then he drew in a breath and focused his gaze forward, on the problems he could clearly see, and what steps they would need to take to meet these dangers head on and without fear.
Thorin had made a silent promise to Bilbo when he had woken up from the gold-madness that had ruined his world. A promise that he would protect those who could no longer protect themselves, that he would do his best to fix all that he had broken and more. So with that thought Thorin faced the problem in front of him and let everything else go. It was a promise Thorin intended to keep, no matter what.
