Chapter Text
It was a fair while before their Company Burglar told them a tale again. What with the hobbit refusing to speak with any of them after Thorin discovered his secret. After that, they literally lost the time for such fanciful pastimes. They escaped Rivendell, climbed the Misty Mountains, they encountered stone giants of old. Then the goblins caught them and before long, they were prisoners and it was only after the wizard had rescued them that they had realised their burglar was missing.
Thorin was ashamed to admit that he wrongfully accused the burglar of abandoning them.
It was a relief when he was proven wrong. But there was no time for making amends - just yet - for soon after, they were chased by Azog and his warg-riders. It was by their luck that eagles had saved them after Thorin was felled and here they were now, making camp near a river in hopes of resting for a short while before they continue on with their quest.
Thorin let out a soft breath and allowed his sister-sons to nestle in closer to him. After he was brought back from the brink of death, he found himself incapable of begrudging his nephews’ touch on his person. Fíli who was oft content to follow his commands was deathly silent and it was only when he embraced the boy that his fair-haired nephew broke down sobbing. Kíli on the other hand shouted at him for a quarter of an hour before embracing him tightly.
He will not forbid them from assuring themselves that he lives still.
It was midday when his sister-sons had decided to pester their burglar for more tales but the hobbit only raised a brow at them and returned to his attempts at repairing his coat. (Though it was more of a rag than a coat at this point, but perhaps Thorin could speak to Dori about some repairs later.)
“And what story would you ask of me?” The burglar sighed, setting down his coat. Thorin chuckled when he caught sight of his sister-sons exchanging quick words.
“Well,” Fíli paused awhile before grinning, “You already shared to us a story of historical value and a love story, I was curious if you knew any ghost stories?”
Thorin grew aware of Kíli snickering behind his brother and he raised a brow. Clearly, they were not expecting the hobbit to know anything of such tales. But he caught their burglar’s eyes and took note of a mischievous glint in them. He smirked, it appears their burglar had an idea and this he looked forward to hearing a great deal.
“Well, lad, I’m afraid this is another personal tale for you but this does have a ghost involved to some very small extent.” Thorin raised his brows at Bilbo’s words and he chuckled.
“It appears you have a fondness for such tales.” Thorin found himself commenting on the Hobbit’s tendency to tell tales from his own experiences. “You seem to have experienced many things to be counted as a faerie story.”
Their burglar could only look at him with a small smile before shrugging.
Bilbo gestured for Fíli and Kíli to come closer before he finally took notice of Ori looking longingly at their little group. Thorin only smiled and gestured for the young scribe to join his sister-sons before turning his attention solely on their burglar.
Their Hobbit cleared his throat and looked at them all with a glint in his eyes. “Have any of you encountered cursed items?”
With wide eyes, Fíli and Kíli shook their heads.
Thorin furrowed his brows.
Ori proceeded to take his journal out.
“Have you?” Thorin knew the answer already but still he asked. Bilbo smiled and it was a smile that seemed to tell him all he needed to know.
“A painting.” An ice-cold chill settled at his spine and he nodded for the Hobbit to continue.
From a stranger’s point of view, Thorin felt that Bilbo would have appeared as if he were relaxed but he saw the slight tensing of his muscles before immediately easing his posturing. He noticed the slight tremble in his fingers as the Hobbit straightened his waistcoat.
He did not know how to feel about this tale but he felt it would be something he would not forget.
“I do believe it was one of my cousins’ birthdays when I received it.” It was such an offhand thing to say that Thorin felt his brows rise.
“An unfortunate day to receive an unfortunate thing.”He muttered, Bilbo only smiled.
“I don’t think Filibert would have wanted such a dark thing to be given to me.” Their Hobbit told him soothingly. Yet Thorin did not feel appeased. “He just gave it to me as a mathom. Something to decorate Bag End with and I accepted it.”
“Surely there would be an indicator?” Kíli asked this with his commonly easy grin, though Thorin looked at his sister-son and noticed there was a flash of wariness. “At least a small sign to show it’s cursed?”
He understood why there was a wariness to his youngest nephew.
Bilbo only shook his head.
“The painting had so many things going on in the foreground that you are drawn to it more than what is happening behind.” The Hobbit explained carefully, “You see, it was such a charming little piece. It was a festival - a fiesta if you will - with hobbitlads and hobbitlasses dancing on benches and climbing oiled bamboos. There were bright colours nearly everywhere; even the musicians were colourfully painted.” A flash of a smile appeared on their Hobbit’s face.
“I could almost believe I was there for I distantly remember a harvest festival like that taking place-” It was as if saying it out loud gave Bilbo a revelation and Thorin felt a flash of concern in him when he saw the Hobbit grow pale.
“Bilbo?” Ori was the first one to stand but their Hobbit could only shake his head.
“It’s nothing.” It was as if their Hobbit magically recovered from whatever it was that shook his soul. But once more, Thorin did not question it.
“The painting was given to me by a cousin, Filibert, he said it was a wedding gift from Celandine and CornusGreenhand’s wedding. I was just past my majority that time and was wanting something to distract myself from being alone in my parents’ home and I decided to accept it for want of a new item to disrupt the memories in every furniture present in that smial.
I supposed that that is what loneliness can do to a person. It would make them yearn for the loss of their own memories to escape your grief.” Smiling more to himself than to anyone else, Bilbo continued, “So I stayed long after the wedding before I stumbled back into the smial with my gift and without laying eyes on it and without bothering to think, I took down my parents’ portraits and hung the painting there.”
Thorin looked dumbfoundedly at their Hobbit, unable to process what he had done. Who in their right mind would take down the memories of their parents? Who would willingly remove any signs that they had even lived and given you being? He did not understand this and yet he found himself almost sympathetic to their burglar’s emotional plight.
“Were your parents recently passed then?” He felt it might have been intrusive to ask but what other reason was there for their Hobbit to do such a thing? He seemed to treasure his parents’ memories a great deal as of late with the fuss he kicked up in his hobbithole if his sister-sons were to be believed.
The response he received was a mild nod. Then, a self-deprecating smile, “Rather pitiful, don’t you think?”
Thorin wanted to say no. To assure Bilbo that grief had a fierce hold on everyone and everyone had their ways of dealing with it. Granted, it was not the way of the dwarrow to forget their family, but it could perhaps be the way of grief to force Men and Hobbits alike to act in that way. Yet despite his desire to comfort Bilbo, he was unable to. Bilbo only smiled at him before resuming his tale.
“It didn’t take too long to make me sleep.” Bilbo mumbled, chuckling slightly, “I was rather drunk, you see and all it took was for my head to hit the pillow for me to finally fall unconscious.” Bilbo paused, and then the glint in Bilbo’s eyes returned.
“That was when the nightmare happened.” Thorin frowned. In the span of time they had spent, he was loathe to admit that he had quite forgotten Bilbo’s story.
“It was such a simple but vivid dream,” Bilbo started, his brows knitting together in concentration as he struggled to recall his dream. “I was present in that little party in the painting and I found nothing wrong with that. I did just receive that painting so of course I assumed it was out of fondness for the merry little piece that I had thought of dreaming it.” Bilbo paused and pursed his lips.
“I would and could have believed all those excuses I thought of if it wasn’t for the out of place fellow in the painting.” Thorin leaned forward in intrigue. What could be out of place in such a gathering?
“You see, in the gathering I was in, there was a Man.” Thorin raised his brows at their burglar. He felt like it had made no mention of Men there before but here it was now. “He was a sullen looking thing and he seemed to be wearing ill-fitting and tattered clothes. You would think that the others would have steered clear of him but no, they spoke to him and laughed with him. They seemed to be perfectly welcoming of him.”
Thorin shrugged, “It may have been that he looked to be an unlikable sort but that he had made the people fond of him through interacting with them.” He explained. Thorin would be the first to admit that he was always wary of anyone who would dare think of endearing themselves to him through currying favours but he had seen how Men are.
But the Hobbit only shook his head. “The fellow looked too much to be antisocial that I wonder why he was in the gathering in the first place.” Bilbo paused, his brows furrowing, “Now I remember it, I don’t think the fellow was even in the painting.” The Hobbit’s gaze met Thorin’s and Thorin felt something in him stop.
“At least…not at the first night.”
That was enough to seize Fíli, Kíli and Ori’s attentions all at once and even Thorin found himself wary at what their burglar might have meant by that.
Noticing his rapt audience, Bilbo smiled at them all. “Yes, a magically appearing man in the painting; how odd.” Odd. That was one way to put it all. Yet somehow that was not the most important part of the story. At least, not to Thorin and his companions.
“Did…did the man do anything in your dream?” Ori asked softly, eyes wide with a mixture of fear and awe.
Their Hobbit responded with a slight nod. “Yes. He was at first just standing around looking at the dancers and musicians. But after some time, he left the feast.” Bilbo pressed his lips together tightly before he continued, “After he had left, I decided to follow him. I followed him deep into the woods but every step made me dread what I might find.
I followed him until we reached a clearing and what I saw made my stomach turn.
In that clearing, you see, was a hobbitlass no older the three years past her majority. She was picking wildflowers and humming a Shire lullaby and the man stalked towards her as if she were his prey.” Thorin felt his blood chill at what their burglar had said.
Was it possible that the hobbitlass they were being told of was murdered by the man?
“The hobbitlass seemed unaware about the Man approaching her and even when she noticed his presence, she only gave him a disarming smile and asked him what he wanted. The man did not answer her and only proceeded to trace the flesh of her neck with his index finger.” Thorin did not fault Bilbo in shuddering the way he did.
Even Thorin grew uncomfortable at the Man’s gesture. It felt intrusive.
“Surely, the…hobbitlass would have learned that this Man was untrustworthy?” Bilbo looked at Ori before shaking his head.
“The hobbitlass only smiled with a bit of confusion on her face and asked the Man if he needed help with anything, the Man only silenced her by pressing his thumb on her lips.” Bilbo shook his head, “That was the first night, I woke up after that and I barely thought anything of it.”
“What happened on the second night?” It was Kíli that had asked this and Bilbo waved a hand as if to hint at something vaguely.
“The second night proceeded much like the first in that I dreamt of the gathering, followed the man and saw his actions towards the hobbitlass. But this time, I didn’t wake up straight away like the first night. No, I think waking up like the way I did the first night would have been a mercy.” Something darkened in Bilbo’s eyes and Thorin found it an unwelcome change.
“For I had stayed and I saw the Man bend down to the hobbitlass’s ear. His lips were moving but I cannot read his lips, I cannot even catch a single clue as to what it was he was saying. All I know was that it was enough to make the hobbitlass freeze. It was enough to make her grow frightened and to back away from the man.”
“But she was unable to?” Thorin asked. He was aware of his heart beating fast in concern for a hobbitlass that was most likely dead by now.
Bilbo shook his head. “I was hoping she was able to run away because I woke up before I could discover what happened.” Thorin could hear his nephews groan in frustration at what had happened. Bilbo smiled apologetically.
“Did this happen frequently?” Fíli asked, brows furrowed as he clapped a hand on Kíli’s mouth, muffling his brother’s complaints.
Bilbo nodded.
“For the duration of time it stayed in Bag End? Yes, it happened…” But then their hobbit paused and shook his head, “Actually, let me recant that.It happened for a specific length of time in Bag End but afterwards, I just had a constant feeling of dread when I was near it.”
Kíli frowned and pushed Fíli’s hand away from his mouth.
“Was the man in the painting by then?” Bilbo smiled.
“He was beginning to. When I woke up, I ran to the painting and what I saw made me assume that someone had broken into my smial to paint on it.” Bilbo snorted, it was undignified but Thorin still found himself smiling at that noise. “Well, you see the reason I’d thought that is because of the fact that there were the beginnings of a painting in the farthest part of the background. Right behind a couple leaping onto a bench, was the man in my dream.Or at least…what will be the man in my dream.”
“Like…a sketch?” Ori asked, his brows knitted together in confusion.
Bilbo only shook his head in response.
“No, it was more like someone had decided to immediately begin painting the man without that kind of planning.” Breathing in softly, Bilbo continued, “After this, the dream began a pattern. Every night, I would dream the start and it would continue on a little bit more than where I left it the night before. And every morning, I would see the painting of the man in the background grow more and more clear and defined with every detail that was added to it.”
Thorin frowned, the fact that their burglar was avoiding the details made him curious as to what exactly happened. From the look on Bilbo’s face, he knew that something horrible happened to the hobbitlass but still he pushed on.
“Is it possible that you tell us what happened to the hobbitlass?” He heard his voice asking before he was even aware of thinking it. Bilbo looked at him and gave a slight nod.
“The third night showed me how the Man stalked towards her as she had done what she can to back away from him. How he looked to be a deranged madman as he reached out a hand to wrap around her throat. But I woke up just when her mouth opened to scream.” Bilbo’s jaw clenched and the darkness in their burglar’s eyes grew even moreso.
“The next night, the dream played out as usual and this time I heard her scream. But no one heard it. She was so deep into the woods with the Man that no one could have heard it.” Their Hobbit shuddered a bit before he met Thorin’s gaze, “She didn’t die through the strangulation, though.”
Thorin swallowed thickly when Bilbo said that.
“I only had time enough to see him reach for a sharp stone but after that, I woke again.” Had this been any story, Thorin would have complained of the constant stopping and going of the tale. But he found himself enraptured by Bilbo’s voice along with anxious to hear the end of this tale. This…sequence of dreams.
“Following night, I became witness to how he bashed the poor girl’s head in with that sharp rock. How the rock made an indentation into her skull and how it later on was embedded into her head, her screams dying out with her life.” Bilbo looked pale when he said this but Thorin could only watch and listen. He did not know the best way to comfort their burglar.
He knew what to do when his sister-sons were hurting or when his sister grew grim with reminders of what they lost. He knew what to do when Balin calls him late into the night to help Dwalin through his night terrors. But he did not know Bilbo for as long as any of them. He only knew that Bilbo was used to the comforts of home.
“Was that the end of your dreams, Bilbo?” Kíli asked, his eyes wide with horror at the description of the hobbitlass’s murder.
Bilbo’s expression was enough of an answer for him.
“If it was then I would have slept better somehow.” Bilbo muttered, looking at Kíli with an expression Thorin found himself unable to read. “But the dream continued on from where her murder left of.”
“What did you see?” Fíli looked wary, but also curious. It was something about his eldest sister-son that made him smile. How Fíli would still try to find what he wants to find despite feeling frightened or overwhelmed.
Bilbo was quiet for a few moments before he answered, “I saw how her body was disposed of.” He whispered, “It was tied to heavy stones by the Man and she was dropped into a river in that part of the woods. He tore off his shirt to get rid of the bloodstains that made its way to the fabric and left the woods. He…did not return to the Shire after that.”
There was a long pause before Bilbo looked at Fíli, “That dream took three days to finish.”
Eight days of dreams. Eight days of having to live through a dream where you witness a murder. Eight days of having to replay that dream until you reach the end of it.
“After those dreams ended, I decided to ask around if they knew anything of such an incident.”
“Was there?” Bilbo nodded to Thorin. Thorin waited for Bilbo to relay what had happened.
Bilbo did not disappoint.
“There was a hobbitlass that was murdered in the Shire during a festival. Her attacker was never caught but the one who had found her body was a human as well. He seemed heartbroken when he brought her body back to her family according to the witnesses.” Bilbo paused and bit at his lips. “They said her body was found in the river and from the way she was decomposing, it was eight days after her murder when she was found. She was identified to be Celandine Greenhand’s first cousin and best friend.”
Thorin was silent, an ice cold fear settling at the pit of his stomach. Bilbo pushed on with his tale, however.
“The Man that had found her returned two weeks later and gave Celandine a painting, saying that in his grief he wanted to make something happy to bring some light for those that had lost a good friend in the hobbitlass.” Thorin grimaced. That may have been the goal of the Man but even then it turned for the worse at the end of it all. “The Man was said to have been either a very dear friend to the hobbitlass or something even closer. But no one really knew and no one ever will.”
“Why?” Kíli looked genuinely confused and Bilbo shrugged.
“He left Bree the next day and no one really got a clue where he headed off to.” There was silence between them all for a moment or two before Bilbo let out a nervous chuckle and clapped his hands together.
“Well, I suppose it should have been a ghost story for the boys but I apologise that it turned out into something else.” Thorin shook his head, wanting to stop Bilbo from apologising from imparting a tale upon them.
“It was a good tale, Master Baggins.” Thorin looked at Bilbo and offered him a small smile, “Granted, it was grimmer for the life it was centred around and how it was ended. But it was good and you owe us no apologies.” Bilbo looked doubtful at his reassurance but he nodded and just smiled at Thorin.
“Well, if you’re certain, Master Oakenshield.” Bilbo mumbled before making a nod to him and smiling at the boys.
“I do apologise for not making it as frightful as I’d have liked.” Fíli and Kíli only grinned and shook their heads at his apology.
“It was fine, Bilbo. It wasn’t a ghost story but it was a fine story nonetheless!” Ori even nodded along as if to confirm it.
Bilbo nodded again before leaving, telling them that he needed a quiet place to finish mending his jacket.
Thorin forgot to ask if the murderer ever found justice.
