Chapter Text
Bilbo next told a story to the Company when they were inside Mirkwood. He wasn’t expecting them to ask him if he knew of any story in regards to forests. But they did and he decided to comply. Granted, when they’d asked him, it was a bit more of a mocking question but at the end of the day, Bilbo told them a story and that was that.
The question was brought up in their third day wandering the forest of Mirkwood when its darkness and disease was starting to take its toll on their nerves. Day and night were no longer separable for light can no longer be seen and they only stopped to make camp when exhaustion can no longer be ignored.
They were all preparing to sleep when they heard the creaks and moans that seemed to come from the trees. Kíli let out a yelp while Bofur cursed out at the night air. Bilbo looked up from his bedroll and raised his brows at the nervous dwarrows, his lips twitched up in amusement.
It was an almost endearing sight despite the tension in the air.
While no one said anything about the trees, Bilbo had taken note that all of his travelling companions had grown more wary of the plant life that surrounded them more than anything else. He was not lying that Mirkwood did make him feel terrible but he was not as jumpy or as wary as the rest when they travelled after they got some hours’ sleep.
“You’d think that the roads here would be closed off if the forest looked this bad.” Kíli muttered as he shook out his bedroll to bury himself under the blanket.
Fíli looked up from where he was unrolling his own bedroll and shrugged, “If they closed the paths to Mirkwood then it would take longer to make trade with any of the kingdoms beyond it.” The fair-haired dwarrow pointed out calmly.
Kíli grumbled and shivered when a biting cold wind rushed past them.
“I bet the Shire’s forestry doesn’t look this bad.” Kíli muttered, “After all, the Lady of Bilbo’s did live there once upon a time.”
Bilbo shrugged, “I suppose you’re right that it didn’t look this horrible.” He agreed with a small smile, “But then again most forests don’t look to be this much of a wreck.”
Bofur let out a low whistle, “So you’re sayin’ that the Elvenking’sworse off than the wee mortals he can’t even be bothered to help?”
Almost immediately, a chuckle arose from some of the Company members. Bilbo sighed and shook his head. It was somewhat petty to hear such things just for everyone else to laugh at the poor King’s predicament but in a way, Bofur was not wrong in that statement.
“The Elvenking is in a worse situation in terms of forestry and safety,” Bilbo agreed, though his voice was slow as he pondered on what to say, “and I suppose in his surety in his home remaining as his home as well.”
“What do you mean by that, Bilbo?” Fíli asked, his brows furrowing at what Bilbo had said. Bilbo sighed.
“Well from what I’ve seen here, it looks like the Elvenking is losing his home without any invasion save for the forest’s rot.” He explained patiently, “If it wasn’t so, then would you not have seen some elf homes around here like in Rivendell? Wouldn’t you have seen elves running around and having lively businesses to conduct?” Pressing his lips together, he shook his head.
“From the way it looks to a stranger, the Elvenking seems to be losing the amount of land he can have proper control of and in the process; he loses land for which his people can have a home in.”
There was silence around the camp and Bilbo did not know if it was a good silence or not. But he managed to catch Thorin’s gaze and saw a mixture of curiosity and anger in those eyes. He did not know whether the anger was directed at him or not.
“You seem to be sympathetic towards the elves, Master Baggins.” Bilbo smiled at Thorin and nodded.
“As sympathetic as one can afford to be to every stranger I had and had not yet met.” It was an unexpected surprise to him when Thorin nodded as if conceding to his point.
It was at that moment that a wailing sound filled the air and Kíli let out another curse causing Thorin to smile slightly. “And to the trees?” He asked almost teasingly, “Are you sympathetic to the trees as well, Master Baggins?”
Bilbo paused and pondered carefully what Thorin might have meant by that question and decided to answer it anyway, regardless of what Thorin might have intended.
“In some ways, yes I am sympathetic to the trees.” Keeping his eyes on Thorin, Bilbo continued, “For they suffer more than they should and I don’t think any living being whether they can talk or not would deserve the slow death they are suffering right now.”
“What makes you so sure that trees are even alive?” Kíli asked, his brows knitting together in confusion.
Bilbo snorted and was about to respond when Nori cut in before a word even left his lips.
“Knowing Bilbo, he would most likely have a faerie story for that.” Nori said with a bit of a mocking tone, “For some reason, Bilbo always seems to have a faerie story for everything.”
Smiling, Bilbo raised his brows at Nori and allowed a smirk to grace his lips. Though he knew it was meant to mock his tendency to tell stories, Bilbo felt some Tookishness in him rise up to the dare he saw in Nori’s eyes.
“Actually, Master Nori, you are right that I do have a faerie story for living trees.” And though he would rather not tell them this story due to how it had made him distraught as a sapling once a long time ago in his youth, he figured that it wouldn’t harm anyone if he did.
There was a pause before Bofur let out a laugh and Thorin chuckled. Nori on the other hand remained silent but there was a glint in his eyes that made Bilbo think that the dwarf might have been impressed by him.
“And what is this tale about, Master Baggins?” Thorin asked, Bilbo noticed how young the Dwarf-king looked when he was smiling but made no mention of it.
Bilbo instead returned the smile he received and tried to think of the best way to describe his story.
“Well, it’s a story of sacrifice and of love for family.” Bilbo supposed it was the best way to describe this story, “And I suppose it was just another story that cements the horrors that we can throw at anyone that is not our own.”
There was a short silence before Ori spoke and Bilbo had suspected it would be Ori to break that silence what with the boy’s thirst for knowledge and stories. Fiction or otherwise.
“Could you tell it to us, Bilbo?” Bilbo wanted to say yes but he wanted to make sure they would not be wasting time if he did so. So he turned to face Thorin who only dipped his head into a nod and smiled.
“You may as well, Master Baggins. Humour us with another faerie story, if you will.” Bilbo smiled.
“Very well then, I suppose I will tell you all about ‘The Crying Trees’.” Settling himself upon his bedroll and wrapping himself with the blanket that was packed with it, Bilbo smiled and waited until everyone had made themselves as comfortable as they can afford to be.
“Long ago, when the world was young and new to everything that surrounds it and humansand all their allies were nought but a thought in the Valar’s minds, trees roamed the earth free and joyous.” Bilbo could practically hear his mother’s lilting voice as he echoed her very words.
“That sounds terrifying.” Bofur muttered. Bilbo raised a brow at his friend who only looked at him and shrugged slightly, “It’s true.”
Rolling his eyes, Bilbo pressed on. “In one particular forest - one forest that ceased to exist - was a large family of trees.” Bilbo smiled and looked at his travelling companions, “It is an odd thing, I suppose, to imagine trees having families, but that was the way of life before we were even a thought in the Valar’s minds.”
He could feel Thorin’s gaze on him and Bilbo resolved not to feel anxious at what the Dwarf-king was thinking in regards to his tales.
“This family of trees were just like any other family nowadays. There were mothers and fathers, cousins, aunts and uncles and of course, there were children.” Bilbo chuckled and ignored the confused expressions on some of the dwarrows, “But there was only one grandparent in this particular family. He was simply called Grandfather Tree, for what else can we call him?”
“Perhaps we can call him by name if he had one?” Kíli said this with a bit of a frown, Bilbo smiled.
“I suppose we could have if we even knew his name.” Bilbo mused, “Unfortunately, no one ever bothered giving him a name and so he is only Grandfather Tree.”
Kíli looked as if he wanted to object to what Bilbo was saying, as if the young lad wanted to find a way to give the old tree a name that he was denied of. Bilbo only smiled reassuringly at Kíli. The name never mattered in this story, after all.
“Now, the family of trees lived in peace and harmony, there were no quarrels to be had and no tears to be shed. They had only ever known joy and love and that was perhaps one failing that was given to them.”
“And why would you say that’s a failing, laddie?” It was Balin that had spoken, Bilbo looked and though he expected confusion, he was pleasantly surprised to see understanding in Balin’s gaze.
“I suppose it would be a failing if all people had known were ease and comfort for then they would not know what to do in times of hardship.” Bilbo replied, feeling himself smile when Balin gave him an approving nod.
“The trees had continued on in this way of life through many years, for they did not really die, it was many more years before elves, humans and dwarves were finally brought to life. And when word reached the particular family where we are focusing upon, Grandfather Tree immediately grew wary of the new arrivals of the earth and bade his family never to approach the lands where Men roamed lest anything untoward happened to them.
For a time, the family did their best to follow their elder’s words. They had kept away from where the elves, men and dwarves were resided in and had done all they can to learn where it is no longer safe. For a time, their ways worked.”
“When did it end?” Ori asked. Bilbo was silent.
He could have easily ended the story abruptly as it would have but he had always wondered about that same thing whenever his mother transitioned the tale into the grim ending it always had. Did the trees even have any signs that their end drew near? He was never sure of it as a child.And so, as an adult, he decided to give them that sign that was not mentioned.
“I think that their ways began to end when the trees of the other forests began retreating into themselves.” It was an improvised part of the story, but Bilbo was pleased to have been able to make it work. “With the reign of elves, dwarves and men growing stronger in the lands, the trees began taking note of the loss of some of their brethren and wanted to escape the pain that their kind had been subjected to in their felling. So they retreated themselves further into themselves so as to not feel the pain when their time comes.”
A hushed murmuring arose among the Company and Bilbo observed what his swift addition to the story had caused. He saw troubled expressions upon the faces of his friends and upon Thorin’s face, was one of comprehension and of horror that was awaiting confirmation.
“What of the Grandfather Tree’s family?” Thorin asked softly, Bilbo smiled reassuringly, wanting nothing more than to put them at ease. At least…for the time being.
“Well, they were still untouched by men, elves and dwarves alike, so they still roamed around, free to be themselves and free to play when they wish. But Grandfather Tree began looking out beyond the horizon, dreading the day that the newcomers would come to slaughter his family.” Bilbo paused for a few moments before he spoke once more, “He was well-founded in his wariness for soon after, he began seeing campfire smokes in the distance. And he felt his heart sink - if trees even had hearts - to the very bottom of his being.”
“The family…they were slaughtered?” It was Thorin that had spoken once more, his voice having grown softer with a dawning horror.
Bilbo started before raising his hands and shaking his head, hoping to banish those thoughts from Thorin’s mind. “No, no, no! It’s not that they were slaughtered but…” Bilbo stopped speaking, trying to find a way to phrase the words properly. “They lived.” It was a simple way to say it but that was it. “The family lived when the settlers came.”
He could remember his mother telling him this bedtime story and how he would just stay silent but feel his heart sink at every word after. And now he could in a way understand why it was that his mother had done her best to tell him a different story every night or that she would give him a second story after she tells him this particular one.
“It was Grandfather Tree who had called his family to him, you see, he told them of the coming settlers and how his family must flee come nightfall for he feels they shall come by dawn.” Bilbo paused and took in a steadying breath, “He on the other hand, will be staying behind to block the path his family had taken.”
And just as Bilbo had once done when he was still a child, he heard his traveling companions shout out in protest at that plan.
“Surely, there would be another way?” Kíli asked desperately, his brother however only looked as if he expected that to be the only outcome in the tale.
“What else can he do, Kee?” Fíli asked, his brows knitted together, “The settlers are coming their way likely to find lumber to make houses with and for firewood as well, the least he can do is to find a way to protect his family and to prolong their lives the best way he can. If they all went together then the settlers would still scatter beyond the settlement to find lumber and wood which would in turn have to be the family.”
Bilbo only nodded to show he agreed with the fair-haired prince’s words before he pushed on, “Grandfather Tree was a large and thick tree that is able to block our pathways if he was here with us.” He remembered how his father had illustrated Grandfather Tree and how his father had drawn the rest of the family afterwards.Bilbo had always been awed by the sheer size Grandfather Tree was always said to possess.
“He was confident that his size and width would be able to buy his family enough time for them to make off to another part of the world where they would not be hunted and hurt. And so, though reluctant, his family prepared to leave come nightfall.” Once more, protests arose and Bilbo did not quiet their protests for he could not blame them.
“And the family did not try to take him with them? To persuade him that he wouldn’t need to sacrifice himself?” It was Dori that had spoken and Bilbo looked at the silver-haired dwarf who was looking at him as if Bilbo had decided to announce that he ate puppies.
Bilbo only shook his head, “Unfortunately not.” He sighed, “You see, this is one of the few cases in which we can truly say that there was no other way but through this.”
“Will it be enough, do you think?” This time it was Bombur that had asked this and Bilbo paused, fingered a buttonhole of his red coat, and smiled though it was a grim one.
“It was.” Looking up into the dark foliage of trees overhead, Bilbo moved his lips though it was soundless for a few moments, “Now, you lot kept believing that no one had done what they can to convince Grandfather Tree to join them in their flight but there were.”
A pause followed.
“The children.” Sharp breaths were taken in by the Company and Bilbo nodded silently, “They who loved Grandfather Tree the most had begged him to come with them. But even when his heart ached for the young trees’ tears, he knew he cannot and must not come with them for if he did then there would be none who shall protect his family. So with weathered branches he caressed their faces and bade them leave.
He did not cry in front of them but his heart did ache for the grief of the little ones. Yet despite all his heartaches, he found it in him to give them a last advice.
‘You must leave me so you all may live, little ones.’ He had said with a small smile, ‘You must all live on for my sake and greet the new day in my memory. For you are all that shall remember our joys and laughter and I wish for you to have that chance that many had been stolen away from.’
And though the children wept bitterly, they were borne away by their parents.” Bilbo paused, knowing that that was the end for what happened with the children and Grandfather Tree but he wanted to add some semblance of comfort for their tale. “The children kept looking back to wave to Grandfather Tree who smiled on and waved back.”
“And is that the end of your tale, Master Baggins?” It was Thorin once more and his voice was almost impossible to be heard despite the silence. Bilbo did not want to do it but he shook his head and he heard Ori let out a noise of distress.
“The settlers came as was expected. By then Grandfather Tree’s family had come relatively far that the settlers would not have found them but that they can still see their Grandfather from even that distance. And with that view, they were able to see Grandfather Tree’s form shudder and shake as he took every blow of the settlers’ axes. Despite their safety, they felt every blow keenly as if they were being cut down as well.
They had done all they can to make as large a distance between themselves and the settlers but when they were certain that they had come far enough that they would not be found, they stopped. They had lost their strength and will to push on when they had caught sight of Grandfather Tree’s form being felled by that final axe blow.” As Bilbo gazed around the camp, he could make out the resignation in the Company’s faces. He felt that they knew what will happen.
Though this never happened in the faerie story of his youth, he decided to make it happen in this retelling he was doing.
“Grief-stricken and lost, the family of trees held onto each other and allowed themselves to burrow themselves deeper into their minds. They wanted nothing more to do with this world than to be lost in it and to be forgotten that they had ever lived. By the time the settlers had found the family of trees that were just now an unmoving forest, they were shocked to see an odd substance running down their barks. It almost appeared to the settlers that the trees had been crying.”
There was a silence afterwards. No one dared speak and Bilbo allowed them the silence. It was Kíli who had broken it with a soft voice that sounded like he was about to burst into tears, he asked, “Did the trees at least live on?”
Bilbo shrugged. Unlike his other tales where he had a sure answer, this one never had a sure ending. Not even as a child.For all he knew, this fictional forest might have been cut down by the settlers and they no longer lived on. But he supposed that was the beauty of it all, they all can pretend that a more hopeful ending befell the grieved family.
Thorin did not look pleased at the ending but Bilbo did not expect him to be. Getting up from his bedroll, Bilbo approached Thorin and placed a hand on his shoulder. He did not acknowledge the part in him that wanted to tell Thorin that he was there if Thorin ever needed comfort for anything. Thorin jolted and looked at Bilbo before dipping his head into a nod.
“That was…a sombre tale, Master Baggins.” He commented, his voice eerily soft, Bilbo smiled.
“I suppose it is.” He agreed, “But the comfort in the unsurety of this ending is how we can take hope that if this forest of trees ever existed that they had lived on despite their minds having withdrawn from the world.”
He did not know what else to tell Thorin other than this and he supposed that that was enough for him. Smiling, Bilbo bade his companions good night and he did not tease the younger dwarrows for burrowing at his side when he drifted off to sleep.
Soon after that, Bilbo had noticed how the Company never made fun of the dying trees in Mirkwood anymore so much as that they cursed the darkness that befell the forest.
