Actions

Work Header

Fili on the Lake

Chapter Text

As autumn bit down on all of them, Lakemen hunters went out one morning and found deer and wild pigs ripped apart near the Eastern bank of the lake. Murmurings of out-of-season starlings were seen in the sky as night fell, moving in panicked, black clouds back and forth across the water. An old fisherman said he pulled up his boat at a beach just past the northern rocks and saw deep troughs leading down to the water, like someone had pulled narrow rowboats out of the forest and down to the edge of the lake, but not quite into it.

Tauriel was often in the Master's House, bringing her king's messages to Bard. The young Lakemen militia no longer had their elvish teachers, but the elves were often in Laketown, being ferried back and forth from the mouth of the tributary that led up to their palace. There were more and more armed companies being sent out by Thranduil. They came back with stories of orcs lurking just outside of the fences and fields that marked the cultivated lands of Erebor-Upon-Dale.

Sigrid found Bard one day, sat at his desk in the Master’s Hall with unanswered letters in a pile, staring out the leadlight window with his chin in his hand.

“It doesn’t make sense,” he muttered to Sigrid as she came in. “The element of surprise would give them an advantage. If they’re planning a war, why warn us? Why all this… goading?”

Sigrid began to sort the letters into piles by priority; this today, that tomorrow, those by next week. There was no time for orcs when the letters still needed to be answered.

“Perhaps the fear of war is a means to something else,” she said distractedly. “Like the beaters rousing the birds ahead of the hunters.”

–--

When Tilda went to the workshop under the house, only Kili was there. Tilda had noticed that Fili seemed to be avoiding everyone in Bard’s household.

“Hello,” she let herself in the door instead of leaning over the customer window. “Are you busy?”

“I’m always busy, but you can bother me anyway,” Kili looked up from the post he had on the lathe. He was in a loose shirt rolled up to the elbows and there was sawdust in his hair, which he’d tied up behind his head.

“Why don’t you just cut it?” Tilda asked, leaning on the workbench nearby. “Your hair. It’d be safer.”

“Why don’t you just wear trousers instead of skirts?” Kili asked, stopping the lathe to inspect some small catch in the grain of the post.

“That wouldn’t be proper,” she shrugged, and she added primly, “And I look so good like this.”

“Asked and answered,” Kili grinned. He put down his skew tool and sat up on his stool. “Are you looking for gossip?”

“Not specifically. Do you have some?”

“No, I was hoping you would. Fili’s been an absolute chalk lump for days. Do you know why?”

Tilda shook her head. After a moment she wrinkled her nose. “Sigrid has seemed particularly bossy this week.”

They said at the same time, “Asked and answered.”

Kili sighed, picked up the stool and came to sit across from her at the workbench. He folded his arms and laid his face down on them. “I’m so tired. We’ve got enough work for three carpenters but Kibil doesn’t get up until noon and by teatime he’s too pickled to hold a hammer. I haven’t been out with Tauriel in weeks. And now I have to do the invoices because Fili’s saying he won’t lift a finger to help Kibil until he gives him back the money he took.”

Tilda felt herself go a little cold and still, as if she’d suddenly lost a lot of blood. She said, trying to make it sound casual. “Do you think that’s safe? Making Kibil angry?”

Kili raised his head. “What’s that tone for?”

“Da said he had to go over there and tell Kibil not to cause trouble the other day,” Tilda knotted her fingers on the bench. “He wouldn’t say what happened but he told me to stay away from Kibil if I could help it.”

Kili rolled his eyes. “What’s Kibil going to do, fire me?”

The feeling struck like an arrow in Tilda’s breast: she had to tell him everything. About the box in the canal. About the figure sitting under the rug in the laundry. About the handle of the mangler, and the dwarf sitting under the rug. And how his head—his head—his head was not the right shape, beneath all that blood—

Kili noticed that her face was blotchy and tense as if she was trying not to cry. “Tilda, are you alright?”

“Kili,” Tilda said quietly. “Did your uncle have a box?”

“Does my uncle have a box? What does that mean?”

“Not him,” Tilda said. She took a slow breath to quell the tears. She had to be brave. “The drowned one. When he arrived on the lake, did he bring a box?”

Kili sat up. “Yes, Fili said he did. We never found it.”

“I know where it is,” Tilda said, so quiet she almost couldn’t hear herself. “It’s beneath us. Sunk under the house. All these years.”

“How do you know?”

“I saw it go in,” Tilda said. “The night after you arrived in Laketown. I saw the box go in the lake. I opened it, and there was no treasure, just an old drawing of a tree. And then I saw… I saw how Khagr got in the lake.”

Kili’s hands were flat on the workshop and his face had gone quite grey. “Are you making this up? Are you trying to get Kibil in trouble so your Da kicks him out?”

The tears were in the corner of her eyes again, but she repeated the thought over and over that she had to be brave. “No. No, I would never lie about something like that, I just didn’t tell anyone before now.”

How could she explain? She’d been thirteen. She couldn’t tell the dwarves apart in the dark, she’d only heard their voices and seen the silhouette rowing the dinghy. She didn’t know who had thrown the box in the canal. She didn’t know who had held the mangler-handle. She’d only just met them, so briefly that day.

“Why not?” Kili asked.

“I heard it happen but it was dark and I couldn’t see…”

Tilda covered her face, then looked up at the ceiling. She made a strangled noise of frustration, at herself, at the unfairness of it. She had been a child. And Kili’s smile had been so warm, something new and interesting in this damp, dead-end town.

She said at last, “I thought it might have been you. It might have been you, or your brother, who did it. And if I had told Da what I heard, the town would have driven you out. Or worse. In Dale they hang murderers.”

How could she explain? She knew now that if she had told her father, that first day, their whole lives would be different. The dwarves might have gone straight back to the East before Tilda even knew them. But the lake was good at holding things, at keeping things close, and so were children.

Kili was silent for a long time. Tilda didn’t ask him for anything. Suddenly he was on his feet and heading for the stairs at the back of the workshop, down to the shared laundry room. Tilda hesitated, wondering if she should just go, wondering if Kili would ever be friends with her again. Then she got up and hurried down the stairwell to find Kili standing at the open edge of the room, looking down into the canal.

He didn’t look up at her. “You said the box was sunk underneath the house.”

Tilda came to stand beside him, hugging her arms around her waist. “Yes.”

“Here? In the canal?”

“Yes,” Tilda admitted.

“Khargr had a gem-box. He brought it out of the East with us. Said it was our inheritance and it would make us all rich once he found the right buyer in Erebor,” Kili blinked. “The box disappeared with him. Kibil claimed he found it was empty, another failed swindle by Khagr, and that he threw it away.”

Kili suddenly moved, pulling off his shirt and boots, leaving only a light pair of under-trousers. Tilda gave a cry of annoyance and covered her eyes mockingly, but she didn’t realise what he was doing until it was too late. Before she could stop him he was sitting on the edge of the raised floor, feet slipping into the canal. “Kili, stop, it’s freezing in there!”

“The water’s - what? Five feet, here? Seven?” he looked up at her as he lowered himself over the edge. He did have the decency to curse and grit his teeth, and then in a moment he sunk into the water and was gone. A few curls of sawdust from his hair floated on the surface of the oily water.

“Kili!” Tilda ran to the edge and knelt down. The lake was clearer than usual today, but the busy canals were always silty. He might lose his bearings and come up under the buildings, or under an enclosed part of a jetty, and not find his way before his breath ran out. But then with a bubble and a burst of activity, Kili surfaced, shoving his hair off his face. “Nothing yet,” he coughed, and disappeared again. Tilda wanted to run and find Sigrid or Fili, but she needed to watch the water for signs of where he’d gone. If he got into trouble while she was upstairs it might be too late by the time they returned.

Twice more he dove down and surfaced empty-handed, but on the fourth dive he came up holding a box. It was muddy and covered with the slime that coated most water-exposed surfaces of Laketown, and there were the long, thin shells of tube worms criss-crossing its dark binding.

Kili blew water out of his nose as he heaved himself back up onto the laundry floor. Tilda ran upstairs to find a blanket, brought it down and threw it around Kili, and the two of them climbed the stairs to the workshop.

—

Kili redressed while Tilda did her best to dry the box on the blanket and then placed it in the centre of the workbench. He put the shutter down over the window and turned the sign on the door to closed.

The box waited with what seemed like a conscious presence while they sat down and stared at it. It looked to Kili like a trap, something spring-loaded.

“It doesn’t weigh much,” Tilda said at last. “Maybe it really is empty.”

Kili fetched a chisel and went to work on the rusted latch, pocked and bloated. At last the box opened sluggishly, muddily, one of the hinges audibly snapping as it resisted giving up its secrets. They both leaned forward. Inside the box was what looked like a swollen page of black leather, folded in half, which Kili lifted out gingerly.

The folder was twisted, waterlogged, and hard to peel the two halves apart, but slowly they separated between Kiil’s fingers. Inside was looked like vellum or linen-paper, terribly stained and disintegrating on one edge. It opened to show a soaked, patchy image that for a moment looked as Tilda had described it: a tree sketched in thin, black lines and decorated with scribbles like leaves. But then Kili turned it upside down and he saw at once that it was not a leafed tree, but a family tree - a pedigree.

History tutors the world over made young dwarves memorise all of the first fathers and mothers, and their sons, and their sons’ sons, so he recognised the line of Durin the Deathless. But after that he’d been taught about the Stonefoot kings and queens, and he had never learned much of Longbeard history. Kili’s gaze swept down the lines as the pedigree broadened into many lords and kings, then narrowed as war and the changing of the world whittled down the princes of the Longbeards, fathers bearing sons who were themselves sonless, daughters bearing only daughters and then vanishing from the record.

A few branches remained, and Kili followed the eldest line down, the names vaguely familiar only from passing conversations overheard at pubs in Dale; Dain, Thror, Thrain…

Down, down, to the last two names.

Kili felt his eyes widen, his jaw clenched and trembling. For what seemed like a lifetime, he couldn’t speak.

“Oh, I can read this,” Tilda said suddenly. “We learned in school. D - U - R - Durin, even I know him—“

Kili slapped the leather holder closed and shoved it with the parchment down his shirt. He shut the box again with difficulty around the rusted surviving hinge.

“It’s nothing,” he said. “Probably an old property deed. Some debt Khagr was trying to hide.”

Tilda looked at him. She might not be a fast reader of dwarvish script but she had seen enough dwarvish bills and invoices to know that was not a property deed.

The shop bell dinged despite the closed sign and they both looked up. Bain was leaning through the doorway.

“What are you doing?” He snapped at Kili. “We’re on patrol tonight. You’re already late, Gamling sent me to find you.”

“Ah, sod me, I forgot,” Kili groaned and jumped up. “Just let me get my jacket and my outdoor boots.”

Kili gathered himself together in the backroom. Tilda noticed that he had swept the gem-box from the benchtop without her even noticing. When he returned, it seemed to be gone.

“Give me two minutes and I’ll be outside,” Kili waved his hand at Bain.

“You haven’t got two minutes.” Nevertheless, Bain stepped out.

Kili looked at Tilda as he tidied his collar and buttoned up his coat. “Don’t tell anyone what you told me, not yet. I have to talk to Fili first.”

“I need to tell Da,” Tilda whimpered. “He has to do something about Kibil.”

Kili shook his head. “This is bigger than Kibil. I’ll be back from patrol tonight and I’ll talk to my brother as soon as Kibil is asleep. Then we’ll go to your father and explain what we know.”

“Kili, be careful.”

Kili reached over and squeezed her hand quickly. “Thank you. I’ll see you soon.”

Bain was hollering for him to hurry up. Kili put his hands in his pockets and stepped out into the cold.

Thoughts like shards of pottery were spinning through his head, but for the first time he was beginning to see the shape they made together.

He understood at last why Khagr had dragged them here. The inheritance he claimed he could sell only in Erebor; not a gem or a mithril-threaded sword, but information. It was such a ridiculous, impossible story, that Kibil must have found it unbelievable when he learned the plan. Kili might not have believed it himself, but there was someone else to confirm it - the king’s hobbit, who had spotted them in Dale, a few weeks ago.

Bilbo Baggins had not been sent to spy on Bard’s children. In hindsight, that had always been implausible. Kili cursed silently as he followed Bain through the town to the militia headquarters, and felt a shudder run through him. Bilbo had been spying on them.

Did Erebor already know, or did they only suspect? What had Bilbo learned and taken back to his master under the Mountain? Bain was saying something, about how annoying that so-and-so was sick, and how he didn’t like the look of the fog over there, and Kili replied with half-formed affirmations.

The great kingdom of the dwarves, the magnificent mountain, loomed above the lake with what suddenly felt like malice. Yesterday, Kili would have described it as a remote, glorious world that he imagined was full of gems and gold and handsome dwarves intoning speeches that would fill the history books. Now he thought about how that wealth and power must be maintained with many soldiers, with secret police, with intrigues by lords and dukes each plotting against each other, with assassins beholden to no one but the highest bidder.

His thoughts were in free fall. What had Fili said, third-hand and half-remembered? Something about a battle for the throne. Bard had told Sigrid that the king wanted to marry and beget himself a son, but his military-minded cousin coveted the crown. There was going to be a succession crisis when the king died—

(oh Mahal, was the king already dying? Kili never paid attention to the politics far away under a mountain. If he was dying you wouldn’t know, would you? It was treason to even speak of the future death of a king)

—and maybe history wasn’t Kili’s best subject but everyone knows that in a succession crisis, you have to move fast and eliminate rivals to your chosen successor. Or even better, if you can quietly get rid of them beforehand, it doesn’t look as suspicious.

“Kili,” Bain’s voice broke him out of the fall. He looked up. Bain was holding his sword out to him. They were in the militia headquarters and everyone was ready to leave for patrol. They were all staring at him.

“What’s your problem?” Bain said, more rhetorical than actually concerned.

“Nothing,” Kili said. “I’m fine. Let’s go.”

—

That night, a fog came down the lake that was thicker than any in living memory. Boatmen hurried home before they became lost, and a few managed it only with bright lamps and hollering from the jetties of Laketown. These last few said they had seen something on the Northeastern shore. Something large, moving across the land, always staying in sight of the water.

The fog was too thick to risk sending out messengers to the woodland or the mountain kingdoms. No one could leave by boat, including Tauriel and a handful of her scouts. Bard ordered the Master's house opened and anyone with babies, the infirm or elderly was encouraged to stay in its halls until morning. He gathered barges by the inner docks, ready for an evacuation at the earliest sign. Sigrid stayed close to her father, running errands and taking a rough survey of who had chosen to stay in their homes and who was sleeping in their boats for a fast getaway.

A group of the lakemen militia had gone out on patrol to the Eastern bank when the fog was still gathering, and by nightfall they had not reported back. Sigrid was distributing dinner to those taking refuge in the Master's house when she spotted Fili coming around the edge of the hall to catch her.

"If you want to help, grab blankets and start handing them out," she said, pointing at a pile behind her makeshift quartermaster's desk. He did as she said but continued to follow her.

"Have you had any word about the militia? Kili's out there."

"So is Bain," Sigrid replied. "We can't do anything for them. They'll be lost and cold but they'll come home in the morning, when the fog blows away."

"Something is wrong," Fili hissed, trying not to be overheard by the crowds trying to settle down around them.

She turned to him. "Of course it is. Everyone feels it. But we can only manage what's in front of us."

Fili followed her in silence for another circuit of the room, and then he saw Tauriel passing in the hallway outside. He darted out to catch her, and Sigrid couldn't help but follow, just in case Tauriel had news.

"I don't know any more than you," Tauriel was saying to Fili.

"You could take your scouts out to find them," Fili was whispering. He waved at the wide open doors of the Master's house. The mist was so thick they could not see the far side of the courtyard outside. "You can track them even in this soup. I'm sure you can."

Tauriel shook her head. "While we're in the town, we'll follow Bard's command. He wants us ready and watching."

"Kili's out there," Fili grabbed her hand. "In the dark. With Mahal-knows-what."

Tauriel held his eye. At last she said. "I'll speak to Bard."

"Thank you," Fili gasped.

Not ten minutes later, Sigrid saw Tauriel and two of her archers heading out of the front doors. They were swallowed up by the fog, and shortly after, Bard gave the order to close the doors. The air was growing colder, the heat dropping away so quickly that Sigrid found her hands shaking before she even thought to put her coat back on.

Most people tried to sleep. Sigrid found Tilda sitting in an upstairs balcony overlooking the blank, white void of fog where the town should be, hiding her face so that no one saw her crying. Sigrid crouched down and rubbed her sister's arms. She made her put on a thicker cloak with a hood to keep her head warm. "You should go to bed."

"I'm not going to sleep until Tauriel brings Bain home," Tilda sniffed through her tears.

"Alright, then let's go for a walk. Da has lamp-men circling the town to keep watch, we'll take a shift."

Fili saw them leaving with the lamps and fell into step with them. "Can I join you?"

"If you must," Sigrid muttered, and handed him a lamp.

—

The young militia of Laketown had two units, two self-appointed teams for the fun of competing against each other in their practice tournaments and military exercises. Despite Bard’s regular lectures about their duties, it was all something of a game to the young men and boys charged with protecting the town.

Bain was supposed to be in the Black unit, and Kili was in Red, but the night of the fog the Red unit was out on patrol and down a member, who was sick at home with food poisoning. So Bain had taken his place, and joined the Red patrol along the banks of the lake as the fog rolled in just before dusk.

Of course, they were not afraid of a little mist. They had confidently continued their planned route along the circuit road, and got utterly lost on the way back.

The oldest member of the team, a swart, broad-shouldered man named Gamling, was marching at the front with Hildor, the youngest boy, to keep him calm as the fog grew thicker. Gamling had confidently told them that as long as they kept the sound of the lake’s lapping waves on their right hand side, they would eventually reach the main road towards the bridge and head home. But the lake was so still tonight that almost all sound had disappeared. There were no night-birds calling, no scurrying foxes or stoats, not even the buzzing of mosquitos. The foliage hung still and silent as they pushed through the branches. It was like they were walking with blankets wrapped around their heads, until anyone spoke, and then they all shivered at the loudness of their own voices.

They tried to walk in pairs, where the goat-path they were following allowed it, and somehow Bain had ended up at the back with Kili.

Bain was old enough to be a man about it, but he was not going to pretend that he liked Kili. He told himself that it was not because of Tauriel (it was). He told himself it wasn’t because Kili acted like he knew everything about the world just because he’d been halfway around it (it was). He told himself it wasn’t because last month, Tilda had been home for the holidays and when Bain tried to tell his little sister to be more modest with her jokes and her dress, Kili had laughed him down and said, “Don’t be so jealous, Bain, just because she’s funnier than you,” (it was).

Bain didn’t like him because Kili was, in fact, so annoying. Below Gamling, who was twenty-six and took very seriously his role as the oldest in the group, everyone treated Kili like he was the next-senior member of the militia. Bain knew that wasn’t fair, because obviously by dwarvish standards Kili was barely an adult. But he still had a witty story for every situation, usually quite a funny one, and that made people think he was more mature than Bain knew he really was. It was transparent (to Bain) that his charm masked his obvious lack of real personality. And then when the wood-elves had come to train them, Kili had always been the quickest to pick up on everything they learned. Even though he didn’t have the reach with the melee weapons that the humans had, he seemed to have an instinct for how to use his strength and low centre of balance to his advantage. Fighting him with a sword was like trying to knock over a tree-trunk. A tree trunk that kept trying to sweep your leg out.

Bain had expected to at least be the best in the group at the bow. He was Bard’s son, after all, son of the man who had shot a dragon out of the sky. But the first time they all started practising in front of the elves, although it was not a competition (it was), Kili hit nearer the target than Bain three times out of four. That was unnatural. Dwarves didn’t even use bows. Everyone knew that.

After this feat of accuracy, Kili winked at Tauriel as he strode off the range, handing his bow to the next young member of the militia. “Sorry I’m a bit rusty. Back home, we had to shoot mountain lions to warn them off our herd pastures.”

Bain wanted to gag just thinking about it. ‘Bit rusty.’ What an absolute bucket of filthy bilge-water. He had tried to be a grown-up and treat Kili with the same respect he treated all his fellow militia members, but of course, the git just responded to passive-aggressive respect with cheerful camaraderie. It’s like he thought they were actually friends.

So yes, Bain didn’t like Kili, but at least he was being a man about it.

Nobody was talking as their feet tried to find a safe route downhill, sure that would at least take them back to the shoreline. Although they were stuck walking next to each other, Bain tried to make it clear he was not talking to Kili even more.

The wending convoy stuck as close together as they could, and almost ran into each other when Gamling stopped and raised a hand for their attention.

“There’s a drop ahead,” he sighed. “We can’t climb it in this fog. We’ll back up to that last copse of trees and find another way down from there.”

“We can’t keep going in circles,” one of the other boys complained. “Let’s just pick a sheltered spot and wait out the fog.”

Gamling shook his head. There was a grim, fearful look on his face that he covered with a military bark, “Stay in your pairs, everyone turn around where you are. Kili, you lead us back to the copse.”

Bain tried not to scoff. ‘Kili, you lead us’ - Bain was right here next to him! He was so ready for this patrol to be over. He couldn’t wait to get back to the rest of the Black team and tell them what a mess the Red team had made of a simple walk on the shoreline.

Kili nodded at Gamling and started back up the hill. Bain matched his pace. This was a task in itself, as Kili didn’t seem to get fatigued as quickly as the humans, and the two of them had soon pulled too far ahead of the rest of the militia.

“Kili,” Bain said, trying to hide his breathlessness. “Slow down. We’re leaving the others behind.”

“Ah, sorry Bain, I thought you were keeping up,” Kili stopped and propped one foot up on a rock to lean one elbow on his knee. He waved at the others behind them. Was he posing? Really? What a slice of rotting fish-head he was.

In the fog, not far down the hill but almost invisible through the mist, one of the others waved back. Up ahead, Bain could see the wide, dark shape of what must be the copse. He took a deep breath to keep himself from shoulder-barging Kili as he drew level with him.

He sniffed. There was something in the air.

“Kili,” Bain hissed. “Do you smell that?”

Kili frowned at him and took a breath. “Yes, weird smell… what is that?”

Bain knew what it was. They all knew what it was. All of them, Bain realised, except for Kili, who had not lived in Laketown when Bain had lasted known this smell.

The dark, wide shape behind Kili was not the copse of trees. Trees didn’t shift and move closer like that.

Bain braced against the grassy stones and launched himself towards Kili. He grabbed him by the lapels and hauled him sideways, throwing them both down the hill, tumbling over each other in the thick tussock. Kili yelped in surprise and slid slightly further than Bain, coming out of the roll crouched onto one knee. Bain ended up on his back with his head downhill in a much less dignified pose.

“Run!” Bain raised his head to look towards Kili. “Run!”

Something was coming out of the fog; not an army, not a creature, but a black cloud that oozed and collapsed on itself as it broiled outwards from some unseen source hidden in the mist. Bain tried to scuffle backwards downhill, on his elbows and kicking his feet away, and the edge of the cloud rolled over the bottom of his left leg just as he flipped onto his front and managed to stand up.

The strange cloud didn’t feel wet, but it was hot, and then like a chilling cold it was burning. Bain screamed and his leg gave way as it went into weak spasms. He kept trying to limp on, and then to crawl with his good leg and his hands, but the pain was like a lightning bolt through his spine and brain. No stubborn bravery could have overcome it; he fainted forward into the grass and stones.

He came back to consciousness within what must have been moments. His body was moving through the grass at speed, almost sliding down the hill on his back, and he could see the blundering shapes of his fellow militiamen around and behind him through the fog. For a moment he wondered if some predator had seized him and was dragging him back to its lair. But he turned his head a little and realised Kili was holding him under the arms and dragging him down the hill.

The pain was still so bad that he didn’t want to look at his leg. He looked up the hill, at what was behind them, and wished he hadn’t. One of the other boys - it sounded like Hildor - suddenly screamed and then went very silent, very fast.

The land flattened out and the grass gave way to packed stones beneath Bain’s body. They had come upon the road at last, and at a point well-worn enough that the bridge to town must not be far at all. Bain tried to stand on his good leg but his nerves were shot with fear and pain and he just flopped, held half-upright by Kili.

“Here!” Bain heard Kili shout, waving his arm. “Help me!”

There were three tall figures running in graceful synchronicity out of the fog. Tauriel reached the two of them first, as the rest of the militia arrived in a stuttering pack. She took Bain out of Kili’s arms, hauling him up as if he was half her weight. Bain could not help thinking, through his daze, that this was not how he’d imagined his first real taste of action.

“We need to go,” he gasped, trying to find the words to make Tauriel and the other elves understand. “There’s nothing we can do. Run and warn the town.”

Tauriel called like a clear bell through the night, “Aphad-im! Follow me!” and turned with Bain in her arms back the way she had come.

They were all moving as a group now, the panicked militiamen clustered behind Tauriel while the two elvish archers, Berior and Fainthel, took up the rear. They paced backwards and raised their arrows towards the blank fog.

Bain heard a low rumble behind them, soft as a pot in the fire boiling over, and looked over his shoulder to see the black cloud rushing and writhing towards them along the road. It was thicker than air or steam and moved fast but then splashed down on the road and trees, dissipating more like the spray of a crashing wave than a cloud of smoke. Everywhere it touched, there came a faint hissing sound like raindrops on a roof, and the leaves shrivelled, the trees turned black and the bark split and peeled in many fissures like dry paint in the sun.

“Don’t touch it!” Bain tried to yell, but even he had to admit it came out as something of a shriek. He saw Berior turn and shove the nearest militiamen onwards, but Fainthel must have seen a mark somewhere behind the dark cloud and she stayed to loose an arrow.

Bain saw the edges of the cloud engulf her and for a moment she vanished, and the next she was emerging from the black cloud and stumbling after them, but by the gods, she was burning without fire–

Bain wanted to close his eyes, but it was as if they were frozen open. He saw Kili dart forward and snatch up Fainthel’s bow and a handful of arrows that had spilled from her quiver as she fell.

Tauriel saw it all and even she stumbled, and Bain nearly fell out of her arms. She crouched and swept him up onto her back, and ran on without looking over her shoulder again.