Actions

Work Header

Fili on the Lake

Summary:

Wasn’t that how it worked in fairytales? The prince gathered up the sleeping maiden, promised to wed her, the curse was broken and they lived happily ever after. But Fili wasn’t a prince, he was a bookkeeper to a drunk carpenter, and the marriage offer hadn’t worked anyway. So his little act of valour was a failure.

In this world, the dragon failed to destroy Laketown many years ago, the King survived the battle of Five Armies, Bard is the properly elected leader of Laketown, and Fili and Kili are literally the boys next door who were raised with no idea of their royal heritage.

The lives Fili and Sigrid live are small and dull and rather damp, but at least they have each other; but the world beyond is about to come crashing in.

Notes:

All my thanks for Flollius for the beta-reading, advice and support.

Chapter Text

Prologue

When he has had a short meal and a long, deep ale, Balin goes to find Thorin. Dwalin has gone to wash the road-dust off and find some soft shoes. He will head into town looking for news as well, and perhaps more ale, and comfort after a year away from their home in Ered Luin. Balin aches and wouldn't mind putting his feet up, but first he needs to see his king-in-exile, his king alone.

Thorin is in front of the fire, with a candle lit on the shelf behind him, a little light to read by. The letter itself now sits on the floor beside him, halfway to the crackling embers. Perhaps Thorin wanted to burn it, but didn't quite have the heart, and aborted the motion even as his arm moved to toss the parchment on the fire.

Balin pulls up a stool and gives him a hearty pat on the knee. "I'm sorry, laddie."

"Do you think he'll change his mind with time?" Thorin says softly. His gaze is on the fire, but unfocused.

"No," Balin says. No point in false hope. "He told me straight, ‘don't ask again’. He won't answer another letter."

"Are they well?" Thorin asks, brows raising a little as he imagines a place he will never know. "Does he keep them in a solid home? Are there tutors? Other children?"

"As well as any babe here in Ered Luin," Balin nods and squeezes Thorin's knee. "He's got a level head for business and his herd is of high repute, you know that. It's not pride that he keeps them for. He could marry again and fill his hall with bairns, but he loves his boys. As he loved your sister."

"Good. That's good," Thorin lowers his head. His hand rises to his brow as if to shield his face from the fire's heat, and they both sit in silence as he sobs.

 

———————————————-———————————————-

 

70 years later

"Stars above," Kili wrinkled his nose as he stepped off the ferry to stand beside his brother. "What an absolute dump."

Fili let his agreement show on his face. Khagr and Kibil were haggling with the ferryman. Kibil had asked him to transport their bags onwards to their lodgings instead of leaving everything at the customs house. That cost extra, and the ferryman wanted local currency, as during the boat ride from the south end of the lake he'd grown suspicious of the purity of Khagr's silver Rhûn coin. Which was very prudent, as it was almost certainly either clipped or illicitly debased.

There was a small cough behind them to let them know they were overheard. They turned sharply enough that Fili almost tripped on the bull rail that edged the jetty and would have ended up in the lake if the man standing there hadn't grabbed his arm.

"Steady now?"

"Thank you," Fili winced. "My apologies. We just arrived."

"I saw," the man gave them a small nod and held out his hand. "My name is Bard. I'm your welcoming committee. And your new landlord, as it happens."

The blood drained so fast from Kili's face that Fili would have laughed in almost any other circumstance. Before he could return the handshake, Khagr burst between them and grabbed the lake-man's hand. "Hello, sir, hello!" Big grin, big handshake, big voice. Always the centre of attention. "Did you say your name is Bard? Well, what a delight, what a pleasure. I did not expect the Master of Laketown himself would be here to greet us."

Bard extracted his hand from the dwarf's grip and discretely flexed the blood back into his fingers. "The pleasure's all mine. I thought it best to show you to the house myself, since we'll be neighbours. You would be Khagr?" He had good pronunciation, given it was traditionally an Eastern name, but Khagr had promised them that Laketown was the gateway to the bustling, cultured, and - most importantly - wealthy city-state of Erebor-over-Dale.

Fili took another look around the dock, at the tilting gutters, the bare eaves flecked and grey, the dogs snuffling at something dead in the corner. It didn't look like things were bustling, let alone cultured or wealthy.

"That's me, myself, Khagr," the dwarf gave a jolly bellow and waved at Kibil, who was supervising the luggage as the ferryman tossed it onto the dock. Evidently he had decided not to invest any further in Eastern coin. "That's my brother and business partner, Kibil. These are my dear nephews," he threw his arms around Fili & Kili's necks and ruffled their hair until he received two forced smiles. "Orphans. I took them in after their Pa died a few years back. Better than my own sons, if I acknowledged any," he winked at Bard. "Anyway! Shall we follow your lead?"

"This way, please," Bard did not respond to Khagr's verbosity with an entire biography of his own, but he did help them carry the bags.

The house was two and a half stories and a small loft; the half storey at the bottom seemed to be for boats and other wet-gear storage, with a three-walled laundry area that they shared with Bard’s house, which was more like a basement opening directly onto the canal. The ground floor was taken up by a cramped workshop and shopfront with a lot of impractical built-in shelves, and a trapdoor with a ladder to reach the level above. So they'd all be living on the second floor. It did not look like much space from the outside. From the walkways that bordered the canals, the home was accessed via a set of external stairs and a veranda that wrapped around the whole building.

It was a far cry from their father's rough, homely hall where they had been raised in endless mild winters and bright summers, a house of two great, single-story wings of creamy sandstone, adjoined to a large stable and a huge, double-leaved, oak gate. All together they enclosed a paved courtyard that was always busy with distant cousins, customers and pony-trainers. The house had been surrounded by pastures where a pair of young dwarves could run or ride as far as they liked, as the grass beneath them rippled like oceans in the warm south-east winds. Sometimes thunderstorms taller than the mountains even sailed across the flatlands from the far-distant sea.

But that hall was sold. The ponies were sold. It was all long gone.

Before they reached the end of the veranda, Bard waved at another door, with a fresher coat of paint than most of the places they'd seen so far.

"This is my home, myself and my three children. What we call the Master's House is the town hall, now," he moved them on until they came to a less well-kept door at the end of the veranda and Bard pulled out a set of large keys. "I bought the attached house two years ago, after the owner was widowed in the dragon attack and moved in with her daughter. We had some tenants when the town was recovering, but it really deserves an artisan to make use of the shop," he nodded at the two older dwarves. "Hence why your letter of interest was so," he smiled convincingly, "alluring. Here in Esgaroth trade comes in, trade goes out, but the craftsmen - and the craft dwarves - they don't stick around. They all want to settle in Dale, try to get their wares into Erebor or sold in bulk onto a caravan going further afield. We need honest, skilled fellows here for the ordinary upkeep of our homes. I promise there'll be good money in it."

"Ay, well Kibil's the best carpenter you'll find between here and the mountains," Khagr slapped his brother on the back. Fili noted he didn't specify which mountains. Always giving himself wiggle room to renege later. But it wasn't all false; Kibil was a true artisan.

"The dragon attack?" Kili followed Bard into the house first in order to bring the subject back up, colour finally returning to his face. "That was here? Were you living here?"

"Of course," Bard said.

"Did you see the dragon?" Kili continued to trail Bard as the rest of them followed inside.

The house was dusty, and empty, with a few abandoned pieces of unpadded furniture from the previous tenants. No beds in the two small side rooms, but Kibil could knock those together in a day. Fili wondered where you bought dry mattresses in a town as wet as this.

"I saw him," Bard confirmed. Again, nothing more.

"And this is where he died, is that right?" Kili seemed oblivious to the look on their guide's face - their landlord's face - even when Fili caught his eye across the room and tried to make an 'end-it' motion behind Bard's back. "They shot him with a magic spear and he fell in the lake?"

Bard's lips went thin but at last; Kili's gregariousness had cracked something open. "It went a bit like that. But no, he didn't fall here," he pointed out the window, well-oriented to their place on the lake. "He was struck as he made his second pass, as he opened his throat full of fire. The arrow went up," Bard made a horrible motion into his own mouth with his finger, like someone knocking a tooth out, "here. Then he flew on, with sounds of great pain, and fell at the south end of the lake. We all watched the cloud of steam, large enough to blot out the moon, but it was a lawless, unseeded land back then - the dwarves had just returned to Erebor, you see - and no soul saw where the dragon went down. Many treasure hunters have gone looking, as the lake is shallow and full of sandbanks where it braids into the head of the river. But the body has never been found."

It felt like a shroud had fallen over the room. They could hear the creak of the boards beneath their feet and the jetties outside, and the distant calls of water-birds. Then Khagr turned to Bard and said brightly, "So, for the deposit, you'll take Eastern coin?"

---

Tilda was very happy to have new neighbours. The last time her father invited a bunch of dwarves over, life had gotten very exciting. Tilda knows she shouldn’t have found it exciting, as a few people had died, but no one she knew. And afterwards, the Master was caught trying to escape with the contents of the town coffers, and he and his friends were thrown out into the wilderness with a couple of skinny horses and some bread, and her Da had been elected the new master. And when they started rebuilding Erebor-Over-Dale they’d needed a lot of help from Da and the other men of Esgaroth, and everyone (at least, everyone who survived the dragon) had done very well for themselves. So it all worked out in the end, from Tilda’s perspective. The dwarves, in their way, had brought luck to the house.

The first day the dwarves moved in, they opened up the old, wooden awning of the shopfront. Tilda peered inside and saw dwarves ripping the nails out of the shelves, dwarves measuring flat surfaces, dwarves climbing up ladders, dwarves cutting up planks. There was so much activity that it took her a minute to realise there were only four. The one up the ladder caught her watching and gave her a smile as wide as the sun breaking over the mountain, and she grinned back.

“Hello! I’m your neighbour, Tilda.”

He came down off the ladder, stuck his hand through the service window. She reached out and shook it. It was rough and had the gritty texture of dust mixed with sweat, but it was very warm in the cold, autumn air. “I’m Kili. That’s my brother Fili with the tape. Those two are our uncles, Khagr and Kibil.”

There was a curse from the corner, and he made a gesture of farewell. “I’d better help with that.”

At dinner, Da was late home from the Master’s House, so she told Sigrid about the dwarves. Sigrid was eighteen and growing as grim as their Da. She never beamed like the sun. She just kind of looked at things and went, hmm, and then reminded you of chores you hadn’t done yet.

“Don’t talk to strange men,” Sigrid said with only a glance up from her carrots and sausages.

“He’s not a man. He’s a dwarf.”

“Don’t talk to strange dwarfs, then.”

Tilda rolled her eyes. “He doesn’t even really look like a dwarf, the one I talked to. Hasn’t got a proper beard.”

“Maybe it got caught in the wood lathe," Bain sniggered.

“He looked very friendly. Handsome, even,” Tilda added, raising her voice in just the way she knew would absolutely, perfectly on time, make her sister snap.

Sigrid put her fork down sharply. “Tilda. You are thirteen. Do not talk to strangers. Do not go into their house. Tell me if you see anything funny, you hear me?”

“Alright, Madame, sorry,” Tilda drew the apology out with the cultivated ire of a budding teenager.

“They’re our neighbours, Sigrid,” Bain soothed her. “They won’t be strangers for long.”

“If they’re here for long I’ll like it even less,” Sigrid muttered, picking up her fork again. “Nobody comes to this town because they want to be here, so they must be avoiding somewhere else.”

That evening, Tilda headed downstairs to the open-air laundry room, which was underneath the building and shared with the adjoining house. One whole wall opened directly onto the canal, for easy access to water or quickly rinsing off anything really nasty. It was also freezing cold as a result, so Tilda had been putting off a visit in the hope Sigrid would do the laundry for her, but Sigrid had seen the basket of dirty linens just as she was climbing into bed and told her to at least take it downstairs.

As Tilda’s foot touched the bottom stair she realised she could hear voices, deep and rough, her new dwarvish neighbours. She froze, mindful of her sister’s warning despite her curiosity. But she would also be in trouble if she didn’t get this pile of undershirts in the tub. For a moment she dithered, and in that moment the voices rose to a frenzied pitch.

“You bastard, you rotten filth. I had a good trade in Rhûn, I had loyal customers. I’ve thrown in everything. And you brought us here for one of your rackets?”

“It’s not a trick,” the other voice wheedled. “To the right buyer, this is worth more than a boatload of gold. Tomorrow I’ll go to Erebor and scout out prospects—”

“You said you had a treasured heirloom with a buyer lined up!” The first voice roared. “You said the sale was a done deal!”

“I do have a buyer. They just don’t know it yet. More than one, I’ll warrant - they’ll bid against each other for the privilege—!”

“Another speculation - another self-delusion! Give it to me, give me this drivel,” there was the sound of a sudden struggle. Tilda willed herself silent and invisible, pressed herself against the wall of the stairwell so hard she would feel the imprint of the boards on her cheek when she went to bed that night.

“Give me that stupid box!” The slap of a closed fist on flesh, and a squawk, and then worse, a scrape and the crack of something hard hitting something soft over and over. Groaning, high and weak, and then it started over again. And then there was only panting.

A clang, echoing across the canal, and the first voice whispered, “Oh Yavanna, oh first fathers, what did you let me do?”

There came a fumbling, then a splash, and then the rough sound of cloth being drawn across the ground. Heavy footsteps thudded upwards towards the neighbouring house.

Tilda gasped for air. Slowly, she lifted her foot and stepped down onto the floor of the laundry. She eased her face around the corner until she could see the room. The house on the far side of the canal still had candles in their windows and there was enough pale, burnished light sparkling on the water for her to see that the dwarves were gone.

Tilda took a couple of shaky steps into the room. A heavy, iron handle from the clothes mangler lay on the tiled floor. In the dim light she could see a dark, wet pool around it, with a smear leading to the far corner. At the edge of the floor was a small drop into the canal. Tilda saw something bobbing on the water.

Like a dream, she put down her basket and went to the water, stretching her arm out to catch the thing before it drifted down the canal. It was a flat box about the size of a dinner plate, lined with what she thought was cheap leather. It looked like the sort of box you would use to store and display gems, perhaps a necklace. This is what they had been fighting over, some priceless treasure. Kneeling on the tiles, she found the clasp and opened the box. The interior was still dry.

She almost understood the disappointment that had so enraged the dwarf. It was a large wallet - no, a sort of folder for notepaper, like where Sigrid wrote up the daily bills. When she opened it, someone had crudely folded and squashed an ink drawing to fit inside. It didn’t look like the deeds to a castle or the last will and testament of a wealthy merchant. Tilda unfolded it. It looked like a careful drawing of a tree, branches spreading to the sky and narrowing to a peak, covered in the squiggles of dwarvish letters. It didn’t even have a wax seal of contract or a signature by some great artist.

There was a splash and Tilda looked up to see a small boat in the distant darkness, rowed by a stout figure with wide shoulders. He was coming down the canal towards her. Panic coursing through her, Tilda folded the paper and its binding back inside the box, snapped it closed and pushed into the water, holding it down deep until the bubbles stopped and it had filled with water. At last it sank straight down into the canal.

She jumped up and grabbed her basket, but again her eye was drawn to the smear leading away from the discarded mangler-handle. Her gaze followed it until she saw the figure sitting in the corner, hidden beneath an old rug. She gasped, but the figure didn’t move. Tilda could hear the brush of the oars clearly, coming closer, but she took quick steps to the other side of the laundry and her fingers peeled back the top of the rug, and beneath, in the faded, golden light, in the glitter of a crescent moon off the water, a pale face—

Tilda staggered back, gagging, and ran for the stairs, dumping the basket by the door at the top and sprinting up to her bed. Sigrid was already asleep on the far side of the room and only grunted as Tilda burrowed under the blankets, dress and boots and all. She could not stop shuddering, she could not breathe and yet was breathing too fast. She could not uncurl her limbs, and at last, her mind gave in to the waning shock and she slept, deep and dreamless.

—-

Bard was home in time for dinner the next night. He enjoyed a peaceful evening with his children, too peaceful by half, for Tilda was uncharacteristically quiet. He packed a pipe after supper with Sigrid, settling across from her in front of the fire while the younger ones were getting ready for bed. There were things they needed to discuss, but he wanted a chance to just sit with her for a time.

His thoughts were interrupted by a knock on the door. Bard grumbled and got up to answer it.

“If this is town business I’ll—“ he looked down at the two young dwarves, his new neighbours.

“I’m sorry to bother you so late,” the yellow-haired one - Fili? - stepped closer. “It’s our uncle. We can’t find him.”

Bard tried not to give a sigh. “It’s a rat warren of a town, I know. He’ll find his way if he’s not too proud to ask directions.”

“He’s been gone all day,” Fili said. “We’ve walked the whole town, twice. We don’t think he even came home last night.”

Bard scratched his forehead. “Which… which one is missing?”

“Khagr,” Kili spoke up from behind his brother. One hand was gripping the railing of the veranda. “Wide, auburn beard,” he added.

“Right,” Bard let out a long sigh at last. The one who talked too much and tried to bargain for everything. He leaned forward to look up at the sky. “There’s going to be rain in the next hour. It’s dark enough without adding a downpour. He’ll have to ask for shelter and any door he knocks on will give it, they’re friendly folk all of them, I promise you. They’ll send him home tomorrow.”

Fili shook his head. “Something isn’t right.”

“Tomorrow,” Bard repeated firmly. “Come by the Master’s House if he’s not back by eleven.”

He went back inside, and sat back with Sigrid. He could see through the open door that Tilda was already in bed, which was unusually early for her, and she had the covers pulled over her face. She’d been sleeping the same way last night, too.

“What did you want to talk about?” Sigrid asked, busying herself with hanging some fresh-cleaned linens in front of the fire. There was a washerwoman that came once a week, but the younger children went through there clothes faster than that.

Bard smiled at her. “I’ve had a letter from the head of the Dale merchants’ council. He’d like us to come to a dinner he’s hosting next month - you and I, he specifies. He mentions that his eldest son will be there.”

Sigrid turned her head to give him a wry smile. “I don’t have anything good enough for a councilman’s house.”

“We can afford a dress,” Bard waved his hand around their house. “We could afford a lot of things we don’t have yet.”

“Things we don’t need,” Sigrid finished the laundry and dropped into the chair across from him. She propped her head against her hand. “Do you want me to go? In an expensive dress?”

“I think you should be flattered,” Bard said. “Yes, I think you should go. Perhaps he’ll turn out to be a nice, young man.”

“I wouldn’t have been invited when I was a ferryman’s daughter.”

“I wouldn’t have been invited when I was a ferryman,” Bard shrugged. “But I’m not going to spit on their hospitality now. Especially if an alliance means more merchants in Esgaroth.”

Sigrid laughed, and picked at a fraying piece of the upholstery. “I don’t want to be a cloistered merchant’s wife in Dale.”

Bard nodded. “What do you want, sweetheart?”

After a long silence she said. “To be the Master of Laketown. To run things well and fairly, like you.”

“Well, the bad news is that it’s an elected position, so I can fairly only give you the same chance as anyone else.”

“Or maybe I’ll rule Dale one day,” Sigrid gave an exaggerated shrug. “Why not? Just not a kept creature, trapped in a house, beholden to some arrogant sop who got lucky enough to catch her, babes hanging off her skirts - no, no, not for me,” she sighed.

Bard had no answer, but he wasn’t disappointed, either. She’d eased her mother through the last and fatal pains of childbirth. She’d raised her siblings, taught them to spell and count. She kept the house and welcomed guests to his table. At eighteen she’d already done a woman’s duty by any measure.

—-

A week later, a fisherman pulled Khagr’s body from the lake. He was floating far out to the north of the town, away from the ferry routes. The corpse was barely the shape of a dwarf any longer, but his brother recognised him by his clothes and the beads in his plaits.

“I’m very sorry,” Bard said, squeezing Kibil’s shoulder as they stood over the body, gathered in a spare sheet to keep from losing the detached bits. They were in a private dock under the Master’s House, away from the looky-loos already gathering in the town square outside. Word of a drowning had spread and people had little else for entertainment. Everybody wanted to see a corpse.

“Must have been too drunk to walk,” Kibil said in a flat voice. “Fell into the canal in the dark. He couldn’t swim.”

They went back up to the sunlit front hall, where Khagr’s nephews sat blank-faced on a bench. Fili’s arm was draped over Kili’s shoulders. Bard’s secretary was offering them two small cups of Dale brandy; Kili shook his head, but after a moment Fili took a cup with thanks. Kibil strode over and snatched the cup offered to Kili, and it was gone in a moment. Bard didn’t blame him.

Bard arranged a burial for the dwarf in the town’s graveyard on the Eastern shore. He could tell the nephews were not well pleased with this, as it was a dirt burial and dwarves preferred cut stone, but Kibil overruled them. They hadn’t seen the condition of the body, he’d protected them from that at least. Khagr needed burying as soon as possible.

“It’s strange, though,” the captain of the town guard said to Bard, as they walked from the funeral back to the long bridge that connected Esgaroth to the eastern shore. “That they found him at the north end of the lake.”

Bard glanced at him. The man squinted across the water. “All the currents in the canals flow south,” he pointed out, “towards the River Running. Bodies usually pop out on the south side of town, that’s what the grandpapas will tell you.”

Bard let his words ripen for a moment, then he asked, “Have you heard anyone express disquiet about the dwarves? I will say, he didn’t seem the most honest fellow. You think he could have crossed somebody over money? In two days? Or worse - somebody took a dislike to him just because he was a dwarf?”

The captain shrugged.

“We need good tradesfolk here. We need dwarves to feel safe here,” Bard said with an edged tone. “I don’t want people to make.. conjectures… without proof. A drunken stumble in a new town seems a lot more likely.”

“Ay,” the captain agreed. “But all the same, it’s passing strange.”

—-

The night after the funeral, Kibil sat them down at the table of their new home and told them what was going to happen next.

Fili had just finished going through Khagr’s bags and papers. He had found no valuables beyond a few coins and nothing interesting in the papers, other than a number of replies from Dale landlords declining his request for a shop lease. He had already guessed that Esgaroth was probably not Khagr’s first choice for a home. Fili was sure something was missing; he remembered Khagr packing an old box into his bag, the day they left home - their old home. It had been a flat, leather-bounded box that looked like it might have held jewellery, the sort of thing an artisan might carry to display his wares to potential customers. But he hadn’t found it anywhere in the house, so he assumed Khagr had sold the contents somewhere on their journey.

As they sat down, Kili was cooking fritters on the top of the iron stove and he kept distractedly glancing over to check the pan wasn’t burning. Fili watched Kibil, who had just brought a bottle of something amber out of a cupboard and poured a generous dram into a pottery cup.

“Right,” Kibil said, gulping the liquor. “As you’ve noticed, Khagr was broke. I think we can assume that he deceived all of us, and I’m not here to lay blame.”

“Blame who? He’s dead,” Kili said, and then folded his arms. “You’re not blaming us? He cheated us, too. He was an idiot, he lost our entire inheritance on gambling debts and wild ventures.”

The sting of it was still hot in Fili’s breast, even after almost a decade. The Stonefoots considered a dwarf fully independent at seventy-five years. Their father had died suddenly, without choosing a legal guardian for them; Fili had been a year too young to take control of the estate. Not even a year - ten months. Their father was barely under the stone when the magistrate signed everything over to Khagr, to be held in trust for his nephews until Fili came of age. Ten months was all it took for Khagr to get the stables and the house completely tied up in debts and complex mortgages, so that by the time Fili tried to wrest back control it was like a dead dwarf walking, and within a few years there wasn’t so much as a horseshoe left.

“Then you should have warned me,” Kibil growled.

Fili said quietly. “I tried.”

Kibil shot him a dark look. He cleared his throat, “But the situation remains. It was my money that funded this venture, my livelihood that’s been sold off, and I intend to recoup that loss,” he pointed one callused finger at Fili. “I’ll give you five years training as a woodworker, good training. At the end of it, you’ll have a worthy trade to support yourself and your brother. After that, you can go your own way, wherever you like. Until then, I’ll open the shop as planned and give you the lodgings and board for free, as long as you help around the house–”

“So you get five years free labour and housekeeping to boot?” Fili leaned forward, “I want a fair apprentice’s wage. Whatever the base rate is in Dale. Paid monthly.”

Kibil slammed his hand down on the table and they both jumped. “Don’t interrupt me!” he took another swig of the liquor and breathed the fumes out slowly. “I inherited Khagr’s lease. It’s my shop, my house. You should be bleeding grateful I’m offering you food and a roof over your heads. Or would you rather walk out?”

Fili balled his fists under the table until his nails dug into the skin. He was right. They had nothing. They knew nobody within three hundred miles. If they took Khagr’s few coins, Kibil could even accuse them of stealing from a dead dwarf. Were they going to walk all the way back to Rhûn? With no food and not even a decent tent? In winter?

He said at last. “You take Kili as your apprentice. Four years only. And he gets a good letter of reference at the end of it.”

Kibil glared. “Why him and not you?”

“He’s got better hands for sculpture,” Fili shrugged. “I’ve got the head for numbers. I’ll run the business side of the shop. I know how to balance the books, you can double check them whenever you like. I won’t try any funny stuff,” he held Kibil’s gaze. “I’m not Khagr.”

Kibil huffed through his moustache. “Trial period only. If there’s a single coin out of place, your brother stays and you’re out on the street.”

“Don’t talk to me like you own me, I’ll go where I like,” Kili surged forward but Fili put a hand on his chest.

He nodded at Kibil. “I want a contract for Kili’s apprenticeship. My side of things, we’ll figure out as we go.”

On the stovetop, the fritters began to smoke.

—

The tragedy did more to rally the town around their new neighbours than any efforts Bard could have managed. The drowning of Khagr the dwarf was the most horrible thing that had happened in Esgaroth since the dragon, and the truth was, people were thrilled. There is nothing better than living in peace and comfort and discussing someone else’s misfortune around the dinner table. Several particularly nosy, old biddies took to bringing meals over to the house for a few days, and so were able to make a report of the newcomers right away. “The young ones have very nice manners, and they eat heartily,” one of them said loudly to her friends in the square outside the Master’s house, and Sigrid rolled her eyes as she watched her father leaning in to listen to the gossip. “Their poor surviving uncle, ah, he’s deep in his grief. Won’t even speak when his brother’s name is mentioned.”

Sigrid saw her new neighbours on the shared staircase every couple of days, but gave no more than a passing greeting. She heard them playing music through the wall in the evenings and watched the rapid transformation of the shop downstairs from a derelict husk into a colourfully painted, tidy workspace. She heard from some of lads at the fishmongery that one of the dwarves, Fili, had been in and out of the market procuring shipments of raw wood and testing the quality of nails and brackets, and that he was already taking orders for work to pay for it all. Houses on the lake were always rotting and in need of a master carpenter’s touch, and finally they had two: it seemed that the youngest, Kili, was the assistant to Kibil, whose name was now displayed above the shop in fresh, burgundy paint.

Beyond these details, Sigrid knew and cared little about her neighbours for the first few months. She had half the town to run, as well as her own household. Da needed her more and more as the administration of Esgaroth grew. And now there was talk of building a new town at the south end of the lake, because all the young people kept leaving the lake and heading towards the Lonely Mountain, and there wasn’t enough room in the bulging, patchworked Dale to hold them. A new town would mean safer roads to the south kingdoms and a good base to protect the spreading hamlets and farms around the lake. But they needed money to build a new town, and Esgaroth had only just recovered from the dragon.

So Da was off on diplomatic errands to Erebor and to the Greenwood, trying to play them off against each other and pretend he wasn’t begging for their money. And while he was away, Sigrid had to keep things running, and make it look like it was really the town committee in charge and not Bard’s teenage daughter.

Three months had passed since their new neighbours moved in, and Sigrid finally spoke more than a word to Fili on a cold, clear afternoon near the winter solstice. She went out onto the veranda with a chair to use the daylight while it lasted. Fili was sitting at the other end, outside his own door, clearly with the same idea. He had a pile of sweaters - donated clothes from well-intentioned townsfolk whose children had grown out of them - and was trying to darn the holes.

“Hello,” he nodded at her, and glanced at her fingerless gloves. “I need to get three pairs of those. It’s our first real winter.”

“In Laketown?”

“In my life,” he grinned. “Our family haven’t been West since I can barely remember.”

There was a pause. A boatman in the canal below was calling out to a friend. The gulls cawed around empty freshwater mussels on the edge of the dock. Fili pricked himself with the darning needle and swore, quietly and in some dwarvish tongue.

“I’m sorry about your uncle,” Sigrid said dutifully.

“Don’t mention it,” she looked over to check he wasn’t offended, but he winked at her. “We weren’t that close. It was a shock when it happened, but he was probably going to come to a bad end one of these days.” He wrinkled his nose. “He always had some mad scheme and it always went wrong. I feel like I should miss him. He was the only close family our father had. But I don’t.”

“You’re closer to your other uncle?”

Fili shook his head, eyes focused on the darning. “We only met Kibil a few months ago. He’s their half-brother and there’s some bad blood around the remarriage… should I say was their half brother, since father and Khagr are both dead and he’s still here?”

“I don’t know,” Sigrid said.

“I don’t know either. I don’t know how to feel about any of it. But don’t tell your gentle townsfolk all that, they may stop bringing us all these mourning presents,” he held up the worn, thick-knit jumper with the newly-mended hole in one elbow.

Sigrid sniggered and let the silence fall between them again. She had a lot of paperwork to get through, and he looked like he had a lot on his mind.

They sat in neighbourly silence as the sun peaked low in the sky and began to descend towards the Greenwood, Sigrid with her household accounts and Fili slowly darning the other sweaters. Then Fili began to complain about finding clothes that fit his brother, as the only dwarvish gear in town came in a single size, ‘short-wide’, which left a comic gap between Kili’s shirts and his belts. In reply, Sigrid complained about her little sister growing out of her clothes by the month, and how fussy she’d become about choosing the colour and cut of the replacements, trying to pretty herself up in case some imaginary prince sailed into town in dire need of shelter and nursing. Then Fili complained he was the only one willing to scrape the ice off the commode in the mornings, and Sigrid complained that her teenage brother had started pissing straight off their back balcony into the lake as some kind of proof of his masculinity. Fili complained that his uncle still called them “you boys” even in front of Bard, and Sigrid complained that Bard called her “sweetheart” in front of the town committee even when she was trying to audit the armory. It went on like this, as the early afternoon sun sunk over the forest and into the distant keel of the mountains.

Soon it was too dark for either of them, and they were both shivering and had to get up and go inside; but halfway through the goodbyes, Sigrid thought of something else to complain about, so it took them several more minutes, and only the sound of Bain shouting “Sigrid! Where’s the boot grease?” took her attention away.

“It’ll be by his boots. He leaves it right there on the floor,” Sigrid griped.

Fili smiled. “Well. Good luck with that,” and finally they both went home and closed their doors.

To have a friend! It was intoxicating. To be young, full of worries, and then to find someone you could talk to until your toes got cold; Sigrid felt luminescent with the joy of it.

Chapter Text

Orcs had been seen at the edges of the wild, coming down from the Grey Mountains. For the first time since Erebor was reclaimed, the peoples around the lake had to start drawing the borders into their maps and sending out patrols to guard them.

For a couple of years, the old men and women of Esgaroth told each other that a few disparate raiding parties stealing radishes and sheep didn’t make an invasion. After all, not every scrap of Azog’s army was slaughtered when his son was slain and his kin driven off. And even orcs have to make a living, they jested.

The summer that Sigrid turned twenty-two, the raids became deadly. In one month, four farms were found ravaged, with no survivors, human or animal, and few bodies even to mark their fate. There were great rents in the earth as well, and the buildings were singed and blackened - but not burned. It was as if heat and some poisonous corruption had touched the lintels and beams, corroding them without fire, and leaving a foul-smelling patina on every surface.

The king of Erebor asked a rare favour of Thranduil; that he send some of his people with long memories out to the farms to make sense of it. The orcs might have some magic, or some new weapon. But even the wood elves did not recognise the traces left behind.

Patrols were increased on every border. Bard called for more volunteers for a militia to watch the Eastern shore and the bridge to Esgaroth. Bain was one of the first volunteers, with Kili behind only because he heard the news later. But it was clear that the enthusiastic bunch of young men - and one young dwarf - did not know the hilt of a sword from the pointy end.

Bard had only a handful of experienced guards and no one still in town who saw the last battle with the orcs, excepting himself. He asked Thranduil if the woodland could spare a few patient elves to help them help themselves. Thranduil sent four, with a promise of friendship, which Bard knew would cut both ways if it came to a new conflict.

“…you may rely on our aid if enemies should assail you from the mountains,” Bard read aloud to Sigrid one afternoon in the Master’s Hall. “Or if Erebor turns its eye on the untamed lands around the lake,” Bard muttered to himself, putting down the particularly affectionate letter from Thranduil he had just received.

“Why would Thranduil care? It’s nobody’s land, and he’s had a thousand years to claim it,” Sigrid took the letter and filed it away for him.

“Erebor-upon-Dale grows faster than the people of the woodland, in numbers and in the farmland needed to feed them. Right now the power of the two kingdoms is matched in many ways, but Thranduil knows that the balance will shift. He watches the far future and does not like the look of a dwarven kingdom spreading right up to the Greenwood - or worse yet, a dwarven empire.”

“Is that Erebor’s ambition, do you think?”

“Not the king who sits under the mountain today. But Thorin Oakenshield has no heir from his grandfather’s line, the dynasty that founded Erebor. His cousin Dain from the Iron Hills is the assumed heir, but if he or his children succeed to the throne, it unites two dwarven kingdoms, and Thranduil fears that is the beginning of an empire. I find Dain a cheerful fellow myself, but he has bones of steel that will not tolerate the elves standing in his way, nor any men of Dale or the Lake.”

“Is he popular in Erebor? Will he get what he wants?”

“I’m not sure. I’ve spoken to Thorin’s council recently, Balin and Dwalin in particular - you remember them, the oldest of the company apart from Oin, I believe - and they told me that most of the dwarves in the mountain today are not of Dain’s people. They are Erebor born, Ered Luin born, and they fear Dain supplanting them with settlers from the Iron Hills. So there is clamour for the king to finally marry and get an Erebor-bred prince for his people. He has plenty of eligible, aristocratic dams for him to choose from.”

“Charming,” Sigrid sat down across from her father. “Oh, that we should all be so blessed.”

Bard made a so-so motion with his hand. “Somehow I get the impression that the king prefers bachelorhood, and would have married by now if he’d wished it. But Balin says he can’t put it off forever, and if he manages to whelp an heir on some suitable lady, dwarven children grow slow, and the king is not young. Dain would not lightly give the prize of Erebor to an undersized princeling, and a succession crisis is the worst of all futures,” Bard sighed and tapped his finger on the desk. “All this, Thanduil sees coming from a great distance at a speed that is uncomfortably soon for the lifespan of an elf. He wants the Lakemen to side with him if - when - a succession crisis happens. And if possible, to sway the people of Dale and Erebor to Thranduil’s favoured candidate for the throne.”

Sigrid huffed. “Well. I’m glad the masters of Esgaroth don’t have to worry about such dramas. Not having a king gets more attractive by the day.”

“I quite agree,” Bard laughed. “Although I’m sure your sister would be delighted if I married her off for political gain to a foreign prince clad in cloth-of-gold.”

—

Bard’s house was quieter than it once was. Tilda had been accepted at a boarding school in Dale and came home only four times a year for holidays. Bain was often running about with his friends until late, and Bard got home at all hours. Sigrid liked the space and quiet. But sometimes she found herself cooking more than they needed and inviting Fili and Kili over to share, sometimes with an excuse that she needed Kili to fix a loose chair-leg or replace a rotten windowsill. She didn’t tell Da how often this seemed to happen. Not because he’d worry about the dwarves, but because he’d worry about her, alone in the house and making excuses to invite over her friends. He had more than enough worries already.

The elves who came to Laketown included one of Thranduil’s favourite captains, whom Bard had met a few times, a redheaded elf-woman named Tauriel. The elves were given lodgings in the Master’s House, the finest rooms in Esgaroth, usually kept only for high dignitaries. They were all friendly enough with the lake folk, but kept to themselves once the day’s training was done. Tauriel was the exception; she seemed to have a nervous curiousness of the humans and often wandered the edges of the canals in the evening, watching and asking questions like a child.

Bard invited her to his home for dinner several times. Sigrid was happy to host the elvish captain on short notice. It was slightly bizarre, like having a gigantic, beautiful insect come to tea, but Tauriel was so awkward at fitting in with the family’s rituals and then in turns enthused to talk about life in the forest, that she quickly endeared herself. The first night she came for dinner, Bard worried that she might get lost on her way back to her lodgings.

“Tauriel, would you like me to walk you home?”

“Da, she’s a captain of an entire forest army,” Sigrid laughed. “She can shoot a fly in the dark at three hundred paces. She’s not going to get lost.”

Tauriel was too dignified to agree with Sigrid, and too polite to refuse Bard’s concerns.

“I’ll show you back,” said Bain. “I can’t shoot a fly but I can walk that route in my sleep.”

He pulled on a coat and stepped out onto the veranda to the smell of pipe smoke. There was a grunt of surprise and Bain turned to find Kili standing up quickly.

“Bain! I was waiting for… Tauriel,” he smiled as Tauriel emerged behind Bain. “I thought I could walk you home.”

“I’m walking her home,” Bain said firmly.

“Oh, are you sure? I needed to stretch my legs anyway,” Kili blustered.

Tauriel smiled. “Why don’t you both walk me, and then once I’m safe, you can walk each other back?”

On the way to the masters’ house, Bain wanted to ask Tauriel about whether a lot of elvish women were warriors, or if it was just the Greenwood, but it felt crude to bring it up with Kili present. Kili filled the quiet with an exaggerated anecdote about a bad-tempered pony, which Tauriel seemed to find charming but fell flat with Bain. Since neither of them were getting much traction impressing the elf, most of the walk was spent with Tauriel talking about how lovely the starlight was from the peak of Erebor and a lot of elvish lore about each different celestial body. It was a long, awkward walk back for them both.

—

A couple of nights later, the young militia were out on a night training exercise and Bard was staying late at his work. Sigrid knocked on the neighbour’s door to see if the young dwarves were in. Fili opened the door.

“Do you want to come over?”

“I ate early, to see Kili off,” Fili said, but he sounded disappointed about it. He looked around at the bare-walled room. His uncle was snoring on the sofa and there was a smell of potent liquor in the air. Two bottles sat on the table, one empty and one just uncorked, but Fili looked very sober and alone. Of course, Sigrid remembered too late, Kili would be overnighting with the young militia as well.

“Want a game of cards?” Sigrid asked, trying not to stare around the house. Even though they had now lived here for years, and the shop below was colourful and full of beautifully carved wood details, the second floor still had little in the way of decoration. Just a few practical bits of furniture, sitting about with no care for art or comfort. It was like the dwarves planned to pack up and leave tomorrow.

Fili nodded at her, “Shall I bring a drink?”

Sigrid’s courage surged. “If you like.”

He grabbed the second bottle off the table and followed her next door.

Sigrid dealt out a hand to each of them while Fili poured two generous glasses. She tapped the rims together in blessing. “Won’t your uncle notice the bottle missing?”

“I don’t care. It’s our bottle too,” he put it aside and looked at his hand of cards. “He’s too drunk to climb a ladder most days. Kili’s meeting all the orders, I’m doing odd jobs where I can. He takes the money and spends it on drink, or on raw hardwood and silver that he uses to make ornamental follies no one in Laketown wants to buy.”

He played his hand recklessly, and Sigrid beat him twice in three rounds. They both drunk a little faster than was sensible. It was not a bad liquor, despite the bitterness.

“Is your brother chasing Tauriel?” Sigrid asked, when she got about halfway down the glass.

Fili looked up over his cards and gave her an embarrassed grin. “They think they’re being so secretive. Does your Da know?”

“Everyone knows,” Sigrid said. “And you… you know… approve?”

Fili laughed. “Not all dwarves are insular conservatives. Who am I to tell my brother he can’t have a little happiness?”

Sigrid felt a swell of relief inside her that she didn’t care to examine further. She put down a card.

“Are you not worried about him? She’s basically in charge of the militia. She has swords. I would be terrified to break her heart.”

“I admit, I am more worried about Tauriel,” Fili was playing more patiently, now. “You know how she is, sort of… naïve isn’t the word. She’s very serious.”

“She’s an elf.”

“You know what I mean, even elves have their humours and games. She doesn’t do platitudes or feints.”

“Always talking about the stars,” Sigrid gave him a wry smile.

He put his hand over his mouth to hide his own smile. “Exactly. I think she’s been looking for an excuse to leave the forest for a long time and she wants him to be her great love story. I’m sure Kili feels it’s real right now, but I know how fickle young dwarrows can be. I am one, after all.”

Sigrid laughed and put down a card. “Yes? A bit of a bounder, you mean?”

“Maybe,” he smirked. “I might have depths of lechery you can’t imagine.”

“Ah yes, because this town is lousy with eligible damsels leaning out their windows to catch your eye,” Sigrid slapped down her cards. “Another round to me.”

But Fili had fallen silent. She realised that might have been more of a taunt then she meant it to be. She swallowed. “Have you thought about leaving Kibil and going to Dale? To Erebor, even?”

She wished she hadn’t asked. She didn’t want to know the answer. Tilda was gone, Bain would go soon. If Fili went, it would be just her in this house doing paperwork for Da until she turned grey.

Fili let his losing hand scatter on the table and rubbed his brows. “Yes. As soon as we can. Kili’s apprenticeship will be over this winter. I’ve been saving money from the odd jobs. We’ll go the day Kibil writes him a reference to prove his training. Dale, the Iron Hills, Rhûn, anywhere. We need to get out.”

Sigrid folded her arms on the table. “I’m glad it’s so easy for you. You have no anchor here. And men can walk away easier than women.”

“We have no anchor anywhere, Sigrid,” Fili snapped. “If it goes wrong we could end up in a gutter or starving on the open road. Be glad for yourself, Laketown might be shit but it’s still a home.”

Her cheeks burned crimson. “It’s not shit. And it’s not Laketown that treats you like shit. It’s your uncle and your own bad luck.”

Fili’s expression went hard and cold and furious, and then shifted to an empty, far-away look. He hung his head. “I’m sorry. You’re right. The people of Esgaroth have been very good to us. Your Da has been very good to us. But,” He met her eye again. “I know you feel the same. You want to be more, but Esgaroth won’t let you grow any bigger.”

It was so precisely on the head that Sigrid took a moment to recover. She said at last, “Some days the lake feels like a girdle that’s squeezing me to death.”

“Do you want to play another hand?”

She held up the cup. “I’ll play to the end of this drink. Da will be home soon.”

—-

In early summer, Tilda was home from school for the holidays and following Sigrid everywhere, as if they were the closest sisters that had ever been. Sigrid would have been flattered if Tilda had also helped with the chores and errands for Da, but she seemed too distracted by gossiping about people Sigrid didn’t know as they walked about the town. Sigrid felt like she was a stand-in for all the lovely young lady-friends that Tilda was missing from school, but still, it was nice to spend time with her little sister. And she would never tell Tilda, but she enjoyed listening to the gossip.

“Morwyn Sheen is marrying Toma the Silvermonger’s son today,” Tilda said, as they rested on the public square that bordered the dock in the centre of town. They were eating a small lunch that Sigrid had packed them both this morning.

“So I’ve heard. It seems to be the only excitement this summer,” Sigrid said absently. Morwyn and Toma each came from the town’s wealthiest merchant families, and their union was one of the biggest celebrations Laketown had seen for years.

Tilda brushed crumbs off her hands. “Her Da invited most of the town to a dance tonight, they knocked down a wall in his biggest house to make a proper hall and they’ll have musicians from Dale. Are we going?”

“You want me to chaperone you?” Sigrid gave her a wry smile. “Hoping one of Toma’s younger brothers has gotten less ugly since you left?”

“I’m too good for the boys in this town,” Tilda pouted her lips and gave her hair an exaggerated pat. She grinned. “But yes, I need you to come. Da won’t let me out alone and Bain will sit in the corner drinking with his boys all night. Please come, Sigrid, I promise we’ll do something you like for fun next time.”

Sigrid laughed. “I don’t like anything fun, according to Bain.”

“Well, I promise we’ll do something boring, then,” Tilda seized her hand. “Yes?”

“Yes, yes!” Sigrid patted her hand. “Of course I will.”

Tilda squealed and jumped up. “Let’s get the rest of your silly errand list sorted, quick, so we have plenty of time to get dressed.”

Sigrid gave a groan and pretended to hold her back in pain as she slowly got to her feet. As she finally stood up straight, Tilda was waving across the courtyard. Their young dwarf neighbours were crossing the far side, Kili with a large bag of tools slung over one shoulder and Fili with a folder of building plans under his elbow.

“Hello! Hey, Kili! Fili!” Tilda waved her whole arm. The young dwarves waved back and turned to join them.

“Tilda, good to see you back,” Kili threw an arm over her shoulders as Tilda bent down to embrace him. “Mahal, can you stop growing, please? I thought you liked being closer to my level.”

Fili glanced between them. “Are you both taking a holiday?”

Tilda said, “Yes,” just as Sigrid said, “No, running messages.”

“Well, Sigrid’s not on holiday yet, but she’s just promised to take me to the wedding dance at the Silk Trader’s House tonight,” Tilda linked arms with her sister.

“Do you want to come?” Sigrid asked. “I’m sure you’d be welcome, especially if you arrive with us.”

“And spend the night dancing with my brother? No thanks, I’d rather spend the night with my head in the latrine,” Fili said at once. “We’re installing a flight of stairs tomorrow, I’ve got to help Kili finish the spindles tonight.”

Sigrid said coldly. “You know, Laketown law actually says you’re allowed to dance with people taller than you.”

Fili opened his mouth as if to make a retort, and then his brain appeared to catch up with his mouth and a flush visibly rose up his cheeks. He said nothing.

Kili scratched his chin to hide the face he was making as he tried not to laugh. He generously gave his brother a lot of time to correct the situation, and finally elbowed him. “We need to get back to the shop.”

Tilda waved them off cheerily. “Bye! Have a nice evening polishing your spindles!”

Sigrid heard Kili’s burst of laughter, but she had already turned and stormed off in the opposite direction, dragging her sister behind her.

They went to the dance after dinner. Sigrid borrowed a simple gown from Tilda, which was too short for her but looked fine buttoned over her good petticoats. She added a couple of silver hair-pins, each bearing a tiny freshwater pearl, that she had inherited from Ma. She finished it off with a nice veil over her hair that Da had given her last winterfest but she’d never worn.

The dance hall was bedecked with flowers. The music was much better than the pipers who played at their local tavern. The crowd was riotous as they danced and the bride’s brother got so drunk he fell down the stairs and had to be taken outside and rowed back to his bed. All in all, it was a lovely night, and Sigrid was glad she had been dragged out to it.

And if Tilda noticed her glancing at the door every time it opened and watching each time new guests arrived, well, she was a good enough sister not to mention it on the walk home.

Chapter Text

After the farm massacres, the orcs seemed to withdraw for a time, though patrols around the north end of the lake reported seeing bands from a distance.

Tilda had nearly finished her school year, and Sigrid wanted to go to Dale to spend a few days with her and then bring her back to the lake. Bard agreed to go too, in dire need of a rest for himself. But the morning they were due to leave there was a message asking him to remain on the lake.

“Our two neighbouring kings are coming together in council, which is a rare and troublesome enough thing in itself. They plan to converge here the day after tomorrow,” Bard was staring out the window over breakfast, his food untouched. “What a nightmare. They’ll claim they’re travelling light, without fanfare, and then they’ll turn up with all their aides and guards to try and outdo each other and we’ll have to find a blanket for every sodding one of them. I’ll have to ask Tauriel and her elves to billet in the town and clear their rooms in the Master’s House. What a mess, I don’t need this.”

“Why are they coming here at all, Da?” Sigrid asked. “If they refuse to visit each other and have to use you as an inn, what’s so important it can’t be trusted to a letter?”

Bard glanced at her, and then checked that Bain was still downstairs. He said softly, “It’s a war council. Something is brewing. Thranduil and Erebor are considering an invasion of the Grey Mountains, rather than let the orcs choose their moment to strike. They will have to work together, though, and that they have never done except under the great threat of Azog and the army of the Eye. But they’re both on edge and if there’s another raid from the north I think it will be enough to provoke them.”

“You think it’s a bad idea,” Sigrid guessed.

“I don’t want an end to these peaceful days. Esgaroth is well defended from armies, unless the orcs can muster another dragon on short notice. The bridge piles are in good working order. There is a mechanism at the central guard tower that will cause them to be broken at a moment’s notice, and once the bridge is down no siege will starve us for fish or water. Why would we go looking for a fight when only a fool would waste their strength on us? The orcs will be after Erebor and the Greenwood palace, not our little town,” Bard squinted back out the window at the late summer sun on the lake. He added quietly, “But what do I know? I’m a ferryman.”

He turned to his breakfast and picked at it. “I have to stay and preach peace, even if it’s futile. I’m sorry, we won’t be going to Dale this week. I’ll write and ask one of the councilors to host Tilda when she gets out of school.”

“What? Da, that’s not fair, I can go on my own!” Sigrid cried. “It’s one day’s walk!”

“Not with the raids so recently. We just never know.”

“It’ll be full daylight and a busy road most of the way there!”

“Sigrid, I can’t be worrying about you and your sister on top of everything else.” Bard swept his hand through the air. “I’m Master of this town, I’ll not be seen sending two ladies unaccompanied on the roads.”

Sigrid fumed. ‘Two ladies’! Where was he getting these airs? Bain was allowed to go traipsing around in the dark with his ill-armed young militia, but she couldn’t take care of herself for one trip to Dale? She stood up with her empty plate and made a proper crash of putting it in the wash-tub. Then she turned back and raised her hand.

“I’ll ask the lads to come with me,” she said brightly.

“I don’t think a couple of carpenters are going to be much good if you’re set upon by bandits,” Bard countered.

“You said it yourself, it’s about appearances,” Sigrid waved her hand around their home. “What better bodyguard for the Master’s daughter than two strong, local dwarves?”

Ten minutes later, she was standing in their neighbour’s doorway watching Kili shove spare clothes into two bags while Fili recited a list of instructions to their hungover uncle.

“Sorry to interrupt your breakfast,” Sigrid said, looking over the half-empty plates.

Kili grinned at her as he pulled his boots on. “Interrupt any time you like. Brilliant idea. I haven’t been up the valley since the harvest festival last year.”

“…so it’s just Mrs Gunny’s leaking roof that’s urgent, delay the rest until we’re back,” Fili ticked off on his fingers. “There’s an order from the smithy due tomorrow so you’ll need to be in the shop to check it. It’s paid in advance so don’t let him wheedle more out of you just because the price of iron is going up.”

“Fine,” Kibil turned to Sigrid. “How long will you be gone?”

“Three days,” she smiled at him, but he just grumbled and slouched away back to the bedroom.

Kili picked up his plate and shoveled the last of his breakfast into his mouth with one sweep. Fili picked up the other bag and nodded up at Sigrid. “Well, let’s not waste any more daylight.”

“Manners, Fili, we’re escorting an esteemed dignitary on behalf of the Master himself,” Kili gave an exaggerated bow to Sigrid as they headed out the door. “After you, your honouress.”

—

It was one of those late summer days that was perfect for walking, warm but overcast by enough clouds to keep the direct sun off the rocks. They trudged at an easy pace along the well-worn road, stopping to eat oat-biscuits and to drink from the clear streams as the land rose towards the mountain. They sung songs when the incline wasn't too steep and they had breath to sing, and Fili and Kili taught Sigrid a little Khuzdul, at first claiming it would be good for diplomacy in Bard's councils, but mostly it was curses. Occasionally they passed carts from Dale going in the other direction, and then were passed by riders from behind racing messages to Erebor. Unlike walking the streets of Laketown, no one hailed them or asked them their business. They were three unknown travellers, young and free on the road.

Pleasant though the trip was, Sigrid was ready for it to be over by the time they reached the outlook and saw Dale. Her feet ached and her Laketown garments were far too heavy for the heat, even after she packed her outer skirts into her bag and rolled her sleeves all the way up. She didn't know how dwarves could possibly get around with all their layers and the stoutness of their limbs.

They stayed in a guest house next to the school, run by a middle-aged woman from Esgaroth who had come over in the early days of rebuilding the city. Bard had promised to pay for the whole trip, since the dwarves were only going on his request, but after the landlady warned them about a loose tread on the stair, Kili fixed it for her in a few minutes with the tools from her shed and she was so pleased she gave the dwarves their room for free.

While Fili and Kili ordered dinner and baths at the guesthouse, Sigrid went to the school to see if Tilda was allowed to be released yet. The porter at the gatehouse said Tilda couldn't leave as there was a great feast tonight for the families of the graduating girls, hadn't she known? No, Da had forgotten or skipped over that part of the confirmation letter. The porter looked her up and down.

"There is an expectation of propriety," he said carefully. "Do you have anything more... fitting, to wear?"

Sigrid shook her head. She'd never gotten round to buying an expensive dress for fancy parties in Dale, and even if she had, it would not have occurred to her to bring it. At this late hour, it was doubtful a tailor would find her something on a few minutes notice, even in this busy city.

"Many esteemed young ladies have absent families but will still be celebrated at the feast. I suggest you collect your sister tomorrow," the porter inclined his head towards the exit.

Sigrid went back to the guesthouse, hot and angry. When Fili and Kili heard what happened they were verbosely outraged on her behalf, perhaps overdoing it only a little, and she was somewhat mollified. They spent the evening in a nearby tavern, where some Orocarni dwarves passing through towards Ered Luin recognised Fili and Kili’s accent and joined their table to share nostalgic stories of the East.

Kili asked if they were off soon, and they all were, except for one dwarf only a little older than them who shook his head. “I’m sick of making the journey every year. I’m staying here in Dale after this season, with my wife and two wee bairns.”

“Can’t they travel with you?” Kili asked. “When we were children, our father took us on his trading caravan from Ered Luin back to Rhûn, and that was before the roads were restored.”

“Oh, never, it’s not the distance,” the dwarf’s brother laughed. “His wife’s a Dale-woman, twice his height and three times his temper. They welcome half-breeds here in the West but not in the Orocarni’s, oh no! He’s stuck here for her short lifetime, at least.”

Sigrid could not help but notice Fili sit up a little, suddenly paying attention to the conversation. But, understandably, the dwarf in question took offense to his wife’s natural death being discussed and started berating his brother until he got a shame-faced apology, so there was no way to bring the subject up again.

It was a boisterous and bellowing evening, with Sigrid happy to sit on the edge of the bench nursing a beer and listening. Again she felt the delight of anonymity, of the chance to feel like part of the group, yet not watched by prying eyes. She thought of Fili's plan to leave Laketown as soon as they were able, and felt not only the pain of losing her friends, but also an undertow of jealousy dragging at her spirit. If she didn’t have Da relying on her, if she wasn’t just a woman alone, she could live here, or on the road, or anywhere.

The next morning, they met Tilda in the school courtyard. Her hair was done up in elaborate braids and she was clothed in a dress and jacket of finely-spun Dale cotton, bright green and edged in yellow, with tiny flower details embroidered around the collar. She threw herself into Sigrid's arms with a squeal. She was getting heavy - Sigrid would even say buxom - and her voice had shed the sharp tone of an eternally grumpy teenager, along with the edges of her Laketown brogue.

"Sigrid, I missed you so much!" She drew back and squeezed her sister's hands. "The porter said you arrived too late for the feast last night, I hope there wasn't trouble on the road?"

"Not at all. We just took our time," Sigrid pulled her in for another hug. Tilda introduced her to several friends who were also being collected by parents or in some cases, governesses and servants. Despite a wash at the guesthouse, Sigrid still felt gritty and a bit fetid from yesterday's walk, and increasingly out of place as she shook soft hands and kissed rose-scented cheeks. It took some time to extract them both from the crowd of lovely, well-educated, eminently marriageable young ladies. By the time they got out the school gate and back to the paved Dale street, Fili and Kili were sitting on a nearby step looking painfully bored. They sprang up to great Tilda in turn, and there was another round of exclamations about how smart she looked and why in the world did she smell like she'd fallen in a wood-elf latrine? Tilda withstood the mockery with a haughty grin and retorted that they better learn their station in life now that she was a proper lady.

"Right," Tilda grabbed Sigrid's hand. "Let's go to the market. I've got so much I need to stock up on before we go home."

The central market of Dale was crammed onto a large courtyard bordered by workshops on one side and a retaining wall with a stomach-churning drop on the other. Along the top of the wall was a wide promenade that looked out over the valley, with a clear view of the road leading from the gate of Erebor down towards the lake. When Tilda's shopping list was exhausted they bought bottles of unfermented cider, bags of pastries, and far too many honey-treats. They sat on the curb of the promenade with their backs to the mountain and ate the makeshift lunch as the sun peaked in a cloudless sky. The north arm of the lake glimmered far in the distance.

Tilda could not sit still, perhaps because she had not walked several hours uphill the day before. Suddenly she called to them. "Sigrid! Fili! Kili! Come look!"

Full of pastries and cider, they heaved themselves up and came to the edge of the promenade to follow where she was pointing. A few other pedestrians had stopped to look down as well. There was a cluster of figures riding along the road, outwards from Erebor, with no banners but in a formation that looked more formal than a trading caravan. They were passing directly below, about a hundred feet away, close enough to see their stern faces and fine clothes that glinted with gilded embellishments. The leading dwarves all wore light suits of armour, with helms covering most of their faces.

"That's the king, that's Thorin Oakenshield, near the front with the blue cloak," Tilda cried. She pointed. "And that's his cousin, Dain, lord of the Iron Hills, and I think the one behind them is Dain's son - he's also a Thorin, we had to learn all of them in our politics classes. I wonder where they're going?"

Sigrid said before she could stop herself, "To a meeting in Laketown." She remembered that the war council was supposed to be a secret, but then again, the procession was travelling in broad daylight in front of the whole city.

The king and his retinue were turning down the road away from Dale, now, so that they had their backs to the market promenade. Sigrid took a step away from the edge and as she did so, she realised there was someone standing a few feet away, staring at them.

It was a small person; not a child, by the lines on his face and the expense of his clothing. His face and shape was very familiar to Sigrid, and the reverse must be true, because he had a look of absolute focus on them. But he wasn't looking at Sigrid. She followed his eyeline and realised he was staring with wide-eyed confusion at Fili, at the cragged profile of Fili's face. Fili was still leaning out to gaze after the king's procession as it shrunk into the distance.

At last, Sigrid remembered who the person was. "Bilbo!"

The hobbit's gaze snapped from Fili to Sigrid. He opened his mouth first in surprise and then spreading to a cautious grin. "Oh, could that be... Bard's eldest, am I right?"

"Sigrid," she reminded him, touching her chest. Bilbo hurried to close the gap between them and stuck out his hand for her to shake.

"Of course, of course, and that can't be... Tilda?" He leaned around Sigrid as the others came over as well. "You were just about my height when we last met."

Tilda gave a delicate curtsy. "Hello, Mr Bilbo." She ushered Fili and Kili over to join them. "Mr Bilbo is a hobbit from way over in the far West. He's famous. He's the one who woke up the dragon," she said. "Didn't you, Mr Bilbo?"

“Erm, yes,” Bilbo winced. "Just Bilbo is fine, please, what a delight to see you all," he clapped his hands, and then once again his eye was drawn towards their dwarvish companions. "Now, I was not eavesdropping, obviously," he wrung his hands together, "but I thought I heard Tilda say your names were Fili? And Kili?"

"Pleased to meet you, sir," Kili gave a little curtsey as well, and Tilda punched his arm. "Ow, Tilda! Did they teach you that in finishing school?"

"What are you doing here?" Sigrid frowned. She had neither seen nor heard a word of Bilbo since that night six years ago when Bard had smuggled the dwarves into their home and everything had changed. She heard Bilbo had left the Master's House the next morning, back when it really was still the Master's House, sailing away with the party of dwarves to reclaim Erebor. The dragon had come the next night and erased most of her memory of one small, wet hobbit dripping onto her kitchen floor. She wasn't even sure they'd exchanged a single word.

"I - I live in Erebor," Bilbo said, squinting a little in the bright sunlight. "I stayed, after, you know. The battle and all the business of reclaiming the mountain. Thorin was - the king was - he needed time to recover, and they asked me to stay. The rest of the Company, I mean," he waved his hand, "They were struggling to... manage his illness, from the exertion of the quest, the battle… it was a difficult time. And I stayed until he was back to his old self. I've been here ever since," he shrugged and gave a slightly sad smile. "But I don't like being closed in by a roof all the time, so I come to Dale to get out of the mountain. Buy seeds and plants for a little garden I've got growing on the south slopes, that sort of thing. And what are you all doing here?"

Sigrid waved her hand at her sister. "You are looking at a newly-educated young lady. Tilda's been schooled in Dale and we're taking her home to the lake tomorrow."

"Ah! And you," Bilbo folded his arms, but one finger still pointed at the dwarves. "Friends? Are you from Erebor?"

"Oh, no, we came for the girls," Kili laughed, and at Tilda's snigger he corrected himself, "With Sigrid, I mean. Just to keep her company on the roads, at their father’s request. We're Bard’s neighbours."

"Laketown dwarves?" Bilbo asked, raising his eyebrows.

"From a town near Rhûn, originally. Came to Esgaroth when they were rebuilding Erebor-Over-Dale, just to make a living," Fili answered. There was a note of caution in his voice that Sigrid could not help but agree with. She thought Bilbo came off as a friendly chap, but it still seemed like a lot of questions in very short succession.

"I see," Bilbo seemed distracted by some thought, and then he said with a broad smile that seemed theatrical and hollow. "Do you know, I was going to Laketown tomorrow too!"

"Really?" Tilda wrinkled her nose. "Why?"

Bilbo waved his hand towards the road where the royal procession had disappeared. "Well, I go where the king goes, of course."

"But not... with the king?" Sigrid pointed down the road.

"No. Hate ponies. Rather walk," Bilbo clicked his tongue. "But it did not even occur to me that I should have hired a, uh, bodyguard," he indicated Fili and Kili. "Would you by any chance mind if I travelled with you?"

Sigrid, Tilda and Fili did not answer, but Kili, oblivious to the tension, did so at once. "Of course! You're very welcome, Mr Bilbo," and this time he did give a proper, deep bow. "Anything for a friend of the King Under The Mountain."

They arranged to meet the next morning at a little tea house just beside the West Gate of Dale. That night in the guesthouse, Fili pulled Sigrid aside while Kili and Tilda were trying to pack all of Tilda's market purchases into the small bags they'd brought.

"Was it just me, or was our new friend clearly lying in order to join us?" Fili asked her. "Do you know anything about him? What are his people - these hobbits? Some kind of forest sprite?"

"From what I've heard, they're mostly farmers," Sigrid shrugged. "I know the really expensive pipe-weed all comes from the Shire, but you don't see hobbits themselves this side of the Misty Mountains. I had no idea Bilbo was still living in Erebor. Da's never mentioned him since the night the King's Company came through our house on their way to fight the dragon."

"The King's Company was in your house?" Fili raised an eyebrow. "You never told me that."

"They came. They made a mess. They left," Sigrid shrugged. "But that's why Da got so involved in the battle for the mountain, you know. He helped them in Laketown and the king came to trust his honesty enough to broker the alliance between Erebor, the Iron Hills army, and the wood elves. Without Da, it's possible the armies would have been riven and the orcs would have overwhelmed the whole land before Erebor-Over-Dale could even begin."

Both Fili’s eyebrows were raised now. "Well," he shook his head. "If I'd known that, I'd have made sure the rent was on time more often."

"Maybe this is about Da," Sigrid said, chewing on the inside of her cheek. "There's a very important council convening on the lake tomorrow. Maybe Bilbo wants to make certain that Da is still honest."

“It’s a bit late to start spying now, when the council will be over before Bilbo gets there,” Fili pointed out.

“Maybe it’s the long game,” Sigrid said. “There’s some disquiet in Erebor, because the king needs to marry and get an heir, but his cousin hopes to claim the throne before any child is of age, or somesuch. Da says if there’s a civil war over it, Esgaroth will have to choose sides. Perhaps Bilbo was sent to scout which faction Da would prefer.”

"So tomorrow, we keep all conversation to pleasantries," Fili folded his arms. "Fish and the weather and the price of iron. I'll let Kili know."

"Tilda isn't much for subterfuge, but I guess she's been away so long she's unlikely to say anything incriminating," Sigrid shook her head. "Oh, what are we saying? This is ridiculous! Da has nothing to hide, he's never been anything but fair to both kingdoms. The hobbit's not a spy. He probably just doesn't like ponies."

—

Sigrid somewhat hoped that Bilbo would not be there when they arrived at the pre-arranged teahouse, but they had no such luck. He was sitting at a table outside with a walking stick and a small bag slung over his shoulder, but quite clearly not enough luggage for an overnight journey. Sigrid gently suggested that Tilda stick close to the hobbit, as the two of them would probably be best-matched in their walking pace, and she did not want anyone getting separated alone. She thought Tilda would find it easy to entertain Bilbo on the return journey, while she set a fast pace with Fili and Kili down the valley. But Bilbo seemed very capable of catching up with them every time Sigrid thought she'd managed some distance, so all she ended up with was a very annoyed Tilda who kept asking them to stop and give her a rest.

In this way they made a good pace back to Esgaroth and reached the city gate in time for a very early dinner. Sigrid took them on the shortest route to the main courtyard outside the Master's house. There were armed guards, elves and dwarves, posted at each entrance to the courtyard and at the doors of the house, but they made no attempt to harry them as Sigrid walked to the bottom of the steps. She held out her hand for Bilbo.

"Well, it's been lovely to see you again, Bilbo," she bowed to him as they shook. "Your king will be inside with my Da and the rest of the gathering. I've got to get my sister home but please, next time you're on the lake, do come over for tea."

"Wait, why don't you just pop in with me," Bilbo was trying to hold onto her hand by shaking it for far too long. He looked at Tilda and the dwarves. "I'll introduce you to everyone. Come on."

Sigrid extricated herself and backed up. "It's quite alright. I know there's a very serious meeting going on, I really don't think they want to be interrupted on our account."

And despite a last, feeble protest from Bilbo, they left him standing there and hurried off. As they walked out of the courtyard, Sigrid heard the door open and glanced back to see an old dwarf with a neatly-combed, white beard coming down the steps, asking loudly, "Bilbo? What in Durin's name are you doing here?"

It was both gratifying and alarming to have at least the vague shape of her suspicions confirmed: Bilbo had lied to follow them home. What had he been prying for? And had he found it?

—

They were all so exhausted that after some bread and cheese from Sigrid's pantry, the dwarves parted ways and went home while Tilda and Sigrid went straight to bed. It wasn't even dark out, but Sigrid was hoping to feel the comfort of a familiar mattress in her own home. Instead she felt rather brittle and sad. The holiday had ended before she’d really got the hang of it. Nevertheless, she couldn't keep her eyes open for long.

She was awoken by the clunk of the front door. It was pitch dark outside, and after rolling over she had the headache you get after letting an afternoon nap go on too long, and her mouth tasted horrible from going to bed right after eating cheese. After a few moments listening to Bard clatter around the kitchen, she got up and went out, wrapping a blanket over her nightgown.

Bard had lit a single candle and was polishing off the last of the bread and cheese. He jumped up to embrace her. "I was just about to check if you were home. I assume Tilda is safe and asleep?"

Sigrid nodded. "How did the war council go?"

"Depends on whether you wanted a war," Bard said grimly. They sat down at the table. "They are drawing up plans for a combined force, and sending scouts to look at how the land lies and where it is guarded. But they have not agreed for certain that they will strike first. I don't know whether I made any difference. I felt like I was just there to take notes."

"I'm sure you spoke well, it's just whether they chose to hear you," Sigrid squeezed his hand.

"Did you enjoy Dale? Is Tilda well?"

"Very much, and very well," Sigrid nodded. "But we did have one strange encounter," she told Bard all about the meeting with Bilbo, trying to give an outsider's perspective and not colour the story with her suspicions.

Bard was as bewildered as she was about what the hobbit could have been looking for. "I did notice Bilbo turn up suddenly this evening, but he wasn't admitted to the council room until after everyone had retired. I was mostly annoyed about having to find yet another guest bed, but he settled himself on a bit of comfortable floor in the king's room." Bard huffed out a long breath, making the candle flicker. "I suppose he must have been looking for any crack in my loyalties," he said at last, finishing the last bite of his dinner. "Thorin Oakenshield has doubted them before. I don't like the king sending his sneaky, little assistant to bother my children, but we have nothing to hide, so I wouldn't worry yourself. I've made it clear to the woodland and Erebor that I will first and foremost do what is best for Esgaroth. Given their mission to quell the Grey Mountains will be in defence of the lake, we have promised supply routes and aid if they require it, and in equal measure to each kingdom. And they've both offered fair reward if our fealty is true."

"What reward?" Sigrid frowned.

Bard smiled. "Erebor and the Greenwood will each put in a share to build the new town, on the south bank. I've told them their people will be as welcome as Lakemen or Dalemen. It's early still, but I think they all like the idea of a strong foothold at the head of the river."

"Da, that's brilliant news!" Sigrid hugged him. "I only wish there weren't these rumours of war--"

There was a muffled shouting, and then a bang. Bard and Sigrid fell silent. More shouting, more than one voice. It was coming through the shared wall. The voices fell and rose in pitch and fury. Sigrid looked at her father.

"We should go over there," she whispered, as if they could be heard through the wall over the yelling.

"It's not our business," Bard slumped. "And I've been up since dawn."

"Da! Go over there!" Sigrid snapped at him. He looked ready to continue arguing, but there came a howl, slurred and wordless - not Fili or Kili, Sigrid was sure of it - and another crash. Bard finally got up and hurried to the door.

Sigrid followed in bare feet, wrapped in the blanket, her hair hanging loose over her shoulders. They strode the length of the veranda to their neighbour's house. Bard thumped his fist on the door. "Everything alright in there?"

"Don’t you have a spare key? Just open it," Sigrid hissed. She was wracked suddenly by visions, she didn't know where from, of broken bottles dipped in blood, of brandished slabs of wood, of scuffling bodies with fists or feet pummelling each other. Her heart was racing and against any sense she imagined only Fili, Fili hurt, Fili lying dead, there was no one else in her mind. Her throat was heaving up bile with the panic.

Bard waited. There was quiet. Then they heard the bar shoot back and the door was flung open by Kibil.

Because of their height, they could see everything over his head. The room was tidy and looked just as it had when Sigrid had come by three days earlier. A single chair was overturned by the table, but there were no bottles visible, no weapons. Three cups of tea sat on the kitchen counter, still steaming.

In the middle of the floor, Fili lay propped up on one elbow, his other hand pressed to his ribcage. He was coughing, his breath winded, but there was no sign of blood and his clothing was not even askew. Kili knelt over him protectively, half turned towards him and half towards their uncle.

Kibil blocked the doorway. His eyes looked more sober than Sigrid had seen him for a long time. His expression behind the beard was pinched and his teeth were gritted, but he said in a calm voice. "We're fine."

"You made a lot of noise," Bard said. "I don't want any disturbances in this house."

"I'll run my house how I like," Kibil started to shut the door, but Bard slapped his hand against it to hold it open.

"It's my house, Master Carpenter. If I hear any more brawling, you'll have your week's notice and then I'll find a new tenant," he nodded at Fili. "Are you hurt, son?"

Fili stood up with barely a wince. "It was a misunderstanding. Our apologies, Bard."

Bard let go of the door. "That's your only warning," he said quietly to Kibil. "Have a good night."

Kibil let him step back onto the veranda before he slammed the door. Bard put his arms around Sigrid and led her back to the warmth of their own kitchen. Her shoulders were heaving and she suddenly began to sob, her cheeks hot with the shock and a growing shame of how transparent her fears must have been.

"It's alright, it's alright," Bard sat her down in a comfortable chair. "Fellows stuck under one roof will find reasons to fight. They'll be fine," Bard half crouched beside the chair so that he could hold her while she sat. She turned her face into his chest to try and muffle the stupid, ugly sobs that she could not stop. "He'll be fine," Bard whispered. "You saw him, he was fine."

---

Bard left early to bid the two Kings farewell, one riding off along the bridge and one by boat towards the wood. Tilda was still sleeping and Bain took off after breakfast to go to his militia duties. Sigrid dressed and dithered around the house, but listening all the time. When she heard the neighbour's door and heavy footsteps on the planks outside, she grabbed her boots, Da’s spare coat, and shoved them all on with cursory knots.

From the top of the stairs she saw Fili heading along the walkway beside the canal. She took the stairs two at a time and caught up with him before the first bridge. He turned at the sound of her footsteps. It was another blue, clear day, but colder than it had been during their trip to Dale. A few last swallows swooped over the water behind him, calling to each other, chewing up the insects before they disappeared south for the winter.

Fili looked unflustered and uninjured. He had a bag over his shoulder with his order book and tape measure, and a pencil tucked behind his ear. If he had asked her what the hurry was, Sigrid thought she might even have believed the whole scene last night had been a bad dream. But he just looked at her, and waited for her to speak.

"Is that the first time?" Sigrid asked, shoving her hands in her pockets. "Or has he done it before?"

Fili sighed and she swore he was on the verge of rolling his eyes. She wanted to shove him, but knew that she could never strike someone she loved in anger. "You needn't fuss. No, he hasn't gone that far before. But he's a flabby old drunk and he hits like a kitten," he tried to give her a smile but it didn't look like much of a smile. "It would be easy for me to hit him back and not stop until he wasn't moving, but what would that get me? He has us. He has us, he has us stuck on this cursed, floating crate in a swamp," his voice dropped to a ragged growl and he looked over the water.

"And what if he does it again? What if next time it’s your brother?" Sigrid shuddered. "Just leave. Just walk out. Kili is trained, he doesn't need a letter, his skills will be the proof of his trade."

Fili swallowed and looked up at her. "He found my money," he said softly. "He searched my things while we were in Dale. Accused me of dipping into the shop's coffers. It was mine, all my work, nothing to do with the business," Fili slapped his chest with one hand, as if he could possibly think that Sigrid wouldn't believe him. "So now he claims I'm contracted to him and any wages I earn are his, even though that was never the arrangement. If we walk out we have nothing, Sigrid. We’re paupers."

She hung her head and sat down on a ledge bordering the canal. Fili sat down beside her. They stared over the walkway and into the lagoon across the way, at the small boats bobbing in the ripples. Sigrid tried to think of a solution. Bard could find them a job. Find them another house, loan them the deposit without interest. Would Da do that for her, if she asked? Probably not. Da was so honest, he could not be seen doing favours for her friends. And they would still be stuck in Laketown. Kibil might just make them come back to the house above the carpenter’s shop, with threats or lies. Sigrid had no idea what he was capable of.

Fili reached over and put his hand over hers, where it rested on top of her knees. His hand was warm and stout, callused on the palm but soft at the fingertips. She laced her fingers with his and she felt him go very still, as if he hadn’t realised what he’d done until she’d responded. She reached across her lap and wrapped her other hand on top, as if to keep him from pulling away. Their elbows bumped. She could feel the hair that grew thicker above his wrist, just below the hem of his sleeve.

Their entangled hands rested on top of Sigrid’s leg for a long time. She felt his thumb stroking along the blade of her palm. She wished they could sit here like this for the whole day, looking at the grey water and the rotting boats, and stop thinking, stop worrying, and just be nothing but their warm hands.

He looked up at her until she turned her head and met his eye. "Will you marry me?" He asked.

"What?" Sigrid laughed.

"With Bard's blessing, if he'll give it. We could leave together. That new town everyone's talking about, at the south end of the lake, we could go there and help build it. You and me, and Kili can have his own workshop, and--"

Sigrid ripped her hand away and stood up. "Well, I'm glad you found the words to ask at last, now that you need a dowry from me."

She stepped away from him, resisting the urge to curse him, but her throat had closed over with hot, molten rage and she couldn't have spoken if she tried. She turned and marched off, back up the stairs to her front door. As she went inside she looked back once, and saw him still sitting beside the canal. His head dropped into his hands and he covered his face. She shut the door with a snap behind her.

Chapter Text

As autumn bit down on all of them, Lakemen hunters went out one morning and found deer and wild pigs ripped apart near the Eastern bank of the lake. Murmurings of out-of-season starlings were seen in the sky as night fell, moving in panicked, black clouds back and forth across the water. An old fisherman said he pulled up his boat at a beach just past the northern rocks and saw deep troughs leading down to the water, like someone had pulled narrow rowboats out of the forest and down to the edge of the lake, but not quite into it.

Tauriel was often in the Master's House, bringing her king's messages to Bard. The young Lakemen militia no longer had their elvish teachers, but the elves were often in Laketown, being ferried back and forth from the mouth of the tributary that led up to their palace. There were more and more armed companies being sent out by Thranduil. They came back with stories of orcs lurking just outside of the fences and fields that marked the cultivated lands of Erebor-Upon-Dale.

Sigrid found Bard one day, sat at his desk in the Master’s Hall with unanswered letters in a pile, staring out the leadlight window with his chin in his hand.

“It doesn’t make sense,” he muttered to Sigrid as she came in. “The element of surprise would give them an advantage. If they’re planning a war, why warn us? Why all this… goading?”

Sigrid began to sort the letters into piles by priority; this today, that tomorrow, those by next week. There was no time for orcs when the letters still needed to be answered.

“Perhaps the fear of war is a means to something else,” she said distractedly. “Like the beaters rousing the birds ahead of the hunters.”

–--

When Tilda went to the workshop under the house, only Kili was there. Tilda had noticed that Fili seemed to be avoiding everyone in Bard’s household.

“Hello,” she let herself in the door instead of leaning over the customer window. “Are you busy?”

“I’m always busy, but you can bother me anyway,” Kili looked up from the post he had on the lathe. He was in a loose shirt rolled up to the elbows and there was sawdust in his hair, which he’d tied up behind his head.

“Why don’t you just cut it?” Tilda asked, leaning on the workbench nearby. “Your hair. It’d be safer.”

“Why don’t you just wear trousers instead of skirts?” Kili asked, stopping the lathe to inspect some small catch in the grain of the post.

“That wouldn’t be proper,” she shrugged, and she added primly, “And I look so good like this.”

“Asked and answered,” Kili grinned. He put down his skew tool and sat up on his stool. “Are you looking for gossip?”

“Not specifically. Do you have some?”

“No, I was hoping you would. Fili’s been an absolute chalk lump for days. Do you know why?”

Tilda shook her head. After a moment she wrinkled her nose. “Sigrid has seemed particularly bossy this week.”

They said at the same time, “Asked and answered.”

Kili sighed, picked up the stool and came to sit across from her at the workbench. He folded his arms and laid his face down on them. “I’m so tired. We’ve got enough work for three carpenters but Kibil doesn’t get up until noon and by teatime he’s too pickled to hold a hammer. I haven’t been out with Tauriel in weeks. And now I have to do the invoices because Fili’s saying he won’t lift a finger to help Kibil until he gives him back the money he took.”

Tilda felt herself go a little cold and still, as if she’d suddenly lost a lot of blood. She said, trying to make it sound casual. “Do you think that’s safe? Making Kibil angry?”

Kili raised his head. “What’s that tone for?”

“Da said he had to go over there and tell Kibil not to cause trouble the other day,” Tilda knotted her fingers on the bench. “He wouldn’t say what happened but he told me to stay away from Kibil if I could help it.”

Kili rolled his eyes. “What’s Kibil going to do, fire me?”

The feeling struck like an arrow in Tilda’s breast: she had to tell him everything. About the box in the canal. About the figure sitting under the rug in the laundry. About the handle of the mangler, and the dwarf sitting under the rug. And how his head—his head—his head was not the right shape, beneath all that blood—

Kili noticed that her face was blotchy and tense as if she was trying not to cry. “Tilda, are you alright?”

“Kili,” Tilda said quietly. “Did your uncle have a box?”

“Does my uncle have a box? What does that mean?”

“Not him,” Tilda said. She took a slow breath to quell the tears. She had to be brave. “The drowned one. When he arrived on the lake, did he bring a box?”

Kili sat up. “Yes, Fili said he did. We never found it.”

“I know where it is,” Tilda said, so quiet she almost couldn’t hear herself. “It’s beneath us. Sunk under the house. All these years.”

“How do you know?”

“I saw it go in,” Tilda said. “The night after you arrived in Laketown. I saw the box go in the lake. I opened it, and there was no treasure, just an old drawing of a tree. And then I saw… I saw how Khagr got in the lake.”

Kili’s hands were flat on the workshop and his face had gone quite grey. “Are you making this up? Are you trying to get Kibil in trouble so your Da kicks him out?”

The tears were in the corner of her eyes again, but she repeated the thought over and over that she had to be brave. “No. No, I would never lie about something like that, I just didn’t tell anyone before now.”

How could she explain? She’d been thirteen. She couldn’t tell the dwarves apart in the dark, she’d only heard their voices and seen the silhouette rowing the dinghy. She didn’t know who had thrown the box in the canal. She didn’t know who had held the mangler-handle. She’d only just met them, so briefly that day.

“Why not?” Kili asked.

“I heard it happen but it was dark and I couldn’t see…”

Tilda covered her face, then looked up at the ceiling. She made a strangled noise of frustration, at herself, at the unfairness of it. She had been a child. And Kili’s smile had been so warm, something new and interesting in this damp, dead-end town.

She said at last, “I thought it might have been you. It might have been you, or your brother, who did it. And if I had told Da what I heard, the town would have driven you out. Or worse. In Dale they hang murderers.”

How could she explain? She knew now that if she had told her father, that first day, their whole lives would be different. The dwarves might have gone straight back to the East before Tilda even knew them. But the lake was good at holding things, at keeping things close, and so were children.

Kili was silent for a long time. Tilda didn’t ask him for anything. Suddenly he was on his feet and heading for the stairs at the back of the workshop, down to the shared laundry room. Tilda hesitated, wondering if she should just go, wondering if Kili would ever be friends with her again. Then she got up and hurried down the stairwell to find Kili standing at the open edge of the room, looking down into the canal.

He didn’t look up at her. “You said the box was sunk underneath the house.”

Tilda came to stand beside him, hugging her arms around her waist. “Yes.”

“Here? In the canal?”

“Yes,” Tilda admitted.

“Khargr had a gem-box. He brought it out of the East with us. Said it was our inheritance and it would make us all rich once he found the right buyer in Erebor,” Kili blinked. “The box disappeared with him. Kibil claimed he found it was empty, another failed swindle by Khagr, and that he threw it away.”

Kili suddenly moved, pulling off his shirt and boots, leaving only a light pair of under-trousers. Tilda gave a cry of annoyance and covered her eyes mockingly, but she didn’t realise what he was doing until it was too late. Before she could stop him he was sitting on the edge of the raised floor, feet slipping into the canal. “Kili, stop, it’s freezing in there!”

“The water’s - what? Five feet, here? Seven?” he looked up at her as he lowered himself over the edge. He did have the decency to curse and grit his teeth, and then in a moment he sunk into the water and was gone. A few curls of sawdust from his hair floated on the surface of the oily water.

“Kili!” Tilda ran to the edge and knelt down. The lake was clearer than usual today, but the busy canals were always silty. He might lose his bearings and come up under the buildings, or under an enclosed part of a jetty, and not find his way before his breath ran out. But then with a bubble and a burst of activity, Kili surfaced, shoving his hair off his face. “Nothing yet,” he coughed, and disappeared again. Tilda wanted to run and find Sigrid or Fili, but she needed to watch the water for signs of where he’d gone. If he got into trouble while she was upstairs it might be too late by the time they returned.

Twice more he dove down and surfaced empty-handed, but on the fourth dive he came up holding a box. It was muddy and covered with the slime that coated most water-exposed surfaces of Laketown, and there were the long, thin shells of tube worms criss-crossing its dark binding.

Kili blew water out of his nose as he heaved himself back up onto the laundry floor. Tilda ran upstairs to find a blanket, brought it down and threw it around Kili, and the two of them climbed the stairs to the workshop.

—

Kili redressed while Tilda did her best to dry the box on the blanket and then placed it in the centre of the workbench. He put the shutter down over the window and turned the sign on the door to closed.

The box waited with what seemed like a conscious presence while they sat down and stared at it. It looked to Kili like a trap, something spring-loaded.

“It doesn’t weigh much,” Tilda said at last. “Maybe it really is empty.”

Kili fetched a chisel and went to work on the rusted latch, pocked and bloated. At last the box opened sluggishly, muddily, one of the hinges audibly snapping as it resisted giving up its secrets. They both leaned forward. Inside the box was what looked like a swollen page of black leather, folded in half, which Kili lifted out gingerly.

The folder was twisted, waterlogged, and hard to peel the two halves apart, but slowly they separated between Kiil’s fingers. Inside was looked like vellum or linen-paper, terribly stained and disintegrating on one edge. It opened to show a soaked, patchy image that for a moment looked as Tilda had described it: a tree sketched in thin, black lines and decorated with scribbles like leaves. But then Kili turned it upside down and he saw at once that it was not a leafed tree, but a family tree - a pedigree.

History tutors the world over made young dwarves memorise all of the first fathers and mothers, and their sons, and their sons’ sons, so he recognised the line of Durin the Deathless. But after that he’d been taught about the Stonefoot kings and queens, and he had never learned much of Longbeard history. Kili’s gaze swept down the lines as the pedigree broadened into many lords and kings, then narrowed as war and the changing of the world whittled down the princes of the Longbeards, fathers bearing sons who were themselves sonless, daughters bearing only daughters and then vanishing from the record.

A few branches remained, and Kili followed the eldest line down, the names vaguely familiar only from passing conversations overheard at pubs in Dale; Dain, Thror, Thrain…

Down, down, to the last two names.

Kili felt his eyes widen, his jaw clenched and trembling. For what seemed like a lifetime, he couldn’t speak.

“Oh, I can read this,” Tilda said suddenly. “We learned in school. D - U - R - Durin, even I know him—“

Kili slapped the leather holder closed and shoved it with the parchment down his shirt. He shut the box again with difficulty around the rusted surviving hinge.

“It’s nothing,” he said. “Probably an old property deed. Some debt Khagr was trying to hide.”

Tilda looked at him. She might not be a fast reader of dwarvish script but she had seen enough dwarvish bills and invoices to know that was not a property deed.

The shop bell dinged despite the closed sign and they both looked up. Bain was leaning through the doorway.

“What are you doing?” He snapped at Kili. “We’re on patrol tonight. You’re already late, Gamling sent me to find you.”

“Ah, sod me, I forgot,” Kili groaned and jumped up. “Just let me get my jacket and my outdoor boots.”

Kili gathered himself together in the backroom. Tilda noticed that he had swept the gem-box from the benchtop without her even noticing. When he returned, it seemed to be gone.

“Give me two minutes and I’ll be outside,” Kili waved his hand at Bain.

“You haven’t got two minutes.” Nevertheless, Bain stepped out.

Kili looked at Tilda as he tidied his collar and buttoned up his coat. “Don’t tell anyone what you told me, not yet. I have to talk to Fili first.”

“I need to tell Da,” Tilda whimpered. “He has to do something about Kibil.”

Kili shook his head. “This is bigger than Kibil. I’ll be back from patrol tonight and I’ll talk to my brother as soon as Kibil is asleep. Then we’ll go to your father and explain what we know.”

“Kili, be careful.”

Kili reached over and squeezed her hand quickly. “Thank you. I’ll see you soon.”

Bain was hollering for him to hurry up. Kili put his hands in his pockets and stepped out into the cold.

Thoughts like shards of pottery were spinning through his head, but for the first time he was beginning to see the shape they made together.

He understood at last why Khagr had dragged them here. The inheritance he claimed he could sell only in Erebor; not a gem or a mithril-threaded sword, but information. It was such a ridiculous, impossible story, that Kibil must have found it unbelievable when he learned the plan. Kili might not have believed it himself, but there was someone else to confirm it - the king’s hobbit, who had spotted them in Dale, a few weeks ago.

Bilbo Baggins had not been sent to spy on Bard’s children. In hindsight, that had always been implausible. Kili cursed silently as he followed Bain through the town to the militia headquarters, and felt a shudder run through him. Bilbo had been spying on them.

Did Erebor already know, or did they only suspect? What had Bilbo learned and taken back to his master under the Mountain? Bain was saying something, about how annoying that so-and-so was sick, and how he didn’t like the look of the fog over there, and Kili replied with half-formed affirmations.

The great kingdom of the dwarves, the magnificent mountain, loomed above the lake with what suddenly felt like malice. Yesterday, Kili would have described it as a remote, glorious world that he imagined was full of gems and gold and handsome dwarves intoning speeches that would fill the history books. Now he thought about how that wealth and power must be maintained with many soldiers, with secret police, with intrigues by lords and dukes each plotting against each other, with assassins beholden to no one but the highest bidder.

His thoughts were in free fall. What had Fili said, third-hand and half-remembered? Something about a battle for the throne. Bard had told Sigrid that the king wanted to marry and beget himself a son, but his military-minded cousin coveted the crown. There was going to be a succession crisis when the king died—

(oh Mahal, was the king already dying? Kili never paid attention to the politics far away under a mountain. If he was dying you wouldn’t know, would you? It was treason to even speak of the future death of a king)

—and maybe history wasn’t Kili’s best subject but everyone knows that in a succession crisis, you have to move fast and eliminate rivals to your chosen successor. Or even better, if you can quietly get rid of them beforehand, it doesn’t look as suspicious.

“Kili,” Bain’s voice broke him out of the fall. He looked up. Bain was holding his sword out to him. They were in the militia headquarters and everyone was ready to leave for patrol. They were all staring at him.

“What’s your problem?” Bain said, more rhetorical than actually concerned.

“Nothing,” Kili said. “I’m fine. Let’s go.”

—

That night, a fog came down the lake that was thicker than any in living memory. Boatmen hurried home before they became lost, and a few managed it only with bright lamps and hollering from the jetties of Laketown. These last few said they had seen something on the Northeastern shore. Something large, moving across the land, always staying in sight of the water.

The fog was too thick to risk sending out messengers to the woodland or the mountain kingdoms. No one could leave by boat, including Tauriel and a handful of her scouts. Bard ordered the Master's house opened and anyone with babies, the infirm or elderly was encouraged to stay in its halls until morning. He gathered barges by the inner docks, ready for an evacuation at the earliest sign. Sigrid stayed close to her father, running errands and taking a rough survey of who had chosen to stay in their homes and who was sleeping in their boats for a fast getaway.

A group of the lakemen militia had gone out on patrol to the Eastern bank when the fog was still gathering, and by nightfall they had not reported back. Sigrid was distributing dinner to those taking refuge in the Master's house when she spotted Fili coming around the edge of the hall to catch her.

"If you want to help, grab blankets and start handing them out," she said, pointing at a pile behind her makeshift quartermaster's desk. He did as she said but continued to follow her.

"Have you had any word about the militia? Kili's out there."

"So is Bain," Sigrid replied. "We can't do anything for them. They'll be lost and cold but they'll come home in the morning, when the fog blows away."

"Something is wrong," Fili hissed, trying not to be overheard by the crowds trying to settle down around them.

She turned to him. "Of course it is. Everyone feels it. But we can only manage what's in front of us."

Fili followed her in silence for another circuit of the room, and then he saw Tauriel passing in the hallway outside. He darted out to catch her, and Sigrid couldn't help but follow, just in case Tauriel had news.

"I don't know any more than you," Tauriel was saying to Fili.

"You could take your scouts out to find them," Fili was whispering. He waved at the wide open doors of the Master's house. The mist was so thick they could not see the far side of the courtyard outside. "You can track them even in this soup. I'm sure you can."

Tauriel shook her head. "While we're in the town, we'll follow Bard's command. He wants us ready and watching."

"Kili's out there," Fili grabbed her hand. "In the dark. With Mahal-knows-what."

Tauriel held his eye. At last she said. "I'll speak to Bard."

"Thank you," Fili gasped.

Not ten minutes later, Sigrid saw Tauriel and two of her archers heading out of the front doors. They were swallowed up by the fog, and shortly after, Bard gave the order to close the doors. The air was growing colder, the heat dropping away so quickly that Sigrid found her hands shaking before she even thought to put her coat back on.

Most people tried to sleep. Sigrid found Tilda sitting in an upstairs balcony overlooking the blank, white void of fog where the town should be, hiding her face so that no one saw her crying. Sigrid crouched down and rubbed her sister's arms. She made her put on a thicker cloak with a hood to keep her head warm. "You should go to bed."

"I'm not going to sleep until Tauriel brings Bain home," Tilda sniffed through her tears.

"Alright, then let's go for a walk. Da has lamp-men circling the town to keep watch, we'll take a shift."

Fili saw them leaving with the lamps and fell into step with them. "Can I join you?"

"If you must," Sigrid muttered, and handed him a lamp.

—

The young militia of Laketown had two units, two self-appointed teams for the fun of competing against each other in their practice tournaments and military exercises. Despite Bard’s regular lectures about their duties, it was all something of a game to the young men and boys charged with protecting the town.

Bain was supposed to be in the Black unit, and Kili was in Red, but the night of the fog the Red unit was out on patrol and down a member, who was sick at home with food poisoning. So Bain had taken his place, and joined the Red patrol along the banks of the lake as the fog rolled in just before dusk.

Of course, they were not afraid of a little mist. They had confidently continued their planned route along the circuit road, and got utterly lost on the way back.

The oldest member of the team, a swart, broad-shouldered man named Gamling, was marching at the front with Hildor, the youngest boy, to keep him calm as the fog grew thicker. Gamling had confidently told them that as long as they kept the sound of the lake’s lapping waves on their right hand side, they would eventually reach the main road towards the bridge and head home. But the lake was so still tonight that almost all sound had disappeared. There were no night-birds calling, no scurrying foxes or stoats, not even the buzzing of mosquitos. The foliage hung still and silent as they pushed through the branches. It was like they were walking with blankets wrapped around their heads, until anyone spoke, and then they all shivered at the loudness of their own voices.

They tried to walk in pairs, where the goat-path they were following allowed it, and somehow Bain had ended up at the back with Kili.

Bain was old enough to be a man about it, but he was not going to pretend that he liked Kili. He told himself that it was not because of Tauriel (it was). He told himself it wasn’t because Kili acted like he knew everything about the world just because he’d been halfway around it (it was). He told himself it wasn’t because last month, Tilda had been home for the holidays and when Bain tried to tell his little sister to be more modest with her jokes and her dress, Kili had laughed him down and said, “Don’t be so jealous, Bain, just because she’s funnier than you,” (it was).

Bain didn’t like him because Kili was, in fact, so annoying. Below Gamling, who was twenty-six and took very seriously his role as the oldest in the group, everyone treated Kili like he was the next-senior member of the militia. Bain knew that wasn’t fair, because obviously by dwarvish standards Kili was barely an adult. But he still had a witty story for every situation, usually quite a funny one, and that made people think he was more mature than Bain knew he really was. It was transparent (to Bain) that his charm masked his obvious lack of real personality. And then when the wood-elves had come to train them, Kili had always been the quickest to pick up on everything they learned. Even though he didn’t have the reach with the melee weapons that the humans had, he seemed to have an instinct for how to use his strength and low centre of balance to his advantage. Fighting him with a sword was like trying to knock over a tree-trunk. A tree trunk that kept trying to sweep your leg out.

Bain had expected to at least be the best in the group at the bow. He was Bard’s son, after all, son of the man who had shot a dragon out of the sky. But the first time they all started practising in front of the elves, although it was not a competition (it was), Kili hit nearer the target than Bain three times out of four. That was unnatural. Dwarves didn’t even use bows. Everyone knew that.

After this feat of accuracy, Kili winked at Tauriel as he strode off the range, handing his bow to the next young member of the militia. “Sorry I’m a bit rusty. Back home, we had to shoot mountain lions to warn them off our herd pastures.”

Bain wanted to gag just thinking about it. ‘Bit rusty.’ What an absolute bucket of filthy bilge-water. He had tried to be a grown-up and treat Kili with the same respect he treated all his fellow militia members, but of course, the git just responded to passive-aggressive respect with cheerful camaraderie. It’s like he thought they were actually friends.

So yes, Bain didn’t like Kili, but at least he was being a man about it.

Nobody was talking as their feet tried to find a safe route downhill, sure that would at least take them back to the shoreline. Although they were stuck walking next to each other, Bain tried to make it clear he was not talking to Kili even more.

The wending convoy stuck as close together as they could, and almost ran into each other when Gamling stopped and raised a hand for their attention.

“There’s a drop ahead,” he sighed. “We can’t climb it in this fog. We’ll back up to that last copse of trees and find another way down from there.”

“We can’t keep going in circles,” one of the other boys complained. “Let’s just pick a sheltered spot and wait out the fog.”

Gamling shook his head. There was a grim, fearful look on his face that he covered with a military bark, “Stay in your pairs, everyone turn around where you are. Kili, you lead us back to the copse.”

Bain tried not to scoff. ‘Kili, you lead us’ - Bain was right here next to him! He was so ready for this patrol to be over. He couldn’t wait to get back to the rest of the Black team and tell them what a mess the Red team had made of a simple walk on the shoreline.

Kili nodded at Gamling and started back up the hill. Bain matched his pace. This was a task in itself, as Kili didn’t seem to get fatigued as quickly as the humans, and the two of them had soon pulled too far ahead of the rest of the militia.

“Kili,” Bain said, trying to hide his breathlessness. “Slow down. We’re leaving the others behind.”

“Ah, sorry Bain, I thought you were keeping up,” Kili stopped and propped one foot up on a rock to lean one elbow on his knee. He waved at the others behind them. Was he posing? Really? What a slice of rotting fish-head he was.

In the fog, not far down the hill but almost invisible through the mist, one of the others waved back. Up ahead, Bain could see the wide, dark shape of what must be the copse. He took a deep breath to keep himself from shoulder-barging Kili as he drew level with him.

He sniffed. There was something in the air.

“Kili,” Bain hissed. “Do you smell that?”

Kili frowned at him and took a breath. “Yes, weird smell… what is that?”

Bain knew what it was. They all knew what it was. All of them, Bain realised, except for Kili, who had not lived in Laketown when Bain had lasted known this smell.

The dark, wide shape behind Kili was not the copse of trees. Trees didn’t shift and move closer like that.

Bain braced against the grassy stones and launched himself towards Kili. He grabbed him by the lapels and hauled him sideways, throwing them both down the hill, tumbling over each other in the thick tussock. Kili yelped in surprise and slid slightly further than Bain, coming out of the roll crouched onto one knee. Bain ended up on his back with his head downhill in a much less dignified pose.

“Run!” Bain raised his head to look towards Kili. “Run!”

Something was coming out of the fog; not an army, not a creature, but a black cloud that oozed and collapsed on itself as it broiled outwards from some unseen source hidden in the mist. Bain tried to scuffle backwards downhill, on his elbows and kicking his feet away, and the edge of the cloud rolled over the bottom of his left leg just as he flipped onto his front and managed to stand up.

The strange cloud didn’t feel wet, but it was hot, and then like a chilling cold it was burning. Bain screamed and his leg gave way as it went into weak spasms. He kept trying to limp on, and then to crawl with his good leg and his hands, but the pain was like a lightning bolt through his spine and brain. No stubborn bravery could have overcome it; he fainted forward into the grass and stones.

He came back to consciousness within what must have been moments. His body was moving through the grass at speed, almost sliding down the hill on his back, and he could see the blundering shapes of his fellow militiamen around and behind him through the fog. For a moment he wondered if some predator had seized him and was dragging him back to its lair. But he turned his head a little and realised Kili was holding him under the arms and dragging him down the hill.

The pain was still so bad that he didn’t want to look at his leg. He looked up the hill, at what was behind them, and wished he hadn’t. One of the other boys - it sounded like Hildor - suddenly screamed and then went very silent, very fast.

The land flattened out and the grass gave way to packed stones beneath Bain’s body. They had come upon the road at last, and at a point well-worn enough that the bridge to town must not be far at all. Bain tried to stand on his good leg but his nerves were shot with fear and pain and he just flopped, held half-upright by Kili.

“Here!” Bain heard Kili shout, waving his arm. “Help me!”

There were three tall figures running in graceful synchronicity out of the fog. Tauriel reached the two of them first, as the rest of the militia arrived in a stuttering pack. She took Bain out of Kili’s arms, hauling him up as if he was half her weight. Bain could not help thinking, through his daze, that this was not how he’d imagined his first real taste of action.

“We need to go,” he gasped, trying to find the words to make Tauriel and the other elves understand. “There’s nothing we can do. Run and warn the town.”

Tauriel called like a clear bell through the night, “Aphad-im! Follow me!” and turned with Bain in her arms back the way she had come.

They were all moving as a group now, the panicked militiamen clustered behind Tauriel while the two elvish archers, Berior and Fainthel, took up the rear. They paced backwards and raised their arrows towards the blank fog.

Bain heard a low rumble behind them, soft as a pot in the fire boiling over, and looked over his shoulder to see the black cloud rushing and writhing towards them along the road. It was thicker than air or steam and moved fast but then splashed down on the road and trees, dissipating more like the spray of a crashing wave than a cloud of smoke. Everywhere it touched, there came a faint hissing sound like raindrops on a roof, and the leaves shrivelled, the trees turned black and the bark split and peeled in many fissures like dry paint in the sun.

“Don’t touch it!” Bain tried to yell, but even he had to admit it came out as something of a shriek. He saw Berior turn and shove the nearest militiamen onwards, but Fainthel must have seen a mark somewhere behind the dark cloud and she stayed to loose an arrow.

Bain saw the edges of the cloud engulf her and for a moment she vanished, and the next she was emerging from the black cloud and stumbling after them, but by the gods, she was burning without fire–

Bain wanted to close his eyes, but it was as if they were frozen open. He saw Kili dart forward and snatch up Fainthel’s bow and a handful of arrows that had spilled from her quiver as she fell.

Tauriel saw it all and even she stumbled, and Bain nearly fell out of her arms. She crouched and swept him up onto her back, and ran on without looking over her shoulder again.

Chapter 5

Notes:

Edit to chapter notes: the chapter numbers keep changing because I'll be posting the sequel as a sequel after all instead of an extension, as it's ended up a much longer sequel than I expected and will take time to post.

Chapter Text

Sigrid, Fili and Tilda walked a winding route around the jetties on the edges of the town, straining their eyes into the fog. It was like having your face covered with a white sheet. There were the sounds of lapping water, a baby crying, a prayer from inside a house, the tapping of a moored boat against its pole.

"Why are you two not speaking?" Tilda asked, when they'd got half way around the town. The exercise seemed to have cheered her up a little, and perhaps her fears were somewhat allayed by the apparent emptiness of the fog’s veiled threat. Even the cleverest orcs surely couldn't paddle an army across the lake in total silence. Perhaps it really was just an early, winter fog.

"We can't talk about it. Because we're not speaking," Sigrid replied, and Fili laughed.

"Sigrid, can I--" he began.

"I just said we can't talk about it," she raised her head and stared along the creaking boards. They'd made it almost round to the bridge, but she only knew that by familiarity with this path. She could barely see the posts at the end of the bridge, the threshold of the town.

Fili pushed on, "I'm sorry. Could we--"

"Sh, sh," she raised her hand. He and Tilda fell completely silent. None of them breathed. There was a sound out across the water, a sort of fluttering and splashing. Sigrid turned her face towards it and just at the edge of visibility she saw the still water of the lake was fragmented by a school of fish; more than a school, thousands upon thousands of fish, all leaping and surging in the same direction. Towards the town; away from the eastern shore.

"Sigrid," Tilda whimpered. "There's a smell."

"I know," Sigrid said. "I smell it."

Fili sniffed. "What is that?"

Distantly, there was a thudding, far, far away in the fog, rhythmic and yet out of time, something moving heavily and with a limp. Something large enough to hear from the town even through the blanket of mist.

"Dragon," Sigrid whispered, almost to herself.

A roar like a gale in tall pines flowed over their ears, and with it came something like a short, sharp wind, but not moving like a wave. It came from a single point on the bank far away, towards the landward end of the bridge. It burst outwards like a soap bubble, and pushed the fog out with it, so that in mere seconds a growing sphere of clear, night air was spreading over them, tall enough that the fog was broken at its peak, and a glitter of stars shone through.

They could see outside the town at last. Even in the darkness of the far shore, they could see figures running out of the sparse trees and towards the far end of the bridge.

"Orcs!" Tilda sobbed, pointing at the figures.

"No, not orcs!" Fili began to run towards the opening to the bridge. "It's the militia!"

Sigrid ran after him and grabbed the back of his tunic just before he stepped onto the bridge. "Stay here, signal them!" She waved her lamp and cupped her other hand around her mouth. "Hi! Hi! Hi! This way!"

Fili waved his light too, bellowing in a deep clear voice. "This way! This way!"

Tilda had followed them, trying to wave her light, but she was shaking so much she was in danger of dropping it. The last thing they needed was fire, and Sigrid took the lamp off her and put it down. "Tilda, run back to the Master’s House. Tell Da what we smelled. Get everyone in the boats, we must evacuate the town."

She tried to push Tilda, but Tilda wouldn't move, she only stumbled where she stood.

Sigrid heard Fili's breath catch in a sharp, torn gasp of such fear that she had never heard from him. She turned, and saw something enormous rise out of the darkness.

Smaug.

It was Smaug.

In the starlight and with the fog fading in all directions around him he was an eerie, pale worm. He walked on his back legs and the knuckles of his wings like something insectoid, or not like any animal that Sigrid had ever seen. The membranes of his wings were shredded and the struts between them shattered, scarred, flightless evermore. Patches of scales appeared scratched and cracking, like something mangy, and there was what looked like an iron collar around his neck; and if the collar was marked with a painted eye, Sigrid could not possibly have seen it from this distance, but she would have described it none the less. Where his great, snake's face had once been almost handsome in its symmetry, now it was riven by a twisted scar bursting around a collapsed eye socket. The black arrow, which Sigrid had seen her father fire with her own eyes, on a night six years ago that was now impossibly clear and real in her memory, that black arrow was still there. It had gone through the roof of his mouth and the tip jammed out of his cheekbone into the shadowed space where the dragon's eyeball should have been.

Smaug craned down his neck and opened his mouth, but what emerged was no fire. His inner flame must have been quenched by the waters of the lake, when his strength had given out and he had fallen from a great height onto the sand-bank strewn channels at the south end. Out of his mouth poured a dark, super-heated miasma that shrivelled and wilted the foliage that it touched and left a poisonous patina on every surface. This was what had raided the farms. This was the weapon that the orcs had been testing.

The tiny figures of the Laketown militia had reached the bridge and were sprinting, staggering, crawling as fast as they could. The dragon's poison was heavy in the air and fell out of it quicker than a cloud of steam, coating the ground behind them before it reached their heels.

Halfway along the bridge, there was a gatehouse. It was here that the mechanisms were placed to destabilise the piles and break the bridge. Sigrid had watched her father inspect them twice over the last few months, ensuring they were in order. She knew how they worked. But the men guarding the gatehouse had fled towards the town, and the bridge still stood. The guards had panicked. It was understandable, if unforgivable.

Tilda put her lamp down and pushed Fili towards her sister. "Stay with Tilda."

"What?"

Sigrid unclasped her coat, tossed it down, hitched up her skirts and ran. As she and the militia converged on the bridge, both of them moving closer to the gatehouse from opposite directions, she started to see the details of the survivors. Tauriel was at the front, tall and unmistakable with her bright hair, carrying some young lake-boy on her back. Sigrid was sure it was Bain, she knew her brother's curls anywhere, and the way his arms were gripping Tauriel's neck and shoulders he looked alive and conscious. Behind Tauriel were half a dozen boys and young men, most of them still clutching their swords, though against the dragon it would not have been a cowardice to throw them away and run faster. One of Tauriel's bowmen took up the rear, though there was no sign of the other; but the second bow was in Kili's hands. As they ran, Kili and the elf would nock their arrows, turn and fire in defiance of the dragon, like flicking matchsticks at a bull, and then they would run to catch up with the rest of the militia.

Sigrid reached the gatehouse. It was empty, but the lamps inside were lit. There was the mallet, there were the wedges that held the keystones that would fall and knock the pillars from the base of the bridge. Sigrid crossed the room and lifted the huge bar on the gate, barely able to raise it and throw it aside with a clatter. She leaned against the doors and pushed them outwards.

The fleeing militia were moments away. But the dragon was moving now, faster than any person could possibly run, stepping onto the bridge like a sailor onto the mast's crossbeam.

Tauriel, Bain and Kili were not behind the safety of the gates, but her sister and father and the whole town were. She could not wait for them to reach her. Sigrid picked up the mallet and knocked the wedges out of the bridge's mechanism.

With a creaking and a splintering, the bridge began to give way. The first of the militia were just through the awning where Sigrid stood as the planks beneath their feet began to collapse into the lake. Tauriel's long legs carried her easily through, under the roof of the gatehouse and out the other side.

"Keep running! It's all going down!" Sigrid yelled at her, but Tauriel had not paused anyway.

Sigrid felt the floor under her tilt as three more young men streamed past her. She held out her hand, and caught the arm of the fourth one as the gatehouse began to crumble into the lake, pulling him along even as each plank leaned and slid away beneath them. The bridges’ piles collapsed faster than their footsteps. The elven scout was quick and elegant across the boards and could have got ahead of them, but he stayed and reached back, grabbing Kili by a fistful of his coat just as the dwarf fell backwards, and with a strength that looked impossible for his grace, the elf braced against a falling pillar, leaped and dragged both of them onto the solid end of the bridge.

---

It all happened so quickly that Kili's legs didn't stop running even in the empty air, so when Berior shoved him back onto the steady planks he was in full sprint as he touched down. He could see lights in the distance, the broken shadow of the houses of Esgaroth. It wasn't clear that they'd be safer there, but by Naugladur’s beard, it couldn't be worse than what was behind them.

He ran the remaining stretch of bridge, reached the threshold of the town and almost crashed into Tauriel, who had stopped and turned to name them under her breath as they ran off the bridge. Kili doubled over, heaving for breath, every muscle wrung to exhaustion.

Tauriel looked back along the bridge. "We lost Gamling and Thorn," she cried into the cold night, as if anybody was going to go back for them. Kili saw that Bain had slid off her back and was sitting on the ground, gritting his teeth and holding his burned leg. Tilda was beside him, looking between his face and Tauriel's with her hands slightly raised as if she wanted to help but didn't know how.

"They went into the water when the bridge fell," Berior came up beside her, looking as flustered as an elf could. He and Kili had both lost their bows, but he had drawn a short sword from his belt and stood by the bridge-posts looking back at the huge, hulking shape of the approaching dragon. Gamling, Thorn, two other militia boys, and the other elven scout, Fainthel - all of them gone. Kili counted them in his head, and saw again their deaths by boiling poison and claw. He didn't think he would ever stop seeing them behind his eyes.

But as they watched, the dragon slowed. The defense mechanism had worked exactly as it was built to. Almost fifty feet of the bridge had collapsed around the gatehouse, leaving two blunt-ended jetties facing each other with debris-strewn water between them. The dragon was on the far side, but he had stopped. They could hear and smell his hot, furnace-bellow breaths even from this distance. He had turned his face so that his single working eye was looking directly along the bridge towards them.

"He's afraid of the water," Bain croaked. "He can't cross."

"Where's Sigrid?" Tauriel asked in a drill-instructor's tone. "She was on the bridge with us."

"Where's Fili?" Tilda spoke over her in a shrill voice. "Fili was here! He’s gone!"

"Where?" Kili spun around, searching among the human and elvish faces for his brother.

Bain grabbed Tauriel's hand and hauled himself up, onto his good leg. "Sigrid!" He screamed. "Sigrid!"

"There," Tauriel followed his gaze and pointed back along the bridge.

The fog had cleared enough that the moon was bright in the sky, and they could all see the figure standing at the very end of the bridge, or what had been the bridge from the townward side. A woman's figure, with her hair loose from its bun and trailing down her back. She stood upright and motionless. A bow was hanging from the fingers of her right hand. She must have picked it up, when Berior dropped it to rescue Kili, and perhaps thought she could fire a last arrow or two at the dragon to buy them more time. Her father was still Bard the Bowman and he had taught her how to shoot, though she never had the need for it as the Master's daughter.

The dragon was not looking at them after all; he was looking at Sigrid.

"He's caught her with his eye," Tauriel said, clear but softly, like someone bringing news of a drowning to a fisherman's wife. "She's hypnotised."

"Sigrid!" Bain screamed, "Sigrid, run!”

Tilda shrieked. “Wake up!"

Sigrid didn’t make any sign that she had heard them. She stood placid and limp as a sleepwalker.

The dragon's neck and withers were long. He could not step across the bridge, but he stretched his head out slowly across the gap, a viper moving through the grass to its unsuspecting prey. He opened his mouth, teeth shining except for one broken place where the arrow had gone through. They could hear the hiss of his delight.

"There, there’s Fili!" Tilda squeaked, pointing. “He’s on the bridge!”

Fili reached Sigrid at a dead sprint and opened his arms, catching her around the waist and knocking them both off the broken end of the bridge in the same motion. There was, distantly, the splash of two bodies hitting the surface of the water.

The dragon's teeth snapped closed on empty air. He drew back his neck, whipping his head from one side to the other in vain search for his prey. He straightened up, and finally he did look at the cluster of observers, at the town, at the gulf of water he would once have been able to cross with one flap of his huge, ruined wings. His reptilian lips twisted in a snarl, and with a low rumble he withdrew, backing his hind legs along the bridge with his head low between his shoulders. They watched as he turned and stalked back onto the land, no longer making any attempt to hide his bulk among the trees or lurk in the strange fog that was quickly lifting across the lake.

---

Some creatures are natural swimmers. Dwarves are not. But even a pony can swim, when it needs to.

Fili hit the water holding Sigrid with both arms and they were carried down, deep and on an angle, like a cormorant diving for fish. He was kicking his legs before the movement finished, hugging Sigrid with one hand and reaching out with the other as if to pull the water close. His fingers touched a sunken pile from the collapsed bridge, and he grabbed it and pulled them onwards, kicking off the debris with his legs, almost climbing horizontally through the water.

He couldn’t see much, underwater in the dark, but he could sense the predatory shape of the dragon’s neck stretched above. So he kept going, pushing off from pillar to fallen pillar, his throat beginning to heave for air that wasn’t there, until the shadows became sharper and blocked out all moonlight. They were under the bridge now. All his breath was exhausted. He couldn’t stay under. His body made the decision for him, and he rose to the surface and tried to gasp as silently as possible, shoving his hair out of his face.

The dragon was right above them. Its head was stretched out over the water to the far side of the shattered bridge, where they had been a moment earlier. Fili could see each glinting scale on its neck and the tips of the huge, worn claws tucked over the edge of the planks, less than a yard from his face.

Fili grabbed a loop of rope trailing under the nearest surviving pile and pulled himself close to the great, oaken trunk. He held Sigrid around her shoulders with her back against his chest so that as he craned his neck back, she tilted with him and her face stayed above the water. She was strangely motionless and he had a flash of panic that he had actually drowned her, they had been under the water so long.

Then she took a deep breath with a splutter in it. She was alive. He would have melted with relief if the water wasn’t so cold.

“Sh,” he said, almost so quiet he couldn’t hear himself. Sigrid’s breath became calm and even.

The planks above them creaked and the moonlight shone through gaps where they bowed under the dragon’s weight. He could hear a few cracks and wondered if the structure could possibly hold the beast’s weight any longer. But it had been built to carry heavy cartloads of wood and coal into town, and it held. Suddenly, there was movement, and the crunching of the huge claws as the dragon receded away, towards the shore.

On the far side of the bridge, towards the town, he could hear shouts and then the voices of several men as Bard and the town’s guards arrived and realised what kind of attack they were facing. Fili didn’t dare shout, not knowing how close the dragon still was. He waited, gripping the rope high up so that his arm half hugged the pillar to keep them in place. Sigrid was warm and motionless against his chest. She wasn’t making any attempt to tread water, though he knew she could swim better than him, so he had to hold all her weight up by himself.

There was an increasing clamour from the town. He couldn’t see much from this low in the water, with his view mostly blocked by the far side of the broken bridge.

“They’ll be launching boats,” he said. His teeth were starting to chatter from the cold. “We’re safe. He’s gone.”

But Sigrid still said nothing. Fili adjusted his grip on the rope, his elbow beginning to ache.

“Sigrid?”

His arm was across the top of her chest, and he could feel the rise and fall of her breath. Her eyes were open, though her face was hard to see in the shadows up the bridge.

She must be in some kind of state of paralysis, from the fear. A sort of quiet delirium. It was understandable. Mortals were not meant to face dragons and survive. Fili had only managed to run towards the dragon by forcing himself not to think about what he was doing. He’d been completely focused on reaching Sigrid before those huge teeth snapped down.

“You’re safe, we’re safe,” he repeated, a little louder.

She didn’t even seem to hear him. She lay back in the water, floating a little as the air filled her lungs and then sinking as she exhaled, and stared up at the gaps in the planks where the stars showed through. Her expression was as blank as a death-mask. Her eyes had nothing behind their sheen.

“Sigrid?” Fili clenched his arm around her tighter and tried to squeeze her shoulder hard enough that it would wake a sleeper. “Sigrid. Sigrid!”

She did not seem to hear him, she did not seem to feel him, her body was not even shivering from the cold. She was like a living corpse.

Fili let out a long, shuddering breath of horror. His mind looped around a single thought, spinning towards the gravity of it. The old fairytale about the dragon and the maiden on the hill, and how it stole her thoughts and memory. But that was a children’s story, and Sigrid had only met the dragon’s gaze for a moment, or perhaps a minute. What had Smaug done to her?

There was a constant shouting from the town as neighbours woke neighbours to tell them what they’d seen, or heard third-hand. He could hear the distant calling of men out on the lake, floating slowly in the rescue boats. Their oars splashed, heavy and clumsy in the water. The boatmen were searching out to either side of the bridge, closer to town, in the direction they expected to find two swimmers fleeing the dragon.

“We’re here!” Fili yelled. “Here, under the bridge!”

The oars of the boats were getting further away. He cursed and tried to adjust his grip. His hand on the rope was going numb from the cold, but he couldn’t tread water, not while holding Sigrid up. He could try to swim, but where would they go? There were no steps or ladders up onto the bridge, even assuming he could drag Sigrid up a ladder in the dark. He could either swim to the shore, two hundred feet away, or back to town, which was at least as far. If he couldn’t make it, he’d only find out when they drowned.

He could swim further if he was on his own, but it didn’t even cross his mind to leave her.

“Your Da won’t sleep until he finds us. It won’t be long until the boats come back,” Fili promised Sigrid. He just had to hold on until then.

He managed to maneuver Sigrid around so that they were chest to chest, one of her arms draped over his shoulder and her head resting on the other shoulder. That way he could hold the rope with both hands, with Sigrid’s back against the pillar to keep her from slipping away. Now he could flex his hands one after the other to keep the blood flowing. Heart to heart, cheek to cheek, it was horribly like he was embracing a dead woman for a dance.

Wasn’t that how it worked in fairytales? The prince gathered up the sleeping maiden, promised to wed her, the curse was broken and they lived happily ever after. But Fili wasn’t a prince, he was a bookkeeper to a drunk carpenter, and the marriage offer hadn’t worked anyway. So all he had saved with his little act of valour was her body, not her, not the Sigrid he knew.

Fili could feel the cold creeping into his bones. It made his eyelids heavy and his thoughts slow like oil. The season was not yet deep enough for there to be ice on the lake, but he knew that submerged in this chill, they wouldn’t last until morning. He could probably survive the cold longer than Sigrid. Then he really would be stuck here with a corpse. He told himself it wouldn’t come to that. The boats would come back.

He gripped the rope tighter with both hands. He must not go to sleep. That would doom them both. He must hold Sigrid close, share his warmth until rescue arrived. Stay alert for lights and the sounds of calling voices. Do not go to sleep. Hold on to the rope. Do not sleep. Hold on.

Be dwarven. Endure.

Chapter Text

Tilda sat curled in a corner of the Master’s office with Kili beside her. She had her arm round him, more for her own comfort. Something in his clothes smelled bitterly of the dragon’s venomous breath, but he otherwise was unhurt. Tilda turned her face to hide her tears as she tried to wipe them away with a fold of her dress.

Above their heads, Bard was speaking to a small group consisting of the captain of the laketown guard, the senior member of the remaining militia unit, and Tauriel. Outside, there was the low hum of people running about and talking in rising panic as rumours about what had happened at the bridge spread through the gathered townspeople.

“We have to get everyone on the boats,” Tauriel said. “Smaug may return, or the orcish masters who control him will seek another way to reach the town.”

Bard swallowed and took a moment before he shook his head. “If we try to empty the town in this panic, we’ll have deaths - someone will fall overboard, somebody’s grandda will have a heart attack - or at least there’ll be a few broken arms in the crush. I’m willing to risk that if the dragon returns, but not on the rumour of him,” he hissed a long breath through gritted teeth. “Those who can sleep in the boats should do so. Those who can’t be moved without assistance stay in the Master’s hall. Everyone else sleeps in their own homes, in shifts, listening for the bells.”

“We don’t know what else is out there,” Tauriel growled.

“No, we know exactly what is out there,” Bard pointed back towards the shore. “But Dale, Erebor, the Greenwood, they are all heedless to the danger. Our people are safe, and our next task is to warn our allies.”

“We can’t leave until morning, surely,” the captain of the guard cut in. “The beast would smell any messenger before they made it ten feet from the lake! By daylight we’ll know if there’s a safe path to the mountain.”

“I can make it,” Tauriel said quietly.

Beside Tilda, Kili raised his head. “Tauriel,” he struggled to his feet. “You’ve done enough. You came for us when we thought we were already dead. You saved me, you saved half the militia.”

“There are thousands of people in Dale,” Tauriel smiled at him. “They must be warned.” After a moment she looked over at her remaining elvish companion. “Berior, if Bard can spare someone to navigate the rocks, you go up the forest river to tell Thranduil what has happened. He will be prepared. He remembers the drakes of old.”

“I’ll find you a steady boatman who knows the lake at night,” Bard agreed. “As soon as one of them reports back. They’re still out looking for the… survivors.”

Tilda heard the catch in his voice and burst into silent tears again. Kili sat down again and rubbed her back. It had been more than an hour since Smaug withdrew onto the shore, and of the four people who had gone into the lake, none had been found.

Kili said quietly, “If Fili dies, I’m the eldest son.”

“He’s not dead,” Tilda hissed at him, not sure why being the eldest would matter. “He can’t be dead, because he has to bring Sigrid back.”

Tilda felt so useless, so stupid. She’d done nothing to help anyone. Sigrid had known exactly what to do, Sigrid always knew what to do, and now Sigrid was missing and Fili was missing and if Tilda had just done as her sister told her and run back to Da for help… would they have come fast enough? With their proper longbows, could they have driven the dragon off before Sigrid and Fili went into the lake? She would never know. And she would never be able to tell Sigrid how sorry she was.

“Kili?” Bard said gently. “Would you take Tilda back to the house? We’ll tell you as soon as there’s news. And listen for the bells, just in case.”

—-

Back at home, Tilda dropped down onto the daybed in the living room and lay on her side, staring at the fading fire in the hearth. Kili fetched a stool and tried to fill the kettle for tea but given all the clattering, his hands must be shaking too much. He soon put everything down again. She heard him roaming about, trying to make himself useful to distract himself from his missing brother. “Your kitchen top needs sanding and oiling. What a mess,” he complained. “I offered to do it last month but Sigrid said–” he stopped and stood looking down at the bench.

Having failed at the tea, Kili came over carrying two small cups of milk, from somewhere in their cool store. Sigrid had been saving it for making a cheese sauce tomorrow, but that obviously wasn’t going to happen.

Tilda wondered if she could sleep, just to get some peace from the grief. She wondered if Bain was able to sleep. His leg was a mess, but the town doctor was taking care of him. She had been so worried about Bain, when the militia were lost out there in the fog. She had never even thought to worry about Sigrid.

There was a holler from outside and moments later, a thumping on the door. Kili jumped up, putting both cups down, and ran to open it. It was Bard’s secretary. “They found them. They’re alive, help us get them inside.”

Tilda was on her feet and right behind Kili as they burst out onto the veranda. Bard was coming up the steps carrying Sigrid in his arms as if she was a little girl again, wrapped in a blanket. Fili was behind him, staggering and holding his hands close to his chest, soaking wet from crown to toes.

Tilda helped Bard inside and once they were out of the way, Kili dashed to his brother’s side. Fili was shivering uncontrollably, barely able to unlock his jaw to say, “I’m f-f-fine, just c-cold.”

Bard laid Sigrid down in front of the fire, with her head on a cushion. Tilda ran to get dry towels and clothes. When she returned, Bard was stripping Sigrid’s wet dress off, with only a brief glance at the dwarves, but Kili had just returned from his house with spare clothes for Fili and they were occupied at the other end of the room. “Kibil is passed out drunk,” Kili muttered to his brother.

“Sigrid,” Tilda started crying again, leaning down to take her sister’s hand and kiss her cheek. Sigrid blinked, her face staring into the fire. “I thought you were gone.”

Sigrid didn’t answer. “Give me the towels, we need to get her dry and warm,” Bard snapped, and Tilda helped him redress Sigrid. When they lifted her hands into the sleeves, her arms stayed where they were in the air, until Tilda pushed them back against her body. Sigrid said nothing. Her lips moved, and there might have been words, but none of them were coherent.

The secretary was still in the doorway, his hands on his hips. He said in an excited voice, “Mister dwarf here was under the bridge on the far side, he swam right under the dragon’s nose, and hung to a mooring rope there with Sigrid in his arms. For three hours, in that freezing water! The strength of dwarves, ay.”

“Thank you,” Bard said, looking at Fili. “Thank you for trying to save her.”

Fili shook his head and said nothing. Tilda looked between them and her father. “Da, she’s alright, she’s just cold and in shock. She’s well enough.”

Bard picked Sigrid up again. She hung stiffly in his arms, like a wooden doll, as he carried her to the day bed where Tilda had been trying to sleep. He laid her down as gentle as laying a newborn in a cot, and smoothed her wet hair away from her face. He laid blankets over his eldest daughter and then turned to Tilda.

“I have to go back to the town hall. Take care of her. See if you can get some water and bread into her, but be careful. Don’t force anything, or she may choke.”

“Da, she’ll be fine once she’s slept,” Tilda insisted, sitting on the edge of the bed.

When he was gone, she took Sigrid’s hand in both of her own. “Tell me what happened, Sigrid. Talk to me.”

But Sigrid’s eyes stared at the ceiling, and blinked slowly, and saw nothing.

—

Tilda slept next to her sister and woke to find her demeanor unchanged. She whispered, she sometimes twitched, but she was neither asleep nor awake.

The bells had not rung during the night. Outside, there were a lot of people out on the walkways or navigating through the canals. Tilda could hear them calling to each other, checking on their neighbours and taking stock of the boats, as quite a few had been commandeered during the excitement of the night and had to be reunited with their owners.

Fili was snoring heartily in Bain’s bed and Kili was napping on a folded blanket on the floor beside him. Tilda rummaged in the cupboards until she found an old pottery bottle with a side spout. She dribbled a little water between Sigrid’s lips. She boiled an egg and tried to feed a little into the corner of Sigrid’s mouth, but not much stayed in.

“They’re burning,” Sigrid whispered. Tilda leaned in close. “Fire on the lake.”

The words became mumbles again.

Tilda was trying to help Sigrid drink when there was rapid banging on the door. She jumped and the water sloshed across Sigrid’s collar. Tilda whimpered and tried to dab it dry with her apron. She didn’t want Sigrid to get cold again.

She heard Kibil’s voice through the door, demanding to know if his nephews were inside. Tilda closed her eyes and decided to stay quiet. Maybe he’d go away on his own.

Before the hammering had stopped, Kili was up and stomping past Tilda. He jerked open the door to Kibil standing with his fist raised to knock. His uncle immediately launched into a tirade without waiting for a greeting. “What are you doing here? It’s nearly noon! We have jobs in the calendar, you chinless, lazy little—”

Kili cut him off. “Do them yourself. Do you even realise that the town was attacked by a dragon last night?”

“What kind of excuse is that?” Kibil said, though his facial expression shifted as the implication of Kili’s words caught up with his mouth. Clearly he had slept through the whole thing.

“Sober up and figure out what we have in the stock room,” Kili snarled. “I’ll be going to help rebuild the bridge as soon as Bard gives the word. You do what you like, I’m quit of you,” he slammed the door as hard as he could and turned away, swearing under his breath.

“Maybe we should just leave town,” Kili said as he approached the table, half to himself.

“I doubt Da will be letting any boats leave the town except for the most dire errands,” Tilda pointed out. Beneath the blankets, she felt her sister’s body twitch and leaned in to stroke her brow. “Sigrid? Did you say something? Are you there?”

Sigrid’s eyes had the look of a portrait seen through layers of dirty glass. She whispered, “The dragon burned us all. House, lake, home, and I, I, I... and the orcs, the goblins, the wolves, the bats… there’s a sword through Fili… through his golden armour…”

Fili must have been woken by the commotion, because he had come quietly up to the bed and was standing behind Tilda all of a sudden. Tilda felt him flinch at the sound of his own name. She gripped Sigrid’s hand and whispered in her ear. “It’s alright. I’m here. It’s just a nightmare.”

As Sigrid fell silent, Tilda sat up, wiping her nose on her sleeve. “She’s talking more. That means she must be coming out of the dreams. She’ll be back soon.” She looked at her friends. “Won’t she?”

Fili looked at his brother. “We should get dressed and go find something useful to do.”

“We can’t go home. I just told Kibil where he can stick it.”

“We don’t have anywhere else to go,” Fili said, staring at Sigrid again.

Kili put his hand on his shoulder. “I need to talk to you.”

“Let’s talk while we work on the bridge.”

“No, somewhere private,” Kili said, with a quick glance at Tilda. Tilda wondered what was going on that could be worse than everything else she already knew about.

“Can it wait?” Fili looked at his brother.

Kili looked at him, at the way Fili’s gaze kept being drawn back to Sigrid’s empty face. He smiled, “Sure. Later, then.”

—

Bard returned to the house late in the afternoon. He was staggering as he got to the top of the steps. He has not slept for a moment last night, nor through the day.

“Is there any news?” Tilda asked.

“There are fires lit in the watchtowers around Dale. Tauriel must have reached them safely,” Bard patted her shoulder. “And no sign of anything moving on the Eastern bank by daylight.”

“Maybe it was a mistake,” Tilda mumbled. “Maybe the dragon revealed himself too early and now he’s slunk back to his lair.”

“Or his masters expected to wipe us out in a single night, and because they have failed they must withdraw until they can shift their attack plan for another go tonight,” Bard said with his usual optimism.

Bain was carried in behind Bard with a crutch, helped to a chair at the table by a couple of surviving militia boys before they bade him farewell. After they’d left he groaned and rubbed his leg. “Can someone get me a cup of something strong, I’m begging you—“ he stopped, and shared a look with Tilda. He had spoken as if Sigrid was here.

“Fine,” Tilda fetched him a glass. “But I’m only going to be your maidservant for. You’ve got a crutch, haven’t you?”

Bain smiled at her weakly. He looked at his older sister lying in the bed by the window. There was anger in his face, mixed with shame. Perhaps because he was the one who had joined the militia to save the town, and instead he’d come home safe and mostly intact. Tilda wished she could tell him how glad she was to have him, that if she had lost both siblings in one night it would have broken her, but she suspected he didn’t want her comfort yet.

Bard went to sit with Sigrid, paying no attention to his younger children. He combed his daughter’s hair with his fingers, held her hands between both of his own. Tilda could hear him speaking to her quietly, telling Sigrid how proud of her he was, how Bain and Tilda were safe thanks to her. He talked to her about how he needed her to wake up, because he had so much to do, he needed her by his side, and anyway she was the only one who knew how the filing system for his correspondence worked. He talked to her about his wife, her mother. His voice grew low, until Tilda couldn’t hear all the words but she could figure out from his tone that he was apologising. For hiding in his grief and leaving Sigrid to be mother and woman of the house when she had been just a child herself. All the things Tilda was sure he would never have said to Sigrid when she was healthy and needed to hear them.

Sigrid’s eyes gazed at the blank wall beside his face, and there was no sign that she heard a single word.

Bard wiped his eyes discretely and then turned with a clear face to Tilda. “Help me get her into her own bed, in the bedroom. It’s more comfortable.”

The two of them carried Sigrid through and settled her under fresh bedding, and then went back to the kitchen. They left the door open, but it still felt like an admittance of failure, one step towards accepting something terrible that no one would say out loud: that maybe Sigrid would not come back.

“Has she eaten anything?” Bard asked, staying on his feet to help Tilda chop vegetables and fill a pie dish.

“Not really,” Tilda admitted. “I’ve tried. She drinks, or at least, she swallows if the water trickles into her throat, but she won’t chew.”

They laid Tilda’s fresh but slightly lumpy pastry over the top of the pie, covered it with the lid, and Bard slid it into the hot embers of the fire. Bain hopped about on his crutch cleaning up and occasionally swearing.

“There’s stories about maidens enchanted by the dragon’s eye,” Tilda said. “Unable to remember their own names or language. Is that what’s happened to Sigrid?”

Bard stared into the fire. “We just need to keep her fed until she recovers. I’m going to sleep while dinner cooks. Why don’t you go find the lads and ask them to dinner? I want to thank them properly for all their help last night.”

Tilda complained that she hadn’t made enough for two extra mouths, but Bard was already heading to the other bedroom.

Tilda found Fili and Kili back at the bridge, with a team of workmen from the town. The master builder of Laketown had spent the day inspecting the ends of the bridge and trying to salvage some of the fallen piles. It would be months at least before it was fully repaired, but they hoped Dale would send craftsmen and labourers in aid. For now the builders had stabilised the end of the planks and were starting to build a large raft to transport supplies from one side of the gap to the other.

Fili and Kili welcomed the invitation. After cleaning up, they arrived just as Tilda was setting the table. Kili had even managed to wash off the dragon smell.

“May I see her?” Fili asked Bard, glancing through the open bedroom door at Sigrid.

“Of course.”

He stayed only moments and came back in a rush, blank-faced and silent with his hands under his arms.

Bard offered them each a drink once they’d helped themselves to a plate and sat down. Fili accepted thirstily, but Kili shook his head. Bard smiled at him and dropped into a seat across from the table. “Don’t want to end up like your uncles?”

It seemed like a bit of a thoughtless jibe for her usually diplomatic father, but then, he had had a very long day.

“Not at all. Khagr wasn’t a drinker, so clearly the vice doesn’t come from our side of the family,” Kili said with a sneer in his tone. “I just want to keep my hands steady for hammering tomorrow.”

Bard frowned. When he spoke, Tilda heard a sharp, clear tone in his thoughts. “Khagr wasn’t a drinker? Not like his brother?"

“Oh, never,” Kili shrugged, accepting a mug of tea from Tilda. “Half a pint made him red and sick as a colicky pony. He only ever took a few sips to be polite when he was at someone’s house. Have you any news of Tauriel?”

Bard told him about the signs that Dale had been alerted to danger, and their mutual hope that she had reached the city unscathed. They sll tried to make conversation while they ate, but nobody was in a conversational mood. Once the pie was gone, Tilda cleared the plates.

She noticed that nobody helped her. Tilda looked at the piles of dishes on the benchtop and despaired. She realised she would have to cook tomorrow as well, and perhaps the day after, and perhaps forever. Had this really been Sigrid’s life, all the time? Tilda had never thought to ask if Sigrid would prefer something different. It’s what her sister had always done, since Tilda was too small to remember.

The men and dwarves brought out their pipes. Kili’s wouldn’t light, and Bain reached over with his match and held it to the bowl until the dwarf’s pipe was glowing too.

“Thanks,” said Kili, sounding slightly surprised.

“You’re welcome,” said Bain. Tilda wondered what had got into them both. Bain was usually so rude to Kili, and frankly, Kili always baited him into it, but now they were sitting next to each other, both at the same jaunty angle to the table, both with one arm crooked over the back of their chairs and the other hand holding their pipes to their lips. It was slightly unnerving.

Bard and Fili were talking about what lore and rumours they knew of dragon magic. Tilda left the dishes dirty, refilled the kettle for a second round of tea and slid back into her chair to join.

“What about Thranduil?” Bain leaned forward. “He’s old as the forest and saw dragon-wars long ago, he may know something that could help!”

Bard puffed on his pipe. “Maybe. I imagine that if he received our message last night, he has shut his doors tight and will not allow his folk to leave except for absolute necessity.”

“This is an absolute necessity,” Kili growled. “And Thranduil has Sigrid to thank for the warning. If Smaug had crossed the bridge and devoured all of Laketown, you couldn’t have been able to warn any of them.”

Bard made a humming noise low in his throat. At last he said, “There’s one other person alive who has faced a dragon and lived to tell of it. The Hobbit of Erebor, Mr Bilbo Baggins.”

“Ugh, the king’s little spy,” said Kili. “I don’t think we can trust him.”

Fili said quietly. “But he did escape Smaug’s enchantment, so the story goes. By magic or by luck, he knows a dragon’s charms better than us.”

“He’s got a gentle nature. I think he’ll help if he can, without conditions,” Bard took a long draw of his pipe. “It’s too late to send a runner to Erebor tonight, even if we were confident it was safe out there.”

“We can’t wait,” Tilda spoke up. They all looked at her. “She’s not eating, Da. How long can she go on as she is?” she leaned forward. “We could take her there ourselves. If you’d spare a couple of the guards to help carry Sigrid, we can be at the door of Erebor by sunset tomorrow.” She looked to Fili and Kili. “You will take her, won’t you? If there’s a chance to help her? I’ll go too.”

“We can’t go to Erebor,” Kili said at once.

Fili frowned at him. “We can carry her that far, if we build a decent litter.”

Kili stared darkly into the fire. “It’s too dangerous.”

“Pull yourself together,” Fili growled at him. “No one’s seen the dragon all day. And even if they had, I’m going. I’ll escort Tilda and drag the litter behind me if I have to.”

“Fine,” Kili said. “I’m not leaving you on your own. But we need to watch ourselves once we get inside the mountain.”

—-

They set out the next morning as early as possible. Sigrid was carefully placed on the makeshift litter which the dwarves had knocked together overnight, tied in place with spare belts for the patchy road up the valley. There was a light frame over her face with a thin veil arranged by Tilda to keep the worst of the sun off. It looked horribly like a death shroud, or some mockery of a wedding veil. Tilda showed Fili how to make Sigrid’s body accept mouthfuls of water in case the worst were to happen and they were somehow separated on the journey, but no one made any mention of the danger. That would just be inviting bad luck.

They were rowed across the water to the Northern arm of the lake, closer to Erebor than the Eastern route. As they stepped out of the boat onto the river-burnished stones, Tilda felt a flash of panic. She was sure the dragon would be waiting for them, behind the shrivelled bushes, around the mossy boulders of the slopes above, coiled in a cave beneath their feet. They should not have left the safety of the lake.

She must find her courage. No matter how she liked to play sweet princess games with her school friends, she was Bard the Bowman’s daughter, and Sigrid would not want her to forget that.

—

Dark fell over Esgaroth. Early that morning, Bard had watched his daughters disappear across the lake towards Erebor. The lamps were coming on around the town. It was a clear night, no fog, gibbous moon, and people were beginning to talk in cheerful tones again.

Bard found Kibil downstairs in the workshop, bent over some little contraption of beaten, silver wire and varnished hardwood. Something beautiful, made for a dwarf-lord to hang in his council chambers to show the skill of his artisans to visitors. It would look silly on any wall in Laketown, even the Master’s ballroom.

“Hail, Bard,” Kibil said without raising his gaze from his work. “Are we behind on the rent? My apprentice just quit and we’re already behind on jobs, so you’ll just have to wait until I get paid.”

“I’m not here for the rent,” Bard said, and something in his voice made Kibil raise his head, or perhaps it was the absence of his usual deferential, ‘Master Carpenter’.

“What is it?” he grouched.

“You told me your brother was drunk the night he went into the canal,” Bard said. “You said that to me, the day we pulled his body out of the lake.”

Kibil did not step into the trap. He waited.

“But now I learn that Khagr did not drink. Could not drink without being sick,” Bard inclined his head. “Why did you lie?”

Kibil pushed his chair back from the bench and sat up straight. After a moment he answered, “you’re right. He wasn’t drunk. He took his own life. I found the note, but burned it before the boys could see it. I wanted to spare them that grief.”

“I don’t believe you.”

A ripple twitched over the muscles of Kibil’s face. His brows lowered a little. He said, “It was Fili who killed him. He and Khagr had a fight, the night after we arrived, because he stole Fili’s inheritance. I helped Fili hide the body. But it was not his fault, Khagr provoked him, Khagr struck him first. Don’t punish my nephew harshly, he has suffered with such terrible guilt for four years, and never been able to speak of it. You see how he drinks to forget.”

Bard let him go on like this for some time, until the story had run out. Then he said, “A boat will be waiting for you at dawn tomorrow by the east dock, to take you to the shore. From then on, you are outlawed from these lands. I will see it done that none may treat with you nor give you shelter in any country that borders my lake. Go where you will.”

Kibil made no more defense, and Bard left him to his thoughts.

Chapter Text

 

The journey was a far cry from the holiday walk that they had taken to and from Dale under the summer sun a few months before. The autumn wind was already sharp and cold against their ears, and on the ridges the gusts even threatened to overturn the litter. The fear of the dragon was in all of them, and Tilda walked at the front with her eyes constantly searching the ground. Fili guessed that she was looking for signs the beast had been through this way, and he was glad to have her as their scout. But the land revealed no drag marks of a great tail nor the smell of that oily, black poison.

The sky was pink when they passed below Dale, whose gates were all shut. They looked up to see guards and civilians watching them from the windows and balconies of the city’s towers. Tilda waved to them and got a few waves back, but they did not turn up the road to the city or go close enough to hail any of the watchmen.

The huge doors of Erebor were shut tight. Dale would have sent them Tauriel’s warning as soon as they received it, and even if they did not believe it possible, Erebor was the last place in Middle Earth that would underestimate the rumour of a dragon. But there were eyes in the arrow-slots and windows above the gates, and soon someone opened a small door at the bottom and ushered them in.

As they walked into the mountain, carrying Sigrid like pallbearers, Fili thought of his father’s wake.

Fili felt only anger at his father in those first few days. For dying, for dying suddenly, for dying too soon. Right when Fili thought he was going to go out alone for the first time in his life, have the freedom to make mistakes and not worry about everyone else.

On the third day after his father died, the wake was begun in a stone cold-room in the nearby temple. Khagr had already arrived from who knows where; Fili certainly hadn’t invited him. Khagr had taken charge, or at least, he said he was taking charge. Yet somehow it was Fili who had sent out the death-notices sealed with black wax, found rooms or inns for all the out-of-town mourners, arranged the food, and paid the tomb-cutter and the death-singers from his own money, money that Father had given him for a trip to the Orocarni’s to visit the guild schools.

And Fili had to look after Kili on top of that. Kili was inconsolable. He wanted to lie in his bed all day staring at the wall. He had no memories of their mother’s death. Their grandparents on Father’s side had died before they were born. Khagr had visited rarely in their childhood and Kibil, the older uncle from their grandfather’s earlier marriage, did not even come to the funeral. Father had been everything to Kili; parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles and cousins. Kili behaved like he’d lost his entire family in one terrible blow. He didn’t seem to notice that his brother was still right there.

He certainly didn’t help arrange the funeral or sort out all the estate’s paperwork or go through Father’s belongings or try to keep the stables running as normal, which was partly why Fili (stupid, idiot!) let Khagr help manage it.

Their father had been a good father. He had taught them to ride and to hunt with the bow. He had sent them to good tutors, practiced Khuzdul with them himself, and discussed the histories of the first fathers and first mothers over dinner with them. He gave them the best ponies in the herd and the best rooms in his house.

His delight in his sons was plain to anyone with eyes to see it. When they were young he brought them with him wherever he went, and made them stay up past bedtime to meet important visitors, to boast about them with the sincerity of every parent who thinks their child is better than all other children in this or that way. He had never shown an ounce of disappointment that Fili could not tame the most difficult ponies, or that Kili neglected his bookkeeping lessons to read stories about great heroes winning wars and fighting monsters.

He was a good father; but he did not remarry, and it did not seem to occur to him to hire a governess or a nanny along with the tutors. So from the earliest age, Fili had to be mother to Kili’s scrapes and bruises, and later, to his adolescent griefs and dramas. Fili noticed first when the two of them grew out of their shoes, out of their clothes, out of their beds, and had to ask Father for money and buy everything himself. When Fili had a toothache while their father was away, he had to ride into town and find a reputable barber-surgeon himself. Their father was always busy running the stables, and he let them roam where they liked. It felt like freedom somedays, and other days it just meant Fili was the one who had to cajole and bully his brother into staying home for lessons, or coming home before dark.

When Kili got caught in bed with the daughter of a Blacklock noble, Father of course did the diplomacy and a little bit of apology-money, and it was all smoothed over with no long-term harm. But none of it would have happened if Father had listened to Fili and given Kili a proper talking-to beforehand, when the two youngsters had started their surreptitious courting. Kili’s would-be paramour was promised to the Prince of a distant royal alliance, and it had been clear to apparently nobody except Fili that the poor girl was desperate to escape her engagement by any means, including by getting herself in an unmarriageable condition with the pony-trader’s son. But Father was indulgent, and thought his children could do no wrong, and thought Kili sneaking around with girls far above his station was cheeky instead of nearly life-ruining.

Fili had planned to go to the Orocarni mountains the day he turned seventy-five to find himself a school, and from there a trade or a craft. He was a wealthy and well-educated young dwarf with a good head for business, but he knew he didn’t have an artisan’s hands or a gem-cutter’s rock-sense. He would take up something with changing fashions, where brains and good taste were required to sell it, and from there he’d get a position in a court - there were minor royal houses and noble dukedoms everywhere, in the East - and build a life. His own life.

If Father had died ten months and a day later, everything would have been so different.

—

Fili awoke with a jolt, nearly falling out of his chair.

It took him a moment to remember where he was. A room at least twice as big as their living room in their Laketown house, with walls of polished stone. Bright lamps hung from the ceiling, and the huge, geometric hearth had a fire burning merrily behind some kind of glass or rock-crystal shield, cleverly pulling in fresh air through unseen grates but letting almost no smell of smoke into the enclosed room.

They were in the great halls of Erebor, cut into the living rock like the homes of the forefathers who built Moria and the kingdoms of the Orocarnis. It was like walking through an epic ballad, but he’d had little time to marvel as they were hurried upstairs. Once the dwarves at the gate understood the nature of their errand, a makeshift sickbay had been arranged for Sigrid in one of the guest rooms where non-dwarvish visitors were usually hosted, as these were the only rooms that had beds large enough for her. Fili had dozed off while sitting upright beside Sigrid’s bedside.

Now a dwarf named Oin and two other physicians were examining Sigrid for any sign of injury or ailment, perhaps not trusting that the simple Lake-folk knew what they were doing.

Tilda sat on a stool in the centre of the room and was explaining everything she had seen the night the dragon came, while another dwarf in red velvet, named Balin, listened with a silent, grim expression. Balin had a large, neat, white beard and seemed to be the oldest and presumably most important fellow in the room. Another, younger dwarf named Ori was taking notes. Tilda’s elocution had improved markedly over the course of her schooling. She was precise and illustrative in her description of Smaug and his diminished condition compared to the fire-breathing drake she had witnessed the last time he attacked the town, right down to details of the iron collar he was wearing.

When Tilda got to the part of the story where Sigrid was stupefied by the dragon’s gaze and rescued in the nick of time by Fili, Tilda pointed across at him and every face in the room looked at him. Fili felt himself go slightly pink and folded his arms defensively. He heard a snigger from Kili, who had been roaming about inspecting the stone bas-relief carvings in the wainscoting.

Kili said in a mock-serious voice. “Tilda, don’t forget the part where he swam fifty feet carrying Sigrid and came up between the piles right under Smaug’s front claws.”

“Kili, this is not funny, let me talk,” Tilda snapped at him. “As I was going to say, since then, Sigrid cannot be roused from her trance. That’s why we came here,” she finished. “My father thought your famous hobbit might have some idea of how to cure her, since he has faced the dragon before.”

“This is a strange story indeed,” Balin took a few steps around Tilda’s seat. “So the dragon did not speak, not a word?”

“No,” Tilda shook her head and looked at Kili. “Nor when he attacked the militia, as I understand it.”

“Could he have been rendered mute by his injuries?” Oin rumbled from Sigrid’s bedside. “Did the arrow pass through his throat?”

Tilda shook her head. “I’ll show you where it is,” she held out her hands for the lap desk that the scribe was using, and when Ori meekly handed it over she took his quill and held it with a practiced hand. Without a blotch in the ink, she sketched Smaug’s head and the location of the arrow in bold lines across the parchment before handing the writing board back to Ori.

“Perhaps he is in the thrall of something greater and more terrible,” Balin mused, stroking his beard. “Who placed the collar there?”

Oin clicked his tongue and looked at his fellow physicians. “The girl is right about one thing, her sister seems to have no physical injury. Her condition is consistent with some kind of enchantment, though I’ve never seen the like.”

Balin nodded. “Then he has enchanted this maiden, but himself is enchanted by some other power. And yet the attack on Laketown seems such poor planning, so their mastery of him may not be complete, and was his attempt at revenge despite his master’s will. A strange riddle to unpick.”

There was an alarmed clamour of questions from Ori about what to put in the notes, but Balin raised his hand and the young dwarf fell quiet. “Where is Bilbo?”

As he asked this, Balin looked to the corner by the fire. Fili realised there was someone else sitting there, on the far side of the mantelpiece. The dwarf in the corner seemed to have found the only part of the room somewhat in shadow, so his face was hard to see. He wore a plainer set of clothes than the others, with his dark, curly hair flowing unbound over his shoulders. He answered Balin, “At this time of night? Asleep with a book on his lap.”

“Ori, go fetch him,” Balin commanded. He smiled at Tilda. “You have done a brave thing coming here, my lass. I cannot promise you anything more than our gratitude for your story, but we’ll do what we can.”

Ori left at a dash, and Balin came to stand in front of Fili with a diplomatic smile. He waited a moment for Kili to come and join them. Fili wondered if he was supposed to stand up or bow, but he thought about it so long it felt like he missed his chance, so he stayed in his seat.

“I believe you already heard that my name is Balin, at your service,” the old dwarf said, hands still clasped behind his back. “I chair the king’s inner council. If there is anything you require of the king, you may petition me for it.”

Fili glanced at Sigrid in the bed. “Perhaps ask Tilda, but I think she has everything she needs, thank you.”

Balin looked between their faces. “I mean for yourselves.”

Fili looked at his brother. Kili looked much more offended by Balin’s question than seemed fair, so Fili decided to take the lead. “We only came to help our friend, and anyway, it’s Bard who would owe us payment for the favour - which we wouldn’t accept,” he hastened to add. “Bard and his family have been good neighbours to us since we arrived in Laketown.”

“I’m heartened to hear it,” Balin smiled warmly at him and paused, as if to say something else, but then simply nodded and turned away. Fili could see that the dwarf in the corner was watching this conversation, no doubt able to hear them clearly in the quiet room. He wore a very serious expression, but his face had looked serious since Fili first noticed him.

Fili reached over and tugged Kili’s sleeve. “What was that? Why is he offering us… money? What did I miss while I was asleep?”

“Not much. That’s the first one who’s bothered to formally introduce himself,” Kili mumbled back.

“I assume they think any dwarf from Laketown is a vagabond who needs to be paid to leave their palace,” Fili rolled his eyes at Kili, but Kili didn’t respond with a laugh or a wink; he still appeared furious about what Balin had said.

Before they could discuss it further, Ori returned trailing Bilbo, who was tying a thick dressing gown over his nightwear. He looked around the room and focused on Sigrid’s vacant face. There was no mistaking the pity in his eyes, though Fili knew he’d met only Sigrid twice in six years.

Oin explained the shape of the illness to Bilbo, while Tilda lingered just over his shoulder. Bilbo took the stool over to Sigrid and perched himself on it, settling on the other side of the bed from Fili. He scratched his nose and twisted his fingers on his lap.

“I’m sorry,” he said, looking up at Tilda at last. “I really don’t know what you want me to do.”

Tilda, so confident with the dwarves a moment before, immediately looked at her feet and began to cry, raising her hand to try and hide it. Kili went over and made her sit down on the end of the bed by Sigrid’s feet, saying something soothing to her as she folded herself over her lap, covering her face.

Fili leaned over the bed towards Bilbo. Between them, Sigrid mouthed some nothingness silently into the air. He asked, “But how did you repel the dragon? All those years ago?”

“Riddles. Luck. Hiding,” Bilbo said softly. “Avoiding eye contact,” he winced. “Not that I’m saying there was anything she could have done. Has she gotten any better, since it happened?”

Fili rested his elbow on the mattress beside Sigrid’s head. “We don’t think so. She talks sometimes, but it doesn’t make sense. It’s like she’s in another world, a world of nightmares and shadows.”

Bilbo said nothing for a few moments, and then Fili heard him mutter to himself, “A world of shadows, hmm,” he looked up. “There is… there is something I could try. Something small… like a little spell. It’s a long shot, but it might help me see things from her perspective.”

There was the scraping of a chair and they both looked over. The dwarf in the corner had stood up, shaking his head. “No. Not within the walls of Erebor.”

Bilbo raised a hand to him as if warding off his words. “Only for a few minutes.”

“I forbid it.”

“Oh, well, that’s me told, we’ll just let her waste away, then?” Bilbo said with a grimace. Tilda began to cry harder, burying her face in Kili’s shoulder. Balin ‘tsk’ed at Bilbo, but also looked as lost as the rest of them at this exchange.

The dwarf in the corner let out a long breath. “A few minutes, then.” He nodded at Oin and his assistants. “Put out the lamps, screen the light of the fire.”

“Why? What is the danger?” Balin took a step towards him, but stopped at a glance from the other dwarf. He threw his hands up with a sigh. “Very well, I’ve long given up questioning the wisdom of hobbits.”

In moments, the room was darkened to obsidian, darker than a moonless night on the lake. Fili heard Tilda give a little gasp and then stifle her breath, like a rabbit under the shadow of a hawk. Although he’d never been so deep beneath stone, he found he didn’t feel any fear. He might have been raised in the open grasslands of the East, but he was still a dwarf.

Ori had unfolded a solid, iron shield over the hearth, but it did not entirely cover the back-reflections, and a little light still came from the fire like the corona around an eclipse. As his eyes adjusted, Fili found he could still see the pale profile of Sigrid’s face on the pillow, glowing red like the last embers of a campfire. But it was so dark he found he could not see Bilbo’s face across the bed, even though he must be only a few feet away.

Nobody spoke for a few moments, and then Bilbo said. “Ah, you poor thing, what an awful racket. You’ve been putting up with this for two days?”

And in the bare glow, Sigrid’s face turned towards the sound of his voice. Bilbo said, “Aha! Hello! Can you see me, Sigrid? It’s Bilbo Baggins, do you know me? We bumped into each other a few months ago,” there seemed to be no response from Sigrid. “Do you know who you are?”

Sigrid’s jaw moved, forming around a slow, forced word that seemed to cause her great pain. “Sigrid.”

It was not even a whisper, but the entire room was holding its breath, and the rasp of the name seemed to fill the space.

“Yes! Yes, you are,” Bilbo’s voice rose a little in excitement. “I know it doesn’t seem like it, but you’re safe, Sigrid.” A note of urgency entered his voice. “No– don’t listen to him, don’t listen to any of them, they are mere artifice of the beast echoing in your head. None of them are real. Sigrid, stop looking at them!”

Sigrid hadn’t moved, her face was still turned to Bilbo’s voice, but her eyes were glancing frantically around the room. There was nothing there.

Fili could not stand it any longer. He seized Sigrid’s hand and squeezed it tight, tighter than would be comfortable, forgetting his strength and her frailty. Sigrid’s head whipped around and for a moment he thought he had ruined everything by breaking whatever magic Bilbo was performing.

“Fili?” she said, in a clear, low voice. Her other hand reached across her prone body and touched his wrist, her fingers mapping up his arm to the rolled hem of his shirt. “I can feel your hand.”

“Yes. I’m here, Sigrid,” and for a moment, on the tip of his tongue, he nearly spoke some endearment - darling, sweetheart, ibinê - and just stopped short.

There was movement in the corner of his eye. He saw Bilbo, suddenly visible in the smidge of light, standing up to strike a match and put it to one of the lamps above the bed. Somebody uncovered the fire and the physicians came crowding in. Tilda was leaning over the foot of the bed, her hand on Sigrid’s knee through the blankets.

“Tilda?” Sigrid croaked. “Bilbo? Where are we?”

Her face looked drained, her eyes bloodshot and hollowed, her skin pale and clammy. It was as if fighting her way out of the nightmare had been the peak of a vile fever and she had only just broken through it. She smiled at her sister. “Have you been crying? For me?”

“Yes, you stupid—“ Tilda sobbed and hid her face again. “Stop looking at me like that, I’ll start all over again!”

“I’ll never stop trying to embarrass you, little sister,” Sigrid mumbled. “Can someone bring me water, please?”

—-

Sigrid was groggy and clearly hungry, explaining to the physicians that her throat and eyes were dry and painful. Tilda would not leave her sister’s side while the healers went about their care, chattering to Sigrid about everything that had happened, reassuring her that the town had been saved and Bain would probably recover. Sigrid wanted to send a letter to Bard at first light, and Ori said they didn’t have to wait that long, they could send a raven tonight if there was enough of a moon. He stayed so Sigrid could dictate to him, as her hand was still too shaky to write.

The rest of them left, Balin and the long-haired dwarf going ahead with their heads bent in some quiet conversation. Bilbo stayed for a moment to say goodbye and then trotted out, yawning and pulling his dressing gown tighter over his round belly. Fili gave Sigrid’s shoulder a last squeeze, and she glanced at him, met his eyes, and then was distracted by Tilda again. He left with Kili, and only realised as they got out into the echoing, shining halls how exhausted he was.

Balin and the unnamed dwarf were still in the corridor, at the edge of the landing where the stairs opened up into a greater hall with paths deeper into the mountain. Balin saw Fili yawn and came back to them. He gave them a small bow.

“I’m glad we could be of service to Bard’s family, and that he has such friends as you. There’s rooms made up for you, if you’ll follow me. In the morning, King Thorin would like to speak to you, if you’ll be kind enough to join him for breakfast.”

“We’ll be leaving first thing,” Kili said at once, with a snap in his tone. “I’ve got repairs due in Laketown.”

Fili elbowed him, “Oh, we could stay a day, surely? For the king,” he smiled at his brother and waved his hand at the grand hall just beyond. “Did you ever imagine we’d see the inside of a palace like this, brother?”

Kili was watching the dark-haired, unnamed dwarf. Fili had been craning his neck to stare up at the distant ceiling of the mountain halls and took a moment to realise that the dark-haired dwarf was in turn staring at him, at Fili.

Kili didn’t reply to his brother’s question; he just continued to glare at their nameless companion while Balin hovered at the edge, waiting for them to follow him. At last, the unnamed dwarf came over to join the tense gathering. “Surely you are not in such a rush to return to that chilly town on the lake. Bilbo mentioned you came from the East a few winters back, you must prefer milder seasons.”

Fili nodded, “We’re Stonefoot, born and bred.”

“On your father’s side?”

Fili didn’t really understand the emphasis, but he nodded. “That’s right. Father bred and traded ponies, but neither of us had the gift of talking to them. Our uncle sold the herd for coppers after he died.”

The dark-haired dwarf cut in, almost as if he had been waiting to snatch an opening in the conversation. “I knew a Stonefoot pony trader when I was young. He used to take his flock from Rhûn to the Western shore to cover the best breeds. I never met a dwarf better travelled. He had gold hair, like yours. Very unusual in these parts of the world.”

“Ay, there’s scores of stables in the east,” Fili grinned. “And plenty of yellow-haired dwarves, too. Your friend was probably not one of our kin.”

“No? What was your Da’s name, then?”

“Vili, son of Vim.”

The dwarf raised one eyebrow. Fili laughed and drew back, “Not the same?”

“The same. I knew him well. I went to his wedding.”

“You didn’t—! You were at our father’s wedding?”

There was a sharp, furious grunt from Kili; Fili flinched with the shock of it, but Kili’s voice shoved into the conversation. “Oh come off it. Just ask us what you really want to ask. Your king already sent Bilbo to spy on us and Balin to bribe us, I’m sorry their answers haven’t assuaged his curiosity. Can you just tell us what he wants? Because if the king is willing to pay us a ransom to sod off back to the east and never threaten his reign again I can completely, utterly guarantee we’d take the money and get as far away from that rat-infested swamp of a town on the lake—“

“Laddie, let’s take breath—“ Balin tried to intervene, physically stepping between Kili and the dark-haired dwarf.

“Kili! What has gotten into you?” Fili grabbed his arm and laughed nervously. “Mama didn’t teach you those manners.”

“There, someone finally mentioned her. That’s what you are so desperate to know, isn’t it?” Kili almost spat. “Our mother’s name? That’s what the great King Thorin really needs to know?”

The strange dwarf held his gaze and let the hall fall quiet. His arms were loosely folded across his chest, but it looked more like self-preservation than a challenge. And then the faintest smile crossed his face. “I don’t have to ask, Kili,” he said, and his voice creaked with the weight of it. “You sound just like her.”

Kili’s anger faltered into a wordless confusion. Fili, ever the diplomat, spoke to patch up his brother’s offense. “You knew Ma? From way back in Ered Luin?”

The dwarf smiled wider, but with such grief in his face that even these two strangers could see it. “Yes. And I knew you both. I met you moments after you were born. I remember the days you crawled, ran, spoke for the first time; I taught Fili his first letters. Memories more precious than any treasure in this mountain.”

Fili’s heart was pounding in his chest. His memories of a childhood before his mother died were far away in a mist, with flashes showing through like lightning. He remembered sleeping in a tent between his parents, on a warm summer night. He remembered Kili, too small to walk the trade roads yet, riding on his mother’s back in a sling. And there was a memory of a dwarf so tall he might have been a mountain, a dwarf who carried a real sword and sung to him as they walked side by side. In the broken, distant memory, he showed Fili the delicate filigree on the handle, explaining the meaning behind each rune and image, then gave him a stick and sparred with the sheathed sword until, defeated by the tiny child’s blows, he fell to the ground and cried for mercy as Fili climbed on his chest with a war holler.

Fili swallowed. “Uncle,” he felt the blood flush up his neck, beneath his beard. “I… don’t remember your name, I am sorry. Our father never told us we still had family alive in the West.”

“My name is Thorin,” the dwarf said, beginning to smile.

“Oh. Like the king?”

“Yes, Fili, like the king.” Thorin began to laugh, a deep, rolling chuckle like stones in a mine shaft. “Your father told you nothing of your mother’s family?”

Fili looked at his brother. Kili’s face was ashen and clammy, his eyes wide. He looked like he was going to throw up. His mouth opened, gaped like a gull as he tried to speak. Fili finally answered for him, “Nothing of substance.”

“I think he planned to, when we were grown,” Kili croaked, and fumbled at the inside pockets of his coat. He withdrew a black fold of old, stained leather that Fili had never seen before and thrust it at Thorin, almost like a defensive parry, and Thorin took it and opened it. Kili said in a rush, “He died before giving us this. Father must have kept it hidden, and our uncle - his brother - found it when he inherited the estate. I’ll wager it was at the bottom of a trunk somewhere after everything was sold, when Khagr was scrabbling for any trinket to pay his debts. He said he’d uncovered an heirloom of our house that would fetch a high price in Erebor, he insisted we pack up everything and leave in the middle of the night. He had all sorts of villains chasing him for money and we didn’t think it was worth staying behind to meet them. But he never told us what he’d found, he just brought us to Esgaroth and then he drowned, and this ended up in the canal. I found out about it and pulled it out of the mud the day before yesterday. That’s the first that I knew of the truth - yesterday, I swear, I’m so sorry, I didn’t know anything until a day or two ago. Thorin, I’m sorry,” and he stepped back and attempted a stiff bow.

“Didn’t know what?” Fili frowned, leaning over to try and read the ruined parchment in Thorin’s hands. His gaze followed the spindly lines that spread across the page, a long trunk growing down from the top, widening into branches and then narrowing, down to a single point with two names. It was obviously a pedigree, hand-drawn from someone’s memory rather than a precious artifact illuminated by a professional scribe. It didn’t look expensive.

Fili could see the shape of the names at the top of the tree. He couldn’t guess at anything else as he went down the tree, as the names multiplied and the writing got too small to read upside-down.

“It’s your mother’s hand,” Thorin said quietly. “She made this for you, to teach you who you are,” and he handed it to Fili.

Fili looked at the parchment, rotting at the edges, the ink faded and patchy. He looked at the names at the top.

He looked at the names at the bottom.

Fili raised his head so fast he had a moment of vertigo. Thorin smiled at him, and Kili put his hand on his shoulder.

“I think I should sit down,” said Fili.

Chapter 8

Notes:

Thank you to everyone for reading, I have really loved writing this story. I already have the sequel/continuation written and ready to start posting, although I will take a few days to edit and clean it up.

If you did enjoy this and want to read the next part of the story as soon as it's ready, please follow me or the new series where I'll post the sequel.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

In the morning, no one woke them in their palatial bedroom. Fili stirred under the growing glow of what seemed to be real sunlight, captured and reflected through who knew how many twists and tunnels before it trickled in through a shaft in the ceiling of the guest room. Some servant must have come in early, because there was a little breakfast waiting on a table beside the wide, recessed entrance.

There were clothes laid out on another table, on the other side of the entrance. Fili shoved a piece of thick-buttered bread in his mouth and then wiped his hands on the tablecloth and went to inspect the clothes. There were two outfits, similar but for the details of the cut and the colour. Both were elaborately decorated, Dale-made brocade with leather belts and fine-spun, wool doublets. One was of soft grey, with blue embroidery on the doublet, and was long in the chest and leg; clearly meant for Kili. It was far too broad across the shoulders and thighs for him though, so Fili was heartened to think it had probably been borrowed from the wardrobe of some tall dwarf on short notice, and not miraculously cut and stitched in a few hours.

The other outfit was a near-uniform, dark blue. Fili held the tunic up against his chest. He recognised the colour as he glanced in the mirror. It was the deep blue of the King’s cloak, which they had all seen that day - it felt like years ago - when Tilda had pointed Thorin out from the promenade in Dale.

Fili stepped back from the mirror. The toast seemed to squirm in his stomach.

He found a basin of clean water and towels in a side room, and a comb that appeared to be made of silver, inset with tiny images of dwarves smithing. He cleaned himself up, tamed his hair and put on his old clothes, his own familiar Laketown-made linen, the threads failing at the seams, and his brown, wool trousers with varnish stains.

He had to ask a passing dam for directions back to the makeshift sick bay, though it was only a couple of corridors away. Sigrid was sitting up in bed, holding a steaming cup of dark, creamy tea. Her eyes were lucid and as he sat down beside her she smiled that familiar, wry twist.

“How do you feel?” Fili asked.

She reached out and took his hand. “Like I’ve walked miles uphill in a thunderstorm, but alive. Thank you,” she shook her head. “You can’t imagine how it was to feel a hand, hear your voice in that horrible, loud place. I’m sure I should be worried about nightmares for the rest of my life, but all I can think about right now is the joy of being out of there.”

“You can thank Bilbo for the cure.”

“I’m thanking you,” she said, and squeezed his hand.

Fili swallowed. “Sigrid, would you marry me if I was the crown prince of the greatest dwarf kingdom west of Rhûn?”

She considered his face for a long time before she said, “No.” Like a candle-flame in a breath, Fili felt the flickering out of a life, a future, a world where he could have been mostly happy and lived a mostly quiet life; yet the loss of it was not as painful as he expected.

Then Sigrid asked with a frown and a soft laugh, “Are you the crown prince of the greatest dwarf kingdom west of Rhûn?”

Fili echoed her laugh. “Yes. I think I am.”

“Well,” she relaxed back against the pillow again. “Throw me in the lake and call me a fish, that’s not what I expected to wake up to.”

—-

They were able to spend most of that day in anonymity. Erebor was full of activity, much of it apparently armoured and armed. When Fili returned from visiting Sigrid, he found a very friendly fellow named Bofur had been sent to meet them at their room and guide them on a tour of the main districts of the mountain.

Bofur walked fast and talked even faster, but his guests were a difficult audience and even he ran out of jokes once or twice. During one long silence, while they were heading down from the mirror-gardens that ringed the upper levels, Fili tried to fill the gap and asked him his trade.

Bofur laughed. “Nothing. I do absolutely nothing. I live pleasurably on the profits of our quest and occasionally act as nanny for poncy diplomats from the Eastern kingdoms," he looked back at them with a frown. “Wait, are you poncy diplomats from the Eastern kingdoms?”

“No. We’re from Laketown,” Kili said quickly.

“Ah! Yes, you must be part of that local militia that drove off the dragon. It’s supposed to be hush-hush, they’re trying not to panic anyone, but the rumours are spreading like fire in a coal seam and my lads, I tell you, so is the panic. I can’t imagine why, when’s the last time a dragon bothered Erebor? Not in your lifetimes, I’m certain,” he gave them a wicked grin. “Do you think he’s coming here, then?”

“Who?”

“Smaug,” Bofur turned and stopped. They had reached a quiet intersection with stairs dropping away in two directions. For the first time, Bofur’s mirth showed a little thin on his face. “The one who’s supposed to be dead.”

Fili shook his head. “I wish I could tell you. But he’s had almost three days, and it’s not a long walk.”

Bofur laughed. “True enough. So either you scared him off, or he’s bringing friends.”

Back in the luxurious guest room, someone brought them tea and a kind of honey-soaked spice cake that was inedibly sweet. They sat at the wrought table under the sun shaft and stared at a mosaic of Durin the Deathless discovering Mirrormere. Neither of them spoke for a long time.

“Are you angry that I didn’t tell you straight away?” Kili asked at last.

“Yes,” Fili said, angrily.

“You were so worried about Sigrid, and we all thought the dragon would come back any minute,” Kili leaned across the table. “There just wasn’t a good time.”

“Stars above, Kili, this was kind of important to mention,” Fili couldn’t think what else to say. He couldn’t really think, to be honest.

“What are you going to do?” Kili asked.

Fili looked at him. “Me? Don’t you mean ‘we’?”

“I could still leave and go back home. Really home, I mean, back to Rhûn, open a workshop there. I don’t know if I can stay here and ‘do absolutely nothing’ like Bofur, living the life of a pampered prince. And I’m not going back to finish my sodding apprenticeship with Kibil. He can’t threaten us once he finds out we’re royalty. I’ll go back to the house, pick up my stuff and find a lodging house in Laketown until Bard says it’s safe to travel the roads again.”

“Don’t you think he’d be angry?” Fili winced. They both understood who ‘he’ was, and it was not Uncle Kibil.

“I think he would be a bit sad, but he doesn’t even know me,” Kili swallowed. “When Mama and Father took us away, I must have been barely stringing two words together. Last night in the sick room, it was you he was staring at the whole time. Assessing you, I think, but also yearning. Whatever is really going on here, if there really is some succession crisis brewing or if he just remembers you more fondly, he… I mean this as a warning because you’re my brother… I’m scared of what Thorin will do if you try to leave,” Kili put his hand on Fili’s arm and shook his head.

Fili put his hand on top of Kili’s. “Do you want to go home to Rhûn?”

Kili shrugged. He pulled his hand back and slumped into the chair, staring into his half-drunk teacup. “I’m a grown dwarf now, I’m trained, I can take care of myself. It might be better if I left.”

“Better for the king?” Fili frowned.

“For you. You wouldn’t have to look after me anymore. Finally.”

Fili felt a cold shiver run through him. “Kili, I don’t…” could he really deny it? He’d wanted to get away from Kili, and Father, and the stables. But that had been a different world, lifetimes ago. They were staring into another turn of fortune again, at least as dramatic as the last one. “I want you to be whoever you want to be,” he said slowly. “But if you want to stay and be my brother, I’d like that a lot.”

Kili’s mouth wobbled in the beginning of a smile, but before he could reply, there was a knock on the door. Fili swore under his breath and turned to call them in. It was a retainer in royal livery, asking them if they would join the King in an early supper. Fili had lost track of what time it was. Everything in this place was so precise and yet so indecipherable.

They asked for a few minutes and the retainer withdrew. Kili looked at him. “Do you think we should wear the outfits?”

“I’m not wearing that getup,” said Fili. “And it’s going to look blazing rude if you wear it and I don’t.”

“Ah, Mahal take you, I wanted to wear it,” Kili said with a warm smile. “If they’d given us a bit more time we could have at least visited the laundry room!”

The retainer returned soon and led them along passages and up and down stairways and across the span of a great, busy highway trafficked not just by dwarves but full carts and ponies, lit by enormous spheres of burning light that Fili was aching to understand the engineering of. Fili was fairly sure he’d mapped out the vague shape of the Erebor that Bofur had shown them around, and this was not in any of those public places. They must have entered the private manors of the royal family and their court.

At last they were waved into what, for Erebor, was probably quite a small dining room deep in the mountain. It was still large enough that it would fit the entire of Bard and the dwarves’ houses together in Laketown. The walls were a pale, greenish marble unlike the dark-grey granite of Erebor’s raw-cut halls or the deep shades of reddish-black and brown stone that sheathed the walls of the guest rooms. Combined with the strange lamps flickering in their glass braziers, it almost felt like they were underwater.

For some reason, Fili had assumed this would be a private dinner, just the two of them and the King. However, the large table in the centre of the room had eight chairs around it.

Thorin sat at the far end of the table, his eyes flicking to meet theirs as they entered. There were two empty chairs on his left hand, while the two on his right were filled by Balin and an enormous, bald-topped dwarf. Tilda was next to the two empty chairs and Sigrid sat opposite her, next to the bald dwarf. Peering around the last chair because he was considerably shorter than the high back, at the end of the table facing the king, was Bilbo.

The bald dwarf got up at once and came towards them in what was frankly quite a threatening manner. When he arrived in front of them he bowed low. “Dwalin, son of Fundin, at your service,” he straightened up. He clapped his meaty hands on each of their shoulders, so hard Fili had to brace his knees. “It is good to see you both again, my princes. Your mother was,” and Fili could almost swear there was a sheen in his eyes, “very dear to me.”

As they sat down, Fili realised what a mistake his stubbornness about the clothes had been. Although the other dwarves had dressed in relatively plain robes, they were still of the finest weaves he’d seen before he came to the mountain, and perfectly clean and crisp at every angle. And both Sigrid and Tilda had been given dresses that shone like rippling blue and amber pastures, and sparkled with gems around the collar and chest. Fili couldn’t really blame them for accepting the outfits; Sigrid’s clothes would have been wretched after two days of sickness, and it would have been cruel to ask Tilda to pass up the chance to dress in finery. But it did make Fili and Kili look absolutely ridiculous. They hadn’t even polished their boots.

Without really thinking, Fili started to take the chair next to Tilda, but Kili came up close and gave him a sharp kick to the side of his leg. Fili quickly pretended he was just saying hello to her. It was clear he was supposed to have the chair at the end, beside Thorin and opposite Balin. Kili got to sit down in the much more comfortable spot next to Tilda and within conversational distance of Sigrid and Bilbo.

This is going to be the longest dinner of my life, Fili thought.

Food was brought in by servers as if by clockwork. For the first course, Fili’s end of the table was almost silent, except for pleasantries. Fili couldn’t even discuss the weather, since there was none in the mountain. At the other end of the table, he could hear Tilda regaling Bilbo and Dwalin with the story about the dragon attack, except with even more drama and embellishment than when she’d told it last night to Balin. She must have had a conversation with Kili about his version of events, because she even added in everything that had happened to the militia when they’d stumbled upon the dragon on the shore.

Fili remembered that night in his own mind as moments of utter terror - the long hours of waiting for the militia, the moment he’d seen Kili and the others running for their lives, the sight of the beast - crushed together with the moments that had no feeling at all, only the memory of doing, of running onto the bridge towards Sigrid, towards Smaug, and swimming until his lungs burned. The hours of clinging to the bridge pile, freezing, calling for help until his throat ached. The slow surety creeping over him that Sigrid’s mind was no longer in her body. It was so cold in the water he thought he would die clinging to that pile, and for nothing, because Sigrid was gone anyway. Flashes of it were so clear that his body twitched like it was trying to mimic the movements even while he sat here safe and warm in the mountain hall.

He remembered that when it all happened, Tilda had looked as scared as he’d felt, but now she had already found the courage to tell the story like it was an adventure, as if she was an old-fashioned lore-speaker who’d gone by choice to record the deeds of these great heroes. And Dwalin was crying, “No! The beast’s breath did what?” and other such comments in suitably impressed tones.

Fili looked over and made eye contact with Sigrid. She looked a little green - but maybe it was just the light. She smiled at him and gave an indulgent nod at her little sister. She mouthed something at him. He cupped his hand around his ear and she mouthed again - Thank you.

He shrugged and waved his hand. For what?

She brought her hands together in a cupping motion and then pointed at herself. For saving me.

He flattened his hand on his chest and inclined his head. You’re welcome.

There was a clink as a server retrieved his empty plate and he looked back to his end of the table. He realised Thorin was, once again, watching him with a sharp and inscrutable expression and had seen the silent exchange with Sigrid. Another course was placed in front of him but his stomach had no hunger left for it.

Thorin seemed to be trying to find the words to speak, and then cutting himself off before he could say them. Fili decided that he had to follow Tilda’s lead and at least fake courage. He asked Thorin, “Did you know we were still alive, this whole time?”

Thorin shook his head, picking up his fork and turning to the latest course, which consisted of tiny slices of salted meat each topped with a small lump of some kind of fruit relish. “I had no reason to think you were dead, but you were as seeds in the wind.”

He paused, and Balin stepped in to explain. “After we reclaimed Erebor, Thorin sent many dwarves east to bring you home to your birthright. They returned with the news that your father was dead and his children made destitute and vanished, no one knew where. We could not have imagined you were under our noses this entire time.”

“So it was no secret that we existed,” Fili was starting to put things together from Thorin’s perspective. “And I imagine when Bilbo told you who he’d met in Dale, the risk of imposters was not far from your mind. Come to steal a share of Erebor’s wealth.”

“Yes,” Thorin agreed heavily. “It was a risk I had to guard against. I had to see you for myself before I made any move to acknowledge you. In truth, I thought it so unlikely that Bilbo was right, that I was not willing to entertain even a hope.”

Fili poked at the appetiser on his plate. The fork looked like pure silver; the plate was a fine, white porcelain so delicate it seemed to glow from beneath. “And are you sure?” he said carefully. “Our uncle Khagr was a master of the swindle. I’ve seen him talk clever, well-learned dwarves into practically selling their mothers. Mama’s handwriting on that pedigree proves only that someone found her papers, not that we are really her sons. And the last time you met me, I was - what? Eight? Nine? Am I that same dwarf?”

Thorin glanced at Fili’s worn, faded clothes and the simple, wooden beads in his hair. “From what I have gathered,” and here, Fili was sure he meant, ‘what my spies and agents have gathered’ because he obviously had not been knocking on doors in Laketown in person, “since you arrived in Esgaroth many years ago, you’ve made no grand claims to royalty and asked for nothing from Erebor, except the life of your friend,” he indicated Sigrid at the other end of the table with a twitch of his hand without looking away from Fili. “If this is a play, it is a long and strange one.”

Fili swallowed. He still felt like a cheat. He kept trying to think of ways it could be a mistake. Could it all be happenstance? Could Khagr have learned about the missing princes, noticed the coincidence of their names and ages, forged the pedigree and dragged them here with a plan to sell them to Erebor and then sod off with the profits before anyone figured out the racket? But then their parents’ names must be a coincidence too, and he and Kili were born in Ered Luin, Father had never lied about that.

And he remembered the way Bilbo had stared at him that very first day in Dale. Bilbo had heard his name shouted in the crowd and recognised his face, though they’d never met before. He had seen a family resemblance that had been convincing enough for him to follow them to Laketown to try and engineer a ‘chance’ meeting with Thorin that very night, in the middle of the war council. Fili looked at Thorin’s sharp profile across the table and touched his own nose, and then pretended he was just scratching it.

It had to be true. A part of him was furious that Khagr had kept this hidden from him. But then he’d also have to be furious at his father for doing the same. He had the faintest memories of saying to his father, when he was very young, things like, “I don’t have to do what you say. Mama said we were descended from kings.” And his father would ruffle his hair and reply, “Oh yes, of course she did, all mothers think their sons are little princes." Father must have been so afraid that if they found out their heritage, they would run away to Ered Luin to reclaim it, that after their mother died Father never breathed a word of her family name or homeland. Father was not really denying them anything of material value, since Erebor was still occupied by the dragon at that time. Fili couldn’t bring himself to be angry, not at Father, not even at Khagr. What a waste of feeling it would be, against two dead dwarves.

“Why didn’t you try to find us until you had Erebor?” Fili tried to put a forkfull of food in his mouth but had to force himself to swallow it.

Thorin raised an eyebrow at him.

Fili knew he was dancing around the questions he really wanted to ask. What do you want from me? What use am I to you? So he just came out and said it. “It seems like you didn’t need us until you had a legacy that you wanted to turn into a dynasty.”

He realised too late that the entire table had gone quiet.

Thorin sighed and leaned his elbow on the table. “I would have claimed you as my heirs years before the quest for Erebor, but I had to respect your father’s wishes. What was I to do, steal his children?”

“What do you mean?”

Thorin shook his head. “When your father took the family back east, we thought it would be for two summers, maybe three. But he wrote that your mother had died and he couldn’t risk the journey alone with Kili so young. I sent messengers in person, begged him to give you back to us. He was angry, offended that I would take his children from him. Like I was punishing him for the death of his beloved wife. No more letters came.”

For a moment it seemed he couldn’t find the words to continue. Balin spoke up, “It was a misunderstanding. Among Longbeards, with the death of either parent, the maternal side of the family is expected to be as both mother and father. They often pay for the raising and educating of children, or even take them into their households, to give the surviving parent time to grieve and go where they must. A dwarf who loses a wife or husband needs to be alone, to find understanding for themselves, to accept the will of Mahal, even if such a thing takes years. Caring for their children is supposed to be a kindness. But these are not the traditions of the Stonefoots, so your father took it as an insult.”

“Or he understood,” Fili’s jaw tensed. “You didn’t mean it as a kindness.”

Thorin met his eyes. “No. I would never have let you slip out of my hands again. The last of my kin, the last of the elder line of Durin, two precious reminders of my sister. Your father must have known that, despite my silvered words and pretty platitudes.” His eyes grew dark. “He was a common horse-breaker and I cared nothing for him beyond the good he’d done for Dis. And for my arrogance, I lost you.” And then his face softened. “But here… by the will of the gods, you are home at last.”

Fili tried to smile back. But he thought of Kili’s hand on his arm. I’m scared of what Thorin will do if you try to leave.

—-

Although time was hard to measure, he was sure the dinner had started early in the evening and it seemed it would go on all night, but shortly after the fifth course a messenger arrived with something urgent for Thorin. He, Balin and Dwalin made their apologies and left at a swift pace, while Bilbo walked them back to their rooms.

“I’ll head off to meet some friends. Some of them were in Thorin’s company, when he reclaimed the mountain,” Bilbo explained as they were drawing closer to the guest quarters. “I don’t suppose you’d like to come? It’ll be a bit more,” Bilbo gave an exaggerated wince, “relaxed than tonight’s dinner.”

“Oh, normal dwarves, not important ones? Yes please,” Kili said, practically jumping forward. “Fili?”

“I think I just need to sleep,” Fili said, though his thoughts were screaming in circles around the inside of his skull. “Thank you, Bilbo.”

“I’ll come,” Tilda bounced after them. “Since I’m all dressed up anyway. But Kili, if you tell Da, I shall never speak to you again.”

They stopped outside Fili’s room, and Sigrid came in to try the horrible spice cake, which she agreed was on the rich side but which she ate anyway. Someone knocked and walked in without warning, to offer them tea. Fili jumped as if they’d yelled in his ear. Sigrid asked for tea for two as if it was the most natural thing in the world to have servants, but now Fili was paranoid that Thorin would find out he’d been alone in his room with Sigrid. Were they conservative about that sort of thing, here in Erebor? And why was he even worrying about it? He was just visiting. He didn’t have to follow their rules and proprieties. The tea arrived, and the servant didn’t seem to blink at the two of them sitting alone together, so he tried to relax.

Sigrid drank deeply; since she woke up from the dragon’s spell she seemed to struggle to stay warm. Fili tried to sip his cup. It tasted bitter at first and then clogged his throat when he added cream from the jug. He wished he’d gone out with Tilda and Kili and gotten drunk instead of staying in with his thoughts.

“I did a bad job of my first day as a prince,” Fili muttered, picking the dried fruit out of the spice cake with a tiny fork that he was pretty sure was designed for eating baked snails.

“I’m sure the king doesn’t think that.” Sigrid soothed. “What are you going to do next?”

“I don’t know,” Fili said quietly, leaning in as if Thorin had spies in the walls. “We don’t know anything about these dwarves, about this mountain. Getting involved in the politics of a monarchy like this… what if we’re just pawns in some battle for the succession of Erebor? Your father said Thorin and his people are desperate to produce an heir to keep power out of the hands of the Iron Hills. And worse—“

“Fili—“

“—-and there’s going to be a war with the Grey Mountains, everyone thinks so, and the orcs have a dragon—-“

“Fili.”

“—and I’ve never held a sword in my life, I’m the son of a pony trader, and I don’t even have a pony, I can’t fight a dragon—!”

Sigrid put her hand on his mouth. Her skin was over-warm from holding the teacup, and smelled of the slightly sulfurous water that came from the mountain’s washbasins. He shut up immediately, and she let it fall back onto the table. She said, “Let me talk. My throat still hurts and I can’t shout you down.”

There was a pause, and Fili said, “Well?”

“I’m thinking,” she said, holding his eye. “I think I’d be as panicked as you. I don’t think it’s the dragon that you’re really scared of, or even Thorin. I think it’s because you have been let down by all the others before him. Everyone else died one after another, or turned out to be monsters, or both, and left you with more on your plate to carry. You’ve been completely focused on just keeping you and Kili alive, and now somebody is telling you about this new obligation, this new duty. I understand that feeling of wanting to scream at everyone to just go away and stop giving you things to do,” she shook her head. “But I can tell you from experience, it won’t go away with hiding.”

Fili scrubbed his hand down his face. “I wish we’d left in the summer when we could have made the trip East in good weather. We still could leave, without taking anything from Thorin. If we were nobodies scrabbling for a living back home, at least there would be nothing left for us to lose.”

“And what if Thorin really does want what’s best for you?”

“Then he’ll wait for us to come back when we’re ready,” Fili growled. “Or if not, it will force him to show his real purpose.”

Sigrid tipped her head, her brows furrowed. “Fili, were you not listening to him at dinner? You’re the only family he has left. Make a decision, but don’t make him wait for you any longer.”

“What is my choice? To stay and pretend to be a prince, or go and be a pauper in my father’s land?” Fili dug his hands into his hair. “Anyone would say I was an idiot for thinking twice about it.”

“You could stay and still be a pauper, if you'd prefer that,” Sigrid said quietly. She had taken a small, decorative blanket from the bedside and wrapped it around her shoulders, though the air felt warm and dry to Fili. He waited for her to explain and she said, “If Thorin is just looking for a successor, he won’t want anything but true, dwarvish stock. If you… well, if you were married to me, you’d not be much good to carry on the dynasty, would you? I know how seriously dwarves take marriage. I’m sure he’d accept your abdication.”

Fili stared at her. “Are you really reconsidering?”

“We don’t have to live on the lake. I know you hate it there. We’ll help build Da’s new town in the South, like you wanted all along. If it prospers, and I know it will, it will be a steady, honest life. Thorin could invite us to dinner whenever he likes but he couldn’t force you to be a prince.”

Fili let out a long breath. “It’s not what you wanted. You don’t want to be a mother.”

“I didn’t say that was on the table. But I could do worse for a husband,” she smiled. “Think about it. So that at least you don’t feel Erebor is your only choice.”

—

When Kili and Tilda got back, they were merry but full of news. They had spent the evening with a group of young dwarves, including Ori, the scribe from their first night in the mountain. It had not taken the gathering long before the dwarves were all trying to outdo each other spreading rumours and secrets. Ravens had been back and forth between Erebor and all their allies, even the elves, and although nobody could pin down exactly what the threat was and where it was coming from, it was clear that it was coming.

Sigrid and Fili decided for the four of them; they had to leave the mountain tomorrow, if the threat was not already on the doorstep. If the roads became blocked or shut to forestall an enemy, they could end up trapped in Erebor for who knew how long? If Dale and the mountain were besieged, it could be years.

They decided to leave in the morning, walk the short distance to Dale and stay there overnight, to be sure that Sigrid was properly recovered and to gather any further news. Then they would head straight for the lake the next day. Fili took the responsibility of writing a short goodbye to the king and asking one of the ubiquitous retainers to take it to him, requesting also that a raven be sent to Bard so there would be a boat waiting for them on the north shore.

Balin caught them as they tried to slip out early the next morning, after storing every bit of the extravagant breakfast in their packs and filling their water-skins from Erebor’s fountains. It did not help that they had to ask directions to the front door twice, so they were easy to find.

Balin was panting slightly as he reached them just on the threshold. “Will you wait an hour, at least?” he begged. “The King would like to arrange an armed escort back to the lake.”

“Have there been sightings of danger on the road?” Sigrid pushed.

“No, but he wishes you to be protected.” Balin clasped his hands together. “Things may be moving very quickly, very soon.”

“All the more reason we can’t wait,” Fili said, rearranging the straps of his pack. “I have to get the ladies back to Esgaroth. I promised their father I’d bring them both home safe. Besides, a clumsy armed escort is more likely to attract attention than four walkers dressed like common labourers.”

“Thorin will not be best pleased,” Balin warned. “He would be here himself if he could.”

“Well, let him be as he likes. He’s my uncle, not my king,” Fili replied.

Balin huffed, forming a retort, but Fili turned and waved the others through the small door at the foot of Erebor’s great gate.

The sunshine on his face washed some of the knots from his muscles as they made their way between the arms of the mountain. They were in Dale before the sun marked the eleventh hour. The gates were all shut, but the watchmen had seen them approach from Erebor and ushered them inside.

The watchmen assumed they were envoys from Erebor. When they insisted otherwise and explained they were Bard’s daughters and bodyguards, which seemed the simplest story to stick with, the Dale watchmen decided they must be Esgaroth ambassadors, and brought them straight to the great city hall of Dale. By the time they sorted out the confusion, food and a room had already been arranged for them, which they accepted to avoid any further offense. Kili was delighted to run into Tauriel, who was safe and well in the city hall; she was advising the council of Dale on Thranduil’s intentions and helping them prepare for a possible siege if it came to it.

Kili pulled Tauriel into the room where they’d settled themselves and shut the door. “Do you think it will come to a siege?” he asked her.

“We will try and turn them away first,” Tauriel murmured. “But our scouts and spies bring more confusion than guidance. Three days ago, there were signs of a great force mustering in the North-West mountains, and something coming up from the south. But yesterday, news came that the armies have begun retreating, retraced their own steps, and the smaller forces on the move from clans farther away have now vanished altogether.”

“That’s good news!” Kili looked around at the others all listening in. “Isn’t that good news?”

“Maybe when the dragon failed to breach Laketown, they had to change their plans,” Tilda said hesitantly. “Or they’ve just given up and gone home.”

Tauriel seemed to be gathering her thoughts, perhaps considering what was safe to discuss and what was confidential military judgement. “It is a very great shift in their direction for what seemed like a failed gamble, or possibly even a mistake, if the dragon’s strike was a rogue one. And these retreats were first observed yesterday, not right after the attack at the bridge.”

“Something changed two nights ago,” Fili guessed. He glanced at his brother. “Did your drinking companions say anything about what might have happened?”

Kili shrugged. Tilda said, “That was the first night we were in Erebor. The night Sigrid woke up.”

Without meaning to, Fili thought of the sickbay, and Thorin - before Fili knew he was Thorin - saying to Bilbo, ‘Not within the walls of Erebor. I forbid it.’ Whatever he’d meant, whatever ‘little spell’ Bilbo seemed to have wrought to enter Sigrid’s dreams, even Balin had not been privy to the details. Only the king and the hobbit. But it was just another mystery upon mysteries.

They settled down that night on comfortable, human-sized Dale beds. Kili slipped away when he thought everyone was asleep, no doubt to Tauriel’s room. Fili lay still and let him go without comment. He had been awake since the last bells marked the night-watch, but his eyes didn’t feel the slightest bit heavy.

He could see the clouds through the unshuttered window moving across the stars. He kept expecting to hear a crack as the door was kicked open, or see steel-clad agents climbing in the window. Dale would not protect him against the will of Erebor, and he was sure the king’s army was coming to carry him back to the mountain.

In the thin starlight he could see Sigrid twitching in the next bed, and then with a sharp gasp she awoke. He heard her sit up and swing her legs over the bed.

“New nightmares or old?” he asked. She raised her head, pushing her hair back from her face.

“Hard to say. It’s like memories, but not my memories. Since the dragon came, I feel like everything I dream is real, but not…” she shook her head. “Not our real. It’s hard to explain.”

He was still on top of the bedclothes, and he sat himself up against the wall. He patted the bed beside him and she crossed the gap in bare feet and stretched out along the mattress, pulling his blankets over herself, shivering and shuffling closer to his warmth.

“I’m sure the nightmares will pass with time,” Fili said. “I can’t sleep, do you mind if I smoke?”

“Go ahead,” she was lying on her back, staring into the shadows of the roof beams.

Fili packed his pipe and lit it. The match-flame shone red on their faces and then went out. He nudged her ribs through the blankets. “When you were in the dragon-spell, you said my name.”

Sigrid elbowed him back. “I saw a lot of strange things in the dragon-spell. It wasn’t romantic.”

“The real-but-not things?”

She nodded. “I know now that it was an enchantment, but his voice in my head was so persuasive. My home burned to ashes. The Greenwood poisoned and cut down, the stumps rotting. Erebor enslaved, its people forced to mine down to its crumbling roots by orcs with whips. Iron-shod armies covering the whole world. Some of it felt like omens, but some of it was things that I know never happened. Visions of the past: I saw the night Smaug first came, but it was different, in the dream Da wasn’t there to man the windlance when the mountain started rumbling. He was trapped in a cage and none of us could help him. So Smaug flew over and burned the town to nothing and then fell on it and crushed the ashes, and died for certain. The fire was everywhere, so many dead, and the dragon dead. And you were dead, too.”

“But I wasn’t even in Laketown when the dragon came out of the mountain,” Fili pointed out, waving his pipe. “So it’s just a dream.”

“Yes, that’s true,” Sigrid’s face was tense in the darkness, her gaze moving over the planes of the ceiling, trying to focus on shapes and figures that didn’t exist. “But everything was different. You looked different. You had a sword and armour and your voice sounded different, your accent, your… bearing. You looked like a storybook hero. And it all ended badly.”

Fili let her trail off, drawing on his pipe. He said at last, “I think I’ll stick with being a bookkeeper, then. If that’s my fate as a hero.”

“I don’t think it was the future. The dragon just showed me what was already there,” she said. “That I had all these silly worries about Da, and the town, and you dying.”

He took a long draw on his pipe, and asked softly, “Is that really why you’re rethinking my proposal? Because if I come and live a simple life with you, all those nightmares can’t come true?”

She wouldn’t meet his eye.

He pushed the guess further. “Because if I marry you, you think bad things won’t happen to me? It’s me in particular you’re worried about, isn’t it?”

She shivered. “I suppose it’s ironic. Chances are you’ll still be young and hale when they put me in the ground.” She looked at him and raised her hand, brushed the back of her knuckles against his leg. “Does that make it easier to decide? Because we won’t be forever, you’ll just be buying yourself time to grow up, really.”

He groaned. “That’s not a cheerful reason to get married, Sigrid.”

“I’m not cheerful. I’m Bard’s daughter,” she laughed. They sat without speaking for a while, and Fili realised soon that she was asleep again. He lay down on top of the blankets, facing the window to keep watch. At last he slept fitfully and awoke still safe in the Dale.

So Thorin had not tried to stop them after all.

—

The watchmen let them out the gate again without a fuss. They seemed bored, sitting on the wall staring at the empty valleys and the distant glimmer of the peaceful lake. It felt increasingly hard to believe there really was a war about to break upon their homes. Perhaps Tilda was right. Perhaps the armies had all given up and gone home.

The cart-rutted path from the Dale gate soon joined the wide, smooth road that led from the door of Erebor towards the lake, where it would turn away southwards to the countries beyond. They paused for a moment to drink and eat the last of their pilfered food from yesterday morning, since Dale had given them plenty for the trip, along with letters from the council to take to Bard. The sky was cloudless as it turned slowly towards the coming winter, the air cold but clear, with no smell of smoke or dragon-poison.

Kili and Tilda were already walking on; they had their heads together playing some kind of game, taking turns to pull gloomy faces at each other until the other person crowed with laughter.

Sigrid held out her hand to pull Fili to his feet. “They’re making fun of us.”

“They’ll be younger siblings forever,” Fili said mournfully. “There’s no cure.”

They hefted their packs, but as the others started down the road, Fili found his feet didn’t take a step. Sigrid waited, and then the others noticed and stopped.

“Are you alright?” Kili hollered from up ahead.

Sigrid took a couple of steps closer, slightly downhill from him. Fili reached out and took both her hands, pulling her in. She bent towards him and he kissed her. He didn’t know he was going to do it until he did it, and the shock of it ran through his body like a plunge into the freezing lake. This wasn’t where he’d ever have chosen, out here on the open road with the two shining cities at his back. They had always both kept their secrets so close, so private they had smothered them, but he knew it was his last chance. Maybe his only chance. Sigrid leaned into it and at last, in the same moment, they pulled apart.

Fili said in a rush, “After this war has passed, go build Bard’s new town. When you’re the new Master of two Esgaroths and I am the crown prince, we’ll make an alliance stronger than its parts. I have to go back.”

“I know,” she said, smiling, and added, “We both have to go back.”

She squeezed his hands one last time and stepped away.

Kili had guessed what Fili was about to do and was running back up the path. He reached Fili in a rush and threw himself at him, pressing his face into the rough wool of Fili’s ill-fitting jumper. Fili wrapped him up in his arms and stood with him for a moment.

“I changed my mind,” Kili croaked. “I don’t want to go back to the East. I belong with you. I want to help you. We can face the king together.”

“Good. I will need you,” Fili tightened his grip and mumbled into Kili’s uncombed hair, “You’ll be safe on the lake. Come join me when you’re ready.” He let his brother go slowly.

He stepped away, gave them a last glance, and walked back up the road towards the mountain.

—

Kili found the house and shop empty. The ashes in the belly of the stove were cold. The pantry was bare except for a jar of dried rosemary, one of salt, and a handful of apples, one of them beginning to grow an ugly, brown rot on its skin. The beds were unmade as they’d been the morning they left three nights ago. Kibil’s books were still on the shelf, but his clothes and boots were gone. His uncle had also taken their stock of silver and copper from the workshop lockroom, anything of value that could be carried.

Kili spent several days helping with the bridge and trying to catch up with promised work around the town. In that time, the Laketown workers put together a temporary structure across the gap, with ramps down to planks over clusters of low-set, splayed piles. The temporary structure did not have the grandeur of the ancient, oak columns of the old bridge but was solid enough. It would take people and goods by foot, and maybe small carts and ponies. Probably not the weight of a dragon.

The work kept his hands busy, and his mind turning over. He ate with Bard and the family every night, but slept in the house alone. Sleep came easy after a day’s labour, but he didn’t feel like he woke up refreshed. The cold and damp was rising off the lake as the autumn grew colder and deeper. Everything smelled of mould.

In a few days, messengers from the Greenwood and Erebor-Over-Dale came over the new bridge on horses, which pleased everyone who had built it. Bard looked as grim as he ever was that night, but wouldn’t talk to Kili and Tilda about what the messengers had said. After he went home, Kili heard the faint voices of him and Sigrid through the wall.

That night, Kili went down to the shop and packed up his woodworking tools. Kibil had taken a lot of the best pieces, especially the light ones, but Kili had his own favourites. He wrapped everything in spare cloth and stacked it carefully in a padded bag that was comfortable to sling over his shoulder. He made a quick repair of one boot and folded his oilskin coat on top of the bag, as it smelled like rain in the air.

He looked for anything Fili might want. A couple of sentimental hair-clasps, a watercolour of their father, a little folding knife from Rhûn that Fili always forgot when they went out and then complained about leaving behind. It was so little he could fit it all in a small bag hung on his belt. Their whole lives to this point, tucked away in one little bag.

In the morning he said goodbye to Bard and the rest of the family, handing Bard the keys to the house.

“You can sell anything that’s left,” he said. “Give the money to the militia’s armoury fund.”

Only Tilda laughed. Kili gave her a particularly warm smile and turned to go.

“Be careful,” Bard said, as he went down the steps. “The road to Erebor may not be open long.”

As he crossed the bridge, Kili paused for a moment and looked back at the town on the lake. Smoke columns rose and sat in the air above it, blending into a haze that drifted away down the lake. The swallows were gone now, as were the swifts and the martins, off to some far-southern home where it was warmer and richer, some to Rhûn and some to the farther sea. He felt a few drops of rain, and unhitched the bag so he could put on his coat.

The toolbag was heavy as he tried to lift it back onto his shoulders. He thought, what am I doing? There’s no wood in Erebor.

He slid the bag off his shoulder, reached out his arm, and dropped it off the bridge into the lake. It gave a satisfying smack as it hit the surface and the water closed over it in a moment, the lake pulling it down to join all the other secrets. Kili walked on towards the distant mountain.

Notes:

Thanks for reading and just another reminder, if you want to read the next part of the story in a few days, please follow me or the series!

Series this work belongs to: