Chapter 1: From the Kitchen Gossip of the Shire
Chapter Text
Aside from eating, brewing beer, and smoking pipe-weed, hobbits were perhaps incredibly adept at spreading rumours and gossip. If so much as a single thing happened in the Shire, it seemed virtually everyone knew about it by the day’s end.
If someone was intending to marry, the villagers would usually guess as much when two hobbits suddenly and simultaneously vanished from sight.
In such cases, it was customary to return home already wed.
If a hobbit disappeared from the Shire for a long while, the neighbors assumed he had gone looking for a mate. Thus, the moment someone went missing for any significant stretch of time, any conversation over dinner, tea, or afternoon tea would invariably turn into a discussion of the runaway’s impending betrothal.
Therefore, when Mr. Baggins returned to Bag End after more than a year and proved that he was indeed the real, and most certainly living, Bilbo Baggins, the whole Shire began to whisper.
At first, everyone set about inquiring and twittering about some young hobbit-lass. However, this led nowhere.
Then, someone remembered that upon his return, they had looked over Mr. Baggins’s contract — complete with the signature of the very person to whom Bilbo had pledged his services to.
Thorin Oakenshield.
"My-my, Bilbo Baggins traveled with dwarves."
"Pass the buns, dear... oh, I heard he traveled with a dwarf-king."
"Oh, did he now? Mr. Baggins? With a king?"
Rumors had already been circulating about the returned hobbit’s family anyway. It was said, apparently, that one of Bilbo’s distant ancestors on his mother’s side — definitely someone from the Took clan — had been married to an elf.
Therefore, the notion that Mr. Baggins himself had preferred something rather more exotic to anyone from the Shire seemed perfectly logical.
Of course, it was a slightly confusing fact that "Thorin Oakenshield" did not sound like a female name at all, and moreover, Bilbo himself kept saying that he was his friend. 'He', not 'she'.
On the other hand, Bilbo Baggins had always been a bit... odd in the eyes of other hobbits. Must say queer. To be over fifty years old and not have so much as a couple of children and a wife... not even a mild dalliance! A confirmed bachelor with his own... well... peculiarities.
In short, even back when the traveling hobbit had only just returned to his emptied home, the rumors had already begun to circulate.
"Did they really only... travel?"
"Oh, come off it, Lobelia, what are you implying?"
"But haven't you thought that perhaps Bilbo and this king..."
..
"What?! No, a betrothal must be an exaggeration."
"Then what?"
"A very tragic romance?"
"Oh-h-h, my dear..."
Years later, of course, it ceased to cause any great stir. It simply remained an opinion with which, all in all, almost everyone in the Shire agreed. Instead of Bilbo-the-Confirmed-Bachelor-Baggins, the talkative hobbit-lads and hobbit-lasses over tea-time gatherings were more likely to drop words about Bilbo-the-Heartbroken-Widower-Baggins.
Also, as is usually the case with good gossip, over time it ceased to be a mere assumption.
It became a generally accepted opinion.
And after that — simply a fact.
At any rate, for the whole of the Shire.
Except for Bilbo Baggins himself. But, by universal consensus, Mr. Baggins was an interested party and was therefore considered a highly unreliable source.
"You know, Milo Burrows told me the other day that Bilbo Baggins was betrothed to a king! Can you imagine? Isn't that a bit grand for the likes of him, eh..."
"Quite right, Hugo, I can’t credit it. Not only did he grab himself such a large piece of land to own, but now it turns out he has dealings with the crown!"
"Don’t be like that, it's actually rather sad. He wasn't just betrothed to a king! They broke apart!"
"Oh, yes, I heard the king perished and Bilbo was left a widower!"
When Frodo was still a small lad, he didn't pay much attention to such things, and took little interest besides. To him, Thorin Oakenshield was a hero from his uncle's tales — a formidable king who fought Azog and fell in the Battle of the Five Armies.
Frodo loved to listen to adventures and dragons. Many children did. Often, Samwise Gamgee or young Meriadoc Brandybuck and Peregrin Took would join in to listen to these yarns. It was from the latter two that Frodo learned of the rumors.
"Did you never wonder why your old man didn't marry again?" Merry asked out of the blue one day.
Frodo frowned.
"Again?"
"Well, yes."
"What makes you think he was married the first time? He never seemed to..."
A silence fell over the table. The two young hobbits exchanged glances.
"He wasn't?"
"No."
"Not at all?"
"Well... not at all..?"
Pippin let out a sad, almost broken sigh.
"Poor old Bilbo."
Merry nodded.
"Still mourning..."
Then they bowed their heads in unison.
"So many years passed."
"True devotion."
"You don't see the like of it nowadays."
Frodo understood absolutely nothing: neither what they were talking about, nor why his friends spoke of it with such tragic pathos. Bilbo truly had never mentioned a marriage of his own.
When, on the evening of a same day, Frodo finally resolved to question his uncle directly, Mr. Baggins first choked on his tea, and then glared at his nephew over the rim of his cup, thoroughly rejecting any notion of his marriage.
"Uncle Bilbo, but really! All the hobbits of your age have long since had families. You say you weren't married, but... still, why did you never marry some nice hobbit-lass?" Frodo asked, tilting his head slightly.
"I have no need for it, my boy", the elder hobbit replied, lighting his pipe and rolling his eyes slightly. "My heart, it seems, belongs to books and adventures."
"To adventures?"
"Yes, yes, my dear. Perhaps it stayed behind in the mountains."
After that phrase, Frodo thought he understood everything.
The next day, while helping Sam prune the roses by the gates of Bag End, Frodo remained silent for a long time, watching his uncle blow smoke rings on the porch.
"Sam", Frodo called softly. "Merry and Pippin were saying yesterday... Well, about Uncle. About why he’s alone. They think that Master Thorin Oakenshield was... something more to him. That they were betrothed or some such thing."
Sam froze, gently holding a bud. He did not scoff, but only sighed softly.
"Oh, Mr. Frodo. Folks in the taverns will wag their tongues at anything, and the young masters have listened to too many tales. It's unlikely a dwarf-king was thinking of betrothals when he went to win back gold from a dragon."
"So, you think it’s all nonsense too?"
"I think, Mr. Frodo...", Sam raised his eyes to him, and for some reason, Frodo’s breath caught for a moment, "I think that one doesn't necessarily have to sign papers or wear rings to give one's heart to someone."
He sighed quietly, his cheeks looking a bit redder. "Mr. Bilbo often told the story to you and me, and... I think if a hobbit is ready to throw himself into deadly danger for someone's sake, that... well, it might mean something."
Frodo remained silent, feeling a lump rise in his throat. Sam went back to the roses.
One way or another, the Shire stuck to its own mind.
Old crones on their doorsteps sighed as they brewed chamomile tea; Lobelia Sackville-Baggins pinched her lips triumphantly whenever she passed Bag End; and young hobbit-lasses cited the story as an example and symbol of eternal, if terribly eccentric, fidelity.
They did not care for loose ends here. A hobbit’s life had to be understandable, orderly, and fit within the bounds of propriety.
And if, in order to justify the oddities of a respectable hobbit, he had to be christened "the inconsolable widower of the Dwarwen King" — well, the Shire did so with a light heart.
Chapter 2: From Songs and Conversations in the Corridors of Rivendell
Chapter Text
The first time this conversation took place in the north of Eregion was during the stay of Thorin Oakenshield’s company right there.
Rivendell was drowning in twilight and the scent of lilies.
"Tell me, Lindir, do you suppose they have explored each other's forms yet?" An elven guard elegantly arched an eyebrow, sipping his wine. "I mean... that striking contrast. The coarse, unhewn dwarven stature and that soft roundness of the halfling. It must be... most illuminating."
"I expect they are still at the stage of examining cultural barriers", Lindir replied, somewhat haughtily. "But judging by the sheer diligence with which the Son of Thráin bores his gaze into that hobbit, the barriers shall fall before the full moon."
They exchanged glances with barely perceptible smirks.
Later, the Lord of Rivendell himself raised the subject in a conversation with Gandalf.
"Mithrandir", Elrond began softly, "I heard some... whispers and can't fight my curiousity anymore. Do you think they, I mean, Thorin Oakenshield and Mr. Bilbo Baggins, have already... commenced a comparative analysis of their... differences? As a healer, I find myself exceedingly curious about this... ethnographic experiment."
Gandalf merely pulled his hat down a little lower.
"Elrond, I implore you, stay your healer’s zeal. The Heir of Durin thinks now only of reclaiming his throne, while my Burglar is entirely occupied with trying to survive the company of thirteen stubborn dwarves."
"And yet", the Lord of Imladris smiled gently, his eyes following the small figure of the hobbit, shadowed closely by a sullen dwarf, "a bond is already being forged between them that will outlast this quest. Whatever its nature may be."
Gandalf shifted his gaze to the same spot; a faint spark of mischief appeared in his eyes, and his lips twitched into a smile.
"There is something to that..."
Back then, in the year of the Quest, the elves of Imladris merely jested with courtly wit. To the immortal folk, this strange alliance seemed nothing more than a vivid theatrical performance, a passing seasonal amusement.
Decades, however, rolled by. Spring yielded to autumn, and Rivendell still drowned in the scents of elegant blossoms and a twilight that remembered every step of the vanished heroes. Time, so merciless to mortals, had scarcely touched the Last Homely House, but the whispers had altered their tone.
In the corridors of the palace, they no longer joked about "anatomical contrasts." Now, long after Thorin Oakenshield had come to rest beneath the stone vaults of the Mountain, elven maidens and loremasters whispered of something else entirely.
"They say the King Under the Mountain gifted him a ringmail of pure mithril before he died, binding their souls forevermore", a young elf-maid would sigh. "And the halfling bore it away to his distant land, to mourn him until the end of his days."
"The hobbit treasured his dying breath", a guard would echo, his gaze fixed on the misty distance. "And to this day, in his faraway country, he withers from longing for the King entombed in stone. It was a union as impossible as it was beautiful."
To Arwen, daughter of Elrond, these conversations were more than just an ancient song. In those days when the young Ranger of the North — Aragorn, son of Arathorn — sought hospitality in Rivendell, the Undómiel often frequented her father’s archives. She searched the records for hidden meanings, striving to comprehend the nature of feelings that bind those destined for different spans of time upon this earth. To the immortal elves, a human life — much like a dwarven or a hobbit one — was but a brief flash, yet stories of what could ignite between different kindreds were deemed worth their weight in gold.
"Adár", she asked one day, as she and Elrond went through old scrolls in the library. "Is it true, what the minstrels sing of the King Under the Mountain and the Halfling who helped reclaim it? They say their souls were bound by ancient magic, an irresistible gravity that washes away the differences of the flesh."
Elrond laughed softly, shaking his head.
"Oh, Arwen. Minstrels love to lay the colours on thickly. If only you had seen them then... But, well..." the Lord of Rivendell grew grave, and the wisdom of ages reflected in his eyes. "Perhaps the songs do not lie in one regard. It was a union of opposites."
Elrond fell silent for a time, watching the dying embers in the hearth.
"On that journey, there was no time to speak of feelings, Arwen", the Lord of Rivendell replied gently. "Dwarves are a secretive folk, and hobbits... simple though they may be...", he coughed, "well, is that truly the point? Mortals love desperately, because their hour is short. Out of their attachment, they fashioned a legend that will outlive their flesh."
Arwen lowered her head, a quiet, bitter resolve taking root in her heart.
One way or another, Rivendell stuck to its own mind.
They did not care for earthly mundanity here. Every tale, in passing through elven halls, had to be transformed into a high, poetic ballad of fatal doom, noble spirit, and eternal parting.
To the elves, the story of Thorin II Oakenshield and Bilbo Baggins became a beautiful, sorrowful parable of how two entirely different natures — coarse stone and soft earth — could meld into a singular harmony, if only for a brief, tragic moment.
The minstrels continued to pluck the strings of their harps, singing of the "high, platonic grief of the King Under the Mountain and his Burglar."
And if, in order to praise the devotion of a little hobbit, he had to be made the hero of an ancient tragedy — well, Imladris did so with an elegant reverence.
Chapter 3: From Dispatches and Court Whispers of the Woodland Realm
Chapter Text
In the palace of Thranduil, rumors were treated much like a fine wine: they were allowed to age, enhanced with spices, and served to the table with an elegant, slightly venomous chuckle.
The Woodland Kingdom knew no peace, and if the elves of Rivendell sought a high, platonic poetry in all things, those here sought intrigue, power, and, preferably, a touch of vice.
That the King Under the Mountain had fallen into an absolute mental and — let us not mince words — carnal, fleshy dependency upon his "invisible" companion was something scarcely anyone at court doubted.
It had all begun back when the thirteen dwarves were still sitting in the dungeons, and an invisible spy draft-wheeled through the corridors of the palace. The Silvan elves, possessing flawless hearing, continually noticed peculiar occurrences.
"Think on it", whispered one of the court elves, lazily picking at a cluster of grapes. "First, this halfling roamed our corridors undetected, stealing food from the tables and keys from the guards. And then? Locked himself away in Erebor with a mad Thorin. A dwarf obsessed with gold, who would not allow even his own nephews near him, yet kept this creature by his side without a murmur. A vicious, frightening dependency. A true hostage syndrome, where they continually swapped roles."
"Oh, indeed", chimed in a guardsman who had once watched over the dwarven cells. "I remember how Oakenshield paced his cage. He was possessed even then."
"They say that in Erebor, the King locked the hobbit in the royal chambers out of sheer jealousy."
"Imagine that!.. Though, I am certain the halfling pulled the strings in return, twisting the monarch’s will exactly as he pleased!"
Later, on a quiet evening, Thranduil sat in his chambers. A chalice of carved crystal rested upon his knees, and his slender fingers lazily idled through clusters of white grapes. Legolas stood by the window, peering morosely into the darkening forest.
"That halfling…" Thranduil murmured, a faint, barely perceptible smile playing upon his lips. "I must confess, he admires me. What striking, calculated cunning! To feign the guise of an innocent, domestic creature, win the trust of a mad dwarf, become his intimate caprice, and then steal the greatest treasure of his dynasty right from under the dragon’s nose, only to appear before me to dictate terms to two armies!"
"But Adá", Legolas countered softly, turning around. "Was that not an act of despair? The hobbit wished to save Thorin from his own madness. He surrendered the Arkenstone to stay the war."
Thranduil laughed softly, haughtily, and the sound recalled the rustling of dry leaves.
"Oh, my naive boy. One does not preclude the other. Oakenshield was ready to hurl him from the ramparts; he howled with rage. Yet in the end, the hobbit is perfectly intact. Do you know why? Because that little "burglar" broke into more than just the doors of Erebor. He mastered the will of the King Under the Mountain. Dwarves are slaves to their passions. Once they find their "gem" — be it a stone from the deeps or a halfling in a waistcoat — they lose all reason."
Thranduil paused for a moment, examining his wine against the light, his slender brows drawing together at the bridge of his nose. The irony in his voice gave way to something heavier.
"But in one thing you are correct. To steal and bring the Arkenstone hither is calculation. But to step out unarmed before a deranged dwarf, knowing he could easily kill you... to do so solely to restore his wits... that requires a folly of an entirely different sort." Thranduil fell silent for a brief spell. In his eyes, usually as cold as the ice of the Misty Mountains, there flickered something akin to an old sorrow, buried beneath the centuries. "Perhaps the very folly that mortals so recklessly call love. Perhaps so it is. Love... though that does not make it any less ghastly and destructive. Look at what it has reduced them to: one rots in a stone tomb, while the other is doomed to hide in his hole until the end of his days, nursing his ghosts."
Decades passed. The Shadow of Sauron grew thick, and Mirkwood withered, but the tale of the King and the Burglar became encrusted with new, even more scandalous details. Tauriel, who had tasted the bitterness of loss after the death of the younger dwarven prince, viewed this legend through the prism of her own shattered soul.
"You all search for intrigue where there was only a blind, boundary-breaking fate", she said quietly, meeting Legolas on secret paths near the borders. "I was upon Ravenhill myself. Would a calculating favorite weep so bitterly? When Oakenshield fell, that hobbit shrieked as though his very soul were being torn from him alive. And he refused his share of the gold, taking only a pittance. If this was a game of power, why did he leave as a pauper?"
"My father deemed it, to some degree, a union built upon co-dependency", the prince said in a low voice, turning to Tauriel. "Yet even he admits it was a force that rewrote history. A spoiled hobbit from a respectable family and a proud sovereign who had lost his own Kingdom... Of all the follies of this age, their bond is — perhaps — the most elegant."
The Elvenking, meanwhile, continued to tilt his head indulgently, trying on a crown of autumn leaves before the mirror.
"Mortals seek drama so desperately", he uttered softly, addressing his own reflection rather than the counselor standing nearby. "The hobbit proved to be the only rational being in that entire company of unwashed dwarves. He possessed manners, intellect, and... a loyalty rare for their short span. Well.. Perhaps it truly might have been deeper than calculation. An exhausting and possessive love, but true nonetheless."
Thranduil turned his gaze from the mirror, and his countenance resumed its customary, impenetrable mask of arrogance. He cast a glance at a wax-sealed letter resting upon his carved desk — yet another missive from the rebuilt Dale.
The Elvenking intercepted the letter with his long, slender fingers.
"I recall that in the tent before the Mountain, the Bowman also doubted the halfling's guile... with him, perhaps, we shall discuss this over the next bottle of Dorwinion. Under its influence, dwarven eccentricities are listened to far more indulgently... And Bard always possessed a strikingly sober view on the madness of the Mountain Kingdom. In the next address, hint to him that he should hasten his visit. Before the elven gossips thoroughly transform our respectable burglar into a formidable master of others' minds..."
He turned to his counselor, his light silk robes billowing about him.
"But the court need not know of this. Let them think it was a sophisticated conspiracy. They will sleep the sounder for it, and it is useful for the border guard to believe that halflings are a covert threat."
One way or another, Mirkwood stuck to its own mind.
They did not care for naive faith in pure intentions and fairy tales for fools here. Chamberlains, spies, and guardsmen at feasts continued to pass along jests from mouth to mouth about how the Burglar ruled the King, while court ladies discussed with a slight thrill "the most dangerous royal paramour of the Third Age."
And if, in order to explain how a fragile, tiny creature could master the will of the formidable lord of the mountain and help halt a war, he had to be fashioned into a calculating, dangerous intriguer and a devilishly attractive favorite — well, the Woodland Kingdom did so with a dark, exquisite relish.
Chapter 4: From Tavern Tales of Lake-town
Chapter Text
Bard the Bowman had first encountered this company on the river, and, to tell the truth, they had seemed to him then like nothing more than a bunch of mad vagabonds. Bard had his own worries: he loved his late wife, loved his children to distraction, fretted over the future of Esgaroth, and was simply trying to help those in dire straits. This, of course, was exactly what had led him into difficulties — for he had resolved to carry these smugglers into the town, not yet knowing who they truly were.
An unbearable burden already weighed upon his shoulders: feeding three children, keeping out of the sight of the Master and his lackeys, and somehow surviving in a town rotting alive in the midst of freezing water. He had only agreed to smuggle these bearded madmen out of thought for hard coin for his family. Therefore, the internal relations of the dwarven company held little interest for him.
Not until the day Thorin Oakenshield declared himself King Under the Mountain before the cheering crowd in the square of Esgaroth.
Back then, the old Master of Lake-town had been salivating with greed, the people were shouting with delight, and Bard stood on the platform, feeling everything inside him tighten with a foul premonition. Gold, a curse, a dragon...
The dwarf seemed to him a madman who would lead the town to its death. Bard tried to appeal to the reason of the crowd, but no one would listen.
And it was precisely at that moment that the halfling raised his hand.
Small, disheveled, terribly weary of adventures. He stood firm, in the hearing of all, and vouched for Thorin. There was no profit or fanaticism in his voice. There was a pure readiness, frightening in its devotion, to share any fate — even if that fate led into the jaws of a monster.
It was then that Bard first thought that between them lay a gentleman's agreement, bound by something far sturdier than gold. A deep, unspoken respect between two men ready to die for one another.
Not the co-dependency the haughty elves later fancied gossiping about, but that profound, absolute devotion born only in filth, cold, and shared misfortune...
Yet it did not seem important to fan that spark of thought any further. And why should he? Who needed to know what this halfling was to the heir to the throne — servant, favorite, captive, or comrade — when, because of their stubbornness, the dragon was about to wake and Lake-town would be reduced to ash?
Years passed. Lake-town, once burned by Smaug, was rebuilt anew, and beside it rose majestic Dale from the ruins. Bard became a king, but he did not alter his habits — he remained a simple, honest man.
In the taverns of Esgaroth, which still smelled of tar, cheap ale, and dried fish, entirely different rumors now drifted through the air. Beer-stained wooden tables shook from the blows of fists when half-tipsy carpenters, fishermen, and boatmen began to argue about the old days.
"I'm telling you", a sodden cooper bellowed in a tavern one evening, wiping froth from his mustache. "That hobbit, Baggins, he actually saved Thorin! A true sworn brother. How is it with dwarves, eh? If a dwarf trusts you with his back, you're closer to him than a brother. Mind you, I didn't see anything myself, but I heard that against Azog they stood together, shoulder to shoulder!"
"I heard that they might not have fought just the two of them, but when the King fell, the hobbit was the first to scramble to him, and the King died in his arms!"
"Died in his arms, you say?" smirked an old fisherman sitting in the corner. "I've heard tell of weightier matters than that. Our King, Bard, used to tell how that lad came to him and the elf in their tent in the dead of night. Shaking all over he was, and in his hands — a diamond the size of a fist, the Arkenstone! The hobbit gave it to Bard to stay the war, to keep Thorin from his own folly. Put his own neck on the line, you see? Risked his head for the dwarf. That, brothers, isn't just sworn brotherhood. That’s a friendship sturdier than any marriage. A harsh, manly loyalty."
"And I heard", a maidservant chimed in, setting down fresh mugs with a clatter, "that after the death of the mountain king, that undersized poor soul starved himself entirely, grew thin as a rake, and refused to touch the gold. There’s human honesty for you... or rather, hobbit honesty!"
Bard the Bowman, having dropped into the tavern after a heavy day at council, sat at a distant table in the shadows. He slowly sipped his ale and listened wearily to the local revelers, merely shaking his head in silence. Really, what earthly difference did it make what exactly they had been to each other?
But at home, by the hearth, these conversations caught up with him again.
One evening in his chambers, Bain, now a strapping young warrior, was polishing his father’s sword, while Tilda and Sigrid sorted through the old archives of Dale.
"Father", Sigrid called softly, without looking up from the papers. "I read just now... from the old records... here in the trade ledgers of Erebor... The hobbit Bilbo Baggins refused his fourteenth share of the treasure. In Dale they still wag their tongues, saying the King Under the Mountain cursed him before he died for the betrayal with the Arkenstone, and so the hobbit fled with nothing. But in the taverns down by the river, the old folk sing that they were sworn blood brothers, and Bilbo simply could not bring himself to touch gold on which his friend's body had grown cold."
Bard shifted his gaze to the fire. He had seen the hobbit after the Battle of the Five Armies. Little Baggins had been sitting on the rocks, arms wrapped around his knees, looking as though his entire world had crumbled away.
"Folks in the taverns always look for either filth or fairy tales, daughter", Bard said in a low voice. "Dwarves are a proud people; they seldom admit mistakes. But Thorin, I believe, admitted his."
"So, they were good friends after all?" Tilda asked, resting her cheek on her hand.
"More than friends", Bain said with a shrug of his shoulder. "A true brotherhood of arms. A manly loyalty to one's word. The sort of thing they sing of in ballads."
Bard merely gave his son a sad, understanding smile. Bain was a soldier, the heir to the throne, and saw the world through the prism of honor and weapons. But the Bowman himself, having known both great love and the bitterness of loss in his life, saw something else in this tale.
"One does not have to be brothers-in-arms or warriors of the same shield to lay down one's life for another", he uttered quietly. "In our parts, among men, we call it by a simpler name. A great, rare respect between two souls. They found in one another what both had lacked: Thorin found the peace and home he had been stripped of, and Bilbo found a courage he never knew he possessed. A pity only that they realized it too late."
The children raised their eyes to him.
Bard fell silent, returning to his own thoughts.
One way or another, Esgaroth stuck to its own mind.
Here, on the shores of the Long Lake, they did not care for pompous metaphors and high-flown speeches. Harbor porters, sailors, and merchants at feasts continued to dispute over a tankard of ale. Some argued with a smirk that "the dwarf had simply taken a fancy to a pretty halfling and kept him close," while others, beating their chests with their fists, bellowed ballads of "great martial brotherhood and unbreakable manly friendship."
And if, in order to honor the memory of the fallen king and his little companion, they had to be made the very paradigm of age-old male brotherhood and steadfast respect — well, Lake-town did so with a sincere, half-drunken reverence.
Chapter 5: From the Chronicles and Records of Erebor
Chapter Text
Ori felt his right eye begin to twitch. Upon his desk in the chamber of chronicles in Erebor, stacks of parchment rose in mountains, and for the third time that day, the ink was drying up in his inkwell.
The new King Under the Mountain, Dáin Ironfoot, had made himself perfectly clear: the chronicle of the Quest and the reclaiming of Erebor must be completed, bound into a single volume, and consigned to the archives. Erebor, rising from the ashes, required a grand history. Thorin Oakenshield had restored the dwarves' home; he had become a legend, and his deeds were to shine through the ages like a faceted diamond. The late King Under the Mountain was to appear within it as a monumental figure, cleansed of the blight of the dragon-sickness — a symbol of dwarven fortitude. He was, after all, a figure of great consequence.
Ori set to work in earnest. First and foremost, he resolved to draw upon his own notes from the journey. Secondly, he decided that for historical accuracy and depth, it was well worth interviewing every surviving member of the company.
Regarding the battles, everyone spoke in the same manner: axes swung, orcs perished.
Regarding the dragon, with one voice: the scales were thick, the fire was hot.
Regarding politics — with the invariable grumbling and expression of mild disgust whenever elves were mentioned.
Yet the moment Ori commenced his questioning regarding the relationship between their late king and the hired Burglar, the flawless facade of the chronicle cracked, and absolute, unmanageable chaos ensued.
And it was not as though the witnesses were lying. On the contrary — every single one was ready to swear by Mahal’s beard that he spoke the plain truth, and sincerely believed in his own version.
It seemed that each of them had witnessed an entirely different story.
Bofur was the first to be cornered. He gave the chronicler a conspiratorial wink, sitting right on the edge of the archival table and swinging his legs.
"Oh, come off it, Ori, what is there to puzzle over? The sparks were flying back in the Shire! Surely you remember how Thorin looked at him when the lad fainted dead away at the mention of the dragon! You’re about to say "as if at a sack of flour," right? Well, I tell you — it was the real thing! Our King snorted grandly then, but I noticed how he spent the rest of the evening studying the little fellow. For his whole life, he’d contemplated nothing but grim dwarven visages or insolent elven faces, and then — this clean, soft, domestic creature! Our Thorin fell in love like a faintling right there by the hearth, even if he did pout the whole way. In fact, I reckon that’s why he was pouting... And Bilbo too. Good heavens, he spent half the journey fretting that Thorin couldn’t abide him. I remember him wanting to slip away one night because of it... you know, but he didn’t! Now, mind you, Bilbo never told me anything of that sort about their dealings, but... I think it’s plain as day to anyone that there was a romance. A passionate one at that. I don't know the particulars, but I'm a hundred percent certain!"
Ori recalled the cramped corridors of Bag End and tentatively scratched behind his ear with his quill. Dori, who had slipped into the archive with a tray of chamomile tea (because "the boy works far too hard in these damp halls"), merely snorted in indignation at Bofur’s words.
"Take your nonsense to the tavern, Bofur. What do you mean, "fell in love in the Shire"? Thorin despised him for half the journey."
"Despised him? Whatever are you talking about?!"
Dori sighed.
"Very well, then. Despised is too strong a word. But he was clearly wary of him! At first, there was a rather obvious friction between them, you see..? But after the Misty Mountains… Oh-h-h."
"So you agree there was a romance? Well, there you–"
"No, no! Infatuation. They were both head over heels in love. They were so deeply smitten they didn't even notice it themselves, the fools. They didn't understand how it happened. They simply ran out of time to understand..! Wandering in circles around each other like two rams before a bridge. Do you see? Not a romance or some affair. I think there were only feelings–"
Ori sighed, having no desire to listen to these lengthy disputes, and went to Dwalin, hoping for his bluntness and brevity. The old warrior remained silent for a long time, and then grunted, turning his gaze away.
"Don't talk rot, lad. There’s no call to smear sentimentality across the chronicles. It was a pure political alliance and a special... a very special respect from a leader toward a loyal soldier. In Rivendell, as I recall, Thorin never took his eyes off him. Or do you think they were billing and cooing?" Dwalin took a deep breath and lowered his eyes. In truth, conversations about Thorin still weighed heavily upon him. They had been closest friends since their youth, and Dwalin had always been unreservedly loyal. Though now he looked as if he were clearly holding something back, not telling about everything he knew about it. "It was a martial attachment, nothing more. Thorin understood: this hobbit, with all his craftiness, was our personal trump card. Thorin kept him close because... well... he respected him, of course." The captain of the guard took a deep breath and shook his head, finishing abstractedly, "Everything else is just old wives' tales."
Ori sighed, remembering that even in his own records from those days, certain matters looked far more... ambiguous. And Ori knew he was not the only one. Many had been whispering...
Most of all, the memory of Thorin’s nephews haunted him. Fíli and Kíli — ever laughing, young, full of life, princes who now slept in the tombs beside their uncle. During their lives, they never missed a single chance to snicker at their uncle. To the very end, until that cursed Battle, they would exchange glances with such meaningful smirks that Ori still felt awkward at the thought.
Even back then, at one of the camps on the way to the Misty Mountains, the princes whispered loudly behind the company's backs.
"Ten coins says they’ve already thoroughly explored every single inch of each other", Kíli whispered, stifling a laugh, nudging his brother’s ribs with his elbow and glancing at Thorin.
"Don't talk nonsense", Fíli snorted, though he could not tear his eyes away and could scarcely contain his smile. "Our uncle is too stubborn. They certainly haven’t "explored" anything just yet. That one hug and.. maybe solemn handshakes with a tragic look is the most they've managed."
At later camps, one had only to ask the princes anything regarding Bilbo and Thorin, and they would break into uncontrollable laughter.
"Beorn’s house…" Kíli would begin.
"Don't start!" Fíli would cut him off, choking with laughter.
"I didn't say anything!"
"Which is exactly why you shouldn't start; I remember well enough myself who was coming out of whose room."
"But wha-a-at happened in Beo-o-orn’s hou-u-use..."
Ori closed his eyes tight, his hands trembling slightly at the thought of the princes. They had been... so very young, and...
Ori rubbed his temples. The entries were not coming together.
Balin, sitting in a deep armchair by the hearth, smoked his pipe for a long time, watching Ori furiously scratch his pen against the parchment. The old dwarf’s face was covered in a network of deep wrinkles, and a quiet, wise sorrow lingered in his eyes. He smiled an understanding smile.
"Everyone tries to drape intrigue where there was tragedy, Ori", Balin uttered softly, releasing a perfect ring of smoke. "They were both terribly lonely. One had lost his home, his kingdom, and his entire youth in a foreign land, dragging behind him the weight of exile and the responsibility for our whole people. The other — had never left his quiet shire, lived in plenty, yet surely also pined in his lonely Bag End for something more. Always waiting for something grander than that provincial life. They found in each other a reflection of that emptiness. The drawing together was slow, painful. You know yourself, Thorin was used to having less, and evidently deemed himself simply unworthy of many things. And Bilbo.. he was.."
Ori, biting his lip, carefully wrote upon the parchment: "Deep mutual respect between two lonely souls prevailed between His Majesty and Mr. Baggins."
Balin looked at the entry, smiled a bitter and understanding smile, and shook his head with a kind of wise pity.
"If it makes it easier for you... Still, yes, that is indeed better for official chronicles, lad..."
Ori sighed, realizing that what was "better" for the chronicles did not mean it was easier for himself. The records were catastrophically lacking in mundanity, but the moment Ori attempted to find it among the rest of the company, he became thoroughly convinced: in their own minds, absolutely everyone had matched the king and the burglar together. And, what was most astonishing, the entire company regarded it with a strange, almost familial warmth.
Glóin, whose devotion to his wife and son was a watchword among the company, confidently declared that Thorin had simply... courted him according to all the rules of the Mountain. He assured Ori that Thorin behaved like a typical dwarf who had resolved to establish a family. Bombur, sighing amiably over his kettle, agreed with Glóin’s notions, remarking that they resembled an old married couple who bickered over trifles but breathed in unison. Nori, usually cynical and secretive, said with a chuckle, "Respect, of course, respect".... "Our grim leader" dared not even squeak after the Misty Mountains if the hobbit shook his head in disapproval. Óin, though he had not quite caught the question, nodded knowingly, speaking of how strong their bond and friendship had been, while Bifur, gesticulating fiercely, hotly argued something in a tongue known only to him.
Yet the chief stumbling block, against which any attempt to reduce the chronicle to "mere respect" shattered, was the mithril.
Of this, even those dwarves in Erebor who had not partaken in the Quest, but had come later from the Iron Hills, whispered. To this day, it was discussed in the forges; it was argued over in the barracks.
The most precious mail shirt in the world.
Good heavens, it was worth more than the whole of that notorious Shire with all its hills and holes!
The entire Mountain had seen and remembered: Thorin Oakenshield was swiftly losing his wits. He pined over the gold, sinking into a frightening, dark paranoia. In those black days, he suspected his own blood — Fíli and Kíli — of treachery and conspiracy; he mistrusted Dwalin; he shut himself away from the entire world behind a hastily erected wall, declaring that not a single living soul would receive a single coin from Erebor. He was prepared to unleash war upon the whole world rather than surrender a scrap of his wealth.
And against the background of this madness, this suffocating greed — he gives a halfling the mithril.
Dwarves were a people for whom gold and precious gems were sacred. And this gift spoke louder than any ballads. For any dwarf, from a young miner to a venerable master, this gesture was more binding than any vows, marriage scrolls, or sacred alliances.
At a moment when Thorin trusted no one, Bilbo remained the only one whose worth in the King's eyes outweighed everything else.
Ori gripped his fingers until they ached, staring at the parchment. How was he to fit this piercing, dazzling truth into the dry lines of a report?
In the end, Dáin Ironfoot himself took an interest in the chronicler’s drafts.
The new King Under the Mountain sat in an office cluttered with maps and reports. He took Ori’s tangled notes, skimmed his eyes over the testimonies of the company, and... suddenly let out a quiet, short chuckle into his thick beard. In his eyes, usually stern, there flashed a spark of understanding and some bitter, light humor.
"Oh, Ori, lad..." Dáin shook his head, setting the parchment aside. "I knew my cousin Thorin my whole life. Proud, stubborn, fierce... For him to stoop to romantic sighs? Ludicrous."
Dáin rose, clasping his hands behind his back, and looked out the window at Dale rising from the ruins. He shook his head, yet he smiled warmly.
"Ah, Thorin, Thorin..." Dáin uttered softly, tossing his head, and in his eyes, usually stern, there flickered a shadow of mischief and sad irony. "To hoard the promised gold, declare war on men and elves, fall out with his kin... and give the mithril to a halfling. Truly, a madman of the Durin's line."
The irony vanished from his voice, giving way to heavy statecraft.
"But Erebor needs walls and axes now, Ori. The people need a legend of a grand, infallible Thorin Oakenshield, who cleansed himself of the taint and fell for his home."
Dáin turned and tapped a heavy signet ring against the desk.
"Strike out all the conjectures of the company. 'The Burglar Bilbo Baggins was a trusted confidant of the King, whose exceptional loyalty to the common cause earned the high respect of the court. In token of monarchical gratitude for invaluable service, His Majesty personally gifted Mr. Baggins an ancient mithril mail shirt, thereby sealing the eternal gratitude of the Mountain Kingdom.' And as for the rest... let them babble at the campfires."
"But Your Majesty..." Ori piped softly. "What of... the truth?"
Dáin smiled a somewhat sad smile.
"The truth... And do we even know it, the truth?" They both pinched their lips. "Even among the company, opinions differ, Ori. The truth was known to only two people, and one of them is now dead, while the other is far away in the Shire. Neither of them has any need for official chronicles now. But Erebor has need of them."
One way or another, Erebor stuck to its own mind.
Here, there were no light-minded elven ballads or pompous human tales. In the Mountain Kingdom, everything was measured by the weight of loyalty, the price of metal, and the depth of devotion. But in the chronicles of the Mountain Kingdom, everything had to serve the grandeur of Durin's line.
And if, in order to conceal the private, deeply buried motives of the fallen monarch, his relationship with the halfling had to be christened "the highest royal favor and reward for unprecedented service" — well, Erebor... was ready to do so with a heavy, proud, and silent reverence...
Ori looked at the chronicle for a long time.
Then the scholar sighed, looking at the blank page of the chronicle where the final verdict for history was to be written. The dwarves needed pride in their late king.
He dipped his pen into the ink and with a steady hand wrote upon the parchment:
"...And thus was sealed the sworn brotherhood of the Mountain King and the Burglar of the Shire. Their alliance was as sturdier than mithril, and as deep as the roots of the Mountain. And though fate parted them upon Ravenhill, the memory of the great respect that bound such different peoples shall forever remain in the stones of Erebor."
Ori carefully dusted the parchment with sand, drying the ink, and closed the heavy leather cover. Well, he had done it with a heavy heart and the clear conscience of a chronicler.
Chapter 6: From the Roadside Talk of the Fellowship of the Ring
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
The midday halts in the desolate lands of Eregion felt endless. The Fellowship had waited out the dawn and was now sheltering in the deep shadows beneath overhanging crags and the intertwined crowns of holly trees, escaping Saruman’s spies.
Having kindled a tiny, barely smoldering fire in a deep cleft where the smoke dispersed among the foliage, they passed the long, sultry hours. The silence of the remote noon was broken only by lazy, quiet whispers.
Settled on a fallen log in the thickest shade, Boromir was lazily whetting a dagger. He watched the small hobbits with slightly narrowed eyes. In Gondor, they seldom sang songs of halflings, but the stern commander knew how to note details.
"Tell me, Gandalf", Boromir said softly, without pausing his task. "I look at this lad, Frodo, and at his mail shirt. So tiny… I kept thinking, if an orc were to thrust a spear at him, would that be the end? But look... That is mithril, is it not? For a single item like that, one could purchase three provinces together with their garrisons. Whence did a small lad come by a treasure worthy of emperors? Are all these rumors about the hobbit and the dwa-"
Gandalf half-closed his eyes, tilting his face into the faint breeze.
"Oh, Boromir. It is a gift of age-old generosity... or madness. Depending on whom you ask."
"Huh."
At that moment, Gimli, who sat a little further ahead beside Legolas under the spreading shade of an old oak, took an interest in this turn of the conversation. Mithril... He turned and cast a glance at the nodding Frodo, and then measured the elven prince with a heavy, suspicious gaze.
"You know, pointy-ears..." Gimli grunted quietly, adjusting his heavy axe and, as if by chance, pointing the haft toward the elf. "My father still disputes what truly lay between Thorin Oakenshield and old Master Bilbo. In Erebor, they still whisper of it at feasts, the moment the ale fogs their wits. My old man swears it was an official dwarven courting... and Balin, before he departed for Moria, seemed to mention something of them too."
Legolas barely perceptibly lifted a corner of his lips and an eyebrow, not even deigning to grant the dwarf a direct look, but merely following with a lazy eye a solitary hawk circling high in the blinding sky above the treetops.
"My father used to say it was the true madness of the Third Age", the elven prince replied quietly.
"Aye... There, perhaps, our kins would agree", Gimli snorted, putting away his rag and shifting his heavy weapon.
"At the court in Mirkwood, Bilbo Baggins is still deemed a most skillful and exceedingly dangerous intriguer, who managed to master the will of the Mountain King."
Gimli snorted.
"With us, every dwarf who was on that quest could call him almost a member of the family. Whereas your woodland tales are worth no more than dry leaves.
They fell silent for a short spell, turning their faces to the hot afternoon air. Legolas lowered an appraising look onto Gimli’s broad shoulders. The dwarf merely scowled stubbornly in return, mimicking the appraising gaze. The barriers between their peoples still stood like an immovable wall, yet through that wall, mutual curiosity broke for the first time.
"Well, my father appreciates a good drama, Gimli", the elf replied softly, finally lowering his gaze. "But even he admitted that their bond was... powerful."
A little way off, leaning his back against a moss-grown boulder, sat Aragorn. He was smoking his pipe, watching the smoldering embers shielded from the sun by his palm, and listening to them with half an ear. Seeing how Gimli and Legolas — who but recently had been ready to fly at each other's throats — now silently shared the same patch of shade, the Ranger involuntarily snorted and smiled into his mustache.
He remembered the old scrolls of Imladris and the ballads Arwen used to listen to in her father’s archives. The minstrels sang of high, platonic grief and a union of opposites. The Dúnadan cared little about how and what exactly had transpired between the dwarf and the hobbit, but... if a proud dwarven king could melt his stony heart for a fragile halfling, then he, a mortal man, surely stood a chance of holding the love of an immortal elven maid. Aragorn chuckled.
Gimli, however, resolved to satisfy a long-standing curiosity, crawling noiselessly closer to the half-slumbering hobbits, careful not to expose himself to the sun-drenched glade.
"Listen, lad", the dwarf asked in a low voice, leaning toward Frodo. "Did your uncle ever tell you of Thorin Oakenshield?"
Frodo opened one eye and looked at him with slight surprise.
"Oh, rather. Constantly. I practically grew up on those stories."
"Hmh", Gimli stroked his beard meaningfully. "And what exactly did he say?"
"Well... About the dragon, about the mountain, about how Thorin Oakenshield was a very important and grand person. Why do you ask?"
Gimli grunted, exchanging a glance with Legolas, who had drawn closer.
"No reason...Well! You know, half of Erebor considers them the greatest love story of the age."
Frodo raised himself slightly on his elbows from his reclining position and blinked foolishly, squinting against a ray of sun piercing through the branches.
"And in Mirkwood, your uncle is deemed nothing less than a dangerous and alluring favorite of the King Under the Mountain, who twisted the monarch's will at his pleasure", Legolas added with an utterly composed countenance. A lively, almost mischievous spark glinted in his eyes.
"What. Bilbo?" Frodo sat up abruptly, shifting a bewildered gaze from the dwarf to the elf. "But he... they..."
At this loud whisper, Pippin and Merry, lying nearby on their bedrolls, immediately pricked up their ears. They exchanged the most knowing of looks and at once nodded in tragic agreement, completely in unison.
"We told you so, Frodo!" Merry remarked sententiously. "Poor old Bilbo. So many years have passed, and he is still mourning. True fidelity."
"In the Shire, every cow knows about it", Pippin sighed, sniffing. "Your uncle is just being modest. It’s common knowledge — the widower of the mountain sovereign."
"Right, right, Pip. So many years passed, and they’re all still talking about it."
"The whole world knows of their betrothal. Even the elves", Pippin uttered with a touch of awe.
Legolas let out a quiet, musical laugh, covering his mouth with his palm.
"A widower? Betrothed?" the dwarf repeated, staring at the hobbits. "Well, the Shire, it seems, has succeeded in developing this relationship far better than we have..."
Gimli shook his head, a semblance of a smirk appearing on his face. He shifted his gaze back to the elven prince. Between dwarf and elf, for a fleeting instant, passed that same remarkable, ironic understanding.
"You speak of them as though it were some courtly fairy tale", Boromir spoke up again, and into his tone crept the stern, earthly pragmatism of a warrior of Gondor. "In Minas Tirith, little is known of this whole matter, but my father heard from merchants that it was a grand brotherhood of arms. A manly loyalty to one's word, born in filth and cold. The hobbit went against a dragon for the sake of his leader, and the King gave his life defending his land. A steadfast, manly friendship. Why look for intrigue or finery where men... that is, creatures, simply stood shoulder to shoulder against a common death?"
"A steadfast friendship, you say?" a deep, ironic voice arose.
Gandalf drew on his pipe and then released a beautiful, perfect ring of smoke, which drifted slowly beneath the leafy canopy above the heads of the Fellowship. "Ah, Boromir, son of Denethor... You Men ever strive to fit another's soul into the margins of a military regulation. And you Dwarves, you Elves", the wizard swept his gaze over Gimli and Legolas, "search either for a price in jewels, or for intrigue and the high poetry of fate."
"What were they then, Gandalf?" Sam asked softly from his place, unable to contain himself any longer. He sat with his arms wrapped around his knees, catching every word. "You were there, after all. You saw it all."
Frodo looked at Sam for a long while, and then turned his gaze to the wizard.
"Quite right, Gandalf! We ought to have asked you straight away."
"They were..." The wizard lifted his brows slightly, and then said very simply and indulgently. "Bilbo Baggins and Thorin Oakenshield. A hobbit of the Shire and the Dwarven King Under the Mountain. That is who they were. That is who they are."
Now everyone who had been poised to hear the solution let out a sigh of disappointment. Gimli clicked his tongue, and Aragorn smirked with a quiet chuckle.
"But... that explains nothing", Frodo murmured, at a loss.
The wizard drew on his pipe once more, closing the matter.
The sun was rolling slowly toward the horizon, staining the treetops in crimson, and the camp sank once more into a drowsy anticipation of the twilight.
A dry afternoon wind rustled through the leaves of the hollies.
One way or another, an each remained stuck to his own mind.
Notes:
And then they all read Bilbo Baggins' book and feel sad because they didn't see the kissing scene
