Chapter Text
The first time this conversation took place in the north of Eregion was during the stay of Thorin Oakenshield’s company right there.
Rivendell was drowning in twilight and the scent of lilies.
"Tell me, Lindir, do you suppose they have explored each other's forms yet?" An elven guard elegantly arched an eyebrow, sipping his wine. "I mean... that striking contrast. The coarse, unhewn dwarven stature and that soft roundness of the halfling. It must be... most illuminating."
"I expect they are still at the stage of examining cultural barriers", Lindir replied, somewhat haughtily. "But judging by the sheer diligence with which the Son of Thráin bores his gaze into that hobbit, the barriers shall fall before the full moon."
They exchanged glances with barely perceptible smirks.
Later, the Lord of Rivendell himself raised the subject in a conversation with Gandalf.
"Mithrandir", Elrond began softly, "I heard some... whispers and can't fight my curiousity anymore. Do you think they, I mean, Thorin Oakenshield and Mr. Bilbo Baggins, have already... commenced a comparative analysis of their... differences? As a healer, I find myself exceedingly curious about this... ethnographic experiment."
Gandalf merely pulled his hat down a little lower.
"Elrond, I implore you, stay your healer’s zeal. The Heir of Durin thinks now only of reclaiming his throne, while my Burglar is entirely occupied with trying to survive the company of thirteen stubborn dwarves."
"And yet", the Lord of Imladris smiled gently, his eyes following the small figure of the hobbit, shadowed closely by a sullen dwarf, "a bond is already being forged between them that will outlast this quest. Whatever its nature may be."
Gandalf shifted his gaze to the same spot; a faint spark of mischief appeared in his eyes, and his lips twitched into a smile.
"There is something to that..."
Back then, in the year of the Quest, the elves of Imladris merely jested with courtly wit. To the immortal folk, this strange alliance seemed nothing more than a vivid theatrical performance, a passing seasonal amusement.
Decades, however, rolled by. Spring yielded to autumn, and Rivendell still drowned in the scents of elegant blossoms and a twilight that remembered every step of the vanished heroes. Time, so merciless to mortals, had scarcely touched the Last Homely House, but the whispers had altered their tone.
In the corridors of the palace, they no longer joked about "anatomical contrasts." Now, long after Thorin Oakenshield had come to rest beneath the stone vaults of the Mountain, elven maidens and loremasters whispered of something else entirely.
"They say the King Under the Mountain gifted him a ringmail of pure mithril before he died, binding their souls forevermore", a young elf-maid would sigh. "And the halfling bore it away to his distant land, to mourn him until the end of his days."
"The hobbit treasured his dying breath", a guard would echo, his gaze fixed on the misty distance. "And to this day, in his faraway country, he withers from longing for the King entombed in stone. It was a union as impossible as it was beautiful."
To Arwen, daughter of Elrond, these conversations were more than just an ancient song. In those days when the young Ranger of the North — Aragorn, son of Arathorn — sought hospitality in Rivendell, the Undómiel often frequented her father’s archives. She searched the records for hidden meanings, striving to comprehend the nature of feelings that bind those destined for different spans of time upon this earth. To the immortal elves, a human life — much like a dwarven or a hobbit one — was but a brief flash, yet stories of what could ignite between different kindreds were deemed worth their weight in gold.
"Adár", she asked one day, as she and Elrond went through old scrolls in the library. "Is it true, what the minstrels sing of the King Under the Mountain and the Halfling who helped reclaim it? They say their souls were bound by ancient magic, an irresistible gravity that washes away the differences of the flesh."
Elrond laughed softly, shaking his head.
"Oh, Arwen. Minstrels love to lay the colours on thickly. If only you had seen them then... But, well..." the Lord of Rivendell grew grave, and the wisdom of ages reflected in his eyes. "Perhaps the songs do not lie in one regard. It was a union of opposites."
Elrond fell silent for a time, watching the dying embers in the hearth.
"On that journey, there was no time to speak of feelings, Arwen", the Lord of Rivendell replied gently. "Dwarves are a secretive folk, and hobbits... simple though they may be...", he coughed, "well, is that truly the point? Mortals love desperately, because their hour is short. Out of their attachment, they fashioned a legend that will outlive their flesh."
Arwen lowered her head, a quiet, bitter resolve taking root in her heart.
One way or another, Rivendell stuck to its own mind.
They did not care for earthly mundanity here. Every tale, in passing through elven halls, had to be transformed into a high, poetic ballad of fatal doom, noble spirit, and eternal parting.
To the elves, the story of Thorin II Oakenshield and Bilbo Baggins became a beautiful, sorrowful parable of how two entirely different natures — coarse stone and soft earth — could meld into a singular harmony, if only for a brief, tragic moment.
The minstrels continued to pluck the strings of their harps, singing of the "high, platonic grief of the King Under the Mountain and his Burglar."
And if, in order to praise the devotion of a little hobbit, he had to be made the hero of an ancient tragedy — well, Imladris did so with an elegant reverence.
