Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

With Rumours is Middle-earth Filled

Summary:

History is written by chroniclers. Legends are woven by minstrels. Gossip is spread by neighbors, courtiers, and tavern regulars.

The Shire, Rivendell, Mirkwood, the people of Lake-town, and Erebor all tell the same story differently.

All that's left is to decide which of it is actually the truth. Well, in one way or another...

Chapter 1: From the Kitchen Gossip of the Shire

Chapter Text

Aside from eating, brewing beer, and smoking pipe-weed, hobbits were perhaps incredibly adept at spreading rumours and gossip. If so much as a single thing happened in the Shire, it seemed virtually everyone knew about it by the day’s end.

If someone was intending to marry, the villagers would usually guess as much when two hobbits suddenly and simultaneously vanished from sight.

In such cases, it was customary to return home already wed.

If a hobbit disappeared from the Shire for a long while, the neighbors assumed he had gone looking for a mate. Thus, the moment someone went missing for any significant stretch of time, any conversation over dinner, tea, or afternoon tea would invariably turn into a discussion of the runaway’s impending betrothal.

Therefore, when Mr. Baggins returned to Bag End after more than a year and proved that he was indeed the real, and most certainly living, Bilbo Baggins, the whole Shire began to whisper.

At first, everyone set about inquiring and twittering about some young hobbit-lass. However, this led nowhere.

Then, someone remembered that upon his return, they had looked over Mr. Baggins’s contract — complete with the signature of the very person to whom Bilbo had pledged his services to.
Thorin Oakenshield.

"My-my, Bilbo Baggins traveled with dwarves."
"Pass the buns, dear... oh, I heard he traveled with a dwarf-king."
"Oh, did he now? Mr. Baggins? With a king?"

Rumors had already been circulating about the returned hobbit’s family anyway. It was said, apparently, that one of Bilbo’s distant ancestors on his mother’s side — definitely someone from the Took clan — had been married to an elf.

Therefore, the notion that Mr. Baggins himself had preferred something rather more exotic to anyone from the Shire seemed perfectly logical.
Of course, it was a slightly confusing fact that "Thorin Oakenshield" did not sound like a female name at all, and moreover, Bilbo himself kept saying that he was his friend. 'He', not 'she'.

On the other hand, Bilbo Baggins had always been a bit... odd in the eyes of other hobbits. Must say queer. To be over fifty years old and not have so much as a couple of children and a wife... not even a mild dalliance! A confirmed bachelor with his own... well... peculiarities.

In short, even back when the traveling hobbit had only just returned to his emptied home, the rumors had already begun to circulate.

"Did they really only... travel?"
"Oh, come off it, Lobelia, what are you implying?"
"But haven't you thought that perhaps Bilbo and this king..."
.. "What?! No, a betrothal must be an exaggeration."
"Then what?"
"A very tragic romance?"
"Oh-h-h, my dear..."

Years later, of course, it ceased to cause any great stir. It simply remained an opinion with which, all in all, almost everyone in the Shire agreed. Instead of Bilbo-the-Confirmed-Bachelor-Baggins, the talkative hobbit-lads and hobbit-lasses over tea-time gatherings were more likely to drop words about Bilbo-the-Heartbroken-Widower-Baggins.

Also, as is usually the case with good gossip, over time it ceased to be a mere assumption.
It became a generally accepted opinion.

And after that — simply a fact.
At any rate, for the whole of the Shire.

Except for Bilbo Baggins himself. But, by universal consensus, Mr. Baggins was an interested party and was therefore considered a highly unreliable source.

"You know, Milo Burrows told me the other day that Bilbo Baggins was betrothed to a king! Can you imagine? Isn't that a bit grand for the likes of him, eh..."
"Quite right, Hugo, I can’t credit it. Not only did he grab himself such a large piece of land to own, but now it turns out he has dealings with the crown!"
"Don’t be like that, it's actually rather sad. He wasn't just betrothed to a king! They broke apart!"
"Oh, yes, I heard the king perished and Bilbo was left a widower!"

When Frodo was still a small lad, he didn't pay much attention to such things, and took little interest besides. To him, Thorin Oakenshield was a hero from his uncle's tales — a formidable king who fought Azog and fell in the Battle of the Five Armies.

Frodo loved to listen to adventures and dragons. Many children did. Often, Samwise Gamgee or young Meriadoc Brandybuck and Peregrin Took would join in to listen to these yarns. It was from the latter two that Frodo learned of the rumors.
"Did you never wonder why your old man didn't marry again?" Merry asked out of the blue one day.
Frodo frowned.
"Again?"
"Well, yes."
"What makes you think he was married the first time? He never seemed to..."
A silence fell over the table. The two young hobbits exchanged glances.
"He wasn't?"
"No."
"Not at all?"
"Well... not at all..?"
Pippin let out a sad, almost broken sigh.
"Poor old Bilbo."
Merry nodded.
"Still mourning..."
Then they bowed their heads in unison.
"So many years passed."
"True devotion."
"You don't see the like of it nowadays."

Frodo understood absolutely nothing: neither what they were talking about, nor why his friends spoke of it with such tragic pathos. Bilbo truly had never mentioned a marriage of his own.

When, on the evening of a same day, Frodo finally resolved to question his uncle directly, Mr. Baggins first choked on his tea, and then glared at his nephew over the rim of his cup, thoroughly rejecting any notion of his marriage.
"Uncle Bilbo, but really! All the hobbits of your age have long since had families. You say you weren't married, but... still, why did you never marry some nice hobbit-lass?" Frodo asked, tilting his head slightly.
"I have no need for it, my boy", the elder hobbit replied, lighting his pipe and rolling his eyes slightly. "My heart, it seems, belongs to books and adventures."
"To adventures?"
"Yes, yes, my dear. Perhaps it stayed behind in the mountains."

After that phrase, Frodo thought he understood everything.

The next day, while helping Sam prune the roses by the gates of Bag End, Frodo remained silent for a long time, watching his uncle blow smoke rings on the porch.
"Sam", Frodo called softly. "Merry and Pippin were saying yesterday... Well, about Uncle. About why he’s alone. They think that Master Thorin Oakenshield was... something more to him. That they were betrothed or some such thing."

Sam froze, gently holding a bud. He did not scoff, but only sighed softly.
"Oh, Mr. Frodo. Folks in the taverns will wag their tongues at anything, and the young masters have listened to too many tales. It's unlikely a dwarf-king was thinking of betrothals when he went to win back gold from a dragon."
"So, you think it’s all nonsense too?"
"I think, Mr. Frodo...", Sam raised his eyes to him, and for some reason, Frodo’s breath caught for a moment, "I think that one doesn't necessarily have to sign papers or wear rings to give one's heart to someone."
He sighed quietly, his cheeks looking a bit redder. "Mr. Bilbo often told the story to you and me, and... I think if a hobbit is ready to throw himself into deadly danger for someone's sake, that... well, it might mean something."

Frodo remained silent, feeling a lump rise in his throat. Sam went back to the roses.

One way or another, the Shire stuck to its own mind.

Old crones on their doorsteps sighed as they brewed chamomile tea; Lobelia Sackville-Baggins pinched her lips triumphantly whenever she passed Bag End; and young hobbit-lasses cited the story as an example and symbol of eternal, if terribly eccentric, fidelity.
They did not care for loose ends here. A hobbit’s life had to be understandable, orderly, and fit within the bounds of propriety.

And if, in order to justify the oddities of a respectable hobbit, he had to be christened "the inconsolable widower of the Dwarwen King" — well, the Shire did so with a light heart.