Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 3: Timeline and Power Struggles of the Esgaroth Political Landscape

Notes:

This chapter should be read as speculation on an alternative interpretation of Thranduil's actions over the course of "The Hobbit" film trilogy. For my own amusement, I imagined that Thranduil's motives could rather ally with the strategies of Machiavelli, rather than the stated motives of the book or film universe. Basically, let's just imagine the whole "Gems of Lasgalen" reclamation was a smokescreen for more realpolitik political motives, just as one would imagine the Trojan War was likely not fought over Helen, but more likely over trade routes. In any case, have fun and understand this fan speculation not iron-clad literary theory.

Chapter Text

(As I have said previously, I have a lot of thoughts and feelings about the political power-struggle we glimpse in The Hobbit trilogy, and its hints at a rich and intricate past between the three players of Erebor, Dale, and Mirkwood (née the Greenwood). I want to support this mini-treatise with some dates from the wider Tolkien canon, but the movie clearly changes the timelines as well as the motivations of the three major players of Bard, Thranduil, and Thorin Oakenshield, so they will only be used as a vague reference point rather than absolute truth.)

In the beginning, there was the founding of Erebor. This has made a lot of people very angry and been widely regarded as a bad move.

(Especially this guy)

 

No, but seriously, Erebor has actually been “founded” twice. Once when it was physically established as a dwarven settlement, back in 1999 of the Third Age (for reference, the events of The Hobbit take place in 2941, almost 1000 years later). However, at the time it was not a settlement of any particular note and certainly had not struck upon the treasure that would make its name. That changed in 2590 TA (some 600 years later), when dragons destroyed the dwarven settlement in the Grey Mountains, Thror’s home, and killing Thror’s father Dain I and brother Frór (something of a trend for the line of Durin). Thrór fled, his brother Grór going on to found the settlement in the Iron Hills while Thrór went to Erebor. This is what I call “the second founding of Erebor” because it marks the change from when Erebor went from one of many dwarven settlements to an actual dwarven kingdom ruled by a king of Durin’s Folk (the Longbeards), much in the same way that “Byzantium” becomes “Constantinople”, the city already existed but did not become a capital until the Emperor of Rome (Constantine) made it one.

Character Note 1, Tauriel: It’s worth mentioning here that Tauriel has lived in Mirkwood at least 600 years based on Legolas’s mention of how Thranduil sheltered her. Since the second founding of Erebor took place in over 500 years before the The Hobbit, it’s safe to say that Tauriel is literally older than Erebor, something I really wish she and Kíli had the chance to talk about sometime.

(“I am literally older than the kingdom you’re trying to reclaim,” said Tauriel never)

Tauriel’s age bears mentioning because it means the Greenwood was there long before Erebor became a major kingdom, which would affect the way an immortal like Thranduil would view that kingdom. For one thing, he would have had very long dealings with Thrór, who was King of Erebor for basically the entire time the “kingdom” existed. Thror’s sense of security in his line through his son and grandson cannot be understated, he’d ruled for at least a century before Smaug came and, unlike his father Dain I, had two heirs of two generations to entrust his line to.

Which brings me somewhat to the realm of speculation, hopefully based on some evidence. The alliance between Mirkwood and Erebor was a natural one, but not a comfortable one in my opinion. Thranduil would have been forced to realize that this small dwarven mining settlement was now a power to be reckoned with, that he could no longer ignore it. The history between the elves and dwarves is an uneasy one, filled with ongoing tension when it’s not flaring up into actual violence. Given his age and ancestry, Thranduil would almost certainly have known or at least known people who knew King Thingol, who was murdered by dwarves due to the dispute over the Nauglamir. He would likely not have been pleased at the prospect of a major dwarven kingdom “appearing” on his doorstep, but given its wealth and Thranduil’s own greed for gems (which is canonical) he would have been unable to ignore them and would have had incentive to join an alliance, though perhaps not an alliance he had any intention of honoring beyond the immediate use of trade.

(I call these the “Definitely-Not-The-Nauglamir” TM)

Entering into this political landscape we also have Dale, which was established the same year as the second founding of Erebor (2590). Based on the movie, we can assume that Dale’s existence is entirely owed to the wealth flowing out of Erebor, and the need the dwarves had for a trade provider of goods like food and textiles, since they supported themselves through metalwork and were not self-sufficient, nor did they seem to have any interest in being self-sufficient, seeing such other works as beneath them and their natural skills. Dale is what allowed Erebor to reach the heights of its wealth, by freeing the dwarves to focus on their crafts rather than delegating a portion of their population to subsistence, and in return Erebor repaid Dale’s service of seeing to their needs with wealth beyond imagining. This was a mutually beneficial relationship, but more than that it was a symbiotic one, because when Erebor fell, Dale went with it.

As something of a third wheel in this relationship is Mirkwood. As an ancient kingdom of the Elves, Mirkwood would be a major local political player. They have an army, and lands, and guard the road to the West. However, they do no sow crops, nor do they work metals, or really do anything useful except subsist off their trade contacts with others (much like Erebor), except when it comes to their own hunting for sport in the forest. They are rich, however, due to their age and would have benefited from both Dale and Erebor.  Yet they were also proud, and Erebor would have surpassed the wealth of Mirkwood ten times over in a very short time by Thranduil’s reckoning. Between the blow to his pride and his power, not to mention his greed and distrust of dwarves, the alliance between Thranduil and Thrór would have been a distasteful if useful one.

Enter the dragon sickness. At some point during his reign, Thror’s greed took on a new element, became grasping and covetous and unwilling to part with a single coin, even when a contract existed. This would have placed further strain on the alliance with Mirkwood, because as we see Thrór gives in to petty spite against Thranduil, teasing and taunting him with the wealth of Erebor and showing Thranduil to be the junior partner, something that would enrage proud old King Thranduil. 

Character Note 2, Thorin: This is the world Thorin was born into. A world where an alliance between Mirkwood and Erebor was the natural state of the region. One in which Dale existed to support Erebor, and was repaid with wealth from trade. Because Thorin was born long after the alliance between Erebor and Mirkwood was struck, he would not be able to imagine a world where such an alliance did not exist; he would not naturally understand the tension between Thrór and Thranduil. He would live in a world that glorified this alliance with festivals and songs, not understanding that these glorifications were meant to reinforce a shaky and uncomfortable agreement between two races that naturally hate each other. Hence his confusion when Thrór, in his sickness, begins to mock Thranduil. Thorin’s confusion was clearly a direct result of the fact that as young dwarf he did not understand the tensions between elves and dwarves. In that, he was much like Kíli. Thorin was born a child of privilege, an heir to literally the wealthiest kingdom in the world at that time. To him, the conflicts between dwarves and elves would be centuries-old history. He would have heard such tales, but not leant them much credence because he would see Mirkwood as a supporter of Erebor and its reign, much like Dale in that respect. Though old dwarves would tell Thorin of the crimes of the elves, he would see them as secondary to the importance of the alliance between Erebor and Mirkwood. Can’t you see that we’ve moved on to better times? Thranduil would never break his word. Thranduil is a war hero of the Second Age, he is a trade partner of Erebor, he is our ally, he is—

Thranduil proves himself to be everything that the dwarves ever suspected an elf could be. Cold, remote, holding grudges for centuries beyond the lifespans of all who were involved, uncaring of the lives of lesser mortals, controlled by pride and greed, faithless in the repayment of services rendered, inconstant to allies when it serves his purpose, changeable in his moods.

In my eyes, Thranduil’s betrayal on the day the dragon came was purely a matter of self-interest. To quote Niccolo Machiavelli:

 

“Upon this, one has to remark that men ought either to be well treated or crushed, because they can avenge themselves of lighter injuries, of more serious ones they cannot; therefore the injury that is to be done to a man ought to be of such a kind that one does not stand in fear of revenge.”

Thranduil had several choices on the day that Smaug came: he could send in his armies to battle the beast, which had already taken the city, he could abstain from fighting Smaug directly but lend aid to the dwarves of Erebor in their weakness, or he could do neither and leave the dwarves of Erebor to be destroyed entirely. Clearly, he chose the final option, but why? Many have remarked upon how Thranduil’s baffling behavior, when it seems only a little aid would be needed to vastly improve the circumstances of Thorin and his people, and to honor his alliance. Yet he utterly betrays it, utterly breaks his word on all fronts. The excuse given is that he will not face a dragon a second time, especially when he sees Smaug as a calamity that the dwarves brought upon themselves and therefore not falling under the vague conditions of their alliance, but that still should not preclude aid to the refugees.

(“I could help but…nah.”)

To me, there is only one explanation: Thranduil desired the utter destruction of Erebor and the dwarves that inhabited it. Perhaps not out of pure malice, rather he realized that his people would never be forgiven for not taking on the impossible task of slaying the dragon. Even if he leant aid to the refugees, the muttering would begin immediately that he should have done more to help against the dragon, instead of taking the “easy” job of helping the refugees. He’s not entirely wrong in this, if Thorin’s immediate reaction is anything to judge by. So he follows the advice of Machiavelli: if he helps the dwarves in any way, they will have the strength to take revenge against him for his perceived failure to kill Smaug (regardless of whether he could have done so at all, or would have only lost countless lives as Erebor did, leaving the entire region weakened). It is better in this instance to allow the dwarves of Erebor to disintegrate utterly, broken and scattered by diaspora, unable to rally the strength for vengeance on their faithless ally. As we see in Battle of the Five Armies, Thranduil thinks in terms of centuries. It will only be a short time before all the dwarves who remember Erebor and the alliance are dead, better to let this generation perish in the short time it will take than to risk invasion.

This brings us to the “present” – 2941, Thranduil’s reaction to Thorin in Mirkwood, and later his actions at the Battle of the Five Armies.

Personally, I find it a bit puzzling that Thranduil immediately divined Thorin’s purpose in Mirkwood. To my eyes, the presence of thirteen dwarves appearing on Thranduil’s doorstep was obviously assassination, given Thorin’s extremely vocal hatred of Thranduil and the history with Thingol. It would be ludicrous to assume that a dozen dwarves are on their way to take on a dragon that destroyed a fortress city with literally thousands of warriors. In any case, Thranduil does guess their purpose, and offers his help in exchange for jewels long denied by Thrór and later by the dragon.

The violence of Thorin’s response tells Thranduil everything he needs to know – the dwarves have not forgiven Thranduil’s failure to aid them, quite the contrary.  They will literally suffer imprisonment and death rather than give Thranduil the least of the treasures in their halls. It’s not a matter of payment, it’s a matter of honor and they will die for it rather than treat Thranduil as anything other than an enemy.

Thranduil has only one recourse at this point – prevent Thorin from going to the mountain, at least until such a point that he can bend the dwarf to his will, which is probably never. This immediately explains Thranduil’s decision to lock down Mirkwood as soon as Thorin escapes. If Thorin is successful in slaying the dragon, Mirkwood is next. The only thing keeping the dwarves from coalescing around a new king is the presence of Smaug. The dwarves will flock to the banner of Erebor the minute the fortress city is reclaimed. That means literally thousands of dwarves from Ered Luin and the Iron Hills amassing on Mirkwood’s doorstep for a war of vengeance.

The death of Smaug will mean another thing: the revival of Dale. At present, the only reason that well-constructed city lies empty is because of Smaug. That’s why Lake-town was built upon the water, to defend against the dragon fire. Now, what’s terribly interesting about Lake-town is that they have an active trade relationship with Mirkwood, one that the Master of Lake-town canonically does not want to lose. Lake-town trades wine to the Woodland Realm, because Mirkwood does not produce anything on its own. In Lake-town we can see the effects of Smaug’s presence on the region, meaning nothing permanent can be established and no true wealth accumulated because it risks drawing Smaug’s attention, but we also see that Mirkwood of itself is not nearly as good an ally as Erebor was. Mirkwood is isolationist and not terribly wealthy, at least it does not share its wealth. Erebor was the natural ally of the Men in the region because they were willing to trade the wealth they produced in exchange for goods; Mirkwood is not, at least not to the same extent. Mirkwood as a primary trade partner is one reason why Lake-town is poor, however as their strongest partner and the one with the best standing military, it is in Lake-town’s interest to stay in Thranduil’s good graces rather than risk losing them on the hopes of regaining Erebor and Dale.

Much can be said of Thranduil’s political motivation based on the actions he takes immediately following Smaug’s death. He could have leant archers, or soldiers to Lake-town had he seen them as an ally worth defending. Knowing that the dwarves meant to rouse the dragon, a conscientious ally would have leant those soldiers just in case Smaug took his anger out on Lake-town, a very real possibility if the dragon was indeed merely sleeping rather than dead as the dwarves hoped. Thranduil does not take this action, so I must take this to mean he cares very little for Lake-town.

However, once Smaug is dead, Thranduil recognizes the immediate needs—not of Lake-town, but of Dale. The dragon’s death means the revival of the city, the reclaiming of Erebor means that the alliance will be reestablished between those two cities and peoples.

It means that Mirkwood will now be the kingdom that did not help either of its allies against the dragon.

Thranduil’s Machiavellian plan is at risk of failing. When given the option to help a weakened ally or to allow that ally to be destroyed, rather than risk that weakened ally becoming an enemy, he chose destruction rather than risk his kingdom. However, that destruction was not fully achieved, and now he has a weakened and enraged enemy on his doorstep. His gamble failed.

In that light, the food makes perfect sense. Thranduil only has one option now: to buy the friendship of Dale with food in their hour of need, before Erebor can rally to lend that aid itself. To set Dale up in opposition to their natural trade ally of Erebor, to sow dissent between them, and to reinforce the rather paltry alliance Mirkwood had with Lake-town as more trustworthy than the great wealth Dale once knew with Erebor. To that end, he must also prevent the return of Erebor as a major power in the region, because that balance is now tipped against him by his own actions (some of which were beyond his control, if we believe there was no real chance against the dragon in the first place, but he will still be blamed for that failure).

A key element of preventing Erebor from attacking Mirkwood is to make sure it is not ruled by the dwarf with the most personal sense of betrayal against Thranduil: Thorin and the line of Durin. Hence why Thranduil’s goal is to make sure they are slain, and to go to “war” against thirteen dwarves. With Erebor open for the taking, Thranduil can reestablish the balance of the region by giving the stolen wealth of Erebor to Dale and to Mirkwood, until that runs out.

All of these plans are thwarted by the arrival of the goblin armies. Then a new rule comes into play: the enemy of my enemy is my friend. From the fire of the Battle of the Five Armies a new alliance is forged between the Dale, Mirkwood, and Erebor as ruled by Dain II rather than Thorin. Thanks in part to Gandalf too; it fuses three feuding kingdoms into a single entity that will one day face the Shadow. However, on its own, the “good” races of that region had every reason to fight and hate one another due to old betrayals, and it is only through the introduction of heretofore unknown elements that they are able to move on past that point.