Chapter Text
Alkjira asked (paraphrased): Why did Thranduil come to Erebor when Smaug attacked, but then turn away?
1) On the surface, I’d say it’s just narrative convenience :-/ The implication is that Thranduil came to help, saw the dragon, and turned around. No word on whether he offered any other kind of aid to the dwarves. We presume not, though it makes almost no sense unless Thranduil is supremely Machiavellian and hoped the lack of aid would wipe out the dwarves who would now certainly have a grudge against him.
2) You bring up a fascinating point though, because the timing makes very little sense. Look, the locations of PJ’s Middle Earth are complete nonsense in The Hobbit trilogy. Where the fuck is Dol Guldur, or Mirkwood, or the Iron Hills, or Gundabad if they’re less than a day’s march away from Erebor and then why did it take the Company so long to get there? So the distances are fucked, nevermind trying to figure them out or how long it takes to field an army, which should be days if not weeks. Given that our “previous” scene was Thror denying the gems to Thranduil then yeah, it’s not absurd to think that Thranduil already planned an invasion and was thwarted. To someone as young and naive as Thorin, who seemed to honestly be more astonished by Thror’s refusal than hating Elves at that tender age, it could have read as “Allies who came to help and then turned away”.
BUT he could be wrong. Thranduil could have indeed been coming to invade at the same time as Smaug, for similar reasons. This corresponds with 1) his lack of aid to the dwarves (of course he wouldn’t help them, he wanted to wipe them out) and 2) why his attack IMMEDIATELY resumed the minute Smaug was dead, as Smaug was only an interruption to his plans. It explains too why he didn’t even attempt to negotiate or make a peaceful request for the gems, they were never his intention. They may not even have ever been his only intention, he could very well have intended to seize all the gold in the mountain as part of the ancient vendetta between elves and dwarves and just one too many insults from Thror. In his own words, “I am patient, I can wait” even for things like vengeance for past slights. This is obviously movie-Thranduil only, but you raise an excellent question.
