Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 7: What if dragon sickness and gold sickness are not the same thing?

Chapter Text

(From 2014)

For awhile now we’ve heard the terms “gold sickness” and “dragon sickness” bandied about in the Hobbit fandom. The two tend to be used interchangeably and for awhile this has bothered me, a niggling question at the back of my mind. The interchangeable nature of the names implies they are the same disease, and that the “dragon” in dragon sickness means one acts like a dragon in the desire for gold. 

But what if this isn’t true? What if the answer has been staring us in the face, and PJ has been saying the name of the disease that Thorin contracts the whole time?

What if Thorin never suffers from gold sickness, but from the totally separate disease of dragon sickness?

Let me explain:

The whole reason the gold sickness came into being is because the dwarves were still using the Sauron-corrupted Rings of Power, namely the seven dwarven rings, all of which have been destroyed except for the ring that was given to Thror.

This means that as Sauron regained strength, his corruption grew in the surviving dwarven rings and twisted the good qualities of them to evil. Meaning, Thror’s “sickness of the mind” is really a product of Sauron’s growing strength, a known canonical fact. 

Thrain is said to have gone mad after Azanulbizar, which is coincidentally after he received the dwarven ring from Thror. Being tortured to insanity by Sauron may have had something to do with it too (*sarcasm*).

Dragon sickness, on the other hand, may be a succinct name for a very well known phenomena in the Tolkien universe, suffered by Turin Turambar and possibly Fram.

(cut because it got long)

Keep in mind, everyone who has talked about the Durin “sickness of the mind” has been unaware of the dwarven ring or unaware of Sauron’s return. Therefore very logical conclusions were drawn by people like Gandalf, Elrond, Balin, Thorin, etc. based on false premises. In the AUJ EE Gandalf even mentions the dwarven ring in passing, but draws no conclusions as to its wider impact other than that it has gone missing.

So, what if there is no sickness in the line of Durin, and there never was? It merely follows such hereditary patterns because the dwarven ring is given to descendants. After all, we’ve seen no touch of it in Balin or Dwalin, Oin or Gloin, Fili or Kili, all of whom are equally of the line of Durin. 

And most importantly we did not see it in Thorin when he lived in Erebor.

Why is that? Presumably if all it took was contact with vast wealth Thorin would have exhibited signs. Instead he is shown to be wary of his grandfather’s sickness. This has raised the puzzling question of how he could not be self-aware of his illness once he contracts it, or why he had not contracted it before. 

Except Thorin does get sick when encountering the hoard, because the hoard that has lain under Smaug for over a century is not the same hoard that enchanted his grandfather.

Dragons are cursed beings. From the Lord of the Rings wiki:

[Dragons] also had a hypnotic power called “dragon-spell”; weaker-willed beings could be put into a trance or bent to a dragon’s will when the beast spoke. In addition, this dragon-spell seems to have had the ability to plant mistrust in the listener’s mind. This power also extended to a dragon’s treasure hoard, causing it to excite feelings of greed and animosity among others. Feuds and battles frequently followed upon the death of a dragon; usually between the Hero who slew the beast and the original owners (or their heirs), as well as an occasional ambitious third party. Some have speculated that this ‘curse’ played a part in Fram’s death at the hands of the Dwarves after he had slain Scatha. The same could be said of the famous 'Battle of Five Armies’ upon the death of Smaug. Source

As stated before, Thorin was wary of the gold sickness, though he had no need to be so long as he did not bear a dwarven ring. He would have recognized the signs. He was not one to get lost in a delirium. But the hoard of Smaug is now cursed and it is that curse that he suffers. Since it bears superficial similarity to gold sickness there would have been little reason to investigate further, but actually the symptoms are wildly different and only linked by correlation, i.e that treasure plays a role. 

I’ve been puzzled for awhile as to why the terms “gold sickness” and “dragon sickness” are used interchangeably. It niggled at the back of my mind as not quite right. Gold sickness by its name implies that the sufferer is driven mad by greed. The only way dragon sickness could be the same thing is to imply that the sufferer acts like a dragon, and this makes them desire gold. But what if the “dragon” in dragon sickness really means the source of the disease? Because if that’s the case then Thror and Thrain never had dragon sickness. How could they? Their contact with Smaug mainly consisted of running away from him, the gold of Erebor was still uncorrupted by his presence.

So, we have been tricked into conflating two diseases because they appear to be used interchangeably. We shouldn’t feel bad about it, because the very wise appear to as well, including Elrond and Gandalf. On the surface, gold sickness appeared as mental illness and Thorin succumbing to a disease with similar symptoms made the case for it being hereditary. However, the gold that drove Thror mad was not in the same state as the gold that drove Thorin mad and dragons are known to be cursed beings that also curse their treasure.  This explains why Thorin is not more careful about his symptoms, he knows from experience that he does not suffer the same disease his grandfather did and he is correct. They have completely different sources, the latter of which (dragons) could not possibly have had impact on Thror. 

The wise of Middle Earth have not come to these conclusions because they didn’t know about Sauron or his impact on the dwarven rings and have been drawing their own conclusions for centuries as to why the line of Durin became suddenly gold obsessed. Butif we assume some book canon here, everyone became gold obsessed when coming into contact with Smaug’s hoard, therefore it cannot be a hereditary illness at play or even solely the fault of the gold because no other dwarf was shown having the illness before Smaug came to Erebor. 

One huge upside to all of this is that all of these diseases are artificial, curses caused by dark powers, which means we drop that problematic and annoying use of mental illness as an explanation. 

Tl;dr Gold sickness and Dragon sickness are completely different diseases and Thorin has been misdiagnosed. 

*collapses from the wordiness*

Note: There is the very real possibility that they’ve just given two names to this “mental illness” of the line of Durin over at PJ’s workshop and that Thorin is merely succumbing in the same way as his grandfather. It’s certainly a simpler explanation, and will probably turn out to be true but a girl can dream of a more nuanced world, can’t she?