Chapter Text
indigoire asked: I'm listening to your meta (just started part three) and I'm sure you make mention of it later, but what do you consider dragon sickness to be? Because it's very unclear in the movie. Is it mental illness or is it a curse, or is it mental illness brought on by a curse? Is it a physical sickness and the scene in the golden hall is Thorin's fever breaking, essentially? Everyone seems to go back and forth on what this sickness really is.
So I answered this in two parts, but since the second part was a bit cleaner I’m putting it first and all the ramble-y stuff is under a cut:
I guess I can’t say definitively what dragon sickness is, so first let’s look at its symptoms and the fact that it hits Thorin harder than anyone else:
- Obsession with gold, to the point where it replaces all other priorities in the victim’s life (Thorin on his own values life, and is subverted into holding life as less valuable than gold over the course of his illness)
- Mood swings triggered by thoughts of wealth. Ex. “It was nobly done—but the treasure…” and also “We have to do something” from Dwalin triggering Thorin to immediately think of hiding the gold, and again the acorn scene’s sudden shift when he hears there are people outside (threatening his treasure, in the same way Smaug would be suspicious of anyone outside his door).
- Paranoia that those around the victim will try to steal from them. Smaug also showed this paranoia. This paranoia leads to isolation. Conversely, breaking this isolation is shown to help lessen or remove the effects of dragon sickness.
- Ego Boost “I am fire, I am death!” “Am I not the king?!” “Do not speak to me as if I were some mere dwarf lord, as if I were Thorin Oakenshield” Dragon sickness comes with a power trip that borders on mania. Complete assurance of one’s own superiority, based on the possession of the treasure. The act of possessing treasure and being “king” is all one needs to be actualized. The thought of losing the treasure causes hysteria. For someone like Thorin, who has been beaten down by life, constantly losing people and thing that are dear to him (like his home), and who just found out the great accomplishment of his life, which gave him his epithet Oakenshield was a lie, this kind of power rush gives him a high he’s rarely if ever experience, that of being proud of himself. It would be heady even without the illness, but it turns his victory of reclaiming Erebor into something dark and tragic. It also makes it harder for him to get free of the dragon sickness, because with no point of pride in his life before falling ill it’s hard for him to judge and compare and choose which person he would rather be: Oakenshield or the King. Objectively, Oakenshield was a better person, but it certainly doesn’t feel that way.
Basically: behaving like a dragon in all ways except the physical transformation. (*cough*)
So I wrote this section first but it was all over the place so I’m putting it second because that’s how my brain works and also it’s not as streamlined:
Ok, but first of all it’s important to preface this by saying dragon sickness is a fantasy illness. While it may borrow from the symptoms of real illnesses, and Richard certainly did some research into the mannerisms of people who are suffering some form of illness, there is no 1 to 1 comparison and so I hope no one takes offense if I speak very candidly about it.
First of all, I really like your comment that Thorin coming out of the gold sickness was like a fever breaking, because I think a fever is almost a more apt way of describing what is shown in the movie than a mental illness, because quite honestly the film is a bit ??? when it comes to that. Thorin lost in delirium seems more accurate in some scenes than Thorin having a mental breakdown. It is also, as you say, a curse of some sort in that it is clearly magical and/or it affects a magical race. I know PJ doesn’t stress it very often compared to the elves (who he makes into some kind of angels, quite frankly), but dwarves are magical too. I think emilianadarling in her fic “Beneath the Mountain Music Woke” had the best and most otherworldly take on dragon sickness, where as a dwarf Thorin imagines rubies dripping from his hands and sees gold when he closes his eyes. So I do personally believe dragon sickness has magical properties in that it preys upon the fixation dwarves have on gold and precious gems as a non-human race. The equivalent in elves would be some sort of excessive obsession with starlight, I suppose, it’s a fixation humans can sympathize with but not fully understandbecause to them gold and jewels are not just pretty objects but integral to their being. However, that is straying into pure speculation as far as “dwarves as a different race” goes and is not fully backed up by movie canon. I just wanted to put it out there to stress that dragon sickness is something that happens to fantasy races. While the movie through Gandalf alludes to the fact that everyone around the mountain is currently being touched with dragon sickness, Thorin is the only one explicitly shown to be a victim.
I think the film portrays dragon sickness as a combination of all you said because they themselves are not totally clear on it. It’s a little bit hereditary mental illness, or at least hereditary predisposition to a mental illness, it’s a little bit of a fever with hints of delirium, it’s a little bit of an eldritch magical curse. I’d really like to know if dragon sickness is called that way because it makes one act like a dragon, or if it’s said to be caused by dragons. The film goes back and forth on that too, one minute saying that Smaug’s presence has cursed the gold, the next saying that dragon sickness is a “fierce and jealous love” and therefore something dwarves are familiar with on their own. In “Prayers” I ended up just shifting it to a fever that leads to a physical transformation, in essence saying that as a member of the line of Durin, Thorin is predisposed to the early symptoms of dragon sickness, the fever aspect, but without contact with gold a dragon has sat upon he would not begin to physically transform, which is Stage 2 of dragon sickness that not everyone gets to without said contact. Even there it was a little fuzzy.
