Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 9: Drunk on victory - why dragon sickness isn’t necessary for Thorin to go mad in Battle of Five Armies

Chapter Text

So I was listening to one of my favorite Bagginshield feels songs “All We Are”, by Matt Nathanson, when a particular line caught my attention in regards to Thorin.

“Well, it’s hard to change the way you lose, when you think you’ve never won.”

And it made me realize something: Thorin is a loser.

Oh, not literally, after all he has a lot going for him. But from his own perspective, Thorin’s life has been nothing but a string of failures. Starting with losing his home, being unable to provide for his people, being unable to find his father once he vanished, being unable to save his grandfather. Because lest we forget, he did not reach Thror’s side soon enough to defend him, but was only able to avenge his death with half measures. He did not kill Azog as he believed, only wounded him. (It should be obvious by this point that I’m only talking about movie!Thorin) He did not defeat the orc armies, only put them to rout. In that same battle he also lost his brother, who he also could not save, and various other relatives including Fundin, who was an uncle of his. It can’t even be said that they successfully buried the dead, since there was not the time or ability, instead they were forced to burn them in a sacrilegious act that took on significance in the aftermath of that terrible battle.

Settling in Ered Luin was not a victory either, since by all accounts it was a poor substitute for Erebor. His people were impoverished and living on bare subsistence for many years. One presumes that eventually the settlement stabilized for Thorin to be able to initiate the quest for Erebor. But remember in this too, he failed at gathering more than a dozen dwarves to his side, even after addressing hundreds of their closest kin and allies. Even for so obvious and heroic a goal, he could not sway any other dwarves to his side besides a few of his cousins and some opportunists.

And, good lord, then you have the quest itself! They’re nearly eaten by trolls, then crushed by stone giants, then killed by goblins if not for Gandalf providing a distraction and an escape, then by wargs, and all they’re able to do is hide up a tree while waiting for another distraction and escape. Thorin attempts to provide that distraction, by facing his old foe Azog in single combat.

He is defeated almost instantly, and only rescued by the acknowledged weakest member of the party. I mean it, he doesn’t even get a blow in on Azog, and instead endangers others when they need to step in and rescue him for his attempt at heroism.

Desolation of Smaug is little better. Mirkwood is a disaster, when they get lost and are nearly eaten again, this too Thorin could blame on himself. Then they’re captured, and thanks to Thorin’s old grudge against Thranduil they have little chance of escaping without help. The quest nearly ends right there. To jump forward, even facing Smaug ends in humiliation as they set the dragon loose on Laketown, the exact circumstance that Bard warned them about should they attempt to take the mountain.

Guys, Thorin’s life is just one humiliation after another at this point, how is he even still standing for goodness sake?!

Ok, but to my point now: regardless of how badly things have gone to that point, they do gain the mountain. Smaug is defeated. Erebor is reclaimed. Though the circumstances could hardly be worse, Thorin has won.

And I honestly think that alone would be enough to drive him a little bit crazy.

They say this sort of madness happens to a lot of people who have sudden success in life: lottery winners, overnight celebrities, etc. A world of “no” suddenly turns into a world of “yes”, and good sense vanishes with those boundaries. They are patently and demonstrably self destructive as a result. On some level it is postulated that the sudden turn of fortune is so unexpected that the “winner” cannot help but try to undermine it, if only to prove that it’s real or to make it disappear if it isn’t and prevent the inevitable disappointment.

I’ve gone into great detail on this before in other meta, but basically the need to reclaim Erebor is all that’s keeping Thorin together in life. He’s a lot of trauma and longing and desperation all wrapped up in a shell of bravery that is borderline suicidal. The closer he comes to the mountain, the closer he comes to confronting the source of everything that is broken inside of him, and it’s tearing him apart. The sudden loss of that external drive and pressure makes him fly apart spectacularly. But just as much there is the sudden nature of his success. Not just on the quest but in life, this is the first time Thorin Oakenshield has ever really won anything. Because I don’t think he’d see Azanulbizar or Ered Luin as victories. Balin even points out that he has nothing to be ashamed of, that he has “built a good life for our people in the Blue Mountains”, but it’s not enough. This first true, unequivocal victory of a lifetime ambition is also the first true joy and peace I think he’s ever allowed himself and he just. Can’t. Handle. It.

Thorin can’t handle success. He can’t handle victory. Like so many others who have been dealt a life of hardship, he can’t handle the sudden turn of fortune for the better. He can’t allow himself even a hairsbreadth of self-congratulations and reward because he’s so built against expecting such things. He’s built himself a wall against pain and disappointment because there was no other choice, and in the process lost what it was to be whole, and happy, and content in himself.

So all in all I’d say that the dragon sickness at this point is almost unnecessary. It certainly keeps Thorin on the road to ruin, overwhelming his better judgement. But I think on some level the story could have been told without the inclusion of the illness, simply as the tale of how even the strongest amongst us can lose control once they finally achieve their heart’s desire.