Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 11: The Bystander Effect, aka, Why didn’t the Company do something about Thorin?

Chapter Text

Some BotFA/ dragon sickness meta because it is literally my favorite Hobbit topic:

I believe the reason we don’t see the Company help Thorin sooner, other than narrative convenience, can only be described as the bystander effect.

Definition: The bystander effect, or bystander apathy, is a social psychological phenomenon that refers to cases in which individuals do not offer any means of help to a victim when other people are present. The probability of help is inversely related to the number of bystanders. In other words, the greater the number of bystanders, the less likely it is that any one of them will help. Several variables help to explain why the bystander effect occurs. These variables include: ambiguity, cohesiveness and diffusion of responsibility.

Essentially, everyone was expecting someone else to do something about the fact that Thorin was losing his mind to the dragon sickness and could not be counted on as an effective leader. In my opinion, the best thing they could have done was locked him in a closet or sat on him until it all died down. But they didn’t, why?

Balin: Balin is actually the one I blame the most as the oldest figure of authority, the highest ranked besides Thorin, and the one Thorin is most likely to listen to. Yet his one intervention along with Dwalin is extremely tentative, they don’t really do much more than ask Thorin to reconsider his madness, which is rather ineffective regardless of whether it’s an actual mental illness or more of a fantasy curse. Asking isn’t going to snap him out of it. My theory is that it has something to do with why Thror wasn’t taken out of power, to whit, some sort of Dwarven law that would see any overpowering of the king, even for his own good, as treason. Historically it’s not unusual for the body of the king to be sacrosanct in such a way that he can’t be removed from power even to help him, and perhaps dwarves have a strict law on this. 

Dwalin: Dwalin tried, actually succeeded, but didn’t do something sooner. Why not? First, as I’ve written elsewhere, I think Dwalin’s friendship and respect for Thorin can never be underestimated, BUT it carries a dangerous double-edge which means his respect for his king keeps him from acting as a friend should. This is more or less explicitly stated between Thorin telling Bilbo he did “what only a true friend would” and the fact that even at Thorin’s darkest moment, Dwalin’s words of comfort are “You were always my king,” which, given that Thorin is caught in delusions of grandeur, may not actually be the most helpful thing to say. Basically: Dwalin couldn’t help because he didn’t realize Thorin needed an equal more than he needed a loyal man-at-arms. Another reason he may not have acted was that he was waiting for Bilbo to do so, explained below. 

Thorin’s Nephews: Simply put, they either weren’t there to intervene at first (I think a deliberate story choice by the script writers, there’s no way they would have let Thorin get that bad without intervening, hence why they were left behind in Lake-town with Kili’s injury). Then, they were probably waiting for their elders like Balin and Dwalin to intervene. When that didn’t happen is when Kili finally explodes, pushed to the edge by Thorin’s VERY OOC decision not to fight at Dain’s side. Fili said nothing because the narrative forgot he existed. They too however were only pushed to act after Bilbo was out of the picture. 

The Company: Fealty, low rank, the fact the movie forgot that Gloin and Oin were Thorin’s cousins? The fact that Oin, the healer, was away for a good chunk and then the movie forgot he was a healer? Narrative convenience? In-story I’d say it’s because Dwarves simply don’t rebel against their king, which meant all of their hands were tied as far as standing up to Thorin’s madness. It’s really the only in-universe explanation that works. 

Bilbo: Bilbo is the most complex one and lies at the center of BotFA. Yet he too was suffering from the bystander effect. As a non-dwarf, Bilbo assumed the other dwarves would do something when their king was so obviously sick. As dwarves shackled by their fealty to their king, the dwarves were hoping the outsider would be able to step in to do what they could not. Over the course of the Quest, Bilbo had become increasingly capable, basically a second leader in getting them out of scrapes. Certainly by the vouching scene in Lake-town, there was some sort of special bond between him and Thorin. However, Bilbo seems largely unaware of all of this. He doesn’t see himself as anything more than “just a hobbit”, certainly not as the one who can intervene when their leader and king is losing his mind. If nothing else, that would seem an obvious job for the dwarves who have known Thorin all his life, not for the burglar who joined at the last minute. 

Most likely what happened was a miscommunication, and the time lost on realizing that miscommunication is when everything went to hell. In the time it took for Bilbo to get up the courage to try to intervene with Thorin (the acorn scene, the mithril shirt scene) outside events spiraled out of control. When Bilbo realizes the dwarves will not or cannot do anything, the situation outside the gate prevents any sort of healing effort and instead demands a political/martial solution from Thorin, who doesn’t seem to know what planet he’s on. Really a perfect storm of bad circumstances. The Arkenstone as a gambling chip really is his best bet with the little power he believes he has. Actually, one can’t help but wonder if this too is a product of Bilbo’s self-doubt in his own influence. Could Bilbo have theoretically stepped up, as an outsider and taken Thorin’s place when negotiating with Bard? Would the dwarves have followed him? Would Thranduil and Bard have accepted his authority? It seems very possible that they would have, especially with Gandalf there as well. 

Well, instead Bilbo is given no choice but to flee for his life (and flee right back into danger once he sees that Thorin has recovered, because priorities). 

This is when the dwarves realize they have to take action. Which is very interesting that they wait so long, because it basically shows as true that they expected Bilbo to do something that they could not, and this forces their hand. However, even in the most dire of circumstances, no one lays hands on Thorin. Again, perhaps the body of the king is sacrosanct. They use only words. Kili is really the only one who raises his voice, even Dwalin stays extremely respectful the whole time during his confrontation. 

TL;DR It’s my theory that the dragon sickness situation got as bad as it did because everyone inside the Mountain was expecting someone else to take action against Thorin. The dwarves have some kind of law against rising up against their king, and Bilbo didn’t realize his power as default leader, and didn’t take that power, instead trying to appeal to other “greater powers” to solve the problem for him. Only once the dwarves’ best chance to help Thorin was gone (though they never informed Bilbo they saw him as their best chance) the dwarves act but in an extremely muted fashion. Perhaps it was events happening too quickly, perhaps it was denial over how badly sick Thorin really was, but the time it took to solve the problem was arguably fatal as a result, despite having Thror as a roadmap.