Chapter Text
experimentalpotion asked: OMG probably my shipping googles are too tight on me but whatever. So Bilbo, while in tent, said that Thorin values the Arkenstone above all else, but wow, during all this angst on the ramparts... like Thorin was hurt because it was BILBO who betrayed him, and as it goes, we all are hurt the most by the betrayel of those who are most dearest to us. And like Thorin´s issue wasn´t more about the stone rather about BILBO, so... um, I think Bilbo was veeery mistaken in his assumptions.
Oh, I definitely agree. The more I think about it, the more convinced I am that withholding the Arkenstone was not the right call on the part of Bilbo or Balin. Of course, they couldn’t alter it, because that’s what is in the book, but here’s my view on why they were wrong:
1) They were diagnosing the wrong person. There’s a saying in military history that you’re always fighting the previous war. Balin had witnessed Thror’s dragon sickness, which was indeed aggravated by the stone, as it represented the pinnacle of his power and wealth. The problem is that to Thorin it also represents the pinnacle of Thror’s power and wealth. I think Balin’s diagnosis is not sufficiently nuanced to realize that the Arkenstone is something totally different to Thorin than it was to Thror and far more in line with a memory of his lost grandfather and his legacy, as well as proof to Thorin that he is worthy to walk in the shoes he has just occupied. Could that too have made him worse? Perhaps, or perhaps…
2) Thorin was being far more torn apart by the fact he couldn’t trust his friends and family than he was by the absence of the Arkenstone itself. Loyalty, honor, and a willing heart was the basis of Thorin’s trust in the people around him, and as someone who has been so often beaten down and betrayed, that trust was utterly precious. It’s the basis of his current self-confidence, now that he can no longer base it off of defeating Azog all those years ago and the name Oakenshield. So long as the Arkenstone was missing, all of Thorin’s most desperately needed emotional support was called into question, and I do believe that made the sickness so much worse.
3) In the absence of trust in his friends and family, Bilbo was the only person Thorin could trust. His only light in the dark, based on the fact that Bilbo with the acorn showed that he had no interest in precious items or worldly possessions. Thorin is shown to be desperately clinging to his trust in Bilbo even as he’s surrounded by the greatest achievement of his life none of it matters because he can no longer trust anyone else near him. When Thorin gives that bitter laugh at “Your claim?” all I can think is that he’s laughing at the notion that 1/14th share, or the Arkenstone itself, could come anywhere near the value he placed in his ability to trust Bilbo. Note that once it is gone Thorin free-falls into the sickness. Until then he was still holding on to himself somewhat, still functional. Despite having a huge win in the form of Dain coming to their aid, his despair is immediate as it sinks in that he lost Bilbo and he goes nearly catatonic on the throne as he hits rock bottom. Trust was far more precious to him than the Arkenstone.
4) He gave it to Thranduil. Thanduil. Thranduil, Bilbo, really?! Oh of course Bard was there too, quite visibly as Thranduil’s lackey against Thorin. Of course we understand Bilbo’s motives and Thorin once cured immediately admits it was the right thing to do, but if someone I trusted lied to me and gaslighted me and then gave the most precious artifact I had of my family and grandfather’s pride to the person I hate most in the world, who literally stood by and did nothing while my people died, I think I would go a little ballistic too. Unfortunately everyone was wrong there, and everyone was right, and everyone had understandable motives, which only makes it a worse mess all around.
So long story short, I agree. Bilbo was absolutely right to use the Arkenstone as the only bargaining chip that could effectively break the deadlock ( though the deadlock itself became irrelevant with the arrival of Dain and then the orcs). However, he was utterly mistaken in the belief that Thorin valued the Arkenstone more than his trust in Bilbo and his other loved ones, as that was clearly tearing at Thorin far worse than the absence of the stone itself.
Part 2
emsiecat answered your question “I hear some people enjoy my meta, and I guess miss it??? So if there’s…”
(You might have answered this before?), how you think things might have gone had Bilbo confessed to giving away the Arkenstone before the ‘public humiliation’ thing happened? Would Thorin have reacted differently? Would it change events from there on
Ok, so here’s the thing, it’s kind of impossible to know. Obviously we have the book and they were never going to deviate on it for that scene (well, except that Thorin is more heartbroken than angry and I will never be ok). But then again, the films did change enough canon (like Azog living) that it is fair to speculate on how things could have fallen out differently given the characters they gave us, and how different they are from the book.
I’m not sure Bilbo confessing to giving away the Arkenstone would have had a much better impact. Even Kili is pretty outraged to see the stone in Bard’s hands, so that I think still would have been a problem and may have fallen out much the same way - the public humiliation isn’t really what made Thorin flip out, it was Bilbo’s betrayal and I don’t think a change of scenery would have done much more than make the whole scene a little quieter, with Bofur still hustling Bilbo out of the mountain.
The more interesting question is, what would have happened if he had given it to Thorin instead of Bard?
Because unfortunately, giving the Arkenstone to Thranduil and Bard in the films didn’t do anything except buy the Company maybe 5 minutes on the battlements, because Dain’s army showed up immediately. Even in the book, Bilbo’s actions of giving away the stone barely have any impact at all. He didn’t know the orcs were coming as well, which would bury all the differences between Elves, Dwarves, and Men literally within minutes or hours of the gesture. So in essence, you don’t need Bilbo giving the Arkenstone away to save their lives.
This is by no means to undermine the heroism of that action, or the care he showed in trying to save their lives, or the cleverness in using the one object that could break the stalemate.
However, as I’ve mentioned elsewhere, I think Balin’s advice is wrong to Bilbo on the Arkenstone. I think he was fighting the last war, he was thinking about Thror’s obsession and how it stole his reason. He was not thinking, could not even begin to comprehend, the extent to which the absence of the Arkenstone only drove up Thorin’s paranoia because it was a symbol of Thorin’s right to stand in Thror’s place. Not having it also stole from Thorin his certainty that he could trust those closest to him. I don’t think necessarily that it would have cured him, he could indeed have gotten worse and become almost catatonic, focusing only on the jewel in his hand.
However, I don’t think having it would have made him more violent or despotic, probably just more dazed like Thror was. If the Arkenstone was a drug, it would be a huge injection all at once, but probably one that would make him more passive because he could now trust those around him not to steal from him, and trust in Bilbo. So I don’t think giving it to Thorin would have been the best thing, and in fact forcing Thorin to confront the lowest depths of his illness once he hit rock bottom after losing the stone may have snapped him out of it much sooner. But I think as far as managing his symptoms and giving him peace of mind, having the stone on hand would have made him more able to rely on his support network of the other Dwarves, and it would have spared him the pain of losing Bilbo (even if that pain is what jolted him out of the sickness).
There’s also the question in all of this: was Smaug right? Or was Smaug deliberately manipulating Bilbo to do the one thing that would drive Thorin even more insane, which is fear and suspicion of theft? It would certainly be more in keeping with who and what Smaug is, it is Tolkien lore that dragons deliberately lie to send their prey mad, and that could have been a textbook example. Why do we suddenly trust Smaug’s judgement on what is best for Thorin?
There’s also the question of whether the Arkenstone has any power beyond the symbolic, which the movie leaves dreadfully vague, and so it’s hard to say if the impact on Thorin would have been much better or worse had he had it in hand.
