Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 28: Thorin is a giant marshmallow (emotionally)

Chapter Text

Hmm, I understand the purpose of the question, and don’t get me wrong, I am 1000% in favor of marshmallow Thorin. 

That being said, I wouldn’t mind using this question to address one thought that’s sort of been in the back of my mind in this regard. Back in the day when it was all Dark Fuck Prince Thorin I would have given anything for more common characterization of Thorin as I saw him: that he is someone who loves his family, battles through his insecurities (not always successfully), is always willing to admit when he’s wrong, is slow to make friends but true to those he has, unforgiving of his enemies, stubborn in the face of adversity. 

More often than not though we saw a lot of abusive!Thorin, dark!Thorin, greedy!Thorin, etc etc based off of a surplus of stereotypes and a dearth of critical thinking/observation (or, hey, people just wrote what they wanted to, which is also fine). So honestly, I could not be happier that we’re seeing more of Thorin’s soft gooey center, especially when it comes to his love for his family and Bilbo.

I guess I’m just wary of the pendulum swinging too far the other way? Of course writers, artists, and fans can interpret fictional characters however they wish, in whatever way is most relevant to them. Far be it from me to tell anyone how to write Thorin or any character. When I write meta I’m mostly ruminating on how I see him, and how I would write him based on these observations. So to your point about marshmallow Thorin I would say this:

Thorin is a marshmallow in the sense that he is someone who feels things very deeply: be it love, loyalty, or betrayal. He is deeply touched by the Company’s willingness to follow him (you’ll notice that even when Balin is skeptical towards the physical and mental prowess of the other dwarves, Thorin neverbadmouths them or shows anything less than respect and faith in them, except maybe once when disciplining his nephews but even that was because they were teasing Bilbo, also a member of the Company). He is clearly deeply affected by Thranduil’s betrayal, no need to go into detail there. And when it comes to Bilbo we see throughout that the hobbit’s actions impact Thorin emotionally, both good and bad. 

However, I hesitate in going overboard on the marshmallow characterization 1) because I take everything way too seriously as you may have noticed :P 2) I don’t want to lose track of Thorin’s strength. He has endured untold hardships with bravery and leadership, he is an incredible fighter, he is tough on the battlefield, he will never relent when facing his enemies (perhaps even when he should), and is part of a warrior culture that he embraces as far as courage and valor. 

Basically, Thorin is a tough, stubborn, angry sonuvabitch, which makes his marshmallow side (which is a VERY private face) all the more endearing, but he does have a very tough outer shell which should not be lost track of. I’ve seen some attempts to make Thorin a blushing, stuttering mess, and while that’s cute and has its place in romcom-y type stories, we’ve actually never seen Thorin blush or stammer at any point in movie canon. Even in the acorn scene with Bilbo he is looking at someone he loves unreservedly, he is not holding back or embarrassed by his affections. Honestly, I don’t think Thorin even knows how to be a blushy stuttery mess, for the sheer fact that as a dwarf he is very direct with his emotions and unlike Bilbo sees no need to mask them when in private. 

I guess I’m just worried about the uke shy bashful characterization that drove me insane when applied to Bilbo may just be transferred over to Thorin, and while I’ll take this characterization over the reverse because it has at least a modicum of role-reversal, it’s just as untrue to the characters as shy!Bilbo and DFP!Thorin was.