Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 27: Dutiful Sons: Parallels between Maedhros and Thorin Oakenshield

Chapter Text

(Written in 2013)

One of the things that struck me while seeing “The Hobbit: An Unexpected Journey” was Thorin’s dual nature. Now, Richard Armitage in an interview (which I can’t find for the life of me) did state that he had set out deliberately to establish a dual nature in Thorin, as he does with many of the characters he plays. In another interview he describes Smaug as sort of Thorin’s dark parallel, that Thorin will become more like Smaug as they approach the mountain. So right there we’re seeing that Richard Armitage in his performance intended to have a bit of a dark side/light side conflict in Thorin, all wrapped up around the issue of the treasure of Erebor. Furthermore, Armitage has also made frequent allusions to the deeper lore of the Tolkien universe, and I wouldn’t be at all surprised if he used some of Tolkien’s other flawed leaders in order to inform his portrayal of Thorin.

It’s important to note here that I’m really only exploring Thorin as portrayed by Richard Armitage in the film, and not the book version as such. They are very different characters with very different morals, and share only a few superficial qualities. Thorin in the books is much more of a treasure hunter, and only really has his revelation about what truly matters on his deathbed. I’m actually quite intrigued to see how the movie will pull off the transition, for their version of Thorin seems highly selfless and only interested in treasure insofar as it benefits his people. The problem comes from whether or not avenging his people’s treasure and pride is really in their best interest.

This is really where I began to see the similarities with Maedhros within Thorin’s dual nature. Though first film has only given us hints so far, Thorin clearly has multiple motivations driving him to reclaim Erebor and it’s mostly wrapped up in concern for his people. But how he looks out for his people contains an inherent contradiction that he doesn’t seem entirely aware of, at least not yet. Thorin is looking out for the wellbeing of his people, and he wishes to reclaim the wealth of his people. This is also tied up in the need to get revenge on behalf of his father and grandfather for their disgrace, exile, and death. The latter two, the need to reclaim wealth and take revenge are very much tied up in the pride of the dwarves. At the moment, Thorin seems to view these as inextricably linked to one another. Yet we know this is not entirely true because of Balin pointing out to Thorin that he has made a good life for the dwarves in the Blue Mountains, the wellbeing of his people is already at least partially seen to. Thorin will not concede the point, because he clearly has a sense of responsibility that demands he do more for them. This is a very Tolkien-esque question – what is the primary concern of a good person and a good leader? To what extent should pride, honor, duty, and wealth be a deciding motivator? While Tolkien consistently writes characters for whom these are paramount concerns, he almost universally comes down on the opposite side. That though heroic characters are defined by these concerns, they would be better off if they were more like hobbits and cared for comfort and personal/community well-being over more abstract concepts of wealth and pride.

As a heroic but flawed Tolkien leader these issues are at the heart of Thorin’s dual motivations. He is at his best when concern for his people and his companions, their lives and not their pride, are in command. He is at his worst when his concern for the wealth, pride, and vengeance of Erebor rules him. And yet even the latter are noble and almost entirely selfless instincts, he is a dutiful son and a dutiful leader. It’s just that sometimes his allegiance to his forefathers clouds his judgment when it comes to the care of the living.

Throughout the Silmarillion we see Maedhros in a similar conundrum. After Fëanor’s death, Maehdros is the de facto leader of the Sons of Fëanor and of various Noldor/Elvish factions over the years. There are many instances where the elves under his care would benefit from settling down, making peace, and reconciling with past enemies. There are even a few stretches of time where they manage to do this. Yet every time this peace is interrupted by the Silmarils, in particular the oath Maedhros and the other sons of Fëanor made to take back the Silmarils no matter who has them, be they friend or foe. Maedhros’s oath to his dead father that he would always seek the Silmarils is a dutiful gesture, by some counts one could even consider it “good” if not for all the horrors that come from it. Furthermore, Maedhros himself isn’t really a bad person and he could be a good leader, if not for the oath.

For the moment, Thorin’s motivations, to see to the wellbeing of his people and retake the treasure of Erebor on behalf of his forefathers, are not in conflict. This will change as they approach the mountain, and come to a head in the very Fëanorian moment when Thorin repudiates Bilbo’s friendship because of a bright shiny stone (it’s quite possible that Tolkien’s parents were murdered by jewelry when he was a child, but I don’t judge). The Arkenstone of Thorin, like the Silmarils of Maedhros, represents the point where the wellbeing of their people is in conflict with their pride. Many dwarves would die for the Arkenstone, and do, as do many many elves for possession of the Silmarils. They choose to of their own free will when they pick pride and the treasure of their people over their own lives. Thorin and Maedhros will also take similarly foolish last stands, with a few of their kin against many enemies, in order to reclaim a jewel that mattered more to their forefathers than it does to them, and which is actively damaging their lives. In the process, they will lose their kin as the darker sides of duty and filial loyalty trump their self-preservation and good leadership qualities.

(As a quick aside, Bilbo provides a very interesting role as the peacemaker by using the Arkenstone to break the détente between Thorin and Bard. It almost makes one wonder if all the terrible events of the Silmarillion would have happened if there had there been more hobbits around. Tolkien consistently uses hobbits as a means to break some of the high flung and ridiculous tropes of heroic tales. They are the least likely heroes, but where they step in they are often able to avoid the fatal flaws that would destroy most heroes short of their goals. Other hobbits too are seen to do this, as if hobbits are Tolkien’s very own self-inserts into the great epics of the past sent to fix things up and get everyone to stop fighting. Anyway.)

TL;DR I suppose my conclusion to all of this is Thorin and Maedhro were both split between filial duty and the leadership of their lost and scattered people. Oftentimes they were unable to see the difference between regaining the pride/treasure of their people and looking out for their wellbeing. When attending to the wellbeing of their people, they are both good leaders, but when they are unable to separate their two motivations we see their dark side and they bring ruin down on everything that truly mattered.