Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 30: Thorin is protective, but he would never keep his loved ones from battle, and here’s why

Chapter Text

I’ve seen a lot of discussions that present the idea that Thorin should not have brought Fíli and Kíli on the Quest, or that he would have kept Bilbo from the battle had Bilbo still been there, or that if he could he wouldn’t let anyone fight at all.

Simply put, guys, that is not true. At all. Thorin would never prevent someone from going into battle in an attempt to protect them, and like many things when it comes to Thorin Oakenshield; the reasons are complicated and desperately sad.

1) Thorin is from a warrior culture, and keeping someone from a fight shows a lack of respect

At the most basic and I daresay admirable level, he would not stop Fíli and Kíli from coming on the quest because he trusts them as warriors. To give them that trust, and then say he would not risk them is the exact sort of treatment Eowyn is rebelling against in The Two Towers: it is would shame them. As heirs to Erebor, and grown adults, they have a right to join the quest if they wish to, and Thorin has no right to turn them away.

Likewise, at no point does Thorin even whisper that Bilbo should not join them in their dangers. His fears, rather, is that Bilbo’s incompetence will slow them down, and get Bilbo killed. Jumping down to save Bilbo from a fall off a cliff, an accident that is a result of the perils of their journey, is not the same as keeping him from danger. Even saying Bilbo should not have come is not the same as keeping him from danger. The choice is still Bilbo’s, because at no point does Thorin order him away, though presumably it is his right to do so he would never impose it.

Thorin does protect people in battle though; he stops them from charging into danger or being slaughtered when the fighting would be unequal. However, he’s a dwarf and a warrior, he would not stop people he loves from fighting in the first place.

The one time he keeps someone from a battle is Kíli, because he is obviously wounded. But he does not present keeping Kíli away as weakness of Kíli ’s fighting spirit; it’s the simple facts of the Quest and the speed necessary to get to the door in time. Fíli, by the way, does try to help Kíli because of his injuries, and Kíli does not appreciate it, as seen when Kili waves him off at the beggining of BotFA for trying to help him stand.

2) The exile taught Thorin not to squander resources

With so few dwarves remaining after Erebor and Azanulbizar, Thorin has learned not to be picky about the resources available to him. He takes “not the best or brightest” warriors with him on the Quest and does not turn away anyone who volunteers, even Bilbo. Perhaps, in large part, because protecting people by holding them back from a fight just isn’t an option when you have so few fighters available to you, (see: Helm’s Deep), and it’s the reality he is accustomed to.

Which, by the way, is as good a place as any to point this out: anyone who hid and cowered in their homes when Smaug attacked is almost certainly dead. Those who took up arms would have at least been in a position to defend themselves, escape, or at least die honorably instead of “cowering and clawing for breath.” Thorin is traumatized by the deaths at Erebor, and holding people back from battle would not have prevented those deaths.

3) Thorin has never been protected, and the one time someone tried he lost them forever.

Thorin grew up knowing he would be king, and being king means assuming greater responsibility. In exile, it meant greater responsibility without very much of the greater privilege that goes with it. Thorin would have learned that he cannot turn from a fight, or from his people in need. Whatever his age was, whether he was a minor or older, he was not kept from Azanulbizar, or from fighting the dragon, and in turn he does not extend this form of protectiveness to anyone else.

What’s worse is this: there was one instance where someone tried to stand between him and a threat, and that was his father Thrain on the battlefield facing Azog. And what was the outcome of that? Thrain vanished, without even a body to be found, and Thorin still had to face Azog, but now alone, without his father by his side, having just witnessed his grandfather’s death. It puts a whole new tragic spin on his freak-out that Bilbo defended him against Azog, because the last time someone did that he lost them forever.

Thorin would never protect someone else by holding them back from battle, simply because it would not occur to him to do so. No one has ever done it for him, and the one time they did ended in one of the greatest tragedies of his life, one that he would not risk extending to others.

Conclusions:

Thorin charges into battle, but he expects those warriors who are willing to be there behind him. If he defends others it is not a premeditated attempt to keep them out of danger, but rather an on-the-spot reflex to keep them from hurting themselves or others (holding back Ori in the warg chase, holding back Kíli when it would hurt him or Bilbo during the troll incident, holding back Dwalin and the others at Ravenhill because further fighting would be suicidal), but whenever he does it is tactical.

Thorin does not even consider the possibility of keeping Bilbo or any of his kin from the battle unless there’s an advantage involved or it is their choice. Even giving Bilbo the mithril shirt was not so that Bilbo could hide behind the walls, it was so that Bilbo could come out and fight with them in armor that suited his fighting style to be light and quick and quiet.

They are adults and warriors. It is their choice to follow him or stay behind; it is their choice to go into battle at all. Thorin would not shame them, he would not give up the resources, and he would not expect anyone to do the same thing to him. The thought of holding others back is unthinkable to him and in his mind it is not noble to do so. The only time he backs away from a fight is when his personality has been turned inside-out by dragon sickness. Only then does he consider not fighting to be the safest way to defend what he values most.

There is one caveat to this, the one time we see Thorin show remorse for the dangers he lead his loved ones into was on his deathbed. There we learn that he’s sorry that he led Bilbo into such peril, but Bilbo reaffirms that it was his own choice. Perhaps, without the need to reclaim Erebor on his shoulders, Thorin could have given in to a desire to protect his loved ones by holding them back from a fight, but so long as Erebor loomed in his life, his protectiveness would neverextend to holding others back from battle, even if he wished to.