Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 31: The Politics of Erebor if Thorin had healed from his dragon sickness sooner

Chapter Text

Anonymous asked: Hobbit Meta: Relationship between mirkwood and Erebor after botfa if Thorin had snapped out of his dragonsickness earlier?

Well here’s the funny thing that I think @madamefaust has said more eloquently than I: his statements about Mirkwood weren’t actually that unreasonable even under dragon sickness. They were reasonably distrustful of Mirkwood, I’d say the others dwarves are a good benchmark for how Thorin would have acted normally. On the wall, for example, Kili still yells at Bard and Thranduil for possessing the Arkenstone. The hostility between dwarves and elves is still there, in fact it has been exacerbated by the fact Thranduil brought an army for… what exact purpose except to take the mountain for himself and its treasure now that Smaug is dead and the Company (along with Erebor’s rightful king) likely dead with him? Regardless of dragon sickness, Thranduil was very much in the wrong in the movie.

The bigger question would be, “how would the relationship with Lake-town/Dale/the Men be different?” Because for me the most hair-raising moment of Thorin’s dragon sickness was when he denied aid to refugees, having been one himself. That was to me the most OOC thing he did, in particular since they too were refugees of Smaug and his actions. The dwarves would rightfully be wary of a larger force and the treasure within, but it was clearly gold sickness that prevented Thorin from working out a better arrangement with them sooner. With the Men on his side, they could have mitigated the threat that the Elves posed. Also Dale was not only Erebor’s ally, but their lifeline for food and other supplies the dwarves don’t produce themselves. As I discussed in this meta post about the politics of the region, Erebor needed a new Dale to make the city what it once was, it was disastrous to do anything but try to woo the Men to the dwarves’ side again. That allowed Thranduil to swoop in with food and begin political maneuverings which, if successful, would cripple the future strength of Erebor. Without Dale, Erebor could never sustain the kind of populace it once had, keeping it a minor regional power instead of the major one it once was. 

So to sum up, had Thorin snapped out of his dragon sickness sooner, he could have gotten the men of Lake-town on his side sooner with promise of money to rebuild Dale, which Erebor needs almost as much as the Men do. The Men on his side would have given him a better position of strength with which to negotiate with Thranduil, but Thranduil vs. Thorin / Mirkwood vs. Erebor / Elves vs. Dwarves would likely have remained just as hostile, but perhaps Thranduil would have actually been forced to negotiate rather than move instantly to saber rattling?