Chapter Text
brglarbaggins asked: About your answer to emsiecat's question: I think that when Balin advising Bilbo to keep the stone from Thorin he might've also been concerned about the political power/kingly rights that'd be bestowed on him. In his state, he might've commanded countless dwarves to their deaths, like azanulbizar 2.0 or worse. Your thoughts?
A fair point, and a very interesting one. However, Dain had already showed up with his army ready to take on the Elves, and unless Thorin lied in the missive and said he possessed the stone, it appears he didn’t need it to get at least one army to show up.
The problem here too is we’re getting into the exact nature of the Arkenstone, and the fact it’s very unclear. Thror didn’t have the Arkenstone when he rallied the Dwarves to Azanulbizar in the movies, he didn’t have it at all in the book when he went there, died, and Thrain rallied the troops to Azanulbizar to avenge him. In that instance, the Dwarves’ respect for Thror is what rallied them.
The movie canon is really unclear about the extent of loyalty it can muster. If we just go with what is stated - getting Bilbo to go down, fetch the Arkenstone and come back would have conferred on Thorin the right to summon everyone who turned him down at the beginning of AUJ in order to launch a head-on assault against Smaug. The book it’s super unclear why they need it except that it’s shiny and valuable and Bilbo has been sent on essentially a treasure hunt (look, I can’t blame PJ/Fran/Philippa for any changes they made to the book because the book is kind of a mess when it comes to motivation and sequence of events, and would have translated very poorly to the screen as anything but a children’s story because wtf is anyone’s plan at any point???)
Lastly, given Thorin’s catatonic state when the dragon sickness hits him hardest, and given Thror’s daze, I’m not sure either of them had the will to launch that kind of assault? Thorin didn’t seem terribly invested in doing anything at that point with the battle outside his door, his only concern was hiding the gold and he wasn’t even taking active steps to do anything about it, just talking about it. Sure the Dwarves may obey him out of fealty even in that state, or Thror for that matter, but you gotta admit “Welp, I guess we have to launch a suicidal strike on Moria because he’s got the Arkenstone now” is a pretty flimsy justification for a war, or anything for that matter, I mean we’ve never actually see loyalty given to the Arkenstone put into effect because the whole thing is kinda bullshit, so it may be Thorin’s crazy levels of optimism that getting it back would have any impact at all.
Yeah, tl;dr They didn’t need the Arkenstone for Azanulbizar the first time, also I don’t think Thorin was in a state to move from the throne, let alone command armies (and that’s kinda fucking tragic in its own right), so I don’t think that kind of fear on Balin’s part would have been well-founded.
