Chapter Text
So after reading linddzz fic “Safe and Distant” I was hit hard by a realization: as far as Thorin knows when he arrives at Bag End, Bilbo has already agreed to come along and it’s only after meeting the dwarves (and Thorin) in person that he apparently changes in mind.
Without delving into the book (because they are separate) we can reconstruct what Thorin & Co knew about Bilbo in advance.
- He’s a Hobbit (“So, this is the hobbit.”)
- He styles himself as a burglar (“Looks more like a grocer than a burglar.” (Thorin plz) - “You’ll need a burglar.” “Yes and an expert one too.” “Well, are you?” They’re not asking if he’s a burglar, they’re asking if he thinks of himself as an expert, his profession his already known.)
- He has agreed to serve them dinner. There will be food, lots of it, and Gandalf will make an announcement while they’re there.
So as far as Thorin knew, Bilbo had already agreed to come along, the contract was ready, and they would depart in the morning. Balin says “It appears we lost our burglar” which assumes that Balin and the others assumed they already had him. As a result, no attempt was made to convince Bilbo to come along, or to use a delicate touch. Quite the opposite, there’s some good-natured ribbing from Bofur about what Bilbo has gotten himself into.
So here’s the question: could some of Thorin’s early animosity towards Bilbo stem from his perceived “fickleness”? If Thorin is already insecure about the success of the quest, and just heard from Dain and his other kin that it’s viewed as hopeless and they will not help him, hearing that he had a burglar and then that the burglar changed his mind as soon as he met Thorin and the Company, and then changed it again would not speak well of the hobbit. Especially from a dwarven perspective, which values constancy and oaths.
In a way, from the outset Bilbo was accidentally set up to fail as far as winning the regard of the dwarves, because he appears to be an oathbreaker and fickle, not to mention disliking the dwarves or not trusting them to succeed, almost immediately. It may just take a long time for Thorin to get over this, since it’s essentially a sucker punch straight into all his fears and insecurities.
So what if we do accept that Thorin had a love-at-first-sight moment with Bilbo?
Well then we have to accept he was almost immediately rejected (granted, he was kind of a jerk too with the teasing about being a grocer).
And he only found that affection again much later, when Bilbo “reaffirmed” (actually, declared for the first time) his faith in the quest, in Thorin, and in Thorin’s people. (can never find the actual gif when I need it)
Linddzz, all credit to you for figuring this out because after poring over this movie for years it literally never occurred to me that Thorin thought Bilbo was already coming along, and honestly IMO that changes everything.
