Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 35: Is Thorin controlling?

Chapter Text

Anonymous asked: with overprotective to the point of almost abusive! thorin, i don't see it at all either?? i will say he does care very much about his family but all dwarves we've seen would be insulted by excessive hovering, even fili and kili imo who want to be seen as adults in equal standing? i don't see him regularly as trampling over people's agency at all.

I have literally never seen evidence of him trampling over other people’s agency, which is why I’m so baffled by that characterization? 

And that was well phrased - dwarves and warrior cultures in general in the Middle Earth movies disdain being excessive hovering or being protected (see: Eowyn, or Kili shoving Fili off for being so concerned with his wounds). 

I think the only times even the slightest case can be made for “controlling” Thorin is when he’s giving orders as a leader (”When you are king, you will understand” he says to Fili after he forbids Kili from coming along - clearly showing that order was AS A KING, not as an uncle) and perhaps when he drags Bilbo aside during the mithril shirt scene (but even that reads to me as someone terrified pulling another person away from people they see as threats, thanks to his paranoia in that moment). 

Otherwise, Thorin is extremely careful about the agency of others “I have no right to ask this of any of you, but will you follow me one last time?” and “Go back to your books…” but also giving the mithril shirt at all is for Bilbo to go into battle, as it would be useless if he left Bilbo behind to “protect” him. 

*le angry sigh*