Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 43: What makes Bilbo tick?

Chapter Text

mostlyanything19 and I had a discussion not long ago where we agreed we have a great deal of difficulty writing Bilbo in fic and figuring out what makes him “tick.” This has been a problem that plagues my writing of Bilbo. He’s a great narrator character and he’s good at moving the plot, and I can easily picture him performing a certain action a certain way, but I’ve never quite been able to grasp his inner workings the way I could Thorin. 

At the beginning of Red Dragon there’s a quote from Alphonse Bertillon that has been on my mind lately, “One can only see what one observes, and one observes only things which are already in the mind.” It got me thinking about why it is that I don’t see Bilbo’s inner workings, because he and I don’t necessarily share them. 

Thorin’s inner motivations are clear to me. I feel them intensely and I can easily conceptualize a mental “3D model” of how he’ll act in certain situations. We say “cream egg” facetiously but it’s fairly apt. A gooey center encased in a slightly less gooey outer shell. Thorin’s emotions are intense and he expresses them freely, though sometimes they are controlled by rigid discipline. He’s stubborn and courageous, and it’s not so much that he doesn’t think well of himself it’s that he has larger things to worry about. 

Bilbo is self-interrupting, and fussy, and proper, and I’ve long been able to express that without truly understanding the internal workings of the character that leads to those reactions. 

Then I got talking to linddzz last night after a few drinks and crying over BotFA and something just clicked. 

“Don’t be ridiculous. Get your head out of your ass,” for all its crudity, is the phrase that makes up the core of Bilbo’s being and actions. Unless Bilbo is overwhelmed by action or there is a clear, immediate and present danger, you can actually see how he constantly stops himself from being… himself. 

(This is gonna be another long one, guys since I’ll be exploring the idea for myself for the first time.)

We see him as a young hobbit gleefully attacking Gandalf with a wooden sword (something I’m sure he’s considered later in life with a real one). He’s joyous, and carefree, and then interrupted. Though Belladonna’s actions are completely understandable there, from the perspective of reining in an unruly child, it’s a pattern that Bilbo would eventually internalize. 

Gandalf is taken aback when he meets adult Bilbo all those years later. Where’s the adventurer, the scholar, the budding anthropologist who wanted to meet elves in the woods and was getting himself into messes wandering the Shire? Something happened to turn him into this fussy homebody, who can’t even look an odd stranger in the eye and actively flees him in the marketplace. Who cares more about dishes and doilies than leaving his home. Who pores over books and maps because he still thinks about the outside world but for some reason doesn’t dare engage it. From what we hear, this is a dramatic and troubling shift. Somewhere along the line, someone took everything that made up young Bilbo and told him to stop doing that. And he’s been stopping himself from being Bilbo ever since.

Bilbo’s facial expressions are extremely unique, and provide us with the greatest insight into what’s going on. He’s self-interrupting. You can see him begin to have an emotion, or several at once, and then school his features to settle them back into something social acceptable. Neutrality, irritation, calm agreement, concern, and worry are acceptable. Extreme joy, extreme sadness or tears, overwhelming amusement, in short, the dwarven emotions, are largely cut off to him because in his society they are ridiculous and excessive and he must consider how he is viewed by those around him rather than express how he feels. (It’s one reason that being around the dwarves is so good for Bilbo.)

The few times we see Bilbo express honest, uncontrolled happiness, for example, are when there’s no one around to see him. In Rivendell, when he wanders by himself and takes in the beauty of this place he’s only ever dreamed of. In Mirkwood, when the butterflies flutter around and he sees the sun for the first time in days. In both instances there is no one there to witness his uncontrolled euphoria, and once back amongst the dwarves he’s all business again. Even when he finally breaks down in tears at Thorin’s death, he only does so once he is truly alone. He can’t even bring himself to cry over the death of comrades in front of others, his self-control is actually that rigid which is, wow, actually really intense.

That is the “Don’t be ridiculous,” part.

Now for the, “Get your head out your ass,” part (though I welcome a better way to phrase this, lol). Notice that despite all that Bilbo has done, he never allows himself to feel his accomplishments or even really acknowledge them (and wow is that a trait he shares with Thorin). It’s never about him – even when it really, really is. “I’m just a hobbit” is constantly reiterated. He’s almost never acknowledged for his great deeds like saving the dwarves and he never brings it up and in fact dismisses himself on the Carrock rather than take credit, even though he just saved Thorin’s life. He never once says “I saved you so many times, you should thank me.” Not. Once. Because that falls under “get your head out your ass”. “Stop thinking this about you, or that you’re so great, or that you should be the center of attention. It wasn’t that big of a deal.”

And you can see him thinking that, that he never tries to cash in on the goodwill he’s built up, he never rubs anything in anyone’s face even though with the number of times he’s saved them he probably could. Even when he brings up the vouching, he doesn’t mention that it’s probably the reason they made it out of Lake-town in time for Durin’s day. He only mentions that his honor is at stake too.

Interestingly, the only time Bilbo reflects on his past deeds and talks them up is when he’s giving his titles to Smaug. Again, clear and present danger forces Bilbo to reshuffle himself in his mind, to become the adventurer and the hero, but he almost seems unaware that he’s doing it, or that what he’s done is noteworthy.

It’s actually most maddening during the period of dragon sickness in BotFA. Bilbo is clearly the person with the greatest access to Thorin’s trust. He is literally the only one Thorin is listening to at all anymore, the only one who can wrestle Thorin back into the light. Yet he’s constantly checking himself, he’s constantly reevaluating his own worth and his own worthiness to take on this challenge. Bilbo clearly believes the other dwarves have the greater wisdom and awareness when it comes to Thorin. They’ve got this. 

They clearly do not got this. 

But Bilbo simply can’t acknowledge that this is all on him now. Because he can’t believe that he is someone that has that kind of power over someone like Thorin. He’s so hesitant and holding himself back when it comes to interfering at all in this clearly serious matter. Even when he finally does take action it’s to get others to intervene, because he’s only a “little hobbit” who cannot possibly sway the heart and mind of the king. 

You even see it in the camera angles when Thorin confronts him about being betrayed. He can barely look Thorin in the face, but if he could he would see that Thorin is honestly terrified at the prospect of being betrayed, he is in fact taking Bilbo into his confidence on a deadly serious matter and he is clearly, well, singularly obsessed with Bilbo. This gives Bilbo immense power when it comes to interacting with Thorin, and he never once puts his foot down and uses it. Even at the gate, his words are entirely styled as a fair business transaction rather than a decision Bilbo has made to intervene, and he persists in believing that Thorin’s anger is over the Arkenstone when clearly Bilbo’s apparent betrayal has hit much closer to home for Thorin. 

Bilbo is not prepared for how intensely Thorin feels about him… pretty much ever in BotFA. Acorn scene, mithril shirt scene, the gate, the death scene, every single one shows Bilbo unprepared for being the center of Thorin’s attention and an important person in Thorin’s life. 

Sorry for the shipper tangent there, but it plays into the fact: sometimes you can see Bilbo begin to question. You can see him begin to consider that maybe he is a big deal, maybe he does have a great deal of power. He always buries it again immediately. He shouldn’t be ridiculous, he shouldn’t believe that he himself is a significant figure. Being more than he is, showing his true emotions, those are all ridiculous. 

Watch the film again. Note all the times Bilbo begins to have a sincere emotion, and then stops himself. Of the few times where we see huge, honest smiles from him there’s no one around to see him. In Rivendell, or at the top of the tree with the butterflies, or even when he’s looking at the One Ring in his pocket at the end in Bag End. Bilbo schools his features for others. Don’t be ridiculous. Outward expressions of powerful emotion are ridiculous and must be controlled. It’s so ingrained that you see the flicker of everything he’s thinking all at once before it’s all suppressed with something safer. Neutrality, or fussy concern, or politeness. 

In a way, it’s what makes his 111th Birthday so noteworthy. Bilbo has finally pulled free of it. It’s been a long road, but he no longer cares about making a scene, or what the other hobbits think of him. He’s ready to be Mad Baggins disappearing with a bang and a flash. This is, arguably, who he has been the whole time, when he’s not preventing himself from doing so. 

Considering this is a lot of how I see John Watson too, I wonder if this may be Martin’s own internal conflict, or type-cast, “every man” characters who really aren’t “every men” at all, who have a heart for danger and adventure that they constantly suppress in order to fit in to their world. As a rather joyful weirdo, it’s never occurred to me to ever control my actions the way Bilbo does, which is why it may have taken so long for this to click.