Chapter Text
(Cross-fandom analysis)
GOD, CAN WE TALK ABOUT RICHARD IN ALL HIS ROLES BUT ESPECIALLY FRANCIS FOR A MOMENT?
Ok, so there’s something very inherently masculine about Richard’s performances.
And I can say this, idk with authority, but maybe with close scrutiny that it imbues a lot of his roles. Look, I’ve been writing intensive psychological character studies of Thorin for a couple years now, one being a fic with over 100,000 words, and most of that based on his interviews more than even the content of the movies, so I feel like I’ve kinda spent a lot of time in that headspace.
ANYWAY
So there’s a difference between “masculine” and “masculine” in my mind. There’s ra-ra, Rambo-style testosterone and explosives and whatever other nonsense that is kinda what men want to be
But the thing is, men are human, right? They’re fuckin’ organic beings just like women and they are as much bound by insane societal strictures and amongst them are, excellently performed by Richard, concern with body image, troubles with intimacy, senses of duty, the need to become more but the inherent conflict within that is maybe wanting something else and maybe that something else being not as ragingly toxically patriarchal. And this is important
Because god fucking dammit is Richard super fucking good at showing the inherent conflict in even (if not especially) the very strongest, most imposing men.
Look, Francis Dolarhyde is frankly tortured by his body. He wants to be this solid rock of literally inhuman muscle, but as I think Richard expertly portrayed, he can’t achieve that. Richard was actually better at portraying Dolarhyde’s pathology with his body than a body-builder would have been able to. Because Richard works out obsessively and yet he still has that bit of padding, that bit of softness. And the thing is, he’s criticized the fuck out of himself in “Strike Back” and in other, earlier roles which called for a perfect six pack of abs because his body type literally cannot achieve that. Richard is in fact so fucking perfect at these men tortured by the fact that they do everything right but can’t make up that impossible last 10% that is demanded of men in order to be considered “perfect”. And like women, men are told they can’t be desired, should put off being desired until they achieve something that is literally impossible
And Richard is in fact one of the top most desirable men in the (western) world. Let that sink in for a second. This man still has body image issues.
But back to Dolarhyde. Dolarhyde is a perfect victim of toxic masculinity. What tortures him about his love of Reba, except that it is gentle? He wants to cherish her, he is overawed that she called him “a sweet man”. Not a powerful, strong, frightening man, the desires of the Dragon, but a sweet man. Yet such a characterization is strictly forbidden to that image of masculinity and Richard kills it there. He’s so fucking good like, let me just rant here for a second, he is so fucking good at capturing that divide in the male psyche between wanting to be cherished, and loved, and cared about and for, vs this horrifyingly strict and restrictive view of the killer, the bodybuilder, the man with rough hands and no emotions who should cringe at being called sweet whereas Dolarhyde more or less melts at the thought. Because he’s a human being. He’s a human being who wants desperately, in his own words, to share what he is, what he is becoming. The inherent conflict was when he could not share his ascent into toxic masculinity of biting and murder and (literally) rape without hurting the woman he loved, and he went to exorbitant lengths (within his own head) to make sure that she was separated from the madness, and from him. That she believed he was dead.
The thing is, Richard does this across so many roles. The Crucible is an excellent example of a stomping, snarling figure, literally a dark monolith of a man within the Salem society. Yet what undoes him? His own shame. His wife’s censure, and his own projected image of his wife’s censure of him. He wants intimacy so terribly that years later he’s still tearing himself apart for daring to seek it elsewhere when his own marriage, the one intimacy allowed to him in his society, was falling apart. By the end we see this man crushed and then uplifted by his seeking of intimacy. And yet what also saves him? His willingness, indeed it is imposed upon him but he accepts it, to cast aside the image of the “strong man” who is untouched by anything but reason and iron-clad faith, when he casts those aside he finds his salvation and forgiveness and actualization. In large part, when he forgives himself those roles and finally accepts what matters most to him: the gentle intimacy in his life of the person he cares about most.
One could very strongly say the same for Thorin in “The Hobbit” when his most gentle, real and relatable moments are those murmured words of affection between him and Bilbo, most notably at the end of the first movie, in “the acorn” scene and the “death” scene in the third movie. Richard is uniquely skilled at showing salvation through intimacy. Men who are driven to the very edge of humanity, to unbearable levels of torment and even madness, by their circumstances. By expectations put upon them by their male relatives -Thorin in this case regaining Erebor on behalf of his forefathers even when it’s clear that the mountain is toxic to his existence and identity. Yet he is redeemed by gentle companionship, by his friends like Dwalin, his close relatives like Kili. Perhaps almost-lover, if you believe that interpretation of him and Bilbo (as I do).
This redemption through love is also seen in “North and South” where once again we see a man strictly bound in society’s expectations, seeking the companionship of an equal in Margaret Hale. Like in many of his roles, Richard looks at the actress (and sometimes it is in actor, in other roles) standing across from him as if the sun rises and sets on their word. His greatest torment is that the gruffness of his life and upbringing leave him ill-equipped to express himself to the object of his affection. Richard makes up for this with looks of intensity and adoration that are practically blinding, and he does it across his various roles. He does it with friends and with lovers, to the point where it becomes difficult to extricate the two and leaves many questions as to whether they can be. Richard has a singular ability to show who is the most important person in the life and arc of the character he is playing.
A last word on Dolarhyde, but what was most striking about the finale episode was that even before he spoke the words, a close viewer could see that the Dragon was no longer directly in control. Whatever goodness existed within Francis, the Man, had gained just a bit more power. Perhaps by saving Reba he had done some, and it recasts that desperate struggle for her life and shows him coming out stronger for it. For having spared her the wrath of the thing inside him. Richard had so perfectly articulated the split personality inside his character that we can see when Francis won over the Dragon.
The split between the toxic masculine and the vulnerable, romantic masculine is so striking in Richard’s performances. And it is not feminine, there is nothing about it that speaks to the feminine except that it at times adores the feminine (though not always, there are roles even in Strike Back where the object of his focus and affection appears to be a man).
Richard is an extremely masculine actor, but he goes to a place where most male actors only dabble for the most “bromantic” moments of the script: the place where the toxic masculine fails men. The place where they crave connection, “sharing”, intimacy, touch that is more than a companionable pat on the shoulder. The place where Francis is tormented by the fact his body cannot match the masculine ideal, the place where toxic masculinity allowed Proctor in the Crucible to have an affair and that affair destroyed the intimacy that Proctor really wanted. It is the place where Thorin throws his life away securing the future of a home that literally drove him mad, and is last seen smiling talking to Bilbo of small, domestic things like an armchair, a garden, a home in the Shire. At that moment, it is possible to believe that Thorin would very well give it all up to go back to such a humble home and trade away all the glory the quest has gained, seeing that it was really not what he wanted or needed. It is also the place where John in “North and South” finally bites back his own pride, the pride that will not allow him to speak frankly or shed his arrogance, in order to offer himself to the woman he loves.
“Offering” is another aspect of this. In all his roles, Richard shows his devotion by the act of offering himself. Making himself vulnerable, in some cases literally submissively presenting himself to the object of his adoration. He is a large, strong, imposing man who shows his devotion and indeed even his fear and vulnerability, by offering that which is most tender and easy to hurt and even destroy to the person who can mostly easily destroy it with only the smallest word. He exposes himself to them as a way of silently saying “I love you” but there is a hidden plea in it as well. “Walk gently upon my heart, it is yours”. It is what makes him such an effective romantic lead, why it is right of him to shy away from action roles that will no doubt come his way. Richard’s strength lies very much in his ability to allow himself to show weakness.
I’ve had many thoughts and feelings about Richard’s art, and will most likely have many more, but what is most striking to me is how powerful this man is within his strongest niche, and Francis has (unsurprisingly) become one more character to add to the list of men, not vulnerable men but simply men, who Richard makes shine.
