Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 45: Bagginshield is real because of Johnlock

Chapter Text

Ok, that title’s a bit controversial but hear me out:

It shouldn’t come as news to Tumblr that BBC Sherlock was kind of a big deal. However, as the group that ostensibly “discovered” the show, Tumblr has also already gone through cycles of being jaded with it, finding numerous problems, analyzed and obsessed over it to death. People here are constantly falling in and out of love with the show, if they ever liked it in the first place, but there’s one thing that I think is sometimes missed outside this sphere:

BBC Sherlock was a huge deal in entertainment on a global scale (at least in the English speaking world which is my frame of reference). It’s not just that it did well and launched the careers of Martin Freeman and Benedict Cumberbatch. BBC Sherlock has actually directly changed the course of Hollywood and some of its biggest franchises.

BBC Sherlock has actually had a huge influence on some of the biggest franchises to ever exist: The Lord of the Rings/Hobbit series, on James Bond, Fargo, Marvel, Star Trek, Frankenstein, Shakespeare… huge blockbuster films have borrowed from the cast based on their performance in Sherlock, specifically in order to reference them as was the case with Andrew Scott as C in James Bond, or Benedict as Khan or Dr. Strange. (On a wider scale, BBC Sherlock could be widely responsible for this new “British Invasion” where British actors are being cast on a mass scale in American films. The original LotR trilogy had a ton of American actors like Viggo, Elijah, Sean, Liv, etc. The Hobbit had only Lee Pace . Goddamn Spider-man has been cast with a British actor, and I’d argue BBC Sherlock prompted or at least expanded this latest wave of talent search across the pond.)

So given that Sherlock actors are being typecast based on their role in that series, I don’t think it is a stretch at all to say that many elements made Martin Freeman perfect to play Bilbo, but Peter Jackson specifically stated that BBC Sherlock is why he held up production, an incredibly expensive process, just to get Martin specifically as Bilbo. That his performance in Sherlock is part of how he actually planned out how he would use Martin in the film. 

All of this is very old news, but then again we haven’t had the complete extended trilogy to work with until quite recently, and as such have not been able to see the entire intended arc of the films. 

Tumblr will know better than any other site that the homoerotically charged relationship between John and Sherlock is a huge part of the appeal of the series. One may argue that it is the reason that the series took off at all. And even my homophobic dad will point out that John and Sherlock are really, really gay. Like, so much that even the heteronormative gaze thinks something is a bit fishy, at the very least. So PJ and Co. (I’d argue it’s Philippa more than PJ) could not have avoided the fact that part of what made those performances so magnetic was the underlying homoerotic tension. There is no question John and Sherlock love each other, the only debate is whether or not canon has a sexual component, or whether or not it could, or should. 

So basically: you don’t cast Martin Freeman as your main character and deny the fact that one of his greatest strengths is playing opposite someone he has homoerotic tension with, especially if you’re basing your casting off BBC Sherlock. 

Yes, they cast Benedict in it, but I could have told you from when the news first broke that he was never going to be “seen” in the film, because they were going to avoid having John and Sherlock standing opposite one another in any way because it would be too obvious a reference to Sherlock (he would not play Bard, for example, so I wasn’t the least surprised that he was cast for his voice only). If anything, it just further emphasizes how much BBC Sherlock inspired The Hobbit.

Really though, with Martin as the person they moved production for, that means Richard Armitage (as Thorin) was a more flexible choice (and he knew it, going so far as to not unpack his bags for the first weeks because he was so convinced he would be switched out). Which means part of why he was cast was to have chemistry opposite Martin, rather than the other way around. 

Look, Thorin in the book has really only one touching scene with Bilbo, on his death bed. The person who really shows concern for Bilbo’s well-being and talks to him and has any level of friendship with him in the book is Balin, and he was clearly switched out to be the grandfatherly figure of the films. Thorin was even de-aged to give him more in common with Bilbo and not be an older figure. They gave him dark hair even though there was no indication in the books that he was dark-haired, and Richard’s hair and eyebrows are fake in the films, so they could have been anything. Thorin in the book has white hair, and his nephews are blond, so literally they cast Martin opposite yet another tall, dark haired, blue-eyed, intense man on a mission. 

You cast him from homoerotically charged BBC Sherlock in order to bring chemistry and heart to your film, you put him opposite a Sherlock-like figure as much as one can given that Thorin is a warrior king and not an intellectual savant, you have Martin in a scene where he watches this person die and is shattered by it in a way that clearly echoes John watching Sherlock’s “suicide” and funeral in how he broke down at the tombstone, you have them build this rapport over several movies and you tell me, that after all the things that had to be changed to build this relationship which DID NOT EXIST in the book in this manner, that they were clueless about the possibility of Bagginshield? 

To me there are just too many deliberate choices that had to go into the casting and creation of Thorin and Bilbo, with these call backs to BBC Sherlock littered throughout the films, for it to be entirely coincidence. Now I do believe PJ may have not realize just how homoerotic it was (based on some conversations I’ve had with people who worked on the film) but everyone else on it apparently agreed that the homoerotic tension was everywhere reinforced (with a sly wink and a nod, not horror whenever someone brings it up, including prop and makeup people I’ve spoken to). 

Personally, I think Philippa is responsible, having seen BBC Sherlock and understanding it’s popularity (you can’t tell me the woman who created Tauriel wasn’t perfectly aware of fandom and the post-LotR the Mary Sue storm, and didn’t at least somewhat base Tauriel off the fandom’s common model for a woman in the Fellowship) - you can’t tell me she didn’t understand the homoerotic element and work it in just so they could play to Martin (and Richard’s) strengths and try to steal a bit of the magic that made BBC Sherlock so successful, and bring it to The Hobbit. 

Basically, you can’t tell me that the casting and storytelling choices weren’t all deliberate, weren’t heavily influenced by BBC Sherlock, and weren’t at all impacted by Johnlock, or that the creation of Bagginshield subtext was at all accidental.