Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 46: Was Bilbo canonically gay?

Chapter Text

Look, the evidence is there and probably agreed upon by everyone on Tumblr and/or with eyes.

1) Bilbo never married, and in a society with such enormous families and such an emphasis on domesticity, not to mention his own personal wealth before and after the quest, he was quite a catch. Therefore one can assume just by his actions that it is personal choice.

2) This fact is actually confirmed in the apocrypha by this quote where Gandalf explicitly points out that Bilbo avoided having a family, but then can only speculate on the reasons for this in a way that sounds blatantly queer coded, essentially that there was always something missing from his life (adventure, explicitly, love in the form of a same sex relationship which would be forbidden imo implicitly) 

3) Even in the movies we see Bilbo’s alarm at the sight of large families (”My goodness, are these all yours?”) his reference to young people as “sticky” (”Keep your sticky paws off.”) his lack of ever mentioning a woman unless it was some elven maid out of legend or Lobelia, his rival, whom he only discusses with disdain in the movies. You can’t even claim that it’s just because he’s on an adventure that these things never come up, because Sam had barely spoken to Rosie and talked about her quite often. So we can assume there’s no one he has even considered back home. 

And on and on. Look, one of the things you learn in literary analysis is not to impose your own views on a lack of evidence (ex. there is in fact no actual reference to incest in “The Fall of the House of Usher” by Poe, it’s all implicit and assumed based on later readings and derivative works like movies and such). Sometimes it can be really hard to see what’s really there, and I see this all the time in Tumblr meta (ex. there’s no explicit mention that movie Thorin has PTSD in the movies, unlike Frodo who has actual flashbacks on screen, yet many pieces of meta take his PTSD as a given. Likewise at no point do any of the dwarves call upon Mahal in the books or movies and yet it’s the most common popular exclamation in fic (they actually call upon Durin in the movies, as in “What in Durin’s name is going on?”)). 

Ugh, my point is just that it’s annoying when people assume a character is straight until proven otherwise, as I’m sure we can all agree, and it’s annoying when it’s “sexualizing” a character to give them a sexual identity but only if it’s anything other than straight. You’d hear no outcry at all saying that Bilbo was obviously straight, but heaven forbid you mention that he’s obviously gay in the mainstream. It’s about what’s seeing what’s there and what isn’t there. Ultimately, we have no confirmation and likely never will, but equally we have not a single piece of evidence suggesting Bilbo had an interest in women, whereas we have many subtextual mentions of his oddness, bachelorhood, isolation, and other activities which suggest that he’s either some form of ace or queer-coded, even beyond The Hobbit, which is a children’s book I will concede (and therefore can just not have sexuality feature anywhere as a matter of course), but even into LotR which is not and the Unfinished Tales which are written for adults but never published in Tolkien’s lifetime, and which hold the only discussion of why Bilbo remained alone in language that is startlingly queer-coded.

Part 2

The book doesn’t have proof that Bilbo takes any interest in anyone at all, so if one wished to ascribe one the greatest canonical evidence would be in support of him being somewhere on the ace spectrum.

For example, in the Donald Duck comics Donald is the uncle to the three brothers, rather than a father, perhaps because it removes us the question of whether or not the character has ever had sex or has any sort of sex life to speak of. 

In Disney works especially you frequently see parents removed from the scene and mentors replaced with close but childless friends or relatives, as one sees with Bilbo and Frodo, perhaps for the very reason of removing any question of sex from the narrative. That being said, in those narratives you frequently see economics removed as well. The ways money works in Donald Duck with Scrooge McDuck or frankly just about any Disney story is a huge mystery. It’s an even bigger mystery in Middle Earth. What even is the value of Erebor, is the line of Durin the richest family in the world? How does Bilbo make his money before the Quest? What is a gold coin worth in the Shire, if you even had somewhere to spend it? What makes the Gamgees poor and the Bagginses rich within that context? What even are Elves economically? Who does the laundry in Rivendell? Who does the mucky jobs anywhere for that matter? 

Sorry, got off on a tangent, but it’s not uncommon for stories from the 20th century to eschew these points altogether, perhaps because they were politically loaded questions in a time of Fascism vs Communism vs Anarchism vs Socialism vs Capitalism etc etc and so on. It was impossible to insert money into the narrative without making a statement, and perhaps for similar reasons it’s more comfortable to avoid any discussion of sex or race at all (skin color is rarely brought up in Tolkien’s work, except to say Hobbits have brown fingers and to use “Fair” to describe features, which more applies to beauty than color - Likewise in Disney we have animal characters that also avoids the question of race). 

But going back to your point - I think book Bilbo merits a queer reading to at least be considered. But holy hell, movie Bilbo absolutely screams homoromantic, at minimum.