Chapter Text
emsiecat asked: If Bilbo were to stay in Erebor with Thorin. What do you think he would do to alleviate homesickness? Would he even get homesick do you think? How easily do you think he'd take to the role of Consort? Alternatively if Thorin went to the Shire with Bilbo, how easily do you think he'd fit in? Would he become a blacksmith or something else? Would the hobbits be pretty cool with him or suspicious and gossipy and mean at first?
Ooh, this is a very fun one, though I’m gonna say this is pure headcanon because this is rich (and well trodden) ground for every individual writer to explore.
For Bilbo in Erebor, I’m going to try to buck the trend a little bit. Rather than say “a garden” which I think is the most prevalent trope I’ve seen, I’m going to say pipeweed and poetry. Here’s the thing, we actually have book and movie canon for how Bilbo deals with living away from the Shire when he moves to Rivendell. He smokes his pipe and he writes. Granted, Rivendell has gardens of its own (and side note, the characterization of Bilbo as an obsessive gardener is odd to me because we know he has a gardener of his own in Mr. Holman, who Sam Gamgee is eventually apprenticed to before he takes over the work at Bag End himself) so while I think Bilbo treasures a garden I’m not sure he’d obsessively work in it himself.
I’d even argue he wouldn’t get overwhelmingly homesick any more than he did in Rivendell. Bilbo explicitly noted that Frodo was unlike him, because Frodo’s home was in the Shire, whereas ever since the quest for Erebor Bilbo has been relatively rootless for a hobbit. Also, after all, moving to Erebor doesn’t mean he can never go back! I can see Bilbo going back to the Shire with a bunch of dwarven crafts and toys, rallying up his most beloved furniture and heirlooms, formally leaving Bag End to a relative of his choice, and going back to Erebor with most of his homesickness assuaged for the foreseeable future. Maybe stopping back time and again a bit like Gandalf just to check in on things.
As for Consort, I’ll push back a little against that too. I know it’s a popular trope, and I can absolutely see Bilbo picking up some diplomatic duties (chiefly I see him as doing most of the talking with Mirkwood, just to keep the elves and dwarves from killing each other). But we have no canon regarding dwarven queens, co-rulers, or consorts. I think Thorin in this instance is sole monarch and their relationship is quite private, which I think is their preference thank you very much. I don’t see it having very much bearing on politics except insofar as Bilbo is a trusted adviser, basically a family member by marriage at that point, as important to Thorin’s court as Balin or Gloin would be.
As for Thorin in the Shire, I think others have pointed out eloquently that it would take some sort of trauma to get Thorin to settle in the Shire. However, that trauma could easily be that he survives and Fili and Kili don’t, or simply the after-effects of dragon sickness and any injuries from the Battle of Five Armies. He could see himself as, or be seen as, unfit to rule for whatever reason (perhaps rousing a dragon and dropping it on Lake-town’s head?) and abdicate gracefully to prevent bad blood. Whatever the reason it would almost certainly be tied up in his relationship to the kingship. But assuming simple retirement, for example, as a happier reason for him to be there after some period of ruling in Erebor, I’ll answer the rest of the question.
I think blacksmithing would be something Thorin enjoys, but I doubt he’d do it commercially, first because they don’t need the money and second because customers are pains in the ass because it may bring back bad memories of the Exile. To be honest, based on Bilbo’s homecoming? Yeah the hobbits would probably be dicks to them. Thorin would either have to win them over, or go the route Bilbo canonically did in the book, just tough it out until the younger generation grows up, and until then go traveling or otherwise simply bear the stigma of being an odd and eccentric (at best) outsider. Dwarves are an oddity in the Shire after all, very much associated with Bilbo and Gandalf from that point on. I don’t think it would be entirely bleak in the Shire for him, but I think there’d be resistance and their lives would be pretty private unless Thorin deliberately set out to make friends (which I’m of two minds on of whether or not he’d actually do that). I love Shire AU but I go back and forth in my fics on how successful their tenure there is, but then I also go back and forth with Erebor :P Though I think Bilbo is content in Erebor to a much larger degree than Thorin would be in the Shire unless Thorin is somehow traumatized like Frodo and goes there to heal, then I think he’d be content in the Shire in a way that Bilbo is not.
I mean, these are headcanons more than meta, and basically I’m happy to pick any position when it comes to exploring the aftermath in a fic! After all, how good and bad things are is a great source of tension ;)
