Hab einen wundervollen Tag my Mega Love <3

Mit freundlichen Grüßen
Das AOK-Team

 

Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 49: Would Bilbo be better at destroying the Ring than Frodo?

Chapter Text

 

experimentalpotion asked: Do you think that Bilbo and Thorin would make better ring-bearers on the mission of destroying the ring? After all Bilbo did manage to let it go, while Thorin was the first Durin who did manage to fight of the dragon sickness. If we look at Boromir and Frodo, I´d say that Boromir sort of just snapped out of it without putting a fight, and in Frodo´s case it was Gollum, who took the ring from him, at that brought him to his senses, but with Bilbo and Thorin it really did take a strong will.

Definitely will-power broke both Bilbo and Thorin free (though we don’t know for certain if other Durins have escaped dragon sickness). In fiction I generally avoid writing Thorin and Bilbo doing the quest instead of the Fellowship ( missmithen has my eternal respect and awe for tackling an LotR AU in “Clarity of Purpose”) but if I must speculate…

There’s a few factors involved here that should not be discounted as far as the One Ring’s effects:

1) By the time Frodo did his quest, Sauron’s power had increased exponentially. It may not even be that Frodo was weaker than Bilbo, but rather that the Ring was stronger than when Bilbo bore it. 

2) The Ring’s seduction seems to be cumulative. Just because Boromir broke out of it one time, does not mean he could have done so again and again. It seems a bit of roulette, with the odds stacking against your favor every time. I love Boromir, but I don’t think Frodo was wrong to split the Fellowship then. Clearly the Ring’s power had grown to the point where Men were hearing its call too strongly, and even Galadriel had difficulty letting it pass her by. 

3) I can’t for the life of me find the quote, but Aragorn explicitly says at some point in the books that were it his choice it would be he, Gimli, and Frodo going into Mordor, or something like that. The reason being that dwarves are more resistant perhaps even than elves to its domination. Not only is Gimli never tempted, he is the ONLY person at the Council of Elrond who is even able to take immediate dramatic action to destroy the Ring. Everyone else there is already too much under its spell.

So I actually think that Thorin as an honor guard for the Ring, as a dwarf, would be a strong choice. I think the Ring could have gone long undetected in Erebor for that reason too, that the dwarves are stubborn against its call. However, I wouldn’t blame Frodo for being weaker, he had to deal with it at full power, which Bilbo did not. If the Quest was done many years sooner, then yes it’s possible Bilbo and Thorin would have done “better”, but that’s more a factor of the power of the Ring than individual will power I think, at least when it comes to Bilbo and Frodo. 

Part 2

grimapparitions asked: After reading your latest chapter about Bilbo taking the ring to Mordor, it feels so..right in a way, that Bilbo be the one to take it, not Frodo, and Thorin go with him to help him through the madness , because he knows all to well what its like. Gah, I had more feelings but im garbage at writing things down,now im off to find some Bilbo takes the ring fics, lol. Love you and everything you do, ta

I’m going to publish this because it got me thinking? I think the feeling has to do with “story shape”, in a way, not exactly structure but the way that stories “feel” right or wrong?

Tolkien himself wrestled with who would be the protagonist of Lord of the Rings, I’m pretty sure he did take a stab at versions where it was Bilbo but I don’t remember what stopped him. (There was also a point where the “Strider” figure in Bree was supposed to be a hobbit called “Trotter” who would lead the younger hobbits on their adventure and that was at one point possibly going to be Bilbo too.)

I feel like the films made the question of “Why wasn’t it Bilbo?” more apparent with their tone. “The Hobbit” book is a children’s novel, it does read as a bit silly, so you do want a different protagonist taking on the big Epic Quest later down the line. And who is it going to be? Well, it has to be someone Bilbo would give the Ring to, and since Tolkien interestingly decided it wouldn’t be a son (hmmm…) it became a nephew (technically cousin) and I’m sure after that the whole timeline slotted somewhat naturally into place with it needing to be many years later. Keep in mind too, that when Tolkien wrote The Hobbit the ring was just a magic ring. The author himself didn’t “discover” until much later that it was the One Ring. So since in the films this information isn’t just known but highlighted, it dramatically changes the tone of the films as well and again, sets up a Quest that’s a lifetime away from being fulfilled.

Furthermore, in the films they tried to make Bilbo’s story match the tone of Lord of the Rings so it felt like a more natural prequel than the book does. And that kinda leaves you with the question, why wasn’t it Bilbo? Why did it take 60+ years (even more in the books) to figure out what the Ring was? And also with the film they enlarged the theme of corrupted items like the Arkenstone. I mean, clearly Tolkien didn’t really see the dwarves in The Hobbit to be the makings of a Fellowship-like group, because he didn’t see them as particularly noble, but the movies also highlight their nobility and characters so you’re left with an even stronger sense of “Why couldn’t some of the dwarves have gone to Mordor with Bilbo?” especially given their resilience to the Ring’s corruption (Gimli is canonically the person most trusted to get Frodo through Mordor if it came down to it because of this resilience). 

There was also the powerful theme of madness in the films (again, not really present in the book in regard to Bilbo and even Thorin’s isn’t necessarily explicitly an illness the way it is in the films). You’re left with this powerful parallel of Thorin returning home and being driven mad by the Arkenstone, which Bilbo and his family save him from, and then with Bilbo going home with the Ring and being saved by…. Frodo and Gandalf, years and years later. In the film structure it feels like there’s a missing step, and it’s so bleak to consider that he had no respite from its influence until he was old, and no apparent companion until adopting Frodo. 

Thorin lives, and is the one to help Bilbo overcome his own madness and corruption its parallel form, while destroying an item of evil and saving the world just feels like a natural next step to the relationship and plotlines the films set up, whereas it’s left a little bit dangling as it is? Certainly I’ve made references to the Ring in fics that were meant to parallel canon and received a ton of comments saying that the reader wondered why destroying the Ring wasn’t the next natural step? (In my case, it’s just because the Lord of the Rings is FREAKING HUGE and I think it’s fine as it is, so let’s just change some of the stuff leading up to it but not force Maggie to re-write Tolkien’s tome, shall we? :P)

Thanks for this message, it was really interesting!

For those curious, the drabble we’re discussing can be found here. 

And while we’re discussing fan-written “Bilbo takes the Ring to Mordor” quests, the best one I know of is @mithen‘s “Clarity of Vision” series.