Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 51: Would Thorin have been a happy ruler? (fanfic trope commentary)

Chapter Text

So I just had a weird thought, and I know I’m one of the worst perpetrators of this, but are there any fics out there where Thorin just really enjoys being king of Erebor?

I mean, I know with the dragon sickness and so much of his life being on the road, the general fanon is that he’d have some discomfort in the role, even if he was competent at it. That the work load would be unbelievable and maybe for one reason or another he’s unsuited, or dragon sickness just soured the whole idea of kingship for him. It fits with the themes of PJ’s Middle Earth that almost all rulers we see are reluctant, and it fits a lot with the inner tragedy and dourness of Armitage’s portrayal. 

But honestly it’s almost gotten to the point in my mind where Thorin having unreserved joy at the day to day of being king is the bigger twist. And I can think of a few reasons that would be the case:

- Most of his stress in life probably came from lacking the resources to care for his people, or earn them the respect they deserved. Having the treasury once again at the disposal of Durin’s Folk would probably be a huge relief. Being able to throw money instead of toil at a problem would probably feel great!

- Thorin is demonstrably a pretty inspiring leader when shit isn’t going pear-shaped and just generally stressing him the fuck out all the time. He seems to really love his people too. Maybe being in a position of strength instead of impotence wouldn’t just be a relief but actually actively enjoyable for him.

- Dwarves are pretty chill dudes?? Between the Company and Gimli and Dain’s enthusiastic welcome, I see a lot less murderous backstabbing than I see a bunch of joyful hardworking badasses who enjoy the pleasures of life. Maybe there wouldn’t be any politics making his life difficult, if anything I can’t help but think the dwarven population would be super supportive??

- Sure Erebor is haunted and dusty and full of death, but the 13 dwarves built a goddamn ramparts in like 6 hours, one can only imagine what a large group could do in a few months. His home has been ruined, but they really could probably bring it back to full shine in a very short time, and it would be far less creepy once it’s full of life again.

- Presumably, in an Everyone Lives AU, things turned out pretty ok. Maybe instead of brooding over it, Thorin would actually be relaxed and elated?? The best case scenario worked out? Things are looking up???