Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 52: The Symbolism of Bilbo Burying the Acorn in Dale

Chapter Text

Anonymous asked: What are your thought's on the scene where Bilbo is planting the acorn? Do you think that when he says "it's a promise", it can be another parallel to kili giving Tauriel the rune stone ("keep it as a promise")? I ask this because I love your metas, I hope it isn't a bother. Thanks!

Aaw, thank you Anon!

I confess, when I first “heard” about the acorn burying scene, I was really heartbroken and against it and hoping it wouldn’t make it into the movie.

That was because the description of it was very dismissive of the acorn scene between Bilbo and Thorin. The description just said that Bilbo buries it in Dale as a gift to the Lake-towners, and it was very “wtf” because he had promised Thorin he would bring it home and use it to remember all the dwarves and the adventure by.

What the early description didn’t include was that Bilbo buries it during the battle, when he’s convinced he’s going to die. Which puts a whole different spin on it. I’m still slightly glad that it wasn’t shown, because I prefer the idea that he buried it in the Shire (and maybe it’s the Party Tree). It also puts a spin on the Death Scene that I’m not in huge favor of, with Bilbo having already planted his tree in Dale, convinced he was going to die, when Thorin asks after it. (Or maybe it strengthens it, because Bilbo always saw himself as dying, but thought it impossible that Thorin ever could.)

But more I kinda wish it had made it into the movie because it was a great character moment, and the movie thrived when it was showing character moments and kinda sucked when it was focusing on action (unless it was dwarves kicking ass, but I’m biased).

Bard’s words in that scene about seeing no hope and no way out could easily have come from Thorin (Bard and Thorin have many parallels between them, it’s a shame they didn’t get along), and on some level I kinda feel like Bilbo was reacting as if Thorin said them instead of Bard? Not to take anything away from Bard’s character, but Bilbo’s actions were very much in line with the how he reacted whenever Thorin felt hopeless (like when they couldn’t find the keyhole, or in the Mirkwood dungeons). His kneejerk reaction is to fight back against despair, which I think is the essence of hobbit heroism. Not blind optimism, but rather framing and contextualizing despair to make it lesser, to point out there is a world beyond suffering and that fighting against evil is not in vain.

Bilbo buries the acorn to remind them that life will continue beyond them, that there is hope. He had told Thorin he would look at it to remember “the good, the bad, and how lucky I am that I made it home.” Burying it there, Bilbo can look at it “the rest of his life” which at this point looks like it will be quite short. But that also contextually means he’s looking at it and remembering the Quest, then and there, and his hope of life. It could mean not that he sees that as the place he’s going to die only, but it could be read that he now sees Dale and Erebor as his home. He has made it home, and he’s going to fight for it. It could mean that as he looks at he’s thinking of Thorin and the Company and the Quest, the good as well as the bad. That this is the image he’s taking with him into the dark (much the same way Thorin took Bilbo’s face, and the memory of their conversation about the acorn and Bilbo’s first pledge that he would help them get home).

And this may be extrapolating too far, but at this point think of it: Thorin is still buried within the mountain and will soon spring forth healed of his sickness, like the sprouting from the ground. And given who he last spoke to about the acorn, I can’t help but think that Bilbo is thinking of Thorin when he buries it, and his hopes for the futures, of who will survive the battle, of who is still shut away safely waiting to come forth, even if Bilbo should fall in the attempt. Even if all hope is lost, Thorin is buried somewhere, safe, and when he comes out it will be reminder of life, the good and the bad, and how lucky it is to be home.