Chapter Text
I think there is some logical basis for the idea of misogynistic dwarves from Tolkien himself, and his writing about how female dwarves are few and must be kept within the mountain for their protection. Meaning, if another writer runs with this idea in a thoughtful way, I’m hardly one to judge them because there is source material to back them up, and there is potential for well-written drama and intelligent criticism of the real world if one utilizes this interpretation. However, if it is used lazily or just as a trope to make Thorin into a bad guy then that’s their decision but I will definitely not read it.
As for Thorin keeping women out of the Company, I would actually argue against that on one point: Thorin never criticizes anyone in the Company, even when he appears to be criticizing Bilbo with the fall off the cliff what he really says is, “He’s been lost ever since he left home.” (Projecting much, Thorin?) Thorin never says that someone else can’t join, unlike Balin he never makes snide remarks about the worthiness of others in the Company. In my opinion, Thorin is just so damn flattered when anyone decides to join that he can overlook just about anything. His concern with Bilbo was that Bilbo would get killed, or that Bilbo’s waffling about whether or not he wanted to be there would make others give up on the quest too (not to mention what a blow to Thorin’s pride it must have been to have someone not really sure if they wanted to be there, and whining about it constantly when it’s basically the biggest goal of his life). So I’d actually disagree about Thorin keeping women from the quest or anyone on any basis, other than if they were physically going to get themselves killed or endanger others. He brought Ori, for goodness sake, without any complaints, I don’t even think lack of physical prowess or “dead weight” is an issue, so much as a lack of willingness, that is what Thorin is trying to avoid, if that makes any sense.
But going back to the gender thing:
The fact is, we only see Thorin interact once with a woman in the movies, and never in AUJ (which is when a lot of the fandom characterizations about him were developed) - and that’s the waitress in the Prancing Pony to whom he is unfailingly polite and definitely does not make any gesture or indication that he sees women as people who must be hidden or contained.
From that I would personally derive that even if it was 100% canon that dwarves believed their own women must be sheltered and hidden (which I have trouble believing in the context of Gimli’s female friendships like Galadriel and Eowyn), it would be in my opinion that exile and exposure to the wider world means that 99% of dwarves totally get that other races don’t face their reproduction problems and therefore would be intelligent enough not to hold others to their standards.
However, even that is an extremely conservative reading, again based on Tolkien. In this instance, I prefer when talking dwarven gender to run more with Pratchett, who was very well-read in Tolkien lore and, standing on the shoulders of giants, took dwarven gender to a natural and well-thought out conclusion, which is that dwarves have a type of misogyny which is actually extreme egalitarianism. They are all just dwarves, only “male” insofar as how they appear to the eyes of the outside world, only “female” when it comes to the bearing of children and even that doesn’t appear to have any further gender role tied up in it, as the bearer is still just a dwarf. There’s actually no real confirmation in Discworld that the dwarves who eventually rebel and decide they want to start wearing feminine clothing are necessarily even female by Human standards of genitalia, they may have simply decided they want to enjoy the gender binary (forgive me for any callous language here, it can at times be challenging to discuss gender in a fantasy environment, and with fantasy races and cultures like the dwarves who have no real-world equivalent really).
Personally, I see no reason why dwarves would be sexist, because I truly don’t believe that the “smaller female population” is locked within the mountains. I believe there’s some misunderstanding there, either that currently pregnant dwarves choose to stay in the mountain (when that is an option, which it was not during the exile) for their own protection. I believe that male and female dwarves really are indistinguishable and there’s no reason to believe that a good portion of the Company isn’t “female-by-Human-standards”.
Going to the competence kink, I would also add that in this regard, I think that sexually minded dwarves are probably “bisexual-by-Human-standards”, again, that your genitalia plays very little in to who they are attracted to given their gender culture, it’s just a happy accident whether the couple can conceive children together. Basically, it is also very much Tolkien canon that dwarves are attracted to the great works and competence of other dwarves, so I think Thorin for example would be super turned on by Bilbo’s competence, and as an aside that there’d be no real issue one way or the other what his gender was.
That being said, I think there’s a more compelling case that the Shire is heteronormative, and if either of them is struggling with homosexuality it would be Bilbo. Again, I can read this any number of ways, from homosexuality being open and welcome in the Shire, to it being accepted but kept somewhat quiet, to it being a major taboo that Bilbo struggles with as per the historical time period in England that the Shire is based on (early 20th c.). Bilbo himself however is the son of the adventurous and “remarkable” daughters old Took, so I personally do not see Bilbo as misogynistic, or having any issue towards adventurous women. The one issue I can potentially see is that he may struggle with his own lack of interest in women and having a large family, which would be more unusual and isolating in the Shire. Then again, he may be totally at peace with it and be seen as a favorite uncle by everyone because childless couples have their own niche in Shire society *shrugs* Tolkien doesn’t really go into this, so I consider it free for interpretation by writers, even if I personally prefer that they put some thought into it.
