Chapter Text
thecosmosknowsitself asked: What do you think LGBT is like in Hobbit culture vs Dwarven culture? I think about this a lot
I think this is definitely a place where we need to invoke “Death of the Author” - Tolkien likely saw no reason to even bring up homosexuality in Middle Earth because all his fantastic races are basically Biologically Catholic, and I imagine that’s 99% his own British propriety and him squirming at the thought of having to elaborate on the sex lives of anyone let alone his creations, rather than the kind of post-Tolkien sci-fi/fantasy world building that we are all used to. For the best extrapolations I’ve ever seen on the sex lives of Dwarves, for example, see Terry Pratchett, who is a post-Tolkien fantasist and does think things like “If we say the men and women are indistinguishable to outsiders, what does that mean on a cultural level?” whereas for Tolkien I think it was just, “I’m disinterested in writing Dwarven women.”
Now, to my theories, which I mostly employ for the purpose of writing fanfic:
Now, going with Death of the Author, I still tend to put Hobbits mentally in a sort of proper British society at the turn of the 20th c. If homophobia exists in Middle Earth, it’s probably there and maybe amongst certain groups of Men, though not all. It’s interesting to note that without actual Christian influences, which Middle Earth does not have beyond the morality of the author, and more importantly without a Puritanical movement you actually have a much wider acceptance of homosexuality in most cultures. Look at Roman culture, for example, where it was simply a norm.
In many instances, the purpose of marriage in a society is to determine inheritance and heirs, marriage was more of a business transaction historically than something one did for love, and I could see that being the case in Shire culture.
Which is my elaborate way of saying: I tend to write hobbit marriages as being between one man and one woman because we have evidence for it in canon. However, I believe there’s a broad range of acceptance levels that a fanfic author could reasonably assume based on the type of story they want to write. Someone who wishes to write a story about Bilbo fleeing homophobia (because he is clearly gay, in my opinion, just looking at the Unfinished Tales and all sorts of implied queer readings with his oddness and the fact he never marries, it’s absurd to me to think he is heterosexual if he’s any sexuality at all) could easily do so by having the Shire be extremely homophobic. However, since we have no actual homophobia in the story I could just as easily take the fact that Sam, Frodo, and Rosie cohabited (cohobbited?) and raised their children together as a sign that polyamorous relationships are actually the Shire norm, I mean just look at the Buckland cousins and all the co-raising that goes on there. The nuclear family is actually not in strong evidence in the Shire so much as we see the village mentality of big families living together almost tribally, so you could equally have as wild and free loving a society as you wished, if you were thus inclined as an author. I like to think Bilbo didn’t marry in part too because he was the product of a great romance, and couldn’t see himself settling down into a marriage of anything less, even for the purpose of having children as would have been acceptable in his society even without love. And in that instance I can easily see homosexual marriage being a thing in the Shire as much as anywhere else.
TL;DR - Hobbit society can be anything the author wishes, in my opinion, ranging from Puritanically restrictive to free-loving polyamory as the norm. Personally though, I still like that against a backdrop of prissy fussiness against public displays of affection because Bilbo’s own self-censoring of emotion as part of his society is a huge part of who he is.
As for Dwarves, you cannot, in a million years, convince me that Dwarves would have a problem with homosexuality.
I always pull a face when the fact that Thorin can’t marry Bilbo because of homophobia is the conflict of a story. It just doesn’t make any sense to me and seems gratuitous and designed to make Dwarves into bad guys. Let’s look at what we know:
- The Dwarven gender rate according to Tolkien is horrifically unbalanced, with only 1/3 of dwarves being biologically female and according to him they prefer to remain within the mountain as a result. Even when a man and woman find each other and fall in love mutually, which many don’t, they don’t necessarily have kids. With such a shortage of women you can’t even begin to convince me that Dwarves wouldn’t also seek love amongst the same sex.
- Even if we accept a version of fanon or later Dwarf lore like Pratchett that dwarves have a 50/50 gender split, and it’s only outsiders that can’t tell the difference, you can’t tell me this is a society that puts a ton of emphasis on outwardly heterosexual couples. In such a world I can only imagine that gender and procreation capabilities are an extremely personal matter and no one’s business but the couple’s. Personally, I’m of the headcanon that the reason dwarf women are so rare is because only 1/3 of dwarves identify as female, and that has nothing to do with genitalia. We do have the bathing scene with the fountain to say that dwarves don’t have that much modesty with each other, but we also have them wearing a lot of layers that could say the opposite. Maybe they’re like Men where some are modest, and some are not (I didn’t see Thorin at the revelry, for example). If women are given a hard time amongst Men, then there’s a perfectly sound reason why dwarves would hide the number of women they have, and that they’re scattered about the populace at the same rate of 50/50 as Men, if only to avoid the hassle of other race’s cultures.
Since Dwarves were technically built on the Elven blueprint, and Elves too don’t overly distinguish between male and female, a case can simply be made that they don’t put much stock in gender as determining one’s role in society. In appearance Elves are quite androgynous, in book and movie in my opinion, and there’s nothing really barring women from taking up any craft that Tolkien names, it’s just his own bias that the warrior women are rare, though many of the greatest Elven heroes are female. So I can equally see Aule simply “improving” on the design, or seeing no reason in the first place while the gender divide should have anything to do with one’s station in life.
ANYWAY, TL;DR - However you slice dwarven gender breakdown and politics, I can’t in a million years believe they would be homophobic and in fact I will bet that many if not most Dwarven relationships are homosexual if the gender breakdown Tolkien gives us is true.
That being said, I also go with the idea Dwarves are racially monogamous, maybe not exclusively because they are living beings after all, but dominantly so. Which brings up the question of how many of them are virgins even later into life…
