Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 58: How would Dwarves react to the Shire? (headcanon)

Chapter Text

freakinamask answered your question “I hear some people enjoy my meta, and I guess miss it??? So if there’s…”

Dwarven perceptions of family (both as a unit and as like a bloodline thing) vs Hobbit ones and how the actions of the Sackville-Bagginses towards Bilbo are viewed by each culture (pretty please)

I think in a word: extremely confusing. 

So we don’t have a ton to go on as far as how Dwarves view their families from within in quite the same way that we do with Hobbits, in part because Hobbits seem more based off of real people in Tolkien’s experience so we can kinda just look to early 20th c rural England for a lot. Also because the first 50 something pages of LotR is all about Hobbit culture. Dwarves, on the other hand, are kind of more out of the Norse epics with fealty and clans and sister’s-sons. 

So on the one hand, we have Thorin asking for help from his relatives and them turning him down, on the other we have the fact that thing he was asking them for was to face a dragon that had wiped out a civilization. So their refusal is kinda understandable. In the books, the battle of Azanulbizar was basically fought because Azog killed Thror (rather than something that happened during the battle) and as Thror was seen as a father figure to all dwarves, they rallied to avenge him and there was an extremely close paternalistic bond there. The book also has Gandalf advising Thorin not to raise an army, hence why they go in secrecy and stealth, rather than a refusal on Dain’s part. So in Tolkien’s books I think it’s safe to say that Dwarves are pretty much always there for each other without question, in the movies it’s a little more negotiable but their bonds of loyalty are clearly strong to a fault, where they refuse to disobey Thorin as their king even when he’s clearly unsuited to rule. 

Which is my very roundabout way of saying that I think Dwarves would be extremely baffled that there are blood ties between Bilbo and the Sackville-Bagginses, and yet that family would try to steal from him. I think however though, the shear size of Hobbit families and their interconnectedness would be baffling. Blood ties may be simultaneously more important to hobbits and less, because there’s so many hobbit relatives it would just stand to reason that you can’t be friends with all of them?

However, there’s also the fact that Dwarves are very much “with each other against the world” and they have been since they were created, a race they are pretty cohesive (except for maybe inter-Clan rivalries and if you go back far enough there’s the Petty-dwarves to consider and how they were ostracized). We only really see Hobbits as a large group within their own environment, but once they’re out in the world they’re stick together closely. Once invaders come into the Shire in LotR, even Lobelia stands up to them and is embraced by the Hobbit community as a hero. We see a lot of their infighting because in their homogenous society there’s a lot of petty conflicts and sniping, but faced with a threat they’d probably form a unified front, just as the Dwarves have had a mostly unified front since their creation. Perhaps if we got down deep into Dwarven society we’d find there’s just as much rivalry and competitiveness, we just don’t really see it. In that light, maybe Thorin and the others wouldn’t really be shocked at all. 

Obviously, Bilbo takes sniping and infighting with relatives as a normal part of life, but I think perhaps if properly framed someone like Thorin could understand that this is generally harmless and normal (after all, Bilbo was extremely baffled at the ransacking of his house, so that was not a normal or expected occurrence) and who knows, maybe within their own society it’s similar?