Chapter Text
ok so like ive been thinking,,,, where does this hobbit movie fanon thing come from that dwarves are Super Good at dealing w/ mental illness?? like in the movies the dwarves’ literal response to the gold sickness is “hey thorin :/ that’s .. not entirely cool but we’re not gonna do anything about it.” like. they had no plan to help thorin, at all, they just sat around and waited for him to pop out of gold-sickness. and you can make an argument for hobbits dealing badly with mental illness (see frodo’s choice to ditch shire life because he could never quite fit back in with his physical/emotional scars) but dwarves? ?? idk man
IMO if I had to guess… it’s wish-fulfillment on the part of the authors, which is pretty rampant in any fandom and often has nothing to do with the observable canon. Another possibility is that discussions of LGBTQA+ lifestyle with an emphasis on genderqueer and trans* became more common on Tumblr around 2013, the same time as the Hobbit AUJ came out (at least, that’s when I observed it becoming more of a common topic). This rise, combined with Gimli’s comment in The Two Towers that dwarf women and men are indistinguishable (which is backed up by Tolkien and Pratchett), led to widespread headcanons that dwarves were far more accepting of gender and sexuality. At the same time it was also a common trope for AUJ fics regardless of ship that Bilbo came from a more rigid society with regards to gender and sexuality, and found freedom in the ability to express his true self around the dwarves. Given that being understanding of sexuality, gender, and mental illness are often intertwined on Tumblr as values, it’s possible that when giving dwarves an understanding culture towards gender and sexuality, mental illness crept in too.
However, I would say I agree, I think at least as far as PJ’s movies go, they have a lot more in common with the Klingon culture with its fixation on physical prowess if anything. The closest in-movie example I can see of dwarves dealing with mental illness would be their treatment of Bifur, but that could be argued that dwarves are good at dealing with battle-related injuries like amputation, missing eyes, or embedded axes to the skull. Btw, it’s worth noting this is totally divorced from Tolkien’s actual works, where Gimli isn’t nearly as gruff or buffoonish, and is noted for being a steadfast and supportive friend who I think would be much better at dealing with mental illness than his movie counterpart.
As I’ve noted in a bunch of my dragon sickness meta, such as this one, the dwarves really, really do suck at helping Thorin with his dragon sickness. Even Dwalin who arguably does the most to snap him out of it still calls Thorin “King” when what Thorin really needs is a friend. Balin basically admits defeat from the beginning. There seems to be a pervasive culture where even mentioning that the king may be ill is taboo. No one seems to have done anything about Thror for similar reasons. Maybe it’s limited to monarchs where their word is law so their mental illness can’t be treated or even acknowledged, but given the physically-focused nature of the dwarven culture portrayed in the films, this is my very long winded and rambly way of agreeing with you that while it’s up to the author in fanfic, as very good case can be made that dwarves are really inept and uncomfortable with dealing with mental illness.
It’s a very interesting point you raise!
