Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 62: Dwarves and their "One" - Linguistic Criticism

Chapter Text

Anonymous asked: Your opinion on the Dwarves have Ones trope

Ugh *massages temples*

So basically - I hate the term, but I recognize its utility. We have Dwarves which are a non-human culture, one that we presume is widely culturally if not geneticallymonogamous or asexual. (This is also true of Tolkien Elves, by the way, perhaps more so, and yet you never see the “One” trope applied to elves in Tolkien fanfic.)  So yeah, as a writer, when you are writing non-humans who accept one love in their lifetime or none at all, it makes sense that they may have a unique term to address this. I’ve even been tempted to use the term in this context.

What I don’t like is the word itself. We have so many gorgeous words with long, rich histories in English that convey the same idea as the (rather juvenile and inelegant, in my mind) “One.” Friend, lover, husband, soulmate, darling, partner, etc. and yet we use a number? 

I for one find it interesting the idea that dwarves don’t have weddings, because in their society once you find your partner everyone just knows and there’s no need to have a special ritual around it, as it is also impossible that you would end up with anyone else. So Thorin just immediately referring to Bilbo as his husband the minute he knows both of them are on the same page as far as being in love, has great comedic potential too since in the Shire without the rigid monogamy culture (ie you can remarry, or marry without love) Bilbo would probably jump out of his skin the first time he’s called Thorin’s “husband” since he doesn’t understand that love=marriage without passing through the whole “wedding” thing in Dwarven culture. That’s one way to deal with cultural difference that missmithen and I giggled over some time ago. 

Mostly, I just don’t like that it’s so widely perceived as canon. There’s not a single mention in any Tolkien work of a “One”. It’s a totally fanon term and so many fics seem to just take its existence for granted, and I can’t help but wonder if they know that Dwarves don’t have a One in Tolkien’s text? Or that they’re not the only monogamous species? And why they feel the need to say “One” when there’s so many other words for love and partnership in our language?

So basically, it’s me being a big grouch :P

Part 2

There’s two pieces of Canon that could back it up - (to paraphrase) Tolkien’s quote about dwarves loving only once or not at all, and that many dwarves never bother to get into relationships especially because their population is only 1/3 women (which I think combined with Gimli’s statement based on the LotR appendix that dwarf men and women are indistinguishable is what led to a lot of the gender play fic we see in the Hobbit fandom, and the general liberty with which authors treat dwarven conceptions of gender despite lack of canon representation of female dwarves or in fact any dwarf in a relationship). 

The other is the similar statement that Elves only love once* (*some terms and conditions may apply, for example Finduilas in Children of Hurin, so Elves are monogamous unless it’s plot related apparently). Furthermore, that elves actually fade if their love is denied, as a broken heart is one of the few things that can kill these immortal beings besides injury. Kinda goes along with Tolkien having so many of his races be Biologically Catholic as I like to call it, so he never has to address things like infidelity in immortal relationships, they’re all strictly monogamous by default. 

That I think combined with popular soulmate trends which may have indeed been doing the rounds early in 2013 may have lead to someone using “One” as shorthand to describe a soulmate, and applying that to Tolkien’s world. As I’ve said elsewhere, I totally understand why it’s a useful word, it just rubs me the wrong way because Tolkien’s world is SO linguistically based and unlike most other fandoms where fanon runs rampant because the writers didn’t provide backstory on every little thing, Tolkien actually HAS provided backstory on an exhaustive amount of Middle Earth’s culture and history, so there’s a lot of fanon where there doesn’t really need to be any. Again, which is totally fine, I just hope that people are conscious of what is fanon and what is canon because the canon can in fact be very rich and rewarding to work from and a lot of stuff that ends up in fanon often comes from other fandoms and carries with a lot of very tired, overused tropes (so many yaoi tropes…. so many…). 

TL;DR The “One” thing is not without basis in Tolkien’s world, he just never used that word for it, and I’m still not sure who was the first author to apply it to Hobbit fic.