Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2017-09-05
Completed:
2017-09-06
Words:
64,935
Chapters:
65/65
Kudos:
270
Hits:
0

Collected Bagginshield & Hobbit Meta

Chapter 61: On Dwarvish Cuisine (headcanon)

Chapter Text

I’ve seen some really fantastic takes on making Middle Earth with much more cultural and cuisine variety than the films or books portrayed. Personally, I’ve always head-canoned Erebor cuisine as northern Russian, since the Lonely Mountain and St. Petersburg appear to share a latitude, and climate deeply influences cuisine.

I poked some fun at this with Thorin preparing the rather horrifying “herring under fur coat” dish for Bilbo in my last drabble, largely because I’m rather sick of the idea that Thorin CAN’T cook (he did live many years on the road and fended for himself, he’s not HELPLESS) but someone can be a decent cook and still prepare a dish that someone finds disgusting based on their own cultural experience, as was the case with Bilbo and salted herring mixed with boiled vegetables and mayonnaise :P

That being said, the one real hint we get of dwarven cuisine (besides there distaste of leafy greens) was Gimli’s “roaring fires, malt beer, red meat off the bone” in FOTR. So: bbq and beer, got it. 
But then again, Gimli is kind of a more “Scottish” dwarf (like Dain), and then you have Bofur with his North Irish accent and ultimately for me I kinda decided that dwarves are just generally “Northern” across pseudo-European Middle Earth. So Ered Luin is more Scottish/Northern Irish, but once you travel far East, like Erebor, you get more Scandinavian (Grey Mountains?) shading to Russian. 

This was partially informed too by the quasi-Byzantine architecture we saw in Dale, which to my eyes looked rather Medieval Russian (given their close ties with Byzantium) and the rest made sense. 

But I still see dwarves as primarily preferring red meat and having that Scottish/Northern influence, so imagine my delight when a little more researched (don’t laugh at me, @Sansael) when I learned of Russian Shashlik, which is not only Russian barbecue but Russian barbecue MADE WITH SWORDS 

I MEAN 

HOW DWARVISH IS THAT?! 

Not to mention it’s considered a more upper class dish, and given Erebor’s wealth that makes PERFECT sense. 

So, long story short, definitely planning at least one more Shire AU cooking adventures with Thorin being actually a fairly competent cook, but his native tastes being different enough that Bilbo needs to adjust from his rather bland, southern English Shire expectations. But yes, “herring under fur coat” first, next up shashlik :3